Latest / Newcomer Pod / A Content Farming Retrospective (w/Shawn Colo)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome. Hey guys, everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to Dead cat. This is Tom.
- 0:16I'm here with Eric, very excited about this episode and our
- 0:19special guest Shawn Colo from 3L, capital and excited for a
- 0:24couple of reasons. One 3L has a lot of interesting
- 0:27Investments that we can get into in this podcast.
- 0:30Shawn before he was doing the VC thing with 3.
- 0:33L was the co-founder and CEO of demand media, which is a media
- 0:38company that very much defined, a certain era of online media
- 0:43and is kind of been forgotten by, a lot of people so much.
- 0:46So that when I was telling Eric and Katie how excited I was that
- 0:49Sean wanted to do the episode and he was the former CEO and
- 0:52co-founder of demand media, they're like, what is demand?
- 0:55And I think we should definitely explain all of that here because
- 0:58the story of demand to me, Beyond like I'm saying I've
- 1:01personal residents to this thing and I can explain later in the
- 1:03episode 4 tells a lot of what happens later on in the digital
- 1:08media environment and very much. I think what's going on these
- 1:12days with all of these companies.
- 1:14So, very excited getting all of this.
- 1:16But Sean, first of all, thanks for joining.
- 1:19Thanks for doing this. Yeah, no.
- 1:20Thanks Tom. I love and it's always good.
- 1:22I think that to I'm surprised that Eric and Katie didn't, I?
- 1:25We have Ivory oh my God. He said the Roundup of The
- 1:30Brand's obviously I recognize some of the brands, but yeah, I
- 1:33am excited to sort of learn a little bit of the tech history.
- 1:37I mean, you know, media companies sort of responding to
- 1:41platform incentives is such a trend that we experienced over
- 1:46and over again. So now, with a lot of little bit
- 1:48of distance from it, to get sort of the unvarnished view of it.
- 1:54I'm definitely excited to hear the sorry.
- 1:56I'm good. So yeah, demand when I was
- 1:59explaining it, Eric and Katie I was explaining it as like this
- 2:02holding company that had a lot of different sites that they had
- 2:05a little bit more familiarity with.
- 2:07But why don't you just explain like you at the outset, like,
- 2:10your co-founding of this company who you were involved with early
- 2:13days because that's interesting too.
- 2:14And like what? What was the strategy with this
- 2:17thing? Yeah, I guess I will let me I'll
- 2:19go back a little bit further than that.
- 2:22So I was at a firm called Spectrum, Equity investors.
- 2:24I started my career as a private Equity investor.
- 2:27So this was in the late 90s. He's right, the 97 I think I
- 2:31started at Spectrum and we have to realize what was happening in
- 2:35all different forms of media at that time, right?
- 2:38And media you know we can all Define it slightly different
- 2:41ways but you know the different forms of media and the platform
- 2:44radio cable satellite, right? Yellow Pages was a form of
- 2:49media, right? Because there's a big
- 2:50advertising platform, right? So print magazines.
- 2:54So when I started my career, what was happening was the
- 2:59Telecom? Is Tre just do regulate it
- 3:01platforms. Were opening up and you were
- 3:02seeing a lot of aggregation plays.
- 3:06I then started looking at internet businesses.
- 3:08So this thumbs like conked like 27 through Earth's are 97
- 3:12through like early 2000. And then I started I was sort of
- 3:15tasked with finding literate businesses that we could invest
- 3:18in. But we had a mandate that like
- 3:20we were investing only in in ebitda positive companies so
- 3:24trying to find a profitable internet company and often times
- 3:27are using leverage to like you know Engineer charts.
- 3:32So I kind of had that was my eyelid background.
- 3:34And so, when I, when I started looking at these two things, at
- 3:39the same time like, okay, aired at businesses and, and Media
- 3:42consolidation On In traditional sense, I basically just had the,
- 3:46a little bit of a light bulb moment, which is well, okay.
- 3:49I see all these websites that are growing and these were
- 3:52websites like ehow.com or like dictionary.com, right?
- 3:57And in many ways they actually had like interesting.
- 3:59Maintenance which is just that little bit of a quirk of
- 4:02History, you know, people who are really, you know, registered
- 4:06names and that figured out how to act they wanted to do
- 4:08something with them so they started creating blogs and then
- 4:11of course with the growth of search engines in the growth of
- 4:13Google, these people who were really just passionate
- 4:16enthusiasts, right? They were knowledgeable about a
- 4:18topic sometimes. They were good writers,
- 4:20sometimes they weren't, but they were creating websites and web
- 4:24sites were getting traffic organically from Google for free
- 4:28and that monetizing them. M with Google for free.
- 4:32So you are starting to see this class of profitable websites
- 4:36that were emerging. And what you didn't really see
- 4:40was the Venture capitalists, it really care about those
- 4:43businesses for them. Like you know obviously there
- 4:44were a number of them were they started like really scale they
- 4:47didn't but if you were looking at a business like Trails.com
- 4:51back then, right, which was one of the websites.
- 4:53We ended up acquiring was of really nice business run by two
- 4:57really smart entrepreneurs out. There weren't really Be that
- 5:00attractive to a venture investor at the time.
- 5:03And they also weren't really that attractive to private
- 5:05Equity because they were also too small.
- 5:07Do you remember when you acquired it sort of what the
- 5:09financials look like or what wouldst, what type of business
- 5:13that company at the time might have been doing handing to 12 in
- 5:18revenue, and maybe it was doing like, Two or three of you.
- 5:21But, ah, yeah. Kind of symbol that was the
- 5:24profile and the business basically was this was an
- 5:27attractive domain, like, in a kind of almost not, not pretty
- 5:30good because some people were searching for it, but it felt
- 5:32like a very safe and comfortable website as someone who was
- 5:36searching. Can't because Trails.com, you're
- 5:37like, well, that sounds reliable.
- 5:39Brian then. And then the content on there
- 5:41was good enough that you were, you know, willing to come back
- 5:43to it and because of that traffic, you know, throw some
- 5:46banner ads on it some AdSense and, you know, you could Could
- 5:50you could turn some, you could turn some cash with that.
- 5:52So I started building a deck putting the thing together and
- 5:56then that's when I met my co-founder.
- 5:58Richard rosenblatt who, you know, was was the chair, former
- 6:03chairman of my space. She was based in Los Angeles and
- 6:07when we started and I started socialize this idea.
- 6:09What have I said, we could we could go by these websites and
- 6:12and go and build his company. You know, would love to be on
- 6:15the board. He said, well actually this is
- 6:18it's actually pretty interesting if You add social networking to
- 6:22these sites because he asked the right question at the time I
- 6:24think was like, well, okay now that you buy them, that's great.
- 6:27But how do you grow them, right? What do you do with right?
- 6:29What do you do differently than what they were doing right for
- 6:31right? What do you do?
- 6:32And so it was really, this is, you know, kind of preface book.
- 6:35And it was like, well, if you could snap social networking
- 6:39functionality into these sites, if you can make them social,
- 6:43then you Dad, you have something that could really.
- 6:47Correct, I could be where you are.
- 6:48We talking truck? This was in 2000 and then, let's
- 6:53see what your company and post-sex.
- 6:56So I was probably laid out for God was working on it for
- 7:00probably 18 months ago. It was probably four or five.
- 7:02So Facebook at the time was really just like a college, you
- 7:06know, coeds. Yeah, I'm and on you weren't
- 7:07seeing anywhere near the power of what it was going to be.
- 7:10I mean, I really don't even think it was.
- 7:11I have to go back and went to see what Facebook actually
- 7:14launched because I it may have actually been Been pre faced a
- 7:18big effect, right? It might have been that.
- 7:20It might have been Harvard. I vaguely remember a few friends
- 7:23sort of making the track like investors saying oh I gotta go
- 7:26see, you know, good Boston and see Mark campus and Richard, by
- 7:31the way, is one of these key figures in this group of people
- 7:34in l.a., that kind of defines this what people they called the
- 7:39Myspace Mafia. Which was, you know, I mean
- 7:41obviously there's the PayPal Mafia I guess now the stripe
- 7:43Mafia but as far as La Tech is concerned.
- 7:46Was the group of that era that kind of went off and spun out a
- 7:49bunch of companies, demand, I guess, being an example of that
- 7:53and then Richard sort of being kind of like the, the dawn of
- 7:56the Myspace Mafia, right? Yeah, I'm sure I'm sure you
- 7:59would love that description to the mid-2000s.
- 8:01Facebook is just sort of getting going, you're bringing in sort
- 8:05of, like, Old Guard internet. With the Myspace guy to start it
- 8:10and then correct. And then what so, then we start.
- 8:13So that weird. So then we raised, so then I
- 8:14basically have free Associated 3L.
- 8:18O wise. So letters of intent.
- 8:20Basically we could buy two by three companies simultaneously.
- 8:23We raise 120 million dollars to go do that and we bought one of
- 8:27the businesses part of the, there's another.
- 8:30But I don't want it too far off the track.
- 8:31But part of the other part of the story I mentioned that
- 8:33domain name and those media companies, you know, that is a
- 8:37small web site sidereel.com. But there was also people at the
- 8:40time, we were building portfolios of generic domain
- 8:42names and that I also kind of you.
- 8:46Immediate asset because people were either typing it in or
- 8:50they're worse if you maybe had a landing page or something
- 8:52getting indexed to Google, and then you just saw pays it paid
- 8:55ads. Like, I don't even know if
- 8:57that's really a thing anymore. But right, just a website with a
- 9:00bunch of banner ads on. There was just a web site of.
- 9:02Yeah, I picked up, I picked the search engines of kind of gone
- 9:04away from having that, it's kind of a core business, but, but it
- 9:08was just, it was like, five Blue Links on a page.
- 9:10Yeah, those things work. Fritting money.
- 9:13They were making a ton of money and that was going to be part of
- 9:16this journey. Hurry to that.
- 9:17That was going to be a business that we really need to.
- 9:20And again it was sort of architect is going to be a
- 9:22Content business and media does this but it was going to have
- 9:25multiple elements or companies within it so almost like a
- 9:28conglomerate type of approach from day one, right?
- 9:31And so we bought. So there are a couple companies
- 9:33that we bought. We bought a business called
- 9:34enom, which is a domain name registrar.
- 9:37The great founder depaul's to her a hug enough to found a
- 9:40business called donuts, which is now a multi-billion dollar
- 9:42company in the domain name space, we bought me how.com And
- 9:48I think we bought another sort of portfolio of domain names
- 9:51that was probably generating like 5 million bucks of cash
- 9:55flow. So like day one the business was
- 9:57generating. I think the profile of the time
- 9:59as I remember it was like it was it was about a maybe 70 million
- 10:04and Consolidated revenue and like 10 or 12 of ebitda like day
- 10:08one from. Yeah.
- 10:09Yeah. Which is kind of Unthinkable
- 10:11these days for scaling up a business.
- 10:13What I want to get to eHow and how How you guys kind of scaled
- 10:18the content for for these sites because it's one thing to just
- 10:21have a popular domain. Yeah that people are going to
- 10:23and there's links on it but you know the As I understood it the
- 10:27strategy with e. How is that you guys were trying
- 10:30to have content on there? That was the stuff that people
- 10:33were searching for. And so the content that was on
- 10:36the site was optimized for the most searched for terms on
- 10:39basically Google and so explain a little bit to me because in a
- 10:44second I want to get to content farming and my Yes, exactly.
- 10:48Right, right. So and I'm going to, I'm going
- 10:50to give the founders now of tastemade, which is Larry
- 10:53Fitzgibbon. Steve the Kid, Joe Perez, they
- 10:55were part of this founding team at demand.
- 10:57Now we give them their due because basically in addition to
- 11:01the social networking platform elements of these websites, we
- 11:04also had to sort of look around and say, have the hell else, are
- 11:07we going to grow these like, what are they sites?
- 11:09Like what? And I think one of the things
- 11:11that we realized early was that again, kind of back to That that
- 11:17we used to call it like the most beautiful business model because
- 11:19it was like, you know, content was low cost or free, so you
- 11:23didn't have to pay for Content, you had, you got free traffic,
- 11:27and you have free monetization, right?
- 11:29So it was like, the really the most beautiful business ever,
- 11:32but so, but Larry and Joe, and Larry was Larry was formerly.
- 11:36I see Joe was, at Myspace with Rich and Steve.
- 11:39A kid was actually ahoo. And so we have that sort of DNA
- 11:43the mix and those guys realized that We needed a Content
- 11:47strategy. And so, we then sort of quickly
- 11:51realized, oh, actually, we need to really any, how is it was an
- 11:54easy one because it was multi category, and there was lots of
- 11:58how-to content that we could think of creating, but if we
- 12:02were just sitting around saying, oh well, how about this, you
- 12:04know, how to, you know, how to do a podcast or how to do
- 12:06whatever like that's not going to scale.
- 12:08So we had to really figure out how it was going to scale.
- 12:11And what we ultimately created was will become to man Studios.
- 12:16Has, which was a platform for being a priest called pursuers
- 12:20right writers to create, you know, articles.
- 12:25And so that's kind of thousand high level how it started and
- 12:28then got it to the science of it and the math of it, which was
- 12:31well, instead of just having his open platform and having people
- 12:35write anything, why don't we suggest what they write based on
- 12:39the expected payback, and the math of the article.
- 12:43So, we could say, okay, we know how to You know, how to change a
- 12:47tire. We know, is that that article or
- 12:51we know we did, we did some, our algorithms would sort of, you
- 12:54know, predict that article could be, could generate a hundred
- 12:56million dollars or a hundred dollars Revenue in 18 months,
- 13:00right? Because of the because of the PC
- 13:04rates, and because of the traffic that we were, we were
- 13:06get it. And so we could, we could
- 13:08basically reverse engineer a business model, that was fairly
- 13:11visible in terms of dollars in and done dollars out and the
- 13:15vast vast majority of Of traffic is coming from Google.
- 13:18All right, vast vast, majority 90.
- 13:21Yes, yes. And and basically, like, what
- 13:24the genius of eHow was figuring out, is that a?
- 13:26There's a huge amount of people online that are just searching
- 13:29for how to do stuff. Just just at any given day,
- 13:32people are flocking to search engines, Google specifically say
- 13:36like, oh, how do I change my tire?
- 13:38How do I make a flower bed in my backyard?
- 13:40How do I write start a podcast? And so what, see, how basically
- 13:44did is like, figure out that Says, the types of things that
- 13:47people are searching for and contract out, essentially, two
- 13:50people to write these articles. That's right.
- 13:54Yes. Right, because we did, we wanted
- 13:55to have, we wanted to be a platform for Content creators.
- 13:58We didn't necessarily want to have, you know, Reams and reams
- 14:03of people on our staff writing content, right?
- 14:05And so, okay, so this is where this is where I come into the
- 14:07mix because because it sounds been waiting for this.
- 14:10By the way, Tom has been waiting to tell this story about.
- 14:12Yeah I'm ready to company made. I don't see how.
- 14:15Yeah I'm going to come clean about My history.
- 14:17My first paid gig as a writer because I was living in LA and I
- 14:20had no job at effort certain period of time and I needed
- 14:22money and the thing I think I came across it on Craigslist was
- 14:26like, write articles to make money and, you know, it was
- 14:29through demand Studios and you go to this website.
- 14:32And it basically tells you search around for things that
- 14:34you are an expert on and claim an article and will pay you 15
- 14:38bucks in article. So you can, you know, let's say
- 14:41I was a, you know, a gardening expert and I would see an
- 14:44article about like, oh, how to build a Our bed in my backyard.
- 14:48I would say, oh well, I claim that article and then I write it
- 14:51up and then I press send and I it gets taken up by an editor
- 14:56and I think an editor is also like a paid part of this.
- 14:59I'm gonna get paid like ten trucks.
- 15:00That's right to approve it essentially and then and then it
- 15:03goes online and I collect and the thing that I found out about
- 15:07eHow and I think, you know what helped you guys scale but also
- 15:10maybe what, you know, gave content Farms.
- 15:12A bad name is that the editing behind it was pretty thin.
- 15:16Right. I mean like it was definitely a
- 15:18pass-through sort of thing. People are not really
- 15:20incentivized to do a great job editing stuff.
- 15:23And what I found out was that there were a lot of like
- 15:27articles you know it's because of the way that the algorithm
- 15:30was written. You guys were trying to have as
- 15:32many different articles about similar subjects to like collect
- 15:35every single possible search term.
- 15:37And so I would find that there would be basically, you could
- 15:40rewrite the article. And so I would do a how-to like,
- 15:43how to convert. This was my thing.
- 15:44This is my racket would be like How to convert CDs to mp3s and
- 15:50then there would be an article how to convert my CDs to mp3s.
- 15:54And there was, How can I convert CDs to mp3s?
- 15:57And how can I convert tapes to mp3s?
- 15:59How to make use my computer to convert tapes MP3s?
- 16:02Basically, you guys were incentivized to collect as many
- 16:05different articles as possible, so that no matter what, if
- 16:07someone searches something it comes up at the top of Google.
- 16:10And so what I would need genius, right?
- 16:13Right, right. Yeah brother.
- 16:14Yeah basically it's just like masks on still wasn't.
- 16:17Yeah. Right.
- 16:18Right. Well boy, until until like that,
- 16:20the algorithms are smart enough to do it.
- 16:23I mean Tom's but basically functioning like sort of a
- 16:25little like, computer programming.
- 16:28You're just finding similar. Yeah, well, you know, I think
- 16:31you guys, I mean, tell me how you guys sort of you.
- 16:33This from the company I've never really actually talk to you
- 16:34about this but like, you know, how are you guys filter in the
- 16:37stuff out? Because I know that there was
- 16:39concerns about plagiarism. You didn't want people literally
- 16:41copying and pasting. Yeah, the same article because
- 16:43that would probably trigger some some problems but Yes, it seemed
- 16:47like you guys are too much of a problem with it, I mean, like,
- 16:49it was just like anything that, you know, gets better and better
- 16:54over time, right? So you launch these things, I
- 16:56mean we spent a lot of time thinking about it.
- 16:59Okay. Well how do we how do we scale
- 17:01the editorial? You know, we've got now we've
- 17:02got the Articles coming out, how do you scale the editing process
- 17:05and any but I have to say one of the things that we didn't
- 17:08really, you know, sort of spend a lot of it was spent that much
- 17:13time thinking about the similarity between the Articles
- 17:16per se say, because it was really much more top-down title
- 17:20driven, right? And as long as the article did a
- 17:24good job, right? Answering the question.
- 17:29We thought that that was sufficient, right?
- 17:31We never really I wish I could say we did we did but you know
- 17:35for even from Annie how like editorial standpoint I don't
- 17:39think we really appreciated that the algorithms, we're going to
- 17:43change the algorithms that you know, Google algorithm from
- 17:462000. I mean, I'd be interesting to
- 17:48kind of get the bachelor step but between like whatever was 97
- 17:53and 2008. I don't know.
- 17:55I don't know if it changed at all, but then you started
- 17:58seeing, you know, okay? And then they started cycling
- 18:00through and then and then I take, I think the for whatever
- 18:04reason whether it was our IPO. You know, we had article in
- 18:07wired, I don't know if Google really felt like it was a it was
- 18:11a bad user experience or if they just was it's like, they lie
- 18:14about you, or were you part of the category?
- 18:16Like how much did you know, present content farming?
- 18:20We wrote. So we then started just like
- 18:21just like everything you know like when you see we have some
- 18:23success then there's a lot of a lot of imitation.
- 18:26Well like about.com where do they?
- 18:29You put this like New York Times acquires about.com, right?
- 18:33Yes, yes. So what do you remember?
- 18:35What time period? That was just.
- 18:36Yeah, we almost actually, we almost did a deal with the New
- 18:38York Times you were going to do very big merger.
- 18:41Won't part with demand media. The New York Times Really I
- 18:44would fuck. Yeah, huh.
- 18:46Like how Hosted it get pretty close.
- 18:49You had already placed. Yeah, have price has deal.
- 18:52Negotiated and and then what killed it, I think the time it
- 18:56was just this. Yeah, I think the CEO of the New
- 18:59York Times was Janet. I kept her locked in, but at the
- 19:02time she just got cold feet. Last minute.
- 19:04Didn't want to do it. Whoo.
- 19:06So they would have been in charge or we were going to do.
- 19:09I mean I think we were going to Verge about and demand and then
- 19:12really have a kind of own the category.
- 19:15Oh, so you're Going to be sort of under them, but it about
- 19:18demand would have been. Yeah, we were going to be like
- 19:21creating your title. I was like, it was like our
- 19:28content was really magazine content, right?
- 19:31I mean, disposable it was, it was not g know, I don't offend
- 19:37any, you know, gardening journalist.
- 19:38But it was like gardening Home Improvement, you know, the kind
- 19:41of stuff that, you know, you could, you could time, you know,
- 19:44you could write the top, could write it, you know.
- 19:45And that. By the way, town would do a good
- 19:48job Rite Aid article. You know, maybe well here's the
- 19:51funny thing about that is that like I wrote you know, I would
- 19:55write I made a you know like a I would tell myself I'm going to
- 19:58do ten of these a day and if I do ten a day that's 150 bucks a
- 20:01day, right? If I do it, five days a week,
- 20:02but 750 dollars a week and I paid off my credit card doing
- 20:05that. And after a month of doing that,
- 20:08I think an editor. Finally kicked back, one of my
- 20:10articles that was like, you know, how to take a record
- 20:13player and convert it to mp3s and they're like, you can't just
- 20:15plug up. Turn table into a computer.
- 20:18And I was like, well, I don't really, like probably 40
- 20:22articles saying, do that. Yes.
- 20:25Quality could be a suspect. But but, you know, I think at
- 20:28its best. Sure.
- 20:29Right. It is someone who has an
- 20:30Enthusiast for the category. We do a good job.
- 20:32Yeah. And again this is early days of
- 20:34these types of platforms and I think you go into these thinking
- 20:36people are inherently good there you do the right thing right?
- 20:39And they're just want to share their knowledge.
- 20:41I mean that's really what it was about and we just thought well
- 20:43actually people want to share the knowledge we can pay that By
- 20:46the way, we're one of the only places like around, you know, if
- 20:50you go back to the Huffington Post, having to post was having
- 20:52people write for free, and then people are like, well, they're
- 20:55not paying it and we were like, why are people giving us our
- 20:57time? We're paying people like I don't
- 20:59understand like what that right? What's the negative slant?
- 21:02I'm like what we're doing right? I don't know.
- 21:04But what was I mean if you can like put yourself back in that
- 21:07are because I actually don't really remember specifically
- 21:08what was the chief criticism of these sites.
- 21:11I mean I guess quality. Maybe suspects but like whatever
- 21:13time? Yes I mean I think over time
- 21:16What you had was well, Google Addict started referring to his
- 21:19like thin content and it was like duplicative content.
- 21:22And so that then became one of the things that the algorithm
- 21:26really started directly targeting was that you don't
- 21:29want to have a site that, you know, ten articles on, you know
- 21:33your topic top like you're right they want one but by the way
- 21:36they didn't and again it was just it was a change of mindset
- 21:39because when you think about like engagement metrics in
- 21:42Google and search, like when you're searching for something,
- 21:44you want to answer, right? I don't necessarily want to read
- 21:48a 3 page article on end and the history of MP3s.
- 21:52Tell me how to convert it right. Right.
- 21:53We had that if you do want a true answer which Tom is saying
- 21:57sometimes it didn't always deliver but yeah.
- 22:00Correct. Right?
- 22:01Yes. I mean clearly you know now
- 22:04Google like provides these answers itself.
- 22:07It doesn't even let you go off-site.
- 22:09It's not even about we eventually go from okay.
- 22:11These are to correct. Yeah to like screw it even if
- 22:14you have a good high quality answer we don't even I want to
- 22:17let you. Yeah, do it.
- 22:18We're gonna do it ourselves. Yeah, which is, you know, the
- 22:22evolution with Google explain to me the day in the office is when
- 22:26Google changes there I'll go. Okay.
- 22:28Well, so, so, will the, the story arc is that Google
- 22:31because, you know, demand becomes a very successful public
- 22:34company were born in New York Times, right?
- 22:36Yeah, yeah, I want point at one point.
- 22:38Yeah. Yeah.
- 22:39That was a big headline for it. Yeah.
- 22:47And that was a big thing, but we work of help can be added.
- 22:50The market cap was like, close to two billion, you know?
- 22:52And I said was we're going like two months, maybe Google change
- 22:56the algorithm. And that unfortunately was is
- 22:59just hard for any company. Let alone public company to
- 23:02overcome when your way your cash flow, you know.
- 23:06And by the way, we were profitable, I meani how was a
- 23:08monster business at one point. I mean, I think we have one
- 23:11point was generated text. Uh, yeah, yeah, we paid you 10
- 23:14bucks but I think we probably made a couple hundred.
- 23:16And on the right those are, yeah, the the structure was
- 23:19good. Yeah.
- 23:20But it did tell him but obviously, it wasn't
- 23:22sustainable, you know? And, and so the, when when you
- 23:24have that kind of a hit as a public company, you know,
- 23:28there's no, unfortunately, not a lot, you can do a year.
- 23:29We we went public in 2011, and it happens like that your eye if
- 23:35you like, oh yeah, yeah, yeah. And yeah.
- 23:37And then what you just totally gonna get like, how much meat on
- 23:40top tell Eric it was a big deal. It was like a big deal.
- 23:43Yeah. No.
- 23:43It was the, you know, kind of banner l a tech company.
- 23:47And as it went public like, I'm saying, huge headlines about it
- 23:49being worth more than the York Times.
- 23:51It was like, the new model for Content, there was a lot of
- 23:53hand-wringing about like what it meant for the future of content.
- 23:56Obviously was all Jazz time, it's not like I was close to
- 23:59you, like pay attention to it, right?
- 24:01Yeah. I wasn't even covering it yet.
- 24:02And it was, you know, I started covering La Tech in 2012.
- 24:05And so I guess that was sort of post, you know, post Fiasco and
- 24:09as you guys were dealing with the Fallout from all of this
- 24:12stuff, but yeah. Did you have any signaling that
- 24:15Google was going to do? This I mean, did you guys are
- 24:17like a drum beat that like oh you know they're rejecting the
- 24:20algorithm and this is going to hurt all the content Farm sites.
- 24:23No. But interestingly what happened
- 24:25was the first algorithm change they made, we went up.
- 24:29Hmm. Like our traffic went it was a
- 24:32benefit to us for like two weeks, okay?
- 24:36For three weeks and then the hammer fell and that's when that
- 24:42that is we never really recovered from that.
- 24:45How much resentment is there? Within those companies toward
- 24:48toward Google because you know as I started covering Tech.
- 24:51I remember meeting Jason calacanis who I believe he had a
- 24:54company that was sort of in the sphere of content.
- 24:57Yeah. Yeah.
- 24:58Yeah. Mahalo.
- 24:59Yeah. Hollow.
- 25:00Yeah. Right.
- 25:00They had some kind of user generated content stuff that
- 25:03wasn't they? Yeah, they basically so.
- 25:06Yeah, Jason lost, Mahalo and then copy the try to copy demand
- 25:11try to cram prep of the content and then Lambda bad.
- 25:15You know I didn't I was like no this model.
- 25:16Crap. Yeah.
- 25:17And then whatever. But Chase knowledge, its knees
- 25:19could go ahead man. I mean is it Go does get hot or
- 25:23Advanced a? No I mean well the good thing
- 25:25about it, I mean I think the way we architected it was not, we
- 25:29have couple business lines in there, right?
- 25:31We had we had a big red domain registrar business.
- 25:35That was a profitable profitable business.
- 25:38We had some others other properties to that.
- 25:41We were building that were not dependent upon the contact form
- 25:45and they were more Head say, I thought to contribute the bill
- 25:48that we won comedy site called cracked.com the old crap.
- 25:52I remember when we bought the Branded and that was they were
- 25:55doing six posts a day and there was not a volume game from a
- 26:00Content, standpoint bouncy ruled.
- 26:01That was like, hi Folly. But again, kind of rear virtual
- 26:05writers room. It was very it was it was very
- 26:07soon as good stuff. I mean you guys were sort of
- 26:09that Innovative with like like funny or die and college humor
- 26:12and those kind of online humors out of the time.
- 26:13Yeah. So we had that site, that was
- 26:15really solid and we had Livestrong.com, which was also
- 26:18a. I think it just took good site
- 26:21which had and a companion app called The Daily plate, which
- 26:24literally calorie tracker app that require you, we bought a
- 26:27lot of these businesses, right Sonique, we were requiring.
- 26:30So I stand, that's what I spent the bulk of my time doing like
- 26:3340. I did Livestrong, get rocked by
- 26:35the whole doping Scandal where you guys.
- 26:36Yeah. And but that David issues with
- 26:39no, no. But there were issues with its
- 26:41attached. We didn't affect strong, but
- 26:42that happened while you owned it or yeah.
- 26:46But in a week, That business when fine even though the doping
- 26:48stuff. Yeah, because the business
- 26:50wasn't, it wasn't, you know, it wasn't Lance Armstrong got Kyle,
- 26:53it was really strong program and I remember there being stories
- 26:56about how, you know, Livestrong had to make very clear that it
- 26:59severed ties with Lance Armstrong that he's not
- 27:01affiliated with the business, right?
- 27:03Remember, if there was anything that specific time?
- 27:05I mean I don't I mean it romantic in my memory.
- 27:08Yeah, maybe maybe a little bit. We didn't have any and we didn't
- 27:11have a huge branded ad sales team at the time, I'm here.
- 27:13By the way, at the time, the people running branded ad sales
- 27:16who were I joined Bradford and are honored eenie, huh?
- 27:19So, yeah, Eric, maybe all the way.
- 27:21This was like, the All-Star team like, did digital media.
- 27:24I'm telling you that I had so many good people at this
- 27:27company. So does this company?
- 27:28Still trade is still exists? Or what else?
- 27:31I was. So I died.
- 27:31You're trying to get to the entrance.
- 27:32All right, we were hurt you to get over the thing.
- 27:34I like the real juice that I wanted to get about Google
- 27:37because I know people like Jason calacanis and maybe you as well
- 27:40sort of view this whole episode as an example of Google's, you
- 27:44know, uncheck global Our. Oh right, well, we're going to
- 27:48get to the core lucian's. I just want to get to the end of
- 27:50this story and then there's the only teams we can draw about it.
- 27:53Yeah, I'm fine. Yeah.
- 27:53So yeah, so demand went public. The park cap continued to slip.
- 27:57We then we ended up spinning off the domain business, which was
- 28:02called right side and that ended up being Acquired and then
- 28:05demand changed its name to Leaf Group which was remained, a
- 28:09public company, sort of did okay, not so great.
- 28:11And then they were doing all the right things try to, you know?
- 28:16Right size the Brand's, right, size, the businesses and sort of
- 28:20doing the things that out. And I'll go to about.com for
- 28:22cycle, which is no dot dash. Which is actually done
- 28:24exceptionally, well, under Neil vogel's leadership, but Neal we
- 28:29have the same business model and I think earlier, on maybe about
- 28:32said, you know what we're going to we're going to take down all
- 28:33this content and willing to like rebuild.
- 28:35Some of these Brands and put them into new categories and
- 28:38create take the best content. Like if you took the best, he
- 28:41how I think maybe had three or four hundred thousand articles
- 28:45right? If you took the best 30,000 and
- 28:47started a new how-to website. That would be a killer side.
- 28:50So I think what what about did is they took, you know, the home
- 28:53and garden stuff the and they started doing that and I think
- 28:56they did that sooner than we did as I'm remembered out at the
- 29:00math. And so that now is form the
- 29:03basis for dot dash, which is now a great, a great business.
- 29:06I mean, it's and they report numbers, it's hugely profitable,
- 29:10the big peace in the valley so tomb and was in the process of
- 29:13doing the same thing as Lief group.
- 29:15We had also acquired a Marketplace called Society6
- 29:18which was an artist Marketplace, we started doing some Commerce
- 29:20stuff and that whole business is now owned by The Washington
- 29:24Post. Hmm.
- 29:25And they run it, it's still? Yeah hmm.
- 29:28Yeah, I mean, I don't, I haven't seen I haven't really looked
- 29:30like a button sites. A long time.
- 29:32It sold for way less than it was once worth.
- 29:34And oh yeah, yeah, no. I mean, I think collectively
- 29:36that the both businesses were probably 67 are really dollars
- 29:40if I had to. Yeah, well, I mean maybe a half.
- 29:43Yeah. So I would obviously you know a
- 29:45big what? The first like theme here is
- 29:48just like companies building for like the big Tech Giants and how
- 29:53they can you were sort of like the early days of getting rocked
- 29:57by Google. Did you ever like go to Jonah
- 29:59Peretti and say hey this BuzzFeed idea building off like
- 30:02Facebook is a reckless. Like I've been there before it's
- 30:06wear when you w or Zynga or any of these Mafia will ya.
- 30:09When you wash like the Facebook version of this play out?
- 30:12I don't know. Did you ever send emails to be
- 30:14having like you're an idiot? We did.
- 30:16This already and it doesn't play out very well buckets.
- 30:19I mean, we all understood. I think we were the first ones
- 30:23to really bear the brunt of platform, dependency right?
- 30:27Like and this is now, everybody is at the mercy of the
- 30:30platform's, the platform's weren't as I mean, we sort of
- 30:35weave. It was like, this symbiotic
- 30:37relationship, right? We were growing.
- 30:39And they were, they were kind of benefiting.
- 30:40And, you know, when you look at it, you're like well, wait, why
- 30:43would Google ever do that they make so much money off of our
- 30:46Stuff you know like it's not economically in their best
- 30:49interest to do it. So it was a surprise Town.
- 30:51Answer your earlier question, we were not expecting it a change
- 30:54and yeah I mean I think we shared a lot of War Stories
- 30:58among all the people who are running these you know sites at
- 31:02the time and and you know, talking this was right.
- 31:04I mean it was a real show of Market power from from Google.
- 31:09They never really had to explain themselves.
- 31:11I mean they you know, they just made these jet over again it
- 31:15course at the time. Yeah, everybody.
- 31:16Incredibly pissed. We're all set.
- 31:18This is ridiculous. You know, in the benefit of
- 31:21hindsight like, you know, the platforms are trying to do what
- 31:25they need to do in order to, you know, maintain the qualities
- 31:28that they, you know, hold dear. So so I mean I can't, I wish I
- 31:32could say, you know, through those guys I want to go sue
- 31:34them. But yeah, they did what they
- 31:36did. And we had to react to what the
- 31:41market was giving us. And so we don't know when that
- 31:43I'll go change happened, we Did what we thought was.
- 31:46All right. I think we took the kite.
- 31:47I was okay. Well if that's not the way the
- 31:48markets going to work anymore, let's pull the content down.
- 31:51Let's try to rebuild. Let's just try to move forward
- 31:54but the big, the big question. Eric is really where does scale
- 31:57fit in media? This is really kind of the fun.
- 32:00I think one of the fundamental things that people need to
- 32:03understand and it's hard, right? It's hard to scales.
- 32:07Well, be you know what? How do you build something that
- 32:09actually can can can like scale? Like how big can one thing be?
- 32:15For you have to go enough that it drives traffic to itself.
- 32:18Or what's the importance? Well that maybe that's the think
- 32:20the question as investors, right?
- 32:22So from the capital standpoint from the money coming in
- 32:25standpoint, we want things that can scale investors are looking
- 32:28for businesses that that have, you know, unlimited growth
- 32:32potential, right? Like one of the early
- 32:33Investments we made at Three L's.
- 32:35Go puff, right? Go puff is quick.
- 32:38Commerce company plays in a market that is so big in the
- 32:41u.s., it can be this company cadby, it is becoming a very big
- 32:44business. But for media, how do you play
- 32:47it? You know, how do you do it if
- 32:49you're in news, right? Well, how big can the New York
- 32:51Times V will New York Times has to do have to buy things in
- 32:54sports? That's why they think about
- 32:55buying something like the athletic, right?
- 32:57Like there's always these periods and you just have to
- 33:00understand where you are in the cycles of aggregation and
- 33:03disaggregation. And we were just earlier this
- 33:06aggregation phase of digital media.
- 33:08I'm going to give voice to the sort of the journalistic or
- 33:11though the the position that I think reporters would have or
- 33:15Our companies are built that our product oriented and there are
- 33:18companies that are built that, see some sort of problem in the
- 33:20market and say, we're going to Salt in like where the business
- 33:23guys and we see there's like money to be made here and we'll
- 33:25go higher it, like the product people.
- 33:28And in a way the fact that this was such a torque towards where
- 33:32the business guys versus correct, what's a great product?
- 33:35That no matter what is going on in the world?
- 33:38There are customers for this and so then and so.
- 33:42So you can translate this even Beyond just like Media wrote
- 33:46technology company, dependence to say anytime you know you're
- 33:49building a company to solve sort of peculiarities of how sort of
- 33:54the business landscape set up your more vulnerable that if you
- 33:58build a company that sort of from first principles saying,
- 34:02what's the product where service is and people are people going
- 34:05to want your hat for a long time.
- 34:06Very much so. And the magic is when you get
- 34:08both of those things working together, that is the magic.
- 34:12And unfortunately, what happens if you know the aggregation
- 34:15Model is what you found is. You've bought a buzz, a bunch of
- 34:19businesses that were truly good and organic on their own but
- 34:23they just got to a certain place that they were going to really
- 34:24get much bigger. It was really hard for them to
- 34:26kind of think about how they were going to get much bigger
- 34:29like a cracked or something. Dress.
- 34:30A oh that's like a good product. But right.
- 34:33We've hit the sort of ceiling of what the audience.
- 34:36Exactly. Right.
- 34:36Or that's right. The scale thing is so
- 34:38interesting with media because it's very clear to me how demand
- 34:41approach that which was paying people like me a couple of Bucks
- 34:45to write articles. And if you do that in Mass, you
- 34:47can get enough articles that there is some sort of scale
- 34:49scale, like Advantage, you have a Workforce, a freelance work
- 34:52force. I remember having this exact
- 34:54conversation with Jonah at BuzzFeed like five years ago or
- 34:58so because they were questions about them at the time, after
- 35:00they had raised a bunch of money from NBC.
- 35:02And, and whatever is too like, how are you going to scale?
- 35:05BuzzFeed, you know, it can media, it's just intrinsically
- 35:08hard to do because it's not, it's a labor-intensive projects
- 35:11for most people and his line at the time I think was, you know,
- 35:14this is when Food was really trying to grow internationally
- 35:16and they were opening up, BuzzFeed Brazil and BuzzFeed UK
- 35:19and maybe some I don't Australia or something.
- 35:22And that was his, that was his approach is like if we can kind
- 35:25of spin off locations and we can just produce content there,
- 35:30that's some sort of a global scale.
- 35:31And they've since closed, almost all of those offices.
- 35:34I mean, business has taken a turn for the worse in many ways.
- 35:37So doc has gotten so low that it's do it.
- 35:41I feel like it's survived some of the market turbulence, a
- 35:43little bit just because It's a got to like 500 million market
- 35:47cap or something, right? I haven't looked at it.
- 35:49Yeah, yeah. Might be lower than well
- 35:52Enterprise Value. Yeah cash.
- 35:54Oh yeah, Enterprise, yeah, exactly.
- 35:56I want to get too Buzzy more specifically in a second but
- 35:58just like in this broader topic, do you think there is an
- 36:01approach for media to scale in a way that other tech companies
- 36:04can? I mean, is it foolhardy to
- 36:05expect it and by that, by that, you know, answer like is it a
- 36:09bad VC investment is Media like just not a great you know, fit
- 36:14for The Venture Capital. Yeah, that's really, it depends,
- 36:17I would say you. That's why you don't see a lot
- 36:19of Silicon Valley investors investing in media.
- 36:23It is hard. It's they do from time to time.
- 36:25And every once in awhile, they did, you know?
- 36:26Because sometimes there are things that do kind of break
- 36:29out, or their platforms, or, you know, things, you know, there
- 36:32are some things that can rise above the levels that they need
- 36:35to be for people to generate the returns they do.
- 36:38But it's hard. I mean, I look at and I think
- 36:40you guys both have hit on it, its product authenticity and the
- 36:43labor, it takes to create At a great media experience, and you
- 36:48can't just necessarily replicate.
- 36:50If you guys have a great podcast about business, you can't just
- 36:53say, hey, let's go to a podcast on gardening, you just like
- 36:56right is it doesn't really, it doesn't really flow so, but I
- 37:00think dot dash, I think there are a couple of companies like
- 37:03one of the the company that has I don't doesn't get a good ton
- 37:06of coverage of people. Never really talked about it but
- 37:08the winner. Okay.
- 37:09Of the, from the if you look at the media business from 20 2010,
- 37:1510 to 20 20. I guess that decade.
- 37:17Hmm I don't know. Tom who would you think is the
- 37:19winner and and media in that era?
- 37:23This is going to be some like some like lateral choice that
- 37:27I'm not going to come up with 20 10 to 20 knots.
- 37:29Are you? I'll give you another Hint.
- 37:30It was an l.a. company only company.
- 37:33I don't know Snapchat that immediate area Brandt internet
- 37:37brands which one is an interference and see that's a
- 37:40kind of long. Yeah you know once WebMD.
- 37:44No, but if Parts because this is Kevin.
- 37:47How is your health History Podcast?
- 37:50Yeah, I mean, it's it very big company.
- 37:53I mean, it's, I think it's that one by KKR.
- 37:55Okay. It's been recapitalize the
- 37:57number of times in the billions of dollars and like them J2 and
- 38:02I think dot dash are like the best of that the best media
- 38:05companies around. Sure J2, I'm more familiar with
- 38:09because they own a couple of sites of people have heard of
- 38:11like IGN, and they're always kind of in the mix for You know,
- 38:14their codes can like a stalking horse bitter when certain
- 38:16companies are going bankrupt II can't remember who they bought
- 38:19not lie. Think it was when they bought
- 38:20IGN. It was one of my favorite
- 38:22stories covering La Tech at the time, because J 2 is an online
- 38:25began as an online, fax company correct.
- 38:28And I think they probably still do that to a degree, but like if
- 38:32they sold it, I think, I think they just sold it.
- 38:35I feel like it's all that but like, you know, I remember if
- 38:37you ever watched 30 Rock, you know, there was a joke about how
- 38:40NBC was like a subsidiary of The sheinhardt Wig Company.
- 38:44I was thought it was funny that IGN was a subsidiary of an
- 38:46online fax company, like the biggest gaming site, it just
- 38:49happens, right? Like your stubbornness.
- 38:51Yeah, like a random facts of insurance company.
- 38:54That's about it. So as internet brands so WebMD,
- 38:56well, that's obviously, you know, like remains like it's of
- 38:59a certain of a different era. It's like probably unlikely
- 39:02e.com are right, but remains like a hugely visited site.
- 39:07Well, if there are businesses that have done well, they
- 39:09continue to do well, driving organic traffic from Google, you
- 39:13know. And now Rightly.
- 39:14So they're probably just not talking about it that loudly,
- 39:16right? Because why would that?
- 39:18So, what do you think about BuzzFeed then?
- 39:20I mean, you see them going public is obviously hasn't gone
- 39:23to well in terms of their share price.
- 39:25I mean, what happens, I looked it up like, it's 590 something
- 39:29market cap, it seems like yeah, the Enterprise Value is like,
- 39:33440 is thereabouts. Yeah, and I think that's on
- 39:38Revenue, Eric, and as we get that for you, but pretty
- 39:40significant Revenue, right? It's like, right.
- 39:43The multiples are under Yeah, I mean I think there are real
- 39:46questions about whether growth continues, you know.
- 39:50Yeah. And I think you look at a lot of
- 39:51these companies and I don't know the ins and outs of were
- 39:54BuzzFeed businesses today, I'm guessing they've got a pretty
- 39:57good sized production business. That's like a fee-for-service,
- 40:00they probably got, you know, still a decent sized media
- 40:03business. I just I honestly don't really
- 40:06and again as I told you guys, I've been out of the out of the
- 40:08game, you know, for the last whatever 56 years.
- 40:11So I mean, I think they've done is, you know, But as well as
- 40:14they can. I mean, I don't know what else
- 40:16they could have done, you know, and I think about some other
- 40:19successful Investments like bar stool, which is a really
- 40:23successful very successful Venture investment for the choni
- 40:26group. But you know, they figured out.
- 40:28Okay. Well, they had an angle, they
- 40:31then figured out. Well, there's a, there's online
- 40:32betting in Commerce, that worked really well.
- 40:36And I just feels like the best way to play media is if you can,
- 40:39if you're in something, if you can invest in something in the
- 40:42sort of, you know, tens of millions of dollars.
- 40:44Dollars and sell it in the load of medium sized, hundreds of
- 40:48millions of dollars. Like there are still
- 40:50opportunities to be able to do that.
- 40:52But to think about the next Billion Dollar Plus Media
- 40:56Company. It's really hard to I don't I
- 40:59don't know what the formula is for it.
- 41:00I just I don't know. I don't see it and obviously
- 41:02BuzzFeed you know with whatever how big they are 700 million
- 41:06Revenue I mean or whatever the numbers they're still not third
- 41:09half third you know 400 million Enterprise Value, right?
- 41:12So you know you'd what you would have Of to bed a bed of BuzzFeed
- 41:15investor, if you invested at 40 million Priam and then an even
- 41:18something like the New York Times, I mean, you're seeing a
- 41:20lot of their growth come from like the puzzle games and there
- 41:25is sort of an argument that, you know, some of the upside there
- 41:27is just so, well, we'll get more into games and lesson 2.
- 41:31Well, I thought. Yeah, what was really revealing
- 41:33with the times two is they had this goal of getting to 10
- 41:36million subscriptions and then when they seemed like they were
- 41:40slowing down, it wasn't like in the realm of possibility, the
- 41:43next couple of years, they Wire the athletic and something like,
- 41:46hey, we reach 10 million and it's like, well, yeah, you did
- 41:48what you had to buy those subscriptions to get there.
- 41:50Yeah. But but they've done like the
- 41:52New York Times did a great job with their product.
- 41:54I think the product remains, you know top-notch.
- 41:56Oh totally, you know the daily their dog.
- 41:58Their you know did a good job in audio they're interactive
- 42:02formats or amazing. The video that they're producing
- 42:04is incredible. I'm going to just there, you
- 42:07know, it's a high quality product I mean they've done a
- 42:10good job, every time you probably remember that day they
- 42:12were struggling part of it. The reason like demand was worth
- 42:16more than New York Times. At one point it was because
- 42:17people were just worried about the demise of print, right?
- 42:20And so so that that point, there were probably 70% print, maybe
- 42:2430 percent digital, maybe that 80/20, right, the newer drives
- 42:27is worth seven. Seven point three billion
- 42:30dollars. It is it still a tiny business
- 42:33in the scale of it's like, you know, the most prestigious media
- 42:37brand in the world and compared to the technology company.
- 42:41It's still. Yeah, I knee.
- 42:43But you That's why I think it's sort of indicative of you know
- 42:47like great product is probably going to grow it.
- 42:49Whatever the market rate grows, you know?
- 42:51I mean that's that that I don't know what their Top Line growth
- 42:54is you have to probably in that I'm guessing in the 10 to 15%.
- 42:58I don't even know if it's that high but right there's also
- 43:01companies like Reddit I mean, is we do we think of read it as a
- 43:04media Cup, right? Right it right.
- 43:05It's like oh we don't have to pay people at all to produce our
- 43:08content. I mean, it is amazing.
- 43:10These moderators, spend so much time doing work for, right?
- 43:14Edit and when there is yeah, you can see it so much as like the
- 43:18game is, can you figure out a way to make a bunch of content
- 43:21while paying as little as possible for labor and still
- 43:24getting the best possible content?
- 43:28Yeah. Yeah, I mean, and then of
- 43:30course, you've got Facebook, right?
- 43:32So, right. Which it turns out.
- 43:34It also is a platform company just that platform happened to
- 43:37be apple and when they change their their rules and
- 43:39regulations right. There you go.
- 43:41Yes platforms, do you want it with the last?
- 43:44Minutes here. Do you want to tell us a little
- 43:45bit about 3L and sort of what you guys are approaching their
- 43:48mean, you mentioned. Yeah, puff you guys were fairly
- 43:50early on there, which I'm sure has turned out nicely so far,
- 43:53but you know what else is kind of in the 3L portfolio and
- 43:57thesis. I mean we've been, you know,
- 43:59early growth. Investors were investing ten to
- 44:02twenty five million dollars into, you know, businesses that
- 44:05are generally between 5 and 50 million in Revenue.
- 44:08So we're not really in the Venture business.
- 44:09We're really in the early growth.
- 44:12It's kind of what we do and I think, We've done really well,
- 44:14is find the right combination of things.
- 44:17We've sort of touched on on his podcast, which is, you know,
- 44:20great, teens, big markets, disruptive businesses and ones
- 44:26where we really have a good understanding of the underlying
- 44:29profitability in the unit economics of those companies.
- 44:31So we can try to project and, you know, build our models to
- 44:36suggest when they're going to get to cash flow Breakeven.
- 44:38And then profitability, how do you do that model and go puff?
- 44:41I mean people you know, it feels like we're on.
- 44:44Another cycle of on-demand will never make money.
- 44:48Yeah, I'm like fatigue diet because we sort of watch that
- 44:51with Ubers and or dashes and whether, you know, yeah, those
- 44:55are big companies, I don't know. How do you do that with a
- 44:57doordash? I mean, with a go puff.
- 44:59Well, first of all, when we invested in Cope of, it was
- 45:01profitable in Philadelphia, it was generating ebitda.
- 45:05And we, there were, there's the Nuance that now, the market
- 45:09really appreciates, but didn't for a number of years because go
- 45:12puff is a, it's a filly company. So, you have to like really do
- 45:16some research to find out when the first article was written
- 45:18about this business, but by then, they had probably already
- 45:21raised a couple hundred million dollars.
- 45:22They never publicized around, they didn't talk about the
- 45:25business. It's fascinating looking back at
- 45:28early. Go puff coverage because it's
- 45:29mostly articles in, like the Philly Enquirer and like the
- 45:32Philadelphia weekly, you know, very much positioning it as this
- 45:36leg. Hey, a couple of bro, started a
- 45:38thing where you can get hookah delivery.
- 45:39Yeah, I mean, like, if you're making money, guys, you know,
- 45:41the best strategies make money quietly.
- 45:43I mean, So silly not really is you know, that's what you want
- 45:47to be. Without any wasn't rejection
- 45:50with go puff by the way, to kind of tell them like.
- 45:52Yeah, you guys are building this thing, it's nice.
- 45:53But don't go out there and like, get the Splashy TechCrunch
- 45:57information. They they were when we made our
- 46:00investment, they've had already gotten that religion, so and so
- 46:04we didn't even announce it newer today.
- 46:06And, and but the beauty of that model is, you know, it's they
- 46:09are the inventory provider of, so they're making money on the
- 46:11wholesale retail spread. So it's like a 7-Eleven In store
- 46:14except that the store comes to you, right?
- 46:17And so we've got, you know, it's just a better, it's a better
- 46:20operating model. They can make money on
- 46:22Advertising which they're doing now.
- 46:25And you know, now they're Market continues to expand because once
- 46:28you've got this footprint, you can start to add some of your
- 46:31own products. They launched their own, you
- 46:32know, their own white label set of products called basically,
- 46:36they've acquired, you know, coffee businesses.
- 46:39So now they can bring you coffee that they're that, they're
- 46:41supplying so and not business. All about delivery efficiency
- 46:45and orders delivered per hour and when you have a
- 46:48point-to-multipoint distribution system, it's way better than
- 46:52something like doordash, which is pick up one place, go to
- 46:55another place, pick up, go to another place.
- 46:57So would the way we look at the economics are far superior to
- 47:00what do ashes doing. And that's why we think go puff
- 47:04is going to be just a really big company, but we do that with all
- 47:07of her, you know. And I mean, we try to find that
- 47:10combination of things with all of our investments.
- 47:12Whether it's, you know, so go Powe for chow or Roman or Daily
- 47:17Harvest or, you know, now it fun to businesses like, you know, in
- 47:22code or dealer policy, different markets, you know, some of them
- 47:25are Ensure text of a delivery summer Logistics, summer
- 47:28Telehealth, how big is fun, 2, fun 2 is going to be probably
- 47:32between four and five hundred. We're still investing it will
- 47:34already investing out of fun too but we're still, we should be
- 47:37wrapping that up but in the March cool.
- 47:39So, any any any other companies you want to bring up to us?
- 47:42You guys doing anything in a web.
- 47:44In crypto, we're spending some time.
- 47:46Thinking about how web three crypto are going to influence
- 47:51the industries of which were investing.
- 47:53So, I mean, the short answer is, you know, know, I think we're
- 47:56making some personal Investments and in different funds and
- 47:58companies and things like that, but nothing nothing at the fund
- 48:01level yet. But we've had some interns,
- 48:05we've had some, you know, some of the team has been spending
- 48:08time. Try to understand it.
- 48:10Like we looked at one thing that was sort of in the crypto I
- 48:13erase paste. Which I thought was pretty
- 48:14interesting but obviously you know you would have loved to
- 48:17invested in coinbase you know way that one, right?
- 48:21So things like that and yeah board platforms, are you doing
- 48:23anything just with sort of the market being all over the place?
- 48:27Did you pause investing at all? Or have you just continue to
- 48:30invest or what sort of your approach?
- 48:32But by the way, I'm going to put one more fine, final point on
- 48:34the demand meetings or so, or so, by the way, Richard
- 48:37rosenblatt, and inside his sound, is the CEO of a company
- 48:40called autograph, which is a pretty high-profile business in.
- 48:43The Nft Marketplace since the one with Tom Burke.
- 48:46Tom, Brady so good for those guys.
- 48:48Do you own any of these? Not directly no through a fun
- 48:53and I do, but yeah, correctly. Okay, now, you invested in a
- 48:56fund do, is just gonna buy a bunch of and I've asked to do,
- 48:59they create a crypto fund, a fund that's been investing and
- 49:02fund managers friend. So, yeah.
- 49:04Yeah, indirectly. But because, you know who's
- 49:06going to pick, you know, the best ape.
- 49:08I don't know how to do that, that's not mine.
- 49:11Yeah, so, but no, Eric took some terms in was so, I think it's a
- 49:14very, very in a very, very healthy part of the market right
- 49:17now. I think there's been a lot of
- 49:19things got pulled from. Forward last year, the last
- 49:21quarter of the fourth quarter of last year was just massive Pace,
- 49:26like the the investment paste, the timeline that you had to
- 49:29make decisions. Everything got accelerated and I
- 49:32feel like there's definitely been a little bit of a pause,
- 49:34you know. I don't know what the numbers
- 49:35will show in terms of like dollars invested in the quarter
- 49:37Etc. But at least for us it feels
- 49:39like the it's a it's a bit more normalized.
- 49:43We're having a little bit more time to look at and evaluate
- 49:46companies and that we do know it's been looking at Really
- 49:50interesting. Interesting businesses and I do
- 49:51think the video like the pricing is adjusting to.
- 49:54I mean it's usually a little bit slower to adjust the private
- 49:57markets it but it's something that we've always got to be
- 50:00mindful of when you're making an investment.
- 50:02And one of the things that we usually do in our Android and
- 50:04processes. Just look at the five-year
- 50:05historical trading average for multiples and so you can really
- 50:09can look at within cycle. Okay, well, you know, suffer
- 50:11companies, use to try to 10 other 20.
- 50:14Now the back down to 12. I mean, so, you know, if you if
- 50:18you kept that sort of some Rippling in terms of pricing it
- 50:22so we'll gosh. Okay, we know the markets at 20
- 50:24but if we pay 20 and and the you know, what's the multiples
- 50:26collapse? You could you can get killed
- 50:28right or takes. It's very hard for companies to
- 50:31go through that multiple compression.
- 50:32You gotta grow 100% for a couple of years.
- 50:34Right. You're right.
- 50:35Gotta play with red. So I know it's just feels like
- 50:38it's a good time and we've bet we can see.
- 50:40It's really interesting companies and, and it's nice to
- 50:42have such a strong. A folio, vitarka is so when
- 50:46starting a A media business. Should they stay away from you
- 50:53know, they should stay with Friday.
- 50:54I know the guy I love talking about it.
- 50:57I mean the sort of love-hate relationship with the beauty
- 50:59business, I mean, I so wait. I don't want to discourage
- 51:03anybody from doing it. I mean you can do well you guys
- 51:05can, you know, you guys can have a, you can have a good business
- 51:07and make money be profitable and I'm happy to share like platform
- 51:12were stories that mean, you know, you just don't you have to
- 51:15start with that the authenticity of like, He's Brands.
- 51:18And if you get the product side, right?
- 51:21And it just you get that product Market fit, right?
- 51:23Then they, you know, that's when you can start to figure out,
- 51:25okay, well, how do we can we engine, can we use, you know,
- 51:29some Capital to engineer thing to know?
- 51:32Do we want to buy a? If you guys have an audio
- 51:34business is their video business that maybe is a JC are
- 51:36complementary in, right? You can start building a
- 51:38building a business like that. Actually another business one of
- 51:42the more successful businesses, I think of the last decade to
- 51:45its skiff. I think, I think interesting,
- 51:47you've done a Really good job. Rifat is a smart product
- 51:52oriented. That's the, the travel focused
- 51:54Media Company. Yeah, they always put them in
- 51:56the same category. I used to have Eric and I both
- 51:59were at the information and I feel like they have groups
- 52:01frequently as like, you know, category-specific loyal.
- 52:05Subscriber base media differences.
- 52:08Is it private? Do you know it?
- 52:09It's you have a guest on private, how much it's worth.
- 52:13I don't know how much it's worth but all I could say is it's
- 52:15good, you know, like it's good. They've raised some money.
- 52:19I think people investors in the company will make money.
- 52:21What do you do, you know, do you know, do you think your view on
- 52:24what the information is worth? I haven't seen the numbers
- 52:26lately. I don't know.
- 52:28It's a good question. Yeah, they're never going to
- 52:30sell so it's, I don't know. It's hard to guys value to it.
- 52:34I mean, I see I feel like they've done well, I mean, I
- 52:37again, they built a good product that people like and they're
- 52:40growing a lot these days is a big investment from the top
- 52:43right on a. Yeah, on hiring yeah, borders.
- 52:45But see the problem is so but here's the challenge, here's
- 52:47what you don't want. See you don't want to see
- 52:49businesses that then raise too much money, right?
- 52:51Because if they raise, and this is the, this is the part of the
- 52:55challenge in this business is you grow a business, and then
- 52:58you feel like you have to raise money to keep growing it.
- 53:01But sometimes you do, if you obviously need the capital, but
- 53:03then you might raise too much and you might be at, too high, a
- 53:06price and then you're in a trap, right?
- 53:08Because now you're like, how do I justify this price?
- 53:11What do I do with the money? And then, of course, the next
- 53:14round. I mean, just look at, look at
- 53:15the look at the financing progression for BuzzFeed Right,
- 53:19we raise money at a billion five.
- 53:20Now we got to get, we got to think about how do we make this
- 53:22thing worth five billion, you know or vice?
- 53:25I mean oh yeah so these companies are now there are you
- 53:27get you get trapped because investors will give you the
- 53:31money but it's really hard to kind of.
- 53:33As I said like it's hard to figure out how to scale.
- 53:35Vice has been such a disaster writing, the it's complicated.
- 53:38I mean, they've clearly, you know, they actually own their
- 53:39own have six to seven hundred million in Revenue which that's
- 53:43without doing a, you know, a ton of Acquisitions like, BuzzFeed
- 53:45has to do their revenue comes from lightly different avenues
- 53:49like affiliate because they own, you know, a cable network.
- 53:53But the funny thing about Vice to Me, Maybe funny isn't the
- 53:56right word is that, you know, they raise money from tpg.
- 53:59So there's, you know, you want to talk about like you can raise
- 54:01the money. It's like, well there's a huge
- 54:03amount of caveats that you get raise money from a tpg and all
- 54:06the terms that they put in which is really come back to bite them
- 54:09now. I mean, there are cases from
- 54:11slicing tbg back in the game with Puck didn't Puck raise
- 54:13money from that, we do we know that yet they say, yeah, GPI is
- 54:17the, is the back. Sure of it but you know how much
- 54:20money have they floated to public maybe like less than 100
- 54:23million like, you know, with with Vice they were, you know,
- 54:26meeting valuations that like four and a half billion.
- 54:29I mean it was it was I'm saying it e and and they have all these
- 54:32like, you know, this essentially debt.
- 54:35I mean, it's Venture debt. Like they're gonna have to pay
- 54:37this off and they're not profitable, so it's really messy
- 54:40for them. It's hard.
- 54:41Yeah, again, it's because it's go back to.
- 54:43It's hard to scale, you know, branded media businesses.
- 54:46But but I Would, by the way. Hey, Eric.
- 54:48I would never, I never refer to companies as a disaster because
- 54:51I now heart fake. Yeah, I know how hard it is to
- 54:54build Rises and people work hard every day to try to make them
- 54:57better, right? And so you know, sometimes
- 55:00businesses don't go as well as you think, but I always you
- 55:02know, I was try to keep it positive and be like sure o
- 55:06entrepreneur and protein and yeah it's my job pointy.
- 55:10I do - yeah. Yeah.
- 55:12Yeah. Tweets though.
- 55:25You know, we're just, we're just optimizing for anger on Twitter.
- 55:28So, well, done there. I mean, do you think there are a
- 55:31lot of, like fake views out there or just sort of the idea
- 55:34that like, media companies that aren't in the subscription
- 55:36company subscription business? But are in still sort of the
- 55:40audience? Business.
- 55:42Like how? Now that you're away from it.
- 55:44Like, do you think they have a pretty clear?
- 55:46I'd send some of what their actual like engagement in an
- 55:51audience's? Or I don't know in your heart.
- 55:53You have a view of how real the internet is.
- 55:56Oh well. Like if Facebook, you know, who
- 56:00should be the expert in this can just like change overnight?
- 56:03Like the video, you know, how their views on like video
- 56:06consumption anything? I don't know.
- 56:07I'm just always paranoid that there are a lot of like Because
- 56:11even the biggest most established Media Company, some
- 56:14of their practices around views. I find super questionable.
- 56:19It's complete bullshit, right? So a ton of ore shipments of the
- 56:22audience size is? Yeah I know I yes there's a lot
- 56:26of crap that goes into whenever I see first of all if somebody
- 56:30comes in with a slide and show me how big their their
- 56:32audiences, I just I never really I don't even look at it right,
- 56:36show me how many email addresses you have and she'll be like time
- 56:40on site like jelly. The engagement metrics and
- 56:44that's how I'll I can sort of tell you how, you know, how real
- 56:48the audience is. Yeah, that's where the momentum
- 56:50is with the media. Now, like I work at, you know,
- 56:52Insider now which as, you know, for the longest time was the
- 56:55traffic website. You know, they were all about
- 56:57telling people how much, you know, page views, different
- 57:00articles had, and in the last few years, have switched over to
- 57:02subscription so they could prove actual value and have one
- 57:06stainable Revenue so that's, that's where yeah, I mean, yeah,
- 57:09I know, like, people have been that's why the New York, Tesla
- 57:11subscription dozens, right? So yeah.
- 57:13If you could build a subscriber base and serve them.
- 57:15Well, that's the best way of. I mean, I was really the only
- 57:19way I guess truly can build a Dependable lie business because
- 57:21otherwise you depend you are really and on Google's, when I
- 57:24Facebook and and you just, you know, worked for those clicks.
- 57:29Yeah. Right.
- 57:30All right, son. Well, thanks so much for doing
- 57:32this. And this has been very, like I
- 57:33said, very personally fulfilling to me.
- 57:35I feel like I've been able to go full circle from from working
- 57:39for you. I'm so glad you are ordering.
- 57:41You will, I was at the LA Business Journal to.
- 57:43Now, speaking to you, not as an equal, but as someone who can
- 57:47maybe speak the same language? Yeah, no.
- 57:49I well I think it was cathartic for me, too, so I enjoyed it
- 57:53great. It's always good to talk about
- 57:55demand. And by the way, I apologize to
- 57:57anyone out there who took my advice on converting records to
- 57:59CDs and play their phonograph directly to their computer.
- 58:02Apparently, you can't do that. Yeah.
- 58:04And there was a day by the way that I think you guys Adam and
- 58:07announced that you were getting rid of low quality content just
- 58:10in one Fell Swoop. Up the leading like 100,000
- 58:13articles or something. I think all of my work that I
- 58:15spent during the summer, 2009 is gone.
- 58:18There you go. Yeah, with washed away in that
- 58:20rightfully so, yeah. So well, when I also read
- 58:23underweight way back, so no one will ever find those articles.
- 58:26Okay, there we go. That's right.
- 58:27Yeah, that, well, we'll have to. All right, let's get trivia that
- 58:30away. Sean, thanks so much for
- 58:30joining. Thank you so much.
- 58:32Thanks, guys. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 58:46Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 58:49Goodbye.