Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Bitcoin Arms Race, U.S. Strategic Advantage, and a Changing World Order with Matthew Pines
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of gutless 1974198792972000.
- 0:17And whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we. Sell, I say, when we sell.
- 0:32We just recorded this conversation with Matt Pines
- 0:35from the Bitcoin Policy Institute, And if you're trying
- 0:38to understand what the world might look like in five years
- 0:40from now, this is the episode to hear.
- 0:43From strategic deals, huge deals in the Middle East to the re
- 0:47monetization of gold and Bitcoin, we breakdown how
- 0:50geopolitical power, money, defense and energy are being
- 0:54renegotiated and ultimately why Bitcoin is increasingly being
- 0:58seen as a tool of US statecraft, not just to store value.
- 1:04We take a peek behind the curtain at what's happening in
- 1:06DC, from the strategic Bitcoin reserve to the rise of bit
- 1:09bonds, to how the US is positioning itself in a global
- 1:13Bitcoin arms race. And that absolutely delivered.
- 1:17We really had to barely talk, and you're about to hear why.
- 1:21But before we dive in, ask yourself, is your Bitcoin secure
- 1:24enough for this new era? Maybe you don't want to think
- 1:28about it, but you really should. And so at On Ramp, we work with
- 1:31individuals who take Bitcoin seriously and need a solution to
- 1:34match that. And that's why we focus on multi
- 1:37Institution custody, a model that eliminates single points of
- 1:40failure, includes insurance coverage from Lloyd's of London,
- 1:44and allows your Bitcoin to be passed on to your heirs without
- 1:47them ever needing to manage keys.
- 1:49And all of this can be handled in minutes, not months.
- 1:53So if your Bitcoin strategy spans decades and then Peace of
- 1:57Mind is not optional, it's really foundational.
- 1:59So go to on rampbitcoin.com. You can sign up in minutes, or
- 2:04you can book a consultation with myself or even with Cam.
- 2:07That's stud on the bottom right side there.
- 2:10And we'll make sure you're taken care of.
- 2:12Now. I hope you enjoyed the episode.
- 2:15All right, it's time for the last trade.
- 2:17We've we're broke the streak this week.
- 2:20We've had five people on the podcast for week after week.
- 2:24This week it's just four of us. So we have Michael Tanguma and
- 2:27Brian Cabela's here at On Ramp, and we're joined today by Matt
- 2:30Pines. Matt, you're only one person,
- 2:33but maybe we could say you have the brain of two people.
- 2:36So we do have 5 people on the podcast today really excited to
- 2:39be recording with you. You're the executive director at
- 2:43Bitcoin Policy Institute. You've been full time there
- 2:46since when? February of this year.
- 2:48Yeah. Nice.
- 2:50So you've been involved with them for a while.
- 2:51I think I caught somewhere in your bio, you were the you
- 2:54published the first white paper for them.
- 2:56And then you've been involved for a number of years, I guess
- 2:58three years or so. So really excited to get a
- 3:01better grasp on what's happening, you know, with
- 3:03federal policy. But this conversation I think
- 3:05will span much more beyond that as well.
- 3:08Talk a lot about, you know, what's happening with state
- 3:11strategic Bitcoin reserves, bit bonds, just budget neutral ways
- 3:15to accumulate Bitcoin, something we've been talking quite a bit
- 3:19about, but I think we'll go into way more detail and really just
- 3:23appreciative of you being on the show today.
- 3:25Thanks for joining us. Thanks.
- 3:26For having me, yeah. I've caught a number of your
- 3:28recent episodes so you guys have some good rips.
- 3:31Thanks for letting me out. Well, appreciate that at least
- 3:35someone's listening makes it a little bit more rewarding at.
- 3:38Least one. Person you know.
- 3:40Yeah, that's great. So, Matt, why don't we start
- 3:43with what's going on in the Middle East this week?
- 3:46So there's the US Saudi Investment Forum.
- 3:48You've had some takes online. And maybe before we get into the
- 3:52details of it, could you just kind of share a recap for the
- 3:56audience of what's going on in the Middle East this week?
- 4:00What have you been paying attention to?
- 4:01And then would love to dive into a bit more detail of what the
- 4:04broader implications are, you know, from a policy perspective
- 4:08or economics, geopolitics, etcetera.
- 4:11Yes, yeah. So just like the.
- 4:12Facts like 10,000 foot level view.
- 4:15This was Donald Trump's like first major overseas visit was
- 4:18received by the the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and he's doing a
- 4:21kind of four day tour of the Gulf countries in the main event
- 4:27that kind of kicked everything off was AUS Saudi investment
- 4:30forum where Menorah was strategic.
- 4:32Both arms as well as technology and diplomatic kind of deals
- 4:37were announced. Kind of a whole bundle of
- 4:40initiatives relating to artificial intelligence, new
- 4:44energy investments, critical infrastructure investments, you
- 4:48know, arms sales and announcements on kind of a
- 4:50diplomatic reset potentially in the region.
- 4:54So each individually we're quite significant like as a package,
- 4:58they, they seem to indicate, you know, a strategic shift in how
- 5:02the US government is approaching lots of different policy domains
- 5:06as part of a integrated approach to statecraft to pursue a
- 5:09different vision of America's role in the global order.
- 5:12Right. So that's kind of my
- 5:13interpretation of of the facts and.
- 5:15I think it's being motivated. By a lot of different separate,
- 5:18separate threads that all kind of come under this this sort of
- 5:22rubric of a global reordering right that the administration
- 5:26and the senior officials were telegraphing, you know, even
- 5:28before the election. Their view of economic policy,
- 5:32of security policy, of technology policy as as needing
- 5:36to go through a decisive phase shift under their under their
- 5:40leadership. And so that's what they're
- 5:42executing. You could say their
- 5:44implementation of that vision, right?
- 5:45Could, could be, could be improved in various ways, But
- 5:48it's very clear they have a, an objective here, which is to
- 5:52reorder that sort of terms of the security arrangements, the
- 5:56terms of the trade system, even the monetary system to a certain
- 6:00extent, as well as to use America's strengths to a certain
- 6:04extent, like our, our technological leadership, our
- 6:07military leadership and, you know, to a certain extent, our,
- 6:11our economic, you know, heft around the world to kind of re
- 6:15demarcate the lines around which kind of America considers its
- 6:18zone of influence in, in what you have to sort of accept as a
- 6:23hierarchical system, right. the US views and lots of great
- 6:27powers throughout history, you know, whether explicit or
- 6:29implicitly view the global arrangement in a hierarchical
- 6:34fashion, where they're at the core slash the top.
- 6:37And there are, you know, powers that exist within a certain set
- 6:41of relationships with that power.
- 6:43And there are, you know, deals, inducements and coercion.
- 6:46So what we saw in Saudi? Is an example of this where.
- 6:51We leverage the fact that we can control the supply chain for for
- 6:56frontier AI models and their semiconductor components to
- 7:02essentially grant access to Saudi Arabia to some chips that
- 7:05they have been cut off from under the administration,
- 7:08combined with the fact that the Saudis and other Gulf countries
- 7:10control trillions of dollars of surplus capital.
- 7:14And so The upshot is to bring kind of the Gulf kingdoms into a
- 7:19tech tariff, trade and security zone with the United States that
- 7:23helps underwrite this sort of techno industrial investment
- 7:26strategy that the US is pursuing to secure, you know, continued
- 7:31dominance in these frontier technologies, which will require
- 7:34access to large amounts of energy and large amounts of
- 7:36capital, while also sort of boxing out China from
- 7:40potentially doing the same play in the Middle East.
- 7:42You know, China has their own objectives to to sort of capture
- 7:45the techno industrial frontier and they have certain advantages
- 7:48on the energy side and the kind of the command and capital
- 7:50economy side. And so this is kind of great
- 7:52power technology, great power network competition playing out.
- 7:57We'll see what the counter moves are.
- 7:58But yeah, there was a lot kind of baked into that one day of
- 8:02announcements that kind of are is a prism by which you can kind
- 8:06of see all these different sort of threads coming together.
- 8:09Yeah, it's really well, well, well said.
- 8:11I think like there's an interesting component of, you
- 8:14know, obviously like on the Bitcoin side, most people are
- 8:17just so busy in their day-to-day lives.
- 8:19It's my reason personal where it's hard for people to
- 8:21understand Bitcoin is 'cause like you're on the rat race.
- 8:23So how can you take off to like just understand, you know, 21
- 8:26million very similar to what you just broke down.
- 8:29Most people have no clue if this is happening because they're
- 8:31just so busy. And obviously like the the
- 8:34traditional media is not telling you any of this.
- 8:37Curious, like, where would historically we sit if a
- 8:41different administration would have came in or what was
- 8:44happening before this? Right, Because it's obvious that
- 8:45this sounds like this is kind of a form fitting for a new
- 8:49administration geopolitical favor for the US was like the
- 8:52administration before asleep at the wheel and we're heading down
- 8:55the wrong tracks on this. I think we all know that there's
- 8:57a lot of things are asleep on the wheel at but like what was
- 8:59happening in this respect previously and what would have
- 9:01happened if it would have been a Kamala, you know, president.
- 9:05Yeah. And it's kind of to pick apart
- 9:06each particular issue. The two I think most important
- 9:09issues are, you know, among the more salient right now are on
- 9:13the AI sort of technology. So the geopolitization.
- 9:19Of of frontier technology, specifically AI and and our
- 9:22approach to conflicts in the world, I think.
- 9:26It's fair to say. That the Biden administration
- 9:28and likely the Kamala administration would have
- 9:31continued a policy of kind of, you know, escalation right in,
- 9:36in Europe and, and, and likely would not have been, you know,
- 9:41able to effectively defuse conflicts in the Middle East for
- 9:46a, a variety of different reasons.
- 9:47I think there is a lot of institutional inertia and and a
- 9:50certain contingent of kind of the national security wing of
- 9:53the BI administration that kind of preferred calibrated
- 9:58conflicts for a wide variety of reasons.
- 10:01Because they felt like ultimately they would get the
- 10:03upper hand, that they'd be able to out outlast Russia, that
- 10:07they'd be able to kind of rebalance the Middle East in a
- 10:10in a fashion that would secure their their personal interests.
- 10:15China's a whole separate thing, but there was a policy that was
- 10:20in place to kind of act as if we were still.
- 10:24Kind of the hyper power of the 90s, you know, you know, Jake
- 10:27Sol, the national security advisor kind of came up in that
- 10:30era under the tutelage of Clinton and and Blinken.
- 10:34And it's like a marathon runner. Who was like really fast in in,
- 10:38you know, in their 20s and then ages to their 40s but still
- 10:41thinks they can run. You know, like they like they
- 10:44used to and conducts foreign policy in this case, like like
- 10:47we, we, we still wear the hyper power and we sort of saw, you
- 10:51know, us running into constraints.
- 10:54We weren't all, you know, very adaptable.
- 10:57I think we're seeing now it's sort of this uncomfortable
- 11:00recognition that we are constrained in various ways.
- 11:03We still have lots of reservoirs of strength, but we have to be
- 11:06prudent in how we deploy those to secure our interest in a,
- 11:09what will you know is a multi polar at least bipolar system
- 11:12here. I think there's been a
- 11:15begrudging acceptance that China is a peer competitor and that we
- 11:19can't just sanction them out of these supply chains.
- 11:23We can't just sort of try to isolate them diplomatically
- 11:27because they're the dominant trade partner for most of the
- 11:28countries in the world. And they have their own
- 11:30endogenous technological industrial system which rivals
- 11:34our own, in fact exceeds our own in in many ways.
- 11:37And I think a lot of the sort of the the BLOB heads in, in, in
- 11:42previous years that spanned both, you know, parties kind of
- 11:45view that, you know, this would just be the next we could sort
- 11:48of take out the same bag of tricks essentially.
- 11:51And I think it's not working. And that's it's very
- 11:53uncomfortable, right, for the kind of premises in the national
- 11:55security state that believe that we, we, we sort of stand.
- 11:59Astride the the the the world system.
- 12:01And we can, sort of. Like give give rules and not
- 12:03take rules. I think the uncomfortable part
- 12:06about Trump is he's kind of he's he's a bluffer, he's an
- 12:09exaggerator. But fundamentally, I think if
- 12:11you read between the lines of his speeches, he's recognizing
- 12:13that American power is fundamentally constrained and
- 12:16that we don't have the political mandate to do the same types of
- 12:19global policing and rule writing for the global order that we
- 12:23that we used to. And so there's this sort of
- 12:25calibrated re restructuring of what sort of Pax Americana
- 12:31means, like what is the club and fence for that American system?
- 12:36It doesn't clearly expand to the whole world, right?
- 12:39And we're sort of now trying to find where those lines are that
- 12:42you want to get into the club. This is what you have to sort of
- 12:44pay to get a ticket to the to, you know, inside that, inside
- 12:48that, that sort of tech tariff and security zone.
- 12:50And so, but to do that, you kind of need to like squash the beef.
- 12:54And so I think Trump's meta strategy for foreign policy is
- 12:57just to kind of get peace deals, right, maybe on terms it would
- 13:00not be favorable to a lot of people, you know, from the my
- 13:02administration. But he seems sort of like peace
- 13:05Uber Alice, Like, let's just get ceasefires in in Ukraine.
- 13:09Let's get, you know, ceasefires in Gaza.
- 13:11Let's get, you know, the Abraham accord signed.
- 13:13Let's get a deal with Iran. Let's effectively squash the
- 13:16beef with China over Taiwan. If that means kind of
- 13:19recalibrating policy on Taiwan, you know, away from strategic
- 13:23ambiguity like that may be in the cards here, right?
- 13:25So if you can imagine this, this conflict zone around the EUR
- 13:28Asian periphery, which is essentially this major dynamic
- 13:30that we've been facing for the past few years is sort of, you
- 13:34know, EUR Asian autocratic powers that control the marginal
- 13:37supply of commodities. And, and, and increasingly like
- 13:40high value added goods between Russia and China and other parts
- 13:43of South Asia. Sort of contesting a world order
- 13:46that's dominated by kind of liberal oceanic mercantilist
- 13:49capitalism that controls the dollar funding system, access to
- 13:53credit and global trade. And those systems were kind of
- 13:57in frenemy mode for most of, you know, the post 90s, you know,
- 14:00era. And we were kind of, you know,
- 14:02the hegemon that secured that global system.
- 14:05But for wide-ranging sort of set of historical contingencies is
- 14:08mainly the rise of China. It sort of contested that system
- 14:12where it's fundamentally a cog in this larger machine that's
- 14:15run by the US and and and to certain extent Western Europe.
- 14:19They wanted to sort of reset the terms there.
- 14:21Like they're not just going to be like a cog in the
- 14:23manufacturing sort of producing system.
- 14:26They want to create their own system.
- 14:29And and that's led to these kind of EUR Asian conflict areas,
- 14:32right, like the the sort of autocratic Eurasia going up
- 14:36against, quote liberal Oceana. And I think that that basic Geo
- 14:41economic block like that sort of spans all administrations, But I
- 14:45think the Trump administration's view of it is that's how you get
- 14:49World War three, right. If you don't if you don't
- 14:51navigate that, that competitive dynamic, especially given the
- 14:54fact that, well, one, our supply chains are dependent on China.
- 14:57We saw, you know, trying to just flip the switch on rare earths
- 15:00and everyone in in the Defense Department freaks out and, you
- 15:04know, inflation can whip saw, you know, in a matter of weeks.
- 15:07And we're just too interdependent to really pull
- 15:10put guns to each other's heads. And so we we can't fight wars or
- 15:13else we're going to go nuclear and we're going to destroy
- 15:15civilization. We can't even really fight
- 15:17economic wars because within a matter of weeks, like ports get
- 15:21empty and then 10s of millions of Chinese, you know, urban
- 15:24workers go unemployed and then start being protests.
- 15:26And the Shanghai clique tries to do a coup on XI.
- 15:29So everyone realizes it was kind of mutual economic assured
- 15:31destruction. And I think they've kind of
- 15:33played that out now in this sort of iterative game.
- 15:34And they realize, OK, we just have to kind of like settle up,
- 15:38right, We've become some sort of grand bargain.
- 15:40And I think they had to kind of go through certain high stakes
- 15:43Bluffs and like, you know, scary maneuvers and the financial
- 15:47markets freaked out with liberation day.
- 15:50But I think the glide path we're on, it seems again, there's lots
- 15:54of non linearities in this type of dynamic is that sort of grand
- 15:58bargains are being worked out in real time.
- 16:00And I think the, the, the sort of GCC visit is a critical kind
- 16:04of stepping stone to these sorts of grand bargains that I don't
- 16:09think would have happened under Kamala administration.
- 16:11I think it would have been essentially, can we kind of
- 16:13extend and pretend and kind of maintain the current system of
- 16:17international. You know, there's a certain
- 16:21cohort of folks that manage these these systems and that
- 16:24have gained a lot of status and, and wealth from the flows of,
- 16:28you know, overseas development money, military sales, kind of
- 16:34the think tank military foreign policy ecosystem that was kind
- 16:38of a self working, self licking ice cream cone.
- 16:41So there's a lot of grift in that system.
- 16:44There's going to be new grift in this new system, right?
- 16:46Like grift doesn't go away. This is a different type of
- 16:48grift and there's different people winning and different
- 16:51people losing. And I say we've had gone through
- 16:54like maybe a kind of a quiet like a cold civil war in the
- 16:58Western political economy, right?
- 17:00Kind of existing factions of, of, of say, institutionalist
- 17:05that have developed these bureaucratic control structures
- 17:08that allow them to kind of skim off the top of their societies.
- 17:11And you have kind of counter elites coming in that finally,
- 17:14you know, reject that system, But they're not necessarily
- 17:16coming in with like a, you know, a demos mandate.
- 17:19I think that's a bit more of like a mask that's worn
- 17:22ultimately, right? Political leads do what
- 17:23political leads do. They just want to get themselves
- 17:25access to, you know, those privileged positions.
- 17:27So I, I'm, I'm, I'm in favor of kind of the overall strategic
- 17:32approach that Trump is taking, but I'm not like, I'm also like
- 17:36a realist, right? I don't understand like the
- 17:38structures of the power and human relations.
- 17:41And ultimately this is we're going back to more like a 19th
- 17:43century style, kind of a court Geo court slash, you know,
- 17:49homeless, like pre W family and style like state system where
- 17:52it's like very personalized. Here's why Trump goes in.
- 17:56He has like becomes best friends with Mohammed bin Salman and.
- 17:59His personal. Relationships with these
- 18:01national leaders is like like basically what tips the scales?
- 18:03It's not you know, you know, office floors full of pH DS
- 18:08writing white papers on foreign policy.
- 18:09It's like literally like does Trump like the cut of your jib?
- 18:13And this is where we are right. So anyways, that was a bit of a
- 18:15rambling riff, but I think that's no, that's a funnily
- 18:17very. Different type of approach then
- 18:19you would have gotten under Kamala.
- 18:21That was, yeah. I mean, it's a summary in my
- 18:23view. I look, it's like checkers
- 18:24versus or chess versus checkers in the sense of like you're just
- 18:28having to think about counter positioning where you sit on
- 18:30that, that board and that hierarchical structure.
- 18:34It sounds like a very similar structure except for they're
- 18:36more defined to your point and there's less like fat
- 18:38bureaucracy of how it's going to be managed.
- 18:42Checks. I don't know if you wanted to
- 18:43take it somewhere. Yeah.
- 18:44Well, we'd love to stay on this topic, but shifted more into the
- 18:48monetary perspective. So Matt, you mentioned on
- 18:51Twitter the Riyadh Accord. So there's just realignment of
- 18:54trade, tech, security, money. So how would you tie in what's
- 18:59happening in the Gulf now to the broader balance of power between
- 19:05China, Russia, BRICS countries in the US in the fight for
- 19:09dollar dollarization or de dollarization?
- 19:11So how does this all tie in from a monetary perspective from this
- 19:14global reordering? Yeah, I mean to adapt a line
- 19:17from like Zoltan Pozar, who may have himself adapted it from
- 19:21from from Perry Merling. You know, payment chains are
- 19:27supply chains in reverse. And you could say that like the
- 19:30AI supply chain is a capital flow chain in reverse arms sale
- 19:35chains are capital flow chains. So all of these deals where
- 19:38there's AI security arrangements, you know, explicit
- 19:44access to our, our domestic markets, you know, behind tariff
- 19:47walls, they fundamentally flow through capital markets and, and
- 19:50the offshore dollar system, which has been, you know, the
- 19:53main vehicle for international commerce in this era of
- 19:55globalization. And the fundamental collateral
- 19:57of that global dollar system is U.S.
- 19:59Treasury security. And so.
- 20:02There is a lot of stress being placed on that market and that,
- 20:07you know, set of balance sheets that intermediate to the, the
- 20:10flow of, of, of global commerce and collateral in a, you know,
- 20:14in a secured global dollar system that uses Treasury
- 20:16securities as as funding collateral.
- 20:19And we're printing a ton of Treasury securities and we're
- 20:22we've been forced in the last few years to kind of print more
- 20:24at the short end because there doesn't seem to be as much
- 20:27endogenous demand on the long end.
- 20:29And that was a form of liquidity expansion under Yellen called
- 20:32activist treasury issuance. And so we are in an era where we
- 20:37have a lot of strategic strengths.
- 20:39We also have a lot of strategic vulnerabilities.
- 20:41And I think the Treasury market, our fiscal position are our need
- 20:44to refinance our debt loads post COVID at sustainable rates is,
- 20:49is an acute weakness right now. And we saw that as part of the
- 20:52Liberation Liberation Day reaction when the 30 years
- 20:55started hitting 5%. That was when basically Besson
- 20:58got the upper hand inside the kind of court politics around
- 21:01Trump and basically took control and steered things back to kind
- 21:04of a forward guidance, geopolitically tiered approach
- 21:08to, to to, to tariffs as opposed to the Lutnick Navarro punch
- 21:11everyone in the mouth, you know, and just collect trillions of
- 21:13dollars in revenue kind of idea which blew up in their face.
- 21:18And this is where the monetary system is critical to these
- 21:20strategic dimensions because it's it's a fundamental boundary
- 21:24constraint on what they can do, right?
- 21:26I mean, the, the guy really like Marco Pappich, he has this, you
- 21:30know, this sort of quip. It's like, you know, preferences
- 21:33are optional constraints or not right.
- 21:35And so politicians want to do lots of things.
- 21:37They want to be re elected, they want to be popular, they want
- 21:40everyone to be rich, right? But like the world imposes
- 21:43material constraints and ultimately politicians, what
- 21:47they'll likely do is going to be dictated to 1st order by what
- 21:50their constraints are. And so the US government and our
- 21:52leadership, the fundamental constraint is the treasury
- 21:54system, right? And so they recognize that.
- 21:56And so it's constraining them. And so it's leading to a lot of
- 21:59these deals where the treasury market is a part of the deal.
- 22:04And on the other, on the other side of that deal are countries
- 22:07and national, you know, balance sheets that now recognize
- 22:10explicitly how constrained the, you know, the US is buy it's
- 22:14that position and buy the instabilities associated with
- 22:16the treasury market. And so they're looking to see
- 22:19how they can both hedge as well as take advantage of that
- 22:22opportunity. And so I think you've seen re
- 22:25monetization of hard assets, recognizing that, you know,
- 22:28ultimately at the end game here, and this is, you know, old
- 22:30bromides from from Luke Roman and and and Len Alden for many
- 22:33years now, essentially is the end of the day, like indebted
- 22:36hegemons. When you get past a certain
- 22:38point, you print and and or you do financial repression to force
- 22:42certain, you know, sort of capital pools to sort of eat
- 22:46those losses via financial repression.
- 22:48And then as a, you know, big political bargain and
- 22:50geopolitical bargain is who who's going to eat those losses?
- 22:52Is it going to be domestic bondholders, you know, everyday
- 22:55American savers, pensioners, people, you know, insurance
- 22:59companies, you know, bank balance sheets, or is it going
- 23:01to be, you know, overseas holders of those bonds?
- 23:03Is it going to be the foreign central banks, you know, foreign
- 23:07solid wealth funds, foreign insurance and pension companies?
- 23:11And I think, you know, the, the, the order of operations for U.S.
- 23:15government is to sort of first impose the losses on like our
- 23:19friends and allies who we have a lot of like, you know, coercive
- 23:23ability to force, right? Like say, Japan, Taiwan, South
- 23:27Korea, the UK, Australia countries who won like rely on
- 23:30us for security, intelligence protection and who, you know,
- 23:33have a lot of treasury securities, say, sitting at the
- 23:35short end. And we want them to swap those
- 23:37out for longer dated issuances. This is kind of the result and
- 23:40pose our Bretton Woods 2 point O thesis that will sort of force a
- 23:43series of swaps, force them to sort of extend out our duration
- 23:46and maybe even give us some of their gold and give them 50 year
- 23:49bonds, century bonds, etcetera. So in that environment, which is
- 23:52effectively, you know, a combination of, you know,
- 23:55monetization, you know, backdoor QE using foreign central bank's
- 23:59balance sheets. I mean, I'm aware of, for
- 24:01example, that the Japanese were sort of requesting politely a
- 24:06backdoor dollar swap line to sort of fund long term debt,
- 24:10long term debt purchases, right? Essentially backdoor QE.
- 24:15So the Bank of Japan's balance sheet expands instead of the
- 24:17Fed's balance sheets. So this is the regime we're in.
- 24:21And The upshot is, you know, central bank's balance sheets
- 24:24are going to have to expand to sort of finance the hegemon's
- 24:28military, you know, expansion to secure this this this new zone,
- 24:33this massive technological industrial reinvestment and
- 24:37reshoring. Objective bonds are going to
- 24:41have to eat. It's question is whose bonds eat
- 24:42it first? Anyone that can is going to flee
- 24:44into harder assets. You saw first in gold and I
- 24:46think you're going to see it in Bitcoin.
- 24:47So that's like a pretty simple macro thesis.
- 24:51And I think that's that's where it's very much a case by case.
- 24:56And I think it's also why you see maybe Japan getting almost
- 25:00the worst deal in China at the moment, right?
- 25:02Because you you would think, right naively, oh, well, Japan's
- 25:05like an old ally of ours. They're a friend of ours.
- 25:07Like they should get a better deal than China, right?
- 25:10But if you're from Trump's perspective, you're like, well,
- 25:12no, like Japan is like basically de facto colony.
- 25:16So of course, I can impose a lot more pain, and I can, like,
- 25:19twist their arms a lot more than I can twist China's arms.
- 25:22So, you know, then the inference is, well, China is going to get
- 25:25a better deal than Japan. And that's a fundamentally
- 25:28different way of approaching this than I think the Kamala
- 25:30administration would have been, which is just like, well,
- 25:33they're our friends. We can't, like, insult them.
- 25:35We can't force them to, like, eat pain.
- 25:36Like, there are buddies. And I think Trump's, like, I
- 25:39have no permanent enemies. I have no permanent friends.
- 25:40I have only permanent interests and if you put yourself in a
- 25:44national position of subservience with respect to me,
- 25:46because you rely on me for your security protection, you're
- 25:49embedded in my global trade system.
- 25:51That is, that is I secure for your, you know, if your if your
- 25:54economy. Well, guess what, now I've got
- 25:56you over a barrel. Like Trump is just a guy who's,
- 25:59you know, a bit sociopathic in that sense.
- 26:01Like he's, he has no sense of like, you know, oblige to these
- 26:05folks. And it makes sense from a
- 26:07rational perspective, like if you're in debt and you can pay
- 26:10your brother back slower or whoever is related to your
- 26:13family versus the guy that's going to hit you in the
- 26:15kneecaps, like you kind of pay the guy in the kneecaps first.
- 26:18It's a rational like move. So it it makes complete sense
- 26:21where you would. Again, it's all about
- 26:23positioning it sounds like. Yeah, How does, how does?
- 26:29So there's $9 trillion of federal debt that's rolling over
- 26:33in the next 12 months. And so, Matt, you laid out that
- 26:36the foreign central banks will probably have to take a nice
- 26:40chomp of that, but I'm sure the Federal Reserve plays a part in
- 26:44monetizing or or you know, printing the money for some of
- 26:47that issuance. But the Fed balance sheet, I
- 26:51guess is only what, 6 or 7 trillion today.
- 26:54I don't know how large the the balance sheets are of the other
- 26:57global central banks, but 9 trillion is, is kind of a large
- 27:00number of debt to be rolled over in the next year.
- 27:02So how do you think about, you know, the balance of central
- 27:06banks taking that down in terms of just the capacity to do so?
- 27:10In theory, I guess capacity is unlimited because you could
- 27:12always create more currency. But what's the constraints of
- 27:15the treasury market breaking and loss of faith in in the US
- 27:19Treasuries versus maybe using hard assets to make some of this
- 27:24issuance more appealing? Do you think that's something
- 27:26that we'll see this year or is it something more so and further
- 27:29down the road? Yeah, I mean, there's, there's
- 27:32a, there's two different dimensions that one's like the
- 27:34stock and the, and one's the flow, right.
- 27:36So the, the refinancing is essentially the stock problem,
- 27:39right, which is we have a stock of debt, it's retiring, we need
- 27:43to refinance it, right. And so that's, that's just
- 27:47doesn't necessarily expand the size of the balance sheets that
- 27:49have to take that up. But it now means that the US
- 27:52government has to pay a higher interest rate right on the next
- 27:54tranche of what are those tenders are that it's going to
- 27:57get refinance. So maybe they issued it COVID at
- 28:00one 2%. Now they have to issue it at 5,
- 28:02you know, four and a half 5%. So that's like the the marginal
- 28:07refinancing cost that takes a hit, you know, downstream on
- 28:11everything. You know, we're paying more than
- 28:13our Defense Department budget on, on on on interest costs.
- 28:15So just squeezes out fiscal capacity.
- 28:18That's a federal government problem.
- 28:20The, the, the flow issue is just the deficit itself, right?
- 28:24The fact that I think whatever the annualized run right now for
- 28:27our deficit is something like 6 and a half, 7% of GDP, 1 1/2,
- 28:31two trillion. Dollars just sort of ballpark
- 28:33numbers now. That's a lot.
- 28:36So that's the flow. That's like, OK, those are new.
- 28:39That's like net new treasuries that are going to be pushed into
- 28:42the market just from the federal government sort of deficit.
- 28:46The question is who's who's going to absorb that balance
- 28:48sheet, right. Who's going to absorb that in
- 28:50the balance sheet? And so if it's all at three
- 28:52month tenors, well, there's probably a lot of buyers for
- 28:55that, right. Lots of people will take that as
- 28:56a money like instrument, not a whole lot of duration.
- 28:58Risks, but the US government. That's effectively you're like
- 29:00payday lending, right? Like you're like, you gotta get
- 29:03the role like every three months and you're much more, you know,
- 29:07much more exposed than necessary Fed monetary policy decisions,
- 29:09right. And you'd rather not do that.
- 29:12Like the the the government tries to target a certain sort
- 29:15of average duration. And the last few years have been
- 29:17front loaded because of this very issue.
- 29:20And Besson's now kind of stuck with it.
- 29:21And, and so he wants to issue more at the long end, But I
- 29:25think they know that they can't without either finding a, I'd
- 29:28say a non, a non market buyer, right?
- 29:31Like a such central bank that can be geopolitically coerced in
- 29:34order to, to, to buy it. And I think we effectively have
- 29:39yield. We know we're going to have
- 29:40yield curve control somewhere above 5% on the, on the 30 year.
- 29:44That's, that's about like the mark plus or minus.
- 29:48We're almost there like as we speak.
- 29:52And so I think this is where the intensity of these deals gets
- 29:55more significant because, you know, it's hard to go, you can't
- 30:00really with rule of law domestically go to, you know, JP
- 30:04Morgan and say, we need you to buy more 30 year paper,
- 30:06especially after, you know, Silicon Valley Bank and SVB,
- 30:09right? Where they realized, oh, like
- 30:11our whole our, our, our HTML portfolio, like once we had the
- 30:14mark to market went, you know, zeroed out our, all of our
- 30:18capital and then we got wound up by Elizabeth Warren's goons.
- 30:22And so it's, you got to go overseas where there's no rules,
- 30:25right? There's just pure power.
- 30:28And maybe that's part of the Saudi Gulf deal there.
- 30:31What was interesting about that is like this is a bit of a RIP,
- 30:35but like the traditional Petro dollar system was all
- 30:38commodities, mainly oil and gas are sold in dollars and then
- 30:41those countries accumulate dollars surpluses and then they,
- 30:44you know, redirect those, recycle those into our treasury
- 30:47asset and that helps finance the security protection that then we
- 30:51provide and secure their one party state regimes.
- 30:54That was a good deal. Now it's like they realize they
- 30:56have better leverage. And so, you know, they don't
- 30:58want debt positions. Now the Saudis want equity
- 31:01positions, right? And so they're, they're moving
- 31:03up the value stack because it's a new multipolar system, right?
- 31:06If we had all the juice, then we would just be forcing the Saudis
- 31:08to buy more 30 year paper. Instead, we have to do this deal
- 31:11where we allow them to, you know, essentially invest $100
- 31:15billion in our AI stack, get 18,000 Blackwell survey units,
- 31:21do Co investments and all sorts of breakthrough energy and, and,
- 31:24and, and, and biotech and AI, you know, corporate financing
- 31:28deals and sovereign wealth funds, you know, going into our
- 31:30private equity venture capital markets.
- 31:33So that's, that's, that's a funnily, it's like a, that's a
- 31:35funnily different environment where, where they are, you know,
- 31:39able to acquire more valuable assets and equity essentially
- 31:43positions. And so the question for us is
- 31:46that, OK, how does that, you know, what, what's the mix of
- 31:48debt and equity there? OK, You get investment in in
- 31:51U.S. equity, right, strategic equity, but we also need you to
- 31:54help, you know, finance the fiscal balance sheet here.
- 31:58So I don't know, a lot of stuff is not being made public, right
- 32:01Like that, the flashy stuff, the sexy stuff, the billion dollars
- 32:04in AI and whatever that's public.
- 32:05How much of this is like, well, you have to take down another 25
- 32:10billion in 30 year paper every quarter?
- 32:12Like they're not going to announce that, but some Saudi,
- 32:15you know, balance sheet will show up there, you know, when
- 32:18the time comes for those auctions.
- 32:20So I think something like that's part of the deal here.
- 32:23I just don't think it's going to be made public.
- 32:25Yeah, it makes complete sense. I mean, this ties in to this
- 32:29that also as long as the landing can be stuck and there's not,
- 32:33you know, crazy World War or, you know, too large of a
- 32:37conflict, you can see how this is.
- 32:38I don't know if equitable is the right word, but more productive
- 32:41society, right? Like once you actually have tie
- 32:43in, you hear like equity in certain aspects of our country,
- 32:48but you think about like the the relationship and building and
- 32:52just not being insular. And you know, there's been a lot
- 32:54of you reference drift in our existing, you know, Fiat or the
- 32:58the dollar based system. But curious like as much as
- 33:01you're comfortable in talking about where there's been a lot
- 33:04of things that have aligned and that don't necessarily look
- 33:07organic, but they don't feel organic, like right when you go
- 33:09back to tethers origins and where that sits and the amount
- 33:11of like demand for that. And you can this goes back to
- 33:14like DARPA and the Internet, right?
- 33:15And the Amazons and Googles and Facebooks of like the notion of
- 33:18public private partnerships and how they just naturally
- 33:20beneficially, they've naturally like, like ended up working out
- 33:23for everyone. And so you go to like bitcoins
- 33:26origins and, you know, post OA crisis and notion that this
- 33:29system is unsustainable. Let's see smiling because this
- 33:31is like some of the fun stuff to to potentially chat about that
- 33:33nobody gets to and the guys don't even know.
- 33:35I'm going here with it. But so you have like these
- 33:37origins of Tether, but then like the one that nobody talks about
- 33:42is you you reference it on this last part was Shapiro about it's
- 33:48this easy math of, you know, US take it as roughly 10% of all
- 33:53the gold, right? Where China has like 40%.
- 33:55And I believe that was what the numbers you had quoted where
- 33:58it's kind of like the opposite or maybe it's not that China has
- 34:0140%, it's that US has about 40% of the BTC.
- 34:05And so in this hard money repricing world, it's in our
- 34:08best interest and the natural version as well.
- 34:11Then the the version that everyone knows is, well, you
- 34:15know, you got these loud bitcoiners, they had money.
- 34:17Kamala didn't take the money, Trump did.
- 34:19And maybe that, you know, there's a portion obviously
- 34:21that's true. And then the sense like, I need
- 34:22other tools and bitcoins, the tool.
- 34:25But then you go back and it's like, this game's actually
- 34:27already been working for five years because Sailor came in out
- 34:30of nowhere and he's been effectively, I like to joke,
- 34:32he's like the white hat, white hat SPF.
- 34:35Because while SPF was here to like work on behalf of these
- 34:37other parties, this guy's here evangelizing BTC and bringing it
- 34:41into the corporate structure and onshore and effectively Bitcoin
- 34:43to the US that nobody talks about.
- 34:46And then 23 happens with the ETFs.
- 34:48And Groman's the only person that's picked up on this.
- 34:50And the reason why I've been thinking about it is because
- 34:52I've been having conversations with institutions since back
- 34:54then where nobody wanted to face Coinbase, right?
- 34:57No institution wanted a web 2, web three company, i.e., FTX,
- 35:00Block Fi And then on a dime, everyone pivoted and were like,
- 35:03and they referenced GBTC in the lawsuit, but it never sat right.
- 35:07And growing will cite that we knew we were going to onshore
- 35:11and have a natural inflation environment.
- 35:12So individuals and citizens needed assets to preserve their
- 35:15wealth so they can actually buy things in that environment.
- 35:18So it feels like some of these things have already been like
- 35:20layering in from the corporate treasury to the ETF exposure and
- 35:24in this just like helped push it forward.
- 35:26But I'm curious like how do you think about that as it relates
- 35:29to the past, call it, 6 to 12 months versus past basically
- 35:32five years? Yes, yeah.
- 35:35So first I'll say like there's a from a strategic perspective,
- 35:38there's a kind of a set of simple if ands right.
- 35:41Like if you're going to reorder the global security trade
- 35:45monetary system and you're going to impose financial pressure and
- 35:49essentially those who who you can impose it on.
- 35:51Well, that means that like the the natural buyer of U.S.
- 35:54Treasury security is going to have to be like geopolitically
- 35:57conditioned. So the folks that are inside
- 35:58that zone, they're going to be sort of forced to buy your debt.
- 36:02But the people outside that zone that you can't force the buyer
- 36:04debt, they're not going to be your marginal buyers anymore.
- 36:07And so you should expect in that type of system that harder
- 36:10assets are going to be monetize. And that's kind of this kind of
- 36:13gilded Bretton Woods concept from from Zoltan that I know has
- 36:16been, you know, in the Moran, you know, Besant orbit for for
- 36:20for a year plus now. And in that world, essentially
- 36:23you have a dollar treasury zone, right, the dollar treasury sort
- 36:27of standard, like contracts from a global standard to like a more
- 36:29securitized zone, you know, with, you know, our friends and
- 36:32allies and some of the Middle East as well.
- 36:34And then the rest of the world, you know, essentially needs some
- 36:37neutral reserve asset to settle the payments and and trade
- 36:40between east and West essentially.
- 36:42And then this simple minded system, it's gold.
- 36:44Gold gets re monetized. You have as, as Luke would say,
- 36:47the Shanghai gold exchange. There's now gold exchange is
- 36:50popping up, a cash level futures exchange now looking to open up
- 36:55in Singapore. You've got obviously Dubai is a
- 36:56major entrepot. You've had a lot of gold moving,
- 36:59you know, at at pace in the three months before the
- 37:01election, they sort of did this sort of tariff scare to sort of
- 37:05create that arbitrage in the futures market to actually force
- 37:07physical settlement back at New York away from gold and sort of
- 37:10emptied the London gold vault. So there's a lot of strategic
- 37:12movement of monetary metals, gold specifically, you know, in
- 37:16the last 612 months accelerate in the last three months.
- 37:19So in that world, it's all about re monetizing gold, right?
- 37:23That's like the the sort of baseline central bank kind of
- 37:26normie BIS play. To your point, if that's your
- 37:30play, then if you also at the same time have Bitcoin in the
- 37:34mix and if you are going to be a pro Bitcoin, you know,
- 37:39administration, well then what would you do and why would you
- 37:42do it right? Well, Bitcoin we happen to have
- 37:46through a variety of historical narratives that you could, you
- 37:48know, tell that you just laid out, we have developed a pretty
- 37:51dominant position, just the physical ownership of Bitcoin.
- 37:54And I did that math on the podcast.
- 37:56I think, you know, it's a guesstimate, but if you add up
- 38:00apples to apples, the Bitcoin and gold held by individuals,
- 38:05say custody to ETFs and on government balance sheets, we
- 38:08have about 8 to 10% of the above ground gold stock.
- 38:11You know, in the US, it's collective, you know, ownership
- 38:14and about 35 to 40% of all the Bitcoin that's available.
- 38:19And so if you're going to run this play where scarce assets,
- 38:23hard assets are going to be re monetized, you're going to take
- 38:25more of an official position in the global monetary and trade
- 38:27system. Well, you have at least a four
- 38:29to one advantage by allowing Bitcoin to monetize relative to
- 38:32gold. And we know Bitcoin moved much
- 38:33faster than gold in such an environment.
- 38:35So you can probably get a massive multiple on that.
- 38:37So the region upside to you is much more like asymmetric there.
- 38:41And OK, like this is where you put on your conspiracy hat.
- 38:44Like, did they see this coming? Like, how far down the line did
- 38:47they see this coming? And was this all kind of like a
- 38:49sophisticated plan? I mean, I was been writing about
- 38:52it for a number of years. It's like, am I the only person
- 38:56that thought this would that this could happen?
- 38:57Like it seems a bit hubristic. I don't know, though.
- 39:01If they were like as as I don't know if like you could say, how
- 39:06could you forecast that Trump would win, right, Because if
- 39:08Trump didn't win, then this play may not work as well, right?
- 39:11Like Elizabeth Warren's army comes out and you know, sailor,
- 39:14sailor gets hit with all sorts of investigations and and what
- 39:16not. So I think like, like all
- 39:18things, there's competing power structures in our in our US
- 39:21political economy. There's not one sort of sort of
- 39:24high table master planner that's, you know, running the
- 39:26show. There are, but I believe there
- 39:28are and there have been a contingent of folks, quote in
- 39:31the deep state, you could say that we're, we're watching these
- 39:36dynamics play out over many years, right?
- 39:38Our dependencies on China for our military industrial supply
- 39:40chain hollowing out of our defense industrial capacity,
- 39:44kind of the enrichment of Wall Street at the expense of Main
- 39:47Street and the rise of China that was sort of facilitated by
- 39:49Wall Street. And so there's a schism right
- 39:52between you could say DoD and Wall Street and and Bitcoin to
- 39:58certain extent aligned more with the DoD elements than the Wall
- 40:01Street elements. And I think you're, you know,
- 40:04you're seeing that now play out along with a lot, a lot of other
- 40:06realignments here where Bitcoin is just, I think it's, it's,
- 40:12it's like Chekhov's gun, right? It's like it's on the table
- 40:14there. And you kind of know it's going
- 40:16to be fired, right? Like, like someone put the gun
- 40:18on the table, right? And it wasn't quite sure where
- 40:21it would play a role in the plot, right?
- 40:23But the story's playing out. A lot of things are happening
- 40:26and it's just sitting there and people that are like
- 40:28autistically obsessed with that gun are just staring at the gun.
- 40:31That's us. And they're like, what?
- 40:33Is he gonna pick it up? Is he gonna pick up now?
- 40:35And no, no, he came in, left the room, Okay.
- 40:38Yeah. Yeah, so, but then you just
- 40:40wait, but you just know the guns gonna get picked off the table
- 40:41at some point. And there's a few things you
- 40:44share here. And then on the other pod, which
- 40:45I'd occurred people to listen to, is the thing that makes a
- 40:48lot of this like ephemeral and hard is that there's no they
- 40:51there's no concrete like individual doing anything.
- 40:54So there's different factions within different countries that
- 40:57are always competing. And so to your point, it's like
- 40:59nobody knew Trump would win, but you had these different things
- 41:02happening in parallel. And then this is one of the
- 41:04routes and one thing to call out, I think as a mental model,
- 41:09because it existed was like Bit Max and then FTX.
- 41:12They were effectively the same thing.
- 41:13And it always was weird in my own head that like Bit Max was
- 41:16villainized back in the day, while FTX was the same thing.
- 41:18And it was like allotted and you had Clinton and all the stuff.
- 41:21And it was always like a weird notion.
- 41:23And this tied into the, you're referencing on how you can lean
- 41:27on certain parties that need you.
- 41:31And so Tether probably started organic like somewhat
- 41:33organically. But it's the notion of nobody
- 41:35ever talks about back in the day that when you're putting that
- 41:37much capital through the banking system, you literally have to be
- 41:40working in behalf of like the banking system to make sure that
- 41:43capital flow. And this was when I was getting
- 41:45into the space professionally was an 18 when NYDFS sued them
- 41:50late 1819. I might get the dates wrong, but
- 41:53it was basically where they started looking at the capital
- 41:55flows and they seized the 500 million, I think in Latin
- 41:57America and that's when they launched Leo.
- 41:59But point being is like that could be a line of demarcation
- 42:01where it's like, well, wait, you actually this we need to work
- 42:03this out together because this is to your point that demand for
- 42:06treasuries. And it's interesting because
- 42:08they talk about it now where they're like reference point of
- 42:13the that nobody can compete with them is that they're close to
- 42:15the dollars like, or like physical Fiat in the countries.
- 42:19And it never hit me until listen to that pod you're referencing
- 42:21that there's always existed these like black markets for
- 42:24capital that are funding other things or no, is a different pod
- 42:27that you reference on the, the Carlyle stuff.
- 42:29But it was like, it's starting to all like wrap around where
- 42:32you can see all these like capitals flowing into the system
- 42:34and nobody knows where it comes from.
- 42:35And it's doing these things and you need mechanisms that can be
- 42:38leaned on by the US government to make sure it affects their
- 42:41their how they want to express their view of the world.
- 42:44Yeah. And the Defense Department now
- 42:45explicitly has an Office of Strategic Capital.
- 42:48I know some of the folks that helped run that office, and they
- 42:51have sort of venture capital funds and private equity
- 42:53companies that sort of are officially deputized by them.
- 42:57And this is above. There's some stuff that's covert
- 42:59and some stuff that's just, you know.
- 43:01Normal. Normal stuff, but you can
- 43:02imagine, you know, the, the, the, the battlefield strategic
- 43:06competition is not just about building carrier groups and, you
- 43:10know, setting up military facilities and, you know,
- 43:12strategic deterrence. It's who controls ports, who
- 43:16controls airfields, who controls strategic mineral deposits and
- 43:19refining supply chains. And those are economic entities,
- 43:23right? Those are privately owned,
- 43:25incorporated, you know, LLCS that own and operate this
- 43:29infrastructure and these resource supply chains, which
- 43:31are, you know, between US and China now.
- 43:33Like that's the battlefield, right?
- 43:35And so if you do nothing, China's going to just own all
- 43:38those ports and facilities and rare earths is the US
- 43:41government, U.S. government doesn't really have state owned
- 43:43enterprises that operate in the same sort of like state
- 43:46controlled, like go and just buy this on behalf of the US
- 43:49government, right? But we do have aligned capital,
- 43:52right? That if given financing
- 43:54incentives and you know, patriotic encouragement, we'll
- 43:58we'll go do those things. And so there's that dimension of
- 44:01this which is just. Strategic competition how to
- 44:02ensure the US government's interests and and equities are.
- 44:05Are are manifested through the financial system and there's the
- 44:08more dark side, right, which we've seen manifestations of
- 44:10that go wrong, right, where you have covert activities that you
- 44:14need to finance themselves and they don't want to ask Congress
- 44:16for for money. And so, you know, you need to
- 44:19compromise a hedge fund guy or you give a hedge fund guy access
- 44:22to non public information and he trades on it and makes a a ton
- 44:26of money. And the deal is he gives you 80%
- 44:28of it. That's a pretty simple way of
- 44:30financing covert operations. I can tell you like multiple
- 44:34intelligence services in multiple countries do exactly
- 44:36that. That was actually one of the
- 44:38guys that we did a prisoner swap with for Russia was a guy that
- 44:40was doing that for the Russia insider trading fed information
- 44:43from the SVR. And you know, the deal was he
- 44:46would route those profits back to them.
- 44:48So, you know, financial markets, global capital markets are not
- 44:51just like, you know, the, the idealization of it's all, you
- 44:55know, private sector competing agents here doing arbitrage.
- 44:58There are all sorts of multi level games being played to
- 45:03exploit those systems. And you can go back to like
- 45:05BCCI, the Bank of Commercial, whatever Commerce and Credit
- 45:09International, which was, yeah, essentially CIA front group and
- 45:12is very connected to like Deltech Bank at the time.
- 45:15We know, you know, with Deltek's connections into the crypto
- 45:18space where early on. And so, yeah, it's like doesn't
- 45:20take, you don't need to be like Charlie with the red yarn to
- 45:23like come up with like a pretty plausible hypothesis here that
- 45:27U.S. government is not dumb, right?
- 45:29Like, like they, they know about this stuff, right?
- 45:31The question is, OK, what's the, how much is the long term play
- 45:35versus how much of it is just taking advantage of the balance
- 45:37sheets and the capital flows, you know, and the mechanisms
- 45:40that are available to you at that moment?
- 45:42I think it's more likely the latter, right?
- 45:44Like most bureaucrats just want to find, you know, like, like
- 45:48water, water finds its level, right?
- 45:50And so if you're like, I need to do a thing, what's around here
- 45:53that I can use to do that thing? And if, you know, stable coins
- 45:57exist, oh, I'm going to use that thing to do a certain thing.
- 46:00I think now it's more recent. The strategic element has come
- 46:02into play where when, when Tether is five, $10 billion,
- 46:07it's useful for covert operations.
- 46:08It's not useful for strategic things now when it goes from 200
- 46:12a hundred to 200 billion to a trillion dollars.
- 46:15Now it's much more useful as a strategic tool for US, you know,
- 46:18dollar dominance and and sort of expansion of demand for our
- 46:21debt. Then you know, some pass through
- 46:24for some covert operation. But at the end of the day, this
- 46:27is the give and take between the security state, which is always
- 46:30amorphous and driven by people and people change and those
- 46:34people come Bitcoiners, right. This is the this is the other
- 46:36thing that I've noticed is like when I first got involved with
- 46:39BPI wrote this white paper, Bitcoin US National Security,
- 46:41like an initial assessment and I learned it had been circulated
- 46:44inside the CIA. And actually two of those
- 46:47individuals that read the paper, I don't know if I was the single
- 46:49tipping point for them, but they both left the agency.
- 46:52Actually, one was a a ground branch kind of tier one special
- 46:55operator guy who would did some work with the agency.
- 46:57There was a case officer and they, they, they were tired and
- 47:01they started Bitcoin mining companies and started working in
- 47:03Bitcoin. And they're just like, like it
- 47:06wasn't like an OP. It was just like, this is more
- 47:09interesting and more compelling and more rewarding to me.
- 47:11And I have certain skills and I can apply those, you know, it's
- 47:14in my business wherever it might be.
- 47:16But like people are people, right?
- 47:19And Bitcoin is compelling to a lot of different sort of sort of
- 47:21personality types. You know, our director of
- 47:24government affairs is one of these guys.
- 47:25He was a career CIA officer. He was like deputy in their
- 47:27cyber division and he's going to Bitcoin meetups and just like
- 47:33and then retired and then wanted to get involved in Bitcoin.
- 47:36But his skill set, the closest he could get was for a
- 47:39blockchain, a legs company, which he really didn't like,
- 47:41right, because it's not really the same thing.
- 47:43So the first opportunity were like, hey, man, we would love
- 47:46to. And he kind of all our all our
- 47:48PPI stuff and he's just like, I died in a little bit corner.
- 47:50Now you're saying, oh, is he just like playing the part, you
- 47:52know, is he is he doing? And you know, it took some we
- 47:55had to like we had to put him through some tests, right?
- 47:58There's like, you know, you stick your hand in the thing,
- 48:00right? The beauty, but the beauty of
- 48:03that is the all the incentives are always aligned.
- 48:05Like it's where your story really resonated because we see
- 48:09this at folks we hire and I mentioned the investment fund we
- 48:12operate and it's called early riders because it's literally
- 48:14built on. It's the early riders are going
- 48:16to rebuild the world that are forced out of the the sector
- 48:19that they're in because the bureaucrats won't listen to
- 48:21them. They've just tried as much with
- 48:23the carrot and now it's the stick time.
- 48:25And the stick is, hey, I'm just going to rebuild this faster,
- 48:28more nimble, what a better unit. And so that's, yeah, ultimately
- 48:32if he's holding a Bitcoin bag, he's it's his interest to
- 48:35actually make sure it works with you or he just kind of like self
- 48:39defeating. Yeah, go.
- 48:41Ahead, jump in. Yeah, I was just going to say I
- 48:43wanted to go back to the the analogy of the gun on the table.
- 48:47I love that. And like, I'm curious in your
- 48:49mind, what is the tipping point to someone picking up the gun?
- 48:54And because I think to the to the layperson, perhaps the
- 48:58United States creating a strategic Bitcoin Reserve was
- 49:00like nudging their hand towards the gun.
- 49:03But there hasn't been, you know, to be fair, like a ton of follow
- 49:06through on that idea. We still haven't gotten the
- 49:07audit of how much Bitcoin we own, which was promised, I think
- 49:1030 days out and now it's, you know, two months past that.
- 49:13So curious your thoughts on, you know, the the follow through on
- 49:16the strategic Bitcoin reserve one.
- 49:18And then also like, what is that tipping point for picking up the
- 49:20proverbial gun on the table? Yes.
- 49:23And that's where we go from the sort of more abstract discussion
- 49:25of like the brass tacks here because, yes, the executive
- 49:28order, the history of the of the street Bitcoin Reserve,
- 49:31fascinating kind of case study here.
- 49:32So, you know, some of this is not entirely public.
- 49:35But so back in August in Nashville, you know, Trump gave
- 49:39a speech, BPI was asked, you know, if we had policy
- 49:42suggestions to send to the speech writing team.
- 49:44We had some ideas, threw them down.
- 49:46One of them was the SPR and we were pushed back.
- 49:49This is like, there's been nothing written about the SPR.
- 49:51This is like, it's like a meme, like somebody just made this up.
- 49:55That's not a real thing. And so I wrote, wrote like a
- 49:58little memo. I was like, no, no, it's a
- 49:59serious thing. Like this is the reason why it
- 50:00should, you know, it's like a strategic element of our, of
- 50:04our, of our Bitcoin policy and our, our approach to statecraft.
- 50:08And that got in speech and, you know, so first domino, right?
- 50:12And then, OK, well, then he has to get elected and then do the
- 50:14thing. And then it's OK, we have to
- 50:15draft up a bunch of white papers now to like reinforce that idea
- 50:19like this is a serious thing and then draft up like a notional
- 50:23executive order. Like if he gets if he gets
- 50:25elected, well, here's a way you could do it right.
- 50:27Like, you know, using existing funds, existing legal
- 50:30authorities. There you go.
- 50:32Now we didn't go strike the executive order, but we put
- 50:34ideas on the table. Executive order gets signed,
- 50:36established. The SBR declares Bitcoin the
- 50:39strategic asset digital gold 21st century, you know,
- 50:43important for us to to lead. And then specific instructions
- 50:46are given to the Commerce Department and the Treasury
- 50:48Department to identify budget neutral ways of acquiring
- 50:51additional Bitcoin for the SBR at no marginal cost to the
- 50:54taxpayer. And that has been, you know,
- 50:58given as instructions. We are waiting, you know, from
- 51:00the public's perspective to hear back.
- 51:02Well, what are those ideas, right?
- 51:03Because what does budget neutral mean, right?
- 51:06Like there's no like technical definition.
- 51:08It's a matter of interpretation. And therefore it's on, it's a
- 51:11matter of interpretation, depending on the bureaucrats and
- 51:13the senior officials that are now given this White House
- 51:15mandate to follow through. And that's where it requires
- 51:19kind of in the trenches, you know, analysis and and advocacy
- 51:24to sort of tilt, you know, this machine of state in the more
- 51:28bullish direction relative to the more conservative direction.
- 51:30Because a more conservative bureaucrat who gets that mandate
- 51:32could say, well, budget neutral. Well, almost nothing is budget
- 51:36neutral, right? Because I could always take any,
- 51:38any available, you know, set of assets, liquid or illiquid.
- 51:41And I can always use it for some other thing on my government's
- 51:44program of record. So anything is, you know, by
- 51:47definition, like an opportunity cost for the government's
- 51:49budget. And so I should spend almost
- 51:52nothing on Bitcoin, right? An alternative interpretation is
- 51:55that budget neutral means, well, I can't take existing, like
- 51:58congressionally appropriated funds for my, you know, FY25
- 52:01budget and use it for Bitcoin. But that leaves a lot of other
- 52:05sources of funds to acquire Bitcoin.
- 52:08Tariffs, oil and gas realties, spectrum auctions, existing
- 52:12assets that are held on the government's balance sheet that
- 52:14are not Bitcoin, that could be liquidated for Bitcoin, whether
- 52:16it's federal land, you know, leases for federal buildings or
- 52:21ownership of federal buildings, existing non Bitcoin digital
- 52:24assets all the way up to like revaluing gold certificates.
- 52:27And so like the span of interpretation bureaucratically
- 52:30goes from like buying almost no Bitcoin to buying like a massive
- 52:34slug of Bitcoin, right? And so the executive order
- 52:37doesn't really tell you where they're going to land.
- 52:38And the White House themselves didn't say where they're going
- 52:40to land. And this is now like a person by
- 52:42person issued inside the White House, like who who wants to
- 52:44lean in which direction or the other?
- 52:47And This is why there's different camps, right?
- 52:49Some more conservative, some more aggressive.
- 52:51And the way the Trump policy apparatus works, this isn't like
- 52:53there's like a, you know, a whole bunch of like hierarchical
- 52:56set of studies, right? Where there's like committees
- 52:59upon committees upon committees. And then there's a bunch of
- 53:01Coas. They have the president's
- 53:03working group of digital assets chaired by David Sacks.
- 53:06Bill Hines is running it as the crypto advisor.
- 53:09And he's trying to like, essentially quarterback this.
- 53:11So he's critical to this. Now he's taking these ideas, but
- 53:14then he has to kind of work by consensus from my committee, cuz
- 53:17ultimate has to be recommendations from the
- 53:18Treasury Secretary and the commerce secretary lot, Nick and
- 53:20Besson. And they're doing lots of other
- 53:22stuff, right? Post Liberation Day chaos,
- 53:24Middle Eastern, trillion dollar deals.
- 53:26And so Bitcoin is just not at the top of their paper stack,
- 53:29right. And so I don't think it's for
- 53:32lack of it. It's like, again, we're the
- 53:34autistic people paying attention to the to the, to the, to the
- 53:36checkoff gun. But there's like, you know, five
- 53:39other people in the room and they're having fistfights and
- 53:42there's a fire in the corner and there's like, you know, someones
- 53:44like there's other things happening, but we're just like,
- 53:46no, pick up the gun guys. The thing where the guy's
- 53:50smoking the ball while they're fighting, they're just like.
- 53:52I think it's less this like we're now at the point where
- 53:54it's less this geopolitical exogenous sort of monetary game.
- 53:58It's much more like the inside the court of Trump and these
- 54:03very specific number of finite people that have certain
- 54:06authorities to make decisions, you know, in the next few weeks.
- 54:10And and that's that's harder to predict, right?
- 54:14Like it's easier to model like state relations to a certain
- 54:16extent than like these five people.
- 54:18And like where they stand in this particular question.
- 54:20You need to get inside their heads.
- 54:22And even if you talk to them and they say I'm going to do X,
- 54:25that's like not necessarily like a strong predictor of what that
- 54:28person will literally do the next week, right?
- 54:30So there's lots of people who get, who get told by some of
- 54:33these people, oh, no, no, X is definitely not going to happen.
- 54:35And then X happens a week later, right?
- 54:38And so there's just, you know, I, I have enough hubris.
- 54:41I have enough humility. I would say sorry, say like I've
- 54:44been told various things again, like Grapevine that like, yeah,
- 54:48yeah, yeah, like this is going to happen.
- 54:49And I just go, OK, like, we'll be great, right?
- 54:54But like, I, I don't know how, how, how much of A leg to stand
- 54:57on there. I would say just like finger in
- 55:00the air, the vibes, if I'm going full vibes, Capital Management
- 55:04here, like the vibes are tilting.
- 55:07Like a month ago, post liberation day, it would have
- 55:09been more bearish. I would have said they're
- 55:12distracted. 5 long fire bitcoins not on their agenda.
- 55:15They've got other things to do. You know, we are one voice in
- 55:20this like hurricane trying to like advocate for this thing.
- 55:23And we're being drowned out by stable coin bills, you know,
- 55:26shenanigans with the Dems on market structure and all this
- 55:28other stuff that the most of the crypto lobbies are, are obsessed
- 55:31with because that's what they've told their bosses they're
- 55:34they're going to get done this year.
- 55:36There's not much of A national constituency prioritizing
- 55:38Bitcoin SBR really, except for us.
- 55:41And so, you know, we're we're scrappy, but like we have, we
- 55:44don't have a megaphone. So I was a bit more bearish, I'd
- 55:47say a month ago. I'm like, you know, they might
- 55:50just like throw us a bone here, but I've become increasingly
- 55:54more optimistic again, more vibes per SE than anything like
- 55:58definitive because you have to like, you know, put a large
- 56:02discount factor on all sorts of the rumor mill.
- 56:05I don't know, but I'm I'm increasingly of the opinion that
- 56:08they're going to buy a significant amount of Bitcoin.
- 56:10Trump and Lutnick are like just pure vibes capital, like Co
- 56:13founders, right, like where Trump, you know, literally just
- 56:16wants to own all the bitcoins. And then Lutnick has been
- 56:18talking about, you know, bitcoins price and obviously
- 56:20Cantor and what's going on there that if you had to make a bet,
- 56:23it's just the incentives also align or is like, why don't we
- 56:26just own all the Bitcoin in the US?
- 56:28Let's figure it out. And Trump leans in a direction
- 56:30that way and. This is where like, there's two
- 56:33ways of interpreting silence, right?
- 56:35You can interpret silence as they're ignoring us.
- 56:37It's off the radar screen. It's not a priority.
- 56:40That's the bearish interpretation there's.
- 56:42No interpretation, which is like, it's so serious.
- 56:44They're like, shut the fuck up, right?
- 56:46Like, like, we're going to go hard, but like, you better not,
- 56:49you know, you better. Not even.
- 56:51Like smirk at the direction of a mic.
- 56:53Right, like like this is this is this is this is high stakes.
- 56:56This is for real. Like this is not like a little,
- 56:58you know, side thing anymore, like the bit the big boys are
- 57:01now involved. And it when that happens, it
- 57:03gets serious and you just shut your mouth and you maybe even
- 57:06lie about what your plans are, right?
- 57:09So there's two ways of interpreting, you know, what's
- 57:11going on here, I'd say. The alternative is MicroStrategy
- 57:15could end up just being the US government's coins at a certain
- 57:18point, and then they already had a big stock ball.
- 57:20But that's a. It's a different.
- 57:21I mean, I know that's kind of like, yeah, I mean, that
- 57:25wouldn't be at the top of my list.
- 57:26Like the government can acquire Bitcoin from other pools
- 57:29without, you know, hitting domestic balance sheets.
- 57:33Like I'll just put an example, right?
- 57:35The defense gangs and the, you know, Trendo Agua and other
- 57:39South American and trans trans criminal, transnational criminal
- 57:42organizations were designated as terrorists.
- 57:45Officially, it's by executive order.
- 57:47When you designate those entities and those those leaders
- 57:50as terrorists, there's a whole bunch of national authorities
- 57:52and natural capabilities that you can now point at those
- 57:55people and they're using a lot of crypto.
- 57:59So wouldn't it be nice if we could just go after these
- 58:02fentsimal gangs and these and these cartels and Philip
- 58:06America's SPR with no marginal cost to the taxpayer.
- 58:10So there's there's other ways that you can go after that
- 58:13without, you know, I think sailor has lots of lawyers and
- 58:17we still live in a rule of law country.
- 58:18Like if we're in a situation where the government is seizing
- 58:20micro sailor's Bitcoin stack, like a lot of things have gone
- 58:24horribly wrong in America and you know, we are in there's lots
- 58:29of other things that you should be worried about at the same
- 58:31time. And so you should be your
- 58:33contingency plan. There is more more your citadel
- 58:37and your guns and your self protection.
- 58:40So I know we like to plan for lots of worst case scenarios,
- 58:42but that's not the top of my list.
- 58:43I think there's other the government wants to buy some
- 58:45Bitcoin. It can go buy some Bitcoin.
- 58:48It's got the money printer and you know, athletes resistance
- 58:55always, right? Like constraints determine
- 58:57action. But how do you how do you square
- 58:59or balance like the the perception of like, you know, if
- 59:02they went full, just like we're going to print money and buy
- 59:05Bitcoin, I think there would be a natural tendency to then
- 59:08question the dollar system more granularly.
- 59:12And so I think that's part of the dance too, is like they
- 59:15can't get too aggressive and and, you know, really forcefully
- 59:19grab the gun. They they kind of have to do
- 59:21this, this quasi dance and and not be too over in what they're
- 59:24doing. Would you agree with that?
- 59:25A. 100% yeah. I mean, all Fiat currencies
- 59:28stand in a superposition of positive value and 0 value and
- 59:33there's nothing in between. And so you as a hegemon who
- 59:37issues Fiat paper claims to your future tax revenues, would not
- 59:40want to undermine the confidence in the global markets, you know,
- 59:45you know, sense of the value of that Fiat claim if you have to.
- 59:49You know, essentially it's it's calibration, it's communication,
- 59:52it's forward guidance, it's proportionality.
- 59:55So if they were literally saying and executing on a plan of
- 59:57acquiring as much Bitcoin as they could by printing money,
- 1:00:00well, then everyone's just going to sell what they're not buying
- 1:00:02and buying what they're buying. And then you're a Bitcoin, you
- 1:00:04know, hybrid bitcoinization overnight.
- 1:00:05I don't think that's in the cards.
- 1:00:06I don't think that's in the cards anytime soon until, you
- 1:00:09know, we're literally, you know, on the precipice.
- 1:00:12And so you know, but I think I want to buy.
- 1:00:15In a in a budget fashion, a few 100,000 Bitcoin for, you know,
- 1:00:22we're talking from the government's balance sheet
- 1:00:23perspective, you know, like, like less than $100 billion of
- 1:00:28anything is like it's like kind of you know, it's like a it's
- 1:00:31like a it's in the rounding of of the national of the national
- 1:00:34GDP. So but it's also signal, right
- 1:00:38overall, I mean, my argument has been with the bit bonds idea is
- 1:00:42that if you're going to do a pro Bitcoin strategy, like one way
- 1:00:46you can mitigate that risk essentially is synthetically
- 1:00:48graphed on that hard asset that you're monetizing into your debt
- 1:00:52issuance, right? So this is, you know, maybe not
- 1:00:55phase one, but maybe phase two, phase three for going down this
- 1:00:57particular Rd. here is, you know, bit bonds, right, which is
- 1:01:01basically that right and gives gives exposure to kind of a
- 1:01:05volatility controlled, you know, security that has, you know,
- 1:01:09relationship to Bitcoin and actual Bitcoin payouts.
- 1:01:12The government gets to essentially take proceeds from
- 1:01:14that debt issuance, fill up the, you know, the SBR and they could
- 1:01:18potentially issue that bond at a lower coupon.
- 1:01:22And so they get to borrow cheaply relative to what they
- 1:01:24otherwise could. And so they think there are
- 1:01:26clever mechanisms, you know, government could go go about in
- 1:01:29terms of acquiring Bitcoin while still servicing its debts, while
- 1:01:32still maintaining confidence in its debt markets at the end of
- 1:01:36the day, right? Like sort of recapitalizing
- 1:01:37itself right over time, right. With like with hard assets,
- 1:01:41which is, you know, people speak about this in monetary
- 1:01:44economics, like very casually when it comes to gold is because
- 1:01:47that's been the thing that we've done before with gold, Like
- 1:01:50we've gone on and off gold standards as different countries
- 1:01:53over different times. So it's like not like a
- 1:01:55conceptual, you know, like new thing for that to happen.
- 1:01:59It's new to think about it with Bitcoin, whether we I don't
- 1:02:02think we would go on a Bitcoin standard anytime soon, but
- 1:02:06diversifying your national balance sheet, acquiring a hard
- 1:02:08asset that you can asymmetrically monetize relative
- 1:02:11to say Chinese gold and use that to also help fund the strategic
- 1:02:15techno industrial investment projects.
- 1:02:17Say you use some of the SPR to to to act as seed capital for
- 1:02:20sovereign wealth fund and do energy and AI build out instead
- 1:02:25of relying on Saudi and Gulf money?
- 1:02:28Right. Like, like if I had to like
- 1:02:30pick, you know, KOA A KOA B, Hey, let's like go and kind of
- 1:02:33like buddy up with a bunch of gulf kings to like beg for
- 1:02:37their, you know, trillions of dollars of capital to flow into
- 1:02:40our AI. And therefore we have to give
- 1:02:42them access to frontier a models and maybe even AGI gets born in
- 1:02:46the desert of Saudi Arabia or the Emirates.
- 1:02:48Like wouldn't it be nice if we could actually capitalize those
- 1:02:51investments without having to go to these autocratic regimes?
- 1:02:55Can we just, you know, put some high-powered digital gold inside
- 1:02:59wealth fund, run that up turbo, turn 50 billion into 500 billion
- 1:03:03in a few years and then boom, bring in public private
- 1:03:05investment, leverage it up. You've got $2 trillion in in in
- 1:03:09dry powder to to fund your techno industrial domestic
- 1:03:14renaissance, and you've got no foreign entanglements or
- 1:03:17obligations. Hope you're enjoying the
- 1:03:19episode. Just a quick break, tell you a
- 1:03:22little. Bit more about something we just
- 1:03:24launched. On Ramp Trade is our new account
- 1:03:27here built for individuals who are ready to start accumulating
- 1:03:30Bitcoin or want a simpler, more secure way to grow their
- 1:03:33position. Think about your friends and
- 1:03:35family. Maybe with Bitcoin crossing 100K
- 1:03:38again more recently, perhaps they're asking you questions or
- 1:03:41they might be soon and so they need a secure place to buy
- 1:03:44Bitcoin. Whether you want a dollar cost
- 1:03:47average make one time purchases, we have designed On Ramp Trade
- 1:03:50to give you very low fees. A fully segregated custody
- 1:03:55account, so you have your own Bitcoin in your own wallet on
- 1:03:58chain. You also have access to the on
- 1:04:00ramp terminal. You have access to the on ramp
- 1:04:02team as well. Human support, no chat box, no
- 1:04:06emails, getting lost in the abyss.
- 1:04:07So you can see Cam the stud in the bottom right hand.
- 1:04:10You can talk to Cam if you want to.
- 1:04:13And right now we are running a launch promotion with the code
- 1:04:16TLT through June 30th. So is there actually 0 trading
- 1:04:21fees through September? So you can just be smashed
- 1:04:23buying without even having to pay any fees there and then it's
- 1:04:26also 50% off account fees. And you can actually earn 50 to
- 1:04:30$150.00 in Bitcoin for each person you refer to on Ramp once
- 1:04:34you're signed up. So if your friends and family
- 1:04:36need a place to buy or you want to buy some more Bitcoin, take
- 1:04:39advantage of these lows, low fees for foreseeable future,
- 1:04:43head on over to on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:04:45You can sign up in minutes or you could also speak to us on
- 1:04:49the consultation. You can do that from the home
- 1:04:50page as well now. Hope you enjoyed the rest of the
- 1:04:53episode and all the best to you. See you later.
- 1:04:57I think no, it makes it makes sense.
- 1:04:58I think like from the capitalistic opportunistic
- 1:05:02perspective, I think everything you said, it ties into this
- 1:05:05notion of the traditional 6040 and how, you know, individuals
- 1:05:09all the way to sovereigns have preserved capital inequities and
- 1:05:13bonds is completely everyone in the gold camp, as you alluded
- 1:05:17to, is like known this, the hardcore gold bugs, but there's
- 1:05:20never really been a viable path, But also kind of from the powers
- 1:05:25that be signaling it meaning like gold and Bitcoin become
- 1:05:28money and everything else is a credit instrument.
- 1:05:30And that's a huge like still taboo to talk about today, even
- 1:05:35though big gold sit at whatever $30,000 a Troy oz and bitcoins,
- 1:05:39it's over 100K. And so as that repricing
- 1:05:42happens, there's just going to be a lot of people left holding
- 1:05:44bags of kind of like, you know, they're going to slowly migrate
- 1:05:47over, but they're going to be left holding bags, real estate,
- 1:05:50you know, bonds, traditional equities.
- 1:05:52And so I think that's just like an overarching theme.
- 1:05:56The other aspect, and I know we're coming up, we got about 20
- 1:05:59minutes. I don't know, Jackson, if you
- 1:06:01want to take it in different direction that the thought that
- 1:06:03Matt brought up is there's something interesting I think
- 1:06:06you've been talking about in this convergence of multiple
- 1:06:08like taboo or things that are just so kind of like wild that
- 1:06:11they're all coming together, which is the AI AGI component.
- 1:06:15There's Bitcoin and then there's the natural like UAP
- 1:06:17conversation and they all like kind of tie back to energy in my
- 1:06:21mind. I haven't thought deeply about
- 1:06:23this, but curious how you think about where Bitcoin's almost
- 1:06:25like this Canary in the coal mine for finding the cheapest
- 1:06:27source of energy to mine. And then you're seeing like the
- 1:06:29existing miners or the compute going in like, you know, crap
- 1:06:34picking that up. But then even again, just
- 1:06:37limited knowledge on the UAP side.
- 1:06:38It's like a lot of these sightings or at least a big
- 1:06:40portion or around nuclear and around energy.
- 1:06:43How do you just think about like that world and where this like
- 1:06:46UAP conversations coming up? And I know it's something that
- 1:06:49you're you're known for the talk about and I think a lot of
- 1:06:52people aren't familiar with a lot of these concepts.
- 1:06:53So just maybe starting at the very high level would be good
- 1:06:56for people to tiptoe. We'll sort of tiptoe in here.
- 1:06:58The water's warm. But to your point like, well,
- 1:07:02one like Bitcoin I think is a anti fragile asset that has
- 1:07:06asymmetric option value relative to global disruption.
- 1:07:10And we've talked a lot about the disruptions coming from the
- 1:07:13geopolitical and monetary kind of fragilities and shake UPS
- 1:07:16here. And we think Bitcoin has sort
- 1:07:18of, you know, asymmetric upside relative to those disruptions,
- 1:07:22right? So you want to own Bitcoin
- 1:07:23because you think, you know, indebted government's gonna have
- 1:07:25to print their way out of it. A fragmenting, A fragmenting
- 1:07:27global system is gonna inherently rely on, you know,
- 1:07:30decentralized cross-border, you know, trustless means of
- 1:07:33settlement. We're still a digital
- 1:07:35civilization. So we're going to want to settle
- 1:07:37in a digital, you know, reserve asset doesn't have all the
- 1:07:39physical and transactional and verification cost of gold.
- 1:07:43The the typical bromides full case for Bitcoin that gets
- 1:07:47Bitcoin to, you know, parody with gold right and I think
- 1:07:51that's probably gonna happen in the next, you know, three to
- 1:07:53five years bearish, but that's that's like OK, the normal like
- 1:07:58again, kind of like most of what I focus on and there's other
- 1:08:02disruptions coming in right A lot of focuses on on the
- 1:08:05accelerations coming out of these frontier AI model labs and
- 1:08:08there's been a lot now of the discourse inside the Bitcoin
- 1:08:10community on how that will intersect with Bitcoin right,
- 1:08:13Whether an agent based digital economy is going to use Bitcoin
- 1:08:17as a you know, I mean of exchange as a as a store value
- 1:08:20for their own economic activities.
- 1:08:23You know that don't have bank, they don't have bank accounts,
- 1:08:24so they need to have a digitally native, you know, currency to to
- 1:08:29hold and to transact, you know through and and in which seems
- 1:08:32plausible to me. Obviously Sam Altman has his has
- 1:08:36his druthers. It'll all be world coin.
- 1:08:37So, you know, we need to nip that in the bud, but this is
- 1:08:43another convergence of kind of these accelerating technological
- 1:08:46disruptions that are gonna have like cascading impacts on our
- 1:08:49monetary paradigm. So I think there's a strong
- 1:08:53positive like loop between AI and Bitcoin in many ways.
- 1:08:57There's like maybe other macro level questions about AI that
- 1:09:00are more about how it affects, you know, the the the social
- 1:09:03fabric and division of Labor and where the surpluses are
- 1:09:08concentrated or diffused in society.
- 1:09:09Are those just like hoarded by a bunch of, you know, techno
- 1:09:12oligarchs? Is there some Ubi?
- 1:09:14How is that man? Is there's a whole bunch of
- 1:09:16other questions and that that might have spillover effects on
- 1:09:18how we think about Bitcoin over that, you know, 3 to 510 year
- 1:09:21time. Ryan, you know, the way P
- 1:09:24question is another one of these questions I think people don't
- 1:09:25pay as much attention to because it's been shrouded in a lot of
- 1:09:27historical taboo and stigma intentionally so on the part of
- 1:09:31the the relevant government interests at play.
- 1:09:34But it's it will come in to the top to this discourse sort of
- 1:09:39shift that we saw Bitcoin go through like over the window
- 1:09:42moved. Talking about Bitcoin seriously
- 1:09:44inside DC was like a fringe thing when we got started at
- 1:09:47BPI. And now we're hosting events.
- 1:09:49And I'll tell you the people that you're going to see at our
- 1:09:51policy summit on June 25th, which by the way, sign up
- 1:09:55btcpolicysummit.org. You can go to my Twitter
- 1:09:58accounts, my pin, tweet. You can use a statecraft for a
- 1:10:03free ticket. So people listening if you're
- 1:10:05wow. And you can stay.
- 1:10:07To get a free ticket, but you gotta sign up.
- 1:10:09I might, I might change that discount code, but you know, the
- 1:10:11next in the next week or two. So yeah.
- 1:10:14So, so sign up because I think the people you'll see at our
- 1:10:17policy summit will, you know, align with the topics we've
- 1:10:20talked about here, like the level of people that are gonna
- 1:10:23talk about Bitcoin and it's very serious fashion from a strategic
- 1:10:26standpoint will surprise people. I'll just say that we haven't
- 1:10:29announced some of those people yet.
- 1:10:32So that's, that's, that's this track here, like this Orbison
- 1:10:35window shift can happen pretty quickly.
- 1:10:37And in our particular domain, it wasn't a surprise to us because
- 1:10:39we're like, of course Bitcoin is going to, you know, go to the
- 1:10:42moon. Of course it's going to be a
- 1:10:43strategic asset. Just the world doesn't recognize
- 1:10:44it yet, right? We're the in Group that shares a
- 1:10:47common set of sort of shibboleths and sort of
- 1:10:49canonical lore and kind of a bit of religious, you know, belief
- 1:10:52system that there's going to be some future redeeming event, you
- 1:10:55know, hyper bitcoinization, where I'll be proven right and
- 1:10:58the no corners will be proven wrong and the world will sort of
- 1:11:01bend to my to my vision of things that may actually
- 1:11:04objectively happen, you know, with Bitcoin.
- 1:11:07But we think that's normal because we're in that in Group
- 1:11:09and we've seen that over to window shift in real time AI.
- 1:11:13Similarly, you know, folks that are in that in Group have seen
- 1:11:15this move from less wrong, less wrong blog posts talking about
- 1:11:20the AI super intelligence takeover existential risk.
- 1:11:23Nicholas Bostrom, you know, Elijah Yakowsky, all the sorts
- 1:11:26of stuff. I wrote a whole novel actually a
- 1:11:27number of years ago on quantum AI, super intelligence take off
- 1:11:30scenarios. So I was in that in Group as
- 1:11:33well. And I was like, oh, this is a
- 1:11:34thing. And that's now moved to the
- 1:11:36center of the discourse there. There are now lots of high level
- 1:11:38policy conversations happening as we speak on, you know, the
- 1:11:41timelines for AGI and what that means for geopolitical
- 1:11:44competition. We're having these multi $100
- 1:11:46billion, you know, deals done with Saudi Arabia to box out
- 1:11:49China. It's driving geopolitical
- 1:11:51decision making. UA PS You know, I've seen this
- 1:11:54play out and it kind of I've learned to sort of look around
- 1:11:57kind of the corners here and see those little moves on the on the
- 1:12:00on the the like the tails of the distribution to see those, those
- 1:12:03shifts. And this is this is coming in.
- 1:12:07It's coming in faster, I think, than even some of those other
- 1:12:09ones did. There's a large, you know,
- 1:12:12that's a multi hour conversation, like what's
- 1:12:14exactly coming in? But the, the basic premise is
- 1:12:16that, you know, we will have to accommodate ourselves to the
- 1:12:19fact of non human intelligence, advanced technology that's a
- 1:12:24product of that non human intelligence.
- 1:12:26Israel is interacting with humanity, is has been
- 1:12:28interacting with humanity for some time.
- 1:12:30And there are government programs that have been
- 1:12:32dedicated to this for many decades.
- 1:12:35So those are just facts. People will have to accommodate
- 1:12:37themselves to, you know, some will accommodate themselves to
- 1:12:40those facts. Sooner, sooner, sooner or later,
- 1:12:43it will be uncomfortable in various fashions.
- 1:12:45But then there's a lot of downstream implications of that,
- 1:12:49of accommodating yourself just to those bare facts.
- 1:12:51There's other facts associated with that, you know, that are
- 1:12:55that go in lots of different directions.
- 1:12:58The most relevant you could say for Bitcoin, it's like a hedge
- 1:13:00is technological disruptions to our physics paradigm, right?
- 1:13:05And a good thing about Bitcoin is the difficulty adjustment is
- 1:13:08that even if we have breakthroughs in in energy
- 1:13:10production within two weeks, right, the hash rate will
- 1:13:13adjust. Now the question is more about
- 1:13:16security concentration of whatever that new production is
- 1:13:19if it's dedicated to ASICS. Ultimately, you know,
- 1:13:22concentration of energy goes through concentration of
- 1:13:24compute. And so you know, it's more a
- 1:13:27function of who gets who has access both to the energy and to
- 1:13:29the compute. I think The upshot of the NHIUAP
- 1:13:33story is the technology component and the physics
- 1:13:37component will be far down the line of public discourse and
- 1:13:41disclosure for a lot of non proliferation and existential
- 1:13:45risk concerns. There's a reason why they've
- 1:13:46kept that secret for so long. There's, you know, certain
- 1:13:49things you could pull out of the black ball of of science that
- 1:13:53would be, you know, we we pulled out nuclear physics and those
- 1:13:56give us nuclear weapons. And it was the fact that it's
- 1:13:59somewhat difficult to create high purity uranium and
- 1:14:02plutonium and then get the the triggers right to make a nuclear
- 1:14:06weapon that keeps that risk somewhat constrained.
- 1:14:09If there was aspects of physics that were easier to weaponize,
- 1:14:14while those would be dangerous things to spill into the public
- 1:14:16domain, I think that's part of the consideration.
- 1:14:20I think there's also lots of other things going on associated
- 1:14:23with the evolution of these programs over time.
- 1:14:26And it's part of the geopolitical bargaining that's
- 1:14:27taking place right now. Trump is alluding to
- 1:14:31breakthrough weapon systems that nobody understands how they
- 1:14:34work. And he is, you know, dangling
- 1:14:37that out there for a reason. There's, you know, a lot of
- 1:14:42reconfigurations happening behind the scenes associated
- 1:14:44with these historical conflicts that are being, you know,
- 1:14:48snuffed out quite quickly. You know, at least that's what
- 1:14:51they're trying to do. And this looks like setting the
- 1:14:54stage for, you know, if you're going to be forced to
- 1:14:58accommodate humanity to a reconfiguration of its place in
- 1:15:01the universe, you want to kind of maintain, you want to kind of
- 1:15:04get to a stable position as possible as quickly as possible.
- 1:15:09I don't have a particular timeline.
- 1:15:11I think there's a lot of if fans embedded in this, but we are, we
- 1:15:16are on a trajectory where I mean, the sooner it's like with
- 1:15:19Bitcoin, it's like, you know, the sooner, the better you will
- 1:15:24comment yourself to what's to what's happening, the, the more
- 1:15:26you'll be prepared for the, the change that's coming down the
- 1:15:29line. Yeah.
- 1:15:31I appreciate you running through that and especially in that
- 1:15:33framing because I think for a lot of individuals, a lot of
- 1:15:36this stuff has never even brought to the table.
- 1:15:38And so helping through the lens of, well, Bitcoin was insane
- 1:15:41until it's not an AI is insane until it's not because we've
- 1:15:43heard it since we grew up watching, you know, Terminator
- 1:15:45and stuff. And then ultimately just a
- 1:15:48little bit of a tease for individuals to go down.
- 1:15:53Personally, it's interesting because I've always thought
- 1:15:54about Bitcoin is incentive alignment is just too perfect.
- 1:15:57That had to come and we don't go in here, but it's like it's too
- 1:16:00perfect for it to be created by man Into your point where I
- 1:16:03think you're kind of going is like, well, if it's naturally
- 1:16:05tied to energy and the reflexivity of the difficulty
- 1:16:08adjustment, it keeps the constraints tied in effectively.
- 1:16:11And I remember when the AI stuff was picking up in 21, I had
- 1:16:14this, I know exactly where I where I was at when I was like,
- 1:16:17oh, well, like Bitcoin actually protects us from AI because you
- 1:16:20have to plug in those systems and pay it with something to
- 1:16:22keep the energy. Like the energy has to come from
- 1:16:24a foundational, you know, constraint of the society.
- 1:16:27So it's all fun and like not even fun.
- 1:16:29It's just it's, it's constructive stuff to go down.
- 1:16:31So I appreciate you running through it.
- 1:16:34I know Jackson. I was just going to say like,
- 1:16:36it's, it's, it's hard to kind of, you know, bite off a bunch.
- 1:16:38It's like trying to explain Bitcoin to someone the first
- 1:16:41time. It's like you're fucking crazy
- 1:16:42magic Internet money, cryptography, you know, game
- 1:16:46theory, the history of money. Let me talk to you about calorie
- 1:16:49shells and da da da. And then people go, there's like
- 1:16:51a tiny percentage of population that goes like, oh, that's
- 1:16:53interesting. And then then they go down the
- 1:16:56proverbial rabbit hole and they self educate and they they come
- 1:16:59to some conclusion about the risk weighted probability of
- 1:17:02this Bitcoin thing being a serious thing and then making a
- 1:17:06life choice to invest substantial portions of capital.
- 1:17:08I think there's the same sort of epistemic and personal, you
- 1:17:11know, dynamic at play with this topic.
- 1:17:13There's a lot of initial rejection and taboo and kind of
- 1:17:15resistance to the, the apriori, you know, premise, right, that a
- 1:17:19lot of people just reject out of hand.
- 1:17:20And then some people that go home.
- 1:17:22That's interesting. There might be something there
- 1:17:23and they pay attention to what's happening in the government side
- 1:17:26and other areas and they follow the threat and they self
- 1:17:29educate. Yeah, and it's all objectively
- 1:17:31true. The the crazy part is like, I
- 1:17:34think it might have been one of the pause you did with Danny,
- 1:17:37but it was something that was said it like it ended in the
- 1:17:39most kind of like ominous, like if this is true, it changes
- 1:17:43everything. It was something to that effect.
- 1:17:45And it was referencing the disclosure book.
- 1:17:48And so I went to go start listening to that and there's
- 1:17:50just like all the accounts, like it's just like we can
- 1:17:52objectively say that the debt system is unsustainable.
- 1:17:54Most people be like, no, it's fine.
- 1:17:55And you're like, no, no, there's just there's like enough proof
- 1:17:57here. It's very similar to what you're
- 1:17:58describing and it's all out there, but I did want to give
- 1:18:02some more burn to BPI because I know you touched on it.
- 1:18:04We don't have to. We can, you know, in the last
- 1:18:06kind of like 7 to 10 minutes. Incredible work you guys are
- 1:18:09doing. Like we deeply not only respect,
- 1:18:12but have been in the space for a while and have seen how hard it
- 1:18:16is from like, you know, from the venture side and crypto coming
- 1:18:19in and just getting people to support all coins and go out on
- 1:18:22the, the risk curve and just blow their businesses up all the
- 1:18:24way to the quote, UN quote lobbyists that are, you know,
- 1:18:28have all the dollars to spend. And you guys being in a, in a
- 1:18:30doing things the right way on the think tank side, but also
- 1:18:34having natural constraints. And so anything you want to
- 1:18:36share about that and where people can reach out or get
- 1:18:38involved or allocate capital to help kind of further the cause
- 1:18:41on what you're working on? I think it's super exciting
- 1:18:43because you've been a a leader, Speaking of the space outside of
- 1:18:47the space, like from a, from a, where you're put, you know, put
- 1:18:49food on the table. Now you get to do both, which is
- 1:18:52really exciting because having your mind focus on this, I think
- 1:18:55we'd all agree, is super impactful for kind of furthering
- 1:18:58Bitcoin. Yeah, I know.
- 1:19:00I mean, everyone at BPI, like there's like an implicit filter
- 1:19:03or self selection, like they have to kind of get the bit
- 1:19:05right. And they're they're all finally
- 1:19:07there to like, you know, self actualize, you could say, right?
- 1:19:10Like a lot of think tanks, they get set up in DC to kind of be
- 1:19:13self licking ice cream cones. You know, they want to do the
- 1:19:16same summit every year, kind of the same panel discussions.
- 1:19:20They keep coming back to their donor base and be like, ah, we
- 1:19:22need to do the thing like we're like here to kind of like super
- 1:19:24Dova. It's like start with a bang,
- 1:19:26expand as quickly as possible to like have the strategic impact
- 1:19:30in this relatively limited window.
- 1:19:31We think we have to like decisively shift the future
- 1:19:34trajectory of the US and the global adoption of Bitcoin and
- 1:19:37then potentially do something very different, right?
- 1:19:39Like it's like Bitcoin needs like maximal support, like in
- 1:19:43the next, you know, 12 to 24 months, you would say, right?
- 1:19:46And then just be like an implementation tail.
- 1:19:50But you know, we've kind of came out of kind of a glorified blog
- 1:19:53state, you know, three years ago.
- 1:19:55We now have 8 full time staff inside DCA, total of 10 full
- 1:19:58time staff. We've got a bench of 23 fellows,
- 1:20:00National security experts, Energy.
- 1:20:03Policy experts, philosophers, economists, former deputy
- 1:20:08governors of central banks, right?
- 1:20:10We've got a deep bench of people, but honestly, we're
- 1:20:14still, I would say 10% of the policy advocacy crypto community
- 1:20:19inside DC. And you think about a coin is
- 1:20:23maybe 65% of the market, right? Right.
- 1:20:25If you throw out a lot of, you know, explicit nonsense for like
- 1:20:289095%. So like we're completely
- 1:20:31inverted relative. And I think you see those that,
- 1:20:34you know, reflected in the outcomes in inside DC.
- 1:20:36It's like, why is stablecoins the first priority and then
- 1:20:39market structure and then the SBR, right?
- 1:20:42If you were like objective, you had no inside analysis of how
- 1:20:46much sunk cost there is from all the sort of crypto industrial
- 1:20:49complex there, you'd be like, well, of course the SPR is the
- 1:20:52most important thing. Do that first.
- 1:20:55That's like the foundational neutral reserve asset that
- 1:20:58floats everyone's boats and also aligns more explicitly with U.S.
- 1:21:00National interest here. And our values around the world
- 1:21:04isn't just like special carve outs for a certain crypto
- 1:21:06business model, but it's instead it's the inverted and that's a
- 1:21:09direct function of just how, how things are portioned inside the
- 1:21:12DC, you know, sort of ecosystem. So yeah, we are, we, we want to
- 1:21:17essentially scale proportionally to Bitcoin and Bitcoin's impact
- 1:21:21and try to make sure that at least the policy environment
- 1:21:24inside inside DC is at least like market weighted.
- 1:21:27And it's we're at least, I'd say, you know, 6-6 times away
- 1:21:31from that in terms of our current budget to where that
- 1:21:33would be market weighted. And so, yeah, we're, we're
- 1:21:36aggressively looking for supporters in expansion.
- 1:21:38We're also looking for thought leaders, folks in the community
- 1:21:41that have insight and curiosity about, you know, intersection of
- 1:21:44Bitcoin, the energy system, Bitcoin and AI, Bitcoin,
- 1:21:47national security, Bitcoin, geopolitics, Bitcoin and blank,
- 1:21:51right, basically. And there's a lot of Bitcoin and
- 1:21:53blank things out there. And so we're always looking for
- 1:21:56people, folks to come in with ideas, suggestions on, you know,
- 1:22:01white papers or events that they would like to help host, you
- 1:22:04know, expertise that like to add in.
- 1:22:07We we, we bring on visiting fellows to support particular
- 1:22:11projects. So yeah, we want to act as like
- 1:22:13a, an intellectual and sort of cultural hub to a certain extent
- 1:22:17inside DC on Bitcoin and these larger questions.
- 1:22:20So, yeah, we're going to be opening up a full time office in
- 1:22:23partnership with Pub Key downtown over the course of the
- 1:22:25summer. And that'll be like one of these
- 1:22:27third spaces to host these sorts of events.
- 1:22:30And we'd love, you know, once we're a full operating
- 1:22:32capability to have folks that are in DC just like a spot to
- 1:22:35hang out, grab a burger and, and, and hanging with the BPI
- 1:22:38crew. So yes, you can go to
- 1:22:39btcpolicy.org to, to check us out.
- 1:22:44And you can e-mail me Pines at btcpolicy.org if you have any
- 1:22:50questions or you want to get involved.
- 1:22:52And that's. Star cracked in the in the
- 1:22:54subject. I wouldn't short change yourself
- 1:22:57too much in the sense of like you, you Bitcoin's going to get
- 1:22:59the SBR. It's just a matter of when, not
- 1:23:02if. And you know, nobody else is
- 1:23:04going to get that from the crypto side.
- 1:23:06And then also appreciate, you know how much fun you guys are
- 1:23:09having. You see it on Twitter and it
- 1:23:11reminds me a lot of what we're building here in the sense that
- 1:23:13like as long as you're on the right side of history and also
- 1:23:17you have the passion and energy, it doesn't matter how much
- 1:23:19capital somebody else has because you just are able to
- 1:23:22counter position. And that's kind of like how I
- 1:23:24think about us building this business and it ties into the
- 1:23:27custody stuff where we're, you know, talking with you guys, I'm
- 1:23:30trying to help on just some of the multi institution aspects of
- 1:23:33like what does an SBR actually look like?
- 1:23:35And this was from building self custody solutions for hardcore
- 1:23:37bit corners and realizing like, holy crap, trillions of dollars
- 1:23:40going to come into this space and it's all going to go to
- 1:23:42Coinbase or proxy coinbases. And that's how gold failed.
- 1:23:45So we naturally need to leverage bitcoins properties from a
- 1:23:48decentralized perspective. And I think that's now starting
- 1:23:51to become mainstream. We're like bit bonds or any kind
- 1:23:54of sovereign exposure to the asset.
- 1:23:55It can't be held on plastic devices and desk drawers.
- 1:23:58And it's also can't sit at Coinbase because we know what
- 1:24:00happens when, you know, hard money centralizes.
- 1:24:04So you can just do things just like you wrote a paper and now
- 1:24:06Trump is doing stuff. Yeah, exactly right.
- 1:24:09Like never underestimate the power of of memes, right.
- 1:24:12And you know, an organization starts as a meme and it becomes
- 1:24:16a real political force and you can just do things.
- 1:24:19So I would just go do things. I love the inspirational end to
- 1:24:25this show. Well, Matt, appreciate you
- 1:24:27joining. For those listening, check out
- 1:24:30btcpolicy.org and maybe join the event in June.
- 1:24:34Thanks again, Matt. Thanks, Matt.
- 1:24:36This is awesome. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:24:38week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:24:41valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:24:43rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:24:45All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:24:47notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:24:50reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:24:53entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:24:56investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:24:59your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:25:01Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:25:05one of our private client advisors.