Latest / Murder Junction / Episode 115 - Andrew Lycett and The Worlds of Sherlock Holmes - with added Cucumber Sherlock.
Transcript
- 0:00Sherlock Holmes, the world's most famous detective, a man who, more than
- 0:04a century after his creation, continues to find new avatars in book and on
- 0:08screen, from quirky Sherlock to comedy Sherlock to sexy Robert Downey Junior Sherlock to
- 0:14cucumber Sherlock. Sherlock Holmes, a man famed for his eccentricities, odd dress
- 0:19sense, and addiction to dubious substances. Talking of which, abbit, how
- 0:24are you, my friend, I'm good. I'm very good. Maybe it
- 0:27is the dubious substances. I don't know what it is, but I am
- 0:30full of the joys of Christmas. I must take you back a second,
- 0:33though. You mentioned cucumber Sherlock. What is cucumber Sherlock. Yeah. I
- 0:39did some googling recently, and yet not that type. I hope. Well,
- 0:45you know, cucumber Sherlock might be considered. That's exactly what I was
- 0:48afraid. It's far more innocent than that. It is a cucumber playing the
- 0:53role of Sherlock in an animated I see that sounds slightly less. Well,
- 1:00it's about on the same level as your role in this podcast, really,
- 1:03isn't it. How are you? How are you? My friend? Tell
- 1:06me how you? I'm really good? But I think we should introduce somebody
- 1:08who perhaps knows a little bit more about Sherlock, Cucumber Sherlock, or otherwise
- 1:15than our good selves. Who have we got on today? Us? We
- 1:17have somebody very special today, don't we have? We have a fellow of
- 1:21the Royal Society of Literature, do we not? So we're in the company
- 1:25of greatness. So we have a pre eminent British biographer, Andrew Leissett,
- 1:30whose new work The World of Sherlock Holmes sheds new light on both the great
- 1:34detective and his creator, Arthur Conan Doyle. Andrew, welcome to the show.
- 1:42Hello that and very nice to be with you. And you've never come
- 1:45across Cucumber Sherlock. I'm presuming. If I'm not, I haven't, and
- 1:48I'm very disappointed, because here I am. I've written a book called The
- 1:52Worlds of Sherlock Holmes, and I don't include that in it. You know,
- 1:56I've got a lot of other interesting material, but it'll have to go
- 2:00in the second edition. Yes, volume two. Volume two is better than
- 2:04the second edition. I understand, Andrew, I understand that you play cricket
- 2:08with Vassine. Before we get onto the books, let's I want to ask
- 2:10you a few questions. I understand you play cricket with Vassine. That must
- 2:14be that must be a heartrending, soul destroying experience. I first met Vassine
- 2:22on the playing fields of Dulwich College, and you know, he immediately impressed
- 2:27me with his fourth right play. You know, he's correct player, very
- 2:31correct player, and a great company, great person to have around in there
- 2:36you go, I had, I had he puts the doll into Dullitch Colleges.
- 2:39That's true for seem is that what you do. We're talking to a
- 2:43philistine here, Andrews man knows as much about cricket as he does about literature.
- 2:47That's not encourages, man, don't encourage. And let's start with with
- 2:52a with a brief BIOSO, tell us where you grew up. I grew
- 2:55up in a number of places. I was born in Lincolnshire in England,
- 3:01and then at the age of about six months, I was spirited by my
- 3:05father and my mother indeed out to Africa, where I lived in what was
- 3:09then called Tanganika for eight years, and then we came back, and we
- 3:17sort of flitted around the place. I spent three years in Dublin, been
- 3:23in Yorkshire before settling in Sussex, where you know, it was sort of
- 3:29my main teenage years were in Sussex, so fairly sort of you know,
- 3:34around the place upbringing. But you know, let's leave it at that for
- 3:39the time being. Let's you want further details. Tanganika, that's where the
- 3:46leak He's made a lot of their early early discoveries, early man discovery discoveries.
- 3:53But one of the first books I had I have still have, was
- 3:59of course something the Rise of Man, and it's just sort of about that
- 4:02kind of discovery. But I must admit I didn't really make the connection with
- 4:06the Leaky's, although I did eventually somewhat later meet one of the Leakys.
- 4:14I think it was called Richard Ki. Yeah, he was trying his own
- 4:17planes, probably better than that than you know, sailing his on boat with
- 4:21a name like Leaky. I suppose that was Andrew. Andrew you are you
- 4:28know, you are one of the country's pre eminent biographers. What got you
- 4:30interested in that field? What got me interested in biography? Yeah? Yeah,
- 4:35okay, so I plied a trade as a journalist for twenty odd years,
- 4:43twenty years, let's say, and then I sort of discovered that I
- 4:46was not going to become editor of the Times or anything like that, and
- 4:51I wasn't really really cut out, sort of my character is not cut out
- 5:00for sort of full time being fared at, you know, on the battlefields
- 5:04of Iraq and that sort of thing. So luckily I was able to sort
- 5:09of push myself, you know, pull myself into doing what actually I much
- 5:15better suited that, which is doing a bit of research, because a lot
- 5:18of quite a lot of research in biography, writing about people, but very
- 5:24much in a historical context, because I studied history at university, and you
- 5:30know, I like to I like to give people historical context. And you
- 5:34know that is a definition, if you like, a definition of biography as
- 5:41so as I'm concerned, you know, sort of putting people in their context.
- 5:46And you did that for a person that Abert and I have talked about
- 5:49in the past, mister Rudyard Kipling. I did. Indeed, Yes,
- 5:58I keep coming across the references when I'm doing research. I just was was
- 6:01interested in the guy. Basically, you know, I didn't really know very
- 6:06much about him when I started out, and you know, I didn't know
- 6:11the extent of his comments on Indians. And you know he's not I'm not
- 6:16a big fan. You're not a big fan. Do you know what?
- 6:19He wrote a poem? He wrote a poem called what Happened? Have you
- 6:23ever read that? I probably have, but I can't. It's about a
- 6:27barrister called Harry Chandler Mukergy. So he has the same surname as me.
- 6:31And nobody knows what happens to Harry Chander Mukergy in the end. But when
- 6:38you read it, the poem sort of smacks of, you know, he's
- 6:42very upset at the oppertiness of these you know, these Bengali barristers. How
- 6:46dare they? But he's an interesting character, right, he is very interesting.
- 6:53I mean, you know, you're absolutely right. You know, he
- 6:56gave credence to all those sort of ugly aspects of the British in India,
- 7:03such as you know, saying that the Bengalis were sort of inferior. But
- 7:10nevertheless they you know, they were sort of half educated and therefore they were
- 7:14sort of aspiring to You've you've met me. I'm not half educated, am
- 7:17I? You're not even you're not even a quarter. I haven't met you,
- 7:24really, but you know what I'm what I'm talking about credence. He
- 7:28didn't give any credence to the Congress Party, and you know he was very
- 7:34much opposed to that. You know, he was an imperialist and he believed
- 7:42in ah, what the the the Raj was bringing to India now, the
- 7:49white man's burden. He was a big, big fan of the white man's
- 7:53burden, wasn't he. But we're not here to talk about ki We are
- 7:56here, We're not But I would have say one thing about Kipling is that
- 8:00he was Let's get this right. He was the first British winner of the
- 8:07Nobel Prize and he was the youngest and remains the youngest. So I did
- 8:13not know that. I did not know that at all. Oh wow,
- 8:16So he's still the youngest winner of the Nobel Prize. He won it in
- 8:22early forties. I'll give you another nugget which you might not know, and
- 8:26it just it speaks to the the contradictory views people sometimes have about Kipling.
- 8:33It was Prime Minister Nehru who said India's first prime minister who said that one
- 8:37of his favorite novels was Kim which was written by Kipling. So make of
- 8:41that what you will, but abit you to segue us. Yes, I
- 8:46was going to say, we weren't here to talk about Kipling because we've done
- 8:48him. We are here to talk about the world of Sherlock Holmes and his
- 8:56creator, Arthur Conan Doyle. So Andrew what first they got you in,
- 9:00trusted in, tell us abit about the book, and then tell us why
- 9:03you decided this was the character to look at next. All right, as
- 9:07you say said, I've done a number of biographies. One was on Ian
- 9:13Fleming, creator of James Bond, but another was on Arthur Conan Doyle.
- 9:20And you know I actually did that, gosh getting on for fifteen years ago
- 9:26or something like that, and I remained interested. I was interested in Conan
- 9:35Dole in the first place, because I wouldn't have written that biography. But
- 9:41you know, there was a sort of reason why I wrote about Conan Doyle.
- 9:46So I think that's sort of at the bottom of your question, which
- 9:48is that i'd actually by then i'd written about Kipling, and I was sort
- 9:54of interested in that period, and I in my research on Kipling, I
- 10:00came across this story of Conan Doyle going to the United States after he had
- 10:09he had it sort of abandoned Charlotte Holmes. Initially he killed off Charlotte Homes
- 10:13at the Reicher part Fall, and he was going on a sort of world
- 10:16tour and he went to the United States and he went to visit Rudyard Kipling,
- 10:22who was married to an American woman and was living in Vermont, and
- 10:26the two of them, Conan Dole was accompanied by his brother, and two
- 10:35of them played a game of golf on the sort of rolling fields outside Kipling's
- 10:41home, and that struck my imagination. I don't know why, and I
- 10:46sort of wanted to look at him further. And I approached the the Conan
- 10:52Doyle estate as one does have to as a biographer, but they were sort
- 10:56of in somebody had just died and they were sort of making adjustments, and
- 11:01they didn't want to sort of deal with a biographer at that stage. So
- 11:05I had to to sort of go away and do another biography on Dylan Thomas,
- 11:11a very different character, and then came back to Conan Doyle. And
- 11:18at that moment, as I mentioned the about the state, and it had
- 11:24sort of sorted itself out. One of Conan Doyle's daughter had died and she'd
- 11:31left all her sort of papers, and they were put up for sale at
- 11:37Christie's. And you know, there's a lot of very interesting biographical material there,
- 11:41and that's the sort of thing that a biographer has to get his or
- 11:45her hands on. And I was able to go there and sort of look
- 11:50at these papers even while they were sort of up for sale at Christie's,
- 11:54and then later I was able to to go to people who had bought lots.
- 12:00British Library had some of the most important letters. And there are these
- 12:05rather wonderful people in the United States, the sort of the Sherlockians. They
- 12:13tended to be sort of quite wealthy people like heart surgeons and stuff like that,
- 12:18and they sort of foked out bus sums for these letters. But they
- 12:22were very approachable and allowed me access to it, and so I was able
- 12:26to write my my biography of Conan Doyle. I was also able to visit
- 12:35some university library in the United States which actually had the card of this golf
- 12:41game between Conan Doyle and Kipling, which ended, as they it was a
- 12:46harved game. And I duly did that and it was quite fun. You
- 12:52know. Conan Doyle was somewhat different from Kipling, but still in that in
- 13:01perialist he would call himself a liberal, imperious perhaps genre anyway, that was
- 13:09gosh, that was not getting on, I mean getting on for fifteen years
- 13:15ago, twelve fifteen, something like that. And then I did a couple
- 13:20other things, and actually I was asked, you know, I've sort of
- 13:28kept up an interest in Conan Doyle and in Charlotte Holmes. I'm they're you
- 13:35know, writing about it from time to time. And I was asked by
- 13:37a publisher to do this book on the work, the Worlds of Sherlock Holmes,
- 13:43a sort of illustrated publisher called Francis Lincoln, who are part of the
- 13:48Quarto group. And it's not the kind of publishing I've done before, but
- 13:54it turned out to be a good experience. They produced a really lovely book
- 13:58with wonderful pictures and you know, very nicely good high production values, if
- 14:05you like. And I was able to explore what kind of I hadn't done
- 14:13in my Conan Doyle book, which was to look at Charlotte Holmes really in
- 14:18some ways for the first time, and you know, to look at what
- 14:22went to make up the world of Charlott Holmes. You know, I'm not
- 14:26one of those kind of meticulous people who sort of look at every word of
- 14:35the homes stories. Okay, I have to do that, nevertheless, but
- 14:39I'm more interested in the wider context. So talking about the worlds of Sherlock
- 14:45Holmes, I wanted to look at various things. So one, you know,
- 14:50those various chapters in my book, and one is on the kind of
- 14:56places of Charlotte Holmes, and oh they affected him, and obviously London is
- 15:05right at the center of that. That's well, let's talk if I can
- 15:07interject, let's talk about it. Talk a little bit about that. So
- 15:13do that you spent some time looking at how detective fiction itself evolved through that
- 15:20century, from poemwards, So give us a bit of a comment about that,
- 15:26and then we can have a look at the world of homes specifically.
- 15:31Well, the sort of the detective was beginning to make his mark in the
- 15:41sort of early nineteenth century, if you like, You know that there were
- 15:50various crime novels which emerged at the turn of the century, and the rat
- 16:00Cliff murders were sort of part of the agenda, but the detective didn't really
- 16:07begin to emerge. This is somebody employed to go out and investigate and to
- 16:15you know, according to the Charlotte Holmes formula, to to to observe and
- 16:22deduce what was what was happening. And you begin to see the detectives appearing
- 16:26first in the stories of Edgar Allan Poe who had this detective August Lupin there
- 16:37was another. There were a number of other people who were writing detective stories
- 16:42in the mid nineteenth century. There were sort of a bit they hadn't quite
- 16:52got the hang of the of it. You get detectives getting into other kinds
- 16:59of literature. You get detectives in Dickens, you get inspector Bucket in Gleek
- 17:03House. And one of my favorite detectives is a specter. I think it
- 17:14is Cuff in The Moonstone. That's novel by Wilkie Collins in the mid nineteenth
- 17:19century. But as you also get the sense in that era of people being
- 17:29a bit wary. Actually this is very much the case in The Moonstone people
- 17:33being wary of detectives. There was a sense of they were agents of the
- 17:38state. They came into people's homes and they disrupted family life and detectives had
- 17:49to sort of make their case and they did that initially quite badly. There
- 17:55was a lot of scandal at the early days of Scotland. You a lot
- 18:00of corruption. Nothings changed, you could say, and eventually, uh,
- 18:07you know, you you you get detection becoming more proficient, you get techniques
- 18:15of detection which become accepted practice. You know, one of the ones.
- 18:19In fact, the things, as I'm sure you know, were sort of
- 18:26trials, if you like, in in India for various reasons. Cal Cutter
- 18:32by Hindu and Muslim, hem Chandra boss and as he's all hack and obviously
- 18:37the man who gets the credit is their boss, mister Edward Henry. That's
- 18:41that's true. I was going to say, you know, he was He
- 18:44came back from India and he actually became Commissioner of the Metropolishman Police. A
- 18:48rather formidable, not particularly pleasant character, but you know, you you get
- 18:56that sort of thing coming into of daily practice of the police forces. And
- 19:04you know, obviously a Conan Doyle, so to introduce him, you know,
- 19:11he was interested in that. He was interested in it partly because he
- 19:15had trained as a doctor and he was interested in. He particularly so studied
- 19:26under a famous professor of surgery at Edinburgh University called Joseph Bell, who had
- 19:33this technique of looking at patients and observing and observe and deciding exactly where they
- 19:42came from. And you know famous. This kind of thing that he did
- 19:48was exactly what Charlotte Holmes did when he first met Dr Watson, and he
- 19:56said to Watson, who had just come back from Afghanistan. In fact,
- 20:03he said to uh, to Watson, you you have come from Afghanistan.
- 20:08I perceive that effect. And actually, you know, if I may divert
- 20:15that slightly, that is one of the things that I try and draw out
- 20:22in my book, which is the way that a lot of the things that
- 20:27go on in the stories are sort of blowbacks from Britain's place in the world.
- 20:33So you get Dr Watson coming back from Afghanistan, where he's been,
- 20:38he's been a doctor in fact in this war on the fringes of India,
- 20:45you know, obviously designed to shore up the Empire against the incursions by the
- 20:51by Russia, not by Russia into there. So you know, you lost
- 21:02my thread there of it. So ask another question. Well, let's talk
- 21:04let's talk about the title of the book. Let's talk about the worlds of
- 21:07Sherlock Holmes. Tell us a little bit about what the world was like at
- 21:12that time when Holmes was practicing his craft. Right, Well, I've sort
- 21:18of alluded to it to a certain extent. You know, it was at
- 21:23the height of Britain's sort of role in the world, Britain's empire, and
- 21:36so you get a lot of sort of people coming back from Australia and South
- 21:42Africa they've been mining and they get in. You know, there's a lot
- 21:47of stories that involve people who have this kind of background trying to recover their
- 21:57heritage or whatever it is. So you know, that is a sort of
- 22:03aspect of the world of Charlotte Holmes. Now, obviously it's more than that.
- 22:10I try and talk about London, for example, that's a very bustling
- 22:14city, and you get the sense of Charlotte Holmes living as he does in
- 22:21Baker Street, sort of rushing around London taking handsome cabs. But the world,
- 22:27the world of Charlotte Holmes shows you that, you know, he actually
- 22:33used methods of transport to are just coming on on stream. You get the
- 22:38underground, you get him going on the railways and going out, going out
- 22:44to the country and sort of getting involved in cases in well famously dart More
- 22:49kind of the basketballs. But you know more to it than that. M
- 22:55Now. The other day I can't what day now. I saw the first
- 23:00episode of the Lucy Worsley fronted series about Sherlock and you are a consultant to
- 23:08that series, all right, yeap. And one of the things that came
- 23:12across in that first episode, which I did not know, was that Arthur
- 23:17Conan Doyle came to hate his creation. So what was his what was his
- 23:22reasoning? Why did he why did he hate Chrlock Holmes. Well that's what
- 23:27this series BBC television series is based on. It so sort of it manages
- 23:37to use this this the problems that Conan dor had with Charlotte Holmes to draw
- 23:48up, draw out all sorts of aspects of the author ConA do and his
- 23:55creation, Charlotte Homes. But why did that happen? It was because Conan
- 24:02Doyle, partly because of his upbringing, et cetera, et cetera, he
- 24:10thought that writing for a periodical, the Strand Magazine, where the Charlot Holmes
- 24:15stories first appeared was beneath him. He thought it was you know, I
- 24:21mean it was. It was a periodical magazine, a monthly magazine that was
- 24:26owned by George Nunes, who was a sort of popular magazine publisher who had
- 24:33been made out his money from tip Bits in fact, uh and the Strand
- 24:38magazine was slightly upmarket from that. It was whereas Tipbits was for some kind
- 24:45of newly educated people who sort of this is actually another aspect of the world
- 24:52of homes that you've got, this this sort of new readership coming on the
- 25:00they're newly educated, they're wanting to find out about things. So, okay,
- 25:03now going back again a little bit, and perhaps we'll come back to
- 25:07your question. It was a time of great innovation in it was the sort
- 25:15of the post Darwinian world. People were wanting to find out about the world.
- 25:19They weren't just wanting to find out about the world. They were going
- 25:23out and they were exploring. So it was a great not the great,
- 25:26but a great era of exploration. So going back to Conan Doyle and Sherlock
- 25:37Holmes, Conan Doyle he actually saw himself as a writer of historical novels.
- 25:48He wanted to be like his great mentor not mentor actually his great model,
- 25:55Robert Lewis Stephenson. He wanted to write romantic adventure stories, historical novels,
- 26:00and he did it. He duly did that one. I mean even before
- 26:03he first really got going with with Charlotte Holmes, he'd written a book book,
- 26:08The White Company, which is about one hundred years War, and there
- 26:11were one or two others along those lines. He was very prolific, you
- 26:15know, even wrote poetry actually, but Charlotte Holmes came along. It was
- 26:22the right product at the right time. This magazine, the Strand magazine,
- 26:29which was very influential h had was had just I mean literally a few months
- 26:34before Conan Doyle wrote for it. It had started publication and it was quite
- 26:41successful, and the editor was astute enough to realize that Arlotte Holmes stories were
- 26:51going to going to be well, we're good, you know they well you
- 26:57say that, Andrew. But and it was wildly successful because I believe he
- 27:02wrote a couple of homes novels first, and then the there was a short
- 27:04stories that short story, yeah, the short stories they're actually in in that
- 27:11publication. That that led to his career taking off but if I remember the
- 27:17episode from the other day, one of the things they said was that some
- 27:21of the early reviews for the for the novels were quite awful. I think
- 27:23somebody quoted it was not a bad imitation of a detective story. However,
- 27:29and this will make my colleague very happy. It was. I think the
- 27:34Glasgow Herald were very much more enthusiastic, So that might that. I don't
- 27:41know what that says about the taste of Glaswegians. Probably, yeah, I
- 27:48was gonna say, I mean in that era and up to the era when
- 27:52I was educated. Obviously, the Scottish education system was far superior to the
- 27:56English one, so I would imagine that they were much more astute in there
- 28:00in their understanding of his work for see. Yeah, but I mean when
- 28:04you say the era in which you were educated, I mean that's either the
- 28:07nineteen twenties given your age, or the fact that you only graduated last week.
- 28:14I mean talking about Glasgow. That program, you know, it's still
- 28:18I don't know when this goes out, but it was, it's still on.
- 28:22It's still they've got episodes to go. It was produced in Glasgow,
- 28:26and you know the sort of BBC in Glasgow were responsible. You've banned me
- 28:30from asking you what you're working on next, So I guess the only way
- 28:34to finish this office to say what your hopes and dreams are for the forthcoming
- 28:38cricket season. You know, if this was video, people would realize that
- 28:45I am of a certain age, and you know, I still managed to
- 28:49get out there wonderfully. Well, it increasingly kind of realized that I'm getting
- 28:56towards the end of my career. So you know, my dream is just
- 29:02to get out there and you know, sort of play a few games and
- 29:06perhaps play with you. I tell you what we could ask you, because
- 29:10one of the other pre eminent masters of imperialism, we might say that we
- 29:17just might disagree that you that you did a biography of was Ian Fleming post
- 29:22imperialism. Let's go post imperialism for him the educated view there, Yeah,
- 29:30somebody who well, no, not post imperialism really, but you know,
- 29:34sort of the dying ages of imperialism. I mean, it's a different genre,
- 29:45isn't it. You know, spy novels that you know, it's a
- 29:48very interesting subject which I would you be interested to discuss with you at a
- 29:55later stage in the detective novels and spine novels, and you know the crossover
- 30:00in in thrillers, et cetera, et cetera. Well, maybe if you
- 30:03could just something juicy that you came across while doing the research for Fleming.
- 30:10Uh intrigue was I was the first person I think I'm right in saying to
- 30:17identify and certainly write about his so called Jamaican lover, who actually a very
- 30:23wealthy lady who lived in Jamaica. And but juicy, I mean, you
- 30:32know, there's there's so much about Ian Fleming. You know, there's a
- 30:37lot of wartime activity where he was acting as the personal assistant to the Director
- 30:45of Naval Intelligence, and he had his fingers in all sorts of of espionage
- 30:52pies if you like. But he does. I mean, actually, the
- 30:56the the James Bond stories and they start coming out in nineteen fifty three,
- 31:03and that is very much post war. Britain is sort of just is just
- 31:08coming out of that sort of period of you know, very much post war
- 31:21and it's beginning to engage with the world. It's beginning to understand that you
- 31:27could have fun in the world. And so the James Bond James in Fleming's
- 31:34style is very much full littered with I was going to say, but full
- 31:41of consumer kind of connotations, and he mentions products, et cetera. For
- 31:49the first time. Of course, he's going to wonderful places and people wanted
- 31:55this. But at the same time he's engaging with a world in which the
- 32:00Soviet Union initially is the great a sort of opponent, and then subtly the
- 32:08the the the the villains change and they become less smursh and they become more
- 32:17sort of the the corporate supervillain. But Andrew, it's been absolutely fascinating talking
- 32:23to you. So in the world of Sherlock Holmes is available now. Thank
- 32:29you, I bet do you want to lead us out? And that brings
- 32:31us to the close of another episode. Once again, if you've liked the
- 32:35show, can we ask you to leave a review, sign up for regular
- 32:38episodes using your favorite podcast, and please do spread the word. So Vassi,
- 32:45if we were ever asked to play Sherlock Holmes, how would we tackle
- 32:49the character? And I don't know about you, my friend, but my
- 32:53Sherlock would be addicted to Kate, not cocaine. Yes, that much is
- 32:59obvious, ladies, and gentlemen on that bombshell. Until the next episode,
- 33:01we have been your friends. The Red Hot Chili writers