Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Munger’s First Million: Real Estate Strategy
Transcript
- 0:00When you close your eyes and picture Charlie Munger, what's
- 0:02the image that you know immediately comes to mind?
- 0:05It's the icon, right? The 99 year old Sage.
- 0:09Thick glasses that suit that looks comfortable but expensive
- 0:13sitting on stage next to Warren. Buffett an arena with like
- 0:1640,000 people. Exactly, sipping a coke and
- 0:19dropping these one liners that just completely destroy entire
- 0:22economic theories. Right, we see the Oracle.
- 0:25We see the billionaire with AB, but here's the thing that just
- 0:29drives me crazy. By the usual narrative, yeah, we
- 0:31see the result, but we almost never talk about the engine that
- 0:35got him there. You mean seed capital, the
- 0:37initial fuel? I mean, the first million,
- 0:40because let's be honest, you can't just walk up to Warren
- 0:42Buffett in 1960 and say, hey, let's be partners if you don't
- 0:45have chips to put on the table. And Munger, well, he wasn't born
- 0:49with those chips. He didn't inherit a trust fund.
- 0:51That's right. And the how is actually a lot
- 0:54grittier than people realize. It wasn't just, you know,
- 0:56picking stocks. In fact, if Munger had stuck to
- 0:58just picking stocks with the little money he saved from his
- 1:01paycheck, we we might never heard of.
- 1:03It it wasn't the stock market at all, not initially.
- 1:06And it definitely wasn't his day job as a lawyer.
- 1:09So that is our mission for this deep dive.
- 1:12We are going to strip away the Berkshire Hathaway legend and go
- 1:15back to 1960s California. We are going to unpack the
- 1:20specific mathematical blueprint Charlie Munger use to move from
- 1:24selling his time by the hour to building massive equity.
- 1:28It's really a master class in two things, leverage and
- 1:31velocity. And honestly, it's a strategy
- 1:34that is, well, it's terrifyingly aggressive compared to the safe
- 1:38investing advice we usually hear.
- 1:40We're going to get into the math of that because it is
- 1:42surprisingly aggressive. But before we decode Monger's
- 1:45past strategies, we have to touch on the present for just a
- 1:47second. Sure, if you are trying to
- 1:49follow in these Giants footsteps, you need to know the
- 1:51temperature of the room you're walking into right now.
- 1:53Context is everything. You don't want to be aggressive
- 1:56when the market is screaming danger.
- 1:58Exactly. And to track total market
- 2:00temperature right now, we recommend you search and
- 2:03download the iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App
- 2:06Store. Oh yeah, It provides daily
- 2:08alerts on the Buffett Indicator to help monitor market bubbles.
- 2:11It's essential for anyone looking for value in a noisy
- 2:15world. It's a great tool.
- 2:16It really keeps you honest about valuations so you don't get
- 2:19swept up in the hype. So let's set the stage.
- 2:21The year is 1948. Charlie Munger graduates from
- 2:24Harvard Law School Magna cum laude.
- 2:27The best of the best. He is brilliant.
- 2:29He is hard working. He lands a job at a prestigious
- 2:32firm in Los Angeles. By every standard of the 1950s
- 2:36American Dream, he has won the game.
- 2:38On paper, absolutely. He's in the elite.
- 2:40He has the pedigree, the job, the status.
- 2:42But Munger had this unique ability to look at a situation,
- 2:46even a successful one, and just deconstruct it to find the
- 2:49structural flaw and. He found one.
- 2:51Oh yeah. He realized pretty quickly that
- 2:53he had walked into a trap. A trap.
- 2:56He's a Harvard lawyer making good money in the post war boom.
- 2:59I mean, most people would kill for that kind of trap.
- 3:02It's the linear trap, and this is the fundamental problem with
- 3:05professional services. Whether you're a high-powered
- 3:07lawyer, a consultant, or you know, a specialized surgeon, you
- 3:11are selling your time for money. The tyranny of the hourly rate.
- 3:14Right. And let's say Munger was billing
- 3:16in today's dollars 500 or even $1000 an hour.
- 3:20That sounds great. That sounds amazing.
- 3:21But it is mathematically capped. There are only 24 hours in a
- 3:24day. Even if you never sleep, your
- 3:27income has a hard ceiling. So if Munger stops working, the
- 3:31money stops flowing. Exactly.
- 3:32It's a linear equation. Input time equals output cash.
- 3:36There is 0 leverage. If he takes a vacation, he loses
- 3:39money. If you get sick, he loses money.
- 3:42And knowing Munger's personality, this obsession with
- 3:45efficiency and compounding that inefficiency must have been
- 3:48agonizing. It drove him nuts.
- 3:50It's like driving a Ferrari in a school zone.
- 3:53There's a famous quote from him about this period, he said.
- 3:56I didn't want my client to decide my future, I wanted to
- 3:59decide it myself. He wanted out.
- 4:01He realized that to have true independence, what he called
- 4:04financial dignity, he needed to decouple his income from his
- 4:08effort. He needed a machine that worked
- 4:10while he slept. And he realized that wealth
- 4:12isn't built by high income, it's built by owning equity.
- 4:15Exactly. He needed two things to break
- 4:17out of the trap capital and leverage.
- 4:19OK, capital and leverage. But here's the problem.
- 4:22He's a young lawyer with a big family to feed.
- 4:25He doesn't have capital. He has cash flow.
- 4:27Maybe, but not a giant pile of money.
- 4:30So how does he make that leap? Well, the opportunity presents
- 4:33itself in early 1960s and the setting is crucial.
- 4:36Here we are in Pasadena, CA. The Golden State in its golden
- 4:40era. Specifically a massive macro
- 4:43trend, a population boom, post war America is just flooding
- 4:46into California. The weather, the aerospace jobs,
- 4:49the lifestyle. And when you have a tidal wave
- 4:51of people moving to a specific zip code, what is the one thing
- 4:55they all need immediately? A roof over their heads.
- 4:58Housing Munger looked at the data and remember he's a data
- 5:02guy, and he saw this massive supply and demand imbalance.
- 5:06There were too many people and not enough apartments,
- 5:09especially close to universities like Caltech and the job
- 5:11centers. So simple economics one O 1 High
- 5:14demand, low supply. Prices have to go up.
- 5:17Right. So he decides to partner up with
- 5:20a client of his actually and develop apartment projects.
- 5:24Now I want to pause here because I think most listeners tune out
- 5:27when they hear real estate development.
- 5:28Yeah, they think it's just for tycoons or people with hard
- 5:30hats. Or they think it's about fixing
- 5:32toilets at 2:00 in the morning, right?
- 5:34But Munger didn't approach this like a landlord.
- 5:37He approached it like a mathematician.
- 5:39He looked at the deal structure and realized he could
- 5:42manufacture returns that were well, they were impossible in
- 5:45the stock market. OK, this is the part of the deep
- 5:47dive where we need to slow down and really look at the numbers,
- 5:51because the way he structured these deals, that's the secret
- 5:54sauce wasn't just buying a house and hoping it went up in value.
- 5:58No, not at all. It was an arbitrage.
- 6:00Let's walk through the math breakdown.
- 6:02We'll simplify the numbers to make it crystal clear based on
- 6:04the examples from the source material.
- 6:06OK, walk me through the Monger math.
- 6:08Let's pretend I'm Monger in 1961, OK?
- 6:11Imagine a single apartment project.
- 6:14Let's call it Project Alpha. It costs $100,000 to build.
- 6:18This includes the land, the concrete, the lumber, the labor,
- 6:22everything. Got it. 100K all in cost.
- 6:25Now let's say you build it and the market value upon completion
- 6:29is $120,000. So you sell it immediately.
- 6:32You are not keeping it to rent it out for 30 years.
- 6:34You are building and selling. OK.
- 6:36So 120 sales price minus the 100K cost.
- 6:41That's a $20,000 profit. Correct.
- 6:44Now if you did this the Safeway, the unleveraged way, you would
- 6:48have taken 100,000 of your own hard earned cash, built the
- 6:51thing and made 20 grand. That is a 20% return on
- 6:54investment. Which isn't bad.
- 6:56I mean, 20% beats the S&P 500 in most years.
- 6:58If I made 20% of My Portfolio consistently, I'd be happy.
- 7:01It's good, but is it life changing?
- 7:04No. Does it turn a lawyer into a
- 7:05billionaire? No way.
- 7:07It's too slow. Munger needed velocity, and he
- 7:10didn't have the 100 grand cash to begin with.
- 7:14So what did he do differently? He applied leverage.
- 7:17He went to the bank. In this scenario, Munger and his
- 7:19partners wouldn't put up the full 100,000.
- 7:22They might only put up, say, $20,000 of their own money.
- 7:25This is their equity. OK so they have skin in the game
- 7:2920,000 but they need 100,000 to pay the contractors.
- 7:32Where does the other 80,000 come from?
- 7:34The bank, they borrow the 80,000 as a construction loan.
- 7:37They build the project. The total cost is still 100,000.
- 7:41The building is exactly the same.
- 7:43They sell it for the same price, 120 thousand.
- 7:45OK, so closing day comes, they get the 120 check from the
- 7:49buyer. What happens first?
- 7:51The bank gets paid. They want their 80 grand back.
- 7:54Right bank takes 80,000. You are left with $40,000.
- 7:58Now think about your initial investment.
- 8:00You put in $20,000. You walked away with 40,000 you.
- 8:04Doubled your money. You made a 100% return on
- 8:06equity. The project's profitability
- 8:09didn't change. It was still a 20% margin on the
- 8:11asset. But your return on equity
- 8:14skyrocketed because you used other people's money to fund the
- 8:18bulk of the cost. That is the magic of the equity
- 8:21multiplier. You're earning the profit on the
- 8:23whole building, but only if it's for a fraction of it.
- 8:26Precisely. It acts as a magnifier, and
- 8:29Munger saw this mathematical certainty.
- 8:31This, and this is a big if he could ensure the project sold
- 8:34quickly and at the right price, the returns would be
- 8:37astronomical compared to billing hours.
- 8:40But wait, you said if he could ensure the project sold.
- 8:43That's the catch, isn't it? Real estate is competitive if
- 8:46the market dips or if nobody wants your apartments.
- 8:49That leverage works in reverse. You still owe the bank.
- 8:52That is the risk, yeah. And this brings us to the second
- 8:54type of leverage Munger used. We talked about financial
- 8:57leverage. Now we have to talk about
- 8:59intellectual leverage. Intellectual leverage.
- 9:01I like that, yeah. So how did he outsmart the other
- 9:04developers? Because Munger had zero
- 9:06experience in construction, right?
- 9:07He's a lawyer. Zero.
- 9:09But he had taste and he had logic.
- 9:11Look at the landscape at the time.
- 9:12Most developers were greedy. Land in California was getting
- 9:15expensive. So the prevailing wisdom, the
- 9:18herd mentality, was to build high density multi story boxes.
- 9:22Cram as many units as possible onto the lot.
- 9:25Minimize land cost per unit. It's an efficiency play.
- 9:28It's an efficiency play on a spreadsheet, but the result was
- 9:31these cramped, uninspiring concrete boxes.
- 9:35Dark corridors, no yards, shared walls on every side.
- 9:39They were ugly. Munger being Munger inverted the
- 9:42problem. Invert.
- 9:43Always invert he. Asked If I lived here, what
- 9:45would I want? He put himself in the customer's
- 9:47shoes, and he realized that people moving to California
- 9:50wanted the California dream. They wanted light, they wanted
- 9:53air. They wanted a connection to the
- 9:54ground. They didn't move to Pasadena to
- 9:56live in a dark tower. So he went against the grain.
- 9:59Completely. While everyone was building up,
- 10:01Munger built out. He built one story, maybe
- 10:03two-story garden apartments. Wait, doesn't that hurt the
- 10:06math? Fewer units on the same
- 10:08expensive land. It hurts the density math, yes,
- 10:11but Munger prioritized excellent lighting, extensive landscaping,
- 10:14green space, and privacy. He made them genuinely pleasant
- 10:18places to live. He built a better product.
- 10:20A significantly better product, and the payoff was twofold.
- 10:24First, yes, he could charge a premium price because they were
- 10:27nicer, but the second payoff is the one that really mattered for
- 10:30his wealth compounding. He could sell them faster.
- 10:33Velocity again. In the internal rate of return,
- 10:36the IRR calculation time is the enemy.
- 10:39Every month a unit sits empty, you are paying interest to the
- 10:42bank and your equity is trapped, right?
- 10:44While his competitors were sitting on unsold units in their
- 10:47ugly towers, Munger's units were selling out immediately,
- 10:50sometimes before they were even finished.
- 10:52So he got his capital back, his initial 20 grand plus the profit
- 10:56in say six months instead of 12. Exactly, and because he got it
- 11:00back faster, he could roll it into the next deal sooner.
- 11:02So he combined financial leverage using the bank's money
- 11:06with a superior product strategy that minimized his risk of
- 11:10holding the asset too long. That's the genius.
- 11:13It wasn't just gambling with debt.
- 11:15He skewed the odds in his favor by having the best product in a
- 11:19hungry market. He essentially de risked the
- 11:22leverage by ensuring demand. So he's got the formula.
- 11:25Leverage plus good product equals big returns.
- 11:29What do you do next? Do you just sit on the cache?
- 11:31This is Charlie Munger we're talking about.
- 11:33He didn't buy a yacht. He didn't buy a Ferrari.
- 11:36He initiated the snowball. The snowball between 1961 and
- 11:411964, a very short window, really just three or four years.
- 11:44He rinsed and repeated this process roughly five times.
- 11:48Five projects. And he didn't take the profits
- 11:50out to spend on lifestyle. He let the money compound.
- 11:52He rolled the principal plus the profit from Project A into
- 11:55Project B, which was bigger, then rolled all of that into
- 11:58project C. It's the eighth wonder of the
- 12:00world. Compounding, but usually
- 12:01compounding takes decades. Munger was doing it in months.
- 12:04Because of the leverage, he was compounding at rates of 100% or
- 12:07more per project. So what was the tally at the end
- 12:11of this run? He starts with practically
- 12:14nothing in 1961. Where is he in 1964?
- 12:17In just those few years, he turned his initial scraps of
- 12:20capital into $1.4 million in cash. 1.4 million, now we have
- 12:26to pause and adjust for inflation, 1,000,000 for in
- 12:291964, that's not a million for today.
- 12:32No. Depending on how you calculate
- 12:33it, that is equivalent to well over $10 million, maybe closer
- 12:37to 12 or 13 million in today's purchasing power.
- 12:39So in three years doing a side hustle while working as a
- 12:42lawyer, he made $10 million. Correct.
- 12:45He was independently wealthy. He never had to work another day
- 12:48in his life if he didn't want to.
- 12:49He had secured his freedom. But then something interesting
- 12:53happens, and I think this is the part of the story that is most
- 12:55relevant to investors today. The source mentions a sudden
- 12:58stop. He's making 100% returns.
- 13:01The market is still hot. He's the king of Pasadena real
- 13:03estate. Why did he stop?
- 13:07This is perhaps the most important lesson for the
- 13:09listener. Munger stopped cold.
- 13:11He walked away from development completely.
- 13:13Why Greed usually tells you to keep going.
- 13:15I'm good at this. Let's just do bigger buildings.
- 13:18Because he understood the dark side of leverage, he knew that
- 13:22while leverage multiplies your gains, it also multiplies your
- 13:26losses. And crucially, in those days,
- 13:29these construction loans were often recourse debt.
- 13:32Meaning he was personally on the hook.
- 13:34If the market turned, or interest rates spiked or a
- 13:37project stalled and he couldn't pay back the bank, he wouldn't
- 13:40just lose his profit. The bank could come after his
- 13:42personal assets. He could lose everything.
- 13:44He could lose the 1.4 million he had just made.
- 13:47He could go back to zero. He realized the asymmetry had
- 13:50shifted. He had more to lose than to
- 13:53gain. He'd reached escape velocity.
- 13:55Exactly. He had the seed capital.
- 13:57He needed that 1.4 million to play a different game.
- 14:00A game where he didn't need to sign personal guarantees on
- 14:03construction loans. A game of buying businesses
- 14:06stocks. Right.
- 14:07He took that money, founded his Investment Partnership, and
- 14:11eventually that money merged into the Berkshire Hathaway
- 14:14universe. That real estate money is the
- 14:17grandfather of the billions we see today.
- 14:20I love that he used real estate not as a career, but as a
- 14:23vehicle, a specific tool to get to the starting line of his true
- 14:27career. Precisely.
- 14:29It was a means to an end. He climbed the ladder and then
- 14:31he kicked it away. So what does this all mean for
- 14:34us, for the listener driving to work or at the gym right now?
- 14:37I mean, this is a story of 1960s real estate, but most of us
- 14:41aren't going to go build garden apartments in Pasadena, right?
- 14:45How do we apply the Munger method today?
- 14:47I think there are three huge takeaways here that apply to
- 14:50almost any field, whether you're in tech, sales, or investing.
- 14:54Let's get them take away #1. Number one, the first bucket is
- 14:57the hardest. Munger has always said that the
- 15:00first $100,000 or in today's money may be the first
- 15:03significant nest egg is the most painful to earn.
- 15:06Because you have no leverage yet, you're just pushing the
- 15:08boulder. You are pushing a boulder
- 15:10uphill. You have to be extremely frugal,
- 15:12work incredibly hard, or find a side hustle like Munger did to
- 15:16accumulate that initial capital. You can't invest capital you
- 15:20don't have. There is no magic trick to
- 15:23skipping this step. You have to grind before you can
- 15:26compound. It's the unglamorous truth
- 15:29Munker was working law all day and doing real estate deals at
- 15:32night and on weekends. Take away #2 respect leverage.
- 15:37Notice I didn't say fear leverage or love leverage.
- 15:39Respect it. Munger used it to get rich, then
- 15:42stopped using it to stay rich. That's the key distinction.
- 15:45Most people get it wrong in one of two ways.
- 15:48They either never use leverage because they are too scared so
- 15:51they stay in the linear trap forever, or they use leverage,
- 15:54get rich, get addicted to the easy returns, and then blow
- 15:58themselves up when the cycle turns.
- 16:00That's the smart money track. When you're winning, you just
- 16:02want to double down. And that's how you go broke.
- 16:05Munger knew when to walk away from the table.
- 16:07He used leverage as a booster rocket to get to orbit.
- 16:10Then he jettisoned the rocket. And the third take away.
- 16:13Asymmetric opportunities. Munger didn't just buy random
- 16:16buildings. He identified a massive macro
- 16:19tailwind population growth and combined it with a superior
- 16:23product design. He stacked the deck.
- 16:25He ensured a high win rate. He wasn't gambling, he was
- 16:29executing a business plan where he knew he had an edge.
- 16:32If you can find a situation where you have a tailwind, maybe
- 16:35it's AI right now, maybe it's a specific niche in your industry
- 16:39and you have a better product or skill set, that is where you
- 16:42apply the leverage. It sounds so simple when you
- 16:44break it down like that, but it requires a lot of independent
- 16:47thinking. As the source says, success is
- 16:50often just simple concepts plus execution, but the execution is
- 16:55the hard part. Aggressive execution.
- 16:57Munger wasn't passive. He was building, designing,
- 17:00borrowing, selling. He was all in.
- 17:02He was, and he was willing to look foolish to his law partners
- 17:05who probably thought, why is Charlie messing around with
- 17:08concrete? So here's a provocative thought
- 17:10to leave you with. We often look for the magic
- 17:13bullet in investing, the secret stock dip, the new crypto coin.
- 17:17But Munger's wealth, the foundation of it, came from
- 17:20looking at a very boring problem.
- 17:22People need a place to live. And solving it slightly better
- 17:25than the guy next door. Using the bank's money to
- 17:27amplify the result, it raises the question, what is the boring
- 17:32problem in front of you right now that everyone else is
- 17:34ignoring or solving poorly? And do you have the guts to
- 17:37borrow against your conviction to solve it?
- 17:39That's the Munger challenge. Indeed, before we sign off, a
- 17:42quick reminder. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 17:45on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 17:48or differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 17:52purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 17:55Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 17:57decisions. And hey, if you want to listen
- 17:59to our full deep dive about this topic or access more advanced
- 18:03contents, welcome to join the Deep Value Club membership or
- 18:07subscribe to us on Apple, Spotify Podcasts Channel, Deep
- 18:10Value Investing and luluvc.com. We'd love to see you there.
- 18:14Go find your vehicle for that first million.
- 18:16Thanks for listening to this deep dive.
- 18:18See you next time.