Latest / Consumerpedia / 56 - A Crash Course on Auto Insurance
Transcript
- 0:02Let's be honest. No one likes to shop for
- 0:04insurance. It isn't fun or exciting like
- 0:06buying a new sweater or smartphone.
- 0:08It's a chore. So once you make your decision,
- 0:11you're done. You've got your coverage, you
- 0:13pay your premiums and never really think about it again.
- 0:17In the long run, that's a mistake that can cost you
- 0:19thousands of dollars. I'm Her Weissbaum, the consumer
- 0:22man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:25Welcome to Consumerpedia at checkbook.org, where the
- 0:29nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid trouble,
- 0:32and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:35advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:38can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:42objective. Now here's the host of
- 0:44Consumerpedia America's consumer expert, the Consumer Man Herb.
- 0:48Weissbaum In this episode How much can you save by shopping
- 0:52around for a new auto insurance policy?
- 0:54Are there ways to make that comparison shopping easier?
- 0:57And which insurance companies provide the best customer
- 1:00service? Checkbooks executive editor
- 1:02Kevin Wrestler is here to answer all of those questions for us.
- 1:05Hey Harp, So Kevin. I can think of four reasons why
- 1:08most people who have auto insurance look for a new policy.
- 1:11Their current policy gets canceled.
- 1:13They have an accident or get ticketed, so their premiums go
- 1:15up. They get married or divorced or
- 1:18Mr. Bressler. They have kids who've grown up
- 1:20and are ready to start driving. Yeah, I'm in the situation where
- 1:22I have a daughter who's about to reach driving age and I I'm not
- 1:26necessarily worried for her or my safety.
- 1:29I'm much more worried about my premiums going up because she so
- 1:31far is is proven to be a pretty good driver.
- 1:34But yeah, our costs are going to go way up, so it's time to shop
- 1:37around and make sure I'm not overpaying.
- 1:39OK, so before Merrith gets behind the wheel, you're going
- 1:41to go look around so you can give you the best deal.
- 1:43As we discussed in our podcast about homeowners insurance, I
- 1:46need to shop around for that policy also, so this is a good
- 1:48time to do so. The more expensive your policy,
- 1:51the bigger risk insurance companies see you, the more
- 1:54opportunities there are to save. Just because you're paying so
- 1:57much more for coverage, you likely can find a company that
- 2:00can insure you for far less than what you're paying now, so.
- 2:03Auto insurance is expensive. The average cost of car
- 2:05insurance has increased 29% since 2018, with a 25% jump in
- 2:10the last two years, according to a new report from LendingTree.
- 2:13Nationwide, The average premium is expected to go up another 13%
- 2:17this year. Kevin, what is going on?
- 2:19Why such dramatic price increases?
- 2:21Well, there's two things that. One is that everyone is driving
- 2:25more. I mean, we're no longer, you
- 2:26know, hunkered down at home in isolation for the pandemic.
- 2:30So claims are up. And when there are more claims,
- 2:33insurers have to pay more to settle them.
- 2:35Another thing is the cost of auto body repairs are way, way
- 2:39up. I mean, parts prices are through
- 2:40the roof. But probably even more important
- 2:43than that, the prices of used cars have remained high.
- 2:47So before the value of used cars, you know, used to drop
- 2:50pretty quickly, including right after you bought a new car.
- 2:53But now, because the prices of used cars remain high, they're
- 2:57retaining their value for longer.
- 2:59So instead of giving us a break on our auto insurance premiums
- 3:02or flattening out their rates as our cars get older, we're seeing
- 3:05price increases to cover the cost of insuring more expensive
- 3:09vehicles. So that's reason #1.
- 3:11And what is reason #2? Well, another part of this is
- 3:14just corporate greed really. Insurance companies, they know
- 3:18their customers for the most part.
- 3:20They won't shop around before renewing their policies.
- 3:23And so, you know, most of us just year after year stick with
- 3:26the same company and don't know to shop around or don't think to
- 3:30shop around or don't know that. You know, we might save a lot by
- 3:33doing that shopping around. If the insurance companies know
- 3:36that we're likely just to renew with them and stick with them,
- 3:39you know, why not raise their rates, They're not going to lose
- 3:41much from doing so. And then the flip side is
- 3:43they're going to have a lot more in revenue.
- 3:45The real shame of this is that during the pandemic when we
- 3:48weren't driving insurer saw massive profit windfalls.
- 3:52I mean they basically had very few claims to pay.
- 3:55And so you know, did we see a big price break because of that?
- 3:58Did we get a fat refund check from our auto insurance?
- 4:00Companies I didn't, I don't know about.
- 4:02You. Yeah, I mean, it's a few
- 4:04companies paid, you know, especially mutual companies paid
- 4:07out larger than usual dividends to their policyholders and a few
- 4:10did issue small refunds. But largely, auto insurance
- 4:14companies, if they gave you a break at all, it was only if you
- 4:17renewed with them. But overall, insurance companies
- 4:20just kept those massive profits, those big windfalls.
- 4:24It's not as if they set aside all that extra money for a rainy
- 4:27day when they had to pay more claims like they do now.
- 4:29And instead, you know, they did things like they bought back
- 4:33stock, You know, they just gave bigger dividends to their
- 4:36shareholders. And now that they have to settle
- 4:39more claims, now that their costs have gone up, they in turn
- 4:42are just jacking up our rates. So the best way to fight a rate
- 4:45hike is to shop around for a better price.
- 4:47As we discussed in Episode 40, that's true with homeowners
- 4:50insurance. And as checkbook shoppers
- 4:52discovered, it's also true with auto insurance.
- 4:55We found huge price differences from company to company for the
- 4:58exact same drivers, cars, and regions.
- 5:01Yeah, I mean. Even if your rates haven't been
- 5:03drastically increased, I think really everyone needs to shop
- 5:06around for the best auto insurance rates every few years.
- 5:10And while you're doing that, you may as well also shop for the
- 5:12best homeowners insurance rate. And the reason is we find that
- 5:16some companies charge thousands of dollars more in premiums for
- 5:20the exact same policy, the same drivers, the same cars,
- 5:23everything. I mean, there's this myth out
- 5:25there that companies for the most part charge the same prices
- 5:29for auto insurance, and that's just not true at all.
- 5:32And a lot of people believe you get rewarded for sticking with a
- 5:34company for loyalty. And that's not true either,
- 5:37right? Yeah.
- 5:37I mean, you know, I think a lot of drivers say, well, I haven't
- 5:40had any claims or I haven't had many tickets or accidents.
- 5:43And when I get my renewal papers from my insurance company,
- 5:46there's this big fat discount for being a loyal customer or
- 5:49whatever. The thing is other insurance
- 5:51companies, if you've been a good driver, they know that about you
- 5:54also. They all share data.
- 5:56And so other companies might be willing to give you a bigger
- 5:59price break to attract your business.
- 6:02The only way you're going to find out which companies charge
- 6:04the lowest rates is to shop around periodically.
- 6:07So based on that shopping around the checkbook did, how much can
- 6:11most drivers expect to save by shopping around?
- 6:13So we found almost all of us can save about $500 per year, every
- 6:18year by shopping around for better rates and switching
- 6:21coverage. If you find a lower cost
- 6:22company, some families, especially if you've had an
- 6:25accident or some tickets, or if you're in my case and you're
- 6:27going to have a teenage driver on your policy, those families
- 6:30will save even more because their premiums are higher.
- 6:33They can possibly save $1500 a year or more by switching
- 6:37coverage to a lower cost company.
- 6:39So for our latest report, we gathered rates from major
- 6:42insurers for several sample policyholders in each of our
- 6:45seven metro areas, and each of our sample policyholders would
- 6:49have saved more than $1000 a year by signing on with the
- 6:53lowest cost companies. Wow.
- 6:55That's a big difference, by the way, for those who are saying,
- 6:57well, my old policy just renewed, you don't have to wait
- 7:00for another renewal to come up to see if you could save money
- 7:03by switching companies, right? Just go ahead and do it.
- 7:05Yeah, there's really no reason to wait.
- 7:07By law, if you switch your insurance to a different
- 7:10company, even if you've prepaid premiums to your old company, if
- 7:14you cancel with them, they have to send you a refund for the
- 7:16unused share of anything you've paid for O you know, waiting
- 7:20another four months or whatever for your policy to get near its
- 7:23renewal date. It just means you're going to
- 7:25continue to overpay with your current company.
- 7:28Now this is really important. If you switch, make sure you
- 7:31sign up with a new company before you cancel your old
- 7:34policy. And all of us really need to
- 7:37make sure we continue to pay our premiums that we don't get
- 7:39dropped. Because if you have a lapse in
- 7:41an auto insurance coverage, it will drastically increase your
- 7:44rates with any company. Insurance companies, especially
- 7:46auto insurance companies, they really don't like policyholders
- 7:50who have gone without coverage even for a day.
- 7:52I mean, they see those folks as as big insurance risks.
- 7:55Really good tip. You know, it is a bit of a pain
- 7:57to do this shopping, and there are a lot of websites out there
- 8:00that promise to help consumers find the best auto insurance
- 8:03rate. But Checkbook cautions that they
- 8:05don't. Really work?
- 8:06Yeah, they're horrible. I mean, all these companies that
- 8:08say, oh, you know, we'll gather your information and give you a
- 8:11bunch of different insurance quotes, they don't really do
- 8:13that. For our study, I personally
- 8:15tested more than 25 of these websites, and none of them gave
- 8:20me a binding quote. I mean, I think like two of
- 8:22those websites gave me one rate for American family, and the
- 8:26rate I got from it was really high.
- 8:28The only thing I found that these sites did for me was
- 8:31unleash, you know, a bunch of hungry and desperate, sleazy
- 8:35sales people upon me who would in turn, I guess, you know, send
- 8:38me to a real insurance agent and get a cut of the Commission if I
- 8:41signed up for coverage with them.
- 8:43But they didn't give me a bunch of quotes to compare at at all.
- 8:46Instead, no, what you're going to have to do is collect rates
- 8:49from each of the major insurance companies on your own.
- 8:52Fortunately, most companies have slick rate quoting websites
- 8:56these days. I mean, it's pretty easy to get
- 8:58an insurance quote from them. And also it's easier to get a
- 9:01binding rate for auto insurance online.
- 9:04It's far easier to do that for auto insurance than it is for
- 9:07homeowners coverage. Because with homeowners, you
- 9:09know, usually they want to inspect your home and there's a
- 9:11lot of, you know, this lengthy underwriting process for auto
- 9:14insurance. Usually you can, you know,
- 9:16within only 10 minutes. It's a sort of plugging in
- 9:17information, get a binding quote from one company and so it's
- 9:21going to take a few hours to do the shopping around.
- 9:23But in the end, you know, I think most of us would say,
- 9:26well, spending a few hours to save $1000 is worth my time.
- 9:29Absolutely, and it's a good idea to contact an independent
- 9:33insurance agent. They usually work with a bunch
- 9:34of companies and can help compare prices and policies for
- 9:37you. That's what I've done and it I
- 9:39found it to be really helpful. This time I wound up changing
- 9:42companies thanks to a suggestion for my broker and I saved $1000.
- 9:46For the homeowner, there's an auto policies.
- 9:47I had $1000 in one year. That's a big deal.
- 9:50So knowledgeable independent agents are a great resource.
- 9:53Some insurance companies, they only work through independent
- 9:55agents. That's going to be the only way
- 9:57you can get quotes for some companies.
- 9:59Just know that when you're getting quotes from independent
- 10:02agents, they won't give you price quotes for companies like
- 10:05GEICO or Progressive or other companies that are called direct
- 10:08writers. Companies that only write
- 10:10policies themselves and don't pay out commissions to these
- 10:13independent agents. And The thing is, we often find
- 10:16that those companies are those direct riders.
- 10:19They have the best pricing. OK.
- 10:20So which auto insurance companies have the lowest
- 10:23prices? We're going to talk to Kevin
- 10:24about that next. I'm Her Weissbaum, the consumer
- 10:27man, and this is Consumerpedia powered by checkbook.org.
- 10:32OK. You're ready to shop around for
- 10:34a new auto insurance policy. Checkbook has price comparisons
- 10:37and quality ratings for dozens of insurance companies in these
- 10:40metro areas. Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 10:44Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul and
- 10:48Washington DC. If you live in or around one of
- 10:51these seven cities and haven't joined checkbook yet, check us
- 10:53out. Get a free 30 day subscription
- 10:56to all our ratings by going to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 11:01Checkbook researchers collected thousands of auto insurance
- 11:04rates. So which companies did the best
- 11:06for price? So unfortunately, there was no
- 11:08clear price winner. I'll say that, you know, GEICO
- 11:10and Progressive by and large did often quote low prices.
- 11:15Progressive especially was often a consistent low price option
- 11:19for most of our sample policyholders.
- 11:22These days property insurance companies use such complicated
- 11:25algorithms that every consumer's mileage is going to vary in
- 11:28terms of which companies will offer them the best rates.
- 11:31It's gotten just incredibly complicated how these companies
- 11:34calculate their prices. You know, nearly to the point
- 11:37that our that our own research, all these, you know, price
- 11:39quotes we collected. These sample prices can only be
- 11:42considered like anecdotal. And I don't think drivers should
- 11:45look at our results and say, well now that company was the
- 11:47least expensive for that family. So it'll be low priced for me.
- 11:50It might be, but it might not be.
- 11:52I can tell you though that State Farm, which after GEICO is the
- 11:57largest auto insurance writer in most states, typically doesn't
- 12:00offer low rates and neither does Farmers, which is also a top
- 12:04five rider in most states. Amica, which gets stellar
- 12:07ratings from its customers for claims paying quality, it also
- 12:10offered high rates for almost all of our sample families and
- 12:14some companies like USAA, it used to offer consistently low
- 12:17rates but it doesn't necessarily now it was on the higher price
- 12:21side for a lot of our families. So you know, again, we're coming
- 12:23back to this, that if you haven't shopped for auto
- 12:26insurance in a long time, you'll probably be surprised by how
- 12:29much you can save by switching, especially if you've been with
- 12:33say, State Farm or Farmers or one of those big companies for
- 12:37years and years. Because a lot of times these
- 12:39companies, you know, you're paying a high rate and they're
- 12:41not going to lower your rate because they don't think they're
- 12:43going to lose you because you just keep renewing with them.
- 12:45Sure. Kevin, a lot of people don't
- 12:47know this, but in most states, insurance companies use credit
- 12:50scores to set their rates. Is that a significant factor in
- 12:53deciding how much they're going to charge?
- 12:54Yeah. So in states that allow insurers
- 12:57to use credit scores, it's the biggest factor in terms of
- 13:00whether you'll pay a high or a low rate with that company.
- 13:03They also use other factors like occupation and education, and
- 13:07even whether they think you might bother to shop around for
- 13:09insurance and deciding what rate to offer you.
- 13:13In states that allow them to use credit scoring, it's become the
- 13:16most important variable and what you'll pay.
- 13:19We and other consumer groups that have studied this have
- 13:21found that those with poor credit scores tend to pay three
- 13:25times more than those with good scores for the exact same
- 13:28policies, cars, driver profiles and everything.
- 13:32Now, some states, to their credit, are reconsidering
- 13:34allowing credit scores. For example, it's already banned
- 13:37in California and Massachusetts. And in Maryland, insurance
- 13:40companies cannot use credit scores to set auto insurance
- 13:42rates, although they can use it for homeowners coverage.
- 13:45Here, where I live in Washington state, they're also considering
- 13:48several laws to prevent it. Do you think all states should
- 13:51ban this practice? Yeah, absolutely.
- 13:53My biggest problem is that there's no transparency anymore
- 13:56in terms of how companies set their rates in states that allow
- 13:59insurance companies to use credit scores and other kind of
- 14:02unknown factors to set their rates.
- 14:05Insurance companies in those areas, they basically get to
- 14:07claim that the formulas they're using are proprietary, and they
- 14:10get to keep them a secret, even though the factors and
- 14:14algorithms that they're using dominate their decisions about
- 14:17how much they're going to charge for coverage.
- 14:19And so by keeping these formulas a secret, they're circumventing
- 14:22the laws that were put in place by every state to prevent racial
- 14:26discrimination. And insurance companies have a
- 14:28long and terrible history of racial discrimination.
- 14:32And I'd argue what they're doing today effectively is
- 14:34discrimination. Insurance companies, they argue
- 14:37all the time that they're simply rating individuals according to
- 14:40risk. I mean, their representatives
- 14:41repeat this over and over again. They say the risk sets the rate.
- 14:45But the effect of what they're doing here simply is that
- 14:48they're charging minorities a lot more for insurance.
- 14:52They may be using proxies to do that, like credit scores and
- 14:55occupation or whatever, but the real effect is that blacks
- 14:58especially are paying a lot more for insurance than whites.
- 15:01And it's it's because of these secret factors that they've
- 15:04baked into their algorithms. The reason most states require
- 15:07insurance companies to file their rates with them to begin
- 15:09with is that insurers used to discriminate against black
- 15:12people, and now they're doing that again, Only this time the
- 15:15rate filings they send are meaningless because they don't
- 15:17have to explain their real reason for how they're setting
- 15:19their rates. You know, they say, oh, it's
- 15:21proprietary information, so we're not going to disclose how
- 15:24we've made these decisions. But mostly they're using credit
- 15:28scores and other things that they really don't have anything
- 15:30to do with driver risk. You know how risky that driver
- 15:33might be to insure? And they say, well, our data
- 15:36shows that there's a correlation between credit scores and
- 15:39whether you're likely to file a claim.
- 15:41And they leave it at that. And that's their answer.
- 15:43And that's the response to the insurance commissioners.
- 15:45If I had my credit score dropped tomorrow for something I did,
- 15:47like I forgot to pay a bill or something, am I all of a sudden
- 15:50a a worse driver? Am I all of a sudden riskier?
- 15:52But to them that seems to make sense.
- 15:54Yeah, I mean, their logic is that, you know, you're more
- 15:56likely to file a claim if you have a low credit score.
- 15:59Well, of course you are more likely to file a claim because
- 16:01you don't have enough money to maybe pay for the damages to
- 16:04your car on your own. But the problem here is that
- 16:07there's just this lack of transparency.
- 16:09These companies no longer have to disclose how they made these
- 16:12decisions in the first place. You know, every state has laws
- 16:16in terms of what insurance companies have to do in terms of
- 16:19setting their rates, in terms of filing information about how
- 16:21they made these decisions. But these days insurance
- 16:24companies get around those requirements by saying
- 16:26essentially, well, we had this proprietary formula, we don't
- 16:29have to share it with you. I just think if there were more
- 16:32transparency here, it would be a far better system and also it
- 16:36would eliminate this big danger which is already occurring, of
- 16:39having effectively discrimination baked into their
- 16:42rates. And most credit reports, as
- 16:44we've reported many times before, contain tons of errors.
- 16:47That's really important. So they're basing the decision
- 16:50on information that could be inaccurate.
- 16:51I mean, this is what's really frustrating is that insurance
- 16:54companies know that. They know that credit reports
- 16:56contain a lot of errors. They know that when there are
- 16:59errors that they're difficult to get corrected, and yet they
- 17:02continue to rely on this information that they know is
- 17:05faulty. So let's say you have a low
- 17:07credit score or even maybe you've had a few accidents or a
- 17:10couple of tickets and therefore have really high rates.
- 17:13What kind of things can you do to lower those premiums?
- 17:15The most important thing again, is to start by shopping around.
- 17:19I mean, especially if companies view you as a higher risk, they
- 17:22might charge you higher rates than they do others.
- 17:25But most companies, they want to make sure they have something to
- 17:27sell to everyone who comes looking.
- 17:29So if you have to pay a lot for coverage, it means that you'll
- 17:31find even bigger price variation out there among the different
- 17:35insurance company options, and so therefore you'll have bigger
- 17:38opportunities to save. All of us should also consider
- 17:40increasing our deductibles to save money.
- 17:42You get usually a big price break by moving from, say, a
- 17:45$500 deductible to a $1000 deductible.
- 17:49Especially for auto insurance, it's important you know you want
- 17:51to avoid making claims for minor problems like, you know, cracked
- 17:55windshield. If you make too many of these
- 17:57small claims, your insurer, they may drop you all together and
- 18:00once that happens, other companies they'll only insure
- 18:02you at a very high price. Another tip is if you have an
- 18:05older car, one way to save on insurance costs is to drop
- 18:08collision and comprehensive coverage once your car's value
- 18:12drops below $5000 or so. Because at that point, there's
- 18:15really no point. And paying a lot of money to
- 18:17insure you your car's value because your car isn't worth
- 18:20that much anymore. You know, when it comes to
- 18:22insurance, price is important, but so is service.
- 18:24And some companies do a much better job of taking care of
- 18:27their policyholders. Which ones?
- 18:29Well, that's straight ahead. I'm her Weissbaum, and you're
- 18:31listening to Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 18:36Consumerpedia fast Facts According to USA TODAY, the
- 18:41cheapest, best selling cars to insure are the Subaru Outback
- 18:44and Subaru Crosstrek. Car insurance rates vary by
- 18:47state. USA TODAY finds drivers of best
- 18:50selling vehicles in Vermont enjoy the lowest average rates,
- 18:5352% less than the national average.
- 18:56Louisiana drivers pay the highest average rates, 70% more
- 19:00than the national average. Only six states have average
- 19:03annual premiums below $2000 Idaho, Maine, North Carolina,
- 19:08Ohio, Oregon and Vermont. The checkbook also rates
- 19:13insurance companies for service quality.
- 19:15The standouts here are Amica, USAA, Erie, which is available
- 19:20in some states, and Chubb. But Kevin, you think cost is
- 19:23more important than quality for this transaction?
- 19:25Yeah. So we collected ratings from
- 19:27consumers who had dealt with their auto insurers for claim
- 19:30service. We also serve at auto body shops
- 19:32and ask them to rate insurance companies for treating their
- 19:35customers fairly. We also analyze complaint
- 19:38histories with state insurance departments.
- 19:41Overall, I'd say that most companies got poor ratings for
- 19:45claims quality. As you mentioned, there are a
- 19:47few standouts, but I think that most drivers should make their
- 19:50decisions based on costs, service, quality.
- 19:53It's like a tiebreaker if two companies quote similar rates.
- 19:56But even if the middling company offered me really low rates, I'd
- 20:00still switch to it. Most policyholders are with
- 20:03companies that provide no better service than what they get from
- 20:06low cost options. I mean, it's not as if State
- 20:08Farm gets stellar ratings when we survey their policyholders.
- 20:12They're about the same as most other insurers.
- 20:14So you may as well switch to, you know, GEICO or Progressive
- 20:17or whatever from Farmers and State Farm to save $1000 a year
- 20:21because you're not going to pay some kind of service quality
- 20:24penalty for doing that. And also, you know, the odds of
- 20:26having to make a really complicated claim, they're
- 20:29pretty low. I'd rather get the $1500 a year
- 20:33savings than say, well, you know, maybe I'll stick with this
- 20:35company because it might do a better job of paying my claims
- 20:38if I have them. What we found is that, you know,
- 20:40even among the worst companies, you know they do pay the claims.
- 20:44It just might be a bit of a hassle to deal with them.
- 20:46And if you do have an accident, one way to ensure that your
- 20:49claims get paid fairly and you get good work is to take your
- 20:52car to a top rated auto Body Shop and have them deal with
- 20:55your insurer. Yeah, this is key.
- 20:57A lot of auto insurance companies, they push their
- 20:59customers to take their cars to approve shops or to like drive
- 21:03in appraisal centers. If there's just a small dent or
- 21:06a very minor repair, that's fine.
- 21:08You can get, you know, a check written or you get the repairs
- 21:10done very quickly and efficiently.
- 21:12But if there's any chance that there's significant damage to
- 21:15your car, take it to the best Body Shop in your area.
- 21:19We evaluate body shops in our seven metro areas and can help
- 21:22you identify the best ones. The reason is that you need that
- 21:26Body Shop as your advocate to push your auto insurance company
- 21:29to make sure that the shop repairs the car to the point
- 21:32that is just like it was before the accident.
- 21:34I mean, after all, that's what your contract with the auto
- 21:37insurance company says it has to do.
- 21:39But unfortunately, many insurance companies look to
- 21:41skimp and really, you know, for lack of better words, screw over
- 21:44their customers. By having a good auto Body Shop
- 21:47in your corner, it can communicate with your insurance
- 21:49company and make the case for why you need repairs done a
- 21:53certain way. Insurance companies are always
- 21:55running ads, promising big savings if we have them cover
- 21:58our homes and our cars. Does this bundling make sense?
- 22:02Will it save us money? Yeah.
- 22:03So some companies do offer what are called dual policy discounts
- 22:07and you should factor in these potential savings when shopping
- 22:10around. But what you need to know is
- 22:12that most companies only offer about a 5 or 10% discount for
- 22:16doing that bundling. So if you're with a really
- 22:18expensive company, even if it offers A5 or 10% bundling
- 22:22discount, that's not going to make that expensive company
- 22:25inexpensive. It's not going to cut your rate
- 22:28by $1500 is what you might see by switching your coverage to
- 22:32the lowest cost company out there.
- 22:34What we often find is that the companies that charge the lowest
- 22:37rate for coverage, they don't offer those dual policy
- 22:40discounts or they don't offer very big discounts.
- 22:42But overall, because your price is going to be so much lower by
- 22:45switching to them, you don't have to worry so much about
- 22:47that. It's not something that you
- 22:49should really concern yourself with.
- 22:50I mean, I think it does make sense to shop for your home and
- 22:53auto policies together, but just know that you might want to
- 22:57split up your auto and home policies to two different
- 22:59companies if that's the way you can save the most money.
- 23:02Optional coverages can really drive up those premium costs.
- 23:05Are there some that we should consider when shopping around?
- 23:08What we found is most of the policy features that insurance
- 23:11companies and their agents push, they're really not worth that
- 23:13much. I mean, don't buy rental car
- 23:16coverage. It sounds like a good deal and
- 23:19every single company pushes these optional coverages, but
- 23:23they just don't do that much for you.
- 23:24I mean, basically these add-ons will cover the cost of a rental
- 23:27car while your car is in a shop if you need repairs made.
- 23:31But they limit the payouts for that type of policy to like
- 23:34$900. So you shouldn't pay 75 or $100
- 23:37a year to maybe get, you know, a maximum of $900 and benefit.
- 23:41It is, though, definitely worth bumping up your liability
- 23:44coverage to a limit of, say, $500,000 or more.
- 23:49Doing that doesn't cost much more, but you get a lot more
- 23:52coverage for your premium that way.
- 23:54Finally, watch out for gimmicks. A lot of companies these days
- 23:57advertise things like disappearing deductibles and
- 24:00accident forgiveness and stuff like that.
- 24:02If it's a free feature, then yeah, OK, go ahead.
- 24:05Didn't take it. But some companies, they charge
- 24:07more for those add-ons. I mean, in the end, it's
- 24:10actually kind of a weird marketing tactic anyways, right?
- 24:12These companies are promoting this optional insurance coverage
- 24:15to protect you against the risk that you might actually need to
- 24:18use their product, that you might need to file a claim and
- 24:21they're offering you insurance against the risk of having your
- 24:24rates get jacked up when you actually need their insurance
- 24:27coverage. I mean, it is a bizarre
- 24:28marketing tactic, but it does work.
- 24:30A lot of people think that these types of benefits have values
- 24:33and they really don't have that much value at all.
- 24:35And if for some reason you are having problems with your
- 24:38insurance company, maybe they don't want to pay you, maybe
- 24:41they aren't paying you. Contact your state insurance
- 24:44Commissioner's Office. They're in your corner and you
- 24:46would be surprised at how a company that won't deal with you
- 24:49all of a sudden starts working for you when they get contacted
- 24:52by the state insurance Commissioner's Office.
- 24:54Especially in states that have strong consumer protection laws
- 24:57around insurance. Some states have stronger laws
- 25:00than others. You know, some insurance
- 25:01commissioners have a lot of power over these companies and
- 25:04can really help you to make things right, especially if the
- 25:06insurance company is is breaking the law.
- 25:09And insurance companies often do try to circumvent the laws that
- 25:12are set up to protect us from that type of abuse.
- 25:14Well, Kevin, you gave us a lot to think about.
- 25:17And good luck with your daughter, because you know, once
- 25:19she learns how to drive, she's going to want a new car, Dad.
- 25:22Yeah, the car she's going to get is sitting in my driveway right
- 25:25now. Good luck, Meredith.
- 25:26I wouldn't want to learn to drive from your dad.
- 25:27Kevin, be well. We'll talk to you next time.
- 25:31Thanks her. Well, that's it for this edition
- 25:33of Consumerpedia. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 25:35and follow us on Apple podcast, Spotify or wherever you listen
- 25:39to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 25:42episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 25:45show is to follow us on Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 25:48Instagram, And at my Consumerpedia on Twitter.
- 25:52I'm Her Weissbaum. Thanks for listening.
- 25:54Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 25:58We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 26:01smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 26:03help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 26:07ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 26:09If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 26:12Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 26:17Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 26:21Washington DC To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 26:24checkbook.org/consumerpedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 26:28we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 26:31the bottom of the show Notes to make a small contribution each
- 26:34month. Consumerpedia Empowering
- 26:36consumers to save money and make smarter choices.