Latest / Consumerpedia / 43 - The CFPB: Protecting Consumers in the Financial Marketplace
Transcript
- 0:01After the Great Recession of 2008, Congress decided the
- 0:05country's financial markets needed more oversight, so it
- 0:08passed the Dodd Frank Act, which President Obama signed into law
- 0:11in July 2010. Dodd Frank authorized the
- 0:14creation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the
- 0:17CFPB. To focus on enforcing federal
- 0:20Consumer Financial laws and protecting consumers in the
- 0:23financial marketplace, the CFPB's prime directive is to
- 0:26ensure that financial products offered to you are fair,
- 0:30transparent and competitive. A lot of the rules they make or
- 0:33are considering could directly affect your pocketbook.
- 0:36I'm Herb Weisbaum, A contributing editor at
- 0:38checkbook.org. Welcome to
- 0:41consumerpedia@checkbook.org. We're the nonprofit that helps
- 0:45consumers select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:48Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:51any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:55completely independent and objective.
- 0:57Now here's the host of Consumer Pedia America's consumer expert,
- 1:01the Consumer Man, Herb Weisbaum. The Consumer Financial
- 1:06Protection Bureau deals with lenders, bank accounts and
- 1:08payments. So that means everything from
- 1:10mortgages and student loans to credit cards and auto loans,
- 1:14plus credit reporting agencies and debt collection.
- 1:17It has a number of initiatives and proposed rules in the
- 1:19pipeline that you should know about and may want to comment
- 1:22on. Our guest is Brian Shearer,
- 1:24Senior Advisor to the Director of the CFPB and he joins us from
- 1:27the nation's capital. Thanks for having me.
- 1:29So before we dive into the nitty gritty of what the CFPB is
- 1:32doing, I'd like to hear how you describe the financial
- 1:35marketplace right now. Well, we're coming off a
- 1:37pandemic and interest. Rates are rapidly increasing and
- 1:42that means the price of credit is increasing for American
- 1:45families. So we're we're keenly attuned to
- 1:47the fact that people are are struggling right now.
- 1:49We've seen a big spike in auto lending over the last decade and
- 1:53credit card balances are around a trillion dollars now total in
- 1:57the United States. Student loan balances are
- 2:00nearing 2 trillion and so, So indebtedness is rising.
- 2:03The price of credit is rising. And people are hurting.
- 2:06We're also in the midst of a lot of technological change in our
- 2:09markets. Lenders are increasingly using
- 2:11advanced underwriting. Data brokers are more prominent
- 2:15than ever. We're just now seeing new AI
- 2:18chat bots proliferating through banking.
- 2:20And so it's a busy time. So the CFPB, along with a number
- 2:24of other federal regulatory agencies, is really focused
- 2:27right now on eliminating junk fees.
- 2:30Tell us about that. Junk fees are unnecessary,
- 2:33unavoidable or? Price charges that inflate
- 2:36prices while adding little to no value.
- 2:39We have a lot of projects at the CFPB that are focused on on junk
- 2:43fees because we found that they are quite prevalent in banking
- 2:46and consumer finance and they take many forms.
- 2:49You know these are high late fees, overdraft fees, fees to
- 2:53make a payment, return deposit, item fees.
- 2:56There are a whole bunch. And a lot of our transactions
- 2:58are taking place online these days, and a lot of decisions are
- 3:01being made by algorithms that must make your job more
- 3:04challenging. That's right.
- 3:05You know, algorithms can automate decision making, but
- 3:09they also introduce a lot of issues.
- 3:11There's a bias problem, there are accuracy problems, just the
- 3:14fact that it feeds additional. Data surveillance.
- 3:18So we're focused on that issue and have concerns.
- 3:21Yeah, a lot of people don't realize that.
- 3:23You say, well, it's been done by an algorithm.
- 3:24It has to be free of discrimination or free of bias.
- 3:27Algorithms can be every bit as biased as the people who write
- 3:30them, right? That's right.
- 3:31And just because an algorithm did it doesn't mean the company
- 3:34didn't do it. If an algorithm causes a company
- 3:37to violate the law, the company violated the law, and that's the
- 3:40way the CPB looks at it. So let's dig into some of these
- 3:43specifics. President Biden made it really
- 3:45clear in a State of the Union address.
- 3:47That he wants to reduce or eliminate junk fees.
- 3:50And in February your agency, the CFPB, proposed a rule that would
- 3:53cap credit card late fees at $8 and require banks and credit
- 3:58unions to justify any future price increases.
- 4:01That would be a pretty dramatic change from where the
- 4:03marketplace is right now. That's right.
- 4:04Congress passed the CARD Act in 2009 to limit late fees to a
- 4:09reasonable and proportional amount, and our proposed rule is
- 4:13seeking to ensure that that is what is actually happening.
- 4:17At the time that the law was passed, the Federal Reserve
- 4:21created a rule that, after inflation adjustments, allows
- 4:26late fees of up to $40. And we're looking to see whether
- 4:30that's reasonable and proportional.
- 4:31You know, our research found that late fee revenue is about
- 4:33five times higher than the actual costs that banks are
- 4:39incurring because of late payments.
- 4:41So our proposal is to drop that $40 down to 8, which is 1/5.
- 4:46This is just a proposal and we will be deciding whether to
- 4:50finalize that $8 threshold. So this is a really important
- 4:53point because we're paying about $12 billion a year as a nation
- 4:57in credit card. Fees, and the banks have always
- 4:59insisted that these fees are the cost of doing business.
- 5:02All cost us money to handle all this.
- 5:04And based on your analysis and data, you're saying it doesn't
- 5:07cost them anywhere near the 30-40 bucks they're charging for
- 5:10late fees. It's pretty close to $8 per
- 5:12transaction, yeah. That's right.
- 5:14I mean, certainly some of it is necessary to pay for the costs
- 5:17of handling late payment, but we're finding that $12 billion a
- 5:21year is more of a profit source than it is just covering costs.
- 5:26And we're looking into whether that's consistent with the law,
- 5:29which requires these fees to be reasonable and proportional.
- 5:33Your director, Rohit Chopra, has called this a multibillion
- 5:36dollar bonanza that punishes and penalizes consumers when they
- 5:40make mistakes. And he even suggested in a news
- 5:42release announcing this proposal that credit card companies could
- 5:45actually be hoping that consumers are a day or two late
- 5:48because they're making so much money from this.
- 5:51Is that why you're talking about the possibility of down the road
- 5:54some sort of grace period similar to what's common when we
- 5:57pay our rent or our mortgage and that sort of thing, that if it's
- 6:00midnight and you pay your bill at 1201, you don't get dinged
- 6:03with a late fee? Yes, we're asking for feedback
- 6:05on whether we should impose a grace period.
- 6:07In many instances, consumers are being penalized for missing
- 6:11their due dates by an hour or two hours or maybe a day, which
- 6:15doesn't cost the bank much. And it's just penalizing people
- 6:18for making a harmless mistake. So the CFPB, as you mentioned,
- 6:22focused on a wide variety of junk fees that are charged on
- 6:26all sorts of financial products, from bank accounts to mortgages
- 6:29to student and auto loans. Give us an idea of what you're
- 6:31looking at in this whole area of junk fees.
- 6:33Junk fees are unnecessary, unavoidable, or surprise charges
- 6:39that inflate prices and add little to no value.
- 6:43We're looking at projects throughout banking to address
- 6:47the junk fee problem. This includes the late fee
- 6:49project we just talked about, overdraft fees, return deposit
- 6:53item fees, pay to pay fees. We're looking at fees that banks
- 6:58charge for customer service experiences and others.
- 7:01And so we're taking a broad look we have.
- 7:03Had a request for public input that we issued last year to kick
- 7:09start our junk fee initiative and we were overwhelmed by the
- 7:13response. We received over 80,000 comments
- 7:17from the general public. And so we think we struck a
- 7:20nerve, and that this is an issue that Americans care about.
- 7:23I certainly know I do, and especially when the junk fee is
- 7:25something that's a surprise that I wasn't aware about, that's an
- 7:28even worse problem in my book is not only you hitting me for
- 7:31something you don't need to do, but you're keeping it hidden
- 7:33somewhere till the very end, or I can't change my mind or
- 7:35whatever. That's right.
- 7:36Often these fees are are undisclosed or if they are,
- 7:38they're disclosed in fine print that you don't read.
- 7:41You know, none of us read the fine print on every agreement
- 7:44that you sign, and so they're often surprises.
- 7:47And this is adding up to a lot of money.
- 7:48We're talking billions and billions of dollars here across
- 7:50the economy. That's right, late fees alone
- 7:53make up 12 billion. And that's just for credit
- 7:56cards. Overdraft fees are similar in
- 7:59amount. And they all really add up.
- 8:01You're also looking at marketing practices that trick people into
- 8:05signing up for subscriptions that have recurring charges and
- 8:07they're difficult to cancel or in some cases impossible to
- 8:10cancel. And you took enforcement action
- 8:12against credit card issuers that deceptively market optional
- 8:15addon products. Can you tell us about that?
- 8:17This is a practice that we call negative options marketing,
- 8:21where you sign someone up for, you know, an ongoing
- 8:25relationship and then the relationship continues unless
- 8:28you opt out. Often, companies will make it
- 8:30very difficult to opt out through digital dark patterns or
- 8:35similar practices. And in fact, we just issued a
- 8:39policy statement on the legal prohibition against abusive
- 8:44practices and highlighted how digital dark patterns, like this
- 8:49practice of engaging in negative options, marketing, and trying
- 8:53to obstruct people's ability to opt out, can be illegal.
- 8:56For years we've warned people that these free.
- 8:59Trial offers. In most cases, you're
- 9:01automatically signed up, enrolled in some sort of
- 9:04subscription program. After the free trial ends, you
- 9:07may not even be aware of it because it may be in the fine
- 9:09printer buried somewhere in the terms and conditions.
- 9:11And they can charge you because they already have your debit
- 9:14card or credit card number, because you had to give it to
- 9:16them in order to get the shipping for the free product or
- 9:18service you want it. Yeah, it's a problem throughout
- 9:20the economy and also in consumer finance.
- 9:24And depending on the way it's done, it's often illegal.
- 9:27Now credit reporting agencies are giant companies.
- 9:29That few of us know about very much, but they have a great
- 9:33impact on so many aspects of our financial life.
- 9:35We're going to talk to Brian about that next.
- 9:37You're listening to Consumer Pedia powered by checkbook.org.
- 9:42If you like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a
- 9:44consumer pedia supporter by using the link at the bottom of
- 9:47the show notes to make a small contribution each month.
- 9:50This is Consumer Pedia. Brian Shearer is senior advisor
- 9:55to the director of the CFPB Consumer Financial Protection
- 9:58Bureau. That's a federal watchdog agency
- 10:00that regulates a wide range of financial products and services,
- 10:04from credit cards to credit reporting agencies.
- 10:07Brian The CFPB issued a report in January that was based on an
- 10:11analysis of nearly a half million consumer complaints
- 10:14about credit bureaus. This is something the CFPB does
- 10:17every year, and it's clear looking at this that year after
- 10:19year, the big three credit bureaus, Equifax, Experian and
- 10:23TransUnion top the list of complaints submitted by
- 10:26consumers to your agency. What are the most common
- 10:29complaints? What are the things people are
- 10:30complaining about the most? Well, first, that's exactly
- 10:33right. We receive more complaints on
- 10:35the credit bureaus than any other market by a significant
- 10:39margin. Like you said, in one year alone
- 10:41we received about half a million complaints, and that's up more
- 10:45than two, 100% from 2020. So it's increasing and really
- 10:48spiking. The major issues we're hearing
- 10:50about are the same issues we've been hearing about for a while,
- 10:54false reporting, problems with investigations about false
- 10:58information and improper uses of people's credit reports.
- 11:03And I've been reporting on credit bureaus for years, and
- 11:06one of the problems that never seems to get better, and he
- 11:08mentioned it. Is response to consumer
- 11:11complaints, we're constantly told.
- 11:12Get your free credit report from Experian, Equifax and TransUnion
- 11:16at least once a year. Look for problems and if you
- 11:19notice mistakes or anything suspicious, contact the credit
- 11:22bureaus. But you're saying that many
- 11:24people do this and nothing happens.
- 11:26That's right. It's a huge problem.
- 11:27It's one of the top complaints we get.
- 11:29Consumers have a right to due process under the law if they
- 11:32find errors in their report. And it is, you know, one of the
- 11:35key methods for maintaining accuracy in the credit reporting
- 11:38system. We're worried that increasing
- 11:40automation and corner cutting is increasingly making the dispute
- 11:43process ineffective. Remember, with the big three,
- 11:46you are not the customer companies that they sell reports
- 11:50to are the customer. And so they don't really have an
- 11:52incentive to do right by consumers other than the fact
- 11:55that the law requires them to. And in fact we at the CPP
- 11:58experience this kind of. You know, runaround treatment
- 12:01that consumers receive first hand.
- 12:03In 2020, when the complaint rates rose, the big three
- 12:07bureaus decided at the same time to make tweaks to their
- 12:11responses to the complaints that the CFPB receives, and they
- 12:15claimed that it screened out unmeritorious complaints
- 12:17automatically. We didn't buy it, and so we kept
- 12:20at it. And in 2021, we issued a report
- 12:23to highlight the fact that the big Three weren't responding to
- 12:25our complaints. And to their credit, they
- 12:28shifted course after we called them out.
- 12:30Now the credit bureaus are responding again and they're
- 12:32finding that a lot of complaints actually did have merit.
- 12:35Before the change, they were giving relief to 3% of
- 12:38complaints and now they're back up to about 50%.
- 12:41And so that's a huge difference. But my point is we haven't seen
- 12:44any other market engaged in this kind of conduct.
- 12:47We saw first hand that the bureaus were willing to use
- 12:50automation and corner cutting to kick hundreds of thousands of
- 12:54meritorious CPB complaints off the system and not respond.
- 12:58And for companies that are supposed to have a lengthy and
- 13:01thorough due process investigation process as a core
- 13:06feature of their business, it's really concerned.
- 13:08And let's be clear, a mistake in your credit file can be more
- 13:11than just your age or your address.
- 13:13Something in there could keep you from getting a student loan
- 13:16or a car loan or drive up. The interest rate you pay on
- 13:18credit cards. This is a serious kind of
- 13:20mistake in your life that you don't want to happen or or if
- 13:23you find it, you want to correct it.
- 13:24That's right. Your credit report can affect
- 13:26whether you can get a loan, the price of a loan that you can
- 13:29get. It can also affect whether you
- 13:31can get a job security clearance if you work for the government.
- 13:35There are lots of implications. So it's really important that
- 13:38the information be accurate, but also that consumers dispute
- 13:42rights are honored. So is the CFPB considering some
- 13:46sort of new rules to ensure that the credit bureaus do what
- 13:49they're supposed to do and treat us fairly?
- 13:51Yes, we are. The Fair Credit Reporting Act,
- 13:53which is a federal law, requires that agencies not engage in
- 13:58false reporting. It gives consumers a right to
- 14:01see their data. It gives consumers a due process
- 14:04right to challenge errors, and it strictly limits how this
- 14:07information can be used and. We're focused on those four key
- 14:11pillars of the law and looking to update our regulations for
- 14:15the 21st century. At the moment, we have an open
- 14:19docket to collect public input on this effort and you can go to
- 14:22our website to submit a comment. So if someone listening feels
- 14:25they've been treated unfairly by a credit Bureau, maybe they
- 14:29reported a problem that wasn't fixed you'd like to hear from.
- 14:32Yes, absolutely. And in addition, we're also
- 14:35looking at the newer data broker market as part of this effort,
- 14:39you know. In the 1970s, Congress passed
- 14:42the Fair Credit Reporting Act to regulate data brokers.
- 14:45And since that time, the market has shifted and has found
- 14:50purported loopholes to the point that only a few data brokers are
- 14:53actually following this law. And so we're looking into that
- 14:56in particular and whether data brokers should be regulated
- 14:59under the FCRA. You know, it's interesting as
- 15:01you just mentioned, the client for the data brokers and also
- 15:05for the credit bureaus, we're not the clients.
- 15:06The clients are the companies that buy this information or
- 15:09uses information. You would think for their
- 15:11clients they would want to have accurate information in the
- 15:14files as well. They may be able to lend money
- 15:16to people who they can't because the information in the file is
- 15:18erroneous. It would seem like from both
- 15:20sides they should be getting this right not let alone that
- 15:23it's the law. That's a good point.
- 15:25Both consumers and also banks and other financial companies
- 15:29have an interest in this information being accurate, and
- 15:34it's really not just. You know, a consumer protection
- 15:36issue, it's also an issue for the banks and whether they're
- 15:40able to conduct accurate and appropriate underwriting.
- 15:43So let's shift gears here a little bit.
- 15:45The Internet has made comparison shopping really quick and easy.
- 15:49It's made it incredibly easy for websites that seem to be
- 15:51providing objective information to steer us to companies that
- 15:54are actually paying them for referrals.
- 15:56We may or may not know about it. When digital platforms do that
- 16:00to people shopping for a mortgage living their choices to
- 16:03companies that pay them a referral fee, that's illegal,
- 16:05right? Yes, that's what we've said in a
- 16:07recent guidance document. Digital comparison shopping
- 16:10platforms are common features of the modern economy and people
- 16:14use them to find providers. But if these tools are being
- 16:17manipulated with kickbacks, it's it's a real problem and we've
- 16:21said it is unlawful. So you've been looking into
- 16:23these pay to play tactics. Tell us what you see, what's
- 16:26going on and how this possibly could be.
- 16:29Change to the benefit of consumers.
- 16:30You know, I think your listeners are probably familiar with these
- 16:33tools. They're online websites that you
- 16:35go to to shop and you type in some basic information.
- 16:38Maybe you use filters to let the website know what you're looking
- 16:41for and. You know, gives you offers and
- 16:44often they're they're ordered by what's the cheapest.
- 16:46You know. In an ideal world, people can
- 16:48use these tools to shop, see offers and ultimately find the
- 16:51cheapest one for them if you know if that's what they're
- 16:54shopping based on, you know, price.
- 16:56But the the thing that we're worried about the problem is
- 16:58that often these platforms are manipulated by kickbacks where
- 17:03the offerers that are appearing on the website are actually
- 17:06paying the platform to be on the platform and.
- 17:11It preferences lenders that are paying the highest kickbacks and
- 17:13not lenders that are charging the lowest prices.
- 17:17And in particular this is a big problem for small banks and
- 17:19credit unions and smaller non bank lenders.
- 17:22You know they want to have a chance to compete.
- 17:25They want to be able to drop prices and show up higher on
- 17:29these online lists which can really help them build market
- 17:32share. But if they aren't able to pay
- 17:34as much of A kickback as the big players, they don't even show up
- 17:36on the lists. Is it the Cfpb's opinion that
- 17:39disclosure having a little thing says we get paid a referral fee?
- 17:42Does that negate this thing or is that not good enough?
- 17:46Not good enough. Under the Real Estate Settlement
- 17:48Practices Act, it's illegal to pay referral fees and we've
- 17:54viewed that as including these kinds of kickbacks.
- 17:57And you know, we're not new to this.
- 17:59In fact, HUD years ago, before these kinds of online platforms
- 18:03were really all that popular, they effectively said the same
- 18:06thing and so. Our interpretation here is not
- 18:09really a new one, but we felt it was necessary to put it out into
- 18:12the world because that, you know, the market has changed and
- 18:15these tools have gotten much more prominent.
- 18:17You know, in the old days, maybe your real estate agents say,
- 18:19hey, I've got this lender, this broker will really take good
- 18:22care of you and they're getting a kickback for doing that.
- 18:24Now. They can do this massively with
- 18:27all kinds of lenders on a on a website and you may not even
- 18:30realize it. That's right.
- 18:31It's effectively the exact same thing, except it's all done
- 18:34digitally and automatically and not with cash in.
- 18:37Envelopes passed under desks like it used to.
- 18:40And excuse the marketplace, and it's interesting because what
- 18:43you pointed out here was, well, we always think of the CFPB
- 18:46looking out for the consumer by having a fair marketplace that
- 18:49also helps the businesses. You're talking about the small
- 18:51banks and small credit unions. An unfair marketplace hurts them
- 18:55as well as it hurts the consumers.
- 18:56That's right. You know, small banks and credit
- 18:58unions offer, you know, often cheaper prices, and they're
- 19:02trying to find a way to get their products out into the
- 19:05world, to get people to see them.
- 19:07And these online tools can be a really, you know, great way to
- 19:10do that. But if they can't pay, you know
- 19:12the kickback that larger entities can pay, they don't
- 19:15show up on the list. So it's it's a problem for them
- 19:18as well. The CFPB might be able to help
- 19:20you when you feel you're cheated or deceived.
- 19:22We'll talk about that next. This is Consumerpedia powered by
- 19:26checkbook.org. Consumer Pedia Fast Facts More
- 19:32than $16 billion That's how much the CFPB has saved customers
- 19:37since 2011 through monetary compensation, cancelled debts,
- 19:41and other consumer relief ordered as a result of
- 19:43enforcement actions. 192 million people The estimated number of
- 19:48consumers or consumer accounts eligible to receive relief from
- 19:52enforcement actions. $3.7 billion, the approximate total
- 19:57of all civil penalties ordered as a result of enforcement
- 20:00actions. The Consumer Financial
- 20:04Protection Bureau, the CFPB, has a public complaint database.
- 20:08So, Brian, what happens when someone goes online and files a
- 20:12complaint? Well, we have a state-of-the-art
- 20:15complaint website. It's not a typical government
- 20:17website. It's much more intuitive and
- 20:19user friendly than you might expect.
- 20:22When you submit a complaint, the system walks you through
- 20:24submitting your information and then the complaint is sent to
- 20:28the company for a response and the CPB monitors the response
- 20:31and keeps a record of it. And often the company provides
- 20:36the relief that's requested if it's a complaint that has merit.
- 20:39And anybody can see this. This is a public database that
- 20:42anyone, whether you've complained or not, can look at
- 20:44if you're making a decision and see which banks have the most
- 20:46complaints, or which lender has the most complaints, and what
- 20:49the complaints are or whatever. That's right, if you're filing.
- 20:52A complaint. You can choose to make the
- 20:54narrative of your complaint public, but you don't have to.
- 20:57It can be confidential, but there is a lot of data on our
- 21:01website because a lot of people choose to make it public.
- 21:04And it's a great resource. I use it all the time.
- 21:07You can filter by company, by region, by product type, by the
- 21:13issue that the person was complaining about.
- 21:15It's really quite a research tool and I would recommend
- 21:19anyone use it. Now the Bureau can't solve
- 21:22individual problems, so why do you think it's important for
- 21:25people to file those complaints? Well, if you complain it, it can
- 21:28solve your individual problem. The CPV sends the complaint to
- 21:31the company and facilitates consumers getting.
- 21:34A resolution. So, you know, often people
- 21:36complain to the company over and over again and they hear
- 21:39crickets, and then they complain to the CFPB and they get an
- 21:43answer. Companies know that if a
- 21:45consumer complaints about a real issue and they don't fix it,
- 21:48that the CFPB is watching. We can bring, you know, an
- 21:51enforcement action or we might bring up the fact that they're
- 21:55not responding to complaints in an exam.
- 21:58And so we do follow up work and so they often will respond to a
- 22:01complaint that is filed with us where maybe they they wouldn't
- 22:06have done so if you complain directly to the company.
- 22:09So this is also a way that you monitor the marketplace and
- 22:12decide how to focus your limited resources.
- 22:14Yes, that's right. We use the complaint database to
- 22:17prioritize our work to find issues and get leads for our law
- 22:22enforcement activity. It's a tool that we use in our
- 22:25everyday work. So before we go, you have a lot
- 22:28of information available on the CFPB website, consumerfinance
- 22:32Gov Can you rundown some of the resources available that our
- 22:36listeners might want to take advantage of?
- 22:37Sure. The 1st is the complaint
- 22:39database. You can file complaints there.
- 22:41You can also read complaints. It's a great source of data.
- 22:44I would highly recommend both filing a complaint but also
- 22:47using the database for research. We also have a number of open
- 22:53dockets that people can comment on where we regularly seek input
- 22:57from the public on issues that we're thinking about.
- 23:00We have a lot of consumer education resources as well.
- 23:03They're organized by product type.
- 23:05You can use this to answer basic questions about features of loan
- 23:09products. I recommend all of it, but
- 23:11personally, I particularly have found the mortgage content to be
- 23:15very helpful. You know, I used it personally
- 23:18when I was seeking a mortgage, and it's really quite helpful
- 23:21information to help you navigate sometimes the the complex
- 23:24terminology and the confusing disclosures that can act as an
- 23:28explainer. And then you know, last but not
- 23:31least, our website also has a number of resources for lawyers.
- 23:35We have advisory opinions and CFPB circulars that provide
- 23:40guidance on the meaning of our regulations and statutes.
- 23:44And you know, in particular legal services attorneys or
- 23:47plaintiffs attorneys that are supporting people in litigation
- 23:51can use those as tools as they're trying to adjudicate
- 23:55claims. Brian Shearer is a senior
- 23:57advisor to the director of the CFPB.
- 23:59This is. It's been a fascinating
- 24:01conversation and I want to thank you so much for spending time
- 24:04with us today and to help educate it.
- 24:05Thank you. Well, that's it for this edition
- 24:08of Consumer Pedia. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 24:11and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 24:14to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 24:17episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 24:21show is to follow us on Consumer Pedia on Facebook and Instagram.
- 24:25And at my Consumer Pedia on Twitter, I'm Herb Weisbaum.
- 24:29Thanks for listening consumer. Pedia is a public service of
- 24:32checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 24:35helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 24:38You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 24:41and avoid the worst, with local ratings that are accurate and
- 24:44unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 24:47seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 24:50Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 24:55Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 24:58To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 25:00checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 25:04we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 25:07the bottom of the show Notes to Make a small contribution each
- 25:10month. Consumer Pedia Empowering
- 25:12consumers to Save Money and make smarter choices.