Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / If I Was the Intelligent Designer (PART TWO: with Dr. Abby Hafer)
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheist this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews.
- 0:56This coming weekend, I'm speaking at the weekend Reason comes in Calgary,
- 1:00Alberta, Canada. Looking Ahead It's Denver, my hometown of Tulsa, Oklahoma,
- 1:07Albion, Rochester and then Sarnia, Ontario, Canada. All the details
- 1:11times, dates, places, tickets, etc. At Seth andrews dot com
- 1:18slash events. We are continuing a conversation that actually started last week talking about
- 1:27intelligent or not so intelligent design. It made so much sense to talk to
- 1:34an evolutionary biologist. She is author of the book The Not So Intelligent Designer,
- 1:40and I'm glad to call her friend, doctor Abbey Hafer. So good
- 1:42to have you. Nice to be here. Thanks for having me on.
- 1:47You have made I don't know, at least part of your career debunking the
- 1:51idea that we live in a fine tuned universe. Right, I mean,
- 1:55just give me a few of the things that rubbed you wrong about the way
- 1:57things are quote unquote design. Well, my specialty really is looking at they
- 2:05had designed, particularly of the human body. But I can also relate it
- 2:08to other animals. I should explain. I have a doctorate in zoology,
- 2:14but I've spent the last twenty plus years of my life teaching human anatomy and
- 2:17physiology. So as I teach human anatomy and physiology, I cannot help but
- 2:23notice a lot of things that really could have been done better. And because
- 2:29I also have training in zoology, I often notice other animals that got better
- 2:32deals, which means that if we are considered, you know, the pinnacle
- 2:38of creation, Well, I have some words that I'd like to share with
- 2:42our creator. I mentioned earlier that I wish I had the eye of an
- 2:46eagle or a heart. I mean, would you take the eagle eye over
- 2:51what we have? You and I They've definitely got the better eyes in terms
- 2:54of accuracy. So yeah, I mean, there are lots of things that
- 2:59we could have that would be nicer, but the things that I really really
- 3:04love are the things where we got a version that it's just plain wrong,
- 3:09and there are other animals that got better versions of the same thing. For
- 3:15instance, in our eyes, our eyes are built a lot the same way
- 3:21that eagle eyes are. But have you heard about how our retinas are backwards,
- 3:28something about the image being inverted. Well, there's images that are inverted.
- 3:31That just has to do with pinhole cameras and physics and such. But
- 3:37the thing is the actual biology of our eye. The part of our eye
- 3:42that actually takes on the image is called the retina, and our retina actually
- 3:49has the photoreceptor cells that cells that are sensitive to light at the very very
- 3:54back of the retina, and then it has blood vessels lying on top of
- 3:59that, and it has nerve fibers lying on top of that, so that
- 4:02the light that enters your eye actually has to fight its way past all of
- 4:09these nerve fibers and past all of these blood vessels before it gets to the
- 4:14photosensitive cells underneath all that rubbish and so basically, we do not get accurate,
- 4:21high information images to our retinas, and a lot of image processing has
- 4:28to be done before we can even start the process of seeing and making sense
- 4:34of it. When I see ken Ham at the Creation Museum talking about how
- 4:40amazing the eye is, and then I see him wearing prescription lenses for vision
- 4:45correction, hashtag irony. I'm sorry, didn't mean to interrupt, but absolutely
- 4:48hashtag irony. And there are lots of things like that that go on that
- 4:54people don't even think about. But the point is we've got these retinas.
- 4:58Even if your or my eyes work perfectly as well as they possibly can.
- 5:04So I'm not even talking about those of us who need glasses or anything like
- 5:11that, but even if our eyes are working as well as they possibly could,
- 5:15they still have this fundamental design flaw, which is, no matter how
- 5:21good they are, you still have the light fighting its way past this other
- 5:26stuff, whereas invertebrates like squid and octopuses actually have written as where the photosensitive
- 5:33part is actually facing the light, which makes sense when you think about it.
- 5:39The best analogy I can use is if you were to take your camera
- 5:43and put some cotton or various other things in front of the lens, so
- 5:48that there are fibers in such between the lens and the outside world. That's
- 5:54basically the way our eyes are built, whereas that's not the way that squid
- 5:58eyes are built. So the point is, we just got a design that,
- 6:01even when it's working as well as it possibly can, it's just bad
- 6:06compared to squid on octopuses. So you really have to ask who God likes
- 6:12better well, thinking about design quote unquote design for good and for ill in
- 6:17the animal kingdom. I know you spoke about the giraffe and the laryngeal nerve.
- 6:23I think it was supposed to go fourteen inches, but instead it goes
- 6:26like fourteen feet. Yes, that is correct. That is one portion of
- 6:30one nerve where we have this odd thing which happens in all of us,
- 6:35which is that this nerve actually goes and wraps around one of the blood vessels
- 6:42coming out of the heart, which in us is kind of a moderate unnecessary
- 6:46trip for this fiber. But then, of course giraffes have very very long
- 6:51necks, but they have your same basic vertebrate body plan, and so yes,
- 6:57that extra length of nerve just has to become very very very long in
- 7:02giraffes. But I'd like to talk about some other things where I mean.
- 7:08The problem with the lrential nerve example, I think, is that although it's
- 7:13definitely delightfully weird, it does not do us actual harm, where there are
- 7:17plenty of other things that do us actual harm, for instance, testicles.
- 7:29Yes, I can hear you crossing your legs. The point is that men
- 7:34are all familiar with the fact that the testicles are vulnerable, so this is
- 7:42really not a good thing if it could be avoided. And as you probably
- 7:47know, our cold blooded relatives don't have this problem, and their sperm making
- 7:51equipment is safe inside them. But if you have taken anatomy and physiology or
- 7:58anything resembling it, you probably know that for humans, the testes hang outside
- 8:05the body because they have to stay slightly cooler than normal body temperature if they're
- 8:11going to create sperm. And so we are stuck with this kind of you
- 8:15know, weird setup where the testicles have to hang outside the body, even
- 8:20while all our other soft organs like our brain and our stomach and our livers
- 8:26and all this kind of thing are all safely protected inside our bodies. But
- 8:31you know, people will say, oh, but look what God did.
- 8:33God put the testies on the outside the bodies so that you have tests at
- 8:37slightly cooler temperature, And isn't that wonderful? What great planning? The problem
- 8:43there is? I mean, let's start with the basics. It's like,
- 8:46who thought of the idea that normal body temperature should be too hot for sperm
- 8:52production? I mean, this does not sound like good planning to me.
- 8:56But what becomes ever more ironic is that there are plenty of warm blooded animals
- 9:03that have internal testicles, and it includes all birds, did you hear me?
- 9:09All birds, plus fellow mammals like whales and dolphins, and also elephants
- 9:18and rhinoceroses and things like this. They all have internal testicles. So you
- 9:22have to ask yourself who God likes better? Is it rhinoceroses or men?
- 9:28I have rhinoceros envy as well as squid envy as well as well. We
- 9:35should. Yes, yeah, but you're about to become more envious. This
- 9:39is something I just love, and this deserves a bit more writing about.
- 9:43But I have covered this in The Not So Intelligent Designer, which is my
- 9:48book. You've heard of convertibles, right, those nice, fun ragtop cars
- 9:52that you can drive around in a nice weather. Convertibles are not just for
- 9:58cars. There are some animals, some mammals like rats and mice, that
- 10:03have convertible testicles basically where they can tuck them inside to keep them out of
- 10:09harm's way, but if they want to reproduce, then they can take them
- 10:15out, let them cool off and make some new sperm, and away they
- 10:18go, and then they can reproduce. Now, think of this from the
- 10:22human standpoint. From the human standpoint, this would mean that you could have
- 10:30both protection and you could control your fertility. Human men would kill for that
- 10:37kind of thing. The idea that you could just basically turn off your fertility
- 10:41and turn on your fertility depending upon when you want to use it. Wouldn't
- 10:46that be a great system. Yeah, I'm sure there are women worldwide who
- 10:50would be hugely grateful for us to sort of take on that mantle much more
- 10:56right, reproduct their responsibility right, And men as well, I'm sure would
- 11:01love to have something that simple that they could do. So, as I
- 11:05said, this is something that rats and mice got, So you have to
- 11:09ask yourself why the rats and mice got a better deal. Than human men
- 11:13did to make things more interesting and the rodent world. There's also a phenomenon
- 11:20called the Bruce effect, named for its discoverer, Hilda Bruce, and what
- 11:26she discovered is that female rats and mice can actually reabsorb their litters if they
- 11:35are pregnant if they come into contact with the smell of a new male.
- 11:41So this is, you know, another form of birth control where if you
- 11:45could just smell something, women could control their fertility that way, if they
- 11:50got the equipment that rats and mice got. If I may ask a question,
- 11:54though, what's the utility of that it senses the old fact to reorgan
- 12:00a new male. What's the end zone or absorbing the potential offspring. Well,
- 12:07we will start with the fact that think of the advantage of just being
- 12:11able to absorb unwanted pregnancies, particularly given our politics right now, wouldn't that
- 12:16be nice? But the evolutionary end zone in this is mice and rats or
- 12:24mice live in colonies and very often there will be one reproductive male. So
- 12:31if a new male comes along and kicks out the old male, basically he's
- 12:37going to commit infanticide on anything that is produced from the old male's genetic stock.
- 12:45They have great smellers, so they can tell the difference. So therefore
- 12:50it's worth the females while to just reabsorb that litter in order to start reproducing
- 12:56with the new mail. Well, if you and I are speaking from a
- 13:00position of I mean, I guess you don't have to be omnipotent to be
- 13:03a better designer. But any other examples come to your mind, how would
- 13:07you better design everybody in everything? Well, okay, since we're having so
- 13:15much fun talking about reproduction, other animals, including other vertebrates, are able
- 13:20to reproduce without males, and you can see how there are some women who
- 13:26might think that this would be a great advantage to have. I missed the
- 13:30word reproduce without males. Without males, they do not need male input.
- 13:37They can just basically make copies of themselves. They can clone themselves as what
- 13:41it comes down to, And this includes snakes and sharks and all kinds of
- 13:46interesting creatures, and right now walking around in the world, there's also a
- 13:52brand new, all female species of crayfish which has evolved within the last say,
- 14:01ten to twenty years. So the next time that some creationist tells you,
- 14:05well, but you never see evolution happening, or you only see it
- 14:07in bacteria or this kind of thing, and somehow they think bacteria evolving doesn't
- 14:13count. This is a new species, a multicellular species that has evolved in
- 14:20the last ten to twenty years, and we have documented it's happening like a
- 14:26crawfish Cambrian explosion. If you will, I'm sorry, okay, yes,
- 14:31I just wanted to participate, Doctor har I just want to play a lot,
- 14:35right, absolutely, absolutely so. As I said, there's the whole
- 14:39business of being able to reproduce without males, which I'm sure some human females
- 14:45would like to be able to do. Then there's the whole problem with the
- 14:48human female reproductive system, where the basic problem is that, well, childbirth
- 14:56is very hard because we have large heads, because we're as we say where
- 15:03I come from, because we are wickets, matt. We have large heads,
- 15:07we have large brains, so we have large heads. But at the
- 15:11same time, we walk upright, so we walk on two legs, which
- 15:16means that you really need narrower hips because walking with very very wide hips is
- 15:24very inefficient and difficult. So women's hips have to be narrow enough on the
- 15:30one hand that we can walk, because otherwise we would die in the natural
- 15:33environment. But on the other hand, the hips have to be wide enough
- 15:39that human babies with their big heads can still be born. And the upshot
- 15:43is an uneasy compromise that does not work very well and it's very harmful to
- 15:50some individuals. It kills a lot of women. Even in our modern era,
- 15:56and certainly in older times it was not unusual for women to die in
- 16:02childbirth, and it was not unusual for infants to die of the process of
- 16:07being born. So it's really not a great system, and you would have
- 16:11thought that the creator of the universe could have done a better job, and
- 16:18a better job is possible because, for instance, kangaroos are also bipeds,
- 16:25but what they do is that they give birth to very small embryo like young
- 16:30which then finish their development on the outside of the body in the mother's pouch,
- 16:34and the mother's pouch comes complete with a nipple for nursing, so the
- 16:40babies develop on the outside of the body of their bipedal mother, which is
- 16:45a much better way to do it if you are going to be a biped
- 16:49and particularly if you are going to be a biped with large heads, which
- 16:56is what we are. So we could have gotten this easy, simple solution,
- 17:03but we didn't. If I was the designer, I'd be tempted to
- 17:07set up a model where I just you know, one click on Amazon,
- 17:11like I would like a child, and then I mean and they would just
- 17:14deliver. Or it's like if you could set up an aquarium in your living
- 17:18room and get it to develop there. I mean, there are possibilities exactly
- 17:23back to the bone structure of the primates. And I'd mentioned this earlier.
- 17:27Is if I know what I'm talking about, I am leaning on the shoulders
- 17:30of primatologists. Is it true that the reason that our knees become arthritic and
- 17:37wear out is because we were not originally bipeds. That is accurate. Yes,
- 17:41we have a whole bunch of problems that come about because we walk upright
- 17:48when our ancestors walked on all fours. This is why we have a bunch
- 17:53of different back problems because likewise, our lower backs in particular need to be
- 18:00able to hold up a whole lot of weight. And it's the difference between
- 18:06going from a suspension bridge to a pillar and you know, the life of
- 18:14a pillar is one that has to be able to hold up a whole lot
- 18:18more weight. It needs a whole lot more compression strength. Basically same thing
- 18:22with our knees. Our knees have to hold up a lot more weight than
- 18:26they would if we were walking on all fours. Coming up next, we're
- 18:32going to get into the whole reproduction thing. What was this quote unquote intelligent
- 18:37designer? Thinking more with doctor Abbehafer next, fucking here with doctor Abbey Haafer.
- 18:51She is an evolutionary biologist. She is author of the book The Not
- 18:55So Intelligent Designer, which, of course I will link in the description box
- 18:59and tell everybody to buy the book because it is amazing. Okay, doctor
- 19:04hay Ford the Designer, any other ideas for decreasing bad design or creating a
- 19:11better design? Well, I mean, I'm just going to talk a little
- 19:15bit more about the bad design of human reproduction, because there's also the whole
- 19:21business of the lack of implantation. When an egg gets fertilized, it is
- 19:26only a few days old when it must implant on the lining of the uterus
- 19:33if it is going to continue to develop. And this is before a person
- 19:41necessarily even knows that they are pregnant, So there are some changes that have
- 19:45already taken place. But here's what I'm getting at, some fairly chunky number
- 19:52of pregnancies fail to implant, and then the fertilized egg just washes out with
- 20:00menstrual flow. So think about this again. You're thinking about all the anti
- 20:04abortion advocates out there saying, oh, God creates a soul at the moment
- 20:10of conception and this kind of thing, Well, why does God create a
- 20:14soul at the moment of conception only to have twenty five percent of those souls
- 20:18last a few days and then fail to implant on the uterine lining Could it
- 20:25be argued then that God is the world's most prolific abortion doctor. Oh,
- 20:30God is the world's busiest abortionist by far, by far. And then there
- 20:37are also sort of post implantation miscarriages, to the point where a fairly large
- 20:45percentage of fertilized eggs never make it through the gestational process, so they die
- 20:52before they ever can really experience much of anything. And it just got a
- 20:59wonder you know, who thought of that, And for that matter, who
- 21:03thought of obstetric fistula, which is basically whereafter during a particularly difficult labor in
- 21:11women. There is so much pressing of the baby's body and that hard head
- 21:17that I was talking about earlier. And even though infant heads are softer than
- 21:22grown up heads, they're still hard enough that in a prolonged labor, you
- 21:26can have the baby's body pressing against the woman's softer tissues and against the bone
- 21:36in her birth canal for long enough that some of that tissue is deprived of
- 21:41blood and oxygen and therefore dies. And this is really disgusting, but this
- 21:48is God's fault, so I'm going to stick it to the creator, whoever
- 21:52it is. That the point is that you can wind up having what is
- 21:59called obstetric fistula, which is where the birth canal the vagina winds up having
- 22:07the tissue between that passage and either the urinary passage or the rectum. You
- 22:15can wind up having the tissue dissolving it between those different tubes, so that
- 22:21women actually cannot control their flow of urine or their flow of feces, all
- 22:26because they gave birth. And does this sound like a good design the you
- 22:33know it does? It does not. And again, if we had been
- 22:38designed like kangaroos, where you could just take the baby out of the uterus
- 22:45at a very very very young age, when it is still just basically an
- 22:48embryo. Just take that embryo out of the uterus, stick it into a
- 22:52pouch on the outside, and away you go. And if you're going to
- 22:57give birth, seriously, it's a much better way of doing it. You
- 23:02do not therefore risk obstetric fistula, which is debilitating. You do not risk
- 23:10dying in childbirth. There are all kinds of advantages to this system which we
- 23:15did not get. So when you hear people talk about fine tuning, a
- 23:19lot of this I think becomes so simple as to become a punchline. It's
- 23:23look at the trees. I hear a lot of those types of the thing,
- 23:26you know, look at the beauty, look at complexity, etc.
- 23:29As someone who has done so much homework, has had so much education into
- 23:33how things operate, complexity does not mean great design, right, wouldn't an
- 23:38engineer went the simplest version of a mechanism You've actually hit on a very very
- 23:45good thing. Yes, evolution creates very complex systems, sometimes in fact needlessly
- 23:53complex systems, because, as you said, a designer would actually go for
- 23:59the simplest process that works. What we cannot do as evolved creatures is kind
- 24:07of go back and do a reboot. So whereas in something that is designed
- 24:14like a sound system, we went from wax cylinders, for example, in
- 24:19recorded music, to vinyl discs to CDs to completely digital online music formats,
- 24:27and each time we oh, and I forgot cassette tapes in there as well.
- 24:33Each time we went back and we redesign the whole thing from start to
- 24:38finish to be able to provide music in a new way. We didn't get
- 24:44that with say the way we give birth, or the way we see or
- 24:48the way we digest our food. We didn't get any of that because we
- 24:53are not designed. Because we start with what we've got, and then there
- 25:00are random mutations that take place, and maybe some of those mutations work,
- 25:04and some of those mutations don't. The people with the delatarious mutations have a
- 25:11lot of problems and can die, and or i should say not just people,
- 25:15but the organisms with the mutations die. Nature doesn't care. And if
- 25:21there's a slightly better mutation that comes along then that gives a selective advantage,
- 25:26then that advantage may be carried forward. But it's all just basically about dying
- 25:33and breeding and dying and breeding. But what this means is that you can
- 25:37get lots and lots and lots of complexity through this. But what you don't
- 25:41see is design. Does that make sense? It does? It does.
- 25:45I'm carrying along a lot of evolutionary baggage, and sometimes that baggage is what.
- 25:52It doesn't mean anything, It's just there, and sometimes it can be
- 25:56detrimental. Would that be an accurate way to say it. I mean,
- 25:59it's baggage no matter how you slice it. Yeah. Actually, And I
- 26:02will give two examples of baggage. Then, baggage no matter how you slice
- 26:10it is a mixed metaphor. Mixed metaphor, that's true. But I'm going
- 26:15to give you, let's call them evolutionary leftovers, also known in the profession
- 26:21as vestigial organs or vestigial reactions. So I'm going to give you an example
- 26:27of a bit of evolutionary leftovers that does us no harm, and then I'll
- 26:33talk about one that does do us harm. So let's start with a really
- 26:37fun one, the Erector Peely muscle. You have hair all over your body.
- 26:44You're probably aware of this, and sometimes you get goosebumps right when your
- 26:51little hairs literally stand up straight. You get goosebumps when you're cold and when
- 26:56you're tired. Did you ever think about that? I mean we have.
- 27:00It happened all the time to the point where we don't even scratch our heads
- 27:03and think why did it do that? Anyway, does it accomplish anything?
- 27:07As I mean in my current evolved higher primate state, it accomplished something back
- 27:14when we were furry. This is a reminder that we are evolved from furry
- 27:22animals. We have these tiny little muscles attached to every hair called an erector
- 27:29peely muscle, and they literally will pull your hair up so that it's taller.
- 27:34And it happens when you are cold, because if you are a furry
- 27:41animal and your fur suddenly becomes thicker, that's like putting on a warmer coat.
- 27:48For instance, if you've ever seen birds, which I know are not
- 27:52mammals, but the same process of trying to provide insulation applies. If you've
- 27:57ever seen birds in a tree on a really, really cold day, have
- 28:03you noticed that they fluff their feathers up. What they're doing there is that
- 28:07they're providing a thicker layer of insulation between their warm bodies and the cold air.
- 28:12And that's what happens to us when we get goosebumps. Our little hairs
- 28:18are being pulled upright so that we literally have a thicker coating of insulation to
- 28:23try and retain our body warmth. This works if you have fur. It
- 28:30doesn't help us because our fur at this point is minuscule and doesn't help us
- 28:33stay warm. But it's an evolutionary leftover. It shows that we used to
- 28:40be furry animals because we get goosebumps when we're cold, and the other time
- 28:45we get goosebumps is when we're frightened. And the reason for that is because
- 28:52animals in nature try to look bigger when they are frightened. It's a way
- 28:59of trying to stare down an enemy, whether it's a predator or whether it
- 29:04is somebody you may fight with. If you can make yourself look bigger,
- 29:11the opposition may decide to just go the other way and not have a fight
- 29:15with you after all. And of course, thicker fur is also going to
- 29:18mean that it's going to be harder to find the skin, harder to find
- 29:22the throat, and so on. So animals in nature actually spend a great
- 29:27deal of time trying to avoid fights. That may not be what you think
- 29:33you know when you watch nature videos and this kind of thing. But fights
- 29:37can be fatal in the natural world because they can get infected and wounds can
- 29:41be very dangerous. So animals are all better off if they can avoid fights.
- 29:47If various animals can just puff themselves up and make themselves look bigger,
- 29:52and it can therefore walk away from a fight instead of engaging, they're better
- 29:57off that what our erector peely muscles do. They pull our hair up when
- 30:04we are cold and when we are frightened because we used to have fur and
- 30:11now we don't, so it's an evolutionary leftover. It doesn't do us any
- 30:15good now, but it doesn't do us any harm, so it kind of
- 30:18sticks around and well, there it is. If you were the designer,
- 30:22would you make us furry creatures these days? Or would you think you'd just
- 30:25go like, would you know, a waxing, like a divine waxing so
- 30:29we had nothing, or a lasering? Which would you prefer. I don't
- 30:33know. I mean, the fur on my body doesn't really do me any
- 30:36harm, so I'm not concerned about it one way or another, you know,
- 30:40either way is fine with me. Really, the other thing we should
- 30:44do, since we're talking about evolutionary leftover is otherwise known as vestigial organs,
- 30:48let's talk about the one that kills us, sometimes called the appendix. The
- 30:52appendix is a little teeny sort of worm like hollow, dead end tube that
- 31:02hangs off of our large intestine. And a dead end tube is the perfect
- 31:10place for a bacterial colony. And in animals that digest woody plants, like
- 31:18rabbits and koala bears and all of this kind of thing, they actually have
- 31:22these huge dead end areas to their large intestine, the areas that are now
- 31:30our secum and our appendix. They have these huge, long, fancy versions
- 31:37of these things, and the bacteria there are capable of digesting wood, and
- 31:44so what happens is that the bacteria digest the plant material, and then essentially
- 31:51the vertebrate you know, the koala bear or whomever, they then essentially eat
- 31:56the bacteria. So it's a very benefitial system for those animals that digest cellulose.
- 32:05We don't digest cellulose, we can't digest wood, so we have these
- 32:13little leftover organs that used to do us some favors but don't anymore. But
- 32:20the problem is that these dead ends are still the perfect place for a bacterial
- 32:24colony. They have attenuated and attenuated as the millennia have gone by, but
- 32:31they have not gone away, which is why you occasionally get a really nasty
- 32:37colony of bacteria started in the appendix and it winds up becoming infected, and
- 32:44if it bursts, you're dead. This is the lethal infection known as appendicitis.
- 32:51It used to routinely kill people in the days before decent surgical techniques.
- 32:57Since we've developed decent, clean surgical techniques, if somebody has appendicitis, there
- 33:02are rushed to the hospital, the appendix is snipped out, they are sewn
- 33:07up, all is well and good, and they go about their lives for
- 33:09the rest of their lives and they are fine. Now, I should explain
- 33:13that there is a small amount of immune tissue in the appendix, but there
- 33:19are immune tissues throughout the rest of the digestive system, so we don't actually
- 33:23need the appendix in any way at all, and we'd really be better off
- 33:28without it, because as it is, we are carrying around this ticking time
- 33:31bomb in our abdomens that can blow up and kill us at any time with
- 33:37no warning and no particular reason for it. So, I mean, if
- 33:40you were a designer, you would not give a human an appendix. You
- 33:45just wouldn't, Doctor Hafer. I actually had to go look up seekum because
- 33:50I have no idea what that. Oh. Okay, sekum a powder or
- 33:52a large tube like structure in the lower abdominal cavity that receives undigested food material
- 34:00from the small intestine. My learning is that correct? You are learning that
- 34:06is correct. The secum is the first portion of your large intestine, which
- 34:10is the bit of your digestive system after the small intestine. But the thing
- 34:15is that hanging off the bottom of the scum is the appendix. This blind
- 34:22tube, you know, this tube with only one opening. See, this
- 34:27is why humans are born with big brains, because we need room to learn
- 34:31about the secum and correct. Okay, I'm just glad to know that my
- 34:38conversation with doctor Abbey paper will continue in justice seconds. Hang on continuing my
- 34:58conversation with evolutionary biologist doctor A. Behavior. She is author of the book
- 35:04The Not So Intelligent Designer we've been talking vestigial organs anything else. Well,
- 35:13as I said, I would definitely eliminate the appendix. Just get rid of
- 35:17it. It does us no good whatsoever. Get rid of wisdom teeth while
- 35:22we're at it. For that matter, our teeth in general. You want
- 35:25to talk about not getting something fair. We get two sets of teeth for
- 35:29our entire lives. We are long lived creatures. We get baby teeth,
- 35:34then they get replaced with our adult teeth, and the adult teeth are expected
- 35:37to last us for the rest of our lives, and they generally don't.
- 35:42It's why we had to use our large brains to invent dentists meet and while
- 35:47sharks shed their teeth and grow new teeth on a routine basis all the time.
- 35:53It's why you find fossil sharks teeth on beaches in a lot of places.
- 35:59Does God like sharks better than humans? Because sharks can just keep making
- 36:05new teeth as they need them and shedding the old ones before they have the
- 36:09chance to get cavities and infections, and before sharks need root canals and things
- 36:15like that, all of which is probably good for us because I can't imagine
- 36:20anything more dangerous than a shark with a toothache. But on the other hand,
- 36:25as I said, those sharks got the good stuff when it came to
- 36:29teeth and we didn't. And I would like to call the manager about that
- 36:34one. I don't blame you. Final thoughts, anything else you want to
- 36:37throw out before we call it. There's the ability to produce vitamin C,
- 36:42which we lack but other animals have, which means we can get scurvy but
- 36:47other animals don't. There are some animals that in principle could get scurvy,
- 36:53but we can get scurvy because we cannot produce vitamin C, but other animals
- 37:00can. And if you really want to know something that will make you furious,
- 37:04it is that we possessed the biochemical pathway to make vitamin C, but
- 37:10it's broken, so that gene just switched off. So yeah, basically,
- 37:15the last step in the process got switched off. And the basic evolutionary reason
- 37:23behind this is that since our primate ancestors eight fresh fruits and vegetables anyway,
- 37:31because they were swinging around in trees, when that gene had a mutation,
- 37:37and that last step in the process of making vitamin C got turned off,
- 37:42it didn't do us any harm because we were eating fruits and vegetables anyway.
- 37:47But then, as I said, when we thought we would get smart and
- 37:52live in climates where that we're not necessarily easy accesses to fruits and vegetables,
- 37:57or when we went on long sea voyage, then people started getting scurvy and
- 38:01they didn't really know what caused it. But this is something that for instance,
- 38:07colonists in New England got during the winter time. It's what people got
- 38:13on long sea voyages. This is why British people became known as limes,
- 38:17because they launched these seagoing expeditions all over the world, and then the sailors
- 38:23got scurvy. But it was discovered that citrus juices had a lot of what
- 38:30was needed. They didn't quite call it vitamin C at the time, but
- 38:34so as a result, British sailors were given a small dose of lime juice
- 38:38every day to prevent vitamin C, which is why Brits became known as limes.
- 38:45Native Americans discovered that there was basically an evergreen tree called the annetta that
- 38:51if they boiled that, if they made tea out of that, that also
- 38:55had vitamin C in the tea, and that was how they, for instance,
- 39:00survived long northerly winters when you wouldn't necessarily get fresh produce either. So
- 39:06you know, humans, because we have these large brains, have figured out
- 39:09weighs around the basic problem of our not being able to produce vitamin C.
- 39:15But the fact of the matter is we can't. Other animals can. It's
- 39:20not fair. Sometimes I wonder if I would create myself with an exoskeleton.
- 39:25I can't decide, like what I want exterior protection or would that just be
- 39:30cumbersome? I don't know. Well, exterior protection does have a lot of
- 39:37advantages. It makes it hard to grow, however, this is why lobsters,
- 39:42for instance, when they grow, when they outgrow their shells, they
- 39:45have to basically mold. They get rid of their old shell and then they're
- 39:52kind of soft and vulnerable for a little while, and then they grow a
- 39:54new shell. But if you could get around that vulnerability problem for for a
- 40:00while, I mean, having an exoskeleton would have a lot of advantages.
- 40:04If you wanted to ride a motorcycle, for instance, think of all those
- 40:07soft tissues that would be in a lot less trouble I mean, Or if
- 40:12you get in a bar fight, or right, you just want to look
- 40:14badass, Right, you just want to look badass. Check out my exoskeleton.
- 40:19I look like a Marvel hero. I don't know if it's even practical,
- 40:21but this is how my mind works, doctor, This is how my
- 40:25mind works. Doctor. Heyfer, you are of course proof of the big
- 40:30brain on the human primates. And you're always just so rich with good information.
- 40:36And I enjoy your sense of humor. And I'm going to point everybody
- 40:38to your book because so often we hear about I mean, like, I
- 40:42don't have a dog in this fight. I don't really like. I'm not
- 40:45offended if someone says we are intelligently designed. I'm not insecure about it.
- 40:50I just think it doesn't make any sense if we look around at the monumental
- 40:52waste and what is it? Ninety nine percent of all animals that you know,
- 40:58animal species that were ever two have existed, have apparently died off you're
- 41:04the zoologist. Is that an accurate number? That's probably pretty close? Yes,
- 41:07I mean, if you want to start getting into non human species.
- 41:13Yeah, this whole business of having this grand and wonderful, great designer.
- 41:16If our designs are so great, then why of ninety nine percent of all
- 41:21species gone extinct? And the answer there is because that's the way evolution works.
- 41:27Evolution doesn't really care how we feel like. The universe doesn't care.
- 41:30It just kind of does what it does. Doctor Abbey Hafer, always a
- 41:34joy and the link to your book in the description box. Let's talk again,
- 41:38Sue. Okay, okay, great, thanks for talking to me.
- 41:42Okay, let me finish here by reading a couple of pages, the last
- 41:45two pages of doctor Hafer's book. I just wanted to end on a high
- 41:50note, right, something positive. And again, this is after she has
- 41:52just dismantled these claims about intelligent design chapter thirty five, two page. They
- 42:00say this, They say evolution the greatest indisputably true story ever told. She
- 42:10said, I want to talk about beauty. I want to point out that
- 42:15the human body is actually wonderful. It's just that it's wonderful in the weird,
- 42:21crazy way that evolved systems are wonderful, rather than being wonderful and the
- 42:27careful, mathematical way that designed systems are. There's real beauty and utility here,
- 42:34but not preplanned design. I also think our bodies are beautiful the way
- 42:39they are, regardless of their imperfections. But I also think that there is
- 42:45also real beauty in our ability to think, do research, and really understand
- 42:52the world we live in rather than just making up stories. This capacity allows
- 42:58us to understand atoms and molecules that we can't even see, and principles we
- 43:05can't see that allow airplanes to fly, Electrons we can't see that light up
- 43:12electric light bulbs, and yes, evolution, which often takes eons to occur
- 43:19so no human being can see it working, but we understand it and we
- 43:23can make successful predictions based on it, so we know it's there. ID
- 43:30does not make predictions evolutionary theory does. The evolution of antibiotic resistant bacteria can
- 43:38only be understood by evolutionary theory. Antibiotic resistant bacteria are now killing people we
- 43:46used to be able to cure. I fear having public health officials who don't
- 43:52believe in evolution. Ecology, which is the interplay between different plants and animals
- 44:00and their environments, can only be understood if you understand evolution. I fear
- 44:06having environmental policy made by people who don't believe in evolution. I realize that
- 44:13many people don't like the fact that there are unanswered questions in evolution. However,
- 44:20there are unanswered questions in every scientific field. Modern physicists don't know whether
- 44:25gravity is smooth and continuous or comes in little particles. Yet we use modern
- 44:32physics every day to launch satellites and they stay in orbit. Biblical physics couldn't
- 44:39do that. You don't throw out an entire scientific field because there are a
- 44:45few unanswered questions. In fact, the whole point behind science is to investigate
- 44:52unanswered questions. That's what research is all about. If there are no unanswered
- 44:59questions, then there is no research. If there are no unanswered questions,
- 45:04then there is no hope for improvement. If there are no unanswered questions,
- 45:09then the world is a far duller place. Unanswered questions, or why scientists
- 45:16go to work every morning. Awe and wonder are as much a part of
- 45:22science as they are a part of any religion. I realize that many people
- 45:27dislike what they think are the implications of evolution. If it's all about eating
- 45:32and breeding and dying, they wonder, where do beauty and meaning and justice
- 45:37fit in? Where does purpose fit in? Where? Indeed, one answer
- 45:44is that they fit in where we decide to put them. If we human
- 45:49beings think that beauty and meaning and justice and purpose are important, then it
- 45:53is up to us to put them into our lives and into our world,
- 45:59rather than waiting for God to hand them to us on a silver platter.
- 46:05I realized that other people may be afraid to accept evolution because they want to
- 46:09believe in the uniqueness of human beings. Fortunately, science tells us that we
- 46:15as a species are indeed unique, so is every other species. What's more,
- 46:22it's clear that we are not particularly favored by any god or gods,
- 46:28whatever our egos may tell us to the contrary, does that mean we are
- 46:32worthless? Far from it. We can experience awe and wonder. We have
- 46:39an amazing ability to figure things out. We can make art and appreciate beauty.
- 46:46We can build cities yet appreciate wilderness. We can strive to be the
- 46:52best that we can be and to build the best society that we can build.
- 46:58We can require justice in the firm knowledge that no one has any divine
- 47:04rights, and we can love each other and love this planet. I realize
- 47:10that in writing this book I may be preaching to the choir. However,
- 47:15our public discourse on evolution needs simple, straightforward arguments in order to counter the
- 47:22false claims made by the proponents of ID. In other words, we need
- 47:28talking points, ones that we can bring to our legislators, school boards,
- 47:34and politicians of all stripes. I've tried to provide talking points that anybody can
- 47:39use right here in this book. So there are times when preaching to the
- 47:45choir is exactly the right thing to do. We need clarification, reassurance,
- 47:51and solid political style arguments if we are going to defend evolution against pseudoscientists and
- 47:59political pressure groups. In fact, my main hope for this book is that
- 48:04I've given you the choir some great new songs to sing and in all cases
- 48:10keep in mind that evolution is the greatest, indisputably true story ever told.
- 48:22Thank you so much for listening. I'll see you next time. Follow The
- 48:24Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos,
- 48:30products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist
- 48:36pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log
- 48:40onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.