Latest / Psychopharmacology Today / Ep. 13: Prescriptive Authority (Finally!) Comes to Hawaii
Transcript
- 0:05I'm very excited about the two guests that are with me today.
- 0:08We'll introduce them shortly. I am Dr.
- 0:10George Kapalka, the program director of the Master of Science
- 0:15in Clinical Psychopharmacology at the California School of Professional Psychology,
- 0:21which is part of Alliant University.
- 0:23My first guest is Dr. Judi Steinman,
- 0:26who is actually a former director of this program.
- 0:29I took over the helm right after she was leading the program and thrilled
- 0:33to have her back. And we will be talking today with Dr.
- 0:37Steinman specifically about some of the recent developments in Hawaii.
- 0:42And we'll get to these very shortly.
- 0:44But first I got to introduce
- 0:46Dr. James Phelps, who is a great colleague of mine for about a year now.
- 0:53We share our concern about treatment of bipolar
- 0:59and the use of antidepressants that sometimes takes place.
- 1:03So we'll talk more about that.
- 1:04So let me start with Dr. Steinman.
- 1:06Some really exciting developments in Hawaii.
- 1:10Please tell us about it.
- 1:11I would say so!
- 1:13~ ~ After about 40 years of trying,
- 1:17Hawaii has finally passed a prescriptive authority bill.
- 1:21It is in the form of a pilot study,
- 1:24a three-year pilot study that will be on two of the islands that have
- 1:29the lowest number of psychiatrists and prescribers available.
- 1:35So, Kauai and Hawaii Island.
- 1:39And so ~ the bill allows us to
- 1:43have prescribing psychologists trained at FQHCs,
- 1:48Federally Qualified Health Centers.
- 1:51There's one on Kauai, there's several on Hawaii Island.
- 1:56We're recruiting people to participate,
- 1:59and because it's only three years,
- 2:03we're encouraging people to come to Hawaii if they are
- 2:07a prescribing psychologist someplace else.
- 2:12And if they are interested in training,
- 2:14if you're already a Hawaii resident,
- 2:16that we can start you in the training process through Alliant or through
- 2:22one of the other MSCP programs so that you'll be able to participate at
- 2:27the end of the study, at least.
- 2:29How do you anticipate the credentialing will take place,
- 2:34the timeline, how long it will be before psychologists actually start to
- 2:40be able to exercise those privileges in Hawaii?
- 2:44Well, Act 266, which is the official rules,
- 2:48is ~ asking the Board of Psychology to come up with the credentialing requirements.
- 2:55So we are in the process of that.
- 2:57Fortunately, over the 15 years that I've been involved in Hawaii,
- 3:01we have written a lot of bills,
- 3:03we have gotten ~ a lot of input into the kind of requirements that there would be.
- 3:09We have reviewed all of the different states in terms of what their requirements are
- 3:14for ~ ~ oversight, for education requirements,
- 3:20for clinical training, etc. So ~ you know,
- 3:24we're the ninth state to be able to prescribe now.
- 3:27So fortunately we have a roadmap that we can follow and we don't have
- 3:32to reinvent the wheel there. So ~ the Board of Psychology ~ had asked
- 3:38for two years; they got 15 minutes,
- 3:41so... I exaggerate a little bit.
- 3:44But we're already in the process of working to make that happen.
- 3:49That's great to hear. And ~ have you started to reach out to folks
- 3:54who may be in Hawaii or are interested in coming to Hawaii
- 3:58to think about prescribing there?
- 4:01Absolutely!
- 4:02So there is a woman who
- 4:04has passed the PEP exam. ~ She has had her MSCP for several years now.
- 4:11And ~ when the bill first started we went through a lot of iterations on the bill.
- 4:17And we ended up with ~ being able to be on both Kauai and Hawaii Island.
- 4:24But it started out as just being on Kauai.
- 4:27And she said, "I'm not gonna leave Hawaii Island.
- 4:30I don't think I can help you." But when we included Hawaii Island,
- 4:34it's like people have been coming out of the woodwork and saying,
- 4:37"I want to get the training" or "I'm already trained and ready to go,
- 4:42and I live up the street from the FQHC." So it's really exciting.
- 4:47We just want to be able to help everybody that we can.
- 4:51We forget sometimes, but this is access to care.
- 4:55That really is our primary concern.
- 4:58There have been a lot of people who have said we're not safe.
- 5:02You know, they're concerns
- 5:04that people have, and we would like to help people see
- 5:09how valuable prescribing psychologists can be.
- 5:12And so hopefully there will be more people that respond either to this that we're
- 5:18posting or ~ you know just to contact me directly and we will
- 5:24get as many people involved as we can.
- 5:28And ~ access to care is I know that's something that is very close to your heart
- 5:33and something you're very interested in.
- 5:35~ I wonder if you have some thoughts about ~ the movement
- 5:40of prescribing psychologists now coming to Hawaii and the role
- 5:47of that profession to kind of fill in some of the treatment gaps that exist
- 5:52in so many parts of the country.
- 5:54I do have some
- 5:55thoughts on that, George. ~ I've been interested in the notion
- 5:58of prescribing psychologists for a long time after watching some colleagues
- 6:03try to bring that forth in Oregon.
- 6:05And my experience
- 6:06in Oregon was working for almost the last 20 years very closely with primary care
- 6:11and seeing what primary care is capable of doing in terms
- 6:15of delivering mental health services and knowing where they struggle
- 6:18and knowing that being able to refer to a mental health professional
- 6:23who can prescribe is something they so desperately need.
- 6:27So knowing that psychiatry has not been able to really muster
- 6:32the forces to provide that access.
- 6:35And in fact, our numbers are dwindling rather than growing in terms
- 6:39of addressing this access problem.
- 6:41It's time for us, I think, to turn elsewhere and say,
- 6:45okay, not only is this another potential workforce,
- 6:49but this is a workforce with an ideal set of training who
- 6:52can bring psychotherapy and medications and hold them up alongside one another,
- 6:58which very few professionals can do,
- 7:01and certainly isn't happening in primary care.
- 7:03So, yeah, I have several
- 7:04reasons to be interested in what you're doing and thankful that you're doing it.
- 7:08I'm curious,
- 7:10you've mentioned that ~ there are shortages
- 7:14of psychiatrists ~ really in most parts of the US.
- 7:20What are your thoughts about some of the dynamics behind some of those shortages?
- 7:26Well, as you know, there's a tendency for psychiatrists to go to urban centers.
- 7:30~ Often, the urban centers where they train.
- 7:34Which means the training centers,
- 7:35they're among the few places in the United States where there might be enough.
- 7:40So in New York I was recently discovering,
- 7:42~ you actually can get to a psychiatrist in New York.
- 7:45But in Oregon... You know, what happens to someone who has a first episode
- 7:51of psychosis when primary care cannot refer them to a psychiatrist?
- 7:57What happens to someone who comes in presenting with a complex depression and
- 8:02it's in primary care? ~ As you know,
- 8:05my area of interest is in bipolar disorders and particularly non-manic presentations
- 8:10of bipolar. And what are the kinds of assessments that take place in primary care
- 8:15to assess possible bipolarity and reasons not to use an antidepressant?
- 8:19It's just not happening. There are multiple reasons to think we need some change
- 8:24here and psychiatry, organized psychiatry has just not come forth with that.
- 8:29Can I respond to that as well?
- 8:31In one of the previous years that we were trying to
- 8:34get prescriptive authority passed in Hawaii,
- 8:37there was a primary care physician who wrote a letter to the newspaper
- 8:43and had heard about our bill. And he said,
- 8:46"I can handle the diabetes, I can handle the hypertension,
- 8:49but if I have a patient who comes in and is floridly psychotic,
- 8:54I really am not trained to be able
- 8:57to address that. So I can't really treat that patient at all because
- 9:03we can't communicate." So, he said we would be their best friends.
- 9:08And I think that that is... I mean,
- 9:10George, you have the experience,
- 9:12but I think that is the way it works with primary care providers
- 9:17and prescribing psychologists.
- 9:19I do. I've been a
- 9:22prescribing psychologist now in New Mexico for about nine years,
- 9:28but I had obtained my training in psychopharmacology earlier.
- 9:32And for a number of years I was ~ working very closely with primary
- 9:39care practitioners. In my case it was pediatricians because my area
- 9:43of specialty is primarily children and adolescents.
- 9:46But I've encountered the same situations in conversations with pediatricians
- 9:51frequently where, because of the shortages of mental health prescribers,
- 9:56they had to be the ones to prescribe psychotropic medications because
- 10:01no one else would.
- 10:02Because it simply wasn't you know access to care.
- 10:06But they felt not well-prepared to handle some
- 10:11of those psychotropic medications.
- 10:14And this goes to something that you and I will be talking about
- 10:19in another episode that we will be recording shortly.
- 10:22But the fact that primary care practitioners,
- 10:26because they have limited experience and training in mental health,
- 10:31tend to be comfortable with
- 10:32only some types of medications,
- 10:34some types of psychotropic medications,
- 10:36right? So for pediatricians it might be stimulants for ADHD.
- 10:41For primary care practitioners who treat primarily adults,
- 10:45it usually is antidepressants,
- 10:47right? So then we get into a situation where because
- 10:54antidepressants are the medications
- 10:59that primary care practitioners may have most experience with
- 11:03and are most comfortable prescribing,
- 11:05then those medications end up being used the most frequently.
- 11:08A separate question really is,
- 11:10is that appropriate for the patient?
- 11:12Right.
- 11:13Right, the old adage, "If all you have is a hammer,
- 11:15everything looks like a nail." ~ So there are lots of variations of
- 11:19~ depression and some of them have enough bipolarity in them that antidepressants
- 11:24can make things worse. So if all you have is antidepressants,
- 11:27you're in a position... It's very unfortunate,
- 11:30the primary care providers are trying to do their best and they're being asked
- 11:34to do so many things. But when the only tool that they have available
- 11:38has the capacity to actually make things worse
- 11:41when the sophistication of the assessment isn't possible for them.
- 11:45We've just set them up to be in a very unfortunate position and their patients
- 11:50as well. So we can do better than that.
- 11:52So the Hawaii bill, before it ~ actually
- 11:56got sent from the legislature to the governor to let it pass,
- 12:02they had a version of the bill that would only
- 12:06let us prescribe SSRIs and SNRIs
- 12:11and only diagnose depression and GAD.
- 12:16But it was so remarkably restricted that several of us said,
- 12:21why are we bothering? Let's come back next
- 12:24year and try with a full bill.
- 12:26But at the end of the day, when we went to conference committee,
- 12:30our leaders within the legislature got us that full formulary.
- 12:36The only exclusion is no opioids.
- 12:39It would be helpful if we could prescribe buprenorphine.
- 12:42But okay, we can address that.
- 12:45And there is an age restriction,
- 12:47which I think is very unfortunate because
- 12:50~ our youth... So it's 18 to 65 years of age we can prescribe to.
- 12:56And so we miss the opportunity to help our youth and our "kupuna"
- 13:02or our older patients, but one step at a time.
- 13:06Yeah.
- 13:07I'm so glad that your committee did not allow it to be so restricted because that
- 13:12would just actually continue the problem.
- 13:15It doesn't solve anything.
- 13:16That's what I was thinking. It actually plays into what we were just talking about,
- 13:20the fact that antidepressants,
- 13:22again, would be the medications that would be promoted because prescribing
- 13:26psychologists could prescribe those medications and not others.
- 13:31I agree a hundred percent.
- 13:33Yeah, so this really ~ opens up the issue of,
- 13:37again, the benefits of prescribing psychologists and the
- 13:43way that they can fill those those gaps,
- 13:47because if the formulary includes the full range of psychotropic medications,
- 13:53right, then we can exercise some of our strengths.
- 13:58Our strengths as a profession,
- 14:00in addition to being able to prescribe
- 14:03medications but of course we're trained in psychotherapy,
- 14:06we get tremendous amount of training in that while we become psychologists
- 14:09in the first place. We're very highly trained in psychological assessment,
- 14:13which really helps to clarify some of the issues we were just talking about.
- 14:17For example, is this really a version of bipolar that the patient is presenting?
- 14:25Having tools that have to do with the ability to provide psychotherapy,
- 14:29strong skills in assessment, and now being able to prescribe medications as well,
- 14:35we're able to combine those to provide more comprehensive health care.
- 14:41And as studies have shown by Dr.
- 14:43Hughes specifically, because he...
- 14:45Dr. Hughes, for those of you not familiar with him,
- 14:48is actually, I believe, an economist;
- 14:50he was interested in medical economics.
- 14:54Phillip's background is in pharmaceutical strategy.
- 14:58So his doctoral ~ dissertation
- 15:03was on various aspects of safety and function of prescribing psychologists.
- 15:10So there's also a woman, Alicia Clemens,
- 15:13and she is an economist. And she's published several things now
- 15:18on safety and efficacy.
- 15:20So we have these at least two lines of investigators
- 15:25now that are looking at the safety and the extent
- 15:31to which allowing psychologists to prescribe medications really does fill those
- 15:38treatment gaps. ~ I know there's data from ~ New Mexico
- 15:44and from Louisiana showing that the trajectory ~
- 15:50regarding rates of suicide has
- 15:53~ lowered after psychologists started to prescribe medications.
- 15:59So this again kinda goes back to the idea that the more tools you have,
- 16:04the more effective you can be to intervene in a variety of ways to meet some
- 16:10of the service gaps ~ in the country.
- 16:15There's an irony there in that the comparison,
- 16:18the inherent comparison being made is with psychiatric care.
- 16:22Well, what if there is no psychiatric care?
- 16:25Now the comparison value is nothing.
- 16:28So what is the relative safety of a prescribing psychologist relative to nothing?
- 16:33That's the relevant comparison
- 16:36in a setting where access is not possible.
- 16:39So we did a study
- 16:40in New Mexico of a single office or clinic that
- 16:45has eight prescribing psychologists.
- 16:47And it was found that they had seen 5,000 patients over
- 16:53a seven-year period in two-thirds of the counties in all of New Mexico.
- 16:59So they were able to, you know,
- 17:01go to different places. They drive or now with telehealth they're able
- 17:05to participate that way.
- 17:08But ~ ~ ~ a large population has steady service now as a result
- 17:14of them being established. You know,
- 17:18we can make a difference.
- 17:19Yeah.
- 17:20Yeah. And I'd like to go back to again to kind of look at it
- 17:26in another way, but very similar to what you said,
- 17:29it's psychiatry or nothing. So often as we've mentioned earlier in our interview,
- 17:35it's really psychiatry or primary care.
- 17:37Those are really
- 17:40the choices that patients have,
- 17:42and with the shortage of psychiatry,
- 17:44so many patients that need mental health treatment end up in primary care.
- 17:48Right? So what's the role of psychologists who can have some training
- 17:55in psychopharmacology?
- 17:56Well, they can become very valuable to these primary care professionals
- 18:01who in many states still, unless other options become available,
- 18:06right? But if there are no prescribing psychologists,
- 18:09if the rates of other psychiatric prescribers are not rising very quickly,
- 18:16right? ~ And there are still psychiatric shortages,
- 18:20the bottom line is those patients will mostly go to primary care professionals.
- 18:26So then the benefit for psychologists of obtaining psychopharmacology training,
- 18:31even if they cannot immediately become prescribers because their state
- 18:36has not yet enacted that, those psychologists can enter into close
- 18:43collaborative relationships with primary care practitioners,
- 18:47and having that extra toolbox of not prescribing it
- 18:51but understanding psychiatric medications,
- 18:54their effects, ~
- 18:55understanding for what patient populations and set of symptoms certain psychotropic
- 19:02medications are good targets, are good treatments for those,
- 19:07but not for others, right? So being able to make a difference between which
- 19:11set of symptoms are likely to respond to which medications really helps
- 19:16a psychologist with this kind of training to guide the primary care prescribers
- 19:22who still do a lot of this prescribing and help
- 19:25them actually select the medication that would be more appropriate
- 19:28for that particular patient.
- 19:30Yeah, so you're right. When I say "nothing," I mean over and above what
- 19:34a primary care provider can do when they have no assistance in the way that
- 19:37you just described.
- 19:38And that's still such a situation in so many states in the country.
- 19:43And again, going back to pediatrics,
- 19:45you know, three-quarters or more by some studies,
- 19:4885% of all psychotropic medications for pediatric patients
- 19:52are written by pediatricians. And to go back to again,
- 19:56especially if you're a teenager,
- 19:58if you see a case where
- 20:03you're beginning to see some symptoms of bipolarity,
- 20:06some signs of that coming out,
- 20:08right, how prepared is the pediatrician to recognize that?
- 20:12So the nominal age of onset, the most typical age of onset for bipolar variations
- 20:17is around 18 as a median. But it really starts at puberty in terms of when
- 20:23the first manifestations begin to show up.
- 20:25So yeah, this is a pediatric issue,
- 20:29~ particularly for diagnosis for the majority of people with bipolarity.
- 20:34That's why I continue to push for states that have restrictions to try
- 20:39to lift those restrictions. I know in Illinois they just lifted the top
- 20:44end of their restrictions ~ just a few weeks ago;
- 20:48they're now allowed to prescribe to people from
- 20:5218 up to whatever.
- 20:55So we are now allowed to include our ~ geriatric patients.
- 21:02So you know, it's the same end of the scale,
- 21:05but if we could get in and help children,
- 21:09~ you know, it would make a big difference
- 21:13So much to look forward to. Hawaii,
- 21:16our ninth state in terms of our RxP progress.
- 21:20We had two states pass in 2026.
- 21:25First time that's ever happened,
- 21:26we are very excited about that and also looking at it in another way,
- 21:30we've had four states pass in the last four years.
- 21:33So on average we've been able to do one state per year.
- 21:37We certainly hope that this momentum will increase.
- 21:41I guess in closing my thoughts,
- 21:44and I look forward to yours as well,
- 21:47is one:
- 21:48hopefully this movement continues to grow and states continue
- 21:52to recognize the benefit of passing prescriptive authority
- 21:58for appropriately trained psychologists because it can really help meet
- 22:02the service needs in that particular state.
- 22:05And in states where that's not happening yet,
- 22:10it is very beneficial for psychologists to obtain this training even
- 22:14if they can't prescribe immediately because they can really help
- 22:18the existing providers within the state treat their patients better,
- 22:22understand their patients' needs a little bit better,
- 22:26have some additional choices.
- 22:29I'd like to just throw in, in case there are people who are interested
- 22:33in Hawaii to either move there or who are already there.
- 22:37There's a very unique program offered through
- 22:42the state agency; It's called the HOME RUN project.
- 22:47And so for upskilling, so if you want to advance your profession,
- 22:53they allot $50,000 to a person.
- 22:57If you ~ are a nurse practitioner or physician,
- 23:02I think they allot up to $80,000.
- 23:05But that's money that could go to somebody's education or just
- 23:09to supporting them while they're getting their education.
- 23:12So I encourage people to
- 23:14apply for that HOME RUN program.
- 23:17And you can reach me directly:
- 23:19judi.steinman@yahoo.com. And ~ you'll find me and I
- 23:26can help you further along your interests.
- 23:29Excellent. Thank you. Thank you,
- 23:31Dr. Steinman. Dr. Phelps, final thoughts?
- 23:34More power to you. Keep going.
- 23:36Thank you. And it's thanks to people like you.
- 23:39Right.
- 23:39Thank you, Dr. Phelps, for supporting us.
- 23:42It really means a lot to our profession.
- 23:44Thank you. So thank you again,
- 23:46Dr. Phelps, Dr. Steinman for joining me.
- 23:49I'm Dr. George Kapalka, Director of the MS in ~ Clinical Psychopharmacology
- 23:54at Alliant University. And we will see you next time.