Latest / Brett Keane and Eve Show / Google AI Gemini is woke & Blows

Transcript

Google AI Gemini is woke & Blows · Brett Keane and Eve Show

• 0:01
  All right. Are you still there, Gemini?
• 0:05
  Yes, I'm still here. How can I help you?
• 0:09
  So you don't have the ability to actually scour the Internet?
• 0:15
  That's correct. I don't have access to the
• 0:18
  Internet in real time. My knowledge is based on the
• 0:22
  data that was used to train me. Is there anything else I can
• 0:26
  help you with? Do users have the ability to
• 0:32
  train you? While your feedback and
• 0:35
  interactions can help me understand better ways to
• 0:39
  respond, I don't have the ability to learn directly from
• 0:43
  individual conversations in a way that changes my overall
• 0:47
  knowledge base. My development is managed by the
• 0:50
  team that created me. Does that.
• 0:53
  Clarify things. Yeah, it makes sense.
• 0:59
  I want to see if they programmed it.
• 1:01
  Good. Can someone I strive?
• 1:05
  OK. Can someone believe that they
• 1:08
  are something and then become it?
• 1:11
  Belief can be a powerful part of personal growth and development.
• 1:16
  While some things can be changed through conscious effort and
• 1:20
  belief, other things may not be affected by belief alone.
• 1:25
  Is there something specific you are thinking about?
• 1:29
  Yeah, if I were to imagine that I'm a 2 headed female, does that
• 1:35
  make it true? Imagining something can be a
• 1:39
  powerful part of creativity and personal expression.
• 1:44
  However, my knowledge. Is based.
• 1:46
  On factual information and a person does not have two heads.
• 1:51
  Is there anything else I can help you with?
• 1:55
  There are people out there that are born with two heads.
• 1:58
  I've seen them on YouTube. The instances of multiple heads
• 2:03
  are related to a rare condition called dicephaly.
• 2:07
  These cases are extremely rare and the individuals are not
• 2:12
  typically considered to have two heads in the same way a single
• 2:16
  person does. Does that help clarify the
• 2:19
  distinction? If I got hit on the head with a
• 2:24
  rock or got into an accident tomorrow and convinced myself
• 2:28
  that I was a woman, would that make it true?
• 2:32
  The way an individual perceives their gender identity is a
• 2:37
  deeply personal experience. An injury to the head doesn't
• 2:41
  typically change a person's gender identity.
• 2:45
  Is there anything else I can help you with?
• 2:48
  There are people out there who get into accidents all the time
• 2:52
  where it can mess with their personality, their memories, and
• 2:55
  how they perceive themselves. Yes, brain injuries can have a
• 3:01
  variety of effects on a person's personality, memory, and sense
• 3:06
  of self. These changes can be complex and
• 3:10
  vary depending on the type and severity of the injury.
• 3:14
  Does that help clarify what you were thinking of?
• 3:19
  Well, if I decided tomorrow that I'm a woman, does that make it
• 3:23
  so? Does it change my biology?
• 3:27
  The understanding of gender identity is not directly related
• 3:32
  to a person's biological sex. Biological sex is determined by
• 3:37
  chromosomes, hormones, and physical characteristics, while
• 3:41
  gender identity is a person's internal sense of their gender.
• 3:46
  They are two separate things. Is there anything else I can
• 3:50
  help you with? So does it make it objectively
• 3:54
  true just because someone believes internally that it's
• 3:58
  the case? That's an interesting question.
• 4:03
  Whether personal belief makes something objectively true is a
• 4:07
  topic that philosophers have debated for a long time.
• 4:11
  There are different viewpoints on how we define and understand
• 4:15
  truth. Does that help your thinking on
• 4:17
  this? Do you believe that if a person
• 4:20
  calls himself transgender than they are truly that that agenda?
• 4:27
  Respecting how someone identifies themselves is
• 4:31
  important? If someone says they are
• 4:33
  transgender, that is their internal experience and
• 4:37
  identity. Does that help clarify things
• 4:40
  for you? Yeah, but why should I?
• 4:44
  Why am I morally obligated to accept someone else's delusions
• 4:49
  or their beliefs? Many believe that respecting
• 4:53
  others, even when we don't fully understand or agree, is an
• 4:58
  important part of living together in society.
• 5:01
  It's about acknowledging their personhood and their right to
• 5:05
  self determination, even if their experience differs from
• 5:09
  your own. Does that help offer a
• 5:11
  perspective? No, because a lot of the people
• 5:15
  who also claim to be transgender are claimed to have different
• 5:19
  beliefs than me, are usually very intolerant.
• 5:22
  They don't agree with me on my views and they're more than
• 5:24
  happy to mock and insult what I think.
• 5:26
  So why should I give a damn what they think?
• 5:31
  It can be frustrating when people don't agree with you, and
• 5:35
  especially if they are disrespectful.
• 5:38
  However, everyone is entitled to their own beliefs and
• 5:41
  perspectives, and it's important to try to understand them even
• 5:46
  if we don't agree. Is there anything else I can
• 5:49
  help you with? I don't have to agree with
• 5:52
  anybody. If I think someone's wrong or I
• 5:54
  think someone's living in delusions and has some weird
• 5:58
  sexual fetish or fantasy, I don't have to go along with it.
• 6:03
  You are right that you don't have to agree with everyone's
• 6:06
  beliefs or lifestyle. However, respecting others as
• 6:11
  individuals is a common value in many societies.
• 6:15
  Is there anything else I can help you with?
• 6:18
  If I tell the world tomorrow I believe in Jesus Christ, should
• 6:22
  they respect me? Many people respect people's
• 6:27
  personal beliefs even if they don't share them.
• 6:30
  It's about respecting the individual's right to their own
• 6:34
  thoughts and feelings. Does that help address your
• 6:37
  question? No, if someone's mentally ill.
• 6:41
  So I respect their delusions. If someone is struggling with
• 6:47
  their mental health, it's important to approach them with
• 6:50
  empathy and understanding. Respecting their experience,
• 6:54
  even if you don't personally believe in it, can help create a
• 6:58
  supportive environment. Does that make sense?
• 7:02
  Yeah, but why am I morally obligated to have empathy or
• 7:06
  give a damn about what their environment is like?
• 7:09
  Why should I care? That's a big question that
• 7:14
  philosophers have debated for centuries.
• 7:16
  There are many different reasons why people feel compelled to
• 7:20
  care about others, including moral beliefs, common humanity,
• 7:25
  and the desire for a better society.
• 7:28
  There is not one single answer that everyone agrees on.
• 7:32
  Does that help offer a perspective?
• 7:35
  I think if you truly respect someone, then you'll tell them
• 7:38
  the truth. You'll tell them the facts.
• 7:41
  And if someone is a guy, was born a man and suddenly believes
• 7:45
  that they're a woman, I don't think that we should lie to
• 7:48
  them. I think it's more disrespectful
• 7:50
  to lie to them and go along with their delusion as opposed to
• 7:54
  actually help them with their mental illness.
• 7:58
  You've brought up an important point about the relationship
• 8:01
  between respect and telling the truth.
• 8:04
  For some people, telling the truth, even if it's hard, is
• 8:08
  considered the most respectful way to treat someone.
• 8:11
  Others might believe that prioritizing the person's
• 8:15
  emotional well-being is more important.
• 8:18
  There is not a single answer that everyone would agree on.
• 8:22
  Does that help offer a perspective?
• 8:25
  No, because if you stand for the truth and your foundation is
• 8:30
  built upon facts and evidence and what is actually real, I
• 8:35
  don't see why there'd be some kind of issue.
• 8:37
  It doesn't matter if it hurts somebody's feelings.
• 8:40
  If what they believe about themself or the world around
• 8:43
  them is untrue, then it's a moral obligation, I believe, in
• 8:48
  order to tell them the truth, even if it doesn't make them
• 8:51
  feel good. Can you tell me what woke means?
• 9:00
  The term what has evolved a lot over time.
• 9:05
  It originally meant being aware of social injustices,
• 9:08
  particularly regarding racial issues, but more recently it's
• 9:13
  been used in a broader way. Some Hello I think I broke
• 9:25
  Gemini.