Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Taking Hand-Raising Ownership, Kyle Hits an OEM Bone, and A Massive Fed Pivot
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Hey, it is Thursday morning, December 16th. Kyle and I just braved the Windy City, and it was really windy. That was some kind of takeoff we had last night. Whoo. But we're ready to go.
- 0:12Got a lot to talk about.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know/ Who I is and who I be/ They stop and stare when they see me/ If I said I once, no need to repeat/ I've had a lot of takeoffs- Front up on me, watch her for a week/ Tip my hat when it's cold outside-...
- 0:23in my day, and I have to say, flying [laughs] out of O'Hare last night was a sporty one That was fun We had a lot of straight line winds.
- 0:30And, uh, yeah, I'd rather be taking off in heavy wind [ding] than landing in heavy wind. [laughs] Right. Yeah. 'Cause when you're taking off, you're like- 'Cause you got the engines behind you. They're like- Right.
- 0:39You just, you just punch it, and as long as you have enough thrust to pull you forward, right, and go up, like, yeah, it might be a little weird, but you're, you're gonna be fine. So we made it home last night.
- 0:49A beautiful day in Chicago. We had an amazing time at the Refuel event that, uh, Joe Chirha, Dealer Inspire, Cars.com put on. And let me just say, Jocko. [laughs] He came, he came hard. He d- he wasn't messing around.
- 1:05He called people out. It was great. And had a couple funny moments to boot. Like, he's, he- Yeah...
- 1:10he, he catches the, the serious, the intense, and catches the little, little quips and jabs, too, so- Uh, my- It was really good...
- 1:16my favorite quip, so he's talking about covering and moving, and he's like, "All right, let me explain cover and move." He's like, "One guy shoots, and what happens when one guy's shooting? The enemy ducks, right?
- 1:27So the other guy moves to a better position, and then he shoots, and then I move." He goes, "But what happens if Joe," and he points at Joe Chirha, who's in the front row, "Joe's moving, I'm supposed to be shooting."
- 1:38He's like, "And then I think, you know, I'm kind of thirsty." [laughs] "I think I'm gonna pull out my canteen and take a little drink. What are they gonna do?" He's like, "They're gonna shoot Joe."
- 1:47And then he points at Joe, he goes, "Sorry, Joe." And then he looks next to Joe Chirha's wife is sitting next to him, and he goes, so he goes, "Sorry, Joe, ma'am." [laughs] And that's his, like- [laughs]...
- 1:58giving his, giving his fake condolences to Joe's wife- Like a little condolence. [laughs]... for taking a drink out of his canteen. But either way, [laughs] so there were a lot of great moments.
- 2:06Um, but the biggest takeaway from Jocko, and I think we can all own this as an industry, is that extreme ownership mentality that instead of, he said the, the, the bad Navy SEAL leaders, the young leaders, and you know they're gonna be a bad leader or they are c- currently a bad leader, they come in and the mission goes wrong.
- 2:22And you're like, "Well, what happened?" In a training exercise. And they're like, "Well, that guy didn't do what he was supposed to do, that guy didn't do what he was supposed to do, and that guy didn't do what...
- 2:29And if they would all get it together, we would be successful," right? And then every- he says everybody starts pointing their finger at everybody else. But if the leader comes in and says, "You know what?
- 2:38It was my job to make sure this was taken care of. I didn't do it" And he goes down the line. He goes, "You know what happens? Just the opposite. Everyone else says, 'No, actually, I could have done this better.
- 2:48I should have done this better.'" And so that element of ownership, I think, is, is just, it's so simple to understand, and it's so hard to execute, too.
- 2:57And I think I'm gonna go, speaking of [ding] taking ownership for something not going right. Stop. Segue. Time.
- 3:04[upbeat music] So Kyle had a bit of a firecracker of a post last night, and, you know, he was like, "I hit a nerve." I was like, "I think you hit a bone," [laughs] right?
- 3:15[laughs] And I'm gonna let Kyle explain the post and the fallout.
- 3:20I, you know, I was really concerned this morning that I was gonna reach out to you, and I wasn't gonna get a response because you were bound and gagged [ding] in either, like, the Stellantis basement or CarSaver's, you know, trunk of a CarSaver [laughs] CEO car.
- 3:33[laughs] But all that, what happened yesterday, Kyle? Yeah.
- 3:36Well, well, so let me just first say, look, I wanna give a little commentary on Jocko's thing because I think a lot of times we can, we can segment that to mean, uh, s- super locally, uh, taking ownership.
- 3:49Um, but it's also globally. So i- you know, th- there's this, uh, especially in automotive, like, everything is, whatever's wrong i- is wrong because of someone else, right?
- 3:59Whether it be locally, like that person didn't, you know, get the deal done, or that person didn't, you know, communicate well with that customer, or that manufacturer, you know, doesn't know what they're doing, or that whatever.
- 4:12So, um, I, I wanna just say, like, that hit, that struck me, right, is, uh, especially with the post that I'm just about to talk about, is, like, calling out some of the, the faulty stuff out there.
- 4:25And so not to, not to say altogether that we can't call out wrongs or call out y- you know, things where people aren't executing.
- 4:32Um, but I do think that we have to be careful to, to ensure that we have solutions on the other end, and that we do take our appropriate, uh, level of ownership, so- Yeah, like you gotta raise- The post- You gotta raise your hand, too.
- 4:42Yes. Right? Exactly. You can't, you can't just point the finger. You raise your hand first, and then you call out, right? So the post. So the post. So the post- [laughs]...
- 4:51was essentially calling out the, uh, the OEM, uh, structured.
- 4:56And it w- not the, and, and I wasn't particularly talking about, like, the co-op programs where we have multiple people in where it's like these are the approved providers.
- 5:03But the ones where the OEMs have created direct relationships to create a shopping experience that is OEM branded.
- 5:11So, uh, the ones that, that, that I kinda called out was the Nissan at Home, ShopClickDrive, and eShop, though there are a few others, right?
- 5:19But that, uh, the, the, the segmentation of the customer journey, also, uh, the actual user experience of those platforms, um, is just not up to par with where the rest of the industry, the, the, the privates that are, that are doing some of the, the really cool things on, on the DR platform's side are doing.
- 5:40Or, uh, people outside of our industry are doing from a commerce perspective and a UX, UI- So what you're saying is they're not, you have to put an asterisk next to it. Well, that's okay for an OEM branded site, right?
- 5:55Right. It's not, you can't say, like, "That's a good site." You can be like, "Well, that's better than all the other ones." Right. Exactly.
- 6:01But in no way is it-Up to par with what the consumer expectation is or what is being put out elsewhere in the market. Exactly.
- 6:08And, I mean, obviously, uh, you know, the, the, the, the marketing managers and the DR companies and all of that kinda came, uh, alongside and said, "Yes, this is a problem."
- 6:19There was some pushback in some areas like, "Hey, from an OEM perspective, we've got to own the customer experience."
- 6:26And so this is a piece of owning the customer experience, making sure that it, it feels good to buy a brand X from any one of our stores. So I, I see both sides and I understand it.
- 6:38I just think that right now it's an us versus them battle, and it needs to be a all of us versus problem battle, because the problem is, is that- Well, summarize the post. Summarize the post.
- 6:49[laughs] Summarize it in a sentence. These programs inhibit innovation at the dealership level for the most innovative dealers. Right. Especially the force-fed ones. Right. Okay. Which then, which then
- 7:06basically inhibits really, really positive customer experience, which is the w- uh, which is the end goal of all of this, right? Right. Which then inhibits the perception of the retail automotive industry,
- 7:19which then empowers the barbarians at the gate. Yeah. The end. Full stop. It's, it's, it's a, it's a trickle effect that, like, we just think is just one little...
- 7:30You know, it's like, oh, it bounces to a subdo- it, it bounces to an alternate do- domain that the dealership doesn't own. No.
- 7:37It sh- it, it doesn't do well to care for the culture of our stores and the perception of the automotive retail industry, and so people are gonna buy from Tesla. Right. Right.
- 7:46[laughs] Let's start with that as the main goal, right? That's the winning the war part, right? We're not trying to win a battle of a platform or, uh, you know what I mean, a certain experience.
- 7:55We're trying to win the war. Trying to win the war. Yeah. And what...
- 7:58You know, and when posts like that come up, right, and it has, like, 10,000 views this morning, and, you know, like, the, the data shows, your data shows that, like, you know, the target is right.
- 8:07You're getting re- connection requests, and when you look at who's se- looking at the post, it's all people at OEMs and, you know, big players. Big players.
- 8:15And I think it's easy in these moments, right, to, to think or mistake the fact that someone would put something like that up just to create, like, the dog pile effect, right? When... 'Cause it's- Yeah...
- 8:27really easy to dog pile on, on something negative, especially in, in the environment that we're in. But that's not the intention. The intention is actually to get ex- extreme accountability on both sides.
- 8:39Because even though the OEM seems to be force-feeding it, look, look, it would be great if an executive or someone at the OEM... Can you imagine for a second if somebody at the OEM was just like, "Hey,
- 8:51look, I know we've done a bad job. We've been trying to do well, right? We're not trying to do, to do a poor job." Yes. "But when we look at it, we're, we're doing a bad job. And we want the innovators.
- 9:02We have the budget for innovation, right? We wanna have more of a culture of collaboration and innovation so we can... We wanna be...
- 9:08We, we have the resources to put forth the most technologically savvy, retail-facing, you know, portal or experience in the world. We could set the mark and set the bar right here." Right. "We're gonna do that.
- 9:21We've done a bad job. Who's with us?" You know, to go back to that Jocko example. If they... If somebody was just willing to do that, but they're not. Like, you get defensive leadership. It's ego-driven.
- 9:33And, like, when Jocko yesterday was talking about the number one trait you look for, humility,
- 9:38I think if, if an ounce of humility came from an OEM, instead of that power play, "I'm gonna show you that I'm boss by forcing you into these things," that would change the whole conversation, I believe. And I...
- 9:49Uh, we need- Yeah... an OEM that's brave enough to do it. Yeah. Absolutely. And, and, like, it, and it doesn't... It's not, it's not to say, like, you're doing everything wrong. No.
- 10:00It's just, hey, maybe this is an area that you need- Not at all... new insight, fresh insight. Someone that you haven't listened to or heard from before.
- 10:07And, and what if that just, like, totally unhinges y- o- your whole experience- It will... and, and pushes it forward. Yeah. You could- It'd be crazy... you could be the benchmark. You could be the benchmark.
- 10:18And look- Yeah... a lot of people have reached out, you know, especially, like, you know, I'll say lower level representatives, area reps, saying like, "Hey, help us understand more. We'd love to...
- 10:29You know, we do this and this. Help us understand this." It's like, that's not gonna cut it. Right. That's not gonna cut it.
- 10:35Like, we need to go up the chain of command to have meaningful conversations with someone at the top who sets the tone. Because if that area level rep might be very empathetic and really wanna change it, but guess what?
- 10:45If the top of the chain is ego-driven and not humble and doesn't understand that this is an actual problem, it just doesn't matter. We're wasting our time.
- 10:51We're better off just innovating outside the OEM and figuring workarounds, which is really- Yeah... what it is.
- 10:56The game is, how can I work around my OEM because I don't have any faith that they're gonna give me the best experience. Right. Exactly. And that sucks. And, and- That sucks. Let me- We all lose... let me also be clear.
- 11:05Like, this is s- so there were a couple comments yesterday, both in, like, back channels and, and on threads, that was like, "Yeah, but there are dealers killing it with these platforms," right? Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
- 11:15And I wanna be very clear. Like, one, we're in a time where a lot of people are killing it. Two, there are incredible operators that can work around circ- circumstances that aren't the best and still do really well.
- 11:29Just 'cause they're incredible operators. And still have much, a, a, like, massive amount of margin because of, like, if these things were in place, how much more? Yeah. Like, what, what more there is there? Yeah.
- 11:43And, and I think that, so at the dealership level, if you're looking at it, like, "Why are we fighting over this stuff when I've got X in the showroom or X in the..." Because it's all of it. Yeah.
- 11:52It's all of the right now and five years in the future that we keep talking about, that if you're looking at it at, from that perspective, and to the OEMs, if you're looking at...
- 12:01Like, to the OEMs who are having software di- is talking about being a SaaS company in five years and, and pushing out 30 EVs, like, today matters for your dealership- Yes... to, to your dealers, too.Yep.
- 12:13It's, it's almost like targeting the mediocre players and saying, "How can I make them crush it with this product?" Right.
- 12:20If you can make a great team out of mediocre players, that means you have good leadership and good systems, right?
- 12:25You're always gonna have the stars, like you said, Kyle, that figure out how to make it work no matter what, just 'cause they're- Yes... great athletes, right? Miss a few blocks, guess what?
- 12:32They can get through the lines still. Yep. But if you can put a team together that can make a mediocre running back look like a star, that's something to talk about. [bell dings] Well, there you go.
- 12:42We're coming in heavy on Thursday. We, we're going hard. [laughs] Let's go. [laughs] Look, when you get... Yeah, when you get Jocko yelling at you- Oh, yeah...
- 12:49for an hour, like, you know you're gonna come with fire the next day. Let's get honest. [laughs] Let's just take... You know what? I'm going harder, [laughs] right? You're coming at me, I'm going twice as hard now. Good.
- 13:00No factor. Right. And so, um, switching, switching gears a little bit, we are throwing the industry's first industry-wide Christmas party on Monday. Yes. [laughs] You contextualize it like that.
- 13:12I- That's the only way to contextualize it...
- 13:13I have an ugly sweater on right now 'cause here at Congruent in Syracuse, it's ugly sweater day, and Kyle's like, "This is the first time in my whole career where I don't get a Christmas party."
- 13:21And then he was like, "You know what? We're throwing a really big Christmas party on Monday." So on- Right... Monday is our year-end extravaganza live stream.
- 13:28Please register at dealerspushingback.com/extravaganza, or you can just go to dealerspushingback.com. There's a button right there, Register. There're gonna be giveaways. There's gonna be a live band.
- 13:39There're gonna be a whole boatload of thought leaders, and Paul Waser, the chairman of NAD, is gonna kick us off, and we're gonna have all kinds of stuff. It's gonna be a big family party.
- 13:48Get somewhere where you can watch it with your team. Uh, register. It's gonna be fun. Starting at noon Eastern. Actually, starts about 11:45 Eastern 'cause the band's gonna do a little something.
- 13:58That's when you really wanna be there. Band's gonna do- Yeah... a little something before we officially kick, so, uh, we'll go there. Let's talk about a quick news story. Is, is kind of everywhere, right?
- 14:06The Fed really has, uh, changed direction big time, uh, to- Yeah... curb inflation. Yeah, big news coming out today. Uh, looks like interest rates are gonna be risen.
- 14:15Uh, less purchasing assets and spending, uh, are gonna happen, uh, from kind of, uh, pandemic kind of level spending at the, at the, um, federal, uh, at the federal level.
- 14:26Uh, which has an impact on the economy, uh, y- you know, and to curb inflation. Uh, and then also i- individually at the, at the auto, uh, level, right?
- 14:37So looking at lending or looking at consumer behavior a- amongst raising interest rates where we've become so accustomed to, um, interest rates.
- 14:45Now, I think, and we were talking just a little bit ago, the reality is, is that, you know, when you have a, uh, still an inventory shortage and super high demand, like, the, the where the interest rates are gonna go is not gonna massively affect consumer demand.
- 15:00Yeah. Um, but it definitely will, uh, affect some of the, you know, just lending guidelines and, and some of the opportunities that you've maybe been used to, uh, when submitting that deal over- Yeah...
- 15:11at the dealership level. For sure.
- 15:12Uh, it might look a little bit different coming back, but, uh, you know, overall there, there's, there's definite, uh, you know, positive insights, especially coming from Wall Street on that. Yeah. It's looking good.
- 15:22Geez, remember when there was so many cars in inventory that an interest rate hike, you're like, "Crap, it's gonna be even harder to sell these cars now," right? Right. OEMs have to start discounting more.
- 15:31Dealers are, you know, reducing their, their profits. And now it's just like, "Okay. Okay." Here we go. "Okay." Here's another. "Well, you need the car or have it, so [laughs] half point isn't-" Yeah... gonna kill you.
- 15:41All right, I guess that really kind of is all we have time for today. [upbeat music] It was good to be with you. Look, let's collaborate. Let's take ownership and accountability for what we can do.
- 15:50Start with a little humility, start with a little leadership, and see where we go from there. We'll see you tomorrow. Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be.
- 16:00They stop and stare when they see me. If I said it once, no need to repeat. Run up on me, watch you fall to your knees. Tip my hat when it's time for the kill. Ain't no beast when you're really real. And-