Latest / Her Legacy: Real stories of women, courage & change / Leaving the Church That Raised Me Behind Forever | Her Legacy
Transcript
- The door didn’t slam. It clicked shut with a soft, final sound that echoed louder than any shout ever could in the empty sanctuary behind me. I stood there for a long time, listening to the silence, realizing it was the first time in my life I hadn’t heard hymns humming in my blood. Do you remember the smell of a church basement? For me, it was a specific cocktail of floor wax, stale coffee, and the faint, dusty scent of old paper from the hymnals we kept in the pews. I grew up in that smell. It’s the scent of my childhood Sundays, wrapped tight in wool suits that scratched my neck and dresses that felt like costumes I couldn’t quite take off. We were the good ones. The quiet ones. The ones who knew exactly where to place their hands during prayer and how to smile just enough to show piety without seeming too eager. I spent twenty-five years curating my faith like a museum exhibit. Every Sunday was an opening night. I memorized the verses before I understood them. I learned to nod at the right moments during sermons about submission and sacrifice. I became an expert in the architecture of belonging. But here is the thing they don’t tell you when you’re raised in a community that demands total transparency: eventually, you run out of things to hide because there’s nothing left to show. You start performing your soul instead of living it. Let’s sit with that for a second. The performance. How many of us have stood in those pews, or sat around kitchen tables after service, smiling while our insides were screaming? I did it for decades. I thought that if I just smiled harder, prayed louder, and served more potlucks, I would finally feel safe. I thought safety was something you earned through obedience. I didn’t know then that safety isn’t a transaction. It’s a feeling. And mine had been missing for a very long time. It wasn’t one big explosion that made me leave. It never is, is it? Women’s exits are rarely dramatic fireworks displays. They are slow erosions. Tiny cracks in the foundation that widen until the whole structure feels unstable beneath your feet. For me, it started with a question. Just one small, quiet question that popped into my head during a particularly dry sermon on women’s roles. Why? Why did our worth hinge on our silence? Why was our joy treated as secondary to our suffering? Why was doubt considered a sin rather than a sign of intelligence? I looked around the room and saw hundreds of women nodding along, their eyes downcast, their pens poised over Bibles that were already dog-eared from years of highlighting the same passages. I realized I was looking at a collective holding pattern. We were all waiting for permission to breathe. What did it cost her? That’s what I asked myself when I thought about the women in my lineage. My grandmother left a marriage that broke her spirit to stay in a church that praised her suffering. My mother stayed in a congregation that shamed her for asking questions. They thought they were being faithful. They thought they were protecting us. But protection shouldn’t feel like suffocation. I looked at their hands, calloused from service but trembling from fear, and I realized I didn’t want to inherit that tremor. I wanted steady hands. I wanted to build something that didn’t require me to shrink to fit inside it. When you decide to leave the place that raised you, you aren’t just leaving a building. You are leaving your history. You are leaving your best friends, your support system, the people who knew you as a child and watched you grow into the woman you were becoming. The grief is real. It is heavy and cold and sits in your chest like a stone. I lost friends. Not all of them, thank God, but enough to make the silence in my own home feel deafening. There were text messages that went unanswered. Invitations that stopped coming. The subtle, cutting remarks disguised as concern: 'Are you sure this is what God wants for you?' or 'You seem so unhappy lately.' As if happiness was a rebellion. As if peace was a betrayal. Tell me more about the silence there. Because once you step away from the noise of the crowd, the quiet can be terrifying. In the church, the noise was constant. Prayers, songs, chatter, validation. Outside, it was just me and my thoughts. And my thoughts were messy. They were full of anger, confusion, and a profound sense of loss. I mourned the version of myself that fit perfectly into that mold. I mourned the certainty I used to have. Certainty is a drug, and withdrawal is brutal. I missed the simplicity of black and white. I missed knowing I was good. I missed being chosen. But here is where the story turns, slowly and softly. In the silence, I began to hear a different voice. Not a booming thunder from above, but a whisper from within. I started to reclaim the sacred. I realized that holiness isn’t confined to stained glass windows or specific days of the week. Holiness is in the way you treat a stranger. It’s in the kindness you offer yourself when you fail. It’s in the courage it takes to say, 'This doesn’t work for me anymore.' I started finding beauty in the unexpected places. A sunset that didn’t need a sermon to explain its glory. A conversation with a friend that felt like communion. The quiet dignity of planting a garden and watching life emerge from the dirt without any divine intervention other than patience and care. I learned that my body was not a temple to be policed, but a home to be inhabited. My mind was not a vessel to be filled with doctrine, but a landscape to be explored. This wasn’t rejection of spirituality. It was expansion of it. I realized that the divine isn’t afraid of my questions. In fact, maybe the divine loves them most. I stopped apologizing for my curiosity. I stopped shrinking my doubts. I let them sit at the table. And surprisingly, they didn’t drive me away. They made me deeper. They made me more human. I found that I could still pray, but now it was a conversation, not a monologue. I could still sing, but now the songs were my own. So, who am I now? I am a woman learning to trust her own pulse. I’ve built a new community, smaller perhaps, but infinitely more honest. These are the people who ask, 'How are you really?' and wait for the answer, even if it’s hard to hear. These are the friends who don’t need me to perform goodness to love me. They love me when I’m angry. They love me when I’m confused. They love me when I’m just tired. We meet in living rooms, not sanctuaries. We share meals that aren’t organized by committees. We talk about politics, art, sex, and pain without the filter of propriety. It’s messy. It’s loud. It’s alive. And it feels like freedom. I think about the women who came before me, and I wonder if they would understand. I hope they do. I hope they see that I haven’t abandoned them. I’ve just carried their legacy forward in a new direction. I carry their resilience. I carry their strength. But I leave behind their shame. I leave behind the idea that my worth is tied to my compliance. I choose complexity over comfort. I choose truth over tradition. And every day, in small ways, I practice the radical act of believing myself. If you are sitting in those pews right now, feeling that familiar itch of discomfort that you’ve learned to ignore, I want to speak to you. I want to tell you that it’s okay to feel it. That ache in your chest? It’s not a lack of faith. It’s a signal. It’s your soul telling you that you are ready for more. Ready for honesty. Ready for a love that doesn’t come with conditions. You don’t have to leave today. You don’t have to make a scene. But you can start by noticing. Notice where you feel small. Notice where you feel seen. Notice which parts of you are being suppressed to keep the peace. Peace purchased with silence is not peace. It’s imprisonment. Let’s sit with that for a second. You are allowed to outgrow the spaces that held you. You are allowed to change your mind. You are allowed to seek a god that fits your heart, not one that fits a handbook. It’s scary. I know it is. I still get scared some days. But the alternative—staying small forever—is scarier. So take a breath. Look around. Listen to the silence. And trust that whatever comes next, you will be enough. Exactly as you are. Right now. Thank you for letting me sit with you in this quiet space today. Be gentle with yourselves. You are doing better than you think. Until next time, keep your ears open and your heart wide. This is Lauren Harrison, signing off.