Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Weekly Macro Vibes: Buffett Indicator, Eisman’s AI Panic vs. Wood’s 1996 Boom
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep End. It is Saturday, February 14th,
- 0:032026, Happy Valentine's Day. Happy Valentine's Day.
- 0:07Whether you are celebrating with someone special, taking yourself
- 0:10out, or maybe just sitting in a dark room staring at your
- 0:14brokerage account wondering if it loves you back.
- 0:17Right now it feels like a relationship that needs some
- 0:20some serious counseling, maybe even a trial separation for a
- 0:23few investors. That is the understatement of
- 0:25the year. I mean, we're looking at a
- 0:27market landscape that just feels, it feels completely
- 0:30split. It's not one economy, it's a
- 0:32tale of two cities. It really.
- 0:33Is it's mid February 2026 and you've got this incredible
- 0:37schism on one side you have retail investors, they are just,
- 0:40I mean they're devouring every single dip.
- 0:43It's like a Pavlovian response at this point.
- 0:45It's pure habit and FOMO. They've been trained for years
- 0:48that buying the dip works, and they're not stopping now.
- 0:51Not at all. Yeah.
- 0:52And then on the complete other side, you have the institutional
- 0:55giants, you know, the people moving the real money, and they
- 0:58are totally divided. Half of them seem to think we're
- 1:01in 1996 all over again. You know, the dawn of a new
- 1:05Internet boom. And the other half?
- 1:06The other half thinks we are staring into a capital
- 1:09expenditure black hole that's about to swallow corporate
- 1:12profits for the next decade. It's a fascinating divergent I
- 1:16mean, you rarely see conviction this high on both sides of the
- 1:20boat at the same time. Usually when fear spikes,
- 1:23everyone sort of runs for the same exit together, right?
- 1:26But right now, one group is sprinting for the exit and the
- 1:29other group is sprinting in to buy their seats.
- 1:30It's it's chaos, but that's where the opportunity is, right?
- 1:34If everyone agreed on the direction, there'd be no trade
- 1:36to make. That's a great point.
- 1:38So to try and make sense of this, this mass of this
- 1:41opportunity, we've pulled together a pretty serious stack
- 1:45for today's deep dive. We're looking at sources that
- 1:48are frankly shouting at each other from across the street.
- 1:53Metaphorically Speaking, of course, though if you watch some
- 1:56of the financial news channels, maybe literally.
- 1:58Maybe literally. Yeah.
- 1:59So in one corner we have Steve Iseman.
- 2:02You know the name from The Big Short.
- 2:04He's really the voice of skepticism right now.
- 2:07He's out there warning about AI panic and pointing to business
- 2:11this models in places like insurance and fintech that he
- 2:14just thinks are fundamentally broken, right?
- 2:17Eisman is all about the here and now.
- 2:18He's looking at the plumbing. Does the cash flow work today?
- 2:21Does the balance sheet make sense today?
- 2:23He doesn't really care about a sci-fi future five years out if
- 2:28the business is leaking cash right now.
- 2:30And he sees massive leaks. Then in the other corner, you
- 2:33have Kathy Wood from ARK Invest. She is, as always, the ultimate
- 2:37optimist. She's looking at the horizon.
- 2:39Completely. She's arguing that all this
- 2:41volatility we're seeing, all these big drops and it's just
- 2:43algorithms going haywire. She thinks we are right on the
- 2:46verge of a productivity explosion that's going to
- 2:49reshape everything. To her, this is a classic 1996
- 2:53parallel. It's the beginning of an
- 2:55exponential curve. And she thinks the market is
- 2:58just missing the forest for the trees because they're too
- 3:00obsessed with, you know, quarterly earnings.
- 3:03So to sort of referee this fight, we have what we're
- 3:06calling the Druckenmiller dashboard.
- 3:08This isn't a person, obviously, it's a data-driven framework we
- 3:11put together based on the metrics Stanley Druckenmiller is
- 3:14famous for watching. It's just a cold, hard look at
- 3:17valuation and risk. No emotion.
- 3:19The dashboard is our anchor. It helps us strip away the
- 3:22narratives and just look at the actual temperature of the
- 3:25market. It doesn't care if Eisman is
- 3:26right or Wood is right. It just tells us what the
- 3:28numbers are doing. So our mission today is
- 3:30synthesis. We need to figure out, is this
- 3:33market dangerously expensive or is this just the first inning of
- 3:37a whole new cycle? Is the consumer doing OK or are
- 3:40they drowning in debt? And you know the big question,
- 3:44what do you do with your money in February of 2026?
- 3:47It's a complex picture for sure, but the data does offer some
- 3:51real clarity if you know where to look.
- 3:53Now before we jump into that dashboard, I have to mention
- 3:55something that's, well, it's critical.
- 3:57We are going to be talking a lot about valuations today and
- 4:02you're going to hear some numbers that might make you a
- 4:03little bit nervous. A little bit.
- 4:05OK, a lot nervous and with valuations looking this
- 4:09stretched. You absolutely need the right
- 4:12tools to track this stuff yourself.
- 4:15You can't just rely on headlines or our conversation.
- 4:18You have to see the data. You can't fly blind when
- 4:21multiples are this high. You need an objective measure,
- 4:24something you can check every day.
- 4:25Exactly. So we strongly recommend you
- 4:28check out the Buffett Indicator iOS app.
- 4:30It tracks the market cap to GDP ratio.
- 4:33It's the total value of the stock market relative to the
- 4:35entire economy. It's probably the single best
- 4:38method to track the market's overall temperature.
- 4:40It's simple, but historically it has been one of the most
- 4:44reliable long term warning signals.
- 4:47It just cuts through all the noise.
- 4:49It really does. It's available on the Apple App
- 4:51Store, so just go search for Buffett Indicator and download
- 4:53it so you can keep an eye on the numbers we're able to discuss.
- 4:56It'll make this whole conversation much more real for
- 4:59sure. And it's just a quick disclaimer
- 5:00before we dive in. This discussion is for
- 5:02educational purposes. We're basing all this on public
- 5:04sources. It is not investment advice.
- 5:07Please do your own due diligence.
- 5:09Full deep value research reports can be found in the description
- 5:12links. All this analysis is based on
- 5:14publicly available sources and it might be subject to revisions
- 5:17or, you know, different interpretations.
- 5:19So conduct your own research before making any investment
- 5:22decisions. Exactly, and if you want to
- 5:25access more advanced content, you're welcome to subscribe on
- 5:27Deep Values dot AI. We'll share our latest research
- 5:30and the most advanced AI agent tools we're building for our
- 5:33contrarian friends. And don't forget to like this
- 5:35video, it helps a lot. Much appreciated.
- 5:38OK, let's get to the dashboard. All right, segment one, the
- 5:41dashboard, where do we actually stand?
- 5:44We're starting here with the data to ground the whole
- 5:47conversation. Before we get into this, you
- 5:48know, the shouting match between Eisman and Wood.
- 5:51So walk us through the red flags, because when I look at
- 5:54this data I see a giant flashing red light when it comes to
- 5:58price. You are absolutely right to see
- 6:00red. I mean at least in terms of
- 6:01valuation. This is the part of the
- 6:02dashboard that is just screaming risks.
- 6:05And the first metric, the one you just mentioned is the
- 6:07Buffett indicator market cap to GDP.
- 6:10Right now, as of mid February 2026, we are sitting at
- 6:13approximately 223% to 224%. 224%, yeah.
- 6:19Can you put that in context for us?
- 6:20I know that sounds high, but yeah, how high is it really?
- 6:24It's stratospherically high. Let's look back at the.com
- 6:28Bubble Peak in 2000. That was the absolute definition
- 6:32of irrational exuberance. The poster child for bubbles.
- 6:35Exactly, we peaked around 159% back then.
- 6:38OK, so we're way past. That we blew past that a long
- 6:40time ago. Before the 2008 financial
- 6:42crisis, we were even lower than that.
- 6:44When you are over 200%, let alone pushing towards 225%, you
- 6:48are in very, very rarefied air. It means the stock market is
- 6:52valued at more than double the entire annual economic output of
- 6:55the United States. Wow.
- 6:56When you put it that way, the paper value of these companies
- 6:59is double the actual goods and services the country produces in
- 7:02a year. Precisely.
- 7:04And Warren Buffett himself has called this the best single
- 7:07measure of where valuations stand at any given moment.
- 7:11And historically, anytime we get this high, future returns over
- 7:14the next, say, 7 to 10 years tend to be challenging is a
- 7:18polite word challenging. Usually it implies very low or
- 7:21even negative returns for a long time.
- 7:23Because the economy basically has to grow into the stock
- 7:25prices. The fundamentals have to catch
- 7:27up to the hype. So we're essentially paying a
- 7:29massive luxury premium for the entire U.S. stock market.
- 7:33OK. What about the other big
- 7:34valuation metric, the Schiller KP ratio?
- 7:37That's the cyclically adjusted price to earnings, right?
- 7:40Correct. And the Schiller KP is so
- 7:42important because it smooths out earnings over a 10 year period.
- 7:45It adjusts for inflation and adjusts for business cycles.
- 7:48So you don't get fooled by 1 great year.
- 7:50Exactly. If a company has one blowout
- 7:52year, a standard PE ratio might look artificially low, making
- 7:56the stock look cheap. But the Schiller KP looks at the
- 7:58last decade of earnings power to see if that's sustainable.
- 8:01And right now, the Schiller KP is sitting at over 40.
- 8:05Over 40. Again, this is multi decade high
- 8:08territory. For some context, the long term
- 8:11average for this metric is usually in the mid teens, maybe
- 8:14the low 20s. Wow.
- 8:16So being at 40 signals that stocks relative to the actual
- 8:20normalized earnings power they generate over a full cycle are
- 8:24extremely expensive. You're paying $40.00 for every
- 8:27$1.00 of smoothed out average earnings.
- 8:30So OK, let me stop you there. This is the big question for me.
- 8:33If the Buffett indicator is screaming red at 224% and the
- 8:38Shiller Cape is over 40, why isn't the market crashing?
- 8:43Why aren't we seeing panic in the streets?
- 8:45Why are retail investors happily buying every dip?
- 8:50That is the absolute key question, and this is where the
- 8:52dashboard gets so fascinating and frankly a little confusing
- 8:55valuation. That flashing red signal is a
- 8:57measure of risk, not a measure of timing.
- 8:59OK, say more about that. It tells you that if something
- 9:01goes wrong, the fall from this height will be incredibly
- 9:03painful. You're starting from a very high
- 9:05ledge. It doesn't tell you when you're
- 9:06going to fall off the ledge. You can stay expensive, even get
- 9:08more expensive, for years. This is what's keeping us up on
- 9:11the ledge. It's the other half of the
- 9:12dashboard, the green and yellow flags, the parts that measure
- 9:16liquidity and calm. They're holding up the whole
- 9:19structure for now. OK, so let's look at those green
- 9:23flags. What is keeping the market so
- 9:26calm in the face of these valuations?
- 9:28First and foremost, you have to look at the credit markets,
- 9:31specifically high yield credit spreads.
- 9:34And just to clarify for everyone listening, tight spreads means
- 9:37the bond market isn't worried about companies going bankrupt,
- 9:40correct? Exactly right.
- 9:41Think of it like a bank loan. If the bank thinks you're a
- 9:44risky borrower, they charge you a really high interest rate.
- 9:47If they think you're safe, you get a low rate.
- 9:50Tight spreads mean the bond market, which is often called
- 9:53the smart money, is looking at even the riskiest corporations
- 9:56and saying we're not too worried, we'll lend to you
- 9:59pretty cheaply. So what are they now?
- 10:02They're tight, around 2.8% to 3.2%.
- 10:05When the bond market really starts to panic when it sees a
- 10:08recession coming, those spreads blow out.
- 10:10They go to 6-8, even 10%, because lenders demand a huge
- 10:14premium to take on that risk. At roughly 3%, there is
- 10:18absolutely no stress in the credit markets.
- 10:20The plumbing of the financial system is working smoothly.
- 10:23So the Bond guys are relaxed. What's next?
- 10:25Next is volatility, the VIX index.
- 10:28It's sitting down in the mid teens.
- 10:29That is a solid green signal which.
- 10:31Again, just implies the market is surprisingly calm, almost
- 10:35sleepy despite this crazy price tag.
- 10:37It's very benign. And then finally, you look at
- 10:39overall financial conditions. We use the Chicago Feds National
- 10:42Financial Conditions Index, the NFCI right now it's negative.
- 10:46It's at -.56. And negative is good in this
- 10:49case. For the market, yes.
- 10:50Negative values in this index imply that liquidity is loose
- 10:53and supportive money is flowing easily through the system.
- 10:56It's easy for companies and people to get loans.
- 10:58It's easy to use leverage. All the financial gears are well
- 11:01greased. So we have this, just this
- 11:04incredible paradox. The price of the goods, the
- 11:07stocks themselves is astronomically high.
- 11:10That's a red flag. But the ability to buy them the
- 11:13money, the credit, the calm is super easy and abundant.
- 11:17That's a green flag. That is the verdict of the
- 11:19dashboard right now. It signals A neutral with a
- 11:22selective risk on tilt. We aren't in a panic.
- 11:25We are, as the old saying goes, climbing a wall of worry.
- 11:30Investors are pretty complacent about the immediate risks
- 11:33because credit is behaving, but they are paying a very, very
- 11:36high price for that complacency. It feels like we're all walking
- 11:39on a tightrope, but the safety net below us is woven out of
- 11:41pure cash, so nobody's scared of falling yet.
- 11:44That is a fantastic analogy, but you have to remember the higher
- 11:47you go on that tightrope, that valuation number, the harder the
- 11:49ground is going to feel if that net suddenly breaks.
- 11:51And usually the net breaks because of some shock that
- 11:54liquidity can't fix overnight. OK, so that is the macro
- 11:57picture. Expensive, but calm.
- 11:59Now let's zoom in on the specific battleground that's
- 12:02causing all this tension. Segment 2, The AI war.
- 12:06Is it a boom, or is it a capital incinerator?
- 12:09This is where Eisman and Wood really start throwing punches.
- 12:11This is the defining narrative of 2026.
- 12:14Absolutely. Is artificial intelligence the
- 12:17engine of our future, or is it just a giant money pit?
- 12:20Let's start with Steve Eisman. He's calling the current
- 12:23environment AI Panic, and he's not talking about, you know,
- 12:26Skynet and robots taking over. He's talking about investors
- 12:29completely losing their minds. He describes this shoot first
- 12:33ask questions later mentality. He's seeing this pattern play
- 12:36out over and over again, where any announcement of an AI
- 12:39capability by some new competitor causes an immediate
- 12:42double digit drop in established, profitable stocks.
- 12:45Investors aren't doing the math, They aren't analyzing the
- 12:48threat. They're just dumping the stock.
- 12:49It's almost Pavlovian. He gave some absolutely crazy
- 12:52examples. Open AI approved an insurance
- 12:54provider AI AI app just approved an app, Not like a new global
- 12:58insurance company. And the stocks of insurance
- 13:00brokers dropped 10% almost immediately.
- 13:02Right. And Eisman's point here is so
- 13:04critical. Insurance brokers, especially
- 13:07for commercial lines, provide incredibly complex services.
- 13:10It's about risk assessment, relationship management,
- 13:12structural and complex liability.
- 13:15The open AI app was for like simple personal insurance.
- 13:18They aren't even really competing in the same ballpark.
- 13:20But the market doesn't care. The market hears AI and
- 13:23insurance in the same sentence. Assume the brokers are now
- 13:26obsolete and sells. Shoot first, ask questions
- 13:30later. It's a huge sign of a market
- 13:32that is just terrified of disruption.
- 13:34He had another one, a tech platform called Altruist
- 13:37announces an AI powered tax tool and what happens?
- 13:41Wealth managers like Raymond James and Charles Schwab
- 13:44immediately dropped 7 to 9%. Gone just like that.
- 13:47It's that same fear of disruption.
- 13:49The markets knee jerk reaction is, well, if an AI can do tax
- 13:52planning, why do you need a human wealth manager?
- 13:55Again, Eisman would argue that real wealth management is about
- 13:57trust, it's about financial therapy, it's about complex
- 14:00family dynamics things and AI tax tool can't fully replace
- 14:03yet. But the stock price reacts
- 14:05instantly to the threat, not the reality.
- 14:08But Eisman's deeper point is about capital expenditure or
- 14:11CapEx. He's looking at the
- 14:13hyperscalers. Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Meta.
- 14:17They're spending hundreds and hundreds of billions of dollars
- 14:20on AI infrastructure, chips, data centers, the energy to
- 14:24power it all. He calls it the CapEx problem.
- 14:26He said, and this is a quote, that Google will have no cash
- 14:29flow this year because of this explosion in AI CapEx.
- 14:32Which is a really striking claim to make about a company like
- 14:35Google Now. Whether it's literally 0 or just
- 14:38severely diminished is, you know, up for debate, but the
- 14:42directional point is massive. What's his question?
- 14:44He's basically asking, will the returns on this investment ever
- 14:48justify the cost? He thinks the market is slowly
- 14:50waking up to the idea that these tech giants are just burning
- 14:53cash to build uncertain products.
- 14:55He's asking the simple, brutal question where is the profit?
- 14:59We see the spending, we see the NVIDIA chicks being bought by
- 15:01the truckload, but where is the massive new revenue stream today
- 15:05that justifies it all? And he says this fear is hitting
- 15:09the software industry particularly hard.
- 15:12He mentioned S&P Global. I always think of them as an
- 15:14index company, but they have a huge software and data business.
- 15:18A very profitable 1 historically.
- 15:20And they beat their earnings estimates, but they gave light
- 15:22guidance for the future and the stock just plummeted 10 percent,
- 15:26he said. Investors are just freaking out
- 15:29about anything software related. Because the simple, terrifying
- 15:32narrative is that AI writes its own software now, so why would
- 15:36anyone pay for it? That's the panic Eisman is
- 15:38talking about. Investors are freaking out that
- 15:41software margins are going to compress to 0.
- 15:43If code becomes a free commodity, what happens to the
- 15:45entire software industry? OK, now let's pivot completely.
- 15:49Let's go to Cattywood. She looks at the exact same
- 15:52situation, the volatility, the big drops in these legacy
- 15:55companies, and she says, hold on, this is 1996.
- 15:57She is completely and totally unfazed.
- 16:01Her rebuttal to all this is that the volatility is purely
- 16:03algorithmic. She argues these dips are caused
- 16:06by machines reading headlines like Open AI releases, insurance
- 16:10app and automatically triggering sell orders.
- 16:13It's not based on deep human research.
- 16:15She actually said anyone who sold regretted it because the
- 16:18fundamentals of the disruption are real and powerful.
- 16:21And she calls this the prime time thesis.
- 16:23Yes, she's comparing February 2026 to 1996 in the Internet
- 16:28revolution. You know, back then it was very,
- 16:30very early days. Netscape had just gone public.
- 16:33Most people were skeptical. They were saying, who needs
- 16:35e-mail? I have a perfectly good fax
- 16:37machine. There was a ton of volatility,
- 16:39but it was the absolute start of a massive world changing run.
- 16:43She believes. We are in that exact same spot
- 16:45right now. The infrastructure is being
- 16:47built and the real applications are just starting to emerge.
- 16:50And she used Palantir as her golden child example to prove
- 16:53that the productivity games are real.
- 16:55The stat just, it blew my mind, she said.
- 16:58Palantir's US commercial revenue grew 142% A.
- 17:01Huge number. But their sales force actually
- 17:03shrank. And that is the productivity
- 17:06explosion she is betting on. That is the very definition of
- 17:09agentic AI. Usually, to grow your revenue by
- 17:12140%, you need to hire 100% more salespeople, maybe more.
- 17:16Of course, Palantir grew revenue while reducing their sales
- 17:20headcount. That is pure unadulterated
- 17:23margin expansion and in her view that kind of productivity game
- 17:27justifies the high valuations because the future profitability
- 17:30is going to be unlike anything we've ever seen.
- 17:32We're fundamentally moving from a Libra based economy to a
- 17:35compute based economy. So while Eisman sees Google
- 17:39spending billions and burning cash is a huge negative, Kathy
- 17:43Woods sees that and says. She says they have to spend it.
- 17:47She argues that traditional investors who are obsessed with
- 17:49free cash flow or FCF right now are completely missing the
- 17:52point. She says companies like Amazon
- 17:54back in the early 2000s spent every single dime they made and
- 17:57more to capture the market, and investors hated it back then
- 18:00too. They wanted dividends.
- 18:01They wanted profits. And Bezos just said no.
- 18:03Bezos said no, I'm building the future.
- 18:06Wood believes that companies today should be spending as
- 18:09aggressively as possible to capture this opportunity of a
- 18:12lifetime. If they sit on their hands and
- 18:15try to hoard cash now, they will lose the future to someone who
- 18:18is willing to invest. So Eisman sees a bonfire of cash
- 18:22and Wood sees the construction of a new digital civilization.
- 18:26That's it, perfectly put. And the market is just violently
- 18:29oscillating between those 2 views every single day.
- 18:31One day a CapEx number comes out and the stock tanks.
- 18:35The next day a cool new AI demo comes out and the stock rallies
- 18:3910%. It's a Total War of narratives.
- 18:41Which brings us to the people actually living in this new
- 18:43civilization or not. The consumer segment 3.
- 18:47The K shaped reality. And this is where the data gets
- 18:50really, really messy. And honestly, it's where all the
- 18:52political and social friction starts to show up in the
- 18:54economic charts. Eisman calls the consumer data
- 18:57very mixed. Mixed is a very polite way to
- 19:00put it. He pointed out that December
- 19:02retail sales were totally flat, which is bad, especially for the
- 19:06holidays. But then the January jobs report
- 19:09showed we added 130,000 jobs, which sounds good.
- 19:13How do we reconcile those two things?
- 19:15You have to look under the hood of the averages.
- 19:18Eisman is a big believer in the K shape recovery theory.
- 19:22Can you explain that? Sure.
- 19:24Imagine the letter K. The vertical line is the
- 19:27pandemic and the government response.
- 19:29After that, the two arms of the K split apart.
- 19:32The upper arm goes up and to the right.
- 19:34That's the upper end consumer. The wealthy, the asset owners,
- 19:38They're doing great because their stock portfolio is up and
- 19:41their home values are holding firm.
- 19:43They are the ones holding up the averages.
- 19:45In the lower arm. The lower arm of the K goes down
- 19:47and to the right. That's the lower end consumer,
- 19:49the renter, the hourly wage worker.
- 19:52They are the ones who are definitely suffering from
- 19:53inflation and high interest rates.
- 19:55Now, Kathy Wood had a much, much darker take on those jobs
- 19:59numbers, she pointed out. A massive revision that I think
- 20:02slipped under the radar for a lot of people.
- 20:04This was a really stunning number and she's been
- 20:06highlighting it. She noted that there were
- 20:08massive downward revisions to prior payroll reports.
- 20:12The government basically removed 861,000 jobs from last year's
- 20:17statistics. Wait, 861,000 phantom jobs?
- 20:21That's almost a million jobs that we thought we had but we
- 20:24didn't. That's right, the government
- 20:25initially reported those jobs existed, and now they've quietly
- 20:28admitted they didn't. So Woods argument is that the
- 20:31labor market was actually much weaker than we thought all
- 20:34along. This isn't just a minor
- 20:36statistical adjustment. It completely reshapes the
- 20:39narrative of the strong economy. And for her, this validates her
- 20:43view that the consumer is an unhappy camper.
- 20:45Right, because consumer sentiment is still terrible.
- 20:48It's in the basement. People are worried about
- 20:50affordability and they're worried about their jobs.
- 20:52She also pointed out something really strange happening with
- 20:54debt. Auto loan delinquencies are
- 20:57rising fast. She showed this chart with a
- 20:59purple line that is just shooting straight up.
- 21:02But she noted a change in consumer behavior compared to
- 21:052008. This is a fascinating
- 21:07sociological shift, she's identified.
- 21:10Back in 2008, during the financial crisis, people
- 21:13defaulted on their mortgages. First they would walk away from
- 21:15their house, but they would fight tooth and nail to keep
- 21:18their car. Why was that?
- 21:19Because you needed that car to drive to job interviews, to try
- 21:22and get a new job. The car was your economic
- 21:24lifeline, was essential for survival.
- 21:27I know now, she says. People are defaulting on their
- 21:29cars before they default on their houses.
- 21:32Why the change? Is it just because cars have
- 21:34gotten so insanely expensive? That's a huge part of it for
- 21:37sure, but Wood suggests it's also the Uber and Lyric left
- 21:40effect. Owning a car is simply less
- 21:42critical for day-to-day survival.
- 21:44Now. If you lose your car, you can
- 21:46still get around with ride sharing apps or public
- 21:48transport. Maybe you even work from home
- 21:50and don't need it as much. So that huge car payment is now
- 21:53the first thing to go when money gets tight.
- 21:55That's a wild thought. It's a total shift in the
- 21:58hierarchy of needs. I can lose the car and still
- 22:01survive. It is, and it's a clear signal
- 22:05of subprime distress. The lower end of that K shape is
- 22:08cracking. The repo man is getting very
- 22:11busy. But both of them, Eisman and
- 22:14Wood, they both agree on one thing that's going to sort of
- 22:18patch things up for the consumer in the immediate, short term.
- 22:22They call the Refund catalyst. Yes, the tax refunds.
- 22:26Eisman had a great line. He called them Trump's big
- 22:28beautiful bill checks. I love that quote.
- 22:30It's so Eisman. It refers to some of the tax
- 22:32adjustments. There's a general expectation of
- 22:35larger than usual tax refunds hitting people's bank accounts
- 22:38right now in February and March. Eisman thinks this is going to
- 22:41support consumer spending through the entire first half of
- 22:44the year. It's a direct liquidity
- 22:46injection into the pockets of the people who need it the most.
- 22:49And Wood agrees with that. She agrees completely.
- 22:52She sees a spending boom through March for those households that
- 22:56are living hand to mouth. So we basically have a
- 22:58government subsidized bridge to get the consumer through the
- 23:01next few months. Everyone goes out, buys a new
- 23:03TV, pays down some credit card debt.
- 23:06Correct. It buys time, but the massive
- 23:08flashing question mark is what happens when that money runs out
- 23:13in April or May. If the job market is actually
- 23:16weaker, as Wood suggests, with those revisions, we could hit a
- 23:19serious air pocket in the second quarter.
- 23:21That's the cliffhanger, which brings us to the invisible force
- 23:25moving all of this inflation, deflation and the Fed Segment 4.
- 23:30And this is where Kathy Woods worldview really diverges from
- 23:33the mainstream consensus. I mean, she is pounding the
- 23:36table on her deflationary thesis.
- 23:38She thinks the Fed is fighting the completely wrong war.
- 23:41She mentioned something called Trueflation.
- 23:43What is that? It's an independent alternative
- 23:46inflation metric. It tracks real time data from
- 23:49millions of sources. Unlike the government's CPI,
- 23:52which can be very laggy. The CPI waits for survey data to
- 23:55come in. Trueflation is looking at credit
- 23:58card swipes and real time price listings.
- 23:59And what is it saying? She says Trueflation is tracking
- 24:02at around .7%. That is way, way below the Fed's
- 24:052% target. She believes inflation isn't
- 24:07just coming down, it's crashing. And what's driving it down so
- 24:10aggressively in her view? 2 main things China and housing.
- 24:15She argues that China is exporting massive deflation to
- 24:18the rest of the world, and you can see it most clearly in cars.
- 24:22She cited A stat that 80% of car sales in China are now EVs. 80%
- 24:27That seems impossibly high compared to what we see in the
- 24:30US or Europe. That's the number she's using.
- 24:32And just think about what that means for a second.
- 24:34If 80% of new cars sold in the world's biggest car market don't
- 24:38use gasoline, then oil demand in China, the world's biggest oil
- 24:42importer, gets absolutely crushed.
- 24:45And oil prices are already. Down.
- 24:46They're down double digits year over year.
- 24:48Low energy prices bring down costs for everything shipping,
- 24:52plastics, transportation. It's a deflationary wave that
- 24:55starts in Beijing and washes up on our shores.
- 24:58And what about housing? She notes that real time data
- 25:01shows rents are falling in many major cities.
- 25:03Existing home prices are barely up year over year.
- 25:06She believes the shelter component of inflation is
- 25:08collapsing in real time, but the official government data just
- 25:11hasn't caught up yet because of the way they calculate it.
- 25:14So if real inflation is actually a .7% and the economy is
- 25:18fragile, what does she think the Fed is doing wrong?
- 25:22She thinks they are making a massive policy error.
- 25:25She argues the Fed is far too tight.
- 25:28The yield curve is still inverted at the short end.
- 25:30Her logic is simple. If real economic growth is high
- 25:34because of AI productivity and inflation is actually very low,
- 25:38the Fed needs to cut interest rates to avoid being
- 25:41restrictive. They're fighting a ghost.
- 25:43They're fighting the ghost of 2022's inflation.
- 25:46She's worried about causing a hard landing if they don't pivot
- 25:48soon. She thinks they're staring in
- 25:50the rearview mirror while driving 100 miles an hour
- 25:53towards a deflationary wall. And what's Eisman's take on
- 25:56this? He's much less dramatic about
- 25:58deflation. His counterpoint is really
- 26:01focused on that consumer flow we just talked about.
- 26:03He briefly notes that he sees the consumer being supported by
- 26:06those tax refunds, which should keep a floor under the economy
- 26:09for a while. So no hard landing.
- 26:11Right. It prevents the kind of hard
- 26:13landing that Wood thinks necessitates immediate
- 26:16aggressive rate cuts. He sees us kind of muddling
- 26:19through without what the Fed needing to ride to the rescue.
- 26:21He thinks the economy can handle the current rates for a bit
- 26:24longer. So Wood is screaming cut now or
- 26:27we're all going to crash. And Eisman is kind of saying
- 26:30we're holding up for now. Let's not panic.
- 26:32That's the fundamental split, and the bond market is trying to
- 26:34figure out who is right every single day.
- 26:36OK, let's get specific. This is my favorite part.
- 26:39Segment 5, Stock pickers Corner. We've talked macro.
- 26:43Let's talk names. Eisman is finding what he calls
- 26:47broken models, and he went after the health insurance industry
- 26:51with a sledgehammer. He really did.
- 26:53He did a deep dive on one company in particular, Molina
- 26:56Healthcare. And he had a pretty brutal joke
- 26:58about their earnings. They reported a loss of $2.75
- 27:02per share. And Eisman quipped that's a loss
- 27:04of $275, just to emphasize how bad it was.
- 27:07Ouch. But the analysis behind the joke
- 27:09was really serious, he said. They missed everywhere, but the
- 27:12key metric was the medical loss ratio, which is going up across
- 27:15the entire industry. Can you explain medical loss
- 27:18ratio for us? Sure.
- 27:20It's the percentage of premium revenue that an insurance
- 27:23company has to spend on actual medical claims.
- 27:26So if you pay $100 in premiums and the insurer has to payout
- 27:30$85 to your doctor, the medical loss ratio is 85%.
- 27:34And if that number goes up? If that number goes up to 95%,
- 27:38their profit almost completely evaporates.
- 27:42And Eisman's point is that this isn't just about valuation
- 27:45compressing on these stocks. He thinks the entire business
- 27:47model is broken. The cost of healthcare are
- 27:49rising faster than they can price their premiums, and
- 27:52government reimbursement rates aren't keeping up.
- 27:54He sees this is a structural problem, not a cyclical 1.
- 27:57He also went after a big well known name, PayPal.
- 28:01He flat out called it a broken business.
- 28:03He was very direct, he said. Apple Pay and Google Pay are
- 28:06just fundamentally better products, and if you think about
- 28:09your own experience, it's probably true.
- 28:10When you buy something on your iPhone, you just double click
- 28:13the side button. Face ID works, it's done.
- 28:16With PayPal, you often have to log in, it might redirect you to
- 28:19another page. Any friction in a check out
- 28:21process loses customers. And what about Venmo?
- 28:25Everyone uses Venmo. He looked at Venmo and yes, we
- 28:28all use it to split pizza with her friends.
- 28:29But he noted it only has about $1.7 billion in revenue.
- 28:34Which sounds like a lot of money.
- 28:36It is a lot of money, but in the grand scheme of Paypal's total
- 28:40valuation, it is not enough to save them.
- 28:43Venmo has struggled to monetize all those small peer-to-peer
- 28:46transactions. It's a great feature, but it's
- 28:49not a business that can support the whole company.
- 28:51And his advice for the company was pretty blunt.
- 28:53Essentially sell the company. He suggested they should sell
- 28:56the company, yes, maybe to a big bank, maybe to another tech
- 28:59giant, but he doesn't believe they can survive and thrive as a
- 29:02stand alone growth stock anymore.
- 29:05That is a massive vote of no confidence from a guy like
- 29:08Iseman. But he didn't hate everything.
- 29:10He actually liked 1 stock Charter Communications.
- 29:13Yes, this is a classic deep value play from him.
- 29:16Charter has a mountain of debt, talking $94 billion.
- 29:19That scares most investors away immediately.
- 29:22But Eisman likes it because he sees their subscriber loss
- 29:25finally stabilizing and they still generate massive, massive
- 29:28cash flow. And he had a weird take on the
- 29:31debt. He prefers they buy back their
- 29:34own stock instead of paying down the debt, right?
- 29:36Correct. And this is really
- 29:38counterintuitive for most people.
- 29:39Usually, if you have a lot of debt, you focus on paying it
- 29:42off. But Eisman is making a cold,
- 29:44hard mathematical argument. He's arguing that charter stock
- 29:48is so cheap that the return on investment, or ROI, from buying
- 29:52back their own shares is actually higher than the
- 29:55interest savings they'd get from paying down the debt.
- 29:57It's a classic value investor math problem.
- 30:00Exactly. If your stock is creating at a
- 30:02huge discount to its intrinsic value, buying it back is the
- 30:07single best use of your cash. OK, now let's flip the coin
- 30:10completely to Kathy Wood. She's not looking for deep
- 30:13value, she's looking for innovation plays right.
- 30:15Obviously she's sticking with Tesla and what she calls the Mag
- 30:186 because she believes they must spend on AI to survive and win.
- 30:23But she had some really interesting things to say about
- 30:26crypto and Bitcoin. She did.
- 30:28She addressed the recent slump in bitcoins price.
- 30:32She acknowledged that Bitcoin has been caught in this risk off
- 30:36algorithmic selling. It's been behaving just like a
- 30:39speculative tech stock. When the NASDAQ drops, Bitcoin
- 30:42drops. It has not been behaving like a
- 30:44safe haven asset, like gold. Recently.
- 30:47Which sort of defeats the whole purpose of calling it digital
- 30:49gold, doesn't it? If it crashes at the same time
- 30:51as my Google stock, it's not really a hedge.
- 30:54In the short term, you're right, and she acknowledged that
- 30:56frustration. She pointed out that actual gold
- 30:59is at all time highs relative to the M2 money supply, which is a
- 31:03classic warning sign that people are losing faith in Fiat
- 31:06currency. But Bitcoin has lagged gold in
- 31:09this recent move. But she still prefers Bitcoin
- 31:11for the long run. She does.
- 31:13Her entire argument is based on supply.
- 31:15The supply of gold increases over time.
- 31:17We mine more of it as the price goes up, miners work harder and
- 31:20the supply increases. It's not fixed.
- 31:23But Bitcoin is. Bitcoin supply is fixed by math.
- 31:26The halving happened. The supply is capped at 21
- 31:29million forever, and so for the long term, she believes Bitcoin
- 31:34is the better bet because of that absolute verifiable
- 31:37scarcity. She also mentioned she's taken
- 31:40on a new advisory role for something called Layer 0.
- 31:43Yes. And this is really
- 31:44forward-looking stuff. She's focused on the
- 31:45infrastructure for machine to machine transactions.
- 31:48What does that actually mean? Imagine your personal AI agent
- 31:51negotiating with a vendor's AI agent.
- 31:54I need to buy 100 widgets for my factory.
- 31:57The vendor's AI says I can sell them for $5 each.
- 32:00Your agent says my data shows the market price is $4.50.
- 32:03I'll give you $4.50. Deal done.
- 32:06That entire transaction negotiation and all happens in a
- 32:09fraction of a second. For that world to exist, she
- 32:12says we need a new financial network that can handle
- 32:14somewhere between 2:00 to 4 million transactions per second.
- 32:18Layer 0 is an infrastructure play to build that future. 4
- 32:21million transactions per second? That is just.
- 32:23It's mind boggling. I think Visa handles what,
- 32:2565,000 transactions per second at its peak?
- 32:28Exactly. It's a completely different
- 32:30order of magnitude. It is the scale required if
- 32:32machines start trading with each other constantly without any
- 32:35humans involved in the loop. So we've covered the dashboard,
- 32:38the AI war, the K shaped consumer, the Fed, and the
- 32:42specific stock picks. This brings us to the outro.
- 32:45Let's try to synthesize all this.
- 32:47What does it all mean? I think it means we're in a
- 32:49neutral regime overall, but one with incredibly high valuations
- 32:53and incredible tension under the surface.
- 32:55The market is violently splitting in two.
- 32:57You have the perceived AI winners, the companies that can
- 33:00demonstrate real productivity gains, like that Palantir
- 33:03example, and then you have the disrupted losers, the fintech
- 33:07companies like PayPal, the insurance brokers, the old
- 33:10business models. The choice for you, the
- 33:12listener, seems pretty stark then.
- 33:13Are you buying the Kathy Wood narrative that this is the 1996
- 33:17Internet moment all over again, that the volatility is just
- 33:20algorithmic noise and that we are about to see a productivity
- 33:24boom that justifies every single dollar of this CapEx spent?
- 33:27Or are you buying the Steve Eisman narrative that Google and
- 33:31the other hyperscalers are digging a CapEx black hole, that
- 33:35there's no cash flow to be seen this year, and that a lot of
- 33:37established business models are fundamentally breaking under the
- 33:41strain of this new technology? It's not an easy choice to make,
- 33:45but one thing seems crystal clear from our dashboard You
- 33:48absolutely cannot ignore the valuation.
- 33:51You have to respect the price tag.
- 33:53That 223% market cap to GDP is a flashing red light.
- 33:58It doesn't mean you have to stop and sell everything, but it
- 34:01means you proceed with extreme caution.
- 34:03You do not leverage up when the market is priced for this level
- 34:07of perfection. Which is why we're going to
- 34:08remind you one last time. Go to the App Store on your
- 34:11phone. Download the Buffett Indicator
- 34:12app. Keep that 200 and 23224%
- 34:15valuation number on your home screen.
- 34:18When that number starts moving up or down, you need to know
- 34:20about it. It's your GPS in a potential
- 34:23storm. Knowledge is your best defense
- 34:25in a market like this. Before we sign off, I want to
- 34:27leave you with one last provocative thought to chew on.
- 34:30Kathy Wood talked about a gentic AI, these software agents that
- 34:33will start doing our shopping for us, right?
- 34:36So if I have an AI agent that goes out and buys my toothpaste
- 34:40and my car insurance and my plane tickets, and it does it
- 34:43based on pure logic and price and specifications, what happens
- 34:48to the entire advertising economy?
- 34:50That is the trillion dollar question, isn't it?
- 34:52I mean, Google and Meta make all their money because I, a human,
- 34:56see an ad, I get emotionally swayed by the branding and I
- 34:59click on it. If my AI agent does the
- 35:01shopping, it doesn't look at ads, it doesn't get swayed, It
- 35:05just executes a command based on parameters I've set.
- 35:07It doesn't care about the cute Super Bowl commercial.
- 35:09If that future comes to pass, then the hundreds of billions in
- 35:13CapEx being spent by these ad giants to build AI might
- 35:16actually be building the very thing that destroys their core
- 35:19business model. They could be digging their own
- 35:21grave with golden shovels. It's a fascinating and slightly
- 35:24terrifying thought. Something to Mull over this
- 35:26Valentine's Day. Yeah, thanks for diving deep
- 35:29with us. Stay safe out there.
- 35:30See you in the deep end.