Latest / NEURO MOTION LAB / Mini season NML Episode 8 False Self-Esteem- Why “Thinking Positive” Is Not Enough
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to Neuro Motion Lab, where we explore the fascinating
- 0:14intersection of neuroscience and athletic performance.
- 0:17I'm Fabio Gida, Physical Therapist, trainer, mental
- 0:21performance coach and I'm passionate about helping
- 0:24athletes like you to reach your full potential.
- 0:42Hello, hello and welcome to Narrow Motion Lab podcast, the
- 0:48space where mind and body work together to or give the best
- 0:52possible performance. My name is Fabian Gida and in
- 0:56this mini season we are exploring something that often
- 1:00goes unnoticed, how the nervous system regulates our emotions,
- 1:05our decisions, our motivation and even our identity.
- 1:11In previous episodes we talked about the habit of urgency, the
- 1:15fear of feeling OK or if you're feeling good, motivation as
- 1:20biological signal, and how overthinking is often a symptom
- 1:25of internal uncertainty. Today we're going to explore a
- 1:30topic that everyone thinks they understand but that is often
- 1:36misunderstood. Today we are talking about self
- 1:42esteem, but no the superficial self esteem.
- 1:48You know, the one that you hear in the multivocal quotes or self
- 1:52helps book or Instagram reels. Know that one, We're going to
- 1:58talk about something deeper. We're going to explore the
- 2:02difference between cognitive self esteem and neural security,
- 2:09and why positive thinking alone is often no enough to make us
- 2:15feel safe or confident. OK, well we need to put this in
- 2:21context. For many years we were taught
- 2:26something very simple. If you want to improve yourself
- 2:31esteem, you need to change your thoughts, thinking better about
- 2:36yourself. Repeat positive affirmation.
- 2:40Convince yourself that you are capable.
- 2:44You have probably heard phrases like repeat every day that you
- 2:49are successful or your mind doesn't distinguish between what
- 2:54is real and what is imagined, or if you affirm it enough, you
- 3:01will believe and created. Well, the idea is almost
- 3:08attractive, it's simple and most importantly, it promises
- 3:13something very temptating fast change.
- 3:19But many people discover something strange when they try
- 3:25to do this. When someone repeats affirmation
- 3:29like I'm capable or everything will fine with me or I trust
- 3:35myself, something curious often happen.
- 3:40The mindsets says one thing, but the body responds differently.
- 3:47And then an inevitable question appears.
- 3:52Why doesn't my body believe me? To understand this, we need to
- 3:58clarify what science actually supports and what is doesn't.
- 4:04The brain does not work only through talks.
- 4:10It operates through electrical, chemical and physiological
- 4:14signals. Every thought we have is
- 4:19literally a pattern of electrical activity across a
- 4:22neural network. This is billions of neurons
- 4:27communicating through electrical impulse, generating a small
- 4:31electrical fills. In other words, the brains
- 4:35produce measurable electrical activity.
- 4:39But there is another organ that generates an even more interest
- 4:44electrical fill. You know what we're talking
- 4:47about. We're talking about the heart.
- 4:50The heart also works through electrical impulse.
- 4:54Each heartbeat is triggered by an electrical signal that
- 4:59coordinates the contraction of the cardiac muscles.
- 5:03That activity generates an electromagnetical field that can
- 5:08be measured around the body through electrocardiographic
- 5:12method. Research from the Hertmann
- 5:16Institute here in California has shown that the electromagnetic
- 5:21field of the heart can be detected approximately 1 to 2
- 5:26meters radio around the body using highly sensitive
- 5:31magnometers. Physical speaking, the heart
- 5:37electric field is stronger than the brain, simple because the
- 5:41cardiac muscle is larger and produce a highly synchronized
- 5:46signal. But beyond the physic, what
- 5:50becomes truly interesting is how the brain and the heart
- 5:55communicate. They are constantly interacting
- 5:58through the autonomic nervous system, especially through the
- 6:02bagus nerve. And remember, about 80% of the
- 6:07vagus nerve's fibers are afferent, meaning they carry
- 6:13information from the body to the brain.
- 6:16This means what we think influence what we feel, but what
- 6:22we feel influence our thinking even more.
- 6:29When someone repeats a positive affirmation but internally feels
- 6:33fear, doubt or insecurity, something very common happens.
- 6:39Thoughts and emotion are not aligned, and prefrontal cortex
- 6:44might generate the thought. I'm capable, but the limbicist,
- 6:48the limbic system may be sending a completely different signal.
- 6:53This is danger. The body respond primarily to
- 6:58the emotional signal, not just to the thought.
- 7:03That's is why many information fail, not because the idea is
- 7:09absurd, but because the internal signals lacks coherence.
- 7:16This bring us to an important concept in neurophysiology known
- 7:22as psychophysiological coherence.
- 7:28When the brain, the nervous system and the heart are aligned
- 7:32in the same emotional state, such a calm, confidence or focus
- 7:39and attention, psychological patterns become more
- 7:43synchronizer. Breathing becomes more stable,
- 7:47heart rate variability becomes more organized.
- 7:50Brain networks show more coordinated activity.
- 7:55In that state, thoughts and emotion no longer compete.
- 8:00They reinforce each other, and the information has stopped
- 8:04being just a phrase. It becomes a felt internal
- 8:09experience. Summer School of thoughts,
- 8:14especially contemplative psychology or interpretation
- 8:19inspired by quantum metaphors, use this idea to describe
- 8:24something larger, the idea that when our thoughts and emotion
- 8:29align, we are sending a coherent signal to our environment.
- 8:36From a strict, specific scientific perspective, there is
- 8:42no evidence that we are really sending signals to this quantum
- 8:48universe. But something very real does
- 8:52happen when thoughts, emotion, and Physiology are aligned.
- 8:58Our behavior change, we make different decisions, we move
- 9:03with greater clarity, we persist longer, we perceive
- 9:08opportunities more effectively. From the outside it may appear
- 9:13almost magical, but in reality it's a simple internal coherence
- 9:19turning into effective action. In other words, affirmation do
- 9:25not work when they are are just words.
- 9:29They work when they become coherent internal states, when
- 9:34the mind, the body and the emotional systems are sending
- 9:38the same signal. Because at that point we are no
- 9:43longer trying to convince ourself of something.
- 9:47We are experiencing it. Well, now we're going to talk
- 9:53about the structures involving in this process because to
- 9:57understand self esteem neurologically, we need to take
- 10:00a look at some key brain structures involving in the
- 10:06sense of internal safety or insecurity.
- 10:10Let's talk about the amygdala. The amygdala is a small
- 10:13structure in the limbic system, in the limbic system specialized
- 10:17in detecting threats. And these threats are not only
- 10:21physical because human evolved in social environments.
- 10:26Many threats are social, like rejection, humiliation,
- 10:31evaluation, critical evaluation, public failure, loss of status.
- 10:39Imagine a simple situation. Someone in a meeting is suddenly
- 10:45asked to explain something in front of everyone.
- 10:51Before the person even has time to think, the amygdala
- 10:56evaluates. Is this safe Safe.
- 10:59Or is danger for me if that person had an uncomfortable
- 11:04experience speaking in public in the past, The amygdala may
- 11:09trigger an alarm response. Those alarms traduce in heart
- 11:16rate increase breathing accelerate muscle tones came
- 11:21high so the muscle are tense, cortisol is released.
- 11:27All of this happened before a conscience thought.
- 11:32That is why people often say, I know I shouldn't be nervous, but
- 11:37my body reacts anyway. Well, let's talk about another
- 11:43structure. Another key structure is the
- 11:46hippocampus. It's participate in contextual
- 11:50memory, helping the brain compare present situation with
- 11:55past experiences. If someone had repeated negative
- 12:01experience, harsh criticism of the school, public
- 12:05embarrassment, or visible mistakes, The hippocampus helps
- 12:10reactive that emotional context when a similar situation
- 12:15appears. The brain doesn't necessarily
- 12:18think I'm going to fail in stain, it's run a faster
- 12:23prediction. This feels like something that
- 12:27used to be danger. Can you feel the difference?
- 12:31So the system prepared itself not to perform better, but to
- 12:37protect itself. Let's talk about the prefrontal
- 12:41cortex. The prefrontal cortex is
- 12:43responsible for resigning, planning and self-control.
- 12:50It's allowed us to reflect, analyze situation, and create
- 12:54strategies. It's also the region must self
- 12:59help methods attempt to activate.
- 13:02When we repeat affirmation, we are mainly activate prefrontal
- 13:07cognitive processes. The problem is that the
- 13:12prefrontal cortex does not work alone.
- 13:17It consciously interact with the limbic system and when the
- 13:22limbic system 3 signals become too strong, prefrontal
- 13:27efficiency decrease. In simple terms, thinking better
- 13:33do not always make you or us feels better.
- 13:40Well, without neurochemistry, that is no function.
- 13:44So we're going to talk about a little bit about the
- 13:47neurochemistry, the neurochemistry of confidence.
- 13:51Beyond brain structures, several molecules influence how
- 13:55confidence or insecurity is felt in the body.
- 14:00Dopamine is often associated with pleasure, but its primary
- 14:04function is anticipation and motivation.
- 14:08When the brain perceives A realistic possibility of success
- 14:12or learning, dopamine increase that generates energy,
- 14:16curiosity, initiative, and movement toward action.
- 14:23But when the brain predicts risk or failure, dopamine drops.
- 14:30Tasks begin to fall less attractive and more difficult
- 14:35than they actually are. Let's talk about a little
- 14:38cortisol. Cortisol is the main stress
- 14:41hormone. In a moderate level, it can
- 14:44improve performance. But when cortisol remains
- 14:49elevated for long periods, the nervous system start
- 14:53interpreting many situations as threats.
- 14:57Confidence decrease not because the person lack ability but
- 15:02because the system is operating in a protection mode.
- 15:07Talking about GABA, GABA is the brain main inhibitory
- 15:13neurotransmitters. It acts like breaking system for
- 15:18excessive neural activation. When GABA system function well,
- 15:25a person can experience pressure or challenge without anxiety
- 15:30escalating uncomfortably. And this is crucial for
- 15:36confidence because confidence do not mean absent of activation,
- 15:41it's means being able to sustain activation without losing
- 15:47regulation. Let's see the deep psychology
- 15:51involving on this in from a deeper perspective.
- 15:56Self esteem can be understood not as an opinion about our
- 16:03self, but as the implicit story that the nervous system has
- 16:09learned about who we are. Neurologically speaking,
- 16:13personality is not an essence. Personality is an habit of
- 16:19nervous system that eventually becomes identity.
- 16:24That story is built through thousand of micro experience.
- 16:31How our partners reacted when we tried something new, what
- 16:37happened when we made mistakes. Whatever the emotional
- 16:43environment, respond with support or with curiosity or
- 16:49criticism or shame. Over time, the brain construct
- 16:53an internal model, a map that silence answer 1 fundamental
- 17:00question. Am I someone who can handle life
- 17:05or someone who needs to protect myself from it?
- 17:13That might, that might influence everything, the decision we
- 17:16make, the opportunities with avoid the goals we believe are
- 17:23possible. Something to reflect you people.
- 17:28Well, as usual on this channel, I want to leave you with some
- 17:32practical tools and one important question.
- 17:37If real confident is not building through positive
- 17:40thinking alone, how is builded? The answer is simple.
- 17:48Confidence is built through regulated experience.
- 17:52No through phrases. OK, let's stop talking and go to
- 17:58the actions go to the tools. The first tool is progressive
- 18:03micro challenge. The nervous systems learns best
- 18:07when facing challenge slightly above of our comfort zone.
- 18:13Example speaking in a small meeting If you're afraid to
- 18:17speak in a in front of a big audience, Speaking in in front
- 18:21of a small meeting, sharing an idea with a few people, making a
- 18:26decision. We use to avoid each small
- 18:31success update the brain internals prediction dopamine
- 18:35increase and the brain update It's as a map 2 grow exposed to
- 18:43uncertainty. Confident is not built by
- 18:48eliminate risk. It's built by learning that we
- 18:52can tolerate uncertainty without collapsing.
- 18:57This strengthens communicate between the prefrontal cortex
- 19:02and the limbic system. 3 Psychological regulation.
- 19:08Body state directly effects mental states.
- 19:14But you repeat that because it's very important.
- 19:16Body state directly effects mental states.
- 19:21Breathing, movement, physical training, sleep, and recovery
- 19:27all regulate the nervous system, and more regulated system
- 19:33process pressure more effectively. 4 Reinterpreting
- 19:38discomfort Many people interpret psychological activation as a
- 19:44sign of incapacity, but often that activation simple means the
- 19:50system is preparing for something important.
- 19:54Learning to tolerance that activation change the entire
- 19:59experience. Well, perhaps the most important
- 20:03idea from this episode is this. Real confidence is not the
- 20:09absence of fear, it is the repeated experience of moving
- 20:15forward even when fears appears. The nervous system do not learn
- 20:24confidence from motivational phrases.
- 20:28It learns confidence by accumulating evidence.
- 20:32Evidence that we can try, that we can fail, that we can adapt,
- 20:39that we can keep moving. When enough evidence accumulate,
- 20:47something shift. Identity begins to transform.
- 20:52And what ones feel impossible beings to feel natural?
- 20:59Well, well, well, what a deep topic for today episodes, isn't
- 21:05it? If you know someone who is a so
- 21:08confusing self esteem with neural security, share this
- 21:13episode with them. And if you haven't subscribed
- 21:16yet, follow me on Neuromotion Lab Podcast on Spotify, Apple
- 21:22Podcast, or Amazon. Help us to spray the idea that
- 21:26human performance is not only about strain or discipline and
- 21:31it is about deep nervous system regulation.
- 21:36In our next episode #9 of this 10 episode mini season, we will
- 21:43explore another powerful topic. The topic is tolerance for
- 21:49discomfort. Why some people grow under
- 21:54pressure while others shoot down.
- 21:59Wow. OK, this was never emotional A
- 22:04podcast. My name is Fabian Gida.
- 22:08And remember, when we understand how our nervous system works, we
- 22:16stop fighting ourselves and we begin working with the system
- 22:22that truly drives our lives. See you in the next episode.
- 22:29Bye.