Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court Allows States to Bar Insanity Defenses
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grasso from Bloomberg Radio
- 0:05Speaker 1: on Monday. The Supreme Court rule that states can essentially
- 0:09Speaker 1: eliminate the insanity defense in a six to three ruling
- 0:12Speaker 1: with an unusual lineup joining me is Jordan Reuben, Bloomberg
- 0:16Speaker 1: Law Legal Editor. So Jordan's the defend in here was
- 0:19Speaker 1: accused of four murders. What kind of defense did he
- 0:23Speaker 1: want to mount? The defendant, James Kaylor, wanted to mount
- 0:27Speaker 1: an insanity defense by showing essentially that he wasn't responsible
- 0:33Speaker 1: because he didn't know the difference between right and wrong.
- 0:36Speaker 1: What the courts have called the moral incapacity defense. How
- 0:40Speaker 1: is that different from what most states recognize as an
- 0:44Speaker 1: insanity defense? So he might have actually been able to
- 0:49Speaker 1: raise that sort of defense in most states, But unfortunately
- 0:53Speaker 1: for him anyway, he was prosecuted in Kansas, which, along
- 0:58Speaker 1: with a handful of other states, doesn't recognize such a defense.
- 1:01Speaker 1: And so that's the issue that wound up coming up
- 1:04Speaker 1: on appeal is whether he was allowed to mount that
- 1:07Speaker 1: sort of insanity defense or whether he was limited by
- 1:12Speaker 1: a narrower version of the defense allowed in states like
- 1:16Speaker 1: Kansas where he was prosecuted explain the differences of proof
- 1:21Speaker 1: between those two defenses. Sure, So, taking Kansas for example,
- 1:28Speaker 1: where the defendant James Kaylor was prosecuted here, at trial,
- 1:32Speaker 1: he would have been allowed to show that because of
- 1:35Speaker 1: any mental illness that he had that for some reason
- 1:39Speaker 1: that prevented him from forming the required intent in order
- 1:43Speaker 1: to commit the crime. Also at the sentencing phase, he
- 1:47Speaker 1: was allowed to present evidence of mental illness as mitigation evidence.
- 1:52Speaker 1: What he couldn't do, though, was show at trial that
- 1:55Speaker 1: because of his mental illness, the fact that he didn't
- 1:59Speaker 1: know the difference between right and wrong, he couldn't use
- 2:02Speaker 1: that sort of insanity defense in order to be exonerated.
- 2:07Speaker 1: So it was a six to three decision. It was
- 2:11Speaker 1: Elana Kagan who wrote the majority opinion, and she was
- 2:16Speaker 1: joined by all of the conservative justices, which is an
- 2:19Speaker 1: unusual lineup right. So, you know, in some criminal cases
- 2:24Speaker 1: and in some other cases in general, we do see
- 2:26Speaker 1: this sort of classic five for ideological split. We see
- 2:31Speaker 1: those lines skewed, and in fact, in most cases most
- 2:34Speaker 1: cases are not that sort of typical five for split.
- 2:38Speaker 1: And this would be an example of a case obviously
- 2:41Speaker 1: that doesn't align neatly along with that narrative. Now. Justice Kagan,
- 2:46Speaker 1: of course, is one of the four Democratic appointees on
- 2:50Speaker 1: the Court. However, in addition to some criminal cases not
- 2:53Speaker 1: neatly falling along these ideological makeups, she's also probably to
- 2:59Speaker 1: the right, if you will, on the left side of
- 3:01Speaker 1: the court. So now it's not the most surprising thing
- 3:04Speaker 1: in the world, but of course it is noteworthy in
- 3:06Speaker 1: some respects to point out, so explain what her decision
- 3:12Speaker 1: laid out. Sure, so, really the question, in one way
- 3:17Speaker 1: to look at it, was what sort of leeway do
- 3:19Speaker 1: states have in fashioning the types of insanity defenses that
- 3:24Speaker 1: defendants are allowed to raise. James Kaylor and other defendants
- 3:28Speaker 1: raising similar claims and people supporting him, their argument was
- 3:32Speaker 1: essentially that what Kansas offered, they said, they offered a
- 3:36Speaker 1: type of insanity defense, but by not allowing a defendant
- 3:40Speaker 1: to put his moral culpability on the line in terms
- 3:44Speaker 1: of using that to being able to be acquitted. By
- 3:46Speaker 1: not allowing that, their argument was essentially that these states
- 3:49Speaker 1: really don't actually have an insanity defense in the sense
- 3:52Speaker 1: that the U. S. Constitution allows. Now, the Supreme Court
- 3:56Speaker 1: said that that's not true the U. S. Constitution. It's
- 3:59Speaker 1: due process clause doesn't require states to allow this sort
- 4:03Speaker 1: of moral incapacity defense, and in ruling that, the Supreme
- 4:08Speaker 1: Court gave states leeway to fashion different types of insanity
- 4:12Speaker 1: defense systems along the lines of Kansas's systems. So certainly
- 4:17Speaker 1: victory for states looking to have more leeway and fashioning
- 4:21Speaker 1: their systems, and a loss for people who were advocating
- 4:24Speaker 1: for the more traditional insanity defense, which has been allowed
- 4:29Speaker 1: over the years and may well have been allowed in
- 4:31Speaker 1: most other jurisdictions. Decides states like Kansas. Justice Stephen Bryer
- 4:36Speaker 1: wrote the dissent tell us what his reasoning was. Well,
- 4:40Speaker 1: his reasoning is along the lines of what the defendant
- 4:44Speaker 1: here was saying that the type of insanity defense that
- 4:47Speaker 1: he wanted to raise, that's really the core type of
- 4:50Speaker 1: insanity defense, going back at least to the founding of
- 4:54Speaker 1: this country, and that the majority's decision essentially hollows out
- 4:58Speaker 1: any real insanity defense that defendants are allowed to raise.
- 5:02Speaker 1: That essentially, there isn't an insanity defense when you're not
- 5:06Speaker 1: allowed to put your moral blame worthiness on the line.
- 5:09Speaker 1: And it was a rather lengthy and spirited descent from Brier,
- 5:13Speaker 1: and he was joined by the remaining to a democratic
- 5:16Speaker 1: appointees Justices Ginsburg and Soda Mayor, and really his the
- 5:22Speaker 1: whole case really is a case about history. The majority
- 5:25Speaker 1: looks at history and says, based on history, this type
- 5:29Speaker 1: of insanity defense that the defendant wanted isn't so firmly
- 5:34Speaker 1: rooted in the nation that it's something that the u
- 5:36Speaker 1: s Constitution requires. The descent looks at history and it
- 5:40Speaker 1: comes to the opposite conclusion, saying that being able to
- 5:43Speaker 1: put one's moral culpability on the line really goes to
- 5:47Speaker 1: the heart of the criminal justice system. So it really
- 5:51Speaker 1: was a fundamental disagreement between the majority and the descents here.
- 5:55Speaker 1: The states that have this along with candidates, it seems
- 5:59Speaker 1: sort of region. It's Alaska, Idaho, Montana, and Utah. Any
- 6:03Speaker 1: specific why those states, Well, every state sort of does
- 6:08Speaker 1: its own things, so to speak. And Justice Cagan did
- 6:11Speaker 1: note that those handful of states do similarly have a
- 6:15Speaker 1: system like Kansas. But even beyond that, Justice Cagan noted
- 6:20Speaker 1: in her opinion that a ruling for the defendant Kaylor
- 6:23Speaker 1: would have required striking down those sorts of laws in
- 6:27Speaker 1: those states, not just that, but also some sixteen other states.
- 6:31Speaker 1: So every state has its own specifics in terms of
- 6:36Speaker 1: how it carries out its criminal justice system. And that's
- 6:39Speaker 1: kind of really the issue at the heart of the case.
- 6:41Speaker 1: It's a federalism question in some ways of what are
- 6:45Speaker 1: states allowed to do? What is the US Constitution which
- 6:49Speaker 1: sets essentially the minimum that states have to do? What
- 6:52Speaker 1: does it require? Now, the Supreme Court, the majority didn't
- 6:56Speaker 1: necessarily answer the question of what minimum is re hired
- 7:00Speaker 1: by a state. Really, all that the Court held here
- 7:03Speaker 1: is what Kansas does and its insanity defense system is
- 7:07Speaker 1: good enough. And it left open the question for another
- 7:10Speaker 1: day whether states can fully outright abolish the insanity defense
- 7:14Speaker 1: or whether a state that doesn't allow what Kansas allows
- 7:18Speaker 1: would be good enough. And so we would just have
- 7:20Speaker 1: to see, potentially in a future case, really what the
- 7:24Speaker 1: limits of the Kaylor case is. And Jordan's when the
- 7:29Speaker 1: justices initially took the case, did they say they would
- 7:33Speaker 1: decide whether states can abolish the insanity defense? And then
- 7:36Speaker 1: they came up with a much narrower rule, right, So
- 7:40Speaker 1: the question that was presented by the defendant Kaylor's petition,
- 7:45Speaker 1: was ken states abolished the insanity defense, And so that's
- 7:49Speaker 1: that's a pretty bold question and that got a lot
- 7:51Speaker 1: of people's attention now, And this happens sometimes in Supreme
- 7:55Speaker 1: Court's decisions. The justices they want to decide as narrowly
- 7:59Speaker 1: as possible, will at least they'll say so a lot
- 8:02Speaker 1: of times when they discuss cases. And in a footnote
- 8:05Speaker 1: in Justice Kegan's decision, she made clear that they weren't
- 8:09Speaker 1: deciding this bigger question of kennas States outright abolished the
- 8:13Speaker 1: insanity defense. All they were saying, according to the majority,
- 8:17Speaker 1: According to the majority, was that Kansas didn't abolish its
- 8:21Speaker 1: insanity defense here. What Kansas was doing here was good enough.
- 8:25Speaker 1: So in some respects it was a narrower ruling than
- 8:28Speaker 1: one that some court watchers perhaps expected when cert was
- 8:32Speaker 1: granted in the case. Some legal experts are saying that
- 8:36Speaker 1: this is basically the Kansas rule basically does eliminate the
- 8:40Speaker 1: insanity defense. Right. It's trompted an interesting debate, at least
- 8:46Speaker 1: in the academic community and among lawyers, of is there
- 8:50Speaker 1: really something you can call in insanity defense in a
- 8:52Speaker 1: scheme like Kansas is so. For example, Justice Cagan's opinion
- 8:57Speaker 1: pointed out the fact that a defendant can use their
- 9:01Speaker 1: mental illness to show that they couldn't form the required
- 9:04Speaker 1: intent to commit a crime. Now, sort of the rejoinder
- 9:08Speaker 1: to that, in terms of saying that that doesn't really
- 9:10Speaker 1: count for an insanity defense of any sort, is that
- 9:13Speaker 1: prosecutors in criminal cases have to prove criminal intent anyway,
- 9:18Speaker 1: and so calling that an insanity defense is sort of
- 9:21Speaker 1: a redundancy. It's basically just doubly stating what prosecutors have
- 9:26Speaker 1: to prove, and according to people who aligned with Justice
- 9:30Speaker 1: Brier's dissenting view, doesn't really amount to something you could
- 9:33Speaker 1: really call a true insanity defense. So what are the
- 9:37Speaker 1: implications of this decision, Well, it remains to be seen.
- 9:41Speaker 1: As we are discussing earlier, the Court was only talking
- 9:44Speaker 1: about Kansas's scheme here, and so if other states systems
- 9:48Speaker 1: wind up coming up and being pressed in front of
- 9:51Speaker 1: the court, they could wind up taking a sort of
- 9:54Speaker 1: state by state approach if the Court would examine the
- 9:57Speaker 1: particulars of every state. One thing that we can be
- 9:59Speaker 1: sure or of, at least according to Justice Cagan's opinion
- 10:02Speaker 1: is that the opposite decision and upending the upending the
- 10:06Speaker 1: status quo certainly would have resulted from the majorities you
- 10:10Speaker 1: anyway and having to strike down laws in more than
- 10:13Speaker 1: twenty states, So really, what the decision does is it
- 10:17Speaker 1: upholds the status quo. But of course that's super important
- 10:20Speaker 1: for descendants like James Kaylor and others in similar states
- 10:24Speaker 1: and trying to press similar appeals who are hoping that
- 10:27Speaker 1: the Supreme Court would say that more is required than
- 10:30Speaker 1: what Kansas in similar states have done with their insanity defensives.
- 10:34Speaker 1: Thanks Jordan's that was George Rubens, Jim Brooke Law Editor.
- 10:38Speaker 1: Yeah yea