Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Votes for Women[SAMPLE]
Transcript
- 0:03That report with Ben and Steve. This game is bullshit already bullshit. I
- 0:13support you're popping on the microphone story. Can you pull back a bit?
- 0:17I support votes for women? Yeah, I support that. I mean,
- 0:22you know it'd be I mean, I mean, we've seen some regression over
- 0:27the past couple of years, but that would be incredibly regressive. Now,
- 0:29Yeah, but the thing is, we randomly determined that you are going to
- 0:33play as the suffragists, and I'm the opposition. It's because the dice,
- 0:38because the dice recognize that I'm the moral good in this. Yeah, are
- 0:42you or are you not in favor of votes for women? I am in
- 0:45favor of votes, and so with this game configuration, are the women likely
- 0:50to win the vote? That is unfortunate. You're not good at games,
- 0:55but unfortunate. But but what am I going to have to throw this?
- 0:58But the thing is, though, Steve, right, this is a gang.
- 1:00I am the opposition. You're this like, So let's go By the
- 1:04time this game is over, nobody's gonna have votes. So let's go back
- 1:07right, we're looking at the suffrage struggle. I'm going to use the British
- 1:11example because I don't know anything about the American example. I will after this
- 1:14go though. Yeah, I mean I think we invented votes for women,
- 1:17didn't we? Oh, definitely, it's an American thing. Yeah, fun
- 1:19fact, I believe New Zealand was the first country to give women the vote.
- 1:23Do you know do you have any listeners in New Zealand? I'm sure
- 1:26we have a couple. If you're from New Zealand, say hello, can
- 1:29you can you differentiate between a New Zealand and an Australian accent? Yes,
- 1:33I want to hear. Can you do it? No? Can you try?
- 1:37Yeah? Go ahead, give me a sentence. Um, I think
- 1:42women should get the vote in mate, flyman hell, I mean should get
- 1:47the vote mate. So that's Australian right, Yeah, okay. Now in
- 1:49New Zealand, flyming heal or, I think women should get the vote mite.
- 1:56And now South African flym in hell, I think women should get the
- 2:00voute mate. It's amazing. I don't know why you don't get more voice
- 2:04over work, you know, do you know did you think Man of a
- 2:07Thousand Voices? Ben Madick is quite shouting You're gonna pop on my god?
- 2:10You know you really make you really make this such unenjoyable experience for me.
- 2:15I've listened to the recordings. It doesn't fucking matter. So you don't hear
- 2:17anything. So do you think, right, if you'd have closed your eyes
- 2:21while I did that, yeah, you'd have been thinking, how fucking Sam
- 2:25Neil's in the room with me right now? Then get an Australian and New
- 2:30Zealand or in a South Africa just to pop in, just to do those
- 2:32one line. Yeah, yeah, because I think the listeners. Sure you
- 2:36don't have that many friends. Do you think the listeners were suddenly like bloody
- 2:38hell mate? Yeah, Like the Australians are going bloody hell mate, yeah,
- 2:42and the New Zealanders are bloody hill mate. Yeah, we've got we've
- 2:46got. We've got Paul Hogan, Sam Neil and someone from South Africa.
- 2:50Russell Crowe is interestingly New Zealand. Yes he thinks he's Australian. Yes,
- 2:54from New Zealand. He is. Should think Peter Jackson is listening to this,
- 2:58going bloody hell mate. It's a right accent man saying exactly right.
- 3:01You know what? That sounds a bit more Australian than New Zealand. I
- 3:05can hear the difference, like I don't do the difference. I think maybe
- 3:07in New Zealanders sound like Australians with a bit of a cold. I knew
- 3:09someone from South Africa. And there's one thing people always get wrong with the
- 3:14accent. Yeah you don't say sith certhifica. No, it's wrong. What
- 3:19do you say? South Africa? South Africa? South Africa? From South
- 3:23Africa and New Zealand, you'd be been. I'd been been been anyway.
- 3:28So yeah, as I was saying, right, like Emeline Pankhurst, right,
- 3:31she's looking for someone to sort of marshal Emmeline Pankhurst. She was the
- 3:37woman who led women's suffrage in Britain. Okay, yeah, wait a minute,
- 3:40you have the vote in Britain. I thought, like the king just
- 3:44decides what to do. Well, the thing is in Britain, you see,
- 3:46Yeah, you have like dukes and everyone. But do you or do
- 3:49you not have like an entire chamber of the government full of like lords and
- 3:53whatever, the lord's spiritual and the lord's temporal. Yeah yeah, so it's
- 3:57like the Middle Ages. So I mean very much so, but you know,
- 4:00so say, um, I'll watch your flagate What am I talking about?
- 4:03It? Can the Lord's temporal control time. Yeah, that's right.
- 4:06Fuck me. So I'm trying to fucking do a point here, or are
- 4:11you so thin? Are you? Is it hard for you to make your
- 4:13point because I never have this experience on this You and your fucking collaborative overlap.
- 4:19You got it right this time, it's collaborative overlap. Yeah. Anyway,
- 4:23So the thing is in Britain we have ostensibly a democracy, but actually
- 4:28what it is we vote for people and then they just fucking reduced labor rights
- 4:32and make people even poorer. So why is your country called a United Kingdom?
- 4:39Yeah, well, it's a constitutional monarch. It's a it's not an
- 4:41absolute monarch, constitutional monarchy. But you don't have a constitution, unwritten constitution.
- 4:46We do have a constitution, it's just unwritten. That doesn't make any
- 4:48sense. Well, you know, it's a paradox. What is an unwritten
- 4:51constitution? Well, Britain has I think that you have some kind of weird
- 4:55political arrangement that's entirely designed to operate according to convention, and that convention simply
- 5:00keeps people in power who have always been in power. That convention is to
- 5:02keep the tours in power breaking in the money. Yeah, yeah, exactly,
- 5:06And I gotta I gotta say this is a sharp political podcast, now,
- 5:12isn't it. Yeah. I think it'll be the acumen, the acumen.
- 5:15I think it will be challenging Alista Campbell and Rory Stewart. Absolutely not.
- 5:18I mean maybe for the number two spot, right, number one is
- 5:20like well in the lead though. So anyway, so Emmiline Pankhurst right back
- 5:25in the day, Yeah, she's looking for someone to sort of lead the
- 5:29sort of strategy behind the women suffrage movement. Yeah, and she's got like
- 5:34year like nineteen just after the First World War thing, so well later than
- 5:40the era in which nineteen twenty goes up to nineteen twenty. Yeah, but
- 5:45the suffrage movement in America begins in eighteen forty years. Yeah, I'm sure
- 5:47the British suffrage movement started as a civil an important year in European history,
- 5:51that's right, great shop. When we play in eighteen forty eight Paris Commune,
- 5:57I guess yeah, the Italian on you know, Risorgimento. Yeah,
- 6:01that's like eighteen seventy, isn't it. Something happened. I've read a book
- 6:04Germany. Bismarck people just like people people prepare for this, don't thing.
- 6:10People just like evaporate from you in the pub, well, from me for
- 6:14that reason, from you for different reasons. Just two don't musky, Yeah,
- 6:18that must be it. And and yet look we ended up together exactause
- 6:21nobody can stand to be around either of us exactly. So so you know,
- 6:25Emlyne Pancas, He's like, I need a strategist. Unlike if we're
- 6:29back in the day and I rock up and go, oh oh yeah,
- 6:30Malene, are you right and we should go? Im not and maybe I
- 6:34have a couple of points and that, um, it would be great.
- 6:39Women aren't getting suffrage, right, Women aren't getting suffrage. The guy with
- 6:43that voice gets to vote, but you don't even get to vote in the
- 6:47UK. I don't. I don't have suffrage. Yeah, this is this
- 6:49is like I have no suffrage anyway. I was horrified when I learned this.
- 6:55If you if you leave the United Kings, I think it is likely
- 7:00you would go and like, um, you like stick your thumb in the
- 7:02ink and then make your mark under the observation of the local duke, so
- 7:06he makes sure that you vote correctly. Yea, yeah, But if you
- 7:10leave the Kingdom for like, how many years you lose the right to vote?
- 7:15To make your little your little X? Yeah, I do an X
- 7:17because I can't. All all the Americans listening to this right now should be
- 7:20horrified by should be horrified. I have no suffrage. I am. I
- 7:24am stateless. I still get to vote in the US forever. It's sac
- 7:29Trump sent you a grand sort of the post. Yeah, Biden sent me
- 7:31another grand did he? Yeah? We got two checks, two checks nailed
- 7:36to Germany. It's unbelievable. Yeah, what did you get in the pandemic?
- 7:40Sweet Fanny Adams? Love Sweet Fanny Adams. I assume that means not
- 7:46much. But what I was trying to get to is, back in the
- 7:47day, Emmiline Pankhurst wouldn't have hired me as a strategist. Yeah, which
- 7:53so so that if I was strategist for the women's suffrage movement back in the
- 7:58day, that would have imputed. The fact that I'm running the women's suffrage
- 8:01movement in this bold game is of less important, I would say, to
- 8:07be sure. But you know, since they're on the topic, I have
- 8:09to say that I have I have mixed feelings about the theme for an entirely
- 8:13different reason on and you should understand coming from the UK right, I mean,
- 8:18I'm not sure anybody should have the vote. I mean, look where
- 8:20democracy has gotten us lately, Brexit, Donald Trump, probably Donald Trump again.
- 8:26Are you doing this to be down with the kids, because all the
- 8:28kids really want an authoritarian strong man both are left and the right authority?
- 8:33You know, you know what I think I'm warming to the idea we just
- 8:37can't be trusted with democracy. Look at the choices we're making. Look what's
- 8:41happening. All of the retrograde motion in society is entirely due to giving people
- 8:45like this weird fucking power of the plebiscite. But the plebiscite is cool,
- 8:48isn't it. It's cooled. The plebiscite for stars, I mean, is
- 8:52working really well for the people who are able to like manipulate the people into
- 8:56supporting their continued dominance over the structures of power. Is that what you're about,
- 9:01Ben? There's something's some fucking crazy statistic that like, the Labor Party
- 9:05held power in the twentieth century in Britain for something like twenty two years.
- 9:09Yeah, and then the subsequent seventy eight years with the fucking toris. I
- 9:13mean, I'm not surprised. Look look at this country. Berlin, the
- 9:16most left city that you can imagine. Just vote to the conservative government and
- 9:20it is his fucking unpressed. They're gonna have a conservative mayor in Berlin.
- 9:26Unbelievable. So I don't suppose we're going to be revisiting our relationship with the
- 9:30automobile anytime soon. No, or corporate power, No or or the dominance
- 9:37of finance capitalism. No, we're not gonna be talking about it, aren't
- 9:39we all ch interesting video? But at least we can vote vote for who
- 9:43Who do we get to vote for? Who are the alternative? Same party?
- 9:46They're all the same financial backers, same games, same everything, Steve,
- 9:50who was I quoting there? I don't know who I was quoting?
- 9:54Jello Biafra from a Dead Kennedy's concert. That's very good. How do you
- 9:56come up with these references? Well? What's going on in there? You
- 10:01notice my references? If I watched something when I was like fourteen or fifteen?
- 10:05Yeah, still in there? Baby? What happened between the Oh?
- 10:09Okay? If yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I gotta I guess
- 10:11if it's from if it's from the last two days. Not a bloody chance.
- 10:16Yeah, not a chance. Yeah. So between between your middle teenage
- 10:20years and now, there were certain like habits that you developed that forestalled the
- 10:26creation of new memory exactly. Yeah, I got it, I got I've
- 10:30got an interesting questions, right, Yeah, do you think so? So?
- 10:33I think? Do? I do? I think voting matters? I
- 10:35think it's an interesting question. Wasn't the question I was gonna lost? I
- 10:37mean, I think it's important that we have the right to vote and that
- 10:41everybody has it. Does it really does? Does it really cause change in
- 10:46our society? I'm not so sure about that. I mean, some people
- 10:48would say that it's simply like a symbolic and it doesn't really evince true political
- 10:54power influence simply to vote. I mean many people they vote and they don't
- 10:56do anything else. They don't participate in society, engage civically. And that's
- 11:01what we need people to do. We need people to like, stand for
- 11:03office, not simply show up to the ballot box once every four years,
- 11:07once every four years. Been. They don't even go to off your elections
- 11:09because these elections don't matter. They only vote for the president the election over
- 11:13which they have the least suasion whatsoever. And they think that they've done their
- 11:18bit, they've participated, they stood in line, they got their little sticker
- 11:20and they made a difference, But really they didn't make a difference. And
- 11:24you know what the incumbency rate, it's like over ninety percent. So what
- 11:28are we really changing simply by voting Ben? Anyway, So my question walls.
- 11:33So I think we both agree, So don't be ironic just for a
- 11:39second. Must must say the opposite of what I actually think. So I
- 11:50think we both agree that, you know, votes, women's suffrage was a
- 11:56necessary change, and it was massively unjust. The women's didn't have to fridge
- 12:00for as long as they did, So I think we can both agree on
- 12:01that. But so do you think now? I don't know. We haven't
- 12:05played this game, so I can't say. But when you've got something that
- 12:09is so obviously a social right like women suffrage, right, there's no debate
- 12:15on it, both the left of the right. I think I think a
- 12:18pretty pretty unanimous on it. Do you think a game like this should spin
- 12:26a narrative of the modern prevailing idea that obviously women should have suffrage or do
- 12:35you think a game like this to transport us back to the time where there
- 12:39were intelligent people who genuinely had arguments, whether whether they were valid or not,
- 12:48against women suffrage. Do you think it should present both sides? I'm
- 12:52not saying it doesn't, because I don't know. We haven't played it,
- 12:54or should it or should it or should the perspective be from the obvious received
- 13:00wisdom of them on night. I think it's a difficult question to answer.
- 13:03I think an analogous question would be, um, if you were in a
- 13:07debating society today, would this be a legitimate topic for like forensics? You
- 13:13know, should women have the right to vote? I would say no,
- 13:16no, definitely not. Uh, It's it's settled, And I don't think
- 13:20there's anything really interesting to debate about. I don't even think there are any
- 13:24first principles that you could return to to make any kind of case whatsoever.
- 13:28I mean, it's not it's not a contemporary debate right in a debating like
- 13:31abortion settled, law settled, so so yeah, so I mean, I
- 13:39don't know. But but to me, this game, I have no idea
- 13:41about the game. First of all I want to say is beautiful. This
- 13:45is a beautifully designed game, and that has very little to do with the
- 13:48game, but it's very inviting. It has already to me some of the
- 13:54flavor just sort of like looking at the materials and the cards has some of
- 13:56the flavor of Twilight Struggle. And you could ask similar question. I mean,
- 14:01am I going to consider the Soviet point of view and Twilight Struggle.
- 14:05Twilight Struggle is very neutrals. It's very neutral in its viewpoint, right,
- 14:11Yeah, I suppose, like the history of twil self isn't terribly neuture,
- 14:16but Twilight Struggle. And I'm sure there were people listening to this who played
- 14:18Twilight Struggle a lot more than me. Would say, don't be silly,
- 14:20it's clearly not but and they will have no problem going on Twitter at five
- 14:26the number five games for Doom's Day, telling you what they think. I
- 14:28haven't spoken to Jason Matthews. He admitted that some of his biases crept into
- 14:33it, but he attempted to paint it as an historical, historical event from
- 14:39a neutral view film as much as possible. But Twilight Struggle was made twenty
- 14:43years ago. This is a contemporary game where people are expected to invent their
- 14:54political views on everything. All the time. I don't know, so so
- 14:58I want to caveat this saying we haven't played the game, so I have
- 15:01no idea. But and so my question is, do you think that this
- 15:07should be a game that should invent a political viewpoint or do you think it's
- 15:11a game that should go for a neutral representation of what happened at the time.
- 15:18Um, I mean, I think that as as an artifact, that
- 15:24is, I assume purporting to teach more about a particular important era of history,
- 15:28it probably can't, shouldn't, and won't evince this neutral point of view,
- 15:33but we'll sort of teach us how we got to where we are now,
- 15:37like a better place than where we were before. I think it's very
- 15:41interesting to create a game like this that can serve as such a teaching tool.
- 15:45Like I don't think the topic is necessarily like woke or anything like that.
- 15:48I don't think it is not even not of the moment. I think
- 15:50there are I mean, I have no idea what these materials are for,
- 15:54but I see that the game comes with some like very interesting looking facsimiles of
- 15:58historical documents, and I think, like when you teach history, you are
- 16:02inevitably teaching it from a certain certain point of view, like the point of
- 16:04view of like historical subjects living at a time that is the consequence of everything
- 16:10that came before, and you're telling a certain narrative. We sometimes call this
- 16:14like the Wig interpretation of history. Right. Not everybody teaches it this way,
- 16:18but I think this is like the most typical naive way of teaching history.
- 16:22The Wig interpretation is naive necessarily. Well, this idea of like relentless
- 16:25progress, I mean, I am saying it's it's naive, well, especially
- 16:30especially especially considering that we live so short a time we can only ever look
- 16:37at the past to denote results because the present we could be a very small
- 16:41at the moment, we could be in a very small dip on a very
- 16:45on an upward trajectory, right, and just not know it because we will
- 16:48never know because we don't live long enough. Yeah, I mean we we
- 16:51as our historical subjects ourselves, we can hardly not be conditioned by the societies
- 16:55in which we live, in which we have certain values that derive from like
- 16:59all the historical thens that occurred before, including women gaining the right to vote.
- 17:02It would be weird for us to think otherwise there are probably some people
- 17:04who do. Many historians don't believe in this idea of progress, and they
- 17:08would attempt to be more objective and focus on like very very like small eras
- 17:12in history, or maybe like longer. It seems to me since we longer
- 17:18term changes. I think, I think, since we unburdened ourselves with the
- 17:22shackles of the Abrahamic faith in the West, we've had sort of unprecedented progress,
- 17:27right. I mean, it depends how you look at progress. I
- 17:32mean, it depends what you want to measure and what's important to you.
- 17:34I mean, I think from like an American or European point of view,
- 17:38lots of things could look like progress, but a many historians would probably not
- 17:42want to tell this kind of story, not want to tell this kind of
- 17:45narrative. If for any other reason, then history, like any other academic
- 17:49discipline, tends to create a lot of hyper hyper specialists who don't tell these
- 17:53kinds of narratives except in like, you know, intro courses at university.
- 17:57So, I mean, the things It's interesting because I think the for want
- 18:03of a better term, woke perspective would be and I don't know if the
- 18:07game has this, I assume it won't have, but the woke perspective would
- 18:11be to assert that, to assert that very little progress has been made since
- 18:18the instantiation of suffrage for women, because a lot of sort of modern left
- 18:23wing ideas are based upon how much you can leverage your own particular brand of
- 18:27suffrage. I'm hoping the game is an interesting investigation into the struggles at the
- 18:34time, And while I don't think the thing is I think if you're trying
- 18:40to leverage sympathy for the opposition view, I think it's an impossible task because
- 18:47it's clearly so absurd that anyone should have opposition to suffrage for women. But
- 18:53I think it would. I'm hoping even that we think that is the product
- 18:57of likes. It's like, there are plenty of countries today where like,
- 19:02who do women have the right to vote? In Saudi Arabia? I don't
- 19:06know how do they I don't think anybody does, because it's a kingdom and
- 19:07it's like an autocracy. I don't think they have like voting there now.
- 19:12I think there are loads of countries where there isn't such a thing as voting
- 19:15or suffrage for anybody. Well, so like we come from Western democracies,
- 19:18Western liberal democracies that have all decided to exchange amongst each other, this idea
- 19:23of ever expanding freedom for all. And even in my country, this began
- 19:29as freedom for a very small stratum of society, like wealthy, yeah,
- 19:33like well, wealthy landowning men. And then gradually we have like expanded the
- 19:37franchise over time, and like the power of this idea has even spread,
- 19:41you know, across the ocean to other countries. We've carried it around with
- 19:44us. It has yet to become universal throughout the world, and and it's
- 19:48had its complications and setbacks. And I'm sure and I don't know if this
- 19:51game will explore it. There are are there were women at the time who
- 19:55are against the idea of votes for women. Sure you could say that they
- 19:59had some kind kind of false false consciousness that they were suffering from or or
- 20:03as you know, like legitimate um you know, historical actors in their own
- 20:08right. They but they believe this this idea that you know, they would
- 20:11just end up voting for like without without economic freedom, most women would just
- 20:15like vote for for whomever their husbands voted for. And like what's the difference
- 20:19who asserts to asserts that people can't be wrong based on unulterable characteristics in and
- 20:25is in and of itself infantilizing. I think I think the real question,
- 20:30Ben, is what is going to be, ultimately in the final telling,
- 20:34more interesting this game or this conversation between you and me. You can listen
- 20:42to the rest of this show and hundreds of hours of bonus content, including
- 20:47convention reports, in game bickering, and loads more at patreon dot com.
- 20:52Forward Slash five g f D Correct Thing Business