Latest / Automotive State of The Union / CarMax Gets Lean, Fake Dealers Get Real, Iced Coffee Gets Interviewed
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Tuesday, September 22nd. It's the Automotive State of the Union two days in a row. Kyle and I are both in the studio. How about that?
- 0:08Today, we're gonna talk about, um, AI fraud, CarMax cutting some jobs, and whether or not you can bring an iced coffee to a job interview. Who I go.
- 0:15People really wanna know who I is and who- I mean, I guess it depends on- I don't know... where you're interviewing. [laughs] If it's no need to talk- And what kind of iced coffee it is.
- 0:21Uh- It says something about you... you, you, you bring that up in here, and you got a iced coffee- He's got-... with all the fru-frus- Yeah, all the fru- It's gonna get weird, I'm just telling you...
- 0:29all the- [laughs] I'ma say some things you're not gonna let... You- Oh. We're gonna test the relationship boundaries- Yeah. Oh, my-... at that moment- Oh, my goodness... and we'll know. We'll know. Oh, my goodness.
- 0:37[laughs] Oh, well, we hope you join us tomorrow for our next ASOTU Edge webinar. Uh, we're gonna be talking about the appraisal process and a blind spot that's probably in it with our friends at vAuto.
- 0:47We got Patrick Janes from vAuto and Rachel Holloway from Gilchrist Automotive. You should be at this webinar. And even if you can't- You-... be there in person, you should sign up so you get the recording.
- 0:56You can do that by going to asotu.com, scroll up just a wee bit, click on it, put in your information. And you know how webinars work. We keep it to under 30 minutes, so it'll be, uh, quick, in, out.
- 1:07Heckle us in the comments, always welcome. Uh, also, wanna talk about ASOTU Con West. We have to talk about that. We have ASOTU Con West.
- 1:14It is, it is gonna be the dopest one-day event that I think we've ever put on with some- I-... speakers that will just blow your mind.
- 1:21We're gonna give, uh, I'm gonna- It may be the dopest one-day event you've ever been to... I'm not even gonna name them because I need you to go to the website.
- 1:27I need you to go to ASOTU Con West and check out the speaker line-up, check out the sessions. It's only 10:00 to 5:00, so you can get in, get out, go to California, get your nice weather on- Fly in, fly out for sure...
- 1:37in November so you don't have to worry about it, you know? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. It's- ASOTUConWest.com. Need to make that- Go... ASOTUConWest.com.
- 1:44All right, uh, we wanna-- today's show is made possible by our friends at AutoHub, giving dealers a faster way to appraise, make offers, and acquire vehicles from the customers that are already in your business.
- 1:54They're across the showroom, in the service lane, and online. You can learn more about how you can do that in a very seamless way at AutoHub.io. All right, let's get on to some news. I don't have to. I know. Let's go.
- 2:06Uh, CarMax cutting 145 white-collar jobs as new CEO- What?... Keith Barr looks to reinvigorate the used car retailer amid high vehicle prices, rising industry ra- interest rates, and pressure on profitability.
- 2:20That's a heck of a trifecta to step into [laughs] the CEO role. It's tough. Tough.
- 2:23Uh, the cuts equal about 4% of CarMax's corporate staff and, uh, hit its Richmond area headquarters offices in Dallas, also Atlanta, and Edmonds.
- 2:33Uh, CarMax revenue fell 2% to 25.9 billion last fiscal year, while gross profit per retail vehicle declined 2.5% all the way down to $2,253.
- 2:45Barr's strategy centers on improving digital retail or digital capabilities, growing CarMax's in-house financing arm, and lowering used car reconditioning costs. That sounds like the playbook right there.
- 2:56Sounds like the playbook. This is CarMax- See Carvana running it... this is CarMax's third round of cuts in less than a year, following 350 cuts eliminated in October 2025 and another 230 in January '26.
- 3:08They are getting lean and mean, it sounds like.
- 3:10Look, if, if, if there's a business primed for AI takeover, it is automating systems that already take vehicles across the country and manage schedules and systems, and I bet they are doing that at scale.
- 3:25They've had a, a rich history of understanding pricing matrices. I bet that is coming, uh, under, under attack. Accounting is probably coming, coming under attack.
- 3:33And they have to do something, because over the last five years, they have, uh, basically dropped to a third of their stock price evaluation, and they have not recovered the way that Carvana has.
- 3:44And so you gotta be looking at things like reconditioning costs- Mm-hmm... which is where Car- uh, Carvana went and, and bought a slew of auctions with ADESA and, and started figuring that out.
- 3:54It took them a little time to turn around, and Carvana has constantly been, uh, in the news for how their financing works. So this is a, this is a play. CarMax has, has to figure this out.
- 4:03I, I feel terrible for the people that are getting laid off.
- 4:05That's never something you wanna see, especially in retail auto, but I understand the sentiment when you've got that other public sitting right across the street, uh, just, like, staring down a barrel, you know? Yeah.
- 4:14Speaking of staring down a barrel. Stop. Woof. Segway. Time.
- 4:17[upbeat music] AI-assisted fake dealership scams are becoming more in- increasingly common on Facebook Marketplace using cloned dealerships, realistic- [laughs]...
- 4:30vehicle listings, and sophisticated supporting documents to fool shoppers. Uh, one recent operation was convincing enough to get a major auto lender to finance a Toyota 4Runner for 36 grand that didn't even exist. Wow.
- 4:45The Drive, that's the news outlet The Drive, describes these AI-assisted scams as widespread. On Facebook Marketplace, a buyer, Will Matthews, said he spotted dozens before becoming a victim himself.
- 4:56The scammers cloned a legitimate Texas dealership almost exactly, producing window stickers, purchase o- offer, uh, orders, a dealer license certificate, and a listing with a legitimate VIN and a realistic price.
- 5:09It went beyond the listing. Matthews received fake GPS- Wow... tracking portal showing a 4Runner traveling from California or to California, seemingly AI-generated photo depicting it on a transport truck.
- 5:20Afterwards, uh, he continued finding seemingly fraudulent vehicle listings, including several in a single afternoon. Said scammers often pay to boost the fakes to reach more shoppers. Even boosting this stuff.
- 5:31He escaped the loan after immediately contacting his lender and invoking the FTC holder rule. The lender ultimately waived the contract. Dang. Wow.
- 5:42It's just incredible what's out there, but this is the opportunity for us as dealers and, and people that work alongside dealers to come along and educate the customer on how to shop, things to look out for, be the place where every single person wants to understand what it looks like to shop.
- 5:58Not just how to shop in a regular ecosystem- Mm-hmm... but in an AI-assisted shopping world, right? What are ways that you can spot scams? What are ways that you can leverage AI to learn from those scams?
- 6:08And if you're training your team to educate your customers in that way, you better believe you're gonna be the authority when it comes time to buy a car. My goodness. Get on. Speaking of buying things. Stop Segway. Time.
- 6:19[upbeat music] All right, this is gonna be a fun one. Fun one to wrap the morning.
- 6:22So here's the thing, iced coffee has somehow become the latest workplace culture war, amen, with TikTok debating whether bringing one to a job interview is harmless or an unprofessional first impression.
- 6:33Career expert Amanda Augustine called a blanket ban on interview beverages, quote, "A little outdated." Hmm. Saying expectations can depend heavily on the workplace and role.
- 6:43Uh, Augustine would still finish the drink beforehand to avoid distractions like condensation, coffee breath, or the possibility of spitting it out while nervous, which is just a total TikTok-y thing to say. Mm-hmm.
- 6:54[laughs] Uh, Dr. Colleen Batchelor said the, uh, Batchelder, said the debate reflects, quote, "A huge gap right now between what Gen Z sees as normal and what hiring managers expect."
- 7:05Recruiter Steve Levy argued employers have long screened candidates based on criteria unrelated to job performance, citing everything from tattoos to academic credentials.
- 7:15Uh, Levy, Levy's only question for an applicant arriving with ice, iced coffee was going to be, "Did you bring some for me?" Okay, I think the last comment- What do you think?
- 7:23I, I think the last comment is a great one, because I think- It's perfect... if you did bring an iced coffee for the interviewer, I think that would actually make you memorable. Game on.
- 7:32And in interviews, you're always trying to stand out and be more memorable. So I don't think the coffee or no coffee thing, um, matters, unless you don't, you don't understand what's happening.
- 7:43You can walk in with a coffee beverage, and if it's part of your personality, and you're able to, like, show that you know what you're talking about, and it's just a part of who you are and use it to stand out, great.
- 7:54If you're just bringing it because you're late or you're running behind or you're thoughtless- Yeah...
- 7:59or it's insignificant and you act like it's just a nonchalant thing that you're doing along your day, it's like, that's not gonna work well.
- 8:05'Cause I wanna know when you show up for an interview with our company that you're thoughtful, you're intentional, that you're willing to, like, support your personality in a way that is, like, intentional.
- 8:15And so- Yeah... like, I don't think it's an either/or. Yeah, and, and as the company, I wanna be hospitable, and you just r- robbed- [laughs] That's... Look, that's like showing up to someone's house- Yeah...
- 8:25with a drink. Listen. Right? But yeah. No, you robbed them of the ability to be hospitable. Oh, but I think that, like, 99 out of 100 companies don't have that part down. So n- part- That's true. That is true. Okay.
- 8:38Okay. Okay. Let's, let's be honest here. However, if it's the one that does have it down, that's probably the one you wanna work for. That's right. So listen, just finish your coffee before you go in. Finish the coffee.
- 8:48Unless you do something super creative with it, and I-I'm- That's right... I'm still actually all in on bringing one for the interviewer. For the interviewer.
- 8:55I think if you bring them- Now, that's, that's the game changer. Yeah. I mean, that's, that's, that should be the point. Bring- I'm stopping by Starbucks. Do you want anything? Bring them an iced coffee.
- 9:03You'll be memorable. If you got the rest- It's on... of what it takes, then you'll get the job. Listen, think about how you can serve somebody else. Be hospitable today. Go out. It's Tuesday. Go be hospitable.
- 9:11[upbeat music]