Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Oops, We Missed A Day with Special Guest Steve Greenfield
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, here we are, day two of ASOTU Con. Day one was out of control. All the comments, the conversations that are having, happening, uh, is everything I think we wanted it to be.
- 0:12So we have Steve Greenfield up here with us today. Hold on, hold on. Let's ask these guys, how many hours of sleep did you get last night? Four hours and 38 minutes, I think was my watch. Crushed it at six hours.
- 0:22I feel amazing. Shut up. Shut up. I really did. He did not get six hours of sleep last night. I totally got six hours. You realize, you did see- No one else out here got six hours. You did see that I have dark rings.
- 0:30You're like a baby. He's a little baby. I am a little baby. [laughs] Yeah. At least you're looking after your health. I... [laughs] You, you look great. I feel great. His beard has less gray than mine does.
- 0:39You can't see him up close, but he looks really great. So Kyle's been telling this story that, um, what was it your wife showed you a picture, was it six years ago? Three, three years ago.
- 0:46Oh, three years ago, right when you decided- It's even worse. It feels like six years. [laughs] Three years ago when Kyle decided to leave the store- Right... and come, and come and work with ASOTU.
- 0:54I had this beautiful, full brown beard. Dark brown. And it's gray. It's all gray. Full of youth. That's years. You guys are gonna need, like, speckled hats soon maybe.
- 1:02Like, your hats are gonna have to reflect the beard color. We're gonna lean into it. All right. [laughs] I'm okay. Well, uh, thank you so much for joining us on the podcast.
- 1:09We, uh, if, uh, we're in front of a, a live breakfast audience today. There's probably 100 and some people in here. Yeah. Hanging out. How are you guys feeling today? [cheers] The, the early crew.
- 1:20Give it up for the early crew. I love it. The early crew. Um, the Maryland Auto Dealer Association is just about 100 yards away from us- Yeah... having their annual meeting in one of the breakouts.
- 1:27They got 100, we stuffed 100 people in a tiny room back there. Yeah. Really? Yeah. It's real tight.
- 1:33[laughs] And then, uh, in another breakout room, we had less people, but we just did a parenting session, which was amazing. That's really cool. Uh, yeah, we got, we have one person who's excited about that.
- 1:42Yeah, one person. Parenting. We got a woo. That's perfect. Um, and so there's just a lot of conversation. I, I don't even know, what is a parenting session? What is that? Um, it's pretty self-explanatory. [laughs] Is it?
- 1:52No, it's not. I feel like, I'm kind of scared to ask, but, uh- This was basically how, how to be, um, a better parent while also being a busy professional. Oh, wow. That's great. It was really cool.
- 2:00The Dalys brought their, uh, family therapist of the decade. I literally- Oh, okay, good. Yeah, bring your therapist to work day. I heard it did. Yeah, yeah, yeah. [laughs] It's a little scary. Shame I missed that.
- 2:08It wa- it was a lot of fun. Well, we're gonna do it again. You can do it with my cats. Yes. Lots of cats. Better cat parent. Oh. Is there therapy, cat therapy? Yeah. I don't know. But either way, go ahead.
- 2:19Yeah, Steve, I, I wanna, we'll get, get into it. I've, I've watched you kind of be almost all over the world recently. Um, and- Yeah, tell me about it. Yeah. You're like, uh, the air- airline miles.
- 2:28[laughs] Yeah, how much sleep did you get last night on a plane? Been on a plane half of, half the first half of the year.
- 2:34But, uh, what I'd, what I'd love to hear from you, you know, we always talk about, like, the relevant news of the day on this podcast, but I'm sure that the conversations that you get to have, 'cause you've been in a couple other countries even recently, are maybe, maybe all the same or a little bit different than what you're hearing in the US.
- 2:52What's been some of the themes or, or one or two of the themes that you've experienced in your travels this year so far? Yeah, it's a good question.
- 3:00So to put it in perspective, two weeks ago I was in Qatar, and, um, you know, here, here you've got a country that, um, oil and gas was discovered in, uh, 75 years ago, 1939.
- 3:11And n- now 300,000 Qataris live in that country. 300,000- Wow... in the entire country, and they have 15% of all the oil and gas on the face of the earth. Oh. Oh, my goodness.
- 3:22So the, these per capita are the, are the most affluent people in the world, but when you fly in, like, it's all desert. It's all desert. That's incredible. So it's inhospitable. So it's a very interesting juxtaposition.
- 3:32And ironically, I was there for a mobility conference where they're pushing autonomous and electrification, and it didn't take me 24 hours, I'm not the smartest guy in the world, but I'm like, "Why on earth, if you're sitting on, like, 15% of all the oil in the world- Do you want electrification...
- 3:45do you give a crap?" It's a threat to, to, to, to- Yeah, I was gonna say, are they, like-... move to electrification... are they, like, look grumpy when you get there? [laughs] Yeah, exactly right. What is that?
- 3:53So very interesting dynamics over there, but it's, it's sort of like i- in the world where you've got all the money you, you could ever spend, you, you need something to differentiate.
- 4:02So they have the world's best airport in Qatar. Right.
- 4:05And th- this is the world in the Middle East where if you, if you can get a single-digit license plate for your Lamborghini, the license plate costs $10 million literally, right?
- 4:14So you, you need status symbols just to stand out. So very interesting. Wait, wait, so you're saying you can buy a $10 million license plate because it's got one through 10, or one through nine? That's, that's correct.
- 4:23Wow. And it's just to show, like- If you think, if, if your neighbors can, can, can, could own 100 Lamborghinis, what's the one way you can stand out? You need to own something that nobody else can own. There's scarcity.
- 4:32One through nine. That's right. Only nine people. Exactly right. Wow. Exactly. Are they transferable? So that's one. And then, you know, I was in Amsterdam on...
- 4:37Ironically, I, I was presenting at Am- in Amsterdam on Tuesday at noon, and I was here at 1:30 in the morning. [laughs] You know, that same day. Thank you. So that's, that's weird.
- 4:47I, I saw that on your calendar- That was weird. I was like-... and I was like-... "How does that work?"... "Are we sure Steve's coming to ASOTU Con?" Yeah, how does that work? And Kyle's like, "He has a room."
- 4:53[laughs] And I connected through, uh, Atlanta.
- 4:54But the interesting thing about Amsterdam to juxtapose, it's, like, one of the most livable, walkable co- countries and cities on the face of the earth, very green, and at 4:30 I was walking out to get...
- 5:05The night before, I was get- walking out to get something to eat, and I mean, you re- really have to be careful because of the bike paths. Everyone bikes there. Everyone's biking, yeah.
- 5:13And at 4:30, everybody's out of work. So it's, like, traffic jams of bikes on these bike paths, which is really interesting to see.
- 5:20But, um, you know, they're the, the quote-unquote 15-minute city where people live within 15 minutes of everything they need, and can either walk or bike to the grocery store, to the movie theater, to the shopping malls, uh, their, their, their place of work and the parks.
- 5:36It's, it's very, very interesting to see, right? So they have the density to be able to do that and the climate.
- 5:41But I mean, to your point, ju- juxtaposing these, uh, interesting places around the world, the other, the other o- observation I'll have is, you know, this level five autonomy, like, that may never happen in the US with the Cruises and, and the Waymos.
- 5:55Um, in, in, in countries that, you know, where they have top-down control, China, for example, or, or the Middle East, where you've got a monarchy who controls the whole country, I mean, they can just cram through-Level five autonomy.
- 6:07I mean, it's, it's gonna happen. You're gonna go to some of these countries, and you won't be able to drive. No one will be driving. Yeah. No one will be driving, because it w- it will be mandated.
- 6:15I mean, I think there's little doubt that if, if a country was able to switch to 100% autonomy, there will be few- fewer deaths. Sure, yeah. Fewer accidents. 'Cause everything's talking to each other. Yeah.
- 6:24But, but in the US, where we are, I mean, we're never gonna get there, but these countries that can cram down the decision from the top down will, will binary flip, like, kinda like Norway has with EVs, will flip over to a- autonomous vehicles.
- 6:37And then you'll, you'll go there, and you'll be like, "There isn't a car with a driver." And I think that'll all happen within the next five or 10 years in some of these countries. Wow, five to 10 years. Yes.
- 6:46That's nuts. No drivers. It is nuts. But, uh, but, uh, I don't think any time, I don't know how long I'm gonna be on this earth, but I mean, no time in my lifetime will we have level five autonomy in the US.
- 6:56It'll be like these edge cases where you can get into a Waymo in Phoenix, but only when the weather's perfect. Yes. Yeah. That's ne- ne- ne- where you guys live, six months out of the year- Yeah...
- 7:07you know- Well, where I live. He's like, "Don't group me in with that." Where, where you live- Yeah. [laughs]... six, s- four to, four to six months out of the year- Yeah, in snow...
- 7:13snow and salt and stuff- Variables, yeah... are gonna crust over the lenses on the Tesla cameras. Yep. So you can't have full autonomy in, in, you know, where you live is, like, the same as me.
- 7:22You might get 10 months out of the year, but we get wicked thunderstorms. Absolutely, yeah.
- 7:26And during a thunderstorm, by the way, 5G doesn't work, so the connectivity to the cloud isn't gonna work in a car, and definitely, like, all those lenses get fogged up, so the cars are basically gonna just turn off, go to the side of the road and park, and say, "Hey, Kyle, take over, because I don't wanna risk you."
- 7:41That's unbelievable.
- 7:42Just things that you don't think about or, or that aren't being talked about, especially in the landscape of, like, in the political landscape, where the idealism of these things sometimes overrides the realty of it- Yeah...
- 7:55the, the reality of it. Um, it, it, so I wanna go back to, like, the Qatar EV thing.
- 8:01Is that, like, is there interest in that just because they know that they can still ship the oil everywhere else around the world, and for them it's a status symbol to have all EVs in the country, basically?
- 8:11Well, my, my sense is, so, so they have almost every single passenger bus all electrified already, and the, the next step will be to get every passenger vehicle electrified.
- 8:20As you can imagine, the EVs aren't manufactured there, so they're coming from China. So all, all these vehicles coming in are, are, are Chinese vehicles, right?
- 8:28China's a big exporter of cars in general, and EVs specifically, and I think it's, it's gonna be bragging rights, like the single-digit Lamborghini license plate.
- 8:36It's like if they can go to 100% electrification and 100% autonomy first- They'll tell the world about it... fir- first country in the world that does so.
- 8:44It's the same reason that they spent $3 billion on an airport to have the best airport in the world, which is, like, mind-blowing when you go into this airport. Yeah, I saw, you made a post about it.
- 8:52It's like a shopping mall. Yeah. It's, it's really amazing. But, you know, they, they need bragging rights.
- 8:55They've got all the money in the world, so they can spend an unlimited amount of money on anything they want to achieve.
- 9:00So it's achieving things first, and then having the bragging rights in the Middle East and globally to say, "We got there first." That's, that, that's all I think it is. But yeah, they- All EVs...
- 9:09they have to have a high degree of confidence. Yeah. That countries like y- the US and other countries- Will keep oil raging, yeah... will continue to burn the oil- Yeah... until it's all gone. [laughs] And they will.
- 9:20It's crazy. All right, so that's a- And they will... much more broad stroke, but you also spend a lot of time on the ground, boots on ground, with dealers, especially in the US, considering, like, what's top of mind.
- 9:29We, we kinda asked the question during the podcast yesterday, what are people asking about? And I think, uh, someone said, uh, "What do the salespeople know?
- 9:36Can, can a, can a consumer actually get educated at a dealership?" And then the other one was, "What's my monthly payment?" Right?
- 9:43Are you experiencing those same things, or is there, are there other things that you're hearing dealers talk about a- as, like, the boots on ground this month right now?
- 9:51Yeah, I, I think we, we're hearing all of it real time on the stage thanks to you guys bringing dealers up here that are, like, you know, very forward-thinking.
- 9:57I think, uh, a lot of it is around what front-end grosses are gonna be on EVs versus ICE vehicles.
- 10:03What I, what I'm challenged with, and I, I don't know if we've heard this yet, but if you've got a salesperson and a consumer comes in, even with the intent to buy an EV, and I size up this consumer, I'm like, "I'm gonna make a lot less gross on that EV than an ICE car," why wouldn't the salesperson do their best to- To switch them...
- 10:19flip them over to an ICE car? So, and, and that, that's gonna get worse this year. If we get more supply- More high, more supply...
- 10:25with fixed demand, I mean, margins on the front end of, of, of EV- EVs are gonna- Sometimes zero. Or they're gonna be negative. In the negative, yeah. Like, they're gonna be well into negative.
- 10:32Like, a dealer's gonna literally look and say, "Ugh, oh my God, I gotta, I gotta help the OEM now move these EVs. I gotta take a loss on every single car."
- 10:39And then somebody who's getting a commission is gonna be like, "I get, I get no commission on that car. Why would I encourage the consumer to buy the EV? I'm gonna flip them over to an ICE vehicle." Yeah.
- 10:48So there will be dysfunctional dynamics. Specifically a 2022 ICE vehicle, right? Yes, right. Used car. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, because of margin compression, all that type of stuff. Right, yeah.
- 10:57So yeah, so un- unintentionally we'll continue to leave EVs on the lot. Right. Right? Yeah. And, and, and then, you know, the OEM has no choice but to come in over top with more incentives and more incentives.
- 11:06So where you saw Ford lose $5 billion in their EV division last year, the, the, the, the blood loss on these EV divisions will be really bad, really, really bad. Like, it's already bad enough.
- 11:16You hear Ford losing 30 or 40 grand per car sold in their EV divisions.
- 11:21It's gonna get far worse, and then, you know, the CEOs of these companies are gonna be like, the Wall Street analysts are gonna say, "Well, how much longer are you gonna spend money on these, these, like, atrocious losses in your EV operations," right?
- 11:32So I, I do believe EVs get far too much stage time- Mm-hmm... at conferences in general, but it's gonna get really, really ugly here, I think. I, I, I don't know the right way out of this. It feels like speed wobbles.
- 11:44You know, like, you watch a skateboarder go down a fast hill, and then all of a sudden you see they correct this way, then they over-correct, then they over-correct. This feels like just the next in the overcorrections.
- 11:53Yeah. Where now, like, there was a story this week we talked about where Nissan is asking dealers to help move the inventory. They're like, "We have no more money to put in the truck," right?
- 12:01Like, "We need you to help move it." And the consumer, from the consumer's perspective, you see that EVs are getting cheaper.Right? Uh, we were talking about my sister was like, "I have $300 a month.
- 12:10Here's the need, here's my life." I was like, "IONIQ 5," right? Right. Yeah. However, like, that's not a realistic, profitable- No... like, mentality, but consumer's like, "Oh, you know what? Maybe EVs are affordable."
- 12:21So adoption- And then you-... seems to speed up for a bit of time. But it's still not profitable. You, you, you can ju- juice sales. I mean- Artificially, yeah...
- 12:26we, we know that most consumers, as dealers will tell you, are payment shoppers. And, you know, if you give me a 299 a month on something with little down, I'm like, "I'm all in."
- 12:34At, like- I don't really care what it is. At 18-month commitment, if I don't like it, I only have it for 18 months. Right.
- 12:39And you're not taking the residual risk, so even if EV prices in two to three years are, like, in the toilet, then I'm not taking the residual risk.
- 12:46So there's gonna be all these cars coming back, and the captive finance companies are gonna be taking massive losses in three years, right? So it's, it's a very interesting dynamic.
- 12:53Yeah, I'm thinking about the speed wobbles. That's, that's my mental space. Speed wobbles. Well, yeah, and not just that, but you're, uh, like, we also may not see the impact of this for two or three years. Right. Right?
- 13:02Which is the crazy thing. W- w- actually, it's a very similar thing that's happening right now with lease returns and the impact that we aren't seeing from, from early COVID and the, the lack of used car inventory.
- 13:14Lack of cars. Right? That's right. So it's a similar, like- It may be the opposite... trailing return thing. Could be the opposite. Yeah, it's, yeah. Yeah, we have too many EVs. Yes.
- 13:20And, you know, if they keep innovating, which they are, and, and the new generation of EVs come out, and they have more range and can be charged faster- Yep, and we haven't-... and have new technology products...
- 13:28figured out the pace of trade cycle management... no one's gonna want these three-year-old EVs, right? Yeah. So it's gonna even hurt more in terms of the residual values.
- 13:33It's the same thing as nobody wants the one-year-old, two-year-old iPhone, right? Right.
- 13:37It's, it's that same type of innovation that's, that's much quicker in the R&D cycle for these OEMs, and so that's dangerous for, you know, people not wanting these things. Right, right. Wow.
- 13:47Well, um, we are 10 minutes to the start- Whoa... of day two, so roll the outro music if you would. [outro music] There it is. There it is. I like that power. Steve- That's cool. [laughs]...
- 13:56thank you so much for being a part of this event, for always being generous with your time and your insights, and, uh, your travel plans. We live vicariously through your travel. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 14:04Well, kudos to you guys. Great conference. Let's hear a round of applause for these two dudes. [outro music] Uh, thank you. Sure. [outro music] Yeah, great. [outro music]