Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / You weren't encouraged to explore in early development. Now what? Part 1.
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. The welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:21love you. Keep going.
- 0:22It is August 29th, 2024. It's 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:30Time. And tonight what I thought I
- 0:33would talk about is exploration. And mainly the question that
- 0:39comes up for people is what or how do I learn to explore if I
- 0:47didn't learn to explore when I was younger or if I learned to
- 0:52explore? But my exploration is mostly
- 0:54focused on secondary exploration.
- 0:58So it's probably important to define the terms of primary and
- 1:02secondary exploration. Primary exploration is the
- 1:07exploration you do because it provides a sense of
- 1:10meaningfulness in life. And so we might also talk about
- 1:15that as the activation of the creative self.
- 1:21We can talk about how the creative self gets inhibited and
- 1:26prevented from arising. On the one hand you have the
- 1:31barrier of fear of engaging in things, and then on the other
- 1:36end you have the the denial of death which creates this sense
- 1:43that time is unlimited and we don't have to solve it now and
- 1:53then. Depending on what your
- 1:54attachment conditioning is like, your relationship to exploration
- 1:58will be quite different. Secondary exploration is, of
- 2:05course, the pursuit of time, energy, and resources that would
- 2:11then allow you to support your life and then also allow you to
- 2:16create the opportunities for meaningful exploration.
- 2:20Secondary exploration, really, since it's so focused on our
- 2:26resources for survival, it often takes the form of not having a
- 2:32lot of meaning potential to it in our society, in our culture,
- 2:39some things are remunerated at a fantastic level and a lot of
- 2:45things are not remunerated so well.
- 2:49And there's not a correlation between a remuneration and
- 2:56meaning necessarily. So that you could be engaged in
- 3:00a secondary exploration that provides an ample amount of
- 3:04resources that you might use to engage in meaningful
- 3:09exploration. But because of the demands of
- 3:11the secondary explorations, you don't have the the personal
- 3:16resources to be able to engage in that.
- 3:19So you have energy which you can use to explore with, and you
- 3:28have to have that energy available to engage in the
- 3:31explorations that provide meaning.
- 3:34And if so much of that energy is consumed by the secondary
- 3:39exploration, it often leaves you in a position where you can't do
- 3:43the primary exploration. It's easy to get out of balance
- 3:47and the way our culture is set up, and this I think is probably
- 3:54less true in Europe. And I'm actually not so sure
- 3:58about how it is in in other cultures, but if the
- 4:13remuneration for the activities that you are able to engage in
- 4:17to provide the resources for your life are so poorly funded
- 4:23that it's very easy to get into a place where all of your energy
- 4:28is consumed just in the basic survival mode.
- 4:32This is in the US in particular because of the inequality and,
- 4:37and the way that the, the, the tax system is set up that really
- 4:41just funnels the money up the chain rather than distributing
- 4:46it. If you're lower down on the
- 4:49economic ladder, your, your time, energy and resources are
- 4:52consumed just in, in gathering the basics.
- 4:56And, you know, I would guess even half of the country is in a
- 5:00position of some scarcity in that this is a this is a
- 5:05decision that we have made as a culture to do this.
- 5:09It's quite intentional and it could be undone if we had the
- 5:16political will to do it. We just don't seem to come up
- 5:20with it. But let's talk a little bit
- 5:29about where the, the origin of the, the capacities to explore
- 5:35come from. When you're born, of course, you
- 5:41don't have language, you don't have organizations around
- 5:47communication. You're entirely dependent on the
- 5:50care that you receive. And the way that you understand
- 5:55yourself in the way that you develop the, the working model
- 5:59of yourself comes from the reflections of the caregivers
- 6:02toward you. And it starts really early,
- 6:06right away. And you know, there's studies
- 6:10that show that the first gesture that infants make or attachment
- 6:15connection happens around 42 minutes of life.
- 6:20So it takes that long to organize coming out of the, the
- 6:24birth experience. And then there's a reflexive
- 6:27smile that's generated by things that move in the visual field of
- 6:32the infant and that calling out for attention and care in the
- 6:43the way that we talk about this, we all basically start out as
- 6:47auto regulators. We're very self oriented, very
- 6:51insular because of that birth experience of coming into life
- 6:55inside the mother's womb. And then when we're expelled
- 7:01from the mother's room, expelled from the Garden of Eden, if you
- 7:05will, and where that infant that is engaged in the world, we call
- 7:12out and the world responds. But in the beginning, in that
- 7:17first few months of life, we're really oriented around
- 7:20ourselves. We have a hard time telling
- 7:23whether there's something else in the environment, and we
- 7:27regulate ourselves as an experience.
- 7:32If somebody comes reliably enough that we begin to
- 7:35recognize that they come and it's helpful to us, we reorient
- 7:39toward an external source of regulation of our experience.
- 7:46And then if that person comes reliably enough, we enter into a
- 7:50collaborative relationship with them where we express ourselves.
- 7:55They understand. They're sensitively enough
- 7:58attuned to us that they can understand what's happening.
- 8:03And then they respond to us by taking care of us in the way
- 8:07that we need. And we understand that loop as I
- 8:12make the authentic expression in of my needs, and then somebody
- 8:21understands what I'm trying to express, and then they respond
- 8:26by taking care of me. So I have the experience of
- 8:30being effective in the world, that the world recognizes me and
- 8:35responds to me. And it begins to create this
- 8:39expectation that if I express myself authentically, the world
- 8:44will respond in a way that meets my needs.
- 8:46And that's the that cycle of security.
- 8:53The caregiver sensitively enough, attunes, empathetically
- 8:58connects, understands the expression of the child, and
- 9:02they mirror that back to the child and we begin to understand
- 9:06the nature of the world. In that reflection.
- 9:09I'm feeling uncomfortable, I'm feeling angry.
- 9:12And the the caregiver reflects that back and informs us what
- 9:16that is. And then as we develop in, in
- 9:24through the different stages in the first year or till we're
- 9:29actually operating an attachment system at about 10 months and
- 9:33then actually then standing on two legs at about a year and
- 9:40beginning to move into the exploration of the environment
- 9:44that we're in. That support from the caregiver,
- 9:48that emotional regulation that comes from the caregiver is the
- 9:51thing that allows us to begin to venture out.
- 9:54So when we're still in the BLOB stage, right, the the caregiver
- 9:59puts us down and maybe we can roll over, but that's as far as
- 10:03we can get. And then we sort of creep along,
- 10:06which is sliding ourselves along.
- 10:08Maybe we can get three feet and then we get up on all fours and
- 10:13we're crawling. And that's when this process of
- 10:16the support for our exploration really begins.
- 10:20The child rolls away from the caregiver and ratchets around
- 10:25looking at the caregiver for the reassurance that they can keep
- 10:29going. And if the caregiver reassures
- 10:32them, they go further and then they'll get to the doorway and
- 10:36they'll crawl out the doorway and crawl right back in because
- 10:38they don't really have what we call object constancy.
- 10:41They don't know that we're going to be there when they come back.
- 10:45And the more reliable we are and the more reassuring we are, the
- 10:49more emotionally regulating we are for them, the further that
- 10:53they can go until they can really explore the whole house
- 10:57and then maybe even get out into the backyard or if there is one
- 11:01or go to the park. And, and it's always this going
- 11:05out and exploring and coming rushing back to the secure base
- 11:09that will then help them come back into emotional regulation.
- 11:13And the other piece that's so essential to this is the
- 11:20interest and delight in the things that we discover about
- 11:24the world and the opportunity to express it to them as fully as
- 11:28we need to. So that we feel really seen in
- 11:33our exploration, really valued in our exploration and that our
- 11:37exploration has an effect on somebody else.
- 11:45And then as we develop, what we also need from a caregiver is
- 11:49them recognizing the our capacities and moving the goal
- 11:55posts of exploration out over and over again.
- 11:59And not so far out that we can't do it, but a little bit of a
- 12:04stretch in the range of what we can do so that when we go out
- 12:09and explore something, we're going right up to the edge of
- 12:12our capacity and succeeding. It's very defeating for a child
- 12:19to have the goal posts move beyond what they can do and
- 12:23strive for the goal and not be able to reach it.
- 12:26But it's very reinforcing, very encouraging for the child to
- 12:31have the goal set within what they can manage and but a
- 12:34stretch so that they can get to it and feel that the
- 12:37accomplishment of getting to it and then coming back over and
- 12:42over again to express what they found out.
- 12:46And this is one of the, the great challenges of parenting.
- 12:53I remember teaching, I mean, I didn't intend to teach the child
- 13:03to somersault, but it happened in, in just in the play.
- 13:07And they were, they were small. I wonder how old, 3 or 4 or
- 13:12something like that. But once they did the
- 13:14somersault, once they wanted to do it again, and once they did
- 13:18it again, they wanted to do it again.
- 13:20And once they did it again, they wanted to do it again and again
- 13:24and again and again. It was so thrilling to be
- 13:28engaged in something new. And then can you, as the adult
- 13:31that's in relationship to the child, go again and delight and
- 13:36go again and delight and go 40 times and still on the 41st time
- 13:42express a sense of delight in the discovery that the child has
- 13:47of how they can move their body through space?
- 13:54I remember another friend's child would kneel on my legs.
- 14:01He would come right into my face, maybe a half a foot away,
- 14:06and stare into my eyes until he started to laugh.
- 14:12And then he would roll back and break the atunement.
- 14:15And then he would strike me in the chest with his head as he
- 14:21was laughing. And then when he settled, he
- 14:24would come back and do it again. 20 or 30 times or 40 times, he
- 14:31would do this. And could you in each time light
- 14:35up with a sense of delight in the discovery of this?
- 14:39Of course that exercise was in this this a discovery around
- 14:44attunement and how mostly dysregulated it is to get close
- 14:49to somebody and how you can break the attunement and come
- 14:53back and regulate it, then re attune.
- 14:57These kinds of exercise for children are really important
- 15:01because it helps them learn to regulate their emotions while
- 15:05they're engaged in the process of exploration.
- 15:10And the better they get it, regulating them their emotions
- 15:12and exploration, the bigger risks that they can take in
- 15:15exploration. And the poorer you are at
- 15:18regulating your emotions and exploration, the more limited
- 15:21you are in taking the kinds of risks that you need to find out
- 15:26the things that you know. And while the child level of
- 15:30exploration is one thing, the adult level of exploration to
- 15:35really go for something that's it's hard to do and hard to find
- 15:40out, hard to understand, means that you have to have a a pretty
- 15:45brilliant capacity to regulate your own emotions where you
- 15:49won't be able to do it. And so when we talk about the
- 15:54things that happened to children that then carry out into the
- 15:58adult life, this is one of them. You don't really have the
- 16:01capacity to emotionally regulate yourself when you're taking big
- 16:07risks. So that's something that needs
- 16:11to be developed. But let's look at this this
- 16:18process again. If we start, if we all started
- 16:23auto regulators and to move into externally regulating and
- 16:28develop further, we need a reliable caregiver that comes
- 16:31over and over again. So we we shift out of auto
- 16:35regulating into external regulating.
- 16:38But what happens if nobody comes reliably?
- 16:42Nobody helps regulate, Then we really stay in this place of
- 16:48auto regulating. This makes us quite susceptible
- 16:52to substance and process addictions later in life because
- 16:57we don't develop the skill set to to emotionally regulate with
- 17:01other people or to rely on other people to help us regulate.
- 17:06In fact, because nobody came, we don't really even have the
- 17:10concept half the time that this is something that can be done in
- 17:16environments where people don't come reliably and attend with
- 17:20interest to the needs of the child.
- 17:23The child then needs to learn to adapt to a system where they
- 17:27need to attend to the needs of the parent.
- 17:31And in children who stay in the auto regulating system, what
- 17:36they learn is a system of idealization where they present
- 17:40themselves to their caregivers in a way that the caregiver
- 17:44wishes to see them. Typically includes stripping out
- 17:49anything that is negative. But what it also tends to do is
- 17:56to suppress the expression of primary exploration needs
- 18:03because we often as children, because we are unique, find
- 18:13things about the world that are fascinating, that are different
- 18:16from what our caregiver thinks or finds interesting.
- 18:21And if we don't have the sensitively enough attuned
- 18:24caregiver that then finds what we find interesting meaningful,
- 18:31they don't support it in. And, and So what you often find
- 18:36also in people that are primary, primarily auto regulators, is
- 18:41that they learn not to express their primary exploration needs
- 18:47because of the experience of them being rejected and
- 18:51sometimes even shamed by the characters.
- 18:54And so that's a, a, a secret which is unsharable for most of
- 19:00most avoidant people. But what they get good at is
- 19:08providing secondary exploration. They get good at providing of
- 19:17pursuing time, energy and resources because they have to
- 19:24present themselves in a way that the caregiver wants them to in
- 19:29order to get taken care of. They learn a very transactional
- 19:33relationship. I do this for you and then you
- 19:36do that for me. It's not collaborative in that
- 19:39sense. And because they need to gather
- 19:43resources in order to trade for the care that they want, it
- 19:48isn't that they they don't get their needs, but it's that they
- 19:51don't learn to collaborate with somebody to get their needs met.
- 19:56And because they learn a transactional system, they get
- 20:01good at pursuing things that have value in the beginning, of
- 20:08course it's. That have value to the
- 20:10caregivers, what matters to them, but because they see if
- 20:15you can gather the things that matter to other people, you can
- 20:19trade for care. They when they turn toward the
- 20:23outside world, they see things that matter to people and then
- 20:29they go after them would eat. Which, yeah, I understand this
- 20:36in the concept of adults where I want to look good, I want to
- 20:39make money so that the society appreciates me more.
- 20:43But I don't understand in the in the context of kids, what
- 20:48exactly are they doing to idolize themselves?
- 20:52Well, it depends on what is has high social value in the
- 20:57environment they grow up in. They really are a really, you
- 21:01know, kids. They look around and see what
- 21:04what gets attention, what doesn't get attention, what has
- 21:07value that what produces interest in other people, and
- 21:11then they begin to pursue that. In other people or just the
- 21:14caregiver? Well, once you move, you know, a
- 21:19child at say in our culture, four or five begins to move
- 21:22outside of the the direct sphere of the of the family system.
- 21:27If you, if you're, you know, allowed to go to school or
- 21:32preschool daycare, then you're moving into an environment which
- 21:37has a different social hierarchy, which kids are very
- 21:41sensitive to. I can give you an example of
- 21:44that which I, I thought was hilarious.
- 21:48What we, when we used to do retreats up at 2nd circle,
- 21:52people were welcome to bring their children if they wanted
- 21:56to. And on one particular treat, a
- 22:00little girl came, I think she was four years old.
- 22:06And after about 5 days at the retreat, as we were sitting down
- 22:12to do the morning meditation and then begin the class, the the,
- 22:19the, the Dharma talk and instructions for the day, she
- 22:23came up to me with the drawing of everybody sitting in the
- 22:27meditation hall, which was really beautiful.
- 22:30And she gave me an acorn. And then she went over to the
- 22:34retreat manager and gave the retreat manager an acorn.
- 22:37And she didn't give anyone else an acorn.
- 22:40So that she was able, after four or five days of the retreat, to
- 22:44recognize that I was the retreat leader and the retreat manager
- 22:47was the other person who had power.
- 22:50And so she was introducing herself to the two of us.
- 22:55Kids really can't see all of that happening and really
- 22:59respond to that. This is idolization.
- 23:03What? This is idolization, I thought.
- 23:08This is. Respect recognizing social
- 23:11status and then putting yourself in in in the the sphere of
- 23:18people who have high social status.
- 23:25Putting yourself in, is that what you said?
- 23:27Well, the she was 4 and a four year old was able to recognize
- 23:34who the two people had the most social status in terms of
- 23:39running the retreat and was able to introduce herself to both of
- 23:43them with a gift at four years old.
- 23:48This is part of the the human condition.
- 23:54I was just. Wondering what the behavior
- 23:56looks like for a kid. What does he do?
- 23:58What does he say if he or she is showing some viralization?
- 24:05How do you find out? How do you know?
- 24:10Usually the report is the kid is very well behaved and always
- 24:13does whatever they're asked to do.
- 24:18So my child is no problem. I just, I tell them to go play
- 24:24and they go play. They're polite if the family
- 24:31requires politeness, but if a family requires a kid that
- 24:34yells, then the kid is yelling it.
- 24:37It really is what the family system needs from the child.
- 24:44What did your caregivers need from you?
- 24:48And if you were in that situation of of of you, your
- 24:57authentic needs being neglected and the needs of the parents
- 25:01being superseded over them, what it is, what is it that you had
- 25:04to do in order to to stay in their good graces, which does
- 25:12not necessarily mean you had to excel.
- 25:14You could actually need it to fail and you would have done
- 25:17that as well depending on what they they demanded of you.
- 25:30Yeah, I guess mine is also politeness and just quiet shy.
- 25:37Yeah, I think my fear was also a big piece.
- 25:40So it kind of like numbs everything out.
- 25:45But it's hard to know because most of the kids these days, I
- 25:55was thinking about nephews. You know, you train the kid to
- 25:57do so many things. He learns the piano, he goes to
- 26:00football, he goes to school and gets good grades.
- 26:02It's hard to know really when this is happening.
- 26:06I was just wondering if this like signs of behavior or like
- 26:12me but just doing excelling at everything is a sign.
- 26:18Hi, so an example might be, I don't care what you do, you, you
- 26:30should do the things that really you can find enjoyable and
- 26:33interesting and you don't have to be the best, but you have to
- 26:37do your best, right? Is that making sense?
- 26:45The all the science says that you need to play a musical
- 26:48instrument when you're a child to develop the capacity for
- 26:51higher thinking. So you have to play an
- 26:54instrument because that's the developmental challenge that's
- 26:57appropriate for child. But I don't care what instrument
- 27:02you play. Play the one that you want to
- 27:03play. And you don't have to be the
- 27:05first chair of the orchestra or the band, but you have to play
- 27:08it as best you can, if that makes sense.
- 27:12So that what the child experiences in that environment
- 27:16is their interests are primary and their capacities are what
- 27:22matter. And they're being encouraged to
- 27:24be excellent, not in comparison with the the status that the
- 27:31parent is seeking, but what they're good at and what what
- 27:37represents them being accomplished so that they have
- 27:40the experience of being accomplished at something that
- 27:44they like. That matters.
- 27:56You have to be first chair and you can't do it.
- 28:00That's completely defeating for a child, not something that
- 28:04encourages them to really go explore.
- 28:07It's the that has the opposite effect.
- 28:21The people that are most challenged in exploration are
- 28:25preoccupied people of the organized side, the disorganized
- 28:29side. It's a little different, but,
- 28:33and the reason that preoccupied kids are have such a hard time
- 28:38is because they're prevented from exploring by the
- 28:43caregivers, because the caregivers needs trump the
- 28:47child's need to explore. And often this has to do with,
- 28:52you know, because we're likely to have the same attachment
- 28:56strategy as our caregiver. If you grow up to be
- 28:59preoccupied, it's likely that your primary caregiver was also
- 29:03preoccupied. Preoccupied people like physical
- 29:09proximity, constant physical proximity because they use that
- 29:13for regulating. And so if the child the the
- 29:19child becomes the caregiver as a regulator, then the the, the the
- 29:25caregiver doesn't like to be separated from the child.
- 29:28So particularly in that early period before the child enters
- 29:33into the to the school system, the caregiver often interferes
- 29:42with the process of the child being able to explore.
- 29:46And a rule of thumb, of course with small kids is when they
- 29:51want to be picked up, you pick them up and when they want to be
- 29:54put down, you put them down. And So what can often happen.
- 29:59And I was at AI was at a a gathering and there were a lot
- 30:03of kids around. And a child, 3 or 4 ran up to
- 30:09his grandmother and the grandmother scooped him up, but
- 30:12he clearly resisted being scooped up.
- 30:15That wasn't what he wanted. And then she sat him on his lap
- 30:19and she wrapped him up in his arms.
- 30:21And when he wanted to be put down, she wouldn't put him down.
- 30:24And he struggled and struggled and she overwhelmed him with the
- 30:29the strength that she had in relationship to his until he
- 30:33stopped struggling and sat there.
- 30:36But that was so clearly an indication of her interfering
- 30:43with his desire to be put down so he could return to
- 30:47exploration to meet her need for closeness with the grandchild.
- 30:53And all of the protestations of the grandchild were simply
- 30:57ignored and overwhelmed forcefully so that the
- 31:02grandmother could have what she wanted.
- 31:06And those kinds of inhibitions over and over again in childhood
- 31:10or kind of overprotection that comes prevents the child then
- 31:15from having the emotional regulation that they need to
- 31:20begin that foray out into the world around us.
- 31:26And then they look toward the relationship, that closeness to
- 31:31be compensatory for the, the, the need to explore.
- 31:36And it, it isn't. And so there's a kind of despair
- 31:41about that. Disorganized people often are
- 31:47that natural desire to explore is also the mechanism which is
- 31:51used to exploit them. They're encouraged to be
- 31:55encouraged to explore and then directed to explore things that
- 31:58actually in the end, satisfying to the perpetrator but very
- 32:06damaging to the child. So you have the frame of what
- 32:12happens, what might have happened.
- 32:17And now let's flip it over to here we are as adults with our
- 32:23conditioning, our attachment conditioning all intact, looking
- 32:28to solve the dilemma of a life that isn't rich enough and
- 32:36meaning that we aren't in a state of dissatisfaction, even
- 32:40been to the point of despair at at at the way that our life is.
- 32:46And So what we need to do is to begin to explore something, but
- 32:53engage in the activity mainly around the evaluation of whether
- 32:59or not the the engaging in the activity in the process process
- 33:04of doing it is meaningful in in and of itself that the the time
- 33:12spent engaged in the activity provides a sense of
- 33:15meaningfulness. Now, I wish that there was one
- 33:20simple definition of what's meaningful, but because we are
- 33:24unique in our humanness, unique in our conditioning, the
- 33:31solution to each of these is so specific to the unique person
- 33:37that you are, that part of what this discovery process is, is
- 33:44finding that out. But what is general, and the
- 33:51main part of this that is important to understand is that
- 33:59if the attachment system is activated, the exploration
- 34:03system is off. So the first thing we're really
- 34:07looking at is can I feel emotionally regulated?
- 34:10Can I feel safe enough? Can I feel connected enough that
- 34:15the attachment system turns off and then the exploration system
- 34:20turns on? It's very difficult to solve any
- 34:25exploration puzzles if the exploration system is off and
- 34:29the attachment system is engaged, because the attachment
- 34:33system is telling us to abandon exploration and seek proximity
- 34:37to somebody who will help us come back into emotional balance
- 34:42and into a sense of safety. So that's the first thing.
- 34:50Then once the attachment system is disengaged, the exploration
- 34:56system is active, we're going to move into this place that I
- 35:01mentioned at the beginning of the talk of activating the
- 35:06creative self activity. The thing that has curiosity,
- 35:12the thing that has interest, and to allow that interest to flow
- 35:17into the activities that have meaning.
- 35:20And here is really where we're going to encounter this wall of
- 35:26fear and the need to begin to explore what it is that's
- 35:32fearful, which is really a kind of representation of the early
- 35:37experiences of that natural exploration, expression of
- 35:44primary exploration and what what you experienced in that in
- 35:52avoided people, the expectation is rejection.
- 35:58And so the, what really matters is always kept secret so that
- 36:02that rejection doesn't happen. It doesn't paint that primary
- 36:08drive. But remember, in that cycle of
- 36:11exploration, the, the, there's the going out and discovering
- 36:16and there's the returning and expressing it.
- 36:21And so you have to be able to overcome that fearfulness, that
- 36:26anticipation of rejection and sadness in expressing the thing
- 36:31that you discover that which is quite a vulnerable place.
- 36:37So we need to get into a place where the people around us make
- 36:41us feel safe enough that we're willing to be vulnerable in that
- 36:45way with the preoccupied conditioning Mudit.
- 36:56Sir, I was going to ask for an example.
- 36:57What? Why is it what?
- 37:00What is the exploration? It's simple.
- 37:02Why is it just fear in coming back and expressing it?
- 37:08What's an objection from that? Somebody will not like what I
- 37:13found out in the exploration. That because of what in people
- 37:21are quite rigid in terms of their worldview, presentation of
- 37:26things that if you were to to share with somebody something
- 37:32that was of such primary importance to you and they would
- 37:36belittle it, it would be devastating.
- 37:43So we live OK. That your choice of the thing
- 37:47that means so much to you is not worth it.
- 37:53Which is actually just a repetition of what the early
- 37:55experience was like. So not only do you have the
- 37:58momentary experience of rejection, but you have the
- 38:02whole lifetime of sadness dumping onto it.
- 38:07So it becomes an overwhelming experience.
- 38:12And what you'll notice in avoiding people is if they open
- 38:15up and are a little bit vulnerable and, and you don't
- 38:21respond in a good way, they immediately withdraw and they
- 38:24never forget, they never forgive it.
- 38:28And one of the things that also is true because they tend to get
- 38:33into relationships with preoccupied people.
- 38:37If they do open up to a preoccupied person, it's nearly
- 38:42impossible for a preoccupied person not to poke them for
- 38:47being vulnerable, which just completely shuts them down.
- 38:52Interesting. Poke them as in taunt.
- 38:55Yes. Like you're being too
- 39:01vulnerable. Like literally comment.
- 39:05Or that's ridiculous. It means nothing.
- 39:11Which then then of course puts the shuts all of that down for
- 39:16the dismissing person. Now what does the dismissing
- 39:22person get out of that? It reinforces the fact that they
- 39:25can never share the stuff that's the most personal to them, so
- 39:31they never have to make the attempt to do it, which means
- 39:34they never have to risk touching into the terrible sadness of the
- 39:38expression. So it actually works for them.
- 39:41I think it's one of the reasons why it's so common.
- 39:46So it works for them, as in keeping it secret works for
- 39:48them. Yeah, it reinforces their
- 39:51understanding that keeping it secret is the right way to go.
- 39:56But but they miss from that is the.
- 40:01Entrance into collaborative relationships, because it really
- 40:05is one of the requirements of collaborative relationships that
- 40:08you're able to express this stuff fully.
- 40:17The occupied people of course don't explore very well and so
- 40:23they're always looking for reinforcement and not having to
- 40:28because the the to approach the fearfulness for them is really
- 40:34challenging. So you and because preoccupied
- 40:43people tend to be hyperactivating of the
- 40:46attachment system and hypoactivating of the
- 40:50exploration system in order for them to actually connect and
- 40:53settle that fearfulness to get the exploration system to turn
- 40:58on is a whole reorienting of the way that they operate in the
- 41:03world. Once they do that, of course,
- 41:07then they're they're completely inexperienced in exploring and
- 41:16really are lacking basic knowledge of what's meaningful
- 41:19to them and what is it meaningful to them.
- 41:22The good news about that is, of course, that the whole world is
- 41:25open to them and they can try anything from the point of view.
- 41:29Is this meaningful to me? Because they've tried so little.
- 41:32But it it is then also in some sense catching up on a lifetime
- 41:37of not having made those discernments, of really having
- 41:41no direction to go to, but seems daunting.
- 41:47And because they're not used to engaging in regulating
- 41:53relationships really where they are able to regulate themselves,
- 42:00there's that whole piece of developing the capacity to
- 42:03emotionally regulate that will allow them to go out into the
- 42:07world regulated and then and then also have that secure base
- 42:19to fall back on when they when they get dysregulated at the
- 42:22end. So the fearfulness for them is,
- 42:26is that habit of life, that conditioned life of finding
- 42:34problems and seeking continuous proximity to somebody they find
- 42:39regulating and really having very little capacity to regulate
- 42:43themselves independent of someone else.
- 42:47Which means in order to do exploration they almost need to
- 42:51go with somebody and do it more as a as a pair or a small group
- 42:57than on their own. Which means the quality of the
- 43:01exploration is often compromised because the the unique quality
- 43:06of the individuals in the group are not satisfied in a single
- 43:13direction of exploration. Disorganized people because so
- 43:21often the the means of exploration are the thing that
- 43:25are that is used to exploit them.
- 43:30They have a really hard time relying on someone else for
- 43:36emotional regulation. They're really used to
- 43:38withdrawing and regulating independently.
- 43:43Mudit. Sir George, I didn't quickly
- 43:47just, I didn't understand the fearful aspect of the
- 43:48preoccupied. What is the fear about,
- 43:53obviously. The fearfulness of the
- 43:57preoccupied person is that they're not.
- 43:59They don't regulate themselves emotionally well, so that they
- 44:03have a hard time separating from the proximity of their emotional
- 44:07regulator in order to go explore in the 1st place.
- 44:12They have very little experience in exploring and very little
- 44:17discernment about what to explore, and so very little
- 44:24skill in how to make the the determination.
- 44:27And so any aspect of exploration really can produce a sense of
- 44:33fearfulness. Why?
- 44:37Exploration causes fearfulness. The separation should cause
- 44:40fearfulness. It does.
- 44:43So you separated. There you are standing on the
- 44:46sidewalk. What do you do now?
- 44:49Helplessness. Because more, Yeah.
- 44:52Do I go right or left? Do I go straight ahead?
- 44:58What if I get it wrong? I mean, that comes from that
- 45:07lack of experience of exploration there.
- 45:11One one of the things that you notice about people that are
- 45:14good at exploring is that they take in the data, they make
- 45:18sense of it. They formulate a a an intention
- 45:22for an action. They take the action and then
- 45:24they gather of what happens, make another assessment about
- 45:29it, form another plan of action, take another action and they
- 45:34gather the data of what happened and then continue to do that in
- 45:39an easy cycle. But when you don't know that
- 45:45you're supposed to gather the data, you don't know that you're
- 45:47supposed to analyze it and it's supposed to cause you to choose
- 45:51a direction that that becomes quite labored.
- 45:58And then you're fearful if you take the wrong, make the wrong
- 46:01decision and you take an action that you'll have to make another
- 46:04action and you have to make another discernment of what to
- 46:07do. And so it's, and because
- 46:14preoccupied people do not monitor very well, it's very
- 46:18hard for them to connect. I took this action and I had
- 46:23this result. How do I take another action
- 46:27that's going to give me a better result?
- 46:29Or am I simply going to take another action and get another
- 46:32result and not really be able to understand how I want to
- 46:36navigate what's happening? And so part of that is
- 46:40developing that capacity to monitor and then that capacity
- 46:44to discern how to adjust your responses to things so that you
- 46:48can get a better outcome for what you want.
- 46:52And you don't know what you want.
- 46:56So that creates a a sense of fearfulness, which can be
- 46:59paralyzing. And then you take a disorganized
- 47:05person. The fearfulness there is that if
- 47:09I make the wrong decision, I'm going to put myself in a
- 47:12position with a perpetrator where they're going to harm me
- 47:15again. So I have to make the perfect
- 47:18choice where I'm, I'm not going to be harmed by the outcome of
- 47:22this. So that notches the fearfulness
- 47:25up to a whole nother level of if I make the wrong decision, I
- 47:29won't survive it. How do you make fluid choices
- 47:34and keep maneuvering through the process of exploration when
- 47:38every decision is life or death? So that's where that gets tight.
- 47:49There's one more thing I we need to ask is the exploration piece.
- 47:54The actual exploration, you say can be anything.
- 47:58There's so many options, so many possibilities.
- 48:02It's not clear to me what can you know, because the I mean, I
- 48:07was thinking about the people in the gym.
- 48:10Can a person who goes to the gym be really fascinated about his
- 48:13self-image in the sense he loves to exercise and be an
- 48:18exploration or a person loves to read.
- 48:21There is no particular output in these cases.
- 48:24Maybe there isn't the exercise piece, but a person is obsessed
- 48:28with it looking perfect, but he so he puts he loves it.
- 48:31He loves going to the gym, spends hours every day you.
- 48:36Know then you'd have to really look at the motivation for that
- 48:40and whether it's organized around a primary exploration or
- 48:45whether it's around a secondary exploration.
- 48:49I see motivation. So what's the motivation of
- 48:53going to the gym then? Lots of them.
- 48:56Let's say we're abused as a child.
- 48:59And so you go to the gym so that you'll be so powerful that
- 49:01nobody could ever abuse you again.
- 49:04That would not be primary exploration.
- 49:06That would be stuck in the past. You go to the gym because you
- 49:12want to look beautiful so that you can get access to people
- 49:16that you you find beautiful. So it's a that would be
- 49:20secondary, right? Because the activity itself is
- 49:23not the purpose of it. The exploration itself is not
- 49:26the purpose of it. So you go to the gym and you
- 49:30work out furiously because rock climbing is the thing that just
- 49:33sends you, and you want to go to these beautiful places that
- 49:37climb the rock. And the activity of climbing the
- 49:39rock is the thing that really connects you spiritually to
- 49:44everything. And then that becomes a primary
- 49:47exploration. But it could look similarly in
- 49:50terms of the activities. Gotcha.
- 49:54And what we're reading or other things that does not produce any
- 49:57output. Well, I think that that's part
- 50:00of culturally. We have this idea that
- 50:03creativity should necessarily produce a tangible outcome, but
- 50:07that actually isn't true, I don't think, or that the outcome
- 50:15is something that we culturally value, which I also don't.
- 50:21That's one of my biggest gripes about the system that we we live
- 50:25in, that the there is such a narrow band.
- 50:30And one of the things that actually terrifies me about AI
- 50:35is how seamlessly they're compressing what's allowable in
- 50:40our society. What information is allowable in
- 50:44our society. They can really just exclude
- 50:48massive amounts of stuff. You, you know, we're more and
- 50:53more reliant on the Internet. We're more and more reliant on
- 50:56these search engines and the these AI engines to gather the
- 51:01information that we want. And they're just ratcheting down
- 51:06the controls more and more of what's allowable in that frame.
- 51:10And so it's simply never appears in, in the search.
- 51:15And if you don't have some awareness of it existing outside
- 51:19of that, then you think that that little slice, it's really
- 51:24getting down to a tiny little slice of what's out there, is
- 51:30all that all that's out there. And they can really control the
- 51:33themes and the narratives in pretty much any way that serves
- 51:39their purpose. And there simply is no
- 51:45alternative really at a certain point.
- 51:51I think meaning is such a big word in this case.
- 51:54I mean, you don't say you feel good when you do something,
- 51:57that's enough. Because from you know from this
- 52:00auction point of view there is no particular meaning You know
- 52:04the the view of these. That's quite different.
- 52:07Right, right. That's what I'm.
- 52:08Saying there's no intrinsic meaning, that's true.
- 52:12So if you you talk about it. So the colloquial definition of
- 52:16nihilism, right? Nothing matters because nothing
- 52:20has meaning. That's wrong.
- 52:22That's a a misunderstanding of it.
- 52:25There is no intrinsic meaning in anything.
- 52:28You provide the meaning for everything, right?
- 52:33But that that doesn't mean it doesn't mean something to you.
- 52:36That doesn't mean it isn't important.
- 52:39Self, yes, but not but not to life not.
- 52:43To yes not because. Life.
- 52:46The universe has organized itself around what's meaningful
- 52:50and what is it. Right.
- 52:51Exactly. The universe doesn't have any
- 52:54purpose itself, right? Yes, which frees you in a way to
- 53:00go after whatever it is that you find meaningful because there is
- 53:04no inherent hierarchy of meaning except in our culture.
- 53:09We assign that and we reinforce it in in a lot of different
- 53:15ways. And we're, we can, we're just
- 53:24compacted and compacted and compacted.
- 53:26So all of the resources blow into this extremely narrow band
- 53:32of things that are valued and all the rest of it is not.
- 53:37Is there an emotional response to the meaning?
- 53:40The word meaning do you say when you refer to the this is
- 53:45meaningful and if you translate that to emotions, is there a
- 53:49particular emotions you think of?
- 53:52Well you know in the Buddhist thought emotions are neutral, so
- 53:54anything could be meaningful. If your relationship to them is
- 54:01afflictive than any emotion can take on an afflictive quality.
- 54:06Any emotion can take on a beneficial quality.
- 54:14And I'm also an artist, so the main source of meaning in my
- 54:22life is the these artistic expressions that I make.
- 54:28But just because I make them doesn't mean that that they have
- 54:31residents far and wide. They don't tend to represent the
- 54:37the narrow range of cultural value so much and so tend to
- 54:43think of them as not not created to be resident in that way and
- 54:53and deal with the ambivalence of that.
- 54:57Or no impact on anybody else. It doesn't lead to your meaning.
- 55:02That isn't actually. Yeah.
- 55:03The purpose of it is not for that necessarily.
- 55:07There needs to be, I think in all of these expressions, all of
- 55:12these avenues of exploration and expression of the exploration
- 55:17that you engage. And that could be simply to the
- 55:21group of people that are around you that that safety net that
- 55:25you develop. But it's an essential aspect of
- 55:27it. Otherwise it tends to slip into
- 55:30the auto regulating side of things.
- 55:33But the activity actually is just a regulating activity that
- 55:37allows you to withdraw from the engagement of life.
- 55:40So. Then reading that, then we'll be
- 55:42auto regulating. In that case, reading will not
- 55:45be because there's an expression of it.
- 55:48Well, how then, when you read, do you make an expression of it?
- 55:55So around here, everybody, it's a, it's a reading culture around
- 56:01here. So everybody's reading something
- 56:03or other and that enlivens the discussions of ideas between
- 56:08people. And then the discussions take on
- 56:12a very meaningful quality and in the sense of connection and
- 56:17understanding of what's happening.
- 56:21So you could consume the information.
- 56:23Any information could be enlivening and meaningful
- 56:26because I read the newspaper and that lets me have.
- 56:31Right to. Other people, OK.
- 56:35I think we should do a little meditation and and we can
- 56:38continue this conversation next week.
- 56:41We haven't quite completed the topic.
- 56:48All right, let go of the meditation.
- 56:54So we have a few things starting soon.
- 56:57One is the a level 2 class on Friday mornings, the 1st and 3rd
- 57:03Friday it's from 10:30 to 12:30 AM Pacific Time.
- 57:09And then on the 16th we have the first of our series of two,
- 57:16sorry, on the 21st we have our the 21st of September, which is
- 57:20a Saturday. We have the 1st in our series of
- 57:23two half day workshops on exploration.
- 57:27We're going to focus mainly on primary and secondary
- 57:30exploration on the class in September and in October we'll
- 57:38focus on activating the the creative sense of self for
- 57:48artistic expression. If that's something that's
- 57:50interesting to you, that's what's happening, you're
- 57:56interested, It's all of that information is on the website.
- 58:01Ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope that if you're
- 58:04able to support us, you will. There's a link for donation on
- 58:07the website. It helps support me and also the
- 58:10work Meta group is doing. Really appreciate it and the
- 58:13amount is valued. And of course, if if you're not
- 58:18resourced yet, please feel free to attend.
- 58:21Thank you and I will see you soon.
- 58:25Hi.