Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP338: Salesforce Investment In Modernising Its Commerce Platform To Cut Costs & Accelerate Time to Market
Transcript
- 0:00To Salesforce has already announced UCP support your
- 0:02Google One. It's already got an interface
- 0:04for ACP to feed the product catalog into open AI and but
- 0:08also making sure that the site is just ready in terms of Jason
- 0:12LD markup, schema markup trying to make sure that's all there
- 0:15out-of-the-box. They are taking dentic readiness
- 0:17seriously. You listen to Inside Commerce, a
- 0:21weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 0:24experienced digital consultants and re platform specialist James
- 0:27Geddon Paul Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:29leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:31leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:33improve your online CX. This podcast is sponsored by
- 0:39Worldpay and I'll introduce guests in a moment, but today
- 0:42got a conversations coming back to platforms.
- 0:46When Paul and myself started this podcast six years ago, The
- 0:49thing is now we delivery set out to to be agnostic to tech and
- 0:52cover all tech and discuss it meaningfully and objectively.
- 0:57And I'd realized a few months back that actually we haven't
- 1:01looked at some of the more enterprise platforms recently.
- 1:03And there is always change when legacy tech stacks modernize and
- 1:07evolve. And we're looking into the
- 1:09Salesforce ecosystems and Salesforce Commerce Cloud.
- 1:12I think it's really important because Salesforce, which came
- 1:14from, you know, demand, Yeah, well, tomorrow is the
- 1:17acquisition to drive Salesforce. Commerce Cloud has gone through
- 1:19lots of iterations. It's had huge amounts of large
- 1:23global brands on it. The disruption in the market
- 1:26created by Shopify basically owning the SME space for certain
- 1:30verticals like fashion and and like less complex models has
- 1:33meant that they've they've lost market share and they've lost
- 1:36quite a few high profile brands, But they still have a huge range
- 1:40of large global and more complex businesses on them the same way
- 1:43that Adobe does. So really want to have a
- 1:44pragmatic view on where is Salesforce, some of the issues
- 1:48it's had in the past, some of the, the, I guess the objections
- 1:51people have to renewing on it or investing in it.
- 1:54How how true are they today? What sort of business does it
- 1:57suit? What business doesn't it suit?
- 1:58And I've got no better guest today than someone who's got a a
- 2:01huge amount of experience with the platform and with E com
- 2:04generally through agency background.
- 2:06And that's Rob Smith, who's the SVP of Commerce at OSF Digital.
- 2:10Hey Rob, welcome to the. Podcast Oh, James Yeah, really
- 2:13happy to be here. Yeah, thanks for coming on.
- 2:16And you know, we, we said, let's, let's really get into
- 2:20the, the, the, the pros and cons and a really pragmatic view on
- 2:24the platform. So I'm really looking forward to
- 2:25this. I know you work the wide range
- 2:26of, of clients. So do you want to give people a
- 2:28bit of flavour for for who you are, what your skill set and
- 2:31focus is, but also the type of businesses and the type of
- 2:34projects that you guys work on? Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 2:38So as you said, Rob Smith SV commerce at OSF, but I've been
- 2:43in the kind of e-commerce industry for a very long time
- 2:46and digital before that really. So I used to run a business that
- 2:49built websites for all sorts of people from kind of Red Bull's
- 2:53F1 team to Red Bull's ex fighters to Laura Ashley, the
- 2:57long forgotten brand now to a certain extent and the whole
- 3:01kind of remit. So I remember the very early
- 3:03days of e-commerce where you were integrating a payment
- 3:05provider, probably using PHP as a coding language and the
- 3:09payment provider might have been called Protex, if anyone
- 3:11remembers Protex. So these are very early days,
- 3:14kind of 2005. So I've seen that full kind of
- 3:17iteration over the time to the to the much more complex
- 3:20propositions that we've that we've got today.
- 3:25And I think, I think what you said in the introduction is
- 3:27right. I think there's, there's we do a
- 3:29lot of work with Salesforce Commerce Cloud at OSF.
- 3:31We OSF is also whole Salesforce ecosystem.
- 3:35So it deals with all the marketing aspects, service,
- 3:38agent, force, whatever you want to kind of, you know, bring into
- 3:41bring into play. And the kind of customers that
- 3:44we work with these days are still a wide range.
- 3:47So you know, in with in the US, there are brands that are very
- 3:50large, but you've never heard of them like kind of David Yeoman
- 3:53or World Market or any of these kind of folks.
- 3:57But in the UK we also equally work with some of the kind of
- 4:00more famous brands like museums such as BNA and Tate, as well
- 4:04as, you know, big brands like Super Dry.
- 4:06And, and then across the world, we've got quite a few global
- 4:09brands that have that kind of bigger scale, such as kind of
- 4:12L'Oreal or Tiffany as part of the LVMH group or, you know, all
- 4:16of these kind of different things.
- 4:17So we've got this wide remit of experience and I've been kind of
- 4:21on on the inside of a lot of that recently.
- 4:25So I previously do have experience of stuff like the
- 4:28kind of Magento's as it was and that kind of thing.
- 4:31But I have to say I've been much more kind of sales foresight for
- 4:34quite a few years now. So my exposure to the other
- 4:37platforms is is more limited for that's where you come in you for
- 4:41the rest of the the experience there James.
- 4:43Yeah. I think, you know, I was saying
- 4:45to you the reason why I wanted to get you on because I know
- 4:47that that you've got a really good view on this.
- 4:49And when you're working and delivering projects, then you'll
- 4:51see the actual use of the platform versus I guess where
- 4:54maybe my head is out having not worked on a sales force
- 4:57implementation for a couple of years.
- 5:00I have a view of where it was, but that's partial.
- 5:04And there are gaps in my understanding of just how
- 5:06quickly that they've accelerated some of their plans around, you
- 5:09know, faster speed to market for launches, specifically on the on
- 5:12the SME market, which I predominantly work with the
- 5:16adoption of Agentic and, and how fast they've they've delivered
- 5:19those capabilities to market cost models as well.
- 5:24And I guess to frame this conversation with everyone
- 5:26listeners previously where I've seen sales force lose out in an
- 5:31E com re platform in projects is cost is a big one.
- 5:36Because historically there I found greater flexibility around
- 5:39the license fee where I oversaw people on point 5.6%.
- 5:43Then it's all of a sudden it seems that that was 1% plus.
- 5:47So that made a massive change compared to the likes of a shop
- 5:49fire a big commerce. And then it's also the
- 5:52complexity of the admin and the ability to self-serve within
- 5:56admin tool in to get things done versus needing a developer to
- 5:59help you. So those are the areas where I
- 6:01want to drop to come on and really challenge my
- 6:03preconceptions, but also give that honest view of like where
- 6:06it's at and the areas where it's really progressed versus the
- 6:08areas where it's still probably, yeah, needs to needs to sharpen
- 6:12up. So that's the outline.
- 6:14So let's let's start with where the, I guess the the Salesforce
- 6:20Commerce Cloud product from AB to C point of view sits today,
- 6:24where it sits in the market and what it's relative strengths and
- 6:28weaknesses are. Yeah, Yeah.
- 6:30I think that's that's a good place to start.
- 6:32So I mean, it's, as you said before it, it's never really
- 6:37been suited to an SME market, right?
- 6:39It was never built to be that. It was always built from the
- 6:43very start to be able to accommodate kind of multi
- 6:46country, multi language, multi currency, all of these kind of
- 6:50different things and be able to run from one kind of single
- 6:54instance, many different websites and many different
- 6:57locales all kind of within one management interface.
- 7:00And it's, it's still a lot of it's strength is still derived
- 7:03from from that kind of area, I think.
- 7:07And it for what it's worth, it still sits in that kind of upper
- 7:10right of Gartner's kind of magic Quadrant because it's, it's
- 7:12actually been very difficult to challenge.
- 7:14It's kind of scale in that regard.
- 7:17So if you're a brand that does have kind of multi country or at
- 7:22least multi language and multi currency, and then it is
- 7:26something that that it can support quite natively.
- 7:29And, and you know, you know, well understood way without any
- 7:33kind of copying or, you know, cloning of sites or kind of all
- 7:37of that kind of stuff that you might do on on some of the other
- 7:40platforms. Now, some of the other platforms
- 7:42like, you know, Shopify or whatever have caught up a bit
- 7:44with things like markets, but they're still not quite at that
- 7:49true enterprise level of, of of management of those aspects.
- 7:53I think also from a revenue point of view, I wouldn't
- 7:57wouldn't really recommend Salesforce Commerce Cloud, the B
- 8:00to C product anyway for companies that are really
- 8:04turning over less than say 50 million a year kind of online,
- 8:08right. That's the kind of bar of where
- 8:10I might put it. Realistically, it's probably a
- 8:13maybe a little bit closer to 100, right.
- 8:15That's that's the kind of area where I would say it plays
- 8:18better. But coming to your point about
- 8:21cost where, you know, there used to be some flexibility and then
- 8:24it seemed to jump up to kind of that 1% of GMV level.
- 8:28And I think that was because quite a few years ago when
- 8:31Salesforce acquired Demandware, they thought it was a, a more
- 8:35premium product than a lot of the things that were in the
- 8:37marketplace. And I think to be fair to them,
- 8:40they, they weren't wrong. The the issue that we got is
- 8:44that they didn't realise when they were wrong, which which was
- 8:47say just I think COVID introduced a blip that was very
- 8:52difficult for people to understand, right.
- 8:54And I think that goes across all e-commerce.
- 8:56You know, people thought this kind of awkward trend would go
- 8:59on forever. Yeah, that they saw in COVID and
- 9:01lots of people got tripped up when it kind of stabilized,
- 9:03right or or even dipped a bit. And I think sales force was just
- 9:07as conscious of that. So but now in the past few
- 9:09years, they realise they need to compete hard.
- 9:12So you'll find in most of the kind of platform discussions,
- 9:16especially when the sales force and Shopify in the mix that
- 9:19they'll be be incredibly close to each other in terms of the
- 9:22cost of the platform. Again, because they've realized
- 9:24it doesn't have that premium tag that it that it used to and and
- 9:29that is therefore therefore lowered and come down.
- 9:32And I think if we just finish off the cost bit and talk about
- 9:36implementation, because the other thing that we've had
- 9:40levelled at us is that the implementation costs of
- 9:44Salesforce Commerce Cloud are higher than implementing
- 9:46Shopify. And I think at face value, it's
- 9:50quite easy to say that that's true.
- 9:53I think when you add it all up together in terms of, you know,
- 9:58these more enterprise deals, they're closer than people
- 10:01think, Especially when you add on all the little different bits
- 10:04and customisations that you end up doing by the end of the
- 10:07project that people didn't realise at the start of the
- 10:10project because everything looked simple and easy to do,
- 10:13right? Because it's a, it's a good
- 10:14sales process that they run. But the other thing that we've
- 10:17got on our on our side now that we've been using more and more
- 10:21is an AI driven process where especially if it's a RE platform
- 10:25and someone's quite happy with their site or if they've got
- 10:28some brand new designs in a tool like Figma, we can take AI and
- 10:32we can use AI to build a great majority of that front end code.
- 10:36And whenever we do a re platform project, it splits down as kind
- 10:41of front end code is maybe 60% of of what we're talking about,
- 10:45You know, the interface, the check out the product pages, all
- 10:48that kind of stuff. And then the other 35 to 40%
- 10:52kind of thing is, is integration.
- 10:54It's integration to where does the stock come from?
- 10:56Where does the pricing come from?
- 10:57Where do the orders go? Where does all the status come
- 11:00from? You know, all of those kind of
- 11:02enterprise bits. So because we can, AI can
- 11:05obviously help the integrations as well and does, but it plays a
- 11:08really quite strong role these days in the creation of the
- 11:11interface. So now that means that we can
- 11:14come to quite a lot of parity in terms of or close to parity in
- 11:18terms of implementation costs. But I think it's, it's still not
- 11:23the right platform for a lot of people.
- 11:25If if you were a single country and say you just operate in the
- 11:29UK and you're doing about 20 million online, I wouldn't
- 11:34recommend Salesforce.com Skype, it's not the right fit, right?
- 11:37There's there's other platforms that can do that, especially if
- 11:39you're like, say a fashion brand and there's brands like is it
- 11:42centre that I've heard of before?
- 11:44It's quite a fashion focused on this platform.
- 11:47You know, maybe maybe that's a bit better because you can do
- 11:50more in that single platform, but the more you move up to
- 11:53enterprise, lots of other platforms are in play for orders
- 11:57or, you know, a PIM or lots of other different things like this
- 12:01and you need something with a bit of greater flexibility.
- 12:04Ready to grow your business online with world pay e-commerce
- 12:08you can deliver fast, secure payments your customers love
- 12:12backed by global reach and real people powered support scale
- 12:17with confidence and enhance your customers experience with world
- 12:20pay e-commerce. So, yeah, let's run that cost
- 12:23bit because it, I, I find there's a real dichotomy here
- 12:27because part of the bits that that give people some
- 12:30reassurance in more platforms like Salesforce offer, which is
- 12:34I guess greater governance in terms of how staging and
- 12:39production and managed to replication some of the some of
- 12:43the tooling around scheduling of content releases.
- 12:45And we'll come onto the interface bit and, and that and
- 12:49the modernisation because there are two different, there are
- 12:51different bits on there, but you have these, you have actually
- 12:54quite a lot of robust tooling and quite a lot of control and
- 12:57environmental control, which is very different in a SAS world.
- 13:02SAS by by nature isn't set up to, to work in that way, but
- 13:05that does bring costs. So I'm really keen to hear from,
- 13:08from how you seen it, because the, the last project that I
- 13:11looked at Salesforce meaningfully in terms of versus
- 13:14other options was for about a £120 million business.
- 13:20And one of the things that that put off the, they had an in
- 13:23house UX team. So they had senior front end
- 13:26developers. So they, they're going to be
- 13:28doing a lot of release management themselves from like
- 13:31the front end work. And it was, it was the process
- 13:35that would make it much slower for them to execute, even though
- 13:39the quality control was really, really good.
- 13:41So how are you, what has anything changed in there?
- 13:44Because speed to market is often one of the biggest criticisms
- 13:46that's thrown at enterprise platforms.
- 13:49Basically, yeah. And, and I suppose one of the,
- 13:53yes, things have changed and I suppose one of the reasons why
- 13:56I've speed to market is incredibly important, right?
- 13:59But sometimes people I think confuse speed to market with the
- 14:03ability to see a site up and running within, you know, 30
- 14:07minutes or something like this, right.
- 14:08And no one's going to deploy an enterprise commerce site within
- 14:11within 30 minutes, right? It's just not, not, not, not a
- 14:14possibility. And so we shouldn't confuse set
- 14:17up time with kind of overall speed to market, I think.
- 14:20And when we compare some kind of big international roll outs,
- 14:24suddenly that speed to market doesn't look as bad as it did
- 14:28because it can do all those kind of country bits and pieces as
- 14:31well. But the other thing that's kind
- 14:33of happened in in recent times is that there's, there's been
- 14:37iterations of what's called sales forces reference
- 14:41application, right? The thing that comes
- 14:43out-of-the-box with Salesforce that you can customise to make
- 14:46your own and you can alter every single bit of it.
- 14:49There are no limits. So unlike some of the platforms
- 14:52where certain areas are locked down, there is nothing locked
- 14:55down. You you can change everything
- 14:57that a customer sees. That particular reference
- 15:01application has gone through lots of iterations and most
- 15:04recently there's one that will be announced soon at Connections
- 15:08in June, which is a Salesforce event.
- 15:10And that's currently in pilot and we're building on it for
- 15:13customers, which I'm really confident is a is a great
- 15:18technical solution. So it's, it's fully fledged, you
- 15:21know, it's got all the PLPPDP basket, my account, all the
- 15:24different bits you need out of a reference application.
- 15:28But you can still, as I said earlier, use AI to bring your
- 15:31brand in really rapidly so that you've still got that fast time
- 15:34to market. And the technical stack it's
- 15:36built on is React as a, as a kind of central piece, but it
- 15:42also now uses Tailwind for all the kind of CSS and UI and that
- 15:47kind of thing. And it's been hooked up to Figma
- 15:51so that you very easily bring stuff that you've designed in
- 15:53Figma. If you're a UX designer like you
- 15:56were mentioning, just then bring it directly from Figma through
- 16:00AI into that kind of React and Tailwind environment.
- 16:04Because one of the big criticisms previously of
- 16:07Salesforce was that it had a lot of kind of proprietary language
- 16:10in it, what used to be called ISML and lots of other different
- 16:13things. That meant that AI, first of
- 16:17all, couldn't use it very well. And also it meant developers had
- 16:19a ramp up time there to learn how to use these proprietary
- 16:23elements now, because that front end is in React, Tailwind, all
- 16:27that kind of stuff. It's it's stuff people already
- 16:29know. So you can hire very normal
- 16:32developers and within a small period of time, they can be
- 16:35shipping productively. And that front end is also
- 16:40separate to the back end coding now so that you've got that
- 16:44isolation. So in terms of governance that
- 16:45you were talking about before, your integration layer is quite
- 16:49safe in that back end set of coding and your front end
- 16:52remains in a different repository, which also allows
- 16:55more speed and agility and different kind of dev OPS for
- 16:58each part and and so that's improved a lot.
- 17:02On the licence point, so that's really interesting.
- 17:05You said that, that there's been some changes.
- 17:08I know that it's like how long is a piece of straight right,
- 17:10because the the exact license fee that you'll get charged will
- 17:13be dependent on many factors including like size of business
- 17:15complexity, what you need what, how close to end of quarter is
- 17:20or end of year. But are you, are you seeing, are
- 17:24you seeing sub 1% license fees as a more common thing now or is
- 17:30the one is the one, is the 1% limit still still pretty much
- 17:34there that that's the kind of minimum you would expect to be
- 17:36paid? No.
- 17:36No, no, no, I, I if anything it's, it's kind of the opposite
- 17:40of that. I, I it's much sub kind of 1%.
- 17:44You know, you were talking about different figures before when
- 17:47you, that there was some flexibility around point 5.6.
- 17:51You know, I've, I've definitely seen that I've seen a bit lower
- 17:53in certain circumstances as well.
- 17:56So I, I, they, they've really changed their tune on that.
- 17:58They have realised 100% but, but isn't appropriate anymore.
- 18:05They can't come because the other thing is if we're, if
- 18:08we're very honest, you know, with each other, commerce is
- 18:11becoming rapidly a bit of a commodity, right?
- 18:15Good commerce isn't a commodity, but commerce itself as a
- 18:19technical thing is. It's a solve problem.
- 18:23Do you know what I mean? In in some ways a gentic has has
- 18:26changed things and I'm sure we'll get on to that later.
- 18:29But your standard car checkout basket uptime, all of that kind
- 18:33of stuff is, is pretty established.
- 18:37So the idea that you can charge a high premium price for that
- 18:40kind of stuff is is gone and they know that.
- 18:43Yeah, that's really interesting because, yeah, the the project
- 18:45that I worked and one of the main reasons why the client went
- 18:48away from sales force was that they wouldn't go below 1% on a
- 18:51renewal. And that just at the time put
- 18:53them so disproportionately expensive.
- 18:55Oh yeah, absolutely crazy interesting.
- 19:00And this this is This is why I love these these conversations
- 19:02because thing we both know, right, Things change constantly
- 19:05in the vendor space by the the commercial, I mean big commerce
- 19:08has just announced a raft of price increases across its and
- 19:11pay as you go monthly plan. So you can get used to a a like
- 19:15prescriptive view of well actually this won't be so cost
- 19:18affordable and then all of a sudden it changes.
- 19:20Yeah, yeah. The, the what the other we'll
- 19:22tell one of the other we're talking about is what what's
- 19:24frustrated brands, what's changed where those frustrations
- 19:28are being removed. The Salesforce is recognised and
- 19:30doing something versus where there's an issue.
- 19:32The the one area that I've always found really frustrating
- 19:35with both Adobe and Salesforce is they, they have so much
- 19:39functionality under the hood. I've I I come from a demand my
- 19:43background, I've worked with clients and demand my then in
- 19:44Salesforce and Salesforce Commerce Lab is basically just
- 19:47demand where with a new logo and but the admins are just not easy
- 19:54to use. Have they have they spent to
- 19:57have they planning to anytime in modernizing the UI of the admin
- 20:02to make it easier to use and execute?
- 20:04Tasks, yeah. So the couple of couple of
- 20:07things have happened. So what one of the bits of
- 20:09background that you, you might not know too much is that
- 20:13Salesforce did start quite a few years ago trying to build a, a
- 20:17commerce platform on their main core platform, right?
- 20:22They've got their B to B commerce platform that's still
- 20:24there and that's still a really great piece of kit for B to B
- 20:28companies. But they also started to build a
- 20:30kind of direct consumer one on the same Salesforce platform.
- 20:35And a few years ago now, they abandoned that effort because
- 20:39they realised that they just could not create the scale that
- 20:42Demand Ware created in its infrastructure, right without,
- 20:46without it costing an enormous amount of cash.
- 20:49And as a result, what they've done instead is redirect all of
- 20:52that effort into the Demand Ware products.
- 20:54So there was a period of time, a few years post COVID kind of
- 20:57years, I would say where the platform was under invested in.
- 21:02And if you talking closed doors to people, they, they will
- 21:05recognise that, right? It didn't change enough.
- 21:08And it's a common complaint of customers that it demand Ware is
- 21:12great or it was great, but where's the innovation, right?
- 21:15That was always the question. Where's my next thing?
- 21:17What you told me I'm getting 8 to 10 releases a year and I'm
- 21:21getting those releases, but what's in it for me?
- 21:23What can I use these? These were the things our
- 21:26customers were saying. The great thing is over the past
- 21:28couple of years, they've redirected all that investment.
- 21:31So commerce, order management, quite a few different parts of
- 21:34that commerce portfolio all have double the investment that they
- 21:38used to. And in Salesforce terms, double
- 21:40the investment does need does literally mean thousands of
- 21:43engineers, right? It's, it's a lot of people that
- 21:46have put an effort into the platform and that's why this
- 21:48kind of much better front end has appeared.
- 21:51But over time, they've also modernized the UX of business
- 21:54manager. So it looks a lot more like
- 21:56Salesforce now. I don't know whether that might
- 21:58be good or bad for you. I don't know.
- 22:00I. Was in the Marketing Cloud
- 22:01piece. More more like a kind of, yeah,
- 22:04something like that, but more like what they call the
- 22:05Lightning design system, which is more like their CRM kind of
- 22:09look and feel. And they've also started to
- 22:12modernise just certain parts of it, like upgrading certain parts
- 22:15of it to make it better. They, they need to be a tiny bit
- 22:18careful though, because they do have a lot of power users who
- 22:21really learnt to use the platform.
- 22:23So you, you also can't go backwards.
- 22:25But the other thing I'm very excited about now with all the
- 22:30agentic stuff that's coming along is that they're where
- 22:34they're ramping up quite a bit of investment is what they call
- 22:36agentic merchandising, which is when you're in that tool,
- 22:39instead of having click, click, click, fine, fine, look at this.
- 22:43Do you know what I mean? You, you actually just talk to
- 22:45it and say, I need to update this kind of setting and do this
- 22:48and it goes off and it does it for you, right?
- 22:50Which is obviously that kind of assisted route is, is much more
- 22:53interesting or, you know, something around the lines of
- 22:58show me all the products that don't have this description or
- 23:00that description or that I haven't looked at recently or
- 23:04you know, these, these kind of ideas.
- 23:06And they will be opening that up to the partner ecosystem like us
- 23:09to build a genetic skills into the platform, which is really
- 23:13exciting because we can make our own kind of accelerators and and
- 23:17stuff like that on top of it. So I'd say while, while I
- 23:20wouldn't say that that's a place of revolution, it it is a place
- 23:24where things have evolved and I've had good feedback from
- 23:27customers on the kind of improvements that have been made
- 23:30and they do like it. Yeah, the the areas that, that
- 23:35there are some areas I always thought of functioning.
- 23:37It's really good the the native content scheduling, the content
- 23:42slot scheduling without the need for a a head of CMS ahead of the
- 23:48publishing in in the SAS platforms and without doing
- 23:52custom, without creating a custom like private app on top
- 23:54to to do that piece. That's really good.
- 23:57But the the interface of it was always really quite ugly and not
- 24:01very fun. So I think I think I think it's
- 24:04good to hear that they're investing that the agent of I'm
- 24:07being I'm keen to push a little bit further than that because
- 24:10I've been playing around because I work with a lot more like big
- 24:12commerce shop fight type projects at the moment.
- 24:14I've played around a lot with with Shopify sidekick and you're
- 24:17right, I mean, that's that's how e-commerce teams increasingly
- 24:21want to work is not to have to remember a path to achieve, but
- 24:24I want to set up a discount to do X Oh, I've got to go in
- 24:27there, do that, click these things.
- 24:29The ability to just at the moment it's all type based, but
- 24:32in the future is going to be, you know, spoken commands say,
- 24:34right, I want you to set me up a discount with 10% off.
- 24:37That's only for this customer. I don't want it to be eligible
- 24:39with shipping promotions. And that bit is really
- 24:42fascinating to see how it changes people's mindset of how
- 24:45quickly they can do stuff internally.
- 24:48How far has Salesforce got with the agents?
- 24:51Like what? What are the practical ways it
- 24:53can be used? Yeah, it's a good, it's a good
- 24:56question. And it, it is areas like that
- 24:58that they're targeting, right, because because it's the kind of
- 25:01high effort areas. So promotions is a relatively
- 25:05high effort area. One of the things we did
- 25:07recently as a hacker fund, for instance, with AI was that we
- 25:11using Salesforce API, we extracted all of the kind of
- 25:15promotions out of a, a test site and presented it as a kind of a
- 25:20calendar and showed where there were any overlaps or any
- 25:23conflicts or anything like that because that kind of tooling
- 25:25isn't quite there yet. And so that's an example of
- 25:28where where we're kind of taking it in terms of in terms of sales
- 25:32force, it is, it is exactly those kind of things.
- 25:35So promotions, it's also at one point they were looking into a
- 25:39kind of a kind of energetic content builder, if that makes
- 25:44sense, where you could ask it to kind of build up a page and and
- 25:47that kind of thing. They're, they're still working
- 25:49on that as a potential. The, the only thing for them
- 25:53that they need to balance is that because of the enterprise
- 25:56customer set. Well, as I can say, I keep
- 25:59saying enterprise customer set that's a broad range in itself.
- 26:01As you know, you know enterprise of L'Oreal who have, you know,
- 26:06hundreds of countries and like 50 odd brands.
- 26:08That's one kind of enterprise. But you know, super dry who
- 26:13still ship to kind of, you know, 25 countries and and still have
- 26:16plenty of currencies and plenty of complexity.
- 26:19I still consider kind of more, more enterprise despite their
- 26:23kind of mid market revenue maybe.
- 26:27But you've got to be careful because as you said, the
- 26:30headless CMS thing, quite a lot of these people do come with the
- 26:33CMS. We won one recently in the US who were using builder dot IO
- 26:40as a as ACMS and they've got a really nice workflow from their
- 26:45UX team to the content being delivered and they really wanted
- 26:48to preserve that. They didn't want to go backwards
- 26:51on the tool and sales forces inbuilt hauling was not quite as
- 26:54good. But more importantly, they
- 26:56didn't want to disrupt their workflow.
- 26:58They didn't want to relearn another tool, you know, But then
- 27:01I hear from another customer that actually they, that we one
- 27:05recently where they want to go for Salesforce's content tooling
- 27:09because they did have CMS, but they're only using 30% of its
- 27:13capability and they needed to conserve cost.
- 27:15And I'm sure you've heard that that people want to call cost
- 27:19back, they want to lower the TCO, their platforms, they want
- 27:22to do all that kind of stuff. So yeah, plenty of different
- 27:24directions. And that's that sales force's
- 27:26conundrum. How far do they invest in one
- 27:28particular area? So they always have to talk to
- 27:31all the customers. So where they've zeroed in is
- 27:34more on what the core platform does.
- 27:35So maybe slightly less content, slightly more promotions,
- 27:38merchandising, sorting, rules boost and Berry, all this kind
- 27:42of stuff. So one just released is a Gentek
- 27:44Boost and Berry. You can set it rules of what to
- 27:47boost and vary based on a few things and it'll do it.
- 27:50Yeah. I think this is this is an
- 27:51increasing dilemma for the core, the platform vendors is which
- 27:57part of the user experience in the front end piece do they
- 28:01become best in class at within platform?
- 28:04Because you have an ecosystem and you have partners and those
- 28:08partners obviously their income stream is selling solutions for
- 28:13product discovery, personalisation, what you know,
- 28:15loyalty, whatever it might be. And the more you bake true high
- 28:21end quality into the platform, the more you can alienate some
- 28:24of those partners, and it's a real balancing act.
- 28:26Well, you've got to, you've also got to charge for it, right?
- 28:28If you've built it, you've got to somehow recoup that kind of
- 28:31investment and that kind of cost.
- 28:32So another example on the Salesforce side is that the
- 28:36other, the other dimension you've got to think about with
- 28:38Salesforce is that they have a load of other tools that they
- 28:40sell, right. So data Cloud, is there kind of
- 28:44or Data 360 I should say, is there because Salesforce love to
- 28:48rename something, right? Is there best in class kind of
- 28:52segmentation kind of data modelling marketing tool, right?
- 28:56And it is really powerful, really good.
- 28:58I've spent quite a bit of time with it.
- 29:00And so they won't use that. They won't create inside
- 29:05commerce any kind of segmentation kind of tooling or
- 29:09all of that data will come from data cloud and then be used
- 29:12inside commerce. Do do you know what I mean?
- 29:14So they, they're very clear about where they're putting the
- 29:16boundaries. On the other hand, though,
- 29:18they're investing quite deeply. So they bought a company called
- 29:20Simulate with AC and simulate dot AI.
- 29:26And for people listening to this, they should go to West
- 29:30Marine, which is a, they're a company in the US, but they have
- 29:35simulate operating at the moment.
- 29:38And when you do a search, it's their traditional keyword
- 29:40search. But then there's a little button
- 29:43on the left that says ask the skipper.
- 29:45And the skipper is simulate. The skipper is AI.
- 29:49But what simulator has done really well is that they
- 29:52understand the product catalog, but then they build effectively
- 29:56an ontology, if you're familiar with the term, they build a
- 29:58semantic layer of knowledge on top.
- 30:01So yes, West Marine is all about fishing products, but they build
- 30:04a layer on top that says, well, take this fish Finder.
- 30:07What is a fish Finder? Well, fish finders do this and
- 30:10they operate this way And they, they, they use AI to fill in all
- 30:13those blanks of what it's used for so that when you go on the
- 30:17site, you can say I need a fish Finder, but I don't know which
- 30:20one I want. And it asks all the right
- 30:22questions. It says, well, are you deep sea
- 30:24fishing? Are you ice fishing?
- 30:26Are you river fishing? And do you need it to locate?
- 30:29You need it to how deep does it need?
- 30:32You know, I can give you all the examples, but it, it's a far
- 30:35superior way of searching. They've effectively cracked AI
- 30:39search, in my opinion, on site search and recommendations.
- 30:43And so Salesforce bought them and, and so now that'll get
- 30:46folded into the the platform offering because they see search
- 30:51and recommendations as a key part of what they should
- 30:55provide. And a lot of customers are
- 30:57telling them they want to reduce cost by removing third party
- 31:00recommendation engines. Yeah.
- 31:02Yeah, I can see this in other ecosystems as well where the the
- 31:04product is, is accelerating those areas.
- 31:07A product for me, I think product discovery is completely
- 31:10the right area to go. It's not great for those who are
- 31:13running specialist product discovery engines, but it it
- 31:16makes sense because the end of the day, the commerce platform
- 31:20was where you have your product data and you want to be able to
- 31:22create the journeys that you want off the back of that
- 31:25platform with minimum extra tech.
- 31:27Yeah. Well, I think it is the very
- 31:30core to me of what a commerce platform should be, right?
- 31:33It's, it's the product, it's the catalog, yes, because as we say,
- 31:36the checkout bit is kind of commoditized to a certain
- 31:38extent, right? It's yeah, anywhere.
- 31:42Yes, so I definitely, I feel like in other ecosystems as
- 31:45well, there's going to be some disruption there in the in the
- 31:48partner space. I was just laughing whilst you
- 31:51were saying that. I was looking at the West Marine
- 31:53skipper thing and I love the fact it responds with ahoy
- 31:56there. Absolutely.
- 31:57I I can even hear it in the right right tone.
- 32:00It's full, that's right. It's full, it's full branded,
- 32:03but you'll know that it hasn't taken over their keyword search
- 32:05yet, right? They've left the keyword search
- 32:06there and they they kept this so because they similar to how
- 32:09Gemini and and and Google are kind of testing out my mode and
- 32:13you know, whatever it is, because people will shift, but
- 32:16the shift is always slightly slower than we expect, but
- 32:19faster in the long term than we ever thought, right?
- 32:21You know, it's that kind of weird paradox because the the
- 32:25other thing I want to say about a gentic and where there's a lot
- 32:28of investment going is making sure that the site, the kind of
- 32:32reference application and also the kind of back end is ready
- 32:36for a gentic protocols. So like, so Salesforce has
- 32:40already announced kind of UCP support, you know, the Google,
- 32:45Google One. And also it's already got an
- 32:47interface for ACP to feed the product catalog into open AI,
- 32:51for what that's worth these days since they decided to stop doing
- 32:54it. But you know what I mean, It's
- 32:57moves fast, doesn't it? That's for sure.
- 33:00But also making sure that the site is just ready just in terms
- 33:03of, you know, Jason LD markup, schema markup, all that kind of
- 33:06thing, trying to make sure that's all layer out-of-the-box.
- 33:10So they are taking that agentic readiness quite seriously
- 33:13because they, they want to be the platform of truth for
- 33:19agentic orders because and that's another thing that folds
- 33:22into your commercial thing that you spoke about earlier.
- 33:24If they would have kept the pricing really high, what
- 33:27happened with Salesforce customers is that they found
- 33:30ways to place orders around the platform.
- 33:32Do you know what I mean? So like if you, if you had an in
- 33:35store kiosk, they wouldn't be keen on sales force powering it
- 33:39because it'd be more orders adding to that GMB total, right.
- 33:44Whereas now on the on the much lower kind of approach then
- 33:47people are a lot more open. So we have a, a big company in
- 33:51Canada called Dynamite who've just launched in the UK actually
- 33:55with a brand called Garage or Garage.
- 33:57I think they pronounce it multi 100 million kind of company
- 34:01that's using Salesforce to power all their native mobile apps as
- 34:04well. Just using the API.
- 34:06Because that's another thing that Salesforce is probably
- 34:08different from your days when you were with it.
- 34:11It's always had a good API, but they've they've steadily redone
- 34:16it. So it's all on modern standards,
- 34:18you know, modern REST standards and all that kind of stuff and
- 34:20compared to the older API. And so that's, that's also quite
- 34:24a cool thing. Where where do you think
- 34:27Salesforce is strategically headed because it was I like the
- 34:30fact that you position it as you know you need to be on 50
- 34:34million plus suitable to more complex enterprise and we're not
- 34:38talking this just this is about systems architecture operations,
- 34:42not just about size of business. Yeah.
- 34:45So that's quite, I think that's clear and that and that makes a
- 34:48lot of sense. But what where are they headed?
- 34:52Well, to 1 area you've alluded to with simulating the search
- 34:56and making that a core capability platform.
- 34:58But where else are they focused strategically in the road map?
- 35:01Are there specific pillars where they are properly going after
- 35:04with this expanded engineering team?
- 35:07Yeah. So I mean, I, I think we've
- 35:09covered quite a few of them. So obviously Aonogenic is 1 and
- 35:14as a kind of extension of that, that core capability of kind of
- 35:18search recommendations that that kind of area trust is still a
- 35:22big one. So trust and scale, it's always
- 35:24had a reputation for never going down over Black Friday, always
- 35:27scaling to the customer needs. You know they need to they will
- 35:30continue to preserve that even in energetic era where things
- 35:33can really speed up potentially depending on what kind of hype
- 35:36cycle you're you're kind of looking at.
- 35:39I think tooling for business users is is still high with the
- 35:43agentic merchandising that we were talking about.
- 35:47But then the final piece is, is also what we have talked about
- 35:50quite a bit which is around time to market.
- 35:52So before a lot of the kind of onus on getting the platform
- 35:58ready was on the partners like us in terms of speed to market,
- 36:02But they, they realise the more they can build into the products
- 36:05and, and kind of, you know, we used to do these 10 things
- 36:08always in the project, those 10 things are already done, you
- 36:11know, even better, right? So we can, we can all go a
- 36:14little bit faster. So as an example of that,
- 36:18they've been spending quite a bit of time on producing.
- 36:21You know, we mentioned, I mentioned that we've been using
- 36:23AI to do all the front end build of the interface.
- 36:27We're quite ahead on that. But Salesforce is also doing
- 36:30some of their own stuff that they want to give to all the
- 36:32partners because they want to raise all the boats so that
- 36:35things go a bit faster in terms of projects.
- 36:39Because they do they want to make sure that they protect
- 36:42their kind of upper mid market and enterprise position, right,
- 36:46Because one of the fastest growing segments in Salesforce
- 36:48is, is enterprise is still growing really fast.
- 36:51But that kind of mid market area is is also growing really
- 36:56quickly, right? So and we can't forget that
- 36:59Salesforce is a bigger ecosystem.
- 37:02So when they go in, they don't want to just sell commerce head
- 37:04to head with any other platform. They normally want to say, well,
- 37:08have you also solved your data problem?
- 37:09Because we've got data 360. What's your marketing tool
- 37:12doing? Is it, is it as well integrated
- 37:14as, as our set, you know what I mean?
- 37:16So it's much more of A and you find that people get much more
- 37:19kind of benefit and return on investment the more Salesforce
- 37:24products they have are closely aligned together.
- 37:27It's not for everybody, but I think you, you and me saw that
- 37:32era where people were building everything kind of super
- 37:36composable, right? You had a platform for this and
- 37:38the platform for that and the platform for this.
- 37:40And there was huge amounts of API integration wasn't there to
- 37:43try and get anything to work. And the projects ended up being
- 37:4624 months long, you know, and, and I think that era is gone.
- 37:50You know, all the CF OS are kind of going how can we reduce cost
- 37:54across, across our marketing technology, across our commerce
- 37:57technology, not just on looking at this platform.
- 38:01So Salesforce is going to concentrate on his core
- 38:04competency. I think it's still going to stay
- 38:08pretty close to working with partners for other things.
- 38:11So he's got a strong partnership with Stripe, strong partnership
- 38:13with ADN. It's not going to try and be a
- 38:15payment provider anytime soon as an example, which is different
- 38:19to other platforms. So I just think that's that's
- 38:22about where it's positioned, yeah.
- 38:25In terms of like you as a, as a solution specialist working with
- 38:29different clients, what, what are like, what are the key areas
- 38:33where we go? I really wish you did this
- 38:35better because I if I look at yeah, I haven't done a lot of
- 38:38projects recently with with big commerce and Shopify and big
- 38:40commerce are certain things around the page builder and the
- 38:45usability here bears around smart collections and the fact
- 38:49that it's you have to assign products to categories rather
- 38:52than creating rules that auto do Shopify site lack of BTC price
- 38:57lists that have been coming for ages but have never arrived.
- 39:00And yeah, you can do discounts, but it's not the same as true
- 39:02price. They see.
- 39:03So in each ecosystem, you've got things where the platform excels
- 39:06out and that you've got these little annoyances where it
- 39:08hasn't caught up with demand. What would be some of the key
- 39:11functions where ECOM teams got are just This is where I want it
- 39:15to be. Yeah, I think that's a great
- 39:17question. I think there's there's a couple
- 39:18of things with that and and both of them they are addressing to
- 39:22to a certain extent, but I quite like it to speed up a little
- 39:29bit. So we we mentioned about agentic
- 39:30merchandising and all that agentic tooling.
- 39:32I just think there's a, there's a, there's a, I was going to say
- 39:35a goldmine there, but but effectively there is a, a big
- 39:38opportunity there to, to make the lives of all operators and
- 39:42merchandisers and whatever better.
- 39:45Yeah, because there's still a lot of donkey work that that
- 39:48goes on in all platforms, including Salesforce.
- 39:51And tied in with that is the interface, like you said before
- 39:53by the promotion engines, exceptionally powerful.
- 39:56But when you first see that promotion interface, you're
- 39:58like, that's there's a lot going on there, right.
- 40:01To get my head around. So that that'd be one thing.
- 40:04The second thing is the double edged sword of content tooling,
- 40:08because on the one hand, I've got kind of half the customers
- 40:11at the moment saying, well, we don't need any of that because
- 40:14we're going to use Optimisely as our kind of CMS and it's going
- 40:17to do our mobile apps, it's going to do our website, it's
- 40:19going to do everything. Or you know, builder like I
- 40:22mentioned before or Contentful or whoever, right.
- 40:24They're they're already set on that.
- 40:26And then the other half of the customers broad split, I just
- 40:30like, I'd really like to use content Salesforce's content
- 40:32tooling. And at that point I'd just like
- 40:35it to be a tiny bit better. They're working on it.
- 40:37They've got a new version coming and but it's not for a few
- 40:40months yet. So that's a small frustration of
- 40:42mine that it's not quite as good for a lot of customers.
- 40:45They're like, that's good enough.
- 40:48But it's because they're coming from a point at the moment where
- 40:51the market is saying take cost out the platform.
- 40:54But we know how fast the market changes.
- 40:56Sometimes suddenly it'll be back to best of breed or back to you
- 40:59know what I mean, people talking about third party CMSS again and
- 41:02that's that's when it needs a slightly better answer.
- 41:05So they're probably the two bases I'd say.
- 41:07OK, interesting. But I really appreciate you
- 41:10coming on. It's been interesting to hear
- 41:13how they're evolving and where they're focused on.
- 41:15And yeah, I didn't, I knew they'd, they'd invested in the,
- 41:19the engineering resource to speed up the road map.
- 41:21I didn't realize it was that significant.
- 41:23So that's, yeah, that's an address to 1 and it's quite, I
- 41:26think it's nice for people here and the your, your, your view
- 41:30objective viewpoint on the type of and the type of market that
- 41:32it's suitable to. Yeah, I think, I think a lot, a
- 41:36lot of people have a quite fixed perception of what it is.
- 41:40And and I'm not saying some of that is isn't right, but
- 41:44particularly when it comes to to pricing and particularly when it
- 41:48comes to the label of oh, it's still just a man where and
- 41:51they've done nothing. Those two things are worthy of a
- 41:54second look now. And we're what we're seeing
- 41:57quite a lot of is there's also a final shift happening where
- 42:05enterprise platforms such as ATG and Hybris, SAP, hybris are
- 42:10finally coming to end of life, right.
- 42:12HCL, all of these original platforms that you remember from
- 42:16the enterprise days, there are still plenty of customers that
- 42:19are hanging on to them because obviously they think the cost
- 42:21change is huge. And in my experience, Salesforce
- 42:24is is pretty much prime position for a lot of those things
- 42:28because he has both the enterprise scale and the modern
- 42:30technology kind of mixed together.
- 42:31Do you know what I mean? So for a lot of people it'll be
- 42:34worth a second look. Obviously you should do it with
- 42:36OSF as well, but I I shouldn't be have to say that.
- 42:40The we know what you've done, you've done really well.
- 42:42We said when we were planning this that the one thing we don't
- 42:45want to do is evangelise and we're just really going to focus
- 42:47on objective. And I like the fact you've
- 42:49evangelised right at the end. Well, I've got, I've got to say
- 42:51something I'm not otherwise my sales leadership would just be
- 42:54like what you're doing. But at all customers who know me
- 42:58know me. I say exactly like it is,
- 42:59whether anyone's there or not so.
- 43:01Yeah, I know, I know that was tongue in cheaper.
- 43:04But equally though, if, if, if those of you listening are
- 43:07working in a in that more enterprise environment and want
- 43:11to get a potentially more detailed and nuanced view of
- 43:14this, then Rob's details are on the landing page.
- 43:17You can also connect with him on LinkedIn.
- 43:19He's a generally good person to connect with in the industry.
- 43:21So I highly recommend it. But yeah, thanks for taking the
- 43:24time to to come on and and give that that perspective on the
- 43:27market. No problem.
- 43:29Great feature, James. Cheers and thanks as always to
- 43:31everyone for listening. Do reach out to myself or Rob if
- 43:33you've got any questions and keep the ears peeled for next
- 43:36week. You're listening to the Inside
- 43:39Commerce podcast hosted by experienced consultants James
- 43:42Gerd and Paul Rogers. Inside Commerce is your fast
- 43:45tracked additional knowledge featuring interviews with
- 43:47leading e-commerce retailers, industry thoughtleads and the
- 43:50C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 43:53strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 43:55Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 43:58advice based on the experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 44:01strategy and text. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 44:04out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an E comms
- 44:07project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 44:09episode.