Latest / The Showing with Katherine and Darin Persinger / This Mortgage Is A Great Way To Start Real Estate Investing
Transcript
- 0:00All right.
- 0:00What is a DSCR? A DSCR loan is a loan that investors use typically to buy a rental property, I think only to buy a rental property.
- 0:17It stands for debt service coverage ratio.
- 0:22Wow, that's a-- I see why it's called a DSCR.
- 0:25Yes.
- 0:26It's a mouthful.
- 0:26Yeah.
- 0:27Um, the reason why they get it is it's a simpler, I would say easier process for, um, qualifying for it.
- 0:40The transaction is simpler.
- 0:42Um, the lender doesn't use W-2s or 1099s.
- 0:50They don't use personal income to qualify the investor for the loan.
- 0:55They just compare what your monthly payment will be to what the potential rent is going to be for the house that you're buying.
- 1:04Okay.
- 1:04So normally when you get a mortgage, owner-occupied or investor, you need to bring, like, at least the last two years of your income, your, your taxes.
- 1:19You have to bring your tax returns, you have to bring your pay stubs.
- 1:23Pay stubs, if you're W-2.
- 1:24You have to bring, um, bank statements.
- 1:28Yeah.
- 1:29You have to bring-- Usually buyers get really overwhelmed with all the paperwork- Yeah that's required.
- 1:34Okay.
- 1:35But on a DSCR- They, the bank just goes Well, there's cash flow.
- 1:45Yes.
- 1:46They say, "Okay, you want that house?" Okay.
- 1:48"Okay.
- 1:49What will it rent for?" And they hire an appraiser for that.
- 1:52Okay, I was gonna ask, how do they-- how does the bank figure out what it would rent for? 'Cause that feels a little tricky.
- 1:59Rents are definitely harder to find.
- 2:02I will say specifically in Idaho, rents are really hard to find, um, because on the Coeur d'Alene MLS, there's no rentals Um, so you have to rely on, um, things like, uh, like Zillow, I guess, realtor.com,
- 2:21homes.com,
- 2:22apartments.com,
- 2:23all the sites you'd go to to find rentals.
- 2:27We have to rely on this, you and me as real estate agents, or who's figuring out what it rents for? Obviously, if we're working with a buyer, a- an investor that wants to use this, we're ballparking it.
- 2:39We're doing our own research.
- 2:40Yeah.
- 2:40Well- But our research doesn't- Right.
- 2:43We're- mean anything, does it? We're, we're clicking around ahead of time to make sure that this isn't gonna be a huge waste of time.
- 2:49Mm-hmm.
- 2:50Because if, um, if an investor likes a house and they wanna buy it, and their payment's going to be $3,000 based on the- Okay market DSCR rate, interest rates, um, and their down payment loan amount- Mm-hmm and such, but we do a little clicking around and we see it's only gonna rent for $2,000 or $2,200.
- 3:14Well, that's a big gap, and they're not gonna get approved for that DSCR loan- Okay based on that payment and that rent.
- 3:23So we kinda want it to make sense going into it, and this is, um, I, I don't know if there's a minimum down payment required for a DSCR loan.
- 3:32I was gonna ask that.
- 3:33Normally, when you're doing an investor, it's minimum 20%, if not 25% usually.
- 3:40Yeah, it used to be 25% was a requirement for an investor loan, and then at some point they moved it to 20%.
- 3:48Mm-hmm.
- 3:49I think with a DSCR loan, it's just however much you have to put down in order for your payment to be low enough that the rent will cover it.
- 3:57So they're only worried about that final number, is are you going to make enough money to pay back the mortgage each month.
- 4:06So that might mean g- maybe it could be 10%.
- 4:10I don't know that.
- 4:11May- maybe- I'm not a lender.
- 4:12They might want some s- skin in the game.
- 4:15They're definitely gonna want some skin in the game.
- 4:16Okay.
- 4:16And I think that's why they're comfortable with it.
- 4:19So 20% still might be the minimum.
- 4:21It might still be.
- 4:22They, they might not do it for a 10%.
- 4:24I guess the thing is it's always been hard- To make the numbers work to put, to make the numbers work with less than 20% down.
- 4:33Yeah.
- 4:33Now, you kinda have to put 30, I would say, generally.
- 4:39Every market is different, but you're probably not gonna break even, meaning your rent probably won't cover your payment unless you put, um, 30-ish percent down.
- 4:50Mm-hmm.
- 4:51Now, is this the all-in, like taxes, insurance? I think so.
- 4:58It, so it has to cover everything.
- 5:00Yes.
- 5:01Okay.
- 5:04All right, so back to the appraisal.
- 5:05Who's...
- 5:06The bank's figuring this out somehow.
- 5:09They're, like, rents are going to be this, and so we will loan.
- 5:12Yeah.
- 5:13So the lender will order an appraisal- Yeah just like on, on any normal transaction- Okay conventional, FHA.
- 5:22Um, the lender will hire an appraiser.
- 5:24Mm-hmm.
- 5:25The buyer pays for that.
- 5:26I think they're a little bit more expensive on a DSCR loan, so that's something to be aware of if you're a b- if you're a gonna be a DSCR borrower.
- 5:35Um, I don't know.
- 5:37I can't talk too much about the nitty-gritty 'cause I'm not a lender, but I have seen this up close once now.
- 5:42We have done one.
- 5:42Yes, and I was so happy to be involved in that because you and I have been curious about DSCR loans for years now.
- 5:50Um, but yeah, back to how the appraisal works.
- 5:54Um, the appraiser goes out to the house.
- 5:56I, I imagine they make sure that it's in decent enough condition.
- 6:01Um, and then, but the main thing they're figuring out is what would this house rent for- Mm-hmm and is it enough to cover this person's payment that they're gonna have? And then, um, yes, as far as finding rents, it's a lot trickier than finding recent sales.
- 6:27If you're looking for recent sales, you just go on the MLS and you can find sales within a radius, and you can look at all of them, and you can decide which ones are the most similar and choose those ones.
- 6:37Um, but for rentals, you kinda have to go to all these different sites like Zillow, and even then, you see what it was, you s- you see what the, um, homeowner, the landlord was asking in rent.
- 6:51You don't know what it ultimately rented for.
- 6:54Mm-hmm.
- 6:54Maybe they w- it was for rent for 2,500 and only rented for 2,400.
- 6:59So I imagine, I hope appraisers are calling, like doing a little bit more legwork to make sure that they're confident with their numbers.
- 7:09So it seems, I wanna say it's, it seems complicated.
- 7:14It's just different.
- 7:15It's not complicated.
- 7:16It's just different.
- 7:17It, it's actually pretty straightforward, and that's why it caught my attention a while ago, and I, we did get to do one of these, and that's why I wanted to talk about this.
- 7:28'Cause what I liked about it from an investor standpoint, self-employed investors, is we have to put together so much paperwork to qualify This is much more straightforward.
- 7:46Does it or does it not And then it takes a lot of the emotion out of it for an investor, which you, which you want as an investor.
- 7:57And you just go to the seller, "Hey, look, the offer is this.
- 8:02It either works or it doesn't.
- 8:04And if it doesn't, then I'm moving on to the next one."
- 8:09So that's makes a seller who is motivated a lit- maybe more likely or th- they're certainly motivated, like if they wanna make it work, they'll come down in price to make it work.
- 8:21That it's, it's a good negotiation tool that, "Hey, hey seller, I don't just want it for this price because I'm greedy.
- 8:28I sort of need it for this price if I'm gonna make this loan work."
- 8:32It's such a mark-- It, it's so based upon market that I like it on both ends.
- 8:39That a seller goes, "Well, I'm, you know, I raised my kids here.
- 8:44I've lived here for 20 years.
- 8:46I think I should get this much money for it."
- 8:49And if you can, that's great, and you should be able to get as much as you can for it.
- 8:55But if it's been sitting on the market for three years, and I think when we're out talking to sellers, we're trying to identify who's buying this.
- 9:02Is it a move up? Is it a lateral move? Is it a downsizer? Is it a relocator? First time home buyer? Whatever.
- 9:08We're trying to identify that audience.
- 9:10If you're a seller and your home might be for an investor, I think you wanna know about this type of mortgage, and then know how much money do they have to put down in order for it to cash flow.
- 9:26Like, if they need to put 50% down in order to get, to make it cash flow, that's a good signal you might be overpriced.
- 9:35Or just that you cannot rely on investors.
- 9:38Investors will not be interested in your house, and therefore, you're relying on someone to come through your house and fall in love with it and wanna raise their kids in it and wanna live a life there.
- 9:48And so it's just good to know that your, your house, you're relying on emotions.
- 9:54But if you, if you're a first time home buyer and affordability's already an issue And let's say you want to overpay for a house.
- 10:06How do you in this market? Yeah.
- 10:08Well, it still has to appraise.
- 10:09It's, like, that- that's why I like this mortgage.
- 10:12It's su- such an equalizer, and it tells everyone what's going on in the market.
- 10:18'Cause I think we try to separate markets of, well, there's buyers and then there's renters, and the rental market's doing this and owner-occupied is doing this.
- 10:31But so many renters are in single-family homes now.
- 10:37You know, this is a long time ago, and I'm totally dating myself, but a lot of times renters just lived in apartment buildings Or maybe duplexes.
- 10:48Like, it, it was usually multiplex homes that they were living in as renters.
- 10:53It's only over the last 20 or 30 years where we've decided, "Hey, we're, we're gonna rent forever because I can rent a single family home.
- 11:03I can rent a four-bed, two and a half bath house with a three-car garage, so we're just gonna keep renting."
- 11:08So there's n- you're s- saying you're noticing less of an aspiration to own, 'cause if you can have your yard, you can have your house, you can be in your school district, what's the point? Yeah, the- That's how a lot of people feel? Well, I, I don't know if it's necessarily how they feel, it's just they can.
- 11:25But I think those markets have blended so much.
- 11:28Like for example, a data trend, when they go, "Well, the average rent is this," that's based upon a two-bedroom apartment or whatever.
- 11:41Like, what are we basing that on? It's usually a two-bedroom, which one, why do we base it on a two-bedroom always? 'Cause you could be renting a one-bedroom or a three-bedroom or a house.
- 11:54And so I just think knowing what the rental price of what your home could be on the market helps with understanding the price.
- 12:04If you're like, "Well, I think my home's worth $700,000," but then you have people going, "Well, I'm never going to buy a home because I need to come up with 10, 20% down payment, and then my mortgage is gonna be like $5,000, but I can rent this home for 3,000."
- 12:21Well, yeah, at the end of the day it's housing.
- 12:24I think, uh, as a home seller it's- Housing.
- 12:27That's a great way, yeah.
- 12:28Yeah.
- 12:28It's housing.
- 12:29It's, um, I think it's wise as a seller to think about, "Okay, who's going to buy my house?" It's either going to be a buyer who feels the numbers make enough sense for them, it's affordable enough, and maybe there's some emotion involved, or if it's, if it is an investor who wants to get a house in this area that meets this criteria, the numbers do have to make sense.
- 12:54So if I see an offer from them that's, um, 10% below my asking price, maybe instead of getting offended and worked up about it, I can, um, you know, uh, the, the offer should be presented in a way that it's like, "Hey, seller, I love this house.
- 13:09I really wanna make it work, but I can't at your price.
- 13:12So, um, take it or leave it," kind of thing.
- 13:15Like, "If this works for you, I would be so happy to buy it, but, um, it doesn't work at your price.
- 13:22So sorry."
- 13:23You know, no, no emotions involved.
- 13:25And then kind of another way to think about that is it-- "My numbers don't work because I wouldn't get enough rent because your house wouldn't rent for-" this much for what, what, um, for what I need it to.
- 13:40Mm-hmm.
- 13:41So, a, a seller could figure that out be- because are we, when we fill out the offer to purchase, do we, are we putting that type of mortgage that they're looking for? Like, is it going to say DSCR or what's it saying? Yes.
- 14:02All right, so talk to me about that.
- 14:03What does that look like? You have to specify the loan type on an offer, and yes, if you're right- Just go through loan types real quick.
- 14:11What does that mean? 'Cause what, like, a, it's just a mortgage.
- 14:15Yeah.
- 14:15FHA, conventional, VA, DSCR.
- 14:21Those are the main ones, and then if you're gonna be cash.
- 14:24Cash.
- 14:25Cash.
- 14:26So someone will know, a seller will see that, hopefully the agent's explaining it to them, or they ask if they've watched this, and they're like, "What's a DSCR?" And now they can start to be prepared.
- 14:40Well, and when I wrote the offer- Yes you know, it's, it's- And I do wanna get into that.
- 14:44I wanna get into, like, the personal experience that you had with this.
- 14:48Yeah.
- 14:48S- so when I wrote the offer, of course, I specified DSCR on it, and the listing agent, the seller's agent, was really good.
- 14:57She was really experienced, and she sort of pushed back, and she had questions about that, and she called our lender, and she wanted to know, "Okay, what happens if the rent isn't going to cover what his payment will be?" And the lender, um, reassured her that there was c- there was a bit of a plan B, and, you know, he said he was confident the rent would.
- 15:18Mm-hmm.
- 15:19The listing agent was like, "Well, I'm not, 'cause I, I've done a little research- Mm-hmm and I, I think it'll run for X amount, and I don't think his payment will-- or I don't think the rent will cover his payment."
- 15:30So, um, and she was right.
- 15:33And that's fair.
- 15:34That's good work on the listing agent's side.
- 15:36That's really good work, and I told her that.
- 15:37Told her that several times throughout the transaction, and, um, uh, yeah, what happened was the, the rent that the appraiser specified, um, was not going to cover his payment.
- 15:52So- So the appraisal, like you talked about in the beginning, they send an appraisal out or they look online or whatever they're doing to figure out rents.
- 16:00Yeah, there was an appraiser.
- 16:01They go, they come back, and they go, "This will rent for 2,500."
- 16:06Yeah.
- 16:08The buyer needed, like, 2,800, let's say.
- 16:10Yeah.
- 16:11So there's a $300 deficit there that we need to make up somehow.
- 16:14Yeah.
- 16:14There's a gap.
- 16:17When we're representing owner-occupied buyers and the appraisal comes back low, and we're confident that it shouldn't be that low, we can appeal that.
- 16:27Yeah, and that's never worked, not in my 17 years.
- 16:29I've, I've appealed it anytime an appraiser, uh, appraisal has come back low.
- 16:34I've, um, done varying amounts of appealing.
- 16:39Sometimes it's like, well, yeah, obvi- I mean, the appraiser's right, so there's not much we can do.
- 16:45Um, but usually we'll do, I mean, we'll always do what we can, but we'll, we'll provide additional comps, and we'll, um, give our opinion about why the comp the appraiser used shouldn't have been used.
- 16:59And I've never seen an appraiser budge- Mm-hmm on a sale, but this appraiser did, 'cause the a- he set a lower amount- On the rent on the rent.
- 17:11Not on the home value, on the rent.
- 17:13Yeah, on the rent.
- 17:14Came in lower than what we needed it to be.
- 17:16Mm-hmm.
- 17:17So we came up with some additional comps, which was a challenge, but that's fine.
- 17:22Um, so we did a lot of clicking around and calling around and, um, I was calling property management companies too.
- 17:29Mm-hmm.
- 17:30They were not that eager to help me, but, um, one of them, the one that we use, helped me a little bit.
- 17:36And, uh, yeah, well, u- ultimately the appraiser came up in his rental, um, value- Mm-hmm a little bit.
- 17:47Not enough to bridge the gap.
- 17:48Not enough to bridge the gap, but then- But we got closer.
- 17:52We are close enough, and we made it work.
- 17:54And so now it was close enough that the buyer has a choice to make on, "Do I bring more down payment? Is there something else that I can do on my side to bridge the ga- gap?" 'Cause all that matters is does the payment equal the rent.
- 18:11Right.
- 18:12So we didn't-- I really didn't wanna go this route, but we also could have asked the seller if they'd be willing to come down- To come down in price so that the payment would be low enough that the new rental value would cover that payment.
- 18:26Mm-hmm.
- 18:26So we didn't even, we didn't have to do that, thankfully.
- 18:28That just would've felt greedy and kinda shady, um, especially 'cause the listing agent was doing a good job of, from day one, "Hey, I'm, I'm a little skeptical that this is gonna work with this loan type because of the payment amount and the rental amount, so reassure me."
- 18:45And then we did reassure her, so it would've felt kind of crappy of us to, at that point, say, "Hey, we need you to come down in price."
- 18:53All right.
- 18:53So, uh, any- anything else to add on the DSCRs? I, I don't know how long they've been a- around.
- 18:59They've caught my attention over the last five years, I would say.
- 19:05So I don't know how long it's been sitting out there.
- 19:08But I love the idea of it from not just an investor standpoint, but self-employed investor makes it even more complicated for us to buy investment properties.
- 19:21So it just really simplifies the process, and it's what an investor's looking for anyways, unless they're, um anticipating increased home values.
- 19:34They're looking for cash flow.
- 19:35They're looking to buy a property where the numbers work themselves.
- 19:38Yeah.
- 19:39I'll just add a couple of quick things about them.
- 19:42Um, yes, I think, I think that there's probably a lot of investors that it doesn't make sense for because the interest rate is a little bit higher- Okay than a typical conventional or I think even a conventional investor rate.
- 19:56Um, so the rate is not low.
- 19:58It's not the type of loan you get if you're just looking for a low rate.
- 20:02It's just, uh, good for self-employed.
- 20:04It's just simpler.
- 20:05It's also quicker, typically.
- 20:08The transaction is more like, you know, three weeks instead of four.
- 20:14But on the flip side of that, I would say one of the-- Once you have the mortgage as an investor, you can-- it's much easier to, um, to refinance because now they have numbers on that specific- Yeah, that's true property.
- 20:33So if you need to do it to get into it, and then a couple years later go, "I'm gonna refinance," and maybe the home value's up 3%, 4%, 5%, rents have maybe changed a little bit, and now it's just easier to qualify 'cause they're probably basing it, they can base it based on that property- Well, yeah instead of all of your finances.
- 20:54You can say, as the owner, you can say, "Yeah, here's my leases for the past- Mm-hmm two, three years.
- 20:58So it's obviously renting for this much."
- 21:00So yeah, that, that would make the appraisal process easier.
- 21:04So get into it easier and then maybe do a refinance.
- 21:09W- so this is about investor stuff.
- 21:11Is there anything interesting, like how does a owner-occupied homeowner, which is much more of the market, how do they...
- 21:21Is there anything interesting for them, any mortgage stuff going on for them nowadays? For buyers? For buyers, if they're trying to get into, "We got a cool program for owner, for investors."
- 21:33What about cool programs to make it easier for them, besides the typical where you have to jump through a lot of hoops, like down payment assistance and- Yeah blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 21:42Um, I think, I asked a lender buddy of mine the other day about ARMs.
- 21:48I've always been interested in ARMs.
- 21:50We've never done one.
- 21:51I've never done one.
- 21:52Have you? Yes.
- 21:54Okay.
- 21:54Um, so ARMs got a really bad name in '06, '07, '08.
- 21:59And that's when I was doing them.
- 22:00That's when you did it.
- 22:01Yeah.
- 22:02Because you'd get in at a low rate, and then, I don't know, a couple years later, your rate would go up- Mm-hmm to an amount to, which would make your payment an amount that you couldn't afford the home anymore.
- 22:14Mm-hmm.
- 22:14And then, um, yeah, there were a lot of foreclosures because of that.
- 22:17So yes, they have a bad name for, for a good reason, but- Have I ever told you this, I think I've told you this story, and it's probably not the best time to go deep into it, but I, you know, a lot of times when you get that, you think you're getting a mortgage with a bank or a lender, and then almost immediately the first thing they do is they sell it.
- 22:39My ARM got sold, and it was a two-year, and there was a, a max.
- 22:49Um, there's usually a max on, on time and rate, and so mine was a half a percent every six months it could go up.
- 22:58That's quick.
- 23:01Two years was a very short ARM, though.
- 23:03Yeah.
- 23:03Two.
- 23:05The bank who bought it, the lender who bought it Um, there, there's also a max of like the rate will not go beyond this.
- 23:14So it's not like an indefinite thing where all of a sudden you're paying 50% interest rate 'cause you've held, held it for, um, 30 years or whatever.
- 23:25The bank maxed it out immediately the very first term that they could.
- 23:31So all of a sudden my rate went from like, I think it was like, uh, 5.86
- 23:37or something like that to a nine and a half.
- 23:42That sounds like Predatory lending It, well, so what gave me a lot of empathy for people during that time was I was able to, one, continue to make the payments while I fought with the bank, and I knew what they had done wrong.
- 24:01I just wonder how many people during that time- That happened to? that happened to and they didn't know what to do, and then so they just walked away, like, "I can't afford this payment now."
- 24:08Well, I don't know, m- maybe that was a, that was, that was definitely a different time.
- 24:13But now it's very, very, um, basic.
- 24:18It's very standard.
- 24:21I would almost say 100% of the time when you get a mortgage and then another, it's sold to another- Mm-hmm lien holder, the terms have to stay the same.
- 24:29And- Term, they, y- they always have to stay the same, even back then.
- 24:32Okay, it just, you're saying it just didn't.
- 24:33Yes.
- 24:34Just something went south.
- 24:35Yep.
- 24:35Okay, so yeah.
- 24:36I don't think people need to be overly afraid of that happening, but, um- I'm just saying, like, that was part of the problem with ARMs.
- 24:42You can't get a two-year ARM- Yeah.
- 24:44No, our- right now.
- 24:45I don't even think you can get a five-year ARM.
- 24:46Our buyers earlier this year got a seven-year ARM.
- 24:49Yeah.
- 24:50And they got in at, like, 3%.
- 24:51Yes.
- 24:52Like, like these are, like, 2020 rates.
- 24:54A three, maybe it was higher, maybe it was closer to 4%.
- 24:58Three and change.
- 24:58Yeah.
- 24:58Three-point-something, which is incredible, and it's a seven-year ARM, meaning it will stay that low for seven years.
- 25:06Mm-hmm.
- 25:06And it was a easy choice for them 'cause they're like, "We're not gonna stay in this house for more than seven years.
- 25:11Like w- 99% chance we sell it in five to seven years and move on to the next house."
- 25:18But- All right.
- 25:19So l- let's save, um, let, I think we could do a whole other episode on that.
- 25:25We could.
- 25:25So let's, I would just say I think new construction builders are offering some- Builders are offering- interesting programs lower than market rates.
- 25:35And then there's some ARM stuff- Not all, but some out there.
- 25:37So hopefully- Yeah that holds you over until our next episode.
- 25:40Closing thoughts on DSCRs.
- 25:43Um, I think it's worth exploring for the simplicity of it and the quickness of it, and just if you are a buyer with kind of a, a less than ideal, um, less than, like, perfect, like exactly how lenders typically want your taxes and income to look, it might be worth considering.
- 26:11You do have to have a chunk of cash laying around.
- 26:14Make sure you have the down payment, but I think it's a great way to dip your toe into investing.
- 26:23Almost, 'cause i- i- investing should be n- non-emotional And maybe you have a different take on this, but I feel like investors are some of the most emotional.
- 26:36Yeah, for sure.
- 26:37They have their reasons to invest, and they wanna- Yeah hit their numbers for reasons.
- 26:40Yes.
- 26:41It usually involves their family and their personal life.
- 26:44Yes.
- 26:44So at the end of the day, of course it's emotional, but, um, yeah, I would say, uh, it's also a potentially good negotiation tool and just a good kind of interesting experience to try out.
- 26:56And after doing one now, um, I am maybe more excited about doing one potentially in the future.
- 27:05Yeah, I think it's a great way to keep your guardrails on without you driving too, too off the road, because you can get emotional about like, "Oh, if I could get this property, and then we'll be able to s- sell it or transfer it one day to this, and it does this for us, and I'll be able to retire my parents or my spouse."
- 27:26And like they just get, they get this dream in their head, and then they need to make it work.
- 27:30Yeah.
- 27:31So with this one, it's the numbers work or they don't.
- 27:34Very binary.
- 27:35Yeah.