Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Are the Newest Team Member
Transcript
- Lucas: So you just started a new job, you're six weeks in, and you discover that the person sitting next to you — same title, same responsibilities — is making fifteen percent more than you. What do you do? Do you say something now, or do you wait a year like everyone tells you to? Luna: That's a really specific scenario. Is that something you've seen happen, or are we talking hypotheticals? Lucas: It's real. I've coached a few friends through this exact situation. And the common advice — 'just wait, prove yourself, ask at your annual review' — is often wrong. It can cost you real money and set a precedent that you're okay with being underpaid. Luna: Okay, so what's the right approach? You can't just walk into your boss's office on day one and demand a raise. Lucas: Right, and that's the balance. The key is timing and leverage. You don't ask in the first month. But you also don't wait a full year. The smart window is usually between three and six months, after you've delivered something concrete. Luna: So it's not about time served, it's about what you've actually done in that time. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where most people go wrong. They think longevity equals leverage. But in a new role, your leverage is your trajectory. You're learning fast, you're contributing more every week, and you're already performing at a level that's above what they paid for. Luna: Can you give me an example of what that looks like in practice? Lucas: Sure. I had a friend who joined a fintech company as a product manager. She was hired at the low end of the band because she came from a different industry. By month four, she'd led a small feature launch that increased user retention by twelve percent. She documented everything — the emails, the metrics, the feedback from her manager. Luna: And then she asked for a raise based on that? Lucas: She did. She scheduled a check-in with her boss, not an ambush. She said, 'I've been here four months, here's what I've delivered, and I've noticed that the market rate for this role is about fifteen percent higher than what I'm making. I'd like to be adjusted to market.' Luna: And it worked? Lucas: It took a few weeks of back and forth, but yes. Her manager went to HR and got her a ten percent bump, with a commitment to revisit at the six-month mark. She didn't get the full fifteen, but she got a significant adjustment and a clear timeline. Luna: So the key was having those receipts. The concrete achievement made it a conversation about value, not just a complaint about pay. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the foundation. Without the proof, you're just another person asking for more money. With it, you're making a business case. Luna: I have a friend who did the opposite. She compared her salary to a colleague's and felt underpaid, but she hadn't delivered anything standout yet. She asked in month two and got shut down hard. It really hurt her confidence. Lucas: That's a common trap. And it's worth saying — you have to be careful about how you frame the comparison. You don't want to say, 'Dave makes more than me.' You want to say, 'Based on market data, a role like mine typically pays X.' Luna: So you're never comparing yourself to a specific person, even if that's what's driving you. Lucas: Right. You're comparing your value to the market. And that requires research. Sites like salary aggregators can give you a range, but the best data often comes from talking to people in the same industry or even your network. Luna: And if your research shows you're actually at market? Then what? Lucas: Then you wait, build your case, and plant the seed for a six-month review. But if you're truly below market, even as a new hire, you have a legitimate claim. The fact that you're new doesn't mean you should be underpaid for the work you're doing. Luna: You know, this all reminds me that a lot of career advice is really about learning to advocate for yourself. And that's something we care about on this show. If you've found these conversations helpful, and you've ever considered supporting what we do here, there's a simple way to do it. It's like buying us a coffee — just go to buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It keeps the show ad-free, and it's the smallest ask we can make. Lucas: Yeah, and honestly, every little bit helps us keep doing what we're doing. So if that feels right to you, we appreciate it. But let's get back to this — you mentioned the risk of getting shut down. How do you recover from that? Luna: I think the key is not to let it become a dead end. If you get a 'no', you ask for a timeline and a clear set of criteria. 'What would it take for us to revisit this in three months?' That turns a rejection into a roadmap. Lucas: That's a great point. A 'no' doesn't have to be the end of the conversation. It can be the beginning of a performance plan — for you, not a formal one, but a mutual understanding of what success looks like. Luna: And it also signals to your manager that you're ambitious and that you think about your career strategically. That's not a bad thing to communicate. Lucas: Absolutely. So let's outline the steps. First, give yourself a grace period — at least sixty days to learn the role and the culture. Second, document your wins, no matter how small. Third, research the market rate for your position, in your city and industry. Fourth, schedule a formal check-in, not a hallway conversation. And fifth, practice your pitch. Luna: What do you mean by practice your pitch? Like, out loud? Lucas: Yes, out loud. It sounds silly, but rehearsing a few key sentences makes you sound more confident and less nervous. You're not reading from a script, but you know your talking points cold. Luna: I like that. And what's the one thing someone should avoid at all costs? Lucas: Ultimatums. Never say, 'Give me a raise or I'm leaving.' Unless you're truly ready to walk, and you have another offer, that's a bluff that can backfire. Even if you get the money, you've poisoned the relationship. Luna: So it's about being firm but collaborative. You're asking for a conversation, not issuing a demand. Lucas: Exactly. And the best time to ask is when you've just delivered something significant, or when you're about to take on a new project. That's when your leverage is highest. Luna: Let's talk about the market data for a second. How do you find accurate numbers? A lot of sites are behind paywalls or have outdated data. Lucas: Good question. I always triangulate. I'll look at two or three salary sites, but I also talk to recruiters. Recruiters know what companies are actually paying, and they'll often share that if you have a relationship. And don't forget your own network — colleagues at other companies can give you a real-world check. Luna: So it's not just about one number — it's about a range. And then you position yourself within that range based on your experience and performance. Lucas: Right. And remember, you're not just asking for a salary bump. You can also negotiate other things — a signing bonus, more vacation, a title change, or a four-day work week. Sometimes those are easier for a manager to approve than a pure base salary increase. Luna: That's a smart angle. Especially if the budget for your role is fixed, but they have flexibility in other areas. Lucas: Exactly. So if you hit a wall on salary, pivot to other forms of compensation. It shows you're flexible and creative, which only strengthens your case. Luna: And what about the psychological side? A lot of people feel guilty just thinking about asking for more money, especially when they're new. Lucas: That's real. And I think it helps to reframe it. You're not asking for a favor. You're ensuring that you're being compensated fairly for the value you bring. That's not greedy — that's professional. Luna: And the company expects you to advocate for yourself, right? They're not going to just give you a raise because you're doing a good job. Lucas: Ha, if only. Raises are rarely proactive. They're reactive — to market changes, to you asking, to you leaving. So you have to be your own advocate. Luna: So, to sum up: wait a couple of months, document your wins, do your research, practice your pitch, and ask in a structured way. And if they say no, ask for a roadmap. Lucas: That's it. And the worst thing that happens is you're still in the job, with a better understanding of what your manager values. That's not a loss. Luna: I love that. It's a win either way. Thanks for breaking that down, Lucas. Lucas: Anytime. And if you're in this situation, remember — you're not alone, and you're not being unreasonable. You're just taking your career seriously.