Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 260. From Role To Soul: The Four Ingredients For Mastering Meaning
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Answers lead to destinations.
- 0:05Questions lead to journeys.
- 0:07My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:10Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:12Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:16Today I look forward to speaking with Bill Burnett and Dave Evans.
- 0:19Bill is the executive director of the Life Design Lab at Stanford and an adjunct
- 0:23professor in mechanical engineering.
- 0:25Dave is a lecturer in the product design program and co-founder
- 0:29of the Stanford Life Design Lab.
- 0:31Both have worked in various cool and influential jobs from Apple
- 0:34to Electronic Arts to Hasbro.
- 0:37Together they wrote the New York Times bestselling book, Designing
- 0:40Your Life, and their latest book is How to Live a Meaningful Life: Using
- 0:44Design Thinking to Unlock Purpose, Joy, and Flow in Everyday Life.
- 0:49Welcome, Bill and Dave, I am thrilled to have you here as
- 0:52somebody who is trying to figure out what I want to be when I grow up.
- 0:55I'm very excited for our conversation.
- 0:57Thanks.
- 0:58Dave Evans: Great to be here.
- 0:59Bill Burnett: Yeah.
- 0:59Thank you for inviting us.
- 1:00Matt Abrahams: Shall we get started?
- 1:01Dave Evans: Let's go.
- 1:02Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 1:02So, Dave, your new book provides useful tools for living a meaningful life.
- 1:07How do you and Bill define meaning and purpose, and why do
- 1:10you write that we don't need to know our true purpose after all?
- 1:14Dave Evans: Well, you know, we're user-centered designers.
- 1:15We live to reframe things.
- 1:17So the first thing the book does is reframe meaning and purpose.
- 1:20And so we're not after finding the meaning of your life or your one true
- 1:24purpose because we define the human being as a becoming, we're all a dynamic,
- 1:28flowing, constantly changing thing.
- 1:29So how could a changing thing have one static right answer?
- 1:33We encourage people to live meaningfully and direct their lives purposefully, and
- 1:37we've got some tools for how to do that, but we want you to be going the right
- 1:40direction, not find the right destination.
- 1:42Matt Abrahams: I love that idea and making those words adverbs can really help.
- 1:46Gimme an example of living life purposefully.
- 1:49Dave Evans: We talk about coherency a lot, and the whole idea is who I am and what I
- 1:52believe and what I'm doing in alignment.
- 1:54One of our tools is called a coherency side.
- 1:57We have a compass tool that helps you figure that out and write it
- 2:00down in less than three pages, and then you can catch yourself in the
- 2:02act of acting just like yourself.
- 2:04So this morning, I'm having a very coherent moment talking to Matt
- 2:07because he's interested in the same things we are and communicating
- 2:10to people, which is what we do.
- 2:11So man, I'm right on target right now.
- 2:14Matt Abrahams: So it's about reflecting and knowing your
- 2:16purpose, and from that you can then assess if you're in line or not.
- 2:19Dave Evans: Compasses say North, not Seattle.
- 2:21So am I going North?
- 2:22I'm doing the right thing.
- 2:23Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 2:24Very good.
- 2:24Bill, your work in both your books focuses on design thinking.
- 2:27We've talked about design thinking on the show before, but for those who
- 2:31aren't familiar with it can you define what you mean by design thinking?
- 2:35What are some of the core concepts that you employ?
- 2:37Bill Burnett: Yeah, and it was the idea of taking engineering and adding
- 2:40in psychology, anthropology, and art, 'cause we should make beautiful things.
- 2:44But it was always rooted in the notion that you talk to humans about what
- 2:47they need and you try to understand them using anthropological tools
- 2:50like ethnography and other things.
- 2:52So we boiled it down to a five step process.
- 2:54Don't start with the problem, start with people.
- 2:56Empathy.
- 2:57It's the first step in design thinking.
- 2:58Then define the right problem.
- 3:00'Cause oftentimes the problem you got is the wrong thing.
- 3:03It doesn't respond to the human need.
- 3:05Then have lots of ideas.
- 3:06'Cause we know, as designers says, if you have lots of
- 3:08ideas, you have better choices.
- 3:10And then prototype and test.
- 3:11Relentlessly test your hypothesis about the user with a prototype or prototypes,
- 3:15not to prove you're right or wrong, it's just to explore the idea, and then test
- 3:20and then refine it and test and refine it.
- 3:21So it's a very empirical human-centered process.
- 3:25I took a full-time position here at Stanford in 2006, but I'd been teaching
- 3:28design to design students for a long time.
- 3:31When Dave came over in 2007 and proposed, Hey, let's do a class for the students.
- 3:35Are they struggling to launch?
- 3:36Are they concerned about meaning and purpose?
- 3:38I said, absolutely, and it seemed to me like it was a design problem.
- 3:41We could prototype your future.
- 3:43We could interrogate, what do I need?
- 3:46Empathy for me, empathy for the world.
- 3:48What does the world need?
- 3:49So the whole idea of using design thinking for life design just fell into place very
- 3:54quickly and the students really responded.
- 3:56Matt Abrahams: I think it's a wonderful toolkit to look at purpose
- 3:59and meaning, and I have benefited from it from the work you've done
- 4:03in my own life and my own searching.
- 4:05In your book Designing for Life, Dave, you leverage one of the tenets of
- 4:08design thinking when you advocate for prototyping conversations to gather data.
- 4:13What are prototyping conversations and what are some of the best
- 4:17practices for having them?
- 4:18Dave Evans: So again, as Bill just described in design thinking, a
- 4:21prototypes job is to ask an interesting question and learn your way forward.
- 4:25And I'm trying to design this thing called the future.
- 4:27I don't have any data, so you can't analyze it.
- 4:29So we have a very hands-on empirical bottom-up process that talks about
- 4:33gathering data through experiences.
- 4:35And if I'm trying to design my life, I'm thinking about ways people live.
- 4:40Oh, I can go visit the future by sitting down with a person who's doing the kind
- 4:43of thing or living the kinda lifestyle or believing the kind of thoughts that I'm
- 4:46contemplating considering so I could visit the future by entering into their story.
- 4:51So that a life prototype is a conversation or an experience, and
- 4:55importantly, it's not a transactional one.
- 4:57Like, well, how much money do you make and do I need an MBA or not?
- 5:00Those are interesting questions about the transaction of do I
- 5:02want to become Professor Matt?
- 5:04But what I realized is so, wow, you communicate about communicating.
- 5:08How's that for you?
- 5:10That's the narrative story of the experience you're having, and
- 5:12we know neuroscientifically now, that if I actually get into your
- 5:16story, I'm actually having an experience walking along with you.
- 5:20Surrogation, as opposed to simulation, according to Dan Gilbert at Harvard.
- 5:24If I live into your life a little bit, I really can understand things
- 5:27differently than just reading data.
- 5:29Matt Abrahams: Thank you for sharing what you mean by prototyping conversations.
- 5:31Bill, I want to talk about another concept that I really find interesting,
- 5:35which is the idea of an odyssey plan.
- 5:38What is an odyssey plan?
- 5:40How should we develop them and how do we best then communicate them?
- 5:43Bill Burnett: Well, I mentioned that one of the steps in the design process
- 5:46is ideation, having lots of ideas.
- 5:48And we know from lots of research from the business world that if you have a
- 5:51binary decision, an AB decision, you make a bad decision more than 50% of the time.
- 5:56So have more than two.
- 5:57We do three odysseys, and there are three explorations of the
- 6:01next five years of your life.
- 6:02What might that be like?
- 6:04And typically odyssey one is whatever you're doing now, and it just goes
- 6:06great for the first five years.
- 6:08Odyssey two, we suggest, Hey, what's your plan B?
- 6:10AI just took that job and that life is gone.
- 6:13You have to, you know, plan B. And then the wild card plan, the third plan, is
- 6:17what would you do if you had all the money and the resources that you needed?
- 6:20No one would say, well, that's a stupid thing.
- 6:23Why are you leaving a position at Stanford to go be a clown at Cirque Soleil?
- 6:28Matt, that's crazy.
- 6:28So all your friends would say, whatever you're doing is great.
- 6:31Because a lot of times the social pressure of staying in their lane
- 6:35is so powerful that they can't even ideate about something different.
- 6:38So the idea is it's three completely different lives played out in five
- 6:42years and not just work stuff, but life stuff and family stuff, and
- 6:46your bucket list and everything else.
- 6:48And we find when people do three, not one or two, it really opens
- 6:52up the possibilities of what could happen in the next five years.
- 6:56Now, we're not suggesting that you pick one.
- 6:58They're not truly plans.
- 6:59They're really just a chance to imagine yourself in three different futures.
- 7:04And then one of the things we do is we say, okay, pick two of those
- 7:06futures and write me a story.
- 7:08It's four or five years from now.
- 7:09I say, Hey Matt, how you doing?
- 7:10I ran into you to Starbucks.
- 7:11How you doing?
- 7:12You say, I'm great.
- 7:13I go, Hey, what happened with that odyssey?
- 7:15And then you tell me.
- 7:16So you actually write a letter from the future back to yourself
- 7:19about what that Odyssey was like.
- 7:21Sometimes it's challenging for people to think of three things, but once they've
- 7:24actually got it and they get into it, developing these lives really changes
- 7:29their perspective on what's possible.
- 7:30And that's all we're trying to do is open up the solution space.
- 7:33Matt Abrahams: Bill, I want to go back to this idea of meaning.
- 7:36You both articulate four key components of meaning making.
- 7:41I'd love to hear more detail about those.
- 7:43Bill Burnett: We start with this idea of coherence and we have a little
- 7:46tool, as Dave said, we built a compass.
- 7:47You know, who you are, what's your story, what's your theory of work,
- 7:50and what's your theory of everything that's sort of transcendent?
- 7:53So coherence is the first part.
- 7:55Wonder is the second step.
- 7:56Wonder we describe as curiosity plus mystery.
- 7:59And so walking around the world with the sense of wonder.
- 8:03And then the idea of flow.
- 8:05We propose in the book, we live in two worlds, the transactional world
- 8:08of getting stuff done, which is great.
- 8:09And then right underneath that, kinda like an aquifer below the surface, is
- 8:13the flow world where we, where actually the flow world is where you will
- 8:16experience meaning and transcendence.
- 8:19And then the final element is community.
- 8:21We have a mindset called, in creating your world, you create the world and you
- 8:25create the story of the world you live in.
- 8:27And you surround yourself with relationships that are meaningful.
- 8:30It's all about community and relationships.
- 8:33So coherency, flow, wonder, and community are for meaning making methods.
- 8:40Dave Evans: Lemme double down on the community thing for a minute
- 8:41'cause there's social community where we gather to have a good time.
- 8:44Collaborative community where we gather to get something done, which most of your
- 8:48colleagues help us do over at the GSB.
- 8:50And there's a formative community where we are becoming together,
- 8:54and that's a fundamental shift.
- 8:55What we're finding is the overwhelming majority of modern people have lots
- 8:58of social and tons of collaborative community, which is wonderful.
- 9:02Getting something done together is very life-giving, but it's not
- 9:06the same as becoming together.
- 9:07So it's not, did you get it done, Matt?
- 9:10Or how are we gonna do this together?
- 9:11Or wasn't it great when we won?
- 9:12It's like, so are you moving toward the better Bill, Bill?
- 9:17And that conversation we call the formative community, we have some tips for
- 9:19how to do that and it's very life-giving.
- 9:22Matt Abrahams: I wanna come back to those tips.
- 9:23I'm in the process of building one of those formative communities, and
- 9:26I really appreciate how you delineate the different types of community.
- 9:30The more I do the work I do in communication, the more important I
- 9:34see both context and community being.
- 9:37I wanna come back and share with us the wonder activity if you could.
- 9:40Dave Evans: We have a number of tools for each of these things, but the first
- 9:43one is put on your wonder glasses.
- 9:45And put on your wonder glasses means you could sit anywhere, and
- 9:47first of all, you look around the room with your regular glasses on.
- 9:50You just see the way the world is.
- 9:51Like, I'm in the studio and there's Gordon, he is working behind the
- 9:53desk and, and what do I notice?
- 9:55And then I see what's going on, and then I go, oh, there's a,
- 9:57the broom is next to the door.
- 9:58I wonder if that was forgotten.
- 9:59And so my eye naturally goes to things that want to turn into tasks.
- 10:03So suddenly my natural glasses sees the transactional world
- 10:07and what I need to go do next.
- 10:09And I go, thank you very much.
- 10:10Now take another look and just notice, and then what else comes to mind?
- 10:14And then I see this other really nice chair two clicks over from the broom, and
- 10:19I'm thinking, huh, that's an empty chair.
- 10:21And then my wonder glasses look on, like I wonder who might sit in that chair next.
- 10:26I wonder what conversations happen in this room, very thoughtful people.
- 10:31Isn't it great there's an institution dedicated to thoughtful conversation, and
- 10:35then I can just appreciate that and so in about a minute, I go from, oh, I gotta
- 10:39call Patrick back, to, I get to be in deep conversations as part of a long tradition.
- 10:44That's a real joy and I'm so grateful for it.
- 10:46That's the wonder glasses, and you can do it anytime.
- 10:48Matt Abrahams: I love the idea of wonder glasses, and it really, to
- 10:52me, it sounds like it's all about curiosity and allowing yourself
- 10:55to more deeply think about things.
- 10:57You did something there in your example that I really wanna highlight.
- 11:00When you transition from the transactional view of the world
- 11:04to the wondering, curiosity view, you simply said, thank you.
- 11:09I see that, but I wanna look differently.
- 11:11Many of us beat ourselves up or say, oh, I shouldn't be doing that.
- 11:15That's the wrong way to approach things.
- 11:17And you simply acknowledge and move on.
- 11:19And that to me, I think is a key element in this flow state.
- 11:23Dave Evans: Well, again, we have this framing that so many people
- 11:26came to us where we redesigned our lives, but it's still not as
- 11:29fulfilling or meaningful as I thought.
- 11:31What did I do wrong?
- 11:32We go, oh, we got that problem.
- 11:34So that's where this recent book came from.
- 11:35And as we listened to them, they overwhelmingly described lives lived
- 11:39entirely in the transactional world.
- 11:41Now there is only one world.
- 11:43But our brains can't handle the whole thing all at once.
- 11:45We have modalities.
- 11:46So we're inviting people to spend more time in the flow world, which is the
- 11:50present moment through which the entire coursing cosmos is under our feet and
- 11:54in front of our eyes all the time.
- 11:55That present moment, which is different than the transaction in the future.
- 11:59And so the reason we have a friendly relationship between the
- 12:02transactional world and the flow world and transactional thinking, or
- 12:05achieving brain and flow thinking, or the awakened brain, is because
- 12:08they're friends, we need them both.
- 12:10Somebody's gotta take out the trash.
- 12:12So there's nothing wrong with the transactional world.
- 12:14And we accept the fact that most of us are overwhelmingly biased that way because
- 12:18the systems of the world all run on that all the time, so cut yourself some slack.
- 12:22All we're trying to do is get better, and I don't need more
- 12:24reasons to critique myself.
- 12:26Frankly, that's just the transactional world catching me in
- 12:28the act of doing something wrong.
- 12:29I'm just trying to become a person.
- 12:31Matt Abrahams: That's a fundamental mindset shift, but when you do it,
- 12:33it allows access to this flow state.
- 12:35Bill Burnett: Yeah, and it's always there.
- 12:36Matt Abrahams: Yeah.
- 12:37It's just giving yourself permission to see it.
- 12:39Let's go back to formative communities.
- 12:41How do you build these?
- 12:42How do you find the people to support you?
- 12:45What's involved in building that?
- 12:47Dave Evans: It's all about the question.
- 12:48So I start with the definition, you know, Bill and I have been talking
- 12:50about people for a long time.
- 12:51We do human-centered design.
- 12:52So our definition of the human is a becoming.
- 12:55So then if I'm becoming, what am I becoming into?
- 12:58So then it begets what's the question I'm living into?
- 13:00And one of the unfair ways to divide the world in two is there are the
- 13:03people who run around rehearsing their answer and the people who
- 13:05run around living their question.
- 13:07So if you wanna live a becoming growth oriented life, now
- 13:10you're living into the question.
- 13:11So the question is what am I living into?
- 13:14So I'm seventy-two, I've got eleven grandkids, and the question I'm asking is,
- 13:18am I ready to shift out of a role-based life into a more soul-based life?
- 13:22And how can I have my primary verb shift from got to to get to.
- 13:27Now, that's not the same as, I gotta call Patrick back, that I mentioned earlier.
- 13:30That's my transactional task list.
- 13:31I've still got a task list, but the question I'm living into is I wanna
- 13:35spend more time doing get to not got to.
- 13:38How do I do that?
- 13:39So you start coming up with those questions and ask that of
- 13:42yourself, and then find others who wanna ask that question.
- 13:45And you start by having a dinner and let's ask more interesting questions.
- 13:48And if people like it, do it again.
- 13:50And then, you know, read a book together and then say, I think we got a group here.
- 13:53Matt Abrahams: I love this idea of the question I am living into
- 13:56instead of just being the answers.
- 13:57Dave Evans: Yeah, we call that the focus question.
- 13:59Matt Abrahams: Bill, the book also talks about the practice to production trap.
- 14:03What is this and how do we avoid the trap?
- 14:06Bill Burnett: So we always do this, we turn what could be a beautiful
- 14:09moment and it's like, it's one of the things to say, what a beautiful sunset.
- 14:12I long for beauty.
- 14:14It's another thing to say, well, that sunset was okay,
- 14:17but I've seen better ones.
- 14:18You know, where, where could I go to find a better one?
- 14:20And so every time we take a potentially meaningful moment and turn it into
- 14:25another item on our to-do list, we try to make it more efficient.
- 14:28Practice to production is making everything a production, a transaction
- 14:32in the transactional world.
- 14:33It's a big trap and you just want to be aware of it because the beauty of
- 14:37the sunset is beauty in and of itself.
- 14:39It's a completely whole moment.
- 14:42Don't turn everything into a transaction.
- 14:44That's the trap.
- 14:45You know, people just all the time to themselves, they rob themselves
- 14:49of the chance of having a little moment of meaning by judging and
- 14:53making it performative or whatever.
- 14:55Dave Evans: You gotta channel the Beatles.
- 14:56So you're, you're doing your practice and the voice pops up, like, you could do this
- 15:00better and then let it be, just let it be.
- 15:03Matt Abrahams: But first you have to be aware that that's what's happening.
- 15:05Dave Evans: Yeah.
- 15:05And you have to like the Beatles.
- 15:07Matt Abrahams: Thank you.
- 15:08This has been a fantastic conversation.
- 15:10Before we end, I like to ask three questions of all my guests.
- 15:13One I create just for you all and then two, I've been asking forever.
- 15:16You guys up for that?
- 15:17Dave Evans: Yep.
- 15:17Bill Burnett: Sure.
- 15:18Matt Abrahams: Dave, I'm gonna start with you.
- 15:19You both have been communicating about finding meaning,
- 15:23purpose, life for a long time.
- 15:26What are some best practices you have found for helping
- 15:29communicate your messages clearly?
- 15:30We've seen it play out here.
- 15:31You give lots of examples, you bring lots of energy.
- 15:34Talk to me about how you strategically think about how
- 15:37you communicate your messages.
- 15:38Dave Evans: We're narrative animals.
- 15:40We're human-centered designers.
- 15:41It's about the listener, the user, the reader.
- 15:43It's about the reader.
- 15:44It's about the reader.
- 15:44It's about the reader.
- 15:45It's not about you.
- 15:46And the last thing is they never know what you don't say.
- 15:49It's about the user.
- 15:50Keep it a story and don't worry about the stuff you're not saying.
- 15:53Matt Abrahams: Many of the listeners have heard me say this before.
- 15:55A piece of advice my mother, unfortunately, has to constantly
- 15:57remind me of is tell the time.
- 15:59Don't build the clock.
- 16:00I'd love to hear from both of you and we'll start with you, Bill.
- 16:03Who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 16:06Bill Burnett: Sir Ken Robinson, who I think still has one of
- 16:08the most popular TED Talks ever.
- 16:10And he was an educator and was communicating about education and the
- 16:13importance of creativity in education.
- 16:15So I loved his message.
- 16:16And he was funny and self-deprecating, and he is just fantastic communicator.
- 16:21And Richard Feynman, who was the, he is probably the only guy who
- 16:23could ever explain physics to me in a way I could understand.
- 16:26And he did all the math and all the equations, but he made it a story.
- 16:29It's great.
- 16:30Matt Abrahams: Dave, how about you?
- 16:30Who's a communicator you admire and why?
- 16:32Dave Evans: Recently I decided I, my current favorites are
- 16:35Anderson Cooper and Ken Burns.
- 16:36Anderson is a lovely journalist and gets to the story, and Ken Burns manages, he
- 16:42actually returns us into the history.
- 16:44He doesn't talk about it.
- 16:45And he's brilliant at it.
- 16:46He's been doing it for 50 years and I still find him riveting.
- 16:49Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 16:50Four amazing communicators.
- 16:52Thank you.
- 16:52Bill, we heard Dave's answer, which essentially was three key ingredients
- 16:56to successful communication.
- 16:58I'm curious to get your first three ingredients that go into a
- 17:01successful communication recipe.
- 17:04Bill Burnett: When I first heard that question, I was thinking more
- 17:06about one-on-one communication, particularly communicating with my
- 17:10wife or communicating with a friend.
- 17:12And so it was empathy 'cause that's where designers start, right?
- 17:15And then assuming the best of the other person.
- 17:18'Cause we're always in these conversations and people are not
- 17:20giving people the benefit of the doubt.
- 17:22And then yeah, prototyping tests because, uh, one of my favorite, Scott
- 17:26Galloway says, uh, you can't read the label from inside the bottle.
- 17:29And even though you think you're being very clear, unless you try
- 17:33it with somebody and then you say, okay, what did I just say?
- 17:36And then they say, I don't have no idea.
- 17:37Prototyping tests, because you don't know if it's gonna communicate what you want to
- 17:40communicate until somebody else hears it.
- 17:43Matt Abrahams: Amazing ingredients there.
- 17:45I wanna just put an exclamation point around the fact that you practice
- 17:49and you prototype your talks.
- 17:51So many people, either based on being so busy or so nervous,
- 17:56don't take the time to do it.
- 17:58And somebody like you who has been doing this for a long time still does that.
- 18:02Just really shows how important that is.
- 18:04Thank you both.
- 18:05The idea that when we communicate, we give people an entire experience.
- 18:08You have given us a very meaningful experience.
- 18:11This idea of role to soul I really like.
- 18:15We all have that opportunity to go deeper, to be in that moment.
- 18:19And the tools you provide to help us figure out how to live purposefully
- 18:24and meaningfully really hit home for me and hopefully for all of our listeners.
- 18:27Best of luck with your new book, How to Live a Meaningful Life.
- 18:30Thanks for being here.
- 18:31Dave Evans: Matt, thanks so much.
- 18:32Bill Burnett: Thank you.
- 18:35Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 18:36Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 18:39To learn more about life and purpose, please listen to episode 181 with Arthur
- 18:42Brooks and episode 138 with Graham Weaver.
- 18:46This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 18:50Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 18:52With thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 18:54Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 18:58Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 19:00Also follow us on LinkedIn, Instagram, and TikTok.
- 19:04And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 19:07learning content, and our newsletter.
- 19:10Please consider joining our Think Fast Talk Smart Learning Community
- 19:13at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 19:16You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards,
- 19:19our AI coaches, and book club.