Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Horns Effect in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's start with a number: twenty-three percent. That's how much less likely a high-performing employee is to be recommended for a leadership development program if they made one visible mistake early in their tenure — even if they've done great work for years after that. Luna: That's from a 2025 Harvard Business School study, right? I remember reading that. They ran simulations with actual managers and the pattern held across industries. Lucas: Exactly. It's a classic example of the horns effect — the cognitive bias where a single negative trait or event colors your entire perception of someone. And in office politics, it's arguably more dangerous than its famous cousin, the halo effect. Luna: Because with the halo effect, one good thing gives you an unfair advantage. With the horns effect, one bad thing undoes all your good work. Lucas: Right. And if this show has helped you think through a situation like that — how to protect your reputation, or how to evaluate someone fairly — a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these episodes ad-free and independent. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Luna: Yeah, it's a small thing that makes a big difference for us. We keep the shows free for everyone, and listener support is what allows that. Lucas: So back to the horns effect. The HBS study is striking because it's not about low performers — it's about people who clearly delivered results. But that early stumble created what researchers call a 'negative anchor.' Once it's set, every subsequent action gets interpreted through that lens. Luna: I've seen this firsthand. A colleague of mine once asked a tough question in a town hall, maybe phrased it a bit bluntly. She got labeled 'difficult.' Suddenly, every suggestion she made was seen as confrontational, even when she said the same thing as someone else. Lucas: That's exactly how the horns effect propagates. It's not about the content of what you say — it's about the filter people are hearing it through. And the scary part is, most managers don't realize they're doing it. Luna: So how do you fight it? Both as someone who might be on the receiving end, and as someone evaluating others? Lucas: Let's start on the receiving end. Step one is awareness — recognize that if you made a visible misstep, you might be dealing with a horns effect, not a fair assessment. Step two is what I'd call 're-anchoring.' Deliberately show a different side of yourself in a new context. If the mistake was about missing a deadline, then offer to lead a project that requires impeccable time management. Give people new data points that contradict the old narrative. Luna: Does that actually work? I feel like people sometimes double down on their original impression. Lucas: It works if you do it consistently and if you get a third party to vouch for you. The HBS study found that when a peer or a senior leader explicitly pointed out the person's strengths, the bias dropped by nearly half. So it's not just about your own actions — it's about getting allies to recalibrate the conversation. Luna: On the manager side, what's the fix? I mean, we all want to be fair, but these biases are automatic. Lucas: Structure. The single best antidote is to evaluate people against explicit criteria before you consider any global impression. For example, when giving feedback, write down specific behaviors and outcomes before you form an overall rating. The research shows that if you delay making a summary judgment until after you've listed concrete evidence, the horns effect weakens significantly. Luna: So it's about separating the data from the story you tell yourself about the person. Lucas: Exactly. Another tactic is the 'flip test.' Before finalizing any evaluation, ask yourself: if this person had a positive early reputation instead of a negative one, would I be interpreting this behavior differently? If the answer is yes, you're probably in horns-effect territory. Luna: That's a good mental shortcut. I also wonder about the role of company culture. Some organizations seem more prone to this than others. Lucas: Absolutely. Cultures that emphasize 'zero defects' or have a strong blame orientation supercharge the horns effect. One mistake and you're branded. In contrast, cultures that explicitly talk about growth mindset and treat errors as learning opportunities reduce the bias — not eliminate it, but reduce it. Luna: But even in a growth-oriented culture, the horns effect can still bite you if the mistake is public and dramatic. Think about a presentation that goes badly, or a project that fails visibly. Lucas: Right. The more visible the mistake, the stronger the anchoring. That's why it's smart to manage the narrative early. If you realize you've made a public error, address it directly and frame it as a learning moment before others frame it for you. Apologize if needed, explain what you learned, and then move on quickly to your next win. Luna: Don't let the story write itself. You have to get out in front of it. Lucas: Precisely. There's also a subtler version of the horns effect that happens in meetings. Someone speaks up with a slightly off-topic comment, and from then on, people subtly dismiss their contributions. It's not just about big mistakes — it can be small social fumbles. Luna: So what do you do in the moment if you feel that happening to you? Like, you make a point and the room goes quiet, and you sense people are writing you off? Lucas: One technique is to follow up your own point with a question that invites others into the conversation. Instead of letting the silence hang, say something like, 'I'd be curious to hear how that compares to what we saw in the Q2 numbers.' It reframes your contribution as part of a larger inquiry, not a statement that can be judged. Luna: That's clever. You're not defending your idea; you're expanding it. Lucas: Yes. And over time, if you consistently do that, people start seeing you as someone who advances thinking, not someone who makes off-topic comments. You're gradually overwriting that negative anchor. Luna: I want to go back to the manager side for a second. What about performance reviews? That's where the horns effect can do real career damage. Lucas: Performance reviews are a minefield. The HBS study specifically looked at recommendations for leadership development, and the bias was strongest when the evaluation was holistic. When managers had to give a single rating or a simple yes/no, the horns effect ruled. But when they used a rubric with multiple dimensions — communication, execution, collaboration — and scored each separately, the effect dropped by almost two-thirds. Luna: So the takeaway for anyone designing a review process: separate dimensions, don't ask for an overall impression until the end, and ideally don't even show the overall score until all dimensions are scored. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're an employee going into a review where you suspect a horns effect is at play, you can prompt that structured thinking yourself. Say something like, 'I'd love to hear your feedback on each area — here's how I think I did on execution, on collaboration, on initiative.' You're essentially guiding them away from a global judgment. Luna: That requires a lot of self-awareness and confidence, but it's a great move. Lucas: It does. But the alternative is letting the bias run unchecked. And the thing about the horns effect is it's often invisible to the person holding it. They genuinely believe their assessment is fair. So you have to be strategic about providing counter-evidence in a way that feels natural, not defensive. Luna: Let's talk about the opposite scenario — when you're the one who might be biased against someone. How do you catch yourself? Lucas: The simplest check is to ask: 'What would I think of this person if I had never heard about that one incident?' If your answer changes, you're biased. Another is to keep a 'positive data log' — a running list of good things people do. That way, when you evaluate them, you have a balanced record, not just the one negative memory. Luna: That's a good habit for any manager. It's like building a buffer against your own cognitive shortcuts. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not about being soft — it's about being accurate. The horns effect leads to bad decisions. You might pass over someone who'd be a great leader simply because they stumbled once. That's a loss for the organization, not just for the individual. Luna: So wrapping up, the horns effect is powerful, but it's not inevitable. Awareness, structure, and deliberate counter-narratives can defang it. Lucas: Right. And the next time you catch yourself writing someone off based on one thing, pause and ask: is this a pattern, or am I seeing horns? That question alone can change the trajectory of someone's career.