Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Meta Platforms Q3 Shock
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. If you've been watching the
- 0:02financial news, well, you've probably seen the the sheer
- 0:05confusion around Meta Platforms. That's NASDAQ, Q Meta.
- 0:09Their Q32025 report just landed. Oh yeah.
- 0:13It was seriously mixed signals. A real Rorschach test for anyone
- 0:17looking. At it exactly on one side, you
- 0:20see this incredible revenue growth right up 26% year over
- 0:23year to what, $51.24 billion? Which is just phenomenal growth
- 0:28for a company that big, huge numbers.
- 0:30But then, boom, the other headline hits Jab net income
- 0:34plunging 83%, 82%. Right makes it sound like the
- 0:38sky is falling. And that's exactly why we're
- 0:40diving in today. We want to cut through all that
- 0:41accounting noise. You know, lit to the real story.
- 0:44Yeah, assess the actual fundamental quality, the the
- 0:46long term staying power, the Moat of Meta's business.
- 0:50Is it still that high quality fortress people think it is?
- 0:52And we're going to use that rigorous checklist, the sort of
- 0:54Buffett style quality assessment we are, which is crucial here
- 0:58because look, here's the immediate take away for you
- 1:00listening. That 83% income drop, it was
- 1:03almost entirely just an accounting thing.
- 1:05It's OK, non cash, non recurring, if you strip that out
- 1:09their actual underlying profit, it actually grew probably around
- 1:1219% year over year. So.
- 1:14The headline was really misleading you about the core
- 1:16business. Totally misleading all.
- 1:17Right. Let's break that down right away
- 1:19then, because that tax charge seems key.
- 1:21What exactly made GAP net income fall off a Cliff from what was
- 1:26it $15.7 billion last year down to just $2.71 billion?
- 1:31Yeah, the single reason was this enormous non cash tax expense,
- 1:36$15.93 billion. Wow.
- 1:40And it was tied directly to changes in U.S. tax law
- 1:44specifically related to that new corporate alternative minimum
- 1:47tax, the CAMT. It forced a write down.
- 1:50Hang on, this wasn't like actual cash going out the door to the
- 1:52IRS this quarter. Absolutely not.
- 1:54It's an accounting adjustment. It forced Meta to reduce the
- 1:57value of what are called deferred tax assets on their
- 1:59balance sheet because the new law changes how they can use
- 2:02those assets in the future. But the key point for you is it
- 2:05hits the income statement once, but it doesn't impact their cash
- 2:08generation now or going forward. That's a huge distinction.
- 2:13So if we mentally set that aside, the actual operations
- 2:17look really strong. Incredibly robust.
- 2:20Yeah, the core AD engine is just humming.
- 2:23Revenue jumped 26% to $51.24 billion.
- 2:27Was that mostly just more ads being shown or are they getting
- 2:30higher prices too? It was actually a really strong
- 2:33mix of both, which is what you really want to see.
- 2:35It shows pricing power and impressions of the volume that
- 2:38was up 14% and the average price per ad up 10%.
- 2:42Yeah. It's a powerful combination,
- 2:44shows real demand. Definitely, but we also have to
- 2:46talk about the spending side because they are spending a lot
- 2:49to fuel that future growth. They really are.
- 2:51Total cost and expenses jumped 32% year over year.
- 2:55That's up to $30.7 billion. Like it's mainly 2 big things
- 2:59driving that. Yeah, first, just aggressive
- 3:01investment in AI, you know, servers, infrastructure.
- 3:04And 2nd, the the division that just keeps losing money.
- 3:07Reality Labs, right? And they even nudged up their
- 3:09spending forecast for the year, didn't they, the CapEx guidance?
- 3:12They did, yeah. Pushing it to a frankly
- 3:15staggering 70 to $72 billion for 2025, mostly for data centers in
- 3:20AI capacity. And that kind of massive
- 3:23spending, you know, $70 billion a year in CapEx, that's part of
- 3:26how they're trying to build and defend their fortress, which
- 3:29brings us to the Moat itself. OK.
- 3:31So meta score business, we know it's advertising targeted ads,
- 3:34that's like 98% of the revenue. Yep. $50.08 billion just from
- 3:40ads in Q3 and they mentioned having over 10 million active
- 3:43advertisers now at the scale is just.
- 3:47What's the actual Moat? What stops competitors?
- 3:49Is it just the size? It really starts with the
- 3:52network effect from that user scale.
- 3:53It's just unmatched. They report 3.54 billion daily
- 3:57active people DAP across the whole family, Facebook,
- 4:00Instagram, WhatsApp. 3 1/2 billion daily.
- 4:03Daily and Facebook alone, monthly users is still over 3
- 4:06billion. If you're an advertiser trying
- 4:08to reach people globally, there's just no other single
- 4:10platform that comes close to that reach and activity.
- 4:12It's a huge barrier. So scale is #1 but what about
- 4:16the AI and the data side, especially with all that
- 4:18spending we just talked about? Well, that's where the huge
- 4:21CapEx comes in. That's the second layer of the
- 4:23mode, the AI and data Advantage. They're pouring billions into
- 4:26building these specialized AI supercomputers, right, to crunch
- 4:30all the data they get from those, you know, 3.5 billion
- 4:33users. They said over 4 million
- 4:35advertisers were already using their AI Advantage Plus ad tools
- 4:39by mid 2025. So the AI helps them target ads
- 4:43effectively even with less external data like from Apples
- 4:45changes. Exactly, it helps them maintain
- 4:48decent targeting accuracy even when things like cookies or iOS
- 4:51tracking are restricted. And that level of investment in
- 4:54AI hardware and software? Only a couple of companies
- 4:57globally, maybe Google, can even try to match it.
- 5:00It's a huge competitive advantage.
- 5:01It sounds like a 2 pronged strategy.
- 5:03Then defend the core ad business with AI while making this huge
- 5:08long term bet on Reality Labs. Let's talk about how much that
- 5:11Reality Labs bet is costing them right now.
- 5:13Yeah. RL is still very much an
- 5:15investment, a cost center really it only brought in $470 million
- 5:19in revenue in Q3. That's less than 1% of total.
- 5:21Sales. OK, tiny revenue.
- 5:22What about the losses? The operating loss was $4.43
- 5:26billion just for the quarter. 4 1/2 billion loss in three
- 5:30months, yeah. And compare that to the core
- 5:33family of apps segment, Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp.
- 5:37That part delivered almost $25 billion in operating profit.
- 5:41So Reality Labs is still this massive weight pulling down the
- 5:44overall profitability? It's a huge drag.
- 5:47They do have some tiny side businesses starting up right
- 5:50like WhatsApp business tools, meta verified subscriptions.
- 5:54Yeah. They lumped that into other
- 5:55revenue, which was around $690 million for the quarter.
- 5:58So they're trying to diversify a little bit, but like you said
- 6:01earlier, 98% is ads. Meta's fate is tied to digital
- 6:05advertising. And that naturally leads us into
- 6:07talking about the risks. What could go wrong?
- 6:10And it's really important here to separate, you know, the
- 6:12temporary bumps in the road from the really serious structural
- 6:15risks, the things that could permanently damage the business.
- 6:18OK, So what falls into that temporary bucket stuff?
- 6:20We can maybe sort of ignore for the long term.
- 6:23Things like general economic slowdowns, you know, ad budgets
- 6:27might soften for a bit or when a competitor launches a hot new
- 6:30product. Like TikTok?
- 6:31Exactly like TikTok, that felt like a huge threat initially,
- 6:34but Meta reacted right? They poured resources into
- 6:38reels, copy the format, enhanced it, monetized it heavily.
- 6:42They usually manage those kinds of competitive threats within a
- 6:45few quarters. It's their playbook.
- 6:47Copy, then enhance. OK.
- 6:48So those are bumps, yeah. What about the structural risks,
- 6:51the ones that could be permanent game changers?
- 6:53#1 without a doubt is privacy and platform changes.
- 6:58Think Apple's iOS 14.5 update. Right, that hit them hard.
- 7:02Massively estimates are it created a permanent headwind of
- 7:06like $10 billion plus per year in lost revenue potential
- 7:10because it just kneecaps their ability to track users off
- 7:13platform. And it's not just Apple, right?
- 7:15Europe's involved too. Yes, exactly.
- 7:17New EU regulations are now forcing Meta to give users a
- 7:21choice, either opt out of personalized ads completely
- 7:25white, or pay for an ad free subscription.
- 7:27That fundamentally changes how they make money in a huge
- 7:30important market like Europe. That's not temporary.
- 7:32That feels pretty structural. OK, what's #2?
- 7:34The big question mark around the metaverse itself, that Reality
- 7:38Labs division, we talked about losing $4.43 billion a quarter.
- 7:43Yeah, if that massive bet fails to get mainstream adoption, if
- 7:47people just don't want to live or work in the metaverse, then
- 7:50it just becomes this incredibly expensive, permanent drag on the
- 7:53company. Yeah, 10s of billions flushed
- 7:56away every year on R&D. That doesn't pay off.
- 7:58Very expensive hobby. A very, very expensive hobby
- 8:01that weighs down margins for maybe a decade or.
- 8:04More OK. And the third?
- 8:05Structural risk. Yeah, the big one looming over
- 8:08all of Big Tech. Regulation, antitrust.
- 8:11Governments everywhere are getting much more skeptical,
- 8:13much more aggressive. What's the worst case scenario
- 8:16there? The ultimate risk is regulators
- 8:18stepping in and fundamentally limiting how Meta can use data,
- 8:21or even more drastically, forcing them to sell off parts
- 8:24of the company like spinning off Instagram or WhatsApp.
- 8:27I think you have. The family.
- 8:27Exactly. That would shatter the whole
- 8:29family of apps, ecosystem and synergy.
- 8:32It would completely change the investment case.
- 8:34All right, heavy risks, but now let's pivot to the quality
- 8:36assessment. We've got this giant
- 8:38controversial, fast growing tech company.
- 8:41How does it actually stack up against those classic demanding
- 8:44criteria? The Buffett style checklist for
- 8:47durable businesses? Well, you might be surprised.
- 8:49Overall, Meta actually scores remarkably well on most of the
- 8:53core quality checks. It really is a cash generating
- 8:56machine. Let's start with cash flow.
- 8:58OK. Free cash flow FCF How does it
- 9:00look? Exceptionally good.
- 9:01It passes with flying colors. Meta has been FCF positive every
- 9:06single year for the last decade, every year, every year.
- 9:09And the free cash flow margin, that's FCF divided by revenue
- 9:12consistently runs above 20%. Just in 2024, they generated
- 9:16something like $50 billion in free cash flow. 50 billion.
- 9:20That's the sign of a really high quality business.
- 9:22It throws off way more cash than it needs just to operate and
- 9:25maintain itself. And that cash allows them to
- 9:28fund the huge CapEx and absorb those Reality Labs losses
- 9:31without borrowing tons of money. Precisely.
- 9:34OK. Next, profitability and returns.
- 9:37How does it score there? Again, really strong marks.
- 9:40Gross margin is incredibly high, around 82%.
- 9:43Wow, which makes sense, right? They're selling digital ad
- 9:46space, not physical goods. The cost of revenue is low and.
- 9:49Returns return on equity Roe. Roe has averaged somewhere
- 9:53between 22% and maybe 36% in good years, well above the 15%
- 9:59threshold Buffett often looks for and return on invested
- 10:03capital. ROIC also comfortably above that
- 10:06sort of 12% average you want to see for durable competitive
- 10:09advantages. OK.
- 10:10Solid profitability. What about the balance sheet?
- 10:12Is it safe? It's a fortress, absolute rock
- 10:15solid. They have almost no interest
- 10:17bearing debt, the debt to equity ratio is tiny, less than
- 10:20weathered 1, and they're sitting on a huge pile of cash.
- 10:23Over $44 billion as of the end of Q 3/20/25.
- 10:27So they can basically fund themselves in weather storms.
- 10:29Easily. They don't need banks.
- 10:30Oregon capital markets. They fund their massive AI build
- 10:33out internally. OK, so it sounds like a high
- 10:35quality machine on many fronts, but the checklist isn't all
- 10:37passes, right? Yeah.
- 10:38Where does meta stumble? Where does it fail the test?
- 10:40The main failure point is earnings consistency.
- 10:43You know, the ideal Buffett type stock shows positive and ideally
- 10:47smoothly rising earnings per share EPS every single year.
- 10:51Predictable. And Meta hasn't done that.
- 10:53No, EPS actually dropped back in 2019, mainly due to that big $5
- 10:58billion FTC fine they had to pay, and it dropped again
- 11:02significantly in 2022. What caused the 2022 drop?
- 11:05That was a combination of factors, the general economic
- 11:07slowdown hitting ad spend, plus that sudden massive ramp up in
- 11:11spending for the metaverse pivot.
- 11:13So while there were specific reasons the earnings stream just
- 11:16hasn't been that smooth, predictable upward curve, it's
- 11:19been more volatile. Which value investors don't
- 11:21typically like. Exactly.
- 11:23And the other area where it usually fails the traditional
- 11:25test is valuation, the price you pay.
- 11:28Right quality is one thing, price is another.
- 11:30Yes. Historically, Meta's price to
- 11:32earnings ratio, the PE, has typically averaged in the high
- 11:3520s. By late 2024, it was around 24.
- 11:38And Buffett traditionally looks for.
- 11:40Much lower, like a PE of 15 or less, maybe even 10.
- 11:43The only time Meta really dipped into that traditional value
- 11:46territory was very briefly during that big market sell off
- 11:50in late 2022. The PE got down to about 13.9
- 11:54for a short while. That was the moment then.
- 11:56That was the moment if you were strictly following those rules.
- 11:59OK. That perfectly sets up our final
- 12:01segment, the valuation reality check, the stocks trading around
- 12:04$750 a share now. Yeah.
- 12:07Given everything we've discussed, the strengths, the
- 12:09risks, the spending, what does that price imply about future
- 12:13growth? Yeah.
- 12:14This is where we need to look at something like a discounted cash
- 12:16flow or DCF model. It helps estimate the intrinsic
- 12:20value based on future cash flows.
- 12:22And what you find is the value is highly sensitive to your
- 12:25growth assumptions. All right, let's run through a
- 12:27few scenarios. What if we're really
- 12:28conservative? Let's say Meta only manages to
- 12:30grow its free cash flow by say 5% a year from here on out.
- 12:35Basically it matures into a slow growth utility.
- 12:38OK. If you plug in 5% growth and use
- 12:40a pretty standard 10% discount rate, your required rate of
- 12:42return, the intrinsic value you get is only around 200 to
- 12:45$210.00 per share. $200 compared to $750 today.
- 12:50Right, so that tells you immediately the market is
- 12:53absolutely not pricing meta like a slow growth utility.
- 12:56It implies massive downside risk if growth really stalls out
- 12:59because of regulation or the metaverse failing.
- 13:02OK, that's the floor. Maybe what about a more moderate
- 13:05sort of nominal case? Let's say they navigate the
- 13:07privacy stuff. OK.
- 13:08Reality Labs losses maybe stabilize and they average say
- 13:1315% FCF growth over the next decade.
- 13:16All right. 15% growth, that's much better.
- 13:18Obviously that pushes the estimated intrinsic value up
- 13:22quite a bit into the range of maybe 380 to $410 per share.
- 13:26OK, $410, still a long way from $750.
- 13:30Still a long way. The current market price is
- 13:32nearly double. Even the sort of moderate
- 13:33success scenario. It really confirms the market is
- 13:35baking in some very optimistic assumptions about future growth.
- 13:39So to justify today's price, we need the really bullish,
- 13:43optimistic case, right? What kind of growth does that
- 13:45assume? You need to assume something
- 13:47like 20% plus compounded annual growth in free cash flow for the
- 13:51next 10 years, driven by, you know, huge wins in AI reels,
- 13:54monetization really taking off. Maybe Reality Labs finally
- 13:57starts contributing, or at least stops losing so much money.
- 14:00What intrinsic value does that super bullish 20% plus growth
- 14:03scenario get us? Even with that very strong
- 14:06growth, the DCF value lands somewhere between, let's say 600
- 14:11and $730 per share. So even the most optimistic case
- 14:15barely gets us to the current market price of $750.
- 14:18Exactly. The current price is trading
- 14:20slightly above the high end of what even a very bullish perfect
- 14:23execution scenario would suggest.
- 14:25Using standard discount rates. It implies the market either
- 14:28expects better than 20% growth sustained for a decade, or maybe
- 14:32investors are using a lower discount rate, seeing Meta as
- 14:34less risky than that 10% implies.
- 14:36Which brings us finally to margin of safety that buffer
- 14:39against being wrong. It's $750 a share.
- 14:42Are you getting any? Based on these numbers, pretty
- 14:45much 0 margin of safety right now, you are paying a premium
- 14:48price that demands near flawless execution against some pretty
- 14:52significant structural headwinds we discussed.
- 14:54So the real opportunity, the fat pitch, as Buffett calls it, was
- 14:58back when the sentiment was terrible.
- 15:00Absolutely. That period in late 2022 when
- 15:03the stock was trading between $90.00 and $120.00, that was the
- 15:06time even our conservative DCF showed value back then.
- 15:10Today you're paying full price, maybe more, for future success
- 15:14that's promised but not yet delivered.
- 15:15OK, let's try and wrap this all up then.
- 15:17The key take away from our deep dive today seems to be Meta is
- 15:20fundamentally a very high quality business.
- 15:23It generates tons of cash, has high returns, a strong Moat
- 15:27built on scale, and increasingly, AI.
- 15:29It passes most, though not all, of those Buffett quality checks.
- 15:33Yes, the underlying quality is there.
- 15:34But, and it's a big but, the current stock price around $750
- 15:38seems to be pricing in years of substantial near perfect growth.
- 15:42There's very little room for error or disappointment baked in
- 15:45right now. That's right.
- 15:46And when you have a high quality company trading at such, let's
- 15:49say, optimistic expectations, it becomes absolutely crucial to
- 15:53track its valuation relative to the overall market temperature.
- 15:57You need context to make rational decisions.
- 15:59And to help you track that total market temperature, you're
- 16:02welcome to search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator
- 16:06right from the Apple App Store. And just a quick disclaimer, all
- 16:09the analysis we've shared today is based on publicly available
- 16:11sources. Things can change,
- 16:13interpretations differ. This is all for educational
- 16:16purposes. It is definitely not investment
- 16:18advice. Please always do your own
- 16:20homework, your own due diligence, diligence before
- 16:22making any investment decisions. OK, before we go, here's a
- 16:25provocative thought for you to chew on.
- 16:28We've established the core ad business is strong, right?
- 16:31But maybe the single biggest variable for Meta's long term
- 16:34value isn't just ad growth. Maybe it's whether Mark
- 16:38Zuckerberg can actually maintain cost discipline while continuing
- 16:41to pour 10s of billions every year into Reality Labs.
- 16:45Will that metaverse bet finally start to pay off and stop being
- 16:47a $4.43 billion quarterly drag? Or is that massive expense just
- 16:52the permanent cost of trying to stay relevant in the next
- 16:56platform war? Something to think about.
- 16:58And if you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 17:00and others, please subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 17:04Just search for deep value investing.
- 17:06Thanks for joining us. We'll catch you on the next deep
- 17:08dive.