Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #22: Variations Within the Democratic and Republican Parties
Transcript
- 0:00It's time for another episode of the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about the Democratic Republican Party's woah.
- 0:11What if why we talk about that on a political podcast?
- 0:14Well, specifically, I'm going to talk about the variations within the Democratic and Republican
- 0:23parties.
- 0:24Because oftentimes, they get treated as these monoliths, as these hoards of people that all
- 0:31think and act the same way.
- 0:34Sometimes, voters and politicians have a vested interest in doing so to paint the opposition a
- 0:40certain way to win elections because name of the game is to win elections.
- 0:47It's much easier to galvanize your like minded voters by describing the other side of the
- 0:52aisle as one specific way to try to combat them.
- 0:55It's not good for business if you're pointing out the facts that there are nuances within
- 1:04people's, belief systems.
- 1:06But some voters and politicians also actually think their own side should be monolithic.
- 1:14And that's where you get this whole no true Scotsman fallacy of what a, quote, unquote,
- 1:20real democrat and real republican should be.
- 1:25You often hear them called dinos, democrats in name only, and rhinos, republicans in name
- 1:32only.
- 1:33And then the media is also often guilty of painting giant groups of people as one way to
- 1:39more effectively facilitate engagement with their stories.
- 1:43But you'll sometimes get republicans and democrats that do go against the grain, so to
- 1:48speak, and have a completely antithetical view on an issue than their fellow party members, or
- 1:55they'll have similar views but not as strongly supporting or opposing the general view of
- 2:01their party.
- 2:02In any case, however, while members of each of the major parties tend to share a general
- 2:08stance on basic issues, for example, Republicans tend to be more against abortion,
- 2:13and Democrats tend to support more gun control, you still get some variation and opinions on
- 2:20these issues and how each state variation of a party, each state affiliate of a party
- 2:27generally thinks is going to look somewhat different from another state's variation.
- 2:32A Wyoming Democrat and a Hawaii Democrat, while similar to some extent, are not going to be the
- 2:38same, and the same goes for a California Republican versus a Maryland Republican.
- 2:44So how do these intraparty, not interparty, differences make themselves apparent?
- 2:52How do we see differences between Democrats and other Democrats and between Republicans and
- 2:58other Republicans?
- 2:59And why do we see these disparities, and what are some specific examples?
- 3:04Well, let's talk about it.
- 3:07So first of all, why the differences within the party's state variations?
- 3:13Gotta make sure to make this very clear because sometimes they get treated as the same.
- 3:19Party does not equal ideology.
- 3:22One of my former professors, from grad school would be beside himself if I did not point that
- 3:29out specifically.
- 3:30Yes.
- 3:30Most conservatives are Republicans.
- 3:33Yes.
- 3:34Most liberals are Democrats, but that's not always the case.
- 3:39Trend over time of voters with either conserve conservative or liberal ideology is what we
- 3:46might call sorting into their, quote, unquote, correct party, where conservatives are
- 3:52correctly going into the Republican party and liberals are correctly going into the
- 3:58Democratic party.
- 3:59Now sometimes these differences are based on political necessity.
- 4:05Maybe you have a serious disadvantage in voter registration.
- 4:08Show so you may shift more to the center to a to appeal to a wider range of voters.
- 4:14If Democrats are heavily outnumbered, they might try to go a little bit more to the right
- 4:18to get more to the center.
- 4:20If Republicans are more heavily outnumbered, they might try to go to the left to get a
- 4:25little more to the center.
- 4:27After all, people involved in politics are trying to win elections, and sometimes you need
- 4:33to do certain things, change up strategies so that you do win elections.
- 4:38That doesn't always happen, though, and party members often argue about what is necessary to
- 4:44win elections.
- 4:46Sometimes these differences are just based on their upbringing and environment.
- 4:51There used to be the prevailing thoughts in the early days of political science where
- 4:56demography is destiny.
- 4:58That was popularized by the Columbia School of Thought, as we call it, in the 19 forties that
- 5:05focused on the sociological aspects of political behavior.
- 5:10So, obviously, the old adage, demography is destiny is not always true.
- 5:15You don't see a 100% Republicans of a demographic group.
- 5:18You don't see a 100% Democrats of a demographic group, but it does obviously have an impact.
- 5:25Where you come from, your environment is inevitably going to have an impact on what your
- 5:30political beliefs are.
- 5:32For example, rural areas tend to be more conservative and Republican, and urban areas
- 5:38tend to be more liberal and Democrat.
- 5:41So states that are more rural might have a more conservative republican leaning, whereas states
- 5:48that have a little bit more urbanization might have a little bit more of a liberal and
- 5:54democratic leaning, or at least those areas within the state that are rural versus urban.
- 6:02So, also, differences in environments often mean that different issues are more pressing to
- 6:10these voters, these politicians than for other people.
- 6:13Parties in the border states are likely to have differing opinions on immigration policy than
- 6:21their nonborder counterparts because simply border policy is not going to be as important
- 6:27to Maryland voters or Virginia voters versus in Texas or New Mexico.
- 6:37Obviously, there'll still be some similarities for some people, but, inevitably, being closer
- 6:44to a border state is gonna have a different or is gonna have a certain effect on your
- 6:49political opinion simply because you live near the border versus if you live far away from the
- 6:54border.
- 6:57But sometimes differences are not as much about diverging ideological views, but differing
- 7:03operations and structures and capabilities for the state affiliates of and the county
- 7:10affiliates of the Democratic and Republican parties.
- 7:13Generally speaking, every county and county equivalent area has their own Democrat and
- 7:19Republican party affiliate.
- 7:20Might be a few cases where that's not the case, but how well resourced and powerful each are
- 7:26can differ greatly.
- 7:27They're all gonna have different environments to contend with that might shape their opinions
- 7:35a little bit differently than the Democratic and Republican parties at large.
- 7:41California Republicans, Florida Democrats, and other Democratic and Republican affiliates like
- 7:48them have had a lot of struggles gaining voters and representation in government and
- 7:54influencing policy.
- 7:55In fact, several years ago, California Republicans several years ago became
- 7:59outnumbered by independents.
- 8:02Florida Democrats were overtaken by Republicans back in 2021, and now they're over a 1000000
- 8:07voters behind the Florida the Republican Party of Florida's, voter registration numbers.
- 8:15So those kinds of realities might have to might influence the parties to have to shift a little
- 8:23more to the center to appeal to a wider range of voters.
- 8:28Maybe not.
- 8:29But generally speaking, you might expect that to happen so that they can try to gain more
- 8:35support and therefore try to gain more representation in government and try to
- 8:39influence policy.
- 8:42But political necessity and upbringing can conflict for a state level party.
- 8:47You see inter party arguments all the time as to how far to the left should a democratic
- 8:53party affiliate go, how far to the right should a republican party affiliate go.
- 8:59Political necessity might dictate the need for a more ideologically moderate approach for a
- 9:04party, but many members' upbringing have in has influenced their views much further to the left
- 9:12or to the right.
- 9:14Some of them a republican might be a lot more MAGA than your typical republican.
- 9:19A democrat might be a lot more progressive or even socialist than your average democrat is
- 9:26going to be.
- 9:28What's good for an individual democrat or republican candidate might not be good for the
- 9:34party as a whole, and so individuals may may make their differences known in certain beliefs
- 9:40and make a very strong case for their opinions.
- 9:45For example, with the Democratic Party at large, saw a lot of progressives butt heads
- 9:50with their fellow Democrats because they thought they the party should go more towards
- 9:57the left.
- 9:59Obviously, not every Democrat agrees.
- 10:01And this you you saw a similar thing with Republicans with the more MAGA contingent
- 10:06versus those who aren't so MAGA.
- 10:09There's a lot of butting heads there too.
- 10:14So political necessity, upbringing, all these other factors may make some states and county
- 10:23Republican parties more conservative or less conservative than the Republican party at
- 10:28large, and then a state or county level Democratic party may be more to the left or
- 10:35less to the left than the Democratic party at large because of all these factors.
- 10:41So how exactly do you see and measure differences within the parties?
- 10:47So you can look at instances of political infighting.
- 10:51Again, disagreements about the direction of a state level party tend to lead to power
- 10:56struggles, and it gets this gets a lot more into the weeds of of political wheeling
- 11:03wheeling and dealing that your regular voter is not necessarily gonna be paying attention to,
- 11:08but you might have the example of a faction who doesn't believe current leadership is
- 11:13sufficiently supportive of the democratic or republican figureheads and may try to push out
- 11:18that leadership if that faction is powerful enough.
- 11:22So in the case of republicans, maybe there's a faction that thinks that their republican
- 11:28figureheads are not sufficiently supportive of Donald Trump and and the whole MAGA ethos.
- 11:35For Democrats, they may have felt that some were not supportive enough of Joe Biden.
- 11:42Now, obviously, Joe Biden's about to leave office, but point still stands when Joe Biden
- 11:47was in office.
- 11:48Sometimes, there might have been butting of heads as to whether they thought there was
- 11:53enough support of Joe Biden or Barack Obama when he was in office.
- 11:57And you can also apply this to the state level figureheads, like the governors of states,
- 12:04whether they're sufficiently supportive enough of the governor's agenda.
- 12:08You might see a lot of infighting with within a party there.
- 12:12Or, obviously, conversely, if it's the opposite party from the governor, maybe a, like, for
- 12:19democrats, for example, in, Florida, if they feel that a some democrats are not being
- 12:29sufficient or effective in opposing governor Ron DeSantis and his agenda.
- 12:35You might see a lot of struggles for power and leadership there.
- 12:41Another way we can look at it is through public appeal excuse me, public opinion polling.
- 12:47Some people will straight up tell you their issue stances and general ideology.
- 12:52And so you actually still see some Republicans call themselves liberal and some Democrats call
- 12:58themselves conservatives.
- 12:59I've I've seen it.
- 13:01You just look at the more in-depth details of a lot of public opinion polling.
- 13:06Yes.
- 13:07Yes, most Democrats are gonna say that they're liberal, and most, republicans are gonna say
- 13:12they're conservative, but you do find those odd ones out, so to speak, in a lot of cases.
- 13:18But, also, not every voter thinks along ideological lines.
- 13:21In fact, many of them don't.
- 13:23And some of them have different concepts of what being a, quote, unquote, true conservative
- 13:31or a true liberal is.
- 13:34Some democrats think liberal is being something different than what another democrat thinks.
- 13:39Some Republicans think being conservative is different what than what another republican
- 13:44thinks.
- 13:46There's there's really no clear way to say x state's party is the most conservative
- 13:52republican state level party in the nation or x party is the most liberal democratic state
- 13:59level party in the nation.
- 14:01It's more based on inferences and piecing together other data, but this is not a pull
- 14:07foolproof concept.
- 14:08There's just no way to say to rank 1 to 50, which states republican parties are the most
- 14:16conservative to the least conservative, which democratic parties are the most liberal to the
- 14:21least liberal.
- 14:22Can't really do that.
- 14:24But there are some deeper studies by think tanks and public opinion research organizations
- 14:29as to these different strains of thoughts amongst the democratic and republican parties.
- 14:37Pew Research Center had a study about, like, 8 to 10 years ago that came up with names for
- 14:42different blocks of democrats and republicans based on their divergence of views, but I've
- 14:47had I've had trouble, finding it.
- 14:50So can't, unfortunately, can't really highlight it there.
- 14:53But there is also a Pew Research poll surveying ideological and party affiliations for each
- 15:01state.
- 15:01But the info is from 2015, so it's gonna be somewhat outdated, though it's still useful.
- 15:06And you'd see a little bit of differentiation between, okay, this percentage of people, say,
- 15:13in x state, say that they're republican, but how many of them actually said they're
- 15:19conservative?
- 15:21How many people in a state said they were democrat, but then how many of them also said
- 15:26they were liberal?
- 15:27So a couple of examples.
- 15:29And, again, 2015, so a little bit outdated, but Alabama had 52% said that they were republican
- 15:38or lean republican, and 50% said that they were conservative.
- 15:46We've got Colorado where 33% said or excuse me.
- 15:5228% said that they were liberal.
- 15:55And then in Colorado, 42% of voters said they were democrat or lean democrat.
- 16:00So some discrepancies there between the 2.
- 16:03Again, party is not the same as ideology even though even though the 2 are obviously socially
- 16:10correlated.
- 16:11And then the Brookings Institution, another example, they just had a study in December
- 16:172024, and they and according to their research, they came up with 3 groups each for democrats
- 16:23or republicans.
- 16:24For democrats, there was mainstream democrat, progressive, and then democratic socialist.
- 16:30For republicans, they came up with MAGA, mainstream conservative, and moderate publican.
- 16:35Didn't necessarily break it down by state by state by state, but it just goes to show you
- 16:42just the different strains of thought within the 2 major parties.
- 16:48And then, also, you've gotta look at differences between how the elites think.
- 16:53Those are the politicians, the political movers, and shakers versus interest groups
- 16:59versus voters.
- 17:01Each of these collectives as a whole think and act differently.
- 17:06Elites and groups tend to be more rigid and more to the left for the democrats than the
- 17:14typical democratic voter or at least the average democratic voter.
- 17:18And, likewise, elites and groups on the right or for that are for for Republicans tend to be
- 17:24more to the right of the average Republican voter.
- 17:29And this, hearkens back to a an idea back from the 19 sixties, a political scientist by the
- 17:39name of Philip Converse, had this seminal work where he talked about the idea of political
- 17:45constraint, which is the, which is basically how rigid your belief system is.
- 17:51If you change one view or attitude in that belief system, does that mean you have to
- 17:56change your views and attitudes in the rest of the system?
- 18:00So people who have high constraint, changing one view or attitude means having to change
- 18:06another because they're closely linked together.
- 18:10And if you have low constraint, changing one view or attitude has little to no impact on
- 18:16other views and attitudes, and you typically see elites and groups have interest groups have
- 18:22a higher constraint.
- 18:24They they they don't really change their views and attitudes often.
- 18:28And when they do, they they feel they have to shift a lot of other views and attitudes
- 18:32because they're all closely interconnected.
- 18:35Whereas for voters, you typically see a lower constraint.
- 18:38They change their view on one issue, not necessarily gonna affect their views on other
- 18:44issues or at least not by much.
- 18:47And elites that don't tow a certain line might get punished by interest groups that might
- 18:54otherwise support that politician.
- 18:56So some of that interaction between the various groups, but also elites might respond to voters
- 19:04as well.
- 19:04So a lot of, complicated dynamics in that regard.
- 19:10Also, how each state votes in elections also signals some variation within the parties as to
- 19:18how strongly the electorates lean democrat or republican.
- 19:21Now, of course, that's partially a function of how many voters in a state are democrats, how
- 19:26many of them are republicans, how many of them are independents and third parties because
- 19:31states can vary considerably in that regard.
- 19:34For example, Maryland's got significantly more Democrats than Republicans.
- 19:42If you go to, Utah believe Utah tracks voter party affiliation.
- 19:48Yes.
- 19:48Yes.
- 19:48They do.
- 19:49Or or I Idaho, for example.
- 19:51I do I know for a fact they they track that.
- 19:53There are a lot more Republicans than there are Democrats.
- 19:56Wyoming is the same case.
- 19:57And so you have to do you have to keep that in mind.
- 20:03But still, regardless, you see varying degrees of split ticket voting where voters on the same
- 20:13ballot will vote for rev a republican in one office, but then vote for a democrat in another
- 20:19office, and then maybe even a third party in another office.
- 20:23In any case, if they don't vote straight ticket, meaning they just vote republican up
- 20:28and down the ticket, they just vote democrat up, down the ticket.
- 20:31Split ticket's the opposite where they will vote for people in multiple parties, and you
- 20:36have varying degrees of that, within states.
- 20:39And some states with a noticeable lean toward 1 party are much more uniform in their voting for
- 20:45that party than other states.
- 20:48Although governors' races, seem to be a bit more resistant to that straight ticket voting,
- 20:53especially in more recent years.
- 20:56A few examples here.
- 20:59Larry Hogan was a repel republican governor of Maryland.
- 21:03He won in 2014 and 2018.
- 21:06Did not run-in 2022.
- 21:07I believe Maryland has, term limits on their gov governor, so that's why he didn't run
- 21:13there.
- 21:13Charlie Baker was a Republican governor in Massachusetts, 2014 and 2018.
- 21:19Those 2 Maryland and Massachusetts are both very democratic states, but were willing to
- 21:24vote for a Republican governor.
- 21:27And Phil Scott is the current Republican governor of Vermont.
- 21:30He won in 2016, 2018, 2020, 2022, and 2024.
- 21:37Another case where you don't expect them to necessarily vote for a Republican governor, but
- 21:45they did 5 times already.
- 21:49Other current governors on the flip side, the democrats, Laura Kelly in Kansas, which is a
- 21:56very republican state, she won in 2018 and 2022.
- 22:00And then Andy Bashir in Kentucky, democrats, 1 in 2019 and 2023.
- 22:07His father was also a governor of Kentucky as well.
- 22:11One is a little bit less Republican, but still already, showing a a trend towards the
- 22:18Republican Party.
- 22:21All cases of states that are typically toward one party, but then voted for a governor of a
- 22:29different party.
- 22:30So that is another case where you might say, okay.
- 22:34This democratic party, this state's Democratic Party might be a little less hardcore Democrat
- 22:42than other states, and then this state's Republican Party might be less hardcore
- 22:47Republican than another state.
- 22:50Again, not a very concrete specific way to say, okay.
- 22:55This is how Republican this this state level party is.
- 22:59This is how Democrat this state level Democratic Party is.
- 23:03Again, can't quite make specific judgments based on that, but you can sort have some level
- 23:10of comparison where oh, no.
- 23:12No.
- 23:12This state is like, you better be a democrat.
- 23:15Oh, there or and another state might be, oh, no.
- 23:17You better be a republican overview of interparty variation over time, because,
- 23:33obviously, you throughout history, we've seen a lot of major examples.
- 23:39And just for a few of them to to point out, we're just talking about Democrats and
- 23:45Republicans here.
- 23:46Whigs, a little less so or or not as we're not gonna focus really on the Whigs and
- 23:51Federalists.
- 23:52Although the Whigs, that was part of their the issue for with their survival is that there
- 23:58were so many disparate interests in the Whig party, and, ultimately, what killed them killed
- 24:05their party was the slavery issue.
- 24:06There's a lot of proslavery Whigs and a lot of antislavery Whigs.
- 24:10The main thing that held the Whigs together was their hatred for Andrew Jackson when he was
- 24:14president.
- 24:15And then when he when he left office, there wasn't really much to hold the Whig party
- 24:21together after that.
- 24:22But the vacuum they left and and the vacuum, that resulted from them, dissipating.
- 24:30Then you had the Republican party come in in the 18 fifties, founded primarily on the basis
- 24:36of being antislavery.
- 24:38And in the re reconstruction era, you had what they called radical Republicans, and they were
- 24:43a faction against the moderate Republicans.
- 24:46And moderate Republicans amongst their ranks were Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson, 2
- 24:51presidents of the United States.
- 24:52And so radical Republicans often duked it out with moderate Republicans, even finding
- 24:58themselves at odds with Lincoln and Johnson.
- 25:04And a lot of this was they thought the 2 presidents were not nearly strong enough
- 25:08supporters of civil rights, emancipation, enfranchisement of black voters, and that was
- 25:15definitely true of Johnson.
- 25:16Andrew Johnson was, not, not exactly the most, shall we say he was quite bigoted.
- 25:25Let's put it that way.
- 25:28Radical Republicans, they were very ardent supporters of abolishing slavery completely,
- 25:33which fortunately we did in the end, but, they influence a lot of Reconstruction policies,
- 25:40especially when they started accumulating more representation in congress.
- 25:46But that wouldn't last for a whole lot longer after that era because in the very towards the
- 25:54very end of the 1800 and in the beginning of 1900, you had a schism between what were called
- 26:01black and tan versus lily white Republicans.
- 26:04So, again, Republican party, it founded in 18 fifties primarily in opposition to slavery.
- 26:10But once reconstruction ended, they found themselves at a crossroads because as the North
- 26:17pulled out of the South, Democrats started sweeping congressional state and local offices
- 26:22in the south again and instating Jim Crow segregation to stifle black voters.
- 26:28So you had the lily white Republicans who felt that political survival in the south was only
- 26:34possible with an all white Republican Party, and so they advocated for disenfranchising
- 26:41black voters who had basically just gotten the right to vote.
- 26:45And then you had the black and 10 Republicans were the who were the traditional biracial wing
- 26:50of the Republican Party and wanted to continue that integration of black voters.
- 26:55And in any case, South continues to disenfranchise black voters.
- 27:02Jim Crow segregation becomes more stifling.
- 27:05Lily white Republicans, they sort of won out in the end, but they still or one they sort of won
- 27:13the schism against the black and tan Republicans, but southern Democrats still push
- 27:20them out of office for the most part anyways.
- 27:22Occasionally, you saw Republicans win a US senate seat or even a state for president, but
- 27:28by and large, they the Republicans got pushed out regardless of the ultimate results of that
- 27:36black and tan versus lily white schism.
- 27:39Speaking of those Democrats, you had the southern Democrats, also called Dixiecrats,
- 27:44very pro segregationist, anti civil rights for racial minorities.
- 27:49And they were once the dominant view of the Democratic Party, but they eventually were
- 27:52overtaken by northern Democrats with differing views on race, especially when you had the
- 27:59civil rights act of during the 19 sixties and other civil rights legislation.
- 28:05We also abolished poll taxes, which were another method of trying to stop black voters
- 28:10from voting because a lot of times they were they were poor or more poor than than white
- 28:16voters.
- 28:17And so poll tax is a way for them to say, if you wanna vote, you gotta pay this amount.
- 28:22And the way they got around that for poor white voters is oftentimes they had a grandfather
- 28:26clause, which said, oh, if your your your grandfather was able to vote, you don't have to
- 28:32pay this poll tax.
- 28:32So very insidious ways that they found to consolidate their power.
- 28:37And sometimes their heated disagreements with the Democratic Party at large led to third
- 28:42party bids in particularly the 1948 and 1968 presidential elections where Strom Thurmond,
- 28:50who probably his biggest claim to fame, was speaking out against integration in favor of
- 28:56segregation for a full 24 hours, filibustering the senate, basically praising segregation
- 29:04policy.
- 29:05He was the state's rights party candidate in 1948 and even won 4 states, although Harry
- 29:13Truman, the Democrat, did win reelection.
- 29:17George Wallace, most known for being that Alabama governor who stood on the steps of the
- 29:23University of Alabama trying to prevent black students from entering the school.
- 29:31He was the American Independent Party candidate in 1968 and won 5 states, and that was the year
- 29:38that Republican Richard Nixon won his first term.
- 29:43So couple of those, notable examples in both the Republican and Democratic parties
- 29:50historically.
- 29:52But variation within the parties may have been at an all time high around the 19 forties 19
- 29:59fifties because the American Political Science Association put out a report basically
- 30:05lamenting the lack of differences between the two parties.
- 30:08There's a report called toward a more responsible 2 party system, if you ever wanna
- 30:13look it up.
- 30:14Basically, the lack of difference between the two parties was because of the variation within
- 30:19the 2.
- 30:20There was a lot of conservatives and liberals in the Republican Party.
- 30:23There were a lot of Republicans or excuse me.
- 30:26There were a lot of conservatives and liberals in the Democratic Party.
- 30:30But starting in the 19 sixties, the the American Political Science Association, APSA,
- 30:36they kinda started to get their wish because the party started drifting apart from each
- 30:41other, slowly becoming more uniform in ideology within their parties, and you can still see the
- 30:46effects of that today.
- 30:47Conservatives started moving more and more towards the Republican Party.
- 30:51Liberals started moving more and more towards the Democratic Party.
- 30:54And one of the big catalysts for that was Barry Goldwater from Arizona when he ran for
- 31:00president in 1964.
- 31:02Now he got clobbered in that election, but he really put his conservative ethos at the
- 31:07forefront of his campaign and really had his big impact was lessened was not so much in that
- 31:14campaign, but really going down the road.
- 31:18Part of he was part of that it signaled that whole conservatives moving to the Republican
- 31:24Party, liberals moving more toward the Democratic Party.
- 31:29And so in most in large part because of that shift, some states that were once historically
- 31:37very Democrat or Republican have now become very much the opposite way.
- 31:43Most of those states that were part of that blue wall for Democrats.
- 31:47They were they wouldn't vote for yellow dog Democrats.
- 31:50I would vote for a yellow dog before I vote for a Republican.
- 31:53Now most, if not all, those are very strongly Republican.
- 31:58States like Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, who wouldn't vote for a Republican governor for
- 32:06years years, and their state legislatures were almost completely, if not completely,
- 32:14democratic.
- 32:15Now they are very Republican.
- 32:17Massachusetts and Vermont used to be strongly Republican, but now they're very strongly
- 32:23Democrat.
- 32:24Things that you would not expect coming from today, but when you look back at history,
- 32:30obviously, things changed, especially over the course of 60, 70, 80 years.
- 32:36As for specific state examples, let's look at, for example, Alaska.
- 32:42So Alaska Republicans are kind of an odd bunch due to their power sharing agreements despite
- 32:49having numerical majorities in both the state legislative chambers.
- 32:53They have a majority numbers wise of the state house there and of the state senate there, but
- 33:00several Republicans in multiple elections or following multiple elections have broken off to
- 33:06form governing coalitions with Democrats in the state senate and then in the state house with
- 33:12Democrats and independents because there are a few independents in the state house.
- 33:17But this the 2024 elections are not the only instances instance of that.
- 33:24In the state house, there were par power sharing agreements following 2016, 2018, 2020,
- 33:30and 2022.
- 33:32And in the state state senate, you have power sharing agreements in 2,006, 2008, 2010, and
- 33:392,020 22.
- 33:41Though in 2,008 and 2,010, the chamber was split evenly with democrats at 10 republicans,
- 33:4810 democrats anyways.
- 33:49But several republicans not really didn't really go over the party line, but they did
- 33:59come up with a power sharing agreement with Democrats, in some cases, independents.
- 34:05And there's really nothing like that in other states currently.
- 34:08When you look at Alaska's voting history, yeah, it tends to be fairly Republican, but they're
- 34:15not so ardently like we've we we vote Republican every time.
- 34:21President, really, it votes republican just about every time.
- 34:24But when you get to the state level, it's it's kind of a quirky state.
- 34:28Very interesting state.
- 34:29Very quirky.
- 34:31Minnesota, another example where you have, a level of uniqueness to the the state parties.
- 34:41The Democratic Party there is actually called the Democratic Farmer Labor Party or the DFL,
- 34:47and that is because the Farmer Labor Party in the early 1900 was a quite powerful third
- 34:54party, that that gained quite a bit of representation at both congress and, base and
- 35:02state level, state level politics.
- 35:06But in 1944, democrats and the former labor party would merge.
- 35:10So it's a unique blend of 2 parties that you find few, if any, analogs to in other states.
- 35:16You really don't have a different kind of named party in other states.
- 35:25Early not one's named like that.
- 35:26It's some variation of Democratic Party or some variation of Republican Party.
- 35:31But there was also for a time in Minnesota what they called independent Republicans.
- 35:37From the mid 19 seventies to the mid 19 nineties, the state party had changed its name
- 35:41to independent Republicans to sort of distance themselves from national Republicans.
- 35:45Now They're back to just being called Republicans now, but you had an ins in
- 35:51Minnesota, you did have an instance where they were particularly unique relative to other,
- 35:59Republican parties as well.
- 36:01Not to say that they're not unique now, but you you did see, a more unusual step that they took
- 36:08in the seventies to nineties to slightly change their name, although they are now just
- 36:12Republicans again.
- 36:15Nebraska, simply by virtue of having at least a nominally nonpartisan state legislature.
- 36:21In reality, they are Democrats or Republicans.
- 36:25They just can't officially call themselves as such in campaigning and when they're in office.
- 36:30But due to being officially nonpartisan, this can somewhat the general partisan leanings of
- 36:39these candidates.
- 36:40So a unique situation there.
- 36:43You don't have any other state legislature that is con officially nonpartisan in other states.
- 36:52And then lastly, for examples, we're gonna actually look at at a collection of states
- 36:57that's implement what's called fusion voting.
- 36:59Now fusion voting allows more than one political party to nominate a candidate.
- 37:04So a democrats can also have the endorsement of another of a third party, and a Republican can
- 37:12have the endorsement of a third party.
- 37:14Used to be a lot more common than the US.
- 37:17Today, it's it's allowed in some form and only in Connecticut, Mississippi, New York, Oregon,
- 37:23and Vermont, though Mississippi doesn't really use it.
- 37:27Others a lot of other states haven't really addressed it, but there are a couple that have
- 37:32flat out banned, fusion voting.
- 37:35I believe New Jersey is one of them, but this inherently makes the Democratic and Republican
- 37:42parties in these states function a bit different than the Democratic or Republican
- 37:47parties in other states simply because their candidates also have to appeal to these third
- 37:52parties.
- 37:53And some of these 3rd parties are more to the left than your average democrat, and some of
- 37:59them are more to the right than your average republican.
- 38:02And even occasionally, though, you see candidates pull both the democratic and
- 38:07republican party endorsements.
- 38:09Not often, but you do occasionally see it.
- 38:13Few examples of few more specific examples of these states.
- 38:18Vermont Vermont has what's called the Vermont Progressive Party, VPP, which is probably the
- 38:26most powerful slash influential third party in any state.
- 38:31And so that sometimes pulls some Democratic candidates more to the left so that they can
- 38:36get that VPP endorsement.
- 38:41In New York, you have the conservative party, which can sometimes push republican candidates
- 38:46more to the right, and the working families party can sometimes push democratic candidates
- 38:51more to the left because the conservative party is the main right leaning third party, and
- 38:57Working Families Party is the main left leaning third party in New York.
- 39:02So fusion voting, just by default, can make your Democratic and Republican parties a little
- 39:10function and think a little bit differently than states where fusion voting is not a thing.
- 39:16So that is going to end today's talk about well, the the specific subject that we're
- 39:22talking about for today, which is the variations within the Democratic and Republican
- 39:27parties.
- 39:28And so I'm gonna end it off today not on a random question.
- 39:32I'm gonna do something a little bit different with the end of this episode, and it's gonna be
- 39:35a random fact of the day that doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the topic
- 39:41that was discussed today.
- 39:42So some episodes will have a random question of the day.
- 39:46Other times, I will focus on a random political fact and expound upon it.
- 39:50So today, we're doing the latter.
- 39:53Okay.
- 39:54Today's random fact concerns counties and county government.
- 39:58Did you know that not every state has counties?
- 40:03There are over 31100 counties and county equivalents, but not every state uses counties.
- 40:09Alaska has what we call boroughs, and there's 19 organized boroughs.
- 40:14But over half of the state's land is combined into what is called the unorganized borough.
- 40:21It's technically not actually a borough.
- 40:23It's just leftover leftover is not part of the named boroughs, and it's made up what are made
- 40:29up of what are called census areas.
- 40:32So they they governments and or the unorganized boroughs doesn't really operate the same way as
- 40:38they do in organized boroughs, which are their county equivalent.
- 40:43They do function similarly similarly to counties.
- 40:47And then you've got Louisiana, which has parishes, and that's owed to Louisiana's French
- 40:54past, which still influences a lot of the state's political and judicial system today.
- 41:00They have police juries instead of county commissions.
- 41:04Again, though, similar functions, but they are not exactly the same.
- 41:09They are not counties.
- 41:10They are called parishes.
- 41:12And then you also have 41 independent cities, which are basically a county level
- 41:18administrative unit.
- 41:20Vast majority of these are in Virginia, like Richmond, for example, and Chesapeake, Norfolk,
- 41:29I believe Suffolk as well.
- 41:31And a few of those cities, I have a lot of family on my mom's side, so so somewhat
- 41:37familiar with with those areas.
- 41:39But, the other non Virginia independent cities are in are Baltimore, Maryland, St.
- 41:47Louis, Missouri, and Carson City, Nevada Nevada.
- 41:51That's not to be confused with consolidated city county governments.
- 41:54Those are bit different.
- 41:56Independent cities are not located inside the county's borders.
- 41:59But city county governments, that city is still within a border.
- 42:04For example, in my home state of Florida, Jacksonville is a consolidated city county city
- 42:10county.
- 42:11It's merged with the Duval government.
- 42:14Not not city county governments consolidated city county governments don't necessarily work
- 42:18the same way everywhere, but that's just one example.
- 42:23And, additionally, here's a here's a real odd one you might not expect.
- 42:28Not every county has a government.
- 42:31Connecticut abolished county governments back in 1959 1960 or 1959, 1960, right around that
- 42:40at that time, but it still has, counties for elections and other administrative purposes.
- 42:47Rhode Island's 5 counties exist only for judicial administration purposes, and then
- 42:54Massachusetts abolished 8 of its 14 county governments between 19,972,000.
- 43:00So very curiously there, some of the counties have a government, but in in Massachusetts, but
- 43:07not in some of the other counties.
- 43:10So that to me, that's kind of weirder than just not having county governments at all, but, very
- 43:18just fascinating stuff, at least to me, in regards to those counties.
- 43:22So that does it for the random fact of the day, and that does it for today's episode.
- 43:27As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 43:30Like, comment, subscribe, share with those you know.
- 43:37Show notes have my links, like my Facebook, LinkedIn, my book, why independents rarely win
- 43:43elections and how they can become more competitive.
- 43:47Available in paperback and ebook form on Amazon and a couple of my other stuff like my
- 43:54matchmaker FM profile if you wanna be a guest on here, or you want to have me as a guest on
- 44:01your podcast.
- 44:02So that's gotta do it for today.
- 44:04Thank you so much again, and until next time.
- 44:08Take care.