Latest / Dubious Creatures Presents / The Dubious Book Club Podcast Ep 4 - A Study in Drowning Part 2 (Preview)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, and welcome back to the Dubious Book Club
- 0:01podcast. I'm Aubrey, and today we're
- 0:04going to talk about the second-half of A Study in
- 0:07Drowning by Eva Reed. And joining me this week, we've
- 0:12got a couple other dubious creatures.
- 0:15Say hello, dubious creatures. No.
- 0:19So. Yeah, this tracks.
- 0:24So we're going to start off by talking about the second-half of
- 0:28A Study in Drowning, chapter 10:00-ish to the end, and Oh my
- 0:36God, it's a doozy. It starts off like we ended last
- 0:42time with discovering the salacious photographs.
- 0:49I I think so, yeah. Yeah, I think that was where we
- 0:51ended off because I think it was, it was like Chapter 9.
- 0:54Finding finding Ianto's private spank bank, among other things.
- 1:00Yeah, he's got all the, he's got all The Dirty books.
- 1:03But then they found all of Amris's Ye Olde pornography.
- 1:11Yeah. And then also a couple of
- 1:14letters from Amris to he is again still yet unnamed wife,
- 1:23presumably future wife, none of which are particularly safe for
- 1:30work. So it.
- 1:34OK, here's the thing. Like I, I shouldn't make fun.
- 1:39Effie's been through a lot. Sometimes we have to find the
- 1:43the humor in it or to laugh and stuff cry at the.
- 1:46Same time, though, I thought someone was going to need to
- 1:51fetch her a goddamn fainting couch because she just has a,
- 1:56she has a visceral reaction to these things.
- 1:59And I know it's more about the fact that she built up Emery's
- 2:03murder. And as this like, you know, like
- 2:08the good one, you know, the enlightened artist in the midst
- 2:12of all of the in the midst of all of this, you know,
- 2:15depression and gloom and finding out he's just as sad and horny
- 2:20as the rest of us brought her back to earth somewhat.
- 2:25And then never meet Carrie Harrels.
- 2:28Yeah, so I I get it, but. Yeah, things do continue to just
- 2:38escalate at the the mansion. Yeah.
- 2:46And so it continues to be a creep.
- 2:47And Preston is like, yeah, we should probably, like, go and
- 2:51talk to this other writer who was a friend of Everest because
- 2:57they write a lot of letters to each other.
- 2:59And I think he might have been the actual writer of Angaret.
- 3:02Yeah. Just Colin Blackmar, who is, at
- 3:07least in Preston's perhaps not entirely unbiased opinion, not
- 3:12nearly as good of a writer. He's apparently only really
- 3:19known for one piece, which is an epic poem type thing called The
- 3:24Dreams of a Sleeping King, which is considered, well, let's just
- 3:29say it's considered a it's considered a national pastime
- 3:32for purely nationalistic reasons and leave it at.
- 3:35That, yeah, it's kind. Of like grade school.
- 3:40Yeah, they all have to memorize it.
- 3:47Which? Does love escapism?
- 3:50This book is full of so much escapism.
- 3:53Yeah, don't. You just don't.
- 3:54You just love sitting down with a book and forgetting your
- 3:57problems. Yeah, all the time.
- 4:03All the time President Fe continue to get closer and
- 4:06closer even though Yonto was trying to keep them apart.
- 4:10Yeah. Do we?
- 4:11Frankly. I mean.
- 4:14It'll make sense, it'll make sense in a moment, but when you
- 4:17have to physically get two children to leave room for
- 4:20fantasy Jesus with a gun? Yeah.
- 4:28He does. Sort of not really threaten them
- 4:32but stand in front of them while holding a gun and being like
- 4:36what are you 2 doing? That's pretty threatening.
- 4:43It's like, yeah, the I, I will say in retrospect, Ianto's
- 4:50probably the weakest character in the book, mainly because he's
- 4:57not really a character per SE. And I mean, we do kind of learn
- 5:02why he's not a character. We do like he.
- 5:06He really only shows up whenever Effie needs to be freshly re
- 5:10traumatized is the thing. Or to be foreshadowy and re
- 5:16traumatizing that that's those are the two scenes we get with
- 5:19Yonto. Yeah, and we also do learn a
- 5:22little bit more about Effie. We learned about, we learned her
- 5:25full name Euphemia, which is they is a Saint's name.
- 5:29And they say that a Saint's name is only given to a changeling
- 5:32child as to try and make them conform.
- 5:40Yeah. And so I, I, I like this aspect
- 5:46for a couple of reasons, partially because it ties
- 5:49directly into Effie's back story, but also because, again,
- 5:56studying drowning clearly takes a lot of inspiration from the
- 5:58Victorian era. And The funny thing about that
- 6:01is that for all of the cultural and technological enlightenment
- 6:05of the time, changelings, especially in what's now the
- 6:09United Kingdom, are we're still very much considered a thing.
- 6:14Yeah, they come up with the proper terms for that.
- 6:19Yeah, yeah, your child's acting out.
- 6:21Won't sit still in class biting you.
- 6:23Oh. Must have been replaced by the
- 6:25fairies. Goddamn.
- 6:27Fairies. Yeah, because clearly no child
- 6:30whatever acts improperly when their skull is still fusing
- 6:35together. What?
- 6:37No, that's crazy. You're asking.
- 6:40Entirely too much. Yeah, so it I'm not saying
- 6:44that's the only reason why there were so many abandoned and
- 6:46neglected children in the Victorian period, but it's part
- 6:52of it. Certainly, and also.
- 6:56Doesn't help that in the Victorian area there was, you
- 6:59know, oh you got ghosts in your blood, do cocaine.
- 7:03Working. Yes.
- 7:04You've got too much bad blood. We need to bleed you.
- 7:07Yeah, you. Just got to get rid of that.
- 7:10Excess blood. I think we might be a little
- 7:16past that era, but I'll keep it for the imagery.
- 7:20It's fair, yeah. Yeah.
- 7:23Laudanum, cocaine, all that stuff.
- 7:25Oh, you've got a problem. One of these 33 drugs.
- 7:28Here you go. Yeah.
- 7:32I kind of want to know what those pink pills are like.
- 7:36What would be the modern day equivalent to the pink pill?
- 7:40Like an antipsychotic Klonopin, yeah.
- 7:43Probably the modern day equivalent to the pink pill,
- 7:45huh? Do you want me to answer that,
- 7:50or do you want Aubrey to answer that?
- 7:53Nope. Anyway.
- 8:02Yeah. And yeah, we do.
- 8:05We do learn a little bit more about Effie's history and past,
- 8:08the fact that her mother had Effie out of Medlock and
- 8:16essentially she's never known her father because essentially
- 8:19her mother used to work at her grandfather's bank and when her
- 8:26mom got pregnant, he set the guy away.
- 8:31And then, you know, certainly Effie's mother attempted to
- 8:38abandon her at one point, left her by the river where one said
- 8:44you would leave for the fairies to take.
- 8:48Yeah, And again, I must point out, because between this
- 8:52recording and our last one, I, I did look up some other reviews
- 8:59of this book. And one of the, well, OK, one of
- 9:04the common criticisms that isn't very Internet is that the book
- 9:10is just kind of ridiculously grim.
- 9:13And I would refute that if I didn't know enough about history
- 9:19to know that, buddy, for vast majority, for about 49% of the
- 9:24population did. For a pretty solid chunk of
- 9:28history, this was just life. If you were not white or rich,
- 9:32your life was pretty shit, yeah. I'm not.
- 9:35Yeah, call me woke on Twitter. I don't give a fuck.
- 9:38This is just this was just how it was.
- 9:42Yeah, like. You know the first time she sees
- 9:47the fairy king. Yes.
- 9:49Anyway, what I'm trying to say is that I don't think it's
- 9:52necessarily I I get that it's technically a fantasy book, but
- 9:56I don't really see how it's a legitimate criticism to Cole.
- 9:59I Study and Drowning Overly dark when it's very clearly trying to
- 10:04evoke an actual time period. Oh yeah, Honestly very minimal
- 10:11alterations with a lot of the social mores.
- 10:14Yes, but yeah, very king, right? Sexy man King.
- 10:17Yeah, I yes and no. His description.
- 10:24Yes, very sexy. Unfortunately, his obsession
- 10:27with young children, I don't like that.
- 10:29Yeah, it's super creepy. It's very like turn off so.
- 10:33That's where you so that's where you draw the fucking line.
- 10:36Good to know. That's a good place to draw that
- 10:40line. I'm just saying it's.
- 10:41Really a good place to draw that line.
- 10:43That's like the best place to draw the line.
- 10:46I would take these protestations under advisements if your lines
- 10:49weren't drawn in fucking dry erase marker.
- 10:54That's a hard line for all my king friendly people out there.
- 10:58You know what that means? But.
- 11:00Yeah, no, this dude, this, this dude's a creep.
- 11:03Just to get it out of the way, this.
- 11:04That's a good creep. Yeah, takes takes her ring
- 11:07finger, so no one else can put a ring on it, which is why.
- 11:11Which is why we later, well, when we first met her, very
- 11:17notably, she only has nine fingers.
- 11:20This is why, Yeah, just not not a great time to be Euphemia.
- 11:28No, she's. She's really had at heart.
- 11:34Yeah, and naturally, naturally, nobody believes that she
- 11:41actually met the fairy king. You know, the finger rotting off
- 11:46her body, not with standing. And she spends the rest of her
- 11:50adolescent years being overly medicated and gas lit on a Yep.
- 11:55Very. Regular basis, OK, Yep.
- 11:58And we're moving and we're moving, and Effie is sad and
- 12:01we're moving. Preston's a good being and there
- 12:04and supportive I. Love Preston.
- 12:06I love Preston so much. God, he's such a good character.
- 12:11He does his best. He's like, I don't know if I can
- 12:13believe that fairies, but I believe you believe that
- 12:16something happened to you and I want to be there for you.
- 12:20Yeah, I think, I think it would have helped just a bit.
- 12:24It I think it would have helped just a bit if Preston wasn't the
- 12:27only, you know, non garbage human being within a 20 mile
- 12:34radius of Effie over the course of the story just to maybe, I
- 12:40don't know, just to give a little variety.
- 12:43Yeah, but that's like like. It goes.
- 12:47Back to the historical thing, that's just kind of how it was.
- 12:52I know going back into the historical thing, I get it, but
- 12:55I like again, it. I understand why, I understand
- 13:02the context I but I, I don't know there there comes a point
- 13:13when character development just kind.
- 13:15I know this is going to sound a little hypocritical given what I
- 13:17just said, but there comes a point when character development
- 13:19turns into character masochism. So I appreciate Preston.
- 13:29This is a Preston appreciation zone.
- 13:34I appreciate what he does in the context of just generally making
- 13:41Effie have hope that not everybody's going to treat her
- 13:43like a human waste disposal for the rest of her existence.
- 13:50But I maybe would have liked to see her have more of a support
- 13:56system than just one dude. No, that would that would have
- 14:00been nice. But also also the the the
- 14:02isolation and everything plays into a lot of gothic literature
- 14:05trips too. I know.
- 14:07So like, again, I have to immediately, I have to
- 14:09immediately bring this up and then refute it because like, I
- 14:12get why, but my, my appreciation for the Dawn was clashing with
- 14:15my own personal preferences here.
- 14:17No, that's it's totally fair. It's been like, yeah, it would
- 14:19be nice if she had more than one person in her corner, but I
- 14:22understand by history and tropes she cannot.
- 14:27Yeah, so Colin Blackmar, Speaking of garbage people.
- 14:34Oh my God. Yeah, no, it's, it's funny.
- 14:37It's like Preston writes a letter initially.
- 14:39He's like, yeah, no, there's no way he's going to see us or
- 14:41anything. And if he writes a letter and
- 14:43it's just like, I would love to have you and your friends to
- 14:46come over and talk about books. And nothing else.
- 14:52Nothing else. Nothing else.
- 14:55Totally innocent trip. Yeah.
- 14:58So they get to, they take a little road trip and they get to
- 15:08the Blackmar estate, which is very noticeably just garishly
- 15:14wealthy, which is an interesting contrast with Mr. Mirden's abode
- 15:21because, well, both of them are celebrated.
- 15:26Yeah, both of them are celebrated authors, but for some
- 15:29reason, you know, he's this dude who is arguably, at least
- 15:33according to Preston, who we trust implicitly, is arguably
- 15:37the worst writer. And yet he's living it up.
- 15:40Yeah. So they meet him and.
- 15:45He's. And he's vague and creepy and
- 15:51old old. Does insist that they stay for a
- 15:58party. Yeah.
- 16:03Yeah, like the whole I didn't understand giving them Brandy
- 16:08and not feeding them. I remember it got brought up as
- 16:11well in the book and I was just like, yeah, why would they do
- 16:13that? That's weird.
- 16:15That gives creeps vibes. Well, because that's what should
- 16:19do. It doesn't erase the creep vibes
- 16:22whatsoever. It's just, you know, alcoholism
- 16:28was not a thing yet. Either mincers a lot about like
- 16:33how he has many many daughters at least I don't remember the
- 16:38exact number, but it's like 3 I think like three daughters or
- 16:41something yeah and the. Youngest wasn't like the other
- 16:47daughters. And we'll learn why.
- 16:54Yeah, strap in folks. Yes.
- 16:55Oh. Yeah, this is.
- 16:56Where it's wild. Yeah, so they're, they're given
- 17:02this room to stay in. And this is like the first time
- 17:05where, you know, there's there's like a movement romantically
- 17:11between Preston and Effie because she asks him to stay
- 17:14with her because she's like having a panic attack, can't
- 17:17sleep. And so he just kind of, they
- 17:20just kind of sleep, sleep, just sleep together.
- 17:27I know it is actually just sleeping, but the way you
- 17:30emphasize that was like what they just slept.
- 17:34Don't just sleep. No, nothing else.
- 17:36Just sleep. Just a bit of premarital hand
- 17:39holding. Yeah.
- 17:41How dare it's. A very sweet scene.
- 17:44It's so cute, it's actually one of my favorite scenes in the
- 17:47book, especially when he starts speaking in his native language.
- 17:52Yeah, Oh my God. And we learned also a little bit
- 17:56more about Preston, his father, like how his father died from
- 18:01water on the brain. You.
- 18:04Thought the tragic back story wouldn't come for him too.
- 18:07Didn't she hope that you were mistaken?
- 18:10He's he's very he's very like sort of driven to prove himself
- 18:16being having garden. And that's not the right word,
- 18:22but I'm going to continue with it.
- 18:26But he's very proven and he's like, you know, and we get that
- 18:31moment. They have that connection.
- 18:34And the next day they're poking around in the room and they
- 18:38discover some letters underneath the bed.
- 18:41Old dusty letters that have been under there for a long time.
- 18:45Long, long time. Well, they did mention that no
- 18:48one had come into that room for a while.
- 18:51Yeah. So it was made believable.
- 18:56Yeah, but yeah, these letters certainly start to shine a light
- 19:03on certain things. Yeah, mainly that Mearden was a
- 19:10little was a little scamp and. Well, let's just.
- 19:15Say that Effie's parents were the only ones having
- 19:18relationships out of. Wedlock and it further makes
- 19:25them believe that something to do with the authorship of the
- 19:29book being Blackwells of some sort because they talk about
- 19:34delivering that Angaran will be delivered to Meredith.
- 19:40Yeah, Angaran, who is, well, at least as far as we the audience
- 19:45know at this point, is the POV character for the book.
- 19:49But now we are rapidly coming to the realization that Engarred
- 19:53might actually be a real person. Awesome.
- 19:58Like. Because I also love letters.
- 20:01Yeah, quite possibly also Black Bar's youngest daughter, who he
- 20:06effectively sold to Emory's. Who might be the woman in the
- 20:12photographs? Who might be the woman in
- 20:16Yonto's creepy attic? Yeah, yeah.
- 20:21Then they are given clothes and sent to a party.
- 20:29Oh boy. Yeah.
- 20:31Always a party. All of my social anxiety all at
- 20:36once. Just I hate, I hated this
- 20:44chapter not because it was a bad chapter, but because I was just
- 20:50because like it was hitting me where I lived in a big way in
- 20:54some aspects. The chapter itself does feel
- 20:57very claustrophobic with the how it's described it.
- 21:01Dies, yes. Yeah.
- 21:06And it's just all of these old creepy men were just hitting on
- 21:11Fe. I'm so sorry, Evie.
- 21:17We've all been there. It's awful.
- 21:19And then you know Preston. Preston steps up and like, you
- 21:27know, he's a fucking. Man.
- 21:28Yeah, protects her. It's so good.
- 21:34Yeah, I. Love president so much.
- 21:36I'm so. Sorry, no, you're, you're good.
- 21:38We all, we all appreciate him here.
- 21:40There was one benefit that I say with quotation marks to
- 21:46slapping. I don't even remember the
- 21:48fucking guy's name slapping. That guy's right in the self
- 21:53esteem and that was he. Blackmar was also there when
- 21:56that whole large occasion happened.
- 21:58And he mentions believe he mentions his daughter.
- 22:05Yeah. And how apparently something
- 22:07happened to her that Colin Blackmar immediately shuts down.
- 22:14And then just it's so SUS. It's yeah, Effie, we need to
- 22:23call an emergency meeting. Effie, I would like to hold your
- 22:28hand when I say a few things. First off, I love you.
- 22:32Second Mary Preston. I have an agreement with that.
- 22:44Yeah, put a ring on that boy. Because he he saves her, they go
- 22:50out and they're like, well, we've been, we need to at least
- 22:53dance to keep up the, the charade of what we're doing.
- 22:57And they dance. And it's a very good scene.
- 23:00And then I love the metaphor that she uses or she's like, and
- 23:05that's when I realized I was in a romantic or a romance novel.
- 23:10It's like, oh. Really.
- 23:13You just realized that? Oh girl, I get it.
- 23:18But. Aha moment, OK.
- 23:20Girl, I get it, but come on. That's me.
- 23:24I need those moments like. Oh, oh, oh.
- 23:27You actually like like like me? Oh fuck.
- 23:31Yeah, no, because, because Preston was acting so normal
- 23:35these last couple of chapters. I mean to be fair she it's not
- 23:38like she has good like connotations with her romance.
- 23:43I I know it's, it's the curse of it's the curse of the audience
- 23:47POV, but all things being equal, come on, girl.
- 23:51You know, I mean, she takes as much, takes a minute, she gets
- 23:54there in her own time and gets there.
- 23:56So like the big thing of why they were able to do this is
- 23:59that they they lied to Tianto and saying they need if he needs
- 24:03specific books from his other library and they'd be back in 2
- 24:07days. So essentially is they have to
- 24:09kind of rush home from the party and sort of during all of that
- 24:15happening if he has a panic attack in the car A.
- 24:18Bad one. Bad 1 and I believe this is like
- 24:23this is like a right around the time where it's like I I know
- 24:26the phrase that like that Preston says stuck out to me and
- 24:30I'm pretty sure it's right either before or after or during
- 24:35this car panic attack. It's the I'm not afraid to care
- 24:38for care about you, Fe. Oh, oh, that hurt me.
- 24:43I actually cried. I had to put everything down and
- 24:46I like I had to walk away. I was like off no.
- 24:53Oh yeah, it's. Really good at getting into like
- 24:58the gnarly bits of me. I didn't like it, but I loved
- 25:01it. Yeah, it definitely stuck out to
- 25:06me because I was, I was listening and I had to sort of
- 25:08like take a second after that scene.
- 25:13God damn you and your emotional torture porn.
- 25:19You love it. Warming up to it.
- 25:28Yeah, there's, there's the whole big thing in the car where, you
- 25:33know, he comforts her while they're driving and the big sort
- 25:37of connection between them. And when they get back to the
- 25:42estate, he stays with her in the guest house.
- 25:49That's the word I was saying. That's the word I was saying
- 25:51for. And that's where we get our
- 25:53like, one spicy scene of the book.
- 25:55And it's not even that spicy, but it's very sweet and very
- 25:57well written. So romantic, like Oh my God, I
- 26:04it was so sweet and so romantic. I give it a 10 out of 10 for her
- 26:09first time. That was sweet as fuck it.
- 26:12Was very good and very well written.
- 26:17Yeah. So of course, you know, they
- 26:22still got the the mystery of the house to unravel.
- 26:28And that leads us, perhaps inevitably, to the basement at
- 26:36the Meerden Estate, which, if you'll recall from our last
- 26:42recording, is flooded. Because why make anything easy?
- 26:47Can't. So they think that there's
- 26:51probably, if there's any clue to what happened to anger, it's
- 26:54probably down there because clearly Ianto doesn't want them
- 26:58to check down there. Yeah, he keeps the key to it on
- 27:02his person at all times. On like a little like thing
- 27:06around his neck. And.
- 27:09You know, also super dangerous being the basement is flooded.
- 27:12Yeah. So, Long story short, she lives.
- 27:19We still got a few more chapters to go through.
- 27:21So I suppose. That's not exactly surprising,
- 27:25but yeah. Prepping for a massive storm
- 27:28coming. Yeah.
- 27:33So foreshadowing is a narrative device in which, yeah, this book
- 27:40is a lot of things, but subtle is not one of them.
- 27:42No, it is not subtle. Yeah, anyway, so they managed to
- 27:48retrieve a box from the flooded basements, that ones you know,
- 27:54it is printed with Angarod's name on top of it.
- 28:02I. Love this scene in particular
- 28:04because I love how she uses the fear of drowning to actually
- 28:09surpass her own fears. Yeah, no one is is really good
- 28:15is very evocative and how it works things and you know, now
- 28:24it's it's time to reenact 7 and be like what's in the box.
- 28:29What's in the? Box.
- 28:32Open. It open.
- 28:34It they don't really get a chance to do that for a couple
- 28:40reasons. One, nothing makes anybody quite
- 28:44as literally and figuratively wet as nearly drowning.
- 28:50So there's a bit of horizontal, there's a bit of horizontal
- 28:54gymnastics. They fall asleep, they wake up
- 28:57and oh God, the well, the sea is trying to kill them.
- 29:02The storm has come in. It's it's bad.
- 29:05The entire the entire state looks like it's going to fall
- 29:08into the ocean. So they're they're trying to get
- 29:12out before they can't anymore. But unfortunately, you know the
- 29:17fairy king does not want that. Yeah, so as they're basically,
- 29:28you know, because they can unlock the box, they need
- 29:30Deanto's key. So as they're trying to grab it
- 29:32and then get the hell out of dodge, Ianto shows up and
- 29:38naturally decides this is a perfect time for a good old
- 29:41villain monologue of. Course, apparently.
- 29:50Apparently Colin called him because the 2.
- 29:57Preston and Effie the The lovebirds are not nearly as
- 30:01grave detectives as they think they are.
- 30:03And naturally, he was a little that, you know, it's almost as
- 30:07though the dude with something to hide would maybe want to make
- 30:09sure that the thing stayed hidden.