Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 145 - Freddie New: The State is Failing
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 145 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:35Brought to you as always by our wonderful sponsor Veritas Villages.
- 0:40Veritas Villages are off-grid, energy-self-sufficient, luxury communities in Latin America designed for freedom lovers.
- 0:48Bitcoin is accepted at all villages, including for the purchase of property.
- 0:54What's not to like?
- 0:55Anyway, more info at www.ecovillages.life forward slash free cities.
- 1:01Please mention us.
- 1:03If you do business with them, everything you could need is in the show notes.
- 1:07And if you want to meet these guys in person, well, Patrick Hibbert, he's the creator of Veritas Villages.
- 1:14He'll be speaking this year at the Free Cities Conference in Prague, 31st of October to the 2nd of November 2025.
- 1:22yes it's just two months away believe it or not seems like last year is still fresh in my mind
- 1:28this year is definitely shaping up to be something special by the looks of it
- 1:33it's going to be a year of announcements i can't give too much away obviously but if you've been
- 1:39to the conference before you'll know that we normally have a lot of focus on our few flagship
- 1:45projects the most famous being prospera and ciudad morazan who will of course be there in force but
- 1:51big things have been happening behind the scenes this year and i suspect that some exciting new
- 1:58developments may be revealed that could really broaden the map of free cities projects going
- 2:04forward anyway our conference is where you'll get the inside track on all of this stuff and
- 2:11meet everyone in person which is pretty underrated as far as i'm concerned if you're on the fence
- 2:17about attending? Well, this year, I would say this is the one. Our network is growing. And I would say
- 2:24that currently you're lucky enough to be what I would call a first adopter in this space. So come
- 2:31and be a part of it in real life before it gets too big. I watched this happen in the Bitcoin space.
- 2:39Early on, everyone was friends and we all knew each other. Now, when you go to a Bitcoin conference,
- 2:45Sometimes there's 50,000 people there and you can't get to speak to who you want to.
- 2:50Anyway, our conference gets bigger every year.
- 2:52This year is going to be the biggest one yet, but it's still pretty intimate and you could
- 2:57take advantage of that yourself.
- 2:59Anyway, on to today's show.
- 3:01I managed to get Freddie New to sit down with me in the Free Cities podcast chair.
- 3:08Bitcoiners amongst you will know him.
- 3:10He's the head of policy at Bitcoin Policy UK, but for everyone else, he's a lawyer and a political strategist.
- 3:18Often heard publicly voicing his concerns about unchecked bureaucracy and government overreach.
- 3:26And let me say this episode is no different.
- 3:30Here's what my AI made of it.
- 3:32This episode explores why the state is failing from bloated regulation and surveillance to economic fragility and the erosion of personal freedom.
- 3:42We examine the dangers of the online safety bill, the risks of data collection and algorithmic enforcement and the creeping possibility of a social credit system.
- 3:52system. We look at how debt, currency debasement and government overreach threatens financial
- 3:57security, while tools like Bitcoin, VPNs and Freedom Tech offer individuals a path to sovereignty.
- 4:06Ultimately, this is a conversation about responsibility, resilience and the urgent
- 4:11need to reclaim liberty in a world where control is tightening. Yep, that sounds pretty good or
- 4:18as freddie put it he's a fellow brit we don't live in a police state yet now it's amazing i think that
- 4:28these conversations are even being had but hey here we are this is the world we live in now is the time
- 4:34to probably sharpen your wits a little bit i actually do honestly believe it's important to
- 4:41think quite deeply about the strategies that you will be using to navigate the next epoch of human
- 4:48history yes really right thanks to all our wonderful subscribers and please if you're a
- 4:55value for value listener you can pledge just six dollars a month for the subscriber benefits one of
- 5:03which is bonus episodes a new one of which is coming out right now and it's part two of my
- 5:09amazing conversation with a gentleman by the name of gg bitcoin is once again will know him and this
- 5:15one goes very deep is a quick ai summary just for the curious if you're wondering about subscribing
- 5:22this episode dives into the fallout from robert breedlove's bit clout controversy it was a really
- 5:30interesting uh discussion that because it was fresh in the news at the time and the debate over
- 5:36bitcoin's energy use and the surprising spiritual dimensions of bitcoin from questions of trust and
- 5:42sustainability to profound personal awakenings the conversation explores how bitcoin challenges
- 5:47power reshapes world views and even sparks religious like experiences yes uh gg actually
- 5:54talks about what happened to him when he discovered bitcoin and i'm i'd never heard it anywhere before
- 6:00um i definitely had a lot of fun listening back to this episode in fact it was the first time i'd
- 6:06listened to it since it was originally recorded and there's a lot going on there anyway i think
- 6:12you'll like it gg's one of the most important thinkers in the bitcoin space as far as i'm
- 6:17concerned right that's enough from me time for the alpha and this week you might want to listen
- 6:24to this one from inside your wonderful faraday cage because the powers that be aren't going to
- 6:30be very happy with you. You will though, of course, as you sit back, relax and enjoy my
- 6:37conversation with Freddie New.
- 6:46The core of the Free Cities idea is governance, competition between governance. We know competition
- 6:53works in the world and everywhere else. It's just in government, they don't really have
- 6:58it and and in governance they don't really have it because you are sure you can move country
- 7:04it's not a lot of options um of of different types of governance models you get a lot of um obviously
- 7:13um democracies but modern democracies are i mean you just have to look at our democracy currently
- 7:21in the uk to see that it's not working because hardly anyone cares as we see voter turnouts
- 7:28low and the people that win win on a small amount of the constituents who actually even voted let
- 7:36alone people that actually live in the country so it doesn't serve you you know um so you've got
- 7:41you've got limited options the main um interesting thing that the that we promote are private cities
- 7:47there's a couple of them around the world they get independent jurisdiction status legal status
- 7:53from the host government so they can change their own regulations the free zone in dubai
- 7:57at all similar to that well free zones yeah they are i mean dubai is almost one whole free zone now
- 8:03there's this but they they they were part of the evolution for sure they were the special economic
- 8:09zone aspect the newest sort of evolution are special economic zones where you reside at the
- 8:16moment special economic zones you if you were a business like when you came to dubai financial
- 8:20district you brought your capital over and you got preferred deals and you got i mean the main
- 8:26reason that they were so successful is because they they did away with sharia law within that
- 8:30small bit and brought in common law and that's what attracted people but as a there was no resident
- 8:36tax breaks or etc i mean obviously did biden have any tax anyway so it was all good
- 8:41but the new the new versions the new iterations which are two main ones are in honduras now
- 8:48are independent from the government of honduras on legislation regulation they still have to abide
- 8:55by all the laws of, you know, don't murder anyone, don't do this, don't do that.
- 9:01But businesses can come and start with various regulations.
- 9:07They can choose from OECD regulations from around the world.
- 9:11And also, as a resident, you get the same tax breaks.
- 9:14So you get 2 tax there or 2 corporate tax You know it what I mean ideally what we want to see in the next hundred 150 years are thousands of competing smaller places And I think I heard you talk
- 9:30about this, actually, the, the, the idea that one of the things that that's kind of broken about
- 9:37what's going on now, I mean, God, I'm in fact, actually, it's very difficult to know where to
- 9:43start because it's such a huge subject but i think it might be useful to use our own home country the
- 9:48uk as an example of how a place can be run particularly badly um not in it and i'm not
- 9:56i'm not even pointing fingers i don't i don't when you look at all the problems with the way that
- 10:00governance works um i don't necessarily blame the people that are doing all this stuff i think there's
- 10:05a lot of well-intentioned people doing i just think the incentives are there and easy to take
- 10:12to run the country as they are.
- 10:16And I think, you know, in a nutshell,
- 10:19the way things have evolved now is you've basically got
- 10:22productive people, entrepreneurs,
- 10:25staying clear of the government
- 10:27because they don't want to go anywhere near it,
- 10:28but feeling the wrath of the government,
- 10:31which is run by the other group of people
- 10:33who tend to be career politicians, non-productive people.
- 10:38And they are, the whole thing's a mess now
- 10:40You've got people struggling to run a business or people struggling to create a better life for themselves because the people who they don't even like or respect or certainly don't respect as business people are creating all these legislations and laws that make their life even harder.
- 10:57And the result, really, when you actually look at it, is they go away.
- 11:03They go somewhere else.
- 11:04I don't know many people now in the UK that I know who have the stay and fight attitude
- 11:10there's not many of them left not if I took a survey of my friends most people are like right
- 11:18this is this is very difficult there's a limit to how long I can pursue this it's easier for me just
- 11:25to move if they have the kind of situation in their life where they can move obviously if you've
- 11:29family and all that kind of stuff i don't know you you're you're kind of quite heavily embedded
- 11:34i think in the world of you form a lawyer right you are still a lawyer yeah but also you you do
- 11:41work with the governments you advise you do all this kind of stuff i pester is probably a nicer
- 11:47way of probably more accurate way very low but should we get rolling um yeah let's go we already
- 11:52are just tilt the mic up a little bit so it's going a bit more towards you i say but yeah so
- 11:57just start there start there sure um yeah so as you say i'm i am a lawyer so fairly embedded in
- 12:05uh the way that the system works uh just to clarify though i'm not a lawyer who necessarily
- 12:11drafts laws or who litigates i'm uh i was always a transactional lawyer so i started off in m&a
- 12:17uh moved into special situations which are you know effectively trying to rescue collapsing
- 12:22companies and then became more and more involved in the regulatory side, more on the critique
- 12:29rather than the drafting.
- 12:30So a lot of the work I do with Bitcoin Policy, the group that I set up with Susie, whom we
- 12:36recently had on, Bitcoin Policy UK, is trying to advise regulators and politicians who are
- 12:43drafting bad laws and how to make them better.
- 12:45because as you've rightly pointed out,
- 12:50the incentive for any politician coming in,
- 12:55and actually while you were saying that,
- 12:56it occurred to me, I forget who said this,
- 12:58but the raison d'etre of a politician is to create more law
- 13:03and I think it's impossible to point to a single government,
- 13:07maybe Millet is doing it, a single government anywhere
- 13:09where there are fewer laws in the statute book
- 13:12after they leave office and before they arrived.
- 13:15The whole purpose of you being in parliament is to make more laws.
- 13:21And at some point, it seems to be that that is the only reason for your being any longer.
- 13:27And if you fail to make more laws, somehow you failed as a politician.
- 13:31I think that's an idea that's well worth re-examining.
- 13:34Well, it's also the fact that...
- 13:37It's interesting, on this podcast, I've interviewed a lot of people who came from former communist regimes.
- 13:42and it's in as a as a as a brit it's fascinating to hear what what it was like and one of the things
- 13:49everyone talks about the pettiness of the superhuman number of laws that start appearing in the late
- 13:56stages of it and i not being funny mate but i woke up recently and i looked and i was just i
- 14:04don't know reading twitter looking at what was going on and thinking it's happening it's happening
- 14:09the the the kind of stuff that you know like i looked a few up earlier before this interview
- 14:15there was like it got to the point where they were banning blue jeans haircuts had to be a certain
- 14:20length you know we're not there yet but i for me the canary in the coal mines already singing you
- 14:27know there there's talk of banning vpns ever since the the new bill came out to the online safety bill
- 14:33i've heard already people are reporting that right vpns need to be banned you know i've i've seen that
- 14:39kind of mentality in china and i remember thinking wow this is full on you know this is full on this
- 14:45is this is obviously not good vpns are absolutely fine i've used vpns for years and my whole family
- 14:52does and it's purely to stay anonymous and to not have our data leaked and just it's none of your
- 14:57business what i'm looking at online it was officially encouraged by one of the firms that
- 15:00I worked at whenever we went on a foreign trip, take certain steps in order to protect
- 15:05the data that's on your phone because it's valuable.
- 15:07And so is your personal data.
- 15:09You mentioning banning VPNs, I don't know if you saw a post recently by a human rights
- 15:15activist who works for the Human Rights Foundation about Myanmar.
- 15:19They brought in a new rule that the police can stop and search you and they can look
- 15:22at your phone.
- 15:23And if they find a VPN on it, there's grounds for arrest immediately.
- 15:28So if the UK wants to put itself in the same bucket as Myanmar,
- 15:32we're doing a bloody good job of it so far.
- 15:35Well, they are.
- 15:37This is what I mean.
- 15:37They are.
- 15:39The online safety bill is ridiculous.
- 15:42You know, it's porn and kids.
- 15:45That's the way they sell it.
- 15:46But it's not.
- 15:47If you are someone who just uses a normal internet connection,
- 15:51many websites that you go to now, which are nothing to do with porn,
- 15:54are saying, give us your credit card details.
- 15:58And this is already happening as far as I'm concerned now.
- 16:03This is it.
- 16:04Yeah, it's worth drilling into that a little bit.
- 16:06I don't think many people will have read exactly what the legislation says.
- 16:11You know, why should they?
- 16:12I think it's as long as war and peace.
- 16:15Probably.
- 16:15Yeah, and probably less well written.
- 16:18But if you look at the scope of what can potentially be bound,
- 16:21is extraordinarily wide and is left largely within the purview of Ofcom and the Secretary
- 16:25of State who can increase the ambit of what's deemed to be harmful content. And it's interesting
- 16:31you mentioned the kind of websites that are being stopped. The day it came into force,
- 16:35I went on to Reddit's craft beer and I posted a screenshot of what happened. I can't read
- 16:42about craft beer unless I prove my age. I saw a record of a hamster owners forum, which
- 16:49which they had to take the form down because they said, you know,
- 16:53we're just a small organisation.
- 16:56We cannot fund the cost of compliance.
- 16:59So the only option we have is to come off because otherwise we'll get an enormous fine.
- 17:04I had a rather interesting thought that, you know, Mumsnet, the forum.
- 17:07I know it too well.
- 17:08You know it too well.
- 17:09Too well, yeah.
- 17:10Well, I'm always quoted Mumsnet.
- 17:12That's one of those things that my wife, well, less so now actually,
- 17:16But when we had small kids, I used to get the Mumsnet quotes all the time.
- 17:21I mean, we all, you know, I think our children may be of similar ages.
- 17:27It occurred to me that probably Mumsnet's going to fall foul of this as well,
- 17:31because they talk a lot about wine and gin on Mumsnet.
- 17:35Too much, probably.
- 17:36I'm actually not joking.
- 17:39Because the rules apply to any forum that allows user-generated content,
- 17:45which could potentially be harmful,
- 17:47and that would include talking about alcohol, according to the Reddit.
- 17:51I suspect the Guardian comment sections,
- 17:54to the extent that they enable you to mention wine and beer,
- 17:56should probably, actually, maybe it'd be a funny exercise
- 18:00to troll them and report the Guardian to Ofcom.
- 18:02But do you think, then, that that is part of the plan?
- 18:08I mean, in the end, it's obvious to me, at least,
- 18:11that there will be ID to surf the internet if you want to do it the legitimate way.
- 18:17There'll be a million and one workarounds, obviously,
- 18:20but just like there are now in China and behind the Great Firewall,
- 18:23you can still do most of what you want to do if you just know how.
- 18:28And like you say, if you were a foreigner going in,
- 18:30they might even advise you to do that.
- 18:32A governmental employee might even be advised to do that.
- 18:35Just don't do it at home.
- 18:37It's not what we do.
- 18:38Yeah I think there a non risk of that happening which is terrifying It the equivalent of requiring a license to leave your house and to walk around the streets I not talking about driving a car
- 18:51you know, proving that you have the necessary skill set in order to operate a piece of potentially
- 18:56dangerous machinery, I think is generally a sensible thing. And the same with a pilot's
- 19:01license. You know, you want someone operating that machinery to be changed. But that speaking
- 19:06is not something for which anyone needs particular training,
- 19:11and having ideas is a natural human thing to do.
- 19:16And the attempt to police both of those things, I think, is terrifyingly shocking.
- 19:21And because of the very clever way that this has been done,
- 19:23and again, I'm often at a bit of a loss here,
- 19:26I'm torn between the two ends of the spectrum.
- 19:29On the one hand, as you mentioned earlier,
- 19:31I think a lot of this was originally well-intentioned.
- 19:34We want to prevent suicide alleviation, for example.
- 19:39I think that's an honorable aim.
- 19:41Anyone who's experienced self-harm or suicide in their family would, I think,
- 19:46support wanting to prevent people being encouraged from hurting themselves.
- 19:51And again, no one wants children to see unsuitable material online.
- 19:54So I think we can agree that those things are honorable aims.
- 20:00but then extrapolating that out to an attempt to stop people thinking things,
- 20:05free consenting adults from reading things and having opinions that an authority figure doesn't like,
- 20:11that's very chilling.
- 20:13And certainly in the UK we get a bit, I think we get a bit complacent with the fact that
- 20:20we've lived in a relatively free society for so long.
- 20:23We don't think that can happen here.
- 20:25We're recording this in a former Soviet Socialist Republic.
- 20:28and it's within 1991 i think latvia finally got independence after the war came down
- 20:35it's very very recent in what is now a member of the eu where these kind of things happen so we
- 20:42know what was the quote that the tree of liberty must be perpetually refreshed with the blood of
- 20:48patriots and hopefully it won't come to that but but complacency develops relatively easily if you
- 20:54haven't been tested doesn't it you do find i don't know whether you've spoken to many locals
- 20:58but we we work a lot out of prague and everyone in those kind of countries it's still fresh in
- 21:04their minds and you get phenomenally solid good people there and um you know you're right uh
- 21:13nobody back home would consider the same thing happens in it's happening in canada right now
- 21:19canadians think they live in the most of them still think they live in the best country in the
- 21:24world and it's a beautiful place no doubt about it but the way it's run is is creeping and it's
- 21:30the creep that does it the worst the most insidious part of it um but interestingly talking about the
- 21:37the online safety bill again really what's happening is it's gonna come down to the compliance
- 21:45which is really bad because the rules could be stupid which they are we can look at them now and
- 21:53that's ridiculous and stupid but people will enforce it now and the more they enforce it the
- 22:00more ridiculous it'll be and the less likely that there there'll be a backtrack you know are they
- 22:06gonna do you think they're gonna relinquish the sort of craft beer reddit forum do you think
- 22:11they're gonna say do you know what let's let them off no they can't really do that unless the whole
- 22:15country goes this is ridiculous but most people probably especially brits you know aren't going
- 22:23to and before you know it's going to be so late they're going to be what we are going to be arguing
- 22:29with talking to Susie about this yesterday there was someone ranting on Nost the other day about
- 22:35a parcel delivery that came to their house that they had to sign for because it was an over 18
- 22:40item and the guy insisted on I need ID I need to photograph it for their app and he's like
- 22:47I mean, I'm 50 or 45.
- 22:50I'm more than 18, obviously.
- 22:52No, no.
- 22:53Computer says no.
- 22:54And in the end, he just had to turn this package away.
- 22:56And that's what it comes to.
- 22:58You get these ridiculous situations.
- 23:00That's what happened towards the end of the Soviet empire.
- 23:04These ridiculous rules that people then enforce.
- 23:09And this burgeoning set of people who are enforcing the rules is getting bigger and bigger and bigger.
- 23:15they're like oh justify my job let's we need to do this oh that would be a good idea let's do this
- 23:20and you get this horrendous situation which i think we're we're we're i wouldn't say we're in
- 23:26the late stages of well possibly we are but we're in a we're living in a world now where
- 23:31you have to think about so many rules and it's and they're quite punitive as well it's not like
- 23:37that a lot of them aren't obvious a lot of them are just ah you've discovered the rule
- 23:42and you've broken it this is your problem and you're like there's 450 000 rules what what you
- 23:50want me to know all of them you know and and it's it's it requires and this is the the really
- 23:57disturbing part of it it requires a complete rehashing of of everything it appears to me
- 24:04and i don't really know how you do that i mean you the two options are collapse or leave isn't it
- 24:12It's like as an individual, the whole thing either collapses and starts again.
- 24:16And that's seldom a good thing, actually.
- 24:21I think even the results of that kind of system, you normally get the void filled by something similar.
- 24:27Or you leave and you go and look for a place where, in my case, it would be you either go where lots and lots of really rich people are.
- 24:35or you go to a place where lots and lots,
- 24:37where a country really hasn't got a system ingrained yet,
- 24:40somewhere that's, you know, to be left alone.
- 24:43You've either got to be very rich
- 24:44or you just go and live somewhere that hasn't quite made it yet.
- 24:48It's surprising that it's so difficult just to be left alone.
- 24:50Yes, which is the base of it, for sure.
- 24:53Yeah, exactly.
- 24:54So how do we get left alone then?
- 24:56Quite a few things to pick up on there, actually.
- 24:58So before we sort of segue away from the online safety bill,
- 25:02the key reason why I personally am so opposed to it is actually one of privacy and data collection.
- 25:11My general principle for giving information away on the internet is that you should assume that
- 25:15anything you give to an organization, whether that's a corporation or a government, is going
- 25:19to become public information relatively quickly. Because we can demonstrate, I can reel off a list
- 25:25as long as my arm of recent data leaks. They include data leaks from the Ministry of Defence
- 25:30in Britain. If the Ministry of Defence can't protect information, who the hell can?
- 25:34HMRC leaking data continuously.
- 25:38The NHS leaking private medical details and blood sample records.
- 25:44You can go on and on and on.
- 25:46I think the biggest one I saw recently was Ticketmaster, which leaked more email addresses
- 25:51than there are people on the planet.
- 25:52it uh so i mean that so basically with that if you if you give and and this is this is where i
- 26:01think the act is so dangerous if you give your age verification details to any of these websites
- 26:06you are creating and have i think in just two or three weeks that the act has been live
- 26:12huge data pots will already been completed because i think your port of my compliance is completely
- 26:17right. A lot of people will simply tart and roll their eyes, and they'll age verify, they'll give
- 26:25their name, they'll give their driving license. The people who are incentivized not to comply are,
- 26:30you know, 16-year-old boys, or people who care about the privacy, and I think that's always going
- 26:36to be a relatively small subset. But what's almost inevitably going to happen, and your question as
- 26:41to what's going to happen to this act specifically. When the act begins to affect the way that the
- 26:48people who made it live their lives, then I think you have a chance for changing it. Because I
- 26:55suspect most of the politicians who voted for this didn't realize the full implications of it.
- 27:01In fact, there was a very interesting exchange that I had on Twitter with a sitting MP who didn't
- 27:07realized that it also applied to technology companies was i mean actually she deleted this
- 27:13post after she made it um she said what exactly she said it only applies to porn and age verification
- 27:20happens all the time why is the harm you know each of those three limbs of her post were incorrect
- 27:25she clearly hadn't read the act it's not just for porn it's for all kinds of things effectively an
- 27:32ever-expanding set at the discretion of the Secretary of State. And I mean, the danger of
- 27:38huge pots of data is completely obvious. So I think there's going to be a very interesting
- 27:46piece of news to watch out for when, I think as is almost inevitable, Pornhub's data set is going
- 27:53to be leaked at some point. There's going to be a lot of fun to be had going through that and
- 27:58how many MPs are in it.
- 28:02They not going to give Seriously I mean it bad enough giving your details to Reddit let alone to Pornhub I mean the moment you tapping in your details
- 28:13must be a sad moment.
- 28:16Well, exactly.
- 28:17And what's doubly horrific,
- 28:18and I don't want to get too graphic here,
- 28:20but a lot of these sites are actually using age estimation,
- 28:22using your face.
- 28:23Are they?
- 28:24Yeah, they are.
- 28:24How are they doing?
- 28:25Oh, you mean when you click the button to sign up?
- 28:28So not to take control of your webcam.
- 28:30who in their right minds gives control of their webcam
- 28:33to a third-party company.
- 28:35You, you know, unless you're very, very...
- 28:38I think it's too late.
- 28:39Well, yeah, it's terrifying, isn't it?
- 28:40Yeah.
- 28:41That data, they allege is deleted.
- 28:45Most people don't understand how difficult it is to delete something
- 28:47once it's been recorded on a hard drive.
- 28:50I don't think it ever gets deleted.
- 28:51Well, why would it?
- 28:53Why some, you know, data storage exists,
- 28:57and if it's not full why not store everything exactly and most people don't realize that when
- 29:03you hit delete on a file on your hard drive that the file isn't deleted it's just that the pathway
- 29:09to it is cleared so that it can be recorded over again um anyway so where i'm going with this is i
- 29:15think there's a very very substantial risk that these data pots which have been collected by
- 29:20embarrassing websites will be leaked and they will contain details of people who potentially voted for
- 29:25this and that's the point at which i think they may consider that perhaps it's gone too far and
- 29:30maybe we should think of a different way of achieving this really though i mean i think at
- 29:35that point it just gets more absurd i i don't i mean i i've i've my first thoughts of the kind of
- 29:44surveillance state happened probably in the 80s when i look back people were talking about it then
- 29:49being tracked and monitored and etc etc and i remember feeling quite depressed about it back
- 29:55then i was only i was like in my sort of i was an 18 year old boy thinking yeah this does make
- 30:00sense and that was even before the internet really started kicking in because once that happened you
- 30:06see the ability to monitor it just increases exponentially in fact it scales forever that's
- 30:14the terrible thing about it i think when you look at a lot of previous authoritarian regimes they
- 30:20often collapse under the weight of their own size because they can't find enough people to enforce
- 30:26what they're doing but actually algorithms are infinitely scalable and you can see that the
- 30:33whole system will turn into a way of testing compliance is what it is you so you're you're
- 30:41i mean i could easily predict for example that the next step when they realize that the online
- 30:46safety access is an absolute shit show they'll go do you know what the easiest thing saves us money
- 30:51just everything you look at like so you have to sign up for the internet then we don't have to
- 30:57worry about this that and the other and then they've got you because at that point now you
- 31:01can integrate all that data into a are you being a good citizen score which we see already starting
- 31:08in a number of countries around the world and if you're not you lose access to this you lose
- 31:13privileges you lose this this is the and then the law you're a lawyer you see the law suddenly
- 31:19disappears and it becomes an algorithm you know here's here are the rules when you break them you
- 31:25lose privileges and you don't even need to enforce them through through legal means the you know i
- 31:30mean i'm going way into the future there like no but you're right and the cost of enforcement is
- 31:34something i return to a lot and it's historically been a relatively decent defense against bad law
- 31:41frankly um so you know obviously we're we're here for a bitcoin conference at the moment and one of
- 31:46the one of the key things that bitcoin is going on about a lot is uh executive order 6102
- 31:51obviously the uh the confiscation of private ownership of gold in the united states
- 31:55which was actually a relatively ineffective law because it did it thinking about it it
- 32:02functioned in a very similar way to the online safety act a lot of people complied a lot of
- 32:06people didn't. Now, the cost of enforcement of 6102 was vast. The government, even the US
- 32:13government, couldn't send agents on house-to-house searches, so they relied on a relatively large
- 32:18proportion of compliance and wrote off the non-compliance without house-to-house searches
- 32:23in order to find your gold. And in a digital sense, until relatively recently, house-to-house
- 32:31search equivalents of going through vast amounts of digital material was again relatively hard and
- 32:37often human driven but I think you correctly point out that if we're moving into a world of
- 32:42algorithmic searching and enforcement as we clearly are the it comes out of data processing
- 32:48functionally the processing of facial recognition data for example is reaching quite scary levels
- 32:56and is also being rolled out at scary levels in the United Kingdom.
- 33:01Big Brother Watch, with whom we've worked on a few important ventures,
- 33:06pushing back against CBDCs, for example,
- 33:09they are campaigning to try and roll that back.
- 33:13But it's an uphill battle because, as you say,
- 33:15if a government's given access to lots of data that it can process extremely quickly and powerfully,
- 33:22why not?
- 33:23They want to control their citizens as much as possible.
- 33:26This is a complete inversion for me of Alan Moore's famous line out of FIFA Fendetta.
- 33:32People shouldn't be afraid of their governments.
- 33:35Governments should be afraid of their people.
- 33:37They are our servants as long as we live in true democracies.
- 33:41And the idea that they are there to tell us what to do and how to behave and what to think and what to say is completely abhorrent, I think, to anyone who feels the way that we do.
- 33:52You say we shouldn't be afraid of our governments.
- 33:54At least I did show signs of fear of my own government yesterday.
- 34:02I found myself saying something on this podcast about VPNs,
- 34:06and I let it roll, but in the back of my mind I was thinking I might have to cut that out.
- 34:11I then went, fortunately, I checked.
- 34:13It's not illegal to bypass the online safety bill yet.
- 34:19Not for you.
- 34:20Right.
- 34:20Okay.
- 34:21So it's using a VPN.
- 34:23So I'm going to leave it in now. But my instant thought after that is, well, you could in the old days, I would have said, let's say I've done like 150 episodes of this podcast. It's like, yeah, little things slip by, they disappear. You know, you can't really be held accountable. It's too difficult. Now, not true at all. An AI would take 10 minutes to scan everything I've ever said and pull out the parts where I said things that are illegal. As in, you know, that's why I had to check.
- 34:52thought crime yeah well the thought not even a thought crime a real crime me admitting to using
- 34:58a vpn like i say had i have gone online after that interview yesterday and discovered that yes
- 35:03i was committing an offense i would have pulled it out of the episode i would have just cut that
- 35:08bit out and um that's that is me being scared of my government right exactly that's wrong
- 35:15for totally wrong because because they can be far more petty than me and when it comes down
- 35:21to things like um if you have any kind i mean governments tend to leave you alone until you
- 35:28start garnering attention from a certain number of people i suppose there's a limit and suddenly
- 35:33right this is a person of interest now as soon as you're a person of interest in a way you you
- 35:39you're doomed in many senses of the word because at the at the very last moment um they're there
- 35:47they've got more resources than you i'm not even sure how you defend yourself against um against
- 35:54that an attack a big attack from the state like that if you're someone who's got a big mouthpiece
- 35:58a lot of people are listening to you not least because they could bankrupt you legally just take
- 36:04you to court over some ridiculous thing let it run for so long that you know i think you have to go
- 36:10into exile you right exactly you move to another country and then you start reporting from there
- 36:15or whatever. But that's not good. And that shouldn't be happening in our country.
- 36:20Absolutely not. On your worry about VPNs, I don't know if you saw this immediately after the act
- 36:25came out, Politico did some digging into MPs' expenses. And it turns out rather amusingly that
- 36:31Jonathan Reynolds, the business secretary, and Sarah Champion, just to name two people,
- 36:36are not only using VPNs, but they're also charging them back to us as expenses,
- 36:40uh which is nice um this was revealed on the same day that peter kyle went on um all of the news
- 36:47shows and basically said uh this is a paraphrase not a good you know if every time you use a vpn a
- 36:52child dies yeah i i think you posted that one on twitter didn't you yeah click it's so grating
- 36:59though it's so like the the worst thing about that whole sentiment is that and you're a parent
- 37:06It's none of the government's business what your kids are looking at online.
- 37:10It's your business.
- 37:11You're their father.
- 37:12You have a chat with them.
- 37:14If they're rebellious, you ban them yourself.
- 37:17You don't ask someone who really doesn't give a shit about you to try and ban them ineffectively.
- 37:24Because they don't even know them.
- 37:25They're not even close by them.
- 37:27I don't know if you saw this.
- 37:28Someone has...
- 37:30actually set out in relatively significant detail how they would have gone about protecting children
- 37:36from unsuitable material, and a lot of it's to do with certification.
- 37:40So, for example, an adult website is required to broadcast as part of its data package
- 37:47when you try to access that website.
- 37:49This site contains 18 plus material.
- 37:52and then you can set your router and your devices either to accept or reject 18 plus or 18 below
- 37:59material so your child's phone for example you could put a setting there to say that this
- 38:04this phone is used by a 12 year old and material for 12 and under only can be viewed on this
- 38:10and then the device will ping the website and once that certification has been recognized and
- 38:17knowledge then it's it's parental guided access to unsuitable material which i think is what we
- 38:23should all be doing you you should you care for your children you decide what they can and cannot
- 38:27see it's not up to the states to tell me you know if my 17 and a half year old wants to read about
- 38:33craft beer it the craft beer one is very it's horrible but i mean the other thing is as well
- 38:39that your that certification method also doesn't work because plenty of websites aren't going to
- 38:45certificate you know like people think porn hub everyone uses porn hub i think yes a lot of people
- 38:52do but there's probably more porn websites than any other genre on the planet i mean i'd assume so
- 38:58and uh i mean i assume so well
- 39:02so i just thought this data set there are
- 39:07I forget as well.
- 39:11The actual volume of material on the internet that's not crawlable,
- 39:16for example, by Google search engines
- 39:18and is only accessible through Tor is mind-blowing.
- 39:23But that comes back to a point you made earlier
- 39:25around the majority of people won't use Tor
- 39:28and they won't know how to access the dark web.
- 39:31And the huge worry, I mean,
- 39:33and quite apart from the honeypot issue that we raised earlier,
- 39:37the huge worry is the people who actually want to access this material are now going to be driven
- 39:42into places where a whole lot of other most horrific stuff is also lurking so not only is
- 39:48the act illogical it's unenforceable and it's arguably worse than the situation we had before
- 39:55i i think that's par for the course these days i could i could quote you a number of things like
- 40:03that in the modern world that don't work um that i mean the the most obvious one of late was um
- 40:10taxing wealthy people and then ending up with less revenue i mean yes um there are incompetent
- 40:18people not in i don't know whether incompetence the right word there are people who have risen to
- 40:24positions of power in at least our government who don't understand who don't they just don't
- 40:32think things they they don't think things through they they kind of stop at the original idea it's
- 40:37like i know let's tax the rich yay right let's get that sorted without necessarily wondering that
- 40:44the the rich might leave at that point and the answer yeah the answer is well the rich shouldn't
- 40:50leave because that's not that's not right it's like the rich are going to leave people are going
- 40:56to do use vpns people don't really care what you say like they do it because you're bigger than
- 41:03them and they want to comply to make their life easier on the whole but a lot of what you say
- 41:07is complete nonsense and nowadays i don't i couldn't tell you a single politician who says
- 41:14anything coherent that who says actually that's not true that's not true there is a kind of
- 41:21there is a new sort of group of politicians coming through we see it in the uk now it's a bit like
- 41:26what happened in america with trump a number of interesting people are actually starting to speak
- 41:32on alternative media i'm talking about the kind of the mainstream if you turn the tv on if you
- 41:38listen to talk radio you hear nonsense you hear that double speak you hear people skirting questions
- 41:46it's so obvious now that you have this world where there are people who can talk candidly for two
- 41:53hours and people who can't and the people that can't talk candidly for two hours are currently
- 41:59in charge and the people who can talk candidly for two hours so you know listen to anyone for
- 42:04two hours you get a good sense of who they are and they're there they're there and their arms
- 42:09are up in the air going what the hell's going on but but my worry is we have a we're obviously well
- 42:15according to me at least we'll have a regime change at the next election and it'll as far as
- 42:20i'm concerned it'll go to one of the new parties i think everyone's underestimating how quickly a
- 42:25change like that can happen but they'll get into power and they'll just hit a brick wall like
- 42:30everyone else and go oh my god this is a shit show well i can't just stop doing what everyone
- 42:36else has been doing well i think a huge problem i've spoken about this before i'm interested to
- 42:40here you'll take on it too. The real power in the United Kingdom is the bureaucratic civil service,
- 42:48and it's utterly unaccountable to the electorate. It's unaccountable in many ways to ministers and
- 42:56to MPs. So there's so much focus is on who's in power, which government is there,
- 43:04but we always forget the faceless people who sit behind them. My contemporaries,
- 43:09my friends from university who went into the civil service at the age of 22, 23, and are going
- 43:14to stay there for 40 years, entrenched in these enormous buildings, incentivized to keep their
- 43:20jobs and to keep adding to the numbers of civil servants that there are. We've increased the
- 43:25number of civil servants by 150,000, I think, between 2019 and now. Why on earth? We now have
- 43:32half a million civil servants in the United Kingdom. We used to run the entire empire on 40,000.
- 43:38why do we need half a million civil servants do you probably need them because they're they're
- 43:45not doing the job well enough they probably need more people to do a simple job i mean exactly right
- 43:50did you see the headline recently uh reeve says that she's going to have to massively increase
- 43:54the size of the civil service to address the inefficiency problem you i mean i thought you
- 44:00i thought you were going to mention that headline but that's exactly well that's a real headline
- 44:05That's a real headline, yeah.
- 44:06I think it was a telegraph.
- 44:07That's ridiculous.
- 44:08Yeah, well, maybe that's a hit piece, isn't it?
- 44:10Yeah, perhaps.
- 44:11But, you know, what you said.
- 44:13Did she say it like that?
- 44:14No.
- 44:14I mean, did she literally say it like that?
- 44:16I mean, maybe we can look it up and stick it in your show notes afterwards.
- 44:19But, yeah.
- 44:20I mean, I don't care anymore.
- 44:22I expect that now.
- 44:24You expect bullshit from these people because I think what the life they're living in them is just full of these.
- 44:34non-complementary ideas and and paradoxes and you know it's like all terrible regimes they they fall
- 44:44down with honesty kills them you can't just come out and say like i'm i'm longing for the day that
- 44:51someone just says the truth out there or like do you know what um we we could have done better but
- 44:57we tried our hardest and this happened and now these people have been disenfranchised but we're
- 45:03going to try a different way or or mille you know mille is like bulletproof when you look at the way
- 45:08he's dealing with things he really doesn't give a shit and he doesn't care to burden that
- 45:14uncomfortable feeling that maybe um a lot of people are going to dislike him the i suppose
- 45:20the advantage in in argentina was a lot of people were looking for change i'm not sure what's your
- 45:27take on how many people in the uk for example are looking for change i think it's i'm a bit
- 45:33more optimistic actually i think it's a i think it's a non-trivial amount now and i say that
- 45:39partly because if you look at the the speed of collapse and support for labor even among
- 45:43left-leaning people you know i'm reasonably left-leaning myself i i categorize myself as
- 45:48a left-leaning libertarian uh i think the state does have some some functions i tend to devolve
- 45:55to the Hayek and four or five key functions as the principal ones
- 45:59and maybe toss in some healthcare and education
- 46:01for those who can't afford it on top of that.
- 46:05But even among my own relatively left-leaning friends,
- 46:09the collapse in support for labour has been catastrophic,
- 46:12and I think it's largely because they've had 14 years to prepare,
- 46:16have come in, and I don't know if I can swear on the talk,
- 46:20but utterly fucked everything up.
- 46:23your Laffercove tax point is a perfect example.
- 46:27That's first order thinking only
- 46:29without following the consequences through.
- 46:32But I really think a lot about both the kinds of people
- 46:35who go into politics and who go into the civil service.
- 46:39They are individual human beings like you and I.
- 46:42I genuinely believe most people want to do a good job
- 46:45and they want to do good things.
- 46:47I think the number of people who go into power wanting to trample on the faces of the poor is hopefully relatively small because most humans aren like that
- 46:58But there's something about the inefficiency of a monumentally disorganized state that means, you know, when you...
- 47:08I think a lot of it is throwing your hands up in the air and just accepting that this is the way that things always have been, and so this is the way we do things here.
- 47:14And you see this not just in governments, but in very big organizations as well.
- 47:19Actually, Microsoft is an interesting one to look at.
- 47:22Microsoft, obviously, under Gates and Paul Allen, very nimble originally, became incredibly dominant.
- 47:29And then it became extraordinarily moribund for a very long period of time.
- 47:35And part of that was that people would join Microsoft full of vim and vigor and good ideas
- 47:41and get bogged down in an extraordinarily lengthy approval process
- 47:44to do and change anything,
- 47:47which Nadella has actually reinvigorated and turned around
- 47:51by stripping away some of those inefficiencies.
- 47:54So we do have real-world examples of scenarios
- 47:59where companies have taken the wrong path and can go the other way,
- 48:03and I think we're beginning to see some of them in nation-states.
- 48:06Argentina is an example.
- 48:08um el salvador i'm still in two minds around how el salvador is working um obviously some people
- 48:17are of the view that bukele is is a dictator he's obviously got a very very strong law and order
- 48:22focus um but at the same time he's drastically reduced the murder rate and made it a safer
- 48:28country to live in so um you pay his pipe and take your choice yeah i mean what you're describing
- 48:35in a way is a natural life cycle of an organization and the question is what happens at the point of
- 48:46death is it death or rebirth is it change is it transformation you know you're i was just trying
- 48:52to think whether or not i thought argentina was transforming or was it i mean there was no bloody
- 48:58battle obviously so um and also we have to wait to see the problem with all these things i i'm with
- 49:05you on bukele i think um in i've been to el salvador a number of times and every everyone
- 49:11i've ever spoken to loves him there so i'm fully on board with that the only worry i have is that
- 49:17he is still a leader and a politician and i remember various countries in central america
- 49:23on South America who had in the beginning had similar scenarios everyone super excited you could
- 49:29even say what happened I mean it's happened to us even do you remember things can only get better
- 49:36I was working in London I was a journalist then I worked for the independent and I remember getting
- 49:42swept up in all that shit you know and thinking wow change is coming or Trump you know change is
- 49:48coming you know and then or government's going to get smaller doge is going to smash everything
- 49:53oh wait a sec government's getting bigger we're spending more money you know uh in the end do do
- 49:59we do we get to trust any of these people it's very difficult to see how how they can how we can
- 50:05and in some ways i believe the only choice you have is to be as independent on an individual
- 50:15basis as you possibly can, whether that's remaining where you are and living your life
- 50:21as freely as you can, or unfortunately moving somewhere else. And I think it's a supertanker
- 50:28problem. The state, and by the state in the UK, I mean the civil service and the government is so
- 50:35preponderant. And again, returning to a lot of my friends who work in the civil service,
- 50:40they're generally good people. I've been friends with some of them for 25 years.
- 50:45So I trust them implicitly as individuals.
- 50:48But they're stuck in an organization where to make the simplest decision
- 50:51requires five different levels of approval, 18 different forms.
- 50:55And three of the people who need to approve those forms are not in the office
- 51:00because they've done their 25 hours for the week in the first three days.
- 51:03So they get the rest of the week off.
- 51:06And then they get a much bigger pension than I will when they retire,
- 51:10which will be funded for by continual debatement and dilution of the currency.
- 51:14I mean it's impossible to
- 51:17and you mentioned
- 51:19the Soviet
- 51:21Socialist Republic before
- 51:22it's just you get to a point where the bureaucracy
- 51:25is so completely
- 51:27incomprehensible that you
- 51:28can't get anything done
- 51:30try to build anything in the United Kingdom
- 51:32I return again to the idea that
- 51:35high energy is
- 51:37high quality of life and high income
- 51:39there are no low energy high income
- 51:41countries on the planet
- 51:42it. So the whole idea that we need to be using less energy is, to my mind, completely absurd.
- 51:47We need to be using more energy. It's not as though energy is a scarce resource in the universe.
- 51:53Fundamentally, everything is made of it. That's the mass energy equivalence equation, for God's
- 51:57sake. It's a question of harnessing it and storing it and deploying it. Obviously, storing energy is
- 52:03hard, and there are various solutions for that. Trying to build a new nuclear plant in the United
- 52:10Kingdom, which to my mind is what we should be doing everywhere, Rolls-Foyce, one of the builders
- 52:17of SMRs, is, I mean, God knows how difficult it's going to be then to deploy their SMRs in the United
- 52:23Kingdom, because our planning regulations are literally Byzantine. You talked earlier about
- 52:29collapse. It's interesting to look at previous collapses of extraordinarily complex bureaucracies,
- 52:33and the reason we call these things Byzantine is because it was the tail end of a 1400-year-old
- 52:40empire filled with grand viziers and and strange eunuchs who had extraordinarily complicated job
- 52:47titles and no one knew what they did you can learn a lot of lessons from the past though the the the
- 52:53places that lasted the longest um ran in a specific way i'm thinking of places like venice
- 53:00that were run by merchants basically you look at dubai now in a way it's run by merchants
- 53:06in a way i mean it's run by families but there's no politics to speak of if you're an immigrant
- 53:1290 of dubai is for is immigrants and you go there to make money you don't go to vote on anything
- 53:20um there are i mean this is why in the free cities movement private cities are is is one of our big
- 53:27things thousands of competing small jurisdictions not necessarily cities but just makes sense because
- 53:34the reason that all this stuff we're talking about, the bad governance is happening, is because
- 53:41there's no competition in governance. There's no accountability in governance, especially in the
- 53:47civil service. I mean, the civil service, as you mentioned, is the worst out of all of them.
- 53:52Do people lose their jobs in the civil service? I don't know.
- 53:55No, they get promoted, actually. It's funny you mentioned that. You probably saw recently,
- 54:00there was an MOD official who emailed the Taliban a list of the enemies of the Taliban,
- 54:07including our own spies from MI6.
- 54:09Why? Just did a chat by mistake.
- 54:12It was worth looking up.
- 54:15That was why, and this was covered up by a super injunction for three years.
- 54:19This was why we pulled a whole load of the Afghans who'd been our allies into the United Kingdom,
- 54:25because they were at risk of being murdered, obviously,
- 54:27because all of their names and addresses.
- 54:29Oh, that's right.
- 54:30Yeah.
- 54:31I read that.
- 54:31So that story.
- 54:32It's worth looking at what happened to the chap who sent it.
- 54:34I believe he's now been promoted.
- 54:37Yeah.
- 54:37Well, fact-checking me on that.
- 54:39Well, I mean, name me a politician who'd done a shitty job
- 54:42who didn't end up in a nice job straight afterwards.
- 54:47Well, I mean, you mentioned Tony Blair earlier.
- 54:48Oh, my God.
- 54:49How much is he worth now?
- 54:51He's also, I mean, he's a really nasty character.
- 54:55I used to, I worked for the Independent, right?
- 54:57And I, we did a lot of politics.
- 54:59I was a, I was a photographer and one election cycle, it wasn't the things can only get better
- 55:05one.
- 55:05It was another one.
- 55:06I was on their bus.
- 55:08Yeah.
- 55:08Yeah.
- 55:08Well, we all got assigned to different buses.
- 55:10That was, I don't know whether they still do that now.
- 55:12Do they, I mean, but there was like 20 photographers back then there's, there's probably one agency
- 55:16guy now who does it.
- 55:18And we used to go to the conferences and I, you know, I, I spent a fair bit of time with
- 55:22Tony Blair in, you know, in, in relatively intimate situations.
- 55:25Not that he would know who I was now, but he's a really nasty character now.
- 55:32I didn't notice it at the time.
- 55:34I wasn't really looking.
- 55:35But if you look at what he does in the world, he's that kind of, he's our guy that we send out to convince other countries to do this, that, and the other.
- 55:45You know, during COVID, he was massive on digital ID.
- 55:49Whenever you hear Tony Blair say anything, it's like, did you ID, did you ID, did you, you know.
- 55:53he's one of those guys i know what your views on the world economic forum are but he's one of those
- 55:58guys who's a slimy weff kind of guy and i always thought he was slimy to be honest but even back
- 56:04in 97 yeah i didn i was i was swept i think i was swept up in the wow change is coming you know i mean he he yeah he he in fact if you look closely there a picture of me on the internet shaking his hand and it nothing to do he just an award i got he was just giving an
- 56:20award but it does look like i'm like but but no i shouldn't probably shouldn't say that but no he
- 56:28yeah he what i mean what do you think of the world economic forum and all that kind of stuff i mean
- 56:32are they as bad as everyone makes out you know uh i not as perhaps i should have um should have
- 56:41spent more time watching what they say i i mean i i tend to have focused on them from a sort of
- 56:46cbdc perspective uh and the i think they share characteristics with other people in government
- 56:55that i also find worrying and troubling in in a nutshell um so you know a couple of quotes from
- 57:01various different WEF forums over the years.
- 57:04There was a chap talking about CBDCs,
- 57:07and he was getting very excited that you could permission tokens
- 57:11to be used only for food, for example, or for water,
- 57:16which I find extraordinarily chilling.
- 57:18It cuts against the very nature of money for me,
- 57:21which is the most saleable good and can be freely exchanged
- 57:24for anything that you need or want.
- 57:28And there's another guy whose name I can't now remember.
- 57:31But he was, I think he was an ex-Indian central banker.
- 57:36And it's worth digging up the clip of him.
- 57:38He's got this horrible smile on his face when he's talking about how excited he would be to prevent things,
- 57:46to prevent money being used to buy tobacco or alcohol or other things.
- 57:50So I think that's a characteristic that a lot of those people who speak in these forums would share with the worst privacy offenders in our own governments,
- 57:59which is that they have an
- 58:01and it comes back to a point we made earlier
- 58:03a politician's raison d'etre
- 58:05now seems to be to make more laws
- 58:07so if they've made laws
- 58:09the existing statute book
- 58:11never gets smaller it only gets bigger
- 58:12so they need to keep on looking for new things
- 58:15to make laws about
- 58:16and one of the areas they're obsessed with
- 58:19making laws about now is personal freedom
- 58:21to do what you want, go where you want
- 58:23and to spend what you want as you see fit
- 58:25so I think
- 58:27there was a bit of a long winded answer
- 58:28No, but all those things you just mentioned are all part of the same thing, which is, for want of a better word, a social credit score.
- 58:37They're all to do with that.
- 58:39Travel, you know, what you can and can't do, basically.
- 58:44And algorithms will enforce them.
- 58:46You won't need a knock on the door by the police to say you've used up your carbon allowance today.
- 58:52You just won't be able to buy a ticket.
- 58:54and when you get to the station if you've got a fake ticket the facial id will say no that's not
- 59:00your ticket you know is it i i'm i'm i'm really i really don't know i used like i say are you i used
- 59:07to be quite depressed about it then bitcoin appeared in my life and suddenly i was full of
- 59:12hope and now i feel i feel like i've got over another hill in the in the life cycle of all this
- 59:18stuff and it is yeah bitcoin's still phenomenally it's hope no question about it but if you can't
- 59:24spend it because you are wading through a sea of bureaucracy and kyc and i mean it already happens
- 59:32now you can't buy a car with bitcoin anonymously unless you know a friend who's selling up a bitcoin
- 59:37you can do small transactions anonymously and you can do 100 billion dollar tractions
- 59:42100 billion dollar type transactions you know they're not taxed at that end of the spectrum
- 59:47But in the middle there where the government derives taxes, they want to know every single thing you're doing.
- 59:53And that's the thing that most people, when they look at it to begin with, go, yeah, that seems fair.
- 1:00:00You know, they've got to know what we're spending our money on.
- 1:00:04But you and I and people who care about that kind of stuff know that that is horrendous.
- 1:00:09And even just morally, that's wrong.
- 1:00:12I mean, you know, we lived on cash for years.
- 1:00:15We lived on gold coins for years.
- 1:00:17No one knew who was swapping what.
- 1:00:20It's really important.
- 1:00:21It's really none of anyone's business.
- 1:00:23It's a total mindset of liberty that most people don't seem to have these days,
- 1:00:29or it's been beaten out of them, at least in our country.
- 1:00:32That point about cash is fundamentally important.
- 1:00:34The reason cash exists is because it enables people who don't know each other to transact with each other.
- 1:00:39the whole conceptual ideation of a banknote
- 1:00:44is that you and I don't know each other.
- 1:00:47We don't need to trust each other.
- 1:00:49I don't even need to get your name
- 1:00:51if you come into a shop and hand me over a £10 note.
- 1:00:54You definitely don't need your name.
- 1:00:55It's none of your business.
- 1:00:57Absolutely none.
- 1:00:58But people have, I think,
- 1:01:00part of the process of moving away from cash
- 1:01:03and into tapping,
- 1:01:05people have lost sight of the fact
- 1:01:07that money is a KYC-less technology.
- 1:01:11And as you were talking there,
- 1:01:13I also kind of, I think I'm with you on,
- 1:01:16having gone over that second hill,
- 1:01:19I became very excited.
- 1:01:21And I'm now more cognizant of the fact
- 1:01:23that we are very much on the back foot
- 1:01:25in terms of preserving, frankly, you know,
- 1:01:28our ability to transact.
- 1:01:30I go on about this a lot,
- 1:01:32but I think that's a very, very fundamental freedom.
- 1:01:34the train ticket point you made.
- 1:01:39I know in Hong Kong,
- 1:01:40when people were going to the pro-democracy protests,
- 1:01:45their travel was being monitored
- 1:01:46and they developed a system
- 1:01:49whereby you'd leave spent tickets in machines
- 1:01:53for other people to pick up
- 1:01:54to try and throw people off the track.
- 1:01:59But being able to,
- 1:02:00I think for merchants accepting Bitcoin,
- 1:02:04is a huge Trojan horse to keep this going forwards.
- 1:02:08Because once you can pay for things
- 1:02:11in a currency that's not controlled by the government,
- 1:02:14that's quite a powerful pushback against it.
- 1:02:17And you said, obviously, the government wants to know
- 1:02:19exactly what we're spending.
- 1:02:21The reason they want to know what we're doing with our money
- 1:02:23is because they want it.
- 1:02:25They want to cut off it.
- 1:02:26Yes, exactly.
- 1:02:28Government is fundamentally a non-productive enterprise.
- 1:02:31Governments only make money either by tax
- 1:02:33in their population or by borrowing.
- 1:02:37Which is getting harder and harder for them.
- 1:02:38Both of them are getting really difficult.
- 1:02:40And you asked earlier, do I think a change is coming in the United Kingdom?
- 1:02:46I really do think that we are on the verge of some kind of sovereign debt crisis.
- 1:02:52The extent of our indebtedness is enormous.
- 1:02:57By sovereign debt crisis, I don't mean what the man in the street might typically say,
- 1:03:01oh, the UK is bankrupt.
- 1:03:03Governments that can print their own currency and whose debts are denominated in their own currency, as you know, don't go bankrupt.
- 1:03:10They just print more and more money.
- 1:03:12Weimar Germany didn't go bankrupt.
- 1:03:15They just...
- 1:03:16It's a big balance sheet.
- 1:03:17Yes, exactly.
- 1:03:19And we're already getting to the point where, you know, you'll laugh a curve point.
- 1:03:24We're getting to the point where it's very difficult to tax anyone anymore.
- 1:03:28largely because even regular people are beginning to notice that they can't afford anything any
- 1:03:34longer so to my mind the only way of fixing this is via an enormous debasement of the currency
- 1:03:41that's the only way that our unfunded civil service pension liabilities are going to be paid
- 1:03:45personally i'm you know i'm in my mid-40s i don't expect to be getting a state pension
- 1:03:50i don't see how it's fiscally possible i don't see how it would be enough either really really
- 1:03:57I mean, it's one thing getting a pension.
- 1:03:59It's another thing being enough to actually live.
- 1:04:02I mean, that time is gone, I think.
- 1:04:06You can live poorly on it if you want, but if you had any kind of life, you know, I think, yeah.
- 1:04:12I mean, that's a whole other point.
- 1:04:15I was just, as you were speaking, then I thought of something.
- 1:04:19What were you just saying then about?
- 1:04:22Were you talking about unfunded pension liabilities, talking about?
- 1:04:25Oh, yeah, the slow looting of everyone, basically, which is what's happening.
- 1:04:33And so your result would be some form of collapse in the form of a debasement or a conscious debasement.
- 1:04:40I think that, I mean, historically, that's what people have done to solve this kind of indefinite problem.
- 1:04:46There's sort of two related solutions, Israel in the 80s and I think maybe started in the 70s, but definitely in the 1980s.
- 1:04:55they had a short period of very, very high inflation, which effectively wiped out a lot
- 1:04:58of their national, or the real value of a lot of their national debt. And then certainly in 1920s
- 1:05:05and 30s Germany, we saw three or four different currencies, I believe, until eventually the third
- 1:05:11or fourth stabilized. But that was after an enormous period of horrendous hyperinflation.
- 1:05:18And I'm sure you will have read When Money Dies. Yeah, fantastic, but I recommend that to people
- 1:05:22all the time harrowing yeah and really interesting to notice how people live through that kind of
- 1:05:29situation i find that fascinating because we there a very sorry to buy and there a slim version of that happening right now And in as much as in our country groceries have doubled since the pandemic That goes without saying now
- 1:05:43I know that from my own bills that they've doubled.
- 1:05:47And that means my income is halved, potentially, because everything's doubled.
- 1:05:53You know, inflation doesn't happen in just one sector.
- 1:05:55It happens everywhere.
- 1:05:55And in fact, it happens more in a lot of other sectors rather than things like food.
- 1:05:59so and we and you've noticed my me start to change the way i live my life already i know it's not
- 1:06:06hyperinflation where you spend your paycheck the moment you get it and just stock up on xyz but
- 1:06:12there are versions of that happening now and the meme that assets are where you store your wealth
- 1:06:18is suddenly happening all over the place it's bizarre i think and this should be considered a
- 1:06:24positive thing i think in a way but 10 years ago i don't think my father-in-law ever spoke about
- 1:06:32assets it wasn't something i mean if you're in the financial world it is second nature but the
- 1:06:38average person if you're a teacher or a bus driver or whatever you don't the most the nearest you got
- 1:06:44to investing was buying british telecom shares or whatever premium bonds premium bonds yeah exactly
- 1:06:50But all of a sudden, and a lot of it's to do with Robin Hood and things like that, but all of a sudden, people get this idea that people that have been staying rich have been leveraging their assets.
- 1:07:01They haven't been holding on to cash.
- 1:07:03They've been XYZ.
- 1:07:04And suddenly, it's common knowledge, it seems anyway, which is a good sign because I think that can happen with absolutely everything.
- 1:07:12And I think the next stage after that is, why is this happening?
- 1:07:15Oh, my God, it's the government.
- 1:07:16yes you know and and then you get that point where and that could be for us next election cycle
- 1:07:23where people go right i want i don't want those guys because they were terrible and i don't want
- 1:07:29the guys that are in there now as well because they did they did even worse who we got and there's
- 1:07:34some interesting folk coming through but but i'm not sure they have a whole government coming with
- 1:07:40them if you know what i mean i mean where do they find where well i don't know do you have you must
- 1:07:46have seen the latest electoral map predictions for the next election i haven't but are they all
- 1:07:51in it's i think the latest one i saw had reform at close to 400 seats wow which would be a total
- 1:07:58wipeout for both labor and the conservatives and i believe that poll was conducted before
- 1:08:02jeremy corbyn's new party which would leak this doesn't exist does it well it'll steal some vote
- 1:08:07from labor no but it doesn't his new party is just the there's a it's like a white paper isn't it
- 1:08:13well yeah it doesn't exist yet he's just said i'm gonna do this i hate it's like the the
- 1:08:18announcement before the announcement yeah but you know by the time when you know incredibly we've
- 1:08:23got was it four years until the next three four years until the next election 29 well there's a
- 1:08:27petition online now of people saying we need another election already you know one of those
- 1:08:31online petitions where they have to i know nothing will happen but um it's got i saw it yesterday it's
- 1:08:37got 500,000 signatures on.
- 1:08:40Well, that itself is indicative.
- 1:08:41Which is almost as much.
- 1:08:43Well, you know, I mean, how many people voted in the last election?
- 1:08:47Anyway.
- 1:08:47Yes, but that shows, to your point, are we seeing a desire for change in the UK?
- 1:08:52The fact that that poll's got 500,000 signatures in the space of about a week, it tells you
- 1:08:58how, because that's just, that'll be a subset of the people who are discontent.
- 1:09:02That's a relatively small subset of people who are motivated enough to find that poll,
- 1:09:06to bother to click on it, and then to verify their email address.
- 1:09:10So those 500,000 people have gone through quite a lot of hoops
- 1:09:14in order to get their names in that poll.
- 1:09:15There are vastly more people who are discontent.
- 1:09:19I wonder if it had online safety on it, because you have to be 18 to vote.
- 1:09:22Oh my gosh, that would be hilarious.
- 1:09:26Is it harmful stuff?
- 1:09:29I mean, voting is pretty harmful if you think it's going to change anything.
- 1:09:32Well, it's harmful if you're in a government that's about to lose power.
- 1:09:35Yes, for them.
- 1:09:36My big worry, though, is that we obviously tried the Conservatives
- 1:09:41and the coalition government for 14 years.
- 1:09:43That was a disaster.
- 1:09:45Labour is an unfolding disaster at the moment.
- 1:09:49Whoever comes in is going to have one chance
- 1:09:52before people completely switch off,
- 1:09:56and we effectively get into...
- 1:09:57And I actually don't know what the conclusion there will be.
- 1:09:59If you get voter turnout of 9% or 10% at subsequent elections,
- 1:10:03because people say, well, we've tried literally everyone
- 1:10:05and it's all been terrible.
- 1:10:07And the country is clearly run not by whichever bunch of idiots
- 1:10:11we vote into power, but it's run by a faceless grey mob
- 1:10:15of bureaucrats who are unaccountable to the people.
- 1:10:19But the civil service doesn't change, right?
- 1:10:21No, no, it doesn't.
- 1:10:22That's the whole point.
- 1:10:23I think that's that.
- 1:10:24Because I know they're not allowed to be political,
- 1:10:26but they are political.
- 1:10:27Everyone's political.
- 1:10:28You have a leaning, don't you?
- 1:10:29And they're almost all well-educated Oxford people who lean slightly left.
- 1:10:36Which is, you know, I'm not making it.
- 1:10:39That's not a value judgment.
- 1:10:40It's just an observation.
- 1:10:42Lastly, it was a lot of them my friends.
- 1:10:46So if you come into power and you did something about the civil service,
- 1:10:51I think that would make a really interesting change.
- 1:10:55Like Vivek Ramaswamy, I don't know if you saw a couple of interviews with him
- 1:10:58while he was still running for president.
- 1:10:59he said his plan was to come in and he would,
- 1:11:02I forget how he was going to do it,
- 1:11:03he was either going to do it via random selection
- 1:11:06of social security numbers or give everyone an A and a B.
- 1:11:09And then he said, right, all the B's are fired.
- 1:11:12That's a kind of Millet move, isn't it?
- 1:11:14That's a kind of thing Millet would do.
- 1:11:16Yes, and then see if the apparitions.
- 1:11:19But he didn't get in, did he?
- 1:11:20No, he didn't.
- 1:11:20And he didn't get anywhere near getting in either.
- 1:11:22I mean, he was liked by people,
- 1:11:24but at the end of the day,
- 1:11:25the competition was won by the you know the celebrity guy which doesn't i mean what what's
- 1:11:33your take on america and because america is the place for me in my mind anyway it's it's the
- 1:11:40libertarian country it's the one with the interesting it's the one that took our model
- 1:11:45and improved it and implemented it and it's still the place that has an identity of liberty
- 1:11:52on the whole when you go there it's like you you can say there's a large section of the population
- 1:11:57that actually believe in this stuff and are prepared to defend their houses if you come
- 1:12:02and tell them what to do you know and stuff like that so what's your take on that because
- 1:12:06like i said earlier my worry with anything happening in the uk is that a similar but
- 1:12:12more exaggerated version of what happened in america recently happened which is trump's
- 1:12:18really exciting because he's he's going to smash the blob he's going to destroy the deep state
- 1:12:24and then you realize now he there are some things that he appears to be doing especially in the
- 1:12:29bitcoin space and that's my meter that i would look at because that's all i really care about
- 1:12:35i'm a single i'm a voter of i think if if someone's pro bitcoin i'm going to vote for them
- 1:12:41because i think bitcoin is a long-term solution whether they know it or not to the problem of
- 1:12:46government um mainly because it takes away the ability to fund yourself by just basically creating
- 1:12:53money out if you're from your mates you know and the flip side of that if someone's opposed to
- 1:12:57bitcoin they're probably a wrong one yes and that yeah without and you can see that now around the
- 1:13:02world where is bitcoin forbidden do you want to live there yes no yeah that's right well it's
- 1:13:09heuristic i know i mean it's an obvious one yes it's it you know really so so i would i do use
- 1:13:15that as a signal. But what's your take on America? Do you think change is actually happening
- 1:13:21there? Or do you think that it's, as a lot of people think, you know, it's the Roman
- 1:13:27Empire thing, it's the declining end of an empire, biggest government that's ever existed,
- 1:13:33I think?
- 1:13:34I mean, I find America fascinating for a lot of the reasons that you've said. I absolutely
- 1:13:39love the founding principles of the United States.
- 1:13:42Me too.
- 1:13:42The Constitution is a phenomenally well-drafted document, and I profoundly admire the minds of the people who created it, who decided how much power they were willing to see to the state and how much they would.
- 1:13:56As far as I know, it's the only country where people voluntarily chose how much power to give up to the state rather than finding themselves oppressed by the state from the moment of their birth.
- 1:14:06and a lot of the Americans that I know and like hold those principles
- 1:14:12and actually think about them in a way that British people don't.
- 1:14:16And I wonder sometimes if that's because all of the British people
- 1:14:18who thought and felt like that went.
- 1:14:20Went, yes.
- 1:14:21And the people who stayed,
- 1:14:23and we are the descendants of the people who stayed behind.
- 1:14:26I wonder if there's some kind of evolutionary selection pressure.
- 1:14:29Almost certainly.
- 1:14:30I mean, it almost certainly is,
- 1:14:32because I think that's why the attitude is in America.
- 1:14:35it's it's it's something you're born with there in a very subtle way it's not something you
- 1:14:40necessarily learn you can learn it but well I mean I'm not sort of weird at this end of sort of
- 1:14:47obstreperous colonials myself my family had various stints in South America and in Africa
- 1:14:53twice in Africa my great-grandmother was born in South Africa and then my family I grew up in
- 1:15:00Zimbabwe myself.
- 1:15:01Wow, Zimbabwe.
- 1:15:02Yes.
- 1:15:03Wow, that's...
- 1:15:05Were you in Zimbabwe when all the shit was going down?
- 1:15:08Some.
- 1:15:09Actually, you were mentioning earlier around...
- 1:15:11It was when we were talking about Bukali.
- 1:15:12I remember something about Mugabe.
- 1:15:14When Mugabe came in, people forget that he was a popular president.
- 1:15:20And when I was a kid, Zimbabwe was a wonderful place to live and to grow up in.
- 1:15:24and unfortunately as he clung on to power his government became increasingly
- 1:15:31sclerotic and repressive and undemocratic so we saw a sort of live fire exercise of
- 1:15:40what happens when you know a popular freedom fighter basically comes into power
- 1:15:46and then suddenly decides to ruthlessly stamp down on opposition and then obviously the
- 1:15:53hyperinflation but it wasn't as bad when i left it was about inflation was running about 50 60 percent
- 1:15:58uh in the late mid to late 90s when uh i left but a lot of my friends stayed there so i left just
- 1:16:04before sixth form still there now very few one or two um but yeah close friend of mine actually i
- 1:16:12know for a fact his his family had savings which were entirely wiped out and that's true for the
- 1:16:18majority of people who had who had cash savings at the time i think at its worst hyperinflation
- 1:16:23got so bad that it was no longer possible to put a number on it it and i mean it was just an
- 1:16:30extraordinarily weird i've got a hundred billion dollar note actually i bought it in um in um
- 1:16:37what do you call it uh amsterdam was there's a i found a shop in amsterdam it's a lovely little
- 1:16:43a place that sells old currencies.
- 1:16:46And I just, I walked past and I went on the off chance.
- 1:16:48I even got 100 billion.
- 1:16:49It cost me like 60 euros.
- 1:16:51Yeah, it's a lot more than it would have been worth at the time.
- 1:16:53Right, exactly.
- 1:16:53But it's a phenomenal looking thing.
- 1:16:56And it's a pristine one.
- 1:16:57It's an A.
- 1:16:57It's like never been crunched up.
- 1:16:59Not that they were being used anyway.
- 1:17:01They were just bundled up in piles, weren't they?
- 1:17:03No, people were using the US dollar.
- 1:17:04In fact, the physical US dollars in the country are now beginning to collapse.
- 1:17:08And actually, the paper's disintegrating because they're used so much.
- 1:17:12Wow.
- 1:17:13Do they use stablecoins down there?
- 1:17:16Or is the technology not really?
- 1:17:17Beginning.
- 1:17:18So a friend of mine, actually, a school friend,
- 1:17:20set up a business called KuvaCash,
- 1:17:22which is designed to help with cross-border remittances,
- 1:17:26and they'll use stablecoin and Bitcoin as well.
- 1:17:28And I'm in touch with the Bitcoin movement in Zimbabwe.
- 1:17:32I've joined a few calls, done a few spaces with them.
- 1:17:36Hopefully I'll be going back to the Africa Bitcoin conference this year.
- 1:17:39I attended in Kenya last year,
- 1:17:41although sadly there weren't many Zimbos.
- 1:17:43A few friends from Zambia, some guys have crossed the border and are now actually mining in Zambia in some instances.
- 1:17:50Bitcoin mining.
- 1:17:51Yeah.
- 1:17:52Yeah, you've got to be careful when you say mining.
- 1:17:54Yeah, actually it's funny.
- 1:17:55I mentioned my great-grandmother.
- 1:17:56Her dad then moved from South Africa to, as it was, northern Rhodesia.
- 1:18:01There's a mine named after her mother somewhere.
- 1:18:03He was a copper miner.
- 1:18:05But yeah, so back to my slightly random point, I feel a little bit different from a lot of people I went to school and university with.
- 1:18:13the UK and I think partly because you know I'd grown up in these slightly rough and ready places
- 1:18:19where you know something goes wrong you fix it you make a plan you don't I mean we used to our
- 1:18:24cars were held together with you know chicken wire and ingenuity and unfortunately you see the same
- 1:18:32in countries like Cuba which is devastating impacts of both the political situation and
- 1:18:39and poor government.
- 1:18:42And you mentioned Trump coming in
- 1:18:45and everyone thinking he was going to drain the swamp.
- 1:18:48I mean, fundamentally, I think gigantic bureaucracies
- 1:18:53only ever kill themselves.
- 1:18:56I can't think of an instance where someone has successfully come in.
- 1:19:00Well, Millet is a work in progress.
- 1:19:01Is Millet actually reducing the size of government?
- 1:19:05I mean, has anyone...
- 1:19:07I know that he's got inflation down and I know that people love him and this is all good.
- 1:19:12But is he actually reducing the size of government?
- 1:19:14Because I think that is the solution.
- 1:19:17The only solution I can ever come back to is the government is too big.
- 1:19:22Because if the government was, and as you said, as a sort of left-leaning libertarian, you know roughly the real purpose of a government.
- 1:19:32When it comes down to it, the government shouldn't be telling your kids not to look at porn.
- 1:19:36the government should be defending private property on the whole yeah or or maybe a few
- 1:19:40other bits and bobs as well you know a lot of people are undecided about that the main point
- 1:19:45is it's it should be tiny in the same sense of the founding fathers there was no need for
- 1:19:51to to fleece people of money to sort of like fund themselves they had very limited job titles
- 1:19:57and it and it worked beautifully um but well i mean there was a lot of you know there was a lot
- 1:20:04of inviting and stuff i suppose but um i don't know where i'm going with this it's just yeah
- 1:20:09the government needs to do small basically yes i mean it's an interesting observation at the
- 1:20:13moment so we're talking earlier about dubai and the free zones trying to map countries which have
- 1:20:19relatively low tax rates uh against where against sort of energy producing nations is an interesting
- 1:20:25mind game to play i mentioned earlier that governments are an unproductive enterprise but
- 1:20:30if the state owns, if the state effectively has an energy monopoly, everything for me always comes
- 1:20:36back to energy. If the state's able to fund itself through its energy resources, then it technically
- 1:20:42doesn't really need to tax anyone. I often return to the idea that the only reason, it's a bit of a
- 1:20:48facetious point, but I think there's some truth in it. The only reason the state needs to tax people
- 1:20:52is to prove to the international bond markets that it's going to be good for the money,
- 1:20:57that it can service its debts that other nations are buying
- 1:21:02and can pay the coupon on those debts.
- 1:21:07Because I mentioned earlier, obviously, most states only have two sources of income,
- 1:21:11bond markets and their own citizens.
- 1:21:14To the extent, and I'm far from a fan of state-run enterprises,
- 1:21:19and again, we're in a country where there's a living demonstration of why they don't work,
- 1:21:23But to the extent that you have energy-rich nations, they don't need to tax their population
- 1:21:30so much because a lot of their income is derived from oil, and Saudi Aramco is a perfect example.
- 1:21:37Obviously we not in a great position for energy abundance in the United Kingdom as we seeing in terms of our electricity bill So maybe the UK is not a good example there But to the extent and again I don necessarily want governments to have more money
- 1:21:51because they'll probably just spend them on more civil services.
- 1:21:52Yeah, but don't forget that Dubai has began in this sphere, but then pivoted.
- 1:22:00And one of the places it innovated the most was in financial services,
- 1:22:05Dubai Financial District.
- 1:22:06well the uk's got a massive financial hub you know why not like dubai is a i know people either love
- 1:22:14or hate dubai but i think you should look at dubai from the governance perspective and see
- 1:22:19it's basically a family run seven families that run seven jurisdictions now a lot of people don't
- 1:22:26like that already because they think it's undemocratic well you know tough shit you know
- 1:22:31kings and queens run countries often much better than democracies do because they get to think
- 1:22:38longer term they can decide right let's my son's going to inherit this we've got a good hundred
- 1:22:43years of governance here the problem with those kind of places if you get a bad guy
- 1:22:48your son's an idiot he can run the place into the ground and that does happen
- 1:22:52but on the whole like i said earlier people go to um go people go to dubai because they receive
- 1:22:59a good service. Government should be a service. They go there to receive a good service. If the
- 1:23:04service is bad, they often will leave as quickly as they went. If Dubai starts spiraling out of
- 1:23:11control and turning into an absolute nightmare that they don't like, people are going to go.
- 1:23:15And that's the way governance should work in my head. Government should be competing for you,
- 1:23:20not seeing you as just a way to generate income. And unfortunately, Dubai has that option. It had
- 1:23:27some wealth behind it from resources doesn't need to do it and it treats its own citizens incredibly
- 1:23:34well like emiratis they're only 10 of the population there but they are given a lot of stuff
- 1:23:41same with qataris actually right yeah and and as a result they're happy all the incomers are happy
- 1:23:47because they're they're hardly being taxed at all the only reason they're actually being taxed is
- 1:23:51because of pressure from the rest of the world to say hey it's not fair you know about that right
- 1:23:56They would be happy if there was a single tax rate for the whole world that everyone had to comply to.
- 1:24:03And all that is, is doing away with competition again.
- 1:24:05And it's like, this is the thing that keeps coming up.
- 1:24:08Governments want to eradicate competition between them and other people.
- 1:24:14And the problem that they run, they run like that.
- 1:24:18They don't need to compete.
- 1:24:20They don't care.
- 1:24:21if if if the if your local council runs out of money they're not going to lose their job
- 1:24:26the guys aren't going to lose their job they're they're going to just charge you more for a bin
- 1:24:31and the people who cause the problem will probably be the ones who are paid to try and fix it and
- 1:24:35yeah exactly and they're and and they're they've got a pension they were during the pandemic they
- 1:24:43were treated very well it's almost like the rules were based around those kind of jobs you know
- 1:24:47the whole thing is is is an absolute shit show i don't we're so far down the route anyway back to
- 1:24:54the question about america are you positive do you think something's happening there is something
- 1:24:59good happening i'm yeah i'm generally quite sanguine about it i'm certainly given the
- 1:25:03contrast between you know by but the biden administration the trump administration
- 1:25:08you know weirdly i'm i'm i'm obviously not an american voter and my opinions of the biden
- 1:25:15administration were mainly based on his aggressive pursuit and attack on on bitcoin uh and and the
- 1:25:22industry in general nothing wrong with that like i say it's the canary in the coal mine yeah it
- 1:25:25really is and the i think you're completely right you know it was your your one second test as to
- 1:25:32whether it's a good place yeah or a good person yeah good person yeah i mean if it if you do it
- 1:25:36with a person if if i i don't like speaking about him but um he's come up a number of times recently
- 1:25:43on this podcast, Gary's Economics.
- 1:25:45Oh, Christ.
- 1:25:46Yeah, but he's a perfect example
- 1:25:48of someone who speaks authoritatively about Bitcoin
- 1:25:51and doesn't understand it at all.
- 1:25:53Yeah, no one's saying it.
- 1:25:54Right, so that's my red flag
- 1:25:56in a personal relationship as well.
- 1:25:58It's fine to not understand Bitcoin,
- 1:26:01but if you talk about it authoritatively,
- 1:26:03I doubt everything you're saying now.
- 1:26:06Well, exactly.
- 1:26:07It's completely undermined my belief in the FT.
- 1:26:12Are they backing him?
- 1:26:13I didn't even know that.
- 1:26:13Oh, no, no, I meant their incorrect attitude towards the last 15 years.
- 1:26:18I thought he was becoming a columnist at the MT or something.
- 1:26:20It got to the point where I was thinking, you know, the old joke,
- 1:26:24those who can do and those who can't teach,
- 1:26:27and if you can't do either, you work for the FT.
- 1:26:29Right.
- 1:26:33But anyway, you're completely right.
- 1:26:34He speaks about it with great authority and great conviction,
- 1:26:38and he looks like the kind of man who's never even turned on a computer.
- 1:26:43He's also a closet socialist, and I'm not sure he even understands that. But the reason I think Gary's a really good, interesting example is he defaults to the government solving the problem without even a thought, I think. And this is important because I think a lot of people think the same way.
- 1:27:02when a problem arises they look to the government and there's a much bigger view of that whole
- 1:27:10equation which is is it the government's problem is it their fault should they solve it but people
- 1:27:16don't they they it's we especially in the uk we live in such an ingrained system where the
- 1:27:22government solves problems like i'm poor right the government's not helping me you know like
- 1:27:28that's the kind of natural response to it from so many people whereas you find in america it's a bit
- 1:27:33more of a you know pick yourself up by your bootstraps kind of place well i think i know i
- 1:27:40grew up in a country where if you were poor no one was coming to help you if you were poor you lived
- 1:27:44on the freaking streets and i think that's very deeply ingrained into me from when i was a small
- 1:27:51child i grew up in a scenario with it in a country where there were no free schools every kid when
- 1:27:58went to school, their parents paid even a small amount. The government schools were
- 1:28:03charged fees. There was no free health care. It was a tough place to grow up. It forged people
- 1:28:11who were incentivized to change things. So your point is completely correct. We do have this
- 1:28:18mental attitude that someone will look after us someone else will fix this Why are the roads full of potholes Now you see Rod Stewart at the front of his house filling in holes
- 1:28:30Yeah, there's a video from somewhere
- 1:28:32filling in a pothole outside his own house
- 1:28:35because the local council isn't able to do it.
- 1:28:36And in this terrible state of our system,
- 1:28:40I wouldn't be surprised if someone from the bureaucratic system
- 1:28:44came to stop him and said, it's our job.
- 1:28:47Yes.
- 1:28:47I mean, this is how ridiculous everything's becoming.
- 1:28:52And when you look at that, it's basically the collectivist versus the individualist.
- 1:28:57The individualist says, oh, there's a pot outside my house, right, I'm going to go and fix it.
- 1:29:00The collectivists are like, wait a minute, wait a minute, no.
- 1:29:03Whose job is that?
- 1:29:05And we've also over-regulated to the point where if you fill in a pothole with incorrect material,
- 1:29:11then perhaps that is now going to create a health and safety problem where some other regulation has been tripped.
- 1:29:16You know, that's been filled in with gravel, not with bitumen.
- 1:29:20You know, that's not going to meet with, you know, the highways agency standards for road composition.
- 1:29:26And you have so many different interlocking layers and rules that effectively,
- 1:29:31there's something that a lot of the Silicon Valley company directors talk about.
- 1:29:34It's a bias for action.
- 1:29:36As a country in the United Kingdom, we've completely lost our bias for action.
- 1:29:40We now have a throw your hands up in the air and wait for someone else to fix it attitude.
- 1:29:45and unfortunately I mean if I had to sort of
- 1:29:49sum up a lot of my frustration with this
- 1:29:52is that we need to take more personal responsibility
- 1:29:57for actions and really look at the way
- 1:29:59that our system functions
- 1:30:00and understand what it is about the system
- 1:30:03that stops us from taking those actions
- 1:30:04and is there then anything that we can do about it
- 1:30:08and actually returning to something we said recently
- 1:30:11if a government comes in and really decides
- 1:30:13to make those kind of changes,
- 1:30:15to try and reduce the size of the civil service
- 1:30:18or get rid of unnecessary...
- 1:30:20Some regulation is good, for example.
- 1:30:23I think it's sensible that we have a legal system
- 1:30:26which protects people's rights to own property
- 1:30:30and, you know, I know to have those property rights
- 1:30:34enforced in a court of law, fine.
- 1:30:37The back tunnel, I return to a lot.
- 1:30:41Have you read this story?
- 1:30:42on HS2.
- 1:30:45They had spent £100 million
- 1:30:46building a tunnel for some bats
- 1:30:48which may actually not even be there.
- 1:30:51£100 million?
- 1:30:52£100 million, yeah.
- 1:30:54I know people that have been done on bat houses
- 1:30:56when they've been doing an extension
- 1:30:59on their house.
- 1:31:00And that was like £60,000
- 1:31:02but £100 million?
- 1:31:05It was because
- 1:31:06the line was going to run through
- 1:31:08an area of woodland in which it was
- 1:31:10alleged some of these endangered bats might live but it wasn't proven that they were actually there
- 1:31:15but this is why we can't do anything in our country well interestingly you know i was speaking
- 1:31:22to michael monnelly the lord mayor of london yes on the last pod he he's he's into being into
- 1:31:27regulation and understanding that and he did make a really valid point that i hadn't really hit home
- 1:31:32on me prior to that conversation which is most regulation arises out of the industry you think
- 1:31:38of regulation as being something the government does it's something that they might enforce
- 1:31:42but really most business most you know sectors create regulation because they want their products
- 1:31:50to be good and they want some kind of you know like people to believe in them or you know the
- 1:31:55perfect example is cruise ships which are private floating cities basically and there's no guy from
- 1:32:02the government on board enforcing the regulations but they create their regulations they're they're
- 1:32:08in order that their customers have a good experience
- 1:32:11and they don't lose their customers, which was, you know.
- 1:32:13So the regulation things are often quite misunderstood.
- 1:32:17It's just always, oh, it's bloody regulation.
- 1:32:19It's terrible.
- 1:32:21Yeah, I'd agree with that from maybe two perspectives.
- 1:32:23One sort of standardization, which I think is a good form of regulation.
- 1:32:27And that's the kind of experience that I think you're describing
- 1:32:29on like a Carnival cruise ship.
- 1:32:31You know that the industry has certain standards
- 1:32:35which are then enforced by the courts and by the government.
- 1:32:38The other southern negative flip side of that, where I might sort of challenge him slightly,
- 1:32:42is that, yes, industries often do push for regulation because it creates a regulatory moat and reduces competition.
- 1:32:50So that, I think what he said is true, but it can have positive and negative outcomes.
- 1:32:55If what you're doing is creating a moat such that no new entrant can ever break into your company.
- 1:33:00And actually, interestingly, this is what we saw.
- 1:33:02Oh, God, I'm going to get the technology wrong.
- 1:33:04it's worth the United States Postal Service I think tried to push back against either Telegram
- 1:33:11or the email you probably know the story I don't but I was going to say email I could have been
- 1:33:18that uh there was there was some form of I'm so sorry I can't I can't recall the exact story but
- 1:33:23it's worth worth digging up it's quite quite an old story and it was around um whether or not
- 1:33:28email should be effectively run by a particular bot. And obviously, the war was successfully
- 1:33:36fought. The SMTP protocol is an open protocol, and anyone can use it and build on it.
- 1:33:42But that was an interesting example. And I think, returning to the money question,
- 1:33:48Bitcoin undermines the state's monopoly of money, which is why a lot of defensive states
- 1:33:55don't like it and tying that back into america the fact that america has now looked at bitcoin
- 1:34:01and seen all of its manifest advantages i think is a hugely positive step forwards
- 1:34:06because usually where america goes the world follows even reluctantly i did though here
- 1:34:12recently which was an interesting take i think it was preston pish was saying that
- 1:34:16the us's interest in bitcoin and particular stable coins because they're so closely
- 1:34:25related is to do with them requiring liquidity for um sovereign debt oh i completely agree right
- 1:34:33okay but it's not all no i think a lot of people would look at what you said and think wow they
- 1:34:38support bitcoin they believe in liberty and freedom and all this kind of stuff well i think i think
- 1:34:42that i think president's point i completely agree on the stable coin front uh it's very important
- 1:34:48for there to be global demand for united states dollars um and i think they've got some very very
- 1:34:54clever people who've looked at the stablecoin market
- 1:34:56and realized that it is only going to grow exponentially.
- 1:34:59And it a fantastic way of creating US dollar demand in countries that can normally access US dollars It basically the same as the Eurodollar market in the 70s and 80s You enable offshore entities to create US dollars via
- 1:35:13making bonds denominated in dollars. The US doesn't know how many, no one knows how many
- 1:35:19dollars were created in the Eurodollar market.
- 1:35:21I don't think many people knew it existed until recently. I think it's just been talked
- 1:35:25about.
- 1:35:25It's kind of a geeky thing that people, I mean, even I was in the future.
- 1:35:28But it's a really important thing to understand.
- 1:35:30I don't understand it.
- 1:35:31I've dug into the euro-dollar thing, and I kind of get it,
- 1:35:36but I don't really understand it.
- 1:35:37I don't really understand how it functions.
- 1:35:39I mean, very few people do, but at its simplest,
- 1:35:42let's say you're a bank in Luxembourg, and you make me a loan,
- 1:35:46and you denominate that loan in US dollars.
- 1:35:48You've just created some US dollars.
- 1:35:49But that seems really weird.
- 1:35:51It is.
- 1:35:52Yeah, yeah.
- 1:35:52But I mean, I find it all delightfully weird,
- 1:35:56but you know that they're sort of weird i mean this is why i can't why i don't have conversations
- 1:36:02at the dinner table because if i start talking about this kind of stuff my wife will just get
- 1:36:05up and leave but i find it all geekly fascinating i i we're running we're over an hour and a half
- 1:36:12and we did you've got a hard stop i know i i want to leave on a positive note though um from your
- 1:36:19perspective from where you are and like i say you're you you've got a unique perspective because
- 1:36:24you you know you know you were you're in that sector that a lot of people don't have access to
- 1:36:30i think um what how do we how do we deal with this going forward and i mean this problem of
- 1:36:38constant state encroachment bad governance and those are the two main things what what does the
- 1:36:47individual do the normal person who's just trying to run a business or just living their life what
- 1:36:53What should they do?
- 1:36:56Again, trying to end positively, I did just sort of two fronts, one macro and one individual.
- 1:37:03So on the macro level, I think it's very important to try and make it clear to the people for whom we vote
- 1:37:09that there is an increasing groundswell for a reduction in the cost of running the state,
- 1:37:16however that's achieved.
- 1:37:18And that covers all kinds of things that we've been talking about,
- 1:37:21the impossibility of building infrastructure in the UK, the fact that there's no money for councils,
- 1:37:26the fact that pension liabilities are unfunded, the fact that we have too many civil servants,
- 1:37:30and that getting those, I'm sure, good civil servants to do anything is borderline impossible
- 1:37:36because of the loopholes that they have to go through. So reducing the cost of running the state
- 1:37:41is hugely important. And voting for people who have in the manifesto they want to do that,
- 1:37:47I think is an important step. It may not be successful, but it's a step in the right direction.
- 1:37:50And then on an individual level, I mentioned earlier, well, we are very much on the back foot in terms of privacy and surveillance, but there are a lot of new pieces of what's commonly called freedom tech coming to market.
- 1:38:03Jack Dorsey's BitChats is a great example.
- 1:38:06If you haven't downloaded it, you probably have, actually.
- 1:38:10But any of your listeners, that's a fantastic piece of software.
- 1:38:13It sits on your phone and enables you to create a mesh network using Bluetooth with other people who use it.
- 1:38:19that kind of technology is going to be extraordinarily powerful your point earlier
- 1:38:25was what made me think about it about around needing permission to go on the internet
- 1:38:30other forms of internet communication exist and a localized mesh network is one of them
- 1:38:36and using facilities like starlink is another the to the extent that you can reach outside
- 1:38:44a firewall that your country may be intending to impose.
- 1:38:48Learn about those kind of technologies now before you need them.
- 1:38:51There are lots of them out there.
- 1:38:53There is a list of them in my pinned tweet at the moment.
- 1:38:57An increasing number of companies and people and programmers and developers
- 1:39:00are working on this kind of stuff.
- 1:39:03And it is possible to use a browser like DuckDuckGo or like Opera,
- 1:39:08which have built-in VPNs which don't track you.
- 1:39:12You can pay for VPNs like MulVad using Bitcoin
- 1:39:15without surrendering your personal information.
- 1:39:19Explore those, understand them,
- 1:39:21learn how to buy Bitcoin KYC-free.
- 1:39:25Prudently, if you're going to buy Bitcoin,
- 1:39:27I'd suggest that you maintain a KYC stack
- 1:39:29and a non-KYC stack.
- 1:39:32You can then, if, for example,
- 1:39:33you ever need to sell any,
- 1:39:34you can prove chain of title for the KYC stack.
- 1:39:37explore operating systems like graphene os that you can use on an android phone which again won't
- 1:39:44track you won't surveil you won't sell your data to other people and again a lot of this i think is
- 1:39:48precautionary steps as an individual can take we don't necessarily need to use them yet because
- 1:39:54we still don't quite live in a police state but if we ever did it's just as well to have made that
- 1:40:00those preparatory steps first and know that you're a little bit ahead of the game rather than
- 1:40:05how everyone else will be.
- 1:40:09Freddie, many thanks.
- 1:40:12Thank you, Jim.
- 1:40:12I've enjoyed talking to you.
- 1:40:14I've enjoyed it as well.
- 1:40:15I really enjoyed it.
- 1:40:16And I'm surprised you're being so candid
- 1:40:19about things like that.
- 1:40:20When I hear people say things like that,
- 1:40:21I think, dude, they're coming to get you.
- 1:40:23Well, I put a lot of this stuff
- 1:40:25after the online safety hack came
- 1:40:27and then I thought, maybe,
- 1:40:29I hope in my photo I don't have a fire.
- 1:40:31Maybe that's to do with your past
- 1:40:33and where you grew up and stuff.
- 1:40:34you're kind of you're used to living a little bit on the edgier side perhaps but i think it's
- 1:40:40important and remember that you know there are more of us than there are of them correct but
- 1:40:45as as i always think i've decided to put myself in a public arena um but that makes you a target
- 1:40:54and makes you a very simple and easy target in fact and one that might be chosen because you can
- 1:40:59being made uh and you know an example out of but it is important for people to publicly talk about
- 1:41:06these things it's just it is it's just a it's just a horrible horrible situation to be in i find
- 1:41:11although staying positive yes there are still things we can do i'm like that guy i know the
- 1:41:16painter yeah what's that with the fuzzy hair and in the end i painted the thing yeah
- 1:41:21right we're ending on a good one and freddie thank you very much indeed and thank you so much
- 1:41:27And yeah, I look forward to hearing your talk today later at Honeybetter.
- 1:41:31Thank you.
- 1:41:31Real pleasure to have me on.
- 1:41:32Thank you.