Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Did Woody Allen Do It? (2021 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So, burto you and I just watched the Allen Versus Pharaoh documentary on HBO.
- 0:06First first initial reaction in one sentence, burto, what is it?
- 0:11Oh my fin God? Yeah? For me, it was yikes, big
- 0:16time. And so in this episode, we're going to talk about the documentary.
- 0:21Were also going to talk about wood Allen. We're going to talk about
- 0:23Dylan far Farrell. We're gonna talk about the evidence, and I'm going to
- 0:25speculate about what may or may not be wrong with Woody Allen. We're going
- 0:30to talk about abuse, and so if you're triggered by such things, I
- 0:34would listen with caution or not listen. This is the Psychology and Seattle Podcast.
- 0:40I'm your host, doctor Kirknda. I'm a therapist, I'm a professor.
- 0:43Who are you burto? My name is Umbert. I'm a pencil eraser,
- 0:47inspector. Yeah, so big time. Yikes there. I remember buying
- 0:53his story in the nineties. Did you remember do you remember when this came
- 0:56out? Let's start buy this. Even though I might have heard more about
- 1:00it at some point, I sort of only knew that he married her daughter,
- 1:07like the Sunni thing or whatever like that was sort of all I knew,
- 1:11but I must have heard more, and either I thought of who knows
- 1:15whatever, or I don't know, or I just forgot her, because when
- 1:19I was watching the documentary, I'm like, wait, what I honestly thought
- 1:25we were dealing with, Like how how unethical or how whatever all any number
- 1:30of adjectives of like that he married her nearly underaged daughter. You know,
- 1:36yeah, I remember hearing the details. And in the nineties it was you'd
- 1:42get information from the news or MTV or something, maybe the newspaper. And
- 1:49it's no surprise given how Goodwoody Ellen was with media, and how sort of
- 1:56avoidant Mia and Dylan, obviously Dylan as a child was with the media,
- 2:00and how beloved Woody Allen was back then, and how far it was before
- 2:07me too that the general gestalt that everyone had was Woody Allen was being framed
- 2:13by a wrathful ex girlfriend, Mia Pharaoh, who is manipulating her child Dylan.
- 2:21How how sad that was, and how impossible it was to imagine that
- 2:25Woody Allen would do those things. Oh and by the way, he's an
- 2:29excellent actor, right, and an excellent writer and an excellent manipulator of emotion.
- 2:35Yeah, exactly. So when he's sitting there in those press conferences,
- 2:38it's like you believe him. You're like, yeah, man, that's tough
- 2:40that you're going through this. So do you what percentage do you believe that
- 2:46he sexually abused Dylan faroh oh At the by the end of the thing,
- 2:52I'm like, yeah, zero doubt, like a hundred. All my math
- 2:58sorry, my mental math was okay. So on the on the left hand,
- 3:00I have a guy who absolutely did seduce and Mary or whatever married one
- 3:10of her adoptive daughters at her very young, young, young young age,
- 3:15just as she was of age, and with a lot of rumors circling it.
- 3:20If that part is undisputed, like he himself claimed that was the reason
- 3:23for the for the scorn or whatever. Right, So that parts so already
- 3:28we're entering in, like, well, your your morals or your your boundaries
- 3:32are certainly questionable. Okay, there's that judgment. Second, tons of movies,
- 3:38tons of movies exploring this exact question of an older man and a very
- 3:44young woman, right, Okay, now this is all circumstantial, right,
- 3:46But that's on the left hand. On the right hand, we have these
- 3:50very credible accounts from both the victim as an adult as a child, from
- 3:54investigative reporters, from independent, independent researchers, and account sorts of things from
- 4:00the mother consistently year after year from siblings, and what has the mother been
- 4:05up to? What is all her scandals? Was Oh, she does like
- 4:09crazy amounts of charity work around the world. And so yeah, once again
- 4:13like some of these like not admissible in a quarter a lot. Yeah sure
- 4:15for me, come on, get the f out. Yeah for me,
- 4:20I was fairly on board, But I still am holding out for this extremely
- 4:30unlikely scenario that something is a little different than the story that was laid out
- 4:35in the documentary, which we'll get into you later. But there's obviously a
- 4:43problem with denying the account from Dylan, because, as you said, Dylan
- 4:48has been consistent with the story from the beginning and said that it happened,
- 4:51And so why would anyone, including me, question that Dylan said? Of
- 4:57course, It's basically comes down between Woody Allen's story and Dylan Pharaoh's story and
- 5:02almost never that it does happen, But almost never does an adult an adult
- 5:08victim claiming that they were victimized lie about that it's it's if you know,
- 5:13ninety nine percent of the time, no one says anything because they know that
- 5:16they're going to be ostracized, particularly if it's someone like Woody Allen, and
- 5:20so she has every reason not to say something, and not a lot of
- 5:25reasons to say something, especially as an adult. It'd be one thing if
- 5:28she claimed that as a seven year old and then just wanted to put it
- 5:31behind her, which many victims will do. It's another thing for her as
- 5:35an adult to be like, no, no, I remember it happened,
- 5:39and that it just would be extremely unlikely that she would like but might she
- 5:44lie? Might she have fabricated memory? You know, it's it's possible.
- 5:47As a therapist who has been involved in these kinds of cases and knows the
- 5:54science, you know, I have to leave that as a possibility. It'd
- 5:58be nice if we had one hundred percent certainty with these things, but you
- 6:01know, we just don't, and that's that's part of the problem. But
- 6:04do I believe Dylan? Yeah, of course I don't. I don't Why
- 6:09would she lie about it now? She might be, But politically and also
- 6:15advocacy wise, I support Dylan and what her statement is and anyway, So
- 6:24watching the documentary for me, yeah, big time. Yikes. I feel
- 6:29so bad for Dylan Pharaoh and Mia Pharaoh for that matter, the little family
- 6:33and I. The documentary definitely lays out a story that is very compelling.
- 6:41If you haven't seen, it's on HBO, it's very it's pretty shure.
- 6:44It's it's just four hours, and for a documentary these days, that's pretty
- 6:47short, right. I think Tiger King was like ten hours or something,
- 6:50and so you know, it moves pretty quick. It's pretty Darry say,
- 6:55entertaining, because you know, it has to do with Woody Allen and all
- 6:59the people that they ran around with. And there's a lot of footage because
- 7:03Mia Pharaoh took a lot of videotape. She had a VHS home video camera,
- 7:09and there's just a lot of home footage Woody Allen without his glasses,
- 7:13hanging around at the pool and just these behind the scenes footage things. And
- 7:20I just have we just have to add yet another person another hero of mine
- 7:27from my childhood too, not only just someone that's problematic, but like a
- 7:33genuine monster. O. J. Simpson, Bill Cosby. I know people
- 7:38are gonna hate me for saying this, but Michael Jackson maybe, Okay,
- 7:41you know, let's just say the very least there's a chance that he was
- 7:45a monster. I know a lot of people don't think he did it.
- 7:46But Roman Polanski was not so much a hero of mine, but definitely respected
- 7:54him. But Bill Cosby, O J. Simpson, Woody Allen, I
- 7:59mean, these were if you had like the Mount Rushmore of eighties heroes of
- 8:03mine or entertainment heroes of our society, these people would be up there.
- 8:09Yeah, for sure. I mean Bill, Bill Cosby in from nineteen eighty
- 8:13three until nineteen ninety was arguably the most famous aside from Michael Jackson and Madonna
- 8:20maybe. And then you have Michael, and then you have Madonna. There's
- 8:24things about her. O J. Simpson just a huge, hugely loved person
- 8:28from like nineteen seventy five until nineteen eighty five, and Woody Allen for so
- 8:35many years just beloved. And it's just it's you start to wonder was it
- 8:43designed to promote that sort of peep person into the limelight, because we all
- 8:50understand that these sorts of individuals are rare. I mean, the things that
- 8:54Bill Cosby is accused of is extremely rare, right, and the behavior of
- 9:01Woody Allen is extremely rare. I mean, even people who abuse kids,
- 9:05they don't usually marry them. Yeah, so it's it's weird. I wonder
- 9:13if the rarity, if there's sort of a push pull with the rarity,
- 9:18as in, yes, in general, it's rare. But would more individuals
- 9:22be like that where they've given the opportunity because not everyone has the power that
- 9:28a bill caused me has no no bill. If you or I build someone
- 9:35that wouldn't, I'm just I'm just wondering, do we not get to see
- 9:39the full possibility of the percentages because most people don't have the kind of power
- 9:43that it takes to silence all these things, so they might be afraid to
- 9:48act on those instincts or on those impulses. I know, but it's arguable
- 9:54that fifty percent of the biggest stars, you know, the top ten stars
- 9:58of the eighties, fifty percent of them are abusers of a high degree.
- 10:05I mean Harvey Weinstein. Actually you could even add even though he was more
- 10:07behind the scenes beginning in the eighties, from moving into the nineties, these
- 10:13it's just a high prevalence. And and then so you wonder, well,
- 10:18if there if we understand this to be a rare condition, what could be
- 10:24a factor. Well, maybe if you are a psychopath or a sadist,
- 10:31or there's something kind of off about you, maybe you're attracted to these powerful
- 10:35positions, you're sort of obsessed. But I think it kind of so actually,
- 10:39let's sort of drill down on this. So for Bill Cosby, you
- 10:43could imagine, given his profile, that he would be highly driven to be
- 10:48charismatic and very charming as a way of trying to get his way, get
- 10:56get his victimization, because he had a very particular stick, you know,
- 11:01mo when it came to abusing people. He wanted them to be he wanted
- 11:05to pull them in. Because we all understand that Bill Cosby could have had
- 11:09sex with a lot of people who would be willing to have sex with him.
- 11:13Right, Maybe not everyone he wanted to have sex with, but a
- 11:16lot of people, particularly when he was younger. I mean, he would
- 11:18not be sex starved, right, So it wasn't that he wanted sex.
- 11:24He wanted to drug them and have them be unconscious and want them to wake
- 11:33up knowing, you know, because he didn't try to hide the fact that
- 11:35he knocked them out. He didn't say like, oh you you must have
- 11:39just kind of you know, it was so obvious as to what happened that
- 11:46he liked it. I think he also liked the I'm just speculating, but
- 11:50in the of courses are all allegations from dozens of women for thirty years that
- 11:58he you know, so I think for him it could be that he was
- 12:01actually attracted to the limelight because it gave him that that ability to do that
- 12:05sort of thing. You know. Maybe he also liked the limelight, but
- 12:09it was an added benefit for Michael Jackson. If he is guilty, if
- 12:15he didn't know any any number of those things, which of course none of
- 12:18us know because we weren't there, But if he did, then I think
- 12:22for him, his profile was one of immaturity and one of desperation, and
- 12:31one of feeling comfortable with young people. Dude, who is attachment and developmental
- 12:37issues? You know, if Michael Jackson were just like your cousin and wasn't
- 12:41famous, I'm pretty sure everyone would say something's up with that guy, right,
- 12:46there's just something, you know, because he was this giant star.
- 12:48You just say, well, all giant stars are, they're kind of eccentric.
- 12:52But he was massively abused and was noticeably immature and noticeably interested in childish
- 13:03things. And when we were in the eighties we just thought it was,
- 13:07well, Michael Jackson, is this is this wonderful you know, philanthropist of
- 13:15child welfare or something. But looking back, I think he actually just didn't
- 13:20like being an adult. I think he just really liked remaining a child,
- 13:26and for reasons related to as abuse, probably right. And I think that
- 13:31if he did do those things, I think that it was because he didn't
- 13:33feel comfortable with adults and he had a sex drive, and so he targeted
- 13:41in a psychopathic manner children. Was Michael Jackson. You know, when you
- 13:45look at the Bill Cosby allegations, it's a completely different profile and maybe a
- 13:48completely different disorder, maybe a completely different motivation. And then you look at
- 13:54someone like Harvey Weinstein, again totally different, more like Bill Cosby, someone
- 13:58who actually gets off on again. Harvey Weinstein could have had sex with a
- 14:03lot of people as very powerful person, but he liked forcing people to have
- 14:11sex with him. He wanted to some degree the coercion that was that was
- 14:16a part of it. And then you look at someone like Roland Polanski who
- 14:22seemed to genuinely just be interested in young people for sort of common pedophilic reasons.
- 14:30And then you look at someone like what are you all? So let's
- 14:31get into it about like why do you think so when we talk about these
- 14:35different types, well, actually, let me talk about the different types.
- 14:39I'm going to skipped down in my notes and so I'll mention this is probably
- 14:43related to different types because a Roanski doesn't deny it and actually claims, well,
- 14:50yeah, you might find it weird, but that person was into it.
- 14:54And it's a very different situation from this. What if you are to
- 14:58believe the Woody Allen, it's like, oh, not only are they lying
- 15:03there, they are a chronicler, turning the whole family and ruining those children
- 15:07by lying, and like it's crazy, like because you know, you could
- 15:11have imagined someone breaking down and saying, oh God, I did it.
- 15:16I have a problem. Can we please, I'll go to rehab or whatever,
- 15:18right instead, Nope, no, I'm going to take your kids away
- 15:22from you. And you're and you are you know, you are the problem
- 15:26and it's all lies and yeah, so the different and this is my typology.
- 15:33And there's been many proposed typologies of offenders of children sexual offenders of children.
- 15:41But this is my typology based on my minor expertise, given how many
- 15:50times listeners ask us to cover these topics, because this isn't a clinical expertise
- 15:56of mine. I don't work with these folks. I mean I have,
- 16:00but it's not a specialty by any means. So these are my type of
- 16:03This is my type of because the typologies that I've seen in the research,
- 16:06I'm like, I don't know if that really fits my understanding. But so
- 16:11Number one are pedophiles, people who are attracted to miners. These individuals can
- 16:15be psychopathic, meaning that they can lack empathy, or they could have empathies.
- 16:19There are plenty of pedophiles, people who are seemingly born or when their
- 16:26sexuality develops, they they're just oh my god, I'm attracted to kids,
- 16:30and plenty of them. Perhaps most of them actually have empathy and compassion and
- 16:36refrain from actually abusing children, and they might fantasize in their mind, or
- 16:44they might just try to shut down the whole sexuality altogether. But these are
- 16:48pedophiles. Now, you could be a pedophile and also be psychopathic or justify
- 16:55your actions. Maybe Roman Polanski is kind of in that group. So,
- 17:00and pedophiles can be attracted to any age. They tend to, you know,
- 17:04be attracted to a particularly so you know, every age group has its
- 17:08pedophile that's attracted to it. And second type is sadistic personality disorder and also
- 17:18including as a subset as sexually sadists. So these people are just generally sadistic
- 17:23and meaning that they get off on harming other people and children are just easy
- 17:29targets. And sexual harm is just one of the various ways that sadists will
- 17:33harm people. So people who are sadistic in general will generally harm lots of
- 17:40people's in of every age in various ways. Just whoever is an easy target,
- 17:45they'll they'll they'll just harm them because they get off on that. Whether
- 17:48it's poisoning someone or pushing someone downstairs or insulting someone online. They just they
- 17:56love it. It's a rare condition, extremely rare, but they exist,
- 18:00and we've studied him. And then a subset of this is people who actually
- 18:03are sexually sadistic, and this is something like Ted Bundy. Ted Bundy had
- 18:07a number of other labels. We could have applied to him. But he
- 18:11clearly got off sexually by raping and killing, and it wasn't just that well
- 18:19anyway. So so that's sadism. That's the second type, and there's a
- 18:25lot of people in that group, and the difference between sadists and pedophiles against
- 18:30sadists. Children are just easy targets for their harm and if they could harm
- 18:36anyone, they would, It wouldn't matter if it was children or not.
- 18:41The third type is what I'm calling them, the mimicking type. And this
- 18:45is actually perhaps the person you were abused by Berto. She was in all
- 18:49likelihood abused when she was younger. She was twelve, right, she abused
- 18:53you, right, And who knows, but she could have been a pedophile,
- 18:59she could have been a sadist, but it seems possible that she was
- 19:04abused and she just mimicked the abuse as a twelve year old towards you.
- 19:11These people might grow up to have regular sexual lives and not reoffend, they
- 19:19might not be sadistic. And yeah, so there's a fair amount of people.
- 19:25Usually these people are children. The mimickers are usually children. So someone
- 19:30abused their younger sibling and then went on to not abuse and not have an
- 19:34impulse to abuse anyone later in life than they're probably in this campus. This
- 19:37mimicry or sort of sexually abused reactivity type. Now, of course those people
- 19:47can mimic throughout their life at you know, jage of thirty, they can
- 19:49still quote unquote mimic what they were shown. The fourth type is sexually compulsive
- 19:56type. These people, it's sort of like OCD. They essentially just have
- 20:00an overwhelming urge to have sex or to touch other people in certain ways,
- 20:07maybe even to violate them. And I actually worked with someone like this in
- 20:12my past, and it was it was a thing to watch. It was
- 20:17scary the amount of time that he spent thinking about sexually as violating other people,
- 20:26like on a second by second basis, And as soon as he was
- 20:30given an opportunity, and I saw it happen, as soon as he was
- 20:33given a chance, as soon as someone wasn't eyes on him, within a
- 20:38second he was he was on his way to harming someone physically unbelievable. Yeah,
- 20:45it was. It was shocking to It was an obsession of his.
- 20:51It wasn't something I don't I don't think he had any control over because it
- 20:53was completely ruining his life. It was so out of control, it was
- 20:56so noticeable that everyone knew about it and prevented him for you know, he
- 21:02was shooting. Everything in his life was falling apart because of this, and
- 21:04you just wonder, like, that doesn't seem like you have any control over
- 21:08it, right, That's a pretty rare condition. And then the final one
- 21:14is what I'm calling the regressed type. And this is what if Michael Jackson
- 21:18did it again? Can you tell that the internet is a little divided about
- 21:25the Michael Jackson issue. If Woody Allen did it, then he would also,
- 21:30I think, be in this camp. They are people who basically only
- 21:37feel secure with younger people for various abuse reasons or attachment reasons. These people
- 21:42are often introverted and have a hard time relating or feeling comfortable with people their
- 21:48own age and so. And we see this all the time in normal terms,
- 21:53like you'll have a why worked When I worked with families, I would
- 21:57work with a lot of teens and kids, and you know, one in
- 22:00ten of the kids I worked with, a frequent report from the family and
- 22:06the school was that the kid liked hanging out with younger kids. That you
- 22:11had a ten year old that didn't get along with our the ten year olds
- 22:14they got along with seven year olds really well, and they would often feel
- 22:18kind of like a big brother to these seven year olds in the neighborhood.
- 22:22And we would observe and you know, they played appropriately, didn't harm anyone,
- 22:29but you could clearly see that the ten year old just felt kind of
- 22:33like a seven year old, or the thirteen year old felt like a ten
- 22:36year old. A thirteen year old girl when she hangs out with other thirteen
- 22:40year olds, they're talking about whatever thirteen year old teenagers think about. You
- 22:45know, either I don't know what Elisha well, I was gonna say.
- 22:51It was like I was going to say Hannah Montana, but that's like twenty
- 22:53years too late. But you know, stuff like that right like between stuff,
- 22:59and some thirteen year old girls are just like what like, you know,
- 23:02if you have a ten year old girl hanging out with thirteen year old
- 23:04girls, the ten year old girl won't be able to relate. Probably well,
- 23:07if you feel like a ten year old at the age of thirteen,
- 23:10then you're gonna play with them. And we could imagine that being exaggerated where
- 23:14a fifty six year old only feels comfortable hanging out with a seven year old
- 23:18or a fifteen year old. We could understand that as long as it's not
- 23:22inappropriate or sexual or harmful. We're like, okay, that's fine. In
- 23:26some respects. You just relate better to younger people, that's okay. But
- 23:32if you also have attachment needs and sexual needs, you're gonna feel only comfortable
- 23:41with that age group, and then you're going to make excuses because you need
- 23:45to get your knees met and you're going to harm other people. And I
- 23:48from the documentary, it just kind of looked like Woody Allen was that way.
- 23:52What do you think, bro? That's yeah, so I get that
- 23:55sent Look Ever, since I've known about Woody Allen since I was a kid,
- 24:00and I would actually I now wonder if it is, because you know
- 24:04how, sometimes when you've been abused, you both might sense certain things about
- 24:12people, or you might might be attracted to people you might be able to
- 24:15abuse. You know that. I don't. I don't know if that's a
- 24:18scientific fact, but that's sort of like informal wisdom, because I will say
- 24:26that from my own experience when I was younger, I definitely. I definitely
- 24:32could see certain predatory patterns to me, like finding out like you kind of
- 24:37look for people that you could predate on. And I, luckily never,
- 24:42you know, fully, ended up going down that path because and certainly not
- 24:47with kids or anything, but but I could sense that something about my neuro
- 24:53physiology or the way I perceive things must have been affected by by those experiences.
- 25:00Anyways, and then similarly, and this might just be random, but
- 25:03I often do get weird feelings about some people, like one of this person's
- 25:08is like safe to be around if you're younger. But anyways, with Woody
- 25:14Allen, from the moment I was a kid, I was always like that
- 25:18guys creepy. Really Yes, yes, Now it could just be because you
- 25:22know, when you're a kid and you see this older dude acting all weird
- 25:26and funny or old all weird, it's funny to some Maybe that's just odd,
- 25:32But for whatever reason, I never had a good feeling. Now,
- 25:34as I grew older and I watched some of his movies, I appreciated them.
- 25:37I'm like, Wow, these are really entertaining. And then I kind
- 25:40of grew into his mannerisms. I'm like, okay, because one of the
- 25:44things that really used to annoy me when I was young, probably in my
- 25:48teens. I was like, why does wood this Woody Allen character seems seems
- 25:52to have a lot of female attention. Why he seems like this weakling,
- 25:56like this soft spoken we like what And I was always so annoyed about this,
- 26:03like where girl, why is he getting attention? Well he wrote it
- 26:06into the script, no, I understand. But but even in the news,
- 26:08like you would say, like Miah Pharaoh is beautiful, right, like
- 26:11that's his ex wife, like what so um okay, So I would think
- 26:17about that all right, fast forward. I ended up loving his movies and
- 26:19thinking, okay, I see, I'll see through his mannerisms, think the
- 26:22guy's genius blah blah, okay, great, And then I heard this thing
- 26:26about the daughter and I at the time I remember thinking, uh, there
- 26:32was something funny about him after all, But that's about it. Now I'm
- 26:36watching this documentary, I'm like, oh yeah, now it's clearest day,
- 26:40Like the guy absolutely has these mannerisms and things. It's like he's still like
- 26:45a little kid in some ways, and and sadly, and then if this
- 26:52is all true, ends up manifesting as like he can connect emotionally better if
- 26:56they're younger, And I'm like, oh, wow, that is incredible.
- 27:02You've come full circle. Yeah, you've come back to realizing he's creepy.
- 27:06Yeah. Yeah, I wonder if you're picking up on something. You know,
- 27:10when people are abused, they often have a lightning rod or a good
- 27:15radar for that. They're both a lightning rod and they have a good radar,
- 27:19meaning that they detect it at least unconsciously, very easily or more easily.
- 27:25And they're also a tractor because, as you were talking about earlier,
- 27:32because of your abuse, it gave you some impulses to abuse other people,
- 27:40and you would detect that, Oh, that person is more easily victimized.
- 27:47You just you just had a sense and it was never conscious like, and
- 27:49never once in my life had a conversation in my head like ooh I could
- 27:53abuse that person. It's never like that. It was always simply implicit,
- 27:59like just gonna push my boundaries here. But in looking in retrospect, I'm
- 28:03like, oh, that's odd, right, how coincidental that then I go
- 28:07and find out this person has been abused, right, and that I've re
- 28:11traumatized them by me pushing boundaries, right yeah, and you didn't push boundaries
- 28:17with a different person, and you think that person has a way about them
- 28:21that isn't the result of being traumatized, and your radar was able to detect
- 28:29though you know subconsciously don't go there with that person, but do go there
- 28:33with that person? Right yeah? Yeah? Interesting. So my hypothesis,
- 28:38and this is this is as I was watching the documentary, I'm like,
- 28:42Okay, this is interesting because his presentation, at least the way the documentary
- 28:48lays it out, and knowing and I've known a lot about Woody Allen up
- 28:52until this point as well, so it's not like I'm just following the documentary,
- 28:56but and looking into it more, I developed the following hypothesis. This
- 29:00is a total guess because I haven't assessed him. I can't diagnose from afar.
- 29:07All I have in terms of data is from limited resources biased resources.
- 29:11So but you know, for the sake of education, I've seen this happen
- 29:18before, and I wonder if it's This would be the hypothesis I would pursue
- 29:22if if I was tasked by wood A. Yellen himself to figure out what
- 29:26was wrong with him, if there was something wrong with him. So the
- 29:30beginning of this obviously is something was wrong with his early childhood. Was it
- 29:33abuse? Was it neglect? Was it subtle? I suspect, given his
- 29:37own story about his own childhood, that it was subtle neglect emotionally and discounting
- 29:45of who he was so that he felt when he was young that he couldn't
- 29:49really depend on other people. That that would be my guess. And what's
- 29:55the I don't I'm not familiar with the story in a well, he doesn't.
- 30:03Without going into the details, I'll just say that I don't. I
- 30:06don't know. I can't really speculate about the particulars. I'm more sort of
- 30:11working my way back from what I see as an adult. And there's some
- 30:15things that he'll say that sort of fit that a little bit, where he'll
- 30:19depict his parents as being not super warm and a little frazzled. You know,
- 30:29so anyway, but who knows? So, But I would suspect that
- 30:34anyone who, if the allegations are true, did what he did, then
- 30:40there would have to be something going on in his early childhood. Okay,
- 30:42so results in him entering into adulthood avoiding relationships, mostly because he realizes that
- 30:55he can't trust people. He doesn't he doesn't feel good when he's around other
- 30:59people. You know, is an urge to attached to other people, but
- 31:03he finds that it's hard for him. And he has a lot of quote
- 31:08unquote friends, but he you know, he just does a really hard time
- 31:12trusting. When he met Mia, as is depicted in both Woody Allen's account
- 31:18and MIA's account, they hit it off and he said, I'm not ever
- 31:25going to be a husband. I'm going to live separate from you. We'll
- 31:27see each other, oh, true frequently. I'm not going to be involved
- 31:32with your children. You don't depend on me, you know that. And
- 31:37by the way that aspect I found it so fascinating. I was considering that
- 31:44his account is, oh, I love Dylan so much. I spend so
- 31:48much time with her. And then Dylan's account of the aspect she remembers about
- 31:52that where yeah, he was like right there, in fact, maybe too
- 31:55much there, But there was that part of it where it was like,
- 31:57I want nothing to do with children. I never want to raise children,
- 32:01right, I don't want to see a child. Yeah, now there's nothing
- 32:04wrong with that, but it is particular and It wasn't like he had a
- 32:07whole slew of other women that he was entertaining. It was I think it
- 32:13was just Mia. And he knew from the from the very beginning. It
- 32:19wasn't like he started dating me a Pharaoh and as he got into he's like,
- 32:23yeah, I don't know if I made up to be a stepdad,
- 32:27or yeah, I don't know if I can really marry you and be a
- 32:31You know, he knew from the beginning. So up is before Mia,
- 32:35he had already learned, I can't function in relationships. Now we have to
- 32:39assume that Woody Allen had all the normal attachment needs and all the normal desires
- 32:45of family and of closeness, but there was something about relationships from his early
- 32:51childhood that he just could not trust other people, and so that this was
- 32:54his way of managing. It's like, I want to have a relationship,
- 32:58I want to have a closeness, but it's too threatening, so I have
- 33:02to keep my distance. And yeah, and Mia Pharaoh, by the way,
- 33:07acts like a child. Now she's not childish, she's very maternal,
- 33:10but she has a very youthful vibe, right, you know her acting her
- 33:17the character she plays her in her. You know, that was one of
- 33:22the things I realized about this documentary was, Oh, the character that Mia
- 33:25plays often is the way she is in real life. She's she's quite meek,
- 33:30she's quite soft spoken and naive seeming, and well, we found out
- 33:37that she had this terrible bout with polio and that was traumatizing. Yeah,
- 33:44there's also something too. So on the one hand, of course admirable that
- 33:47someone would adopt so many children, But the flip side is that there is
- 33:52something to that, right, like, who is the person that wants to
- 33:54adopt so many children? Why? Yeah, well I could only expect,
- 34:00but she was a very maternal So she's both childish as a vibe and demeanor,
- 34:07which and very non threatening, like in terms of the way Mia seems
- 34:10to come across. There's just like zero threat from her, at least when
- 34:15you first meet her. Probably right, well, even in those recorded calls.
- 34:19Yeah, when she's one hundred percent aware if you believe everything of what
- 34:22Wood he is and what he's doing, and she's still nice, sounds conciliatory,
- 34:28very nice, and at the same time not only childish but also very
- 34:31maternal. You know, she is the all mother wants. She wants to
- 34:37save all the children. She wants to save the world. So she is
- 34:43a very attractive, a very attractive person to someone like Woody Allen. If
- 34:46I'm you know, my speculation is correct, that cannot trust people. If
- 34:52you can't trust me a pharaoh, you can't trust anybody but but I.
- 34:55But he can't trust people very well. So he kept me at a distance.
- 35:00And Mia eventually opened him up, though, and the family environment opened
- 35:06him up. And the way the family was it gave him this like safe
- 35:12haven from all of the lifetime of avoidance and pain I'm guessing, and he
- 35:17starts to realize, huh, babe, I can maybe I can trust other
- 35:22people. And then Dylan enters his life, and at first he's just like
- 35:29at arm's length, but then he starts to realize, huh, actually,
- 35:32if I allow myself to open up to Mia, and now I'm going to
- 35:37open up to this child, Wow, this actually feels really good. I
- 35:43didn't know that I liked being a father because you know, from the beginning,
- 35:45he's just like, don't depend on I can't. I can't be a
- 35:49father. I'm not gonna I'm not gonna be able. But then he and
- 35:52then from another interpretation, he knew he was a pedophile and he was trying
- 35:55to avoid But I don't I'm in my hypothesis. I don't think. I
- 36:00think what happened was he bonded with Dylan and felt a feeling he probably had
- 36:08never felt before, which was, you know, when you're around a child
- 36:14and it's your child and the child loves you back the way children do,
- 36:22like you are your everything, right when when it's your child, your child
- 36:27wants your attention, your child prefers everything you say. Your child when they
- 36:32fall down, they cry out for you. They you know, you have
- 36:37this effect on your child, which is good and that's the way it should
- 36:42be, and if it makes all the sense of the world, that that
- 36:44would be. And so I'm guessing that for Woody Allen, again my sort
- 36:47of running hypothesis is that he had that feeling and Dylan gave that closeness to
- 36:54Woody and for the first time in his life, he felt genuinely safe and
- 37:00close to someone, because it's hard to feel threatened by a seven year old
- 37:05or a five year old child that loves you. They're they're honest, they're
- 37:12caring, you know, they they they want to please you all the time.
- 37:16If you'll sit down and play legos or draw pictures with them, they'll
- 37:21just spend all the time. They won't text other people. They don't they
- 37:24don't want to, they don't want to leave. You know, if if
- 37:28you give them what they want, attention and and non complicated love, then
- 37:34you know they just bask in it and it feels good and they give it
- 37:37back to you. And physical too, you know, it's it's hard not
- 37:42to put hands on with kids. It's you know, they want to sit
- 37:45in your lap, or they want to bump up against you, or they
- 37:49literally want to hug and Like when I was in uh, one of my
- 37:54first jobs in this country, I worked at a daycare center for a summer
- 37:59really, and I had two classrooms. Yes, I had the five year
- 38:02olds and I had the one year olds. Now the one year olds.
- 38:06You know, it's funny when you're a teenager, you don't really know,
- 38:09especially I didn't grow up in a household with a whole bunch of kids,
- 38:14so like I was an only child in my household, so I didn't really
- 38:17know what a one year old is like whatever, So in my mind,
- 38:21the one year olds should be able to do a whole bunch of stuff.
- 38:24But it was it was actually surprising how much personality the different little one year
- 38:29old time. Yeah, but the five year olds, I would get in
- 38:31trouble because I would love like they wanted to be thrown around and so like
- 38:36I'd swing them by their arms, throw them up in the air. And
- 38:39this was pre tons of lawsuits, but it was just starting so that I
- 38:44remember them like, you can't do that. Their arms can fall out of
- 38:46their sockets, and I'm like, what are you talking about that. My
- 38:50uncle's used to do this all the time. It's like, I know,
- 38:52but you got lucky. Yeah, you know, I've talked about this before.
- 38:57I had a daycare in my house growing up. My mom had a
- 39:00daycare and they were all but mostly between the age of like two and five,
- 39:05and yeah, just the cutest things. And all they want to do
- 39:09is, you know, hang out. And when I treated kids as well,
- 39:14get down to the ground play they goes. They want to sit right
- 39:16up next to you, particularly if they have attachment injuries. And I'm guessing
- 39:22that for Woody Allen, this was extremely intoxicating in some functional ways that it
- 39:27was not only perhaps in the beginning good for Dylan to be close to another
- 39:32parent, but also for Woody, as with both with a lot of parents
- 39:37corrective, because it just feels good to hang out with a kid that doesn't
- 39:42harm you, doesn't want to reject you, doesn't doesn't want to you know,
- 39:45isn't thinking thoughts, doesn't sort of distracted by work or something. They're
- 39:51they're just they're there for you, and they're you're there for them, and
- 39:52it feels good. And I'm guessing in the beginning it was innocent and and
- 40:00a good thing, and then it was but it was but because Woody Allen
- 40:05and all of his attachment injuries. Again, this is complete speculation, which
- 40:08is almost zero data. The documentary helped me to form this, so there's
- 40:14sort of visual data or narrative data from from both Woody Allen and Mia Pharaoh
- 40:19end that contributes this. But eventually he's like, I am now for the
- 40:24first time, opening up a vulnerability in my heart that I've i learned to
- 40:30shut off a long time ago. And Mia Pharaoh, my girlfriend, gives
- 40:35me a little bit of this attachment need, but Dylan really gives me this
- 40:39attachment need. Now you'll hear me often talk about how clients will be sexually
- 40:45attracted to their therapists, and one of the you know, conceptualizations is that
- 40:51as an adult and with a lot of attachment injuries, a lot of relationship
- 40:55trauma, and you've you've been rejected, did and harmed, and you finally
- 41:00find someone, your therapist, who is actually carrying in a safe person,
- 41:05not only will your attachment needs come pouring out, like please love me,
- 41:09please listen to me, please give me safety, but also your sexual needs
- 41:13will come pouring out because your whole body is saying I want to be with
- 41:17this person whole, and I don't want to just kind of attached to this
- 41:22therapist. I want to be completely attached. And a part of that system
- 41:29of complete attachment involves your sexual urges. And it's also the first person that
- 41:37you feel safe with. And so when your sexuality wants to find someone that
- 41:42you feel safe with to express that with, then it'll come out as well.
- 41:45So it's possible that for Woody Allen, and I'm not making excuses for
- 41:49him, I just want to be clear that it's possible that for him,
- 41:54in that intoxicating attachment satisfaction for the first time in his life. It led
- 42:02down a road where and they kind of laid this out in the documentary where
- 42:07it was a lot of one on one time, and then it was a
- 42:10lot of cuddling time, and then it was a lot of maybe naked cuddling
- 42:17time, and then it was a lot of sexual time. And you could
- 42:22make the argument that in the beginning he knew he was headed in that direction.
- 42:25He was grooming the whole time. It's possible that happens, But another
- 42:30hypothesis is that he was just going one step, but he just wanted to
- 42:35meld with this other human being because it felt good to him. It felt
- 42:38like safe and intoxicating. And it wasn't purely sexual. It was more attachment
- 42:45based, and the sex was an asterisk on that desperation. Now, again,
- 42:52it's completely psychopathic to do such a thing to a child. It's wrong.
- 42:57It's victim to say anyone would know that. But when you're blinded by
- 43:00the possibility of getting somebody your attachment he's met, and you can feel safe,
- 43:04then you'll make justifications for that sort of thing. And then we also
- 43:07know it was a pattern for him because right so then he realizes, at
- 43:15some point, oh, I've gone too far with Dylan. And also I
- 43:19think Dylla started pulling away from him because she didn't like being all consumed.
- 43:23You know. She talked about how when he was arriving, she would dread
- 43:29it because the sexual abuse obviously, but also just the amount of coercion emotionally
- 43:37that he would perpetrate on her and pull her away. You know. It
- 43:40wasn't like he just said, hey, let's play, do you want to
- 43:43play? It was you are coming with me, and we are going to
- 43:45hang out for the next eighteen hours straight, staring into each other's eyes.
- 43:50And she didn't. She didn't like it, right, oh boy, And
- 43:52so he realized, oh, I can't. I can't depend on Dylan anymore.
- 44:00But I've now realized that I can find satisfaction attachment wise. Well,
- 44:07there's this other kid that seems kind of reclusive and seems lonely and naive because
- 44:17in the documentary they talked about how SUNI had never had a relationship and she
- 44:22was adopted later, like at the age of ten or something or you know
- 44:27something. And that's actually a specialty of mine. I've worked with a particularly
- 44:30Korean kids who were adopted later in life. And yeah, first you know,
- 44:36I'm Asian, so I got referred to you know, a lot of
- 44:38the Asian families or Asian adoptees, and there's a lot of Korean adoptees in
- 44:44Seattle and white families, and they often were adopted six months or later.
- 44:51And those kids who are adopted later have a much greater chance of having a
- 44:54massive attachment injury that can never be can never be healed. Essentially, their
- 45:00neurons developed during a critical time in an environment that actually solidified their brain for
- 45:10the most part in a way that makes it so that they don't really ever
- 45:15attach to people. And the description that they had with Sunni was actually really
- 45:20consistent with what I would see where they would they you know, Mia would
- 45:22talk about how she would really try to open, you know, because they
- 45:25she adopted lots of kids, but a lot of them were at birth or
- 45:30very young, and with Sunni, she was older and she would try to
- 45:34connect with Sunni and it just wouldn't work. You would hear Mia say that,
- 45:37and that it's the very common story that you'll hear, particularly from the
- 45:40main parent. It's often the mother. They'll just lament how because you know,
- 45:45to adopt a child you love human beings, you know you you don't,
- 45:51You're not ambivalent about humans. You love humans, you know, especially
- 45:53that many It's like, yeah, okay, yeah, you must really love
- 45:58being a parent to choose that several times and the complications that come with it,
- 46:05and to have a child that you're giving and giving and giving and giving,
- 46:08and like, years later, the child still seems indifferent to you.
- 46:14I wonder if SUNI has that, I wouldn't be surprised, And so Woody
- 46:17Allen starts kind of randomly looking around, like, well, who can I
- 46:24be close to? And then Sunnie comes along as this very easy target because
- 46:30she doesn't have support, she's not really connected to other people, is naive.
- 46:37She is safe maybe in the sense that she's not particularly demanding because she
- 46:44doesn't really care. She's just kind of good on her own kind of a
- 46:46thing. And also a lot of kids who are teenagers with these backgrounds will
- 46:52have to be quite rebellious and very much wanting to do self destructive things.
- 46:59And so he bonds with her and then realizes, oh, but she's older.
- 47:07So if I just wait a little bit of time, I can actually
- 47:12meld with this person, this developmentally younger person that doesn't have a lot of
- 47:21personality outside of me. You know, the way if I met a fellow
- 47:27fifty six year old person, you know, they have their own friends,
- 47:30they have their own issues, they have power, they can argue back at
- 47:35me. Dylan couldn't do that, and soon yee, I also can't do
- 47:39it. She's maybe she can do it a little bit more than Dylan can.
- 47:43But so this kind of is the best of both worlds because in his
- 47:47mind, he's like, well, she's almost an adult, or she is
- 47:51eighteen or somewhere around that age, and she has sort of development of a
- 47:57younger person, which is someone that I feel comfortable with, and so this
- 48:02is my person. You know. It's started with Mia opening him up and
- 48:07then Dylan opening him up further and really intoxicating him, and then soon he
- 48:10comes along and says, you know, the world is saying to him,
- 48:14look, this is a legal you know, although extremely taboo and problematic,
- 48:21it's something that he doesn't legally have to hide at that point, at least
- 48:27by the time that they made it public. Right. Yeah. The other
- 48:31aspect of this is he as was mentioned in the documentary, and I hadn't
- 48:37really thought about but clearly it's the case constant theme in a lot of his
- 48:42productions about these relationships between these older men and these younger women, and that
- 48:50seems to be something that he wanted to explore artistically constantly. Right And why?
- 48:55Right? Is it because because he wrote those scripts after Dylan and maybe
- 49:02during Sunni or after Sunni? Right? So is it some kind of wrestling
- 49:08with his own discourse of because in Manhattan, for example, he was although
- 49:17involved with a seventeen year old, which is just bizarre to think about a
- 49:22movie being made where the main character is having a sexual relationship with the child,
- 49:30and that they allowed that movie to get made. You know, it's
- 49:34just times are different, right, And he in reality because the narrative was
- 49:38that, well, I forget the gal, but someone said, yeah,
- 49:42that was about me or it was inspired by me. Right, it's a
- 49:45hemingway. I can't remember first name. But so it's yeah, it's a
- 49:52theme. So is it a Is it also a pedophilic attraction that he has
- 50:00that he was always born that way of being only attracted to children? Is
- 50:06it that it's that regressive type where because you know, when you watch Manhattan,
- 50:13you you clearly see that the way he wrote it. The younger,
- 50:17the woman, the girl, the child that he is in a relationship with,
- 50:22is naive and doesn't know the world the way that what Allen does and
- 50:30kind of depends on like Woody, Allen's almost like a dad to her,
- 50:32you know, like a mentor someone that knows how to navigate the world.
- 50:37And is that pedophilic or is that regressive in that it He just feels safer
- 50:45with someone that doesn't understand the world very well, and if he's with someone
- 50:51that understands the world really well, he just feels scared because he just doesn't
- 50:54trust that they're going to that they really love him and that they're really going
- 50:58to stay with him, right, you know? Or both. Anyway,
- 51:01let's take a break. When we get back, let's answer some questions from
- 51:06the listeners. What do you say on this topic? Burto? What do
- 51:07you say? Let's do it so Burto. Before we get into the questions,
- 51:16I want to give a shout out to some of our older what we're
- 51:22going to call it peace. It was the word it's old patron prizes,
- 51:27old patron, old patron who gave us that was that something? It was
- 51:30on It was a comment. As you see you don't like me reading comments
- 51:34on YouTube. Well it was a comment on YouTube. Okay, right,
- 51:37so last time we are debating what to call us, and so you said
- 51:39opps and it is the old patron prizes for today we are going back to
- 51:45November twenty fifteen. These five people have been patrons of the podcast for almost
- 51:52six years. We have Joan from Minneapolis. We have Tina that doesn't I
- 51:58don't know where Tina is from. We have Joanna from Burning bringing him Birmingham,
- 52:04bringing him great Bingham, Birmingham. But you know how they always sort
- 52:09of blend the syllables together, you know, like Worcester. And we have
- 52:15Cat from Copple, Texas. And we have Nick from Seattle. We met
- 52:22Nick at our live event. Do you remember we met Nick and Nick's Nick's
- 52:27mother I believe, and Nick was super great, really great person. So
- 52:34those are our opps for today, pas nice Okay, by the way,
- 52:38it was Nelson ninety nine was the commenter. All right. Well Nelson,
- 52:43you and Burto effectively named the OPPS segment. All right, So getting back
- 52:51to my notes here, So discord, I want to think did the discord
- 52:55So discord, if you don't know, and you can click the link below
- 52:58to join. Discord is a forum where all the fans will talk if when
- 53:04you join our particular server, we'll talk about various things, you know,
- 53:07mainly focused on the podcast. And we have a bunch of moderators who were
- 53:13calling the Discord guardians and Zach compiled. I asked Zach to ask the Discord
- 53:19people questions on the documentary and they submitted these questions, and thank you to
- 53:23the guardians, particularly Zach. Lola on Discord says how sketchy was the assessment
- 53:30with Dylan while determining that she was lying. The whole thing seemed corrupt.
- 53:37The file notes were destroyed. They actually said she was lying, which no
- 53:42one could ever be one hundred percent sure of, and then they weren't able
- 53:45to ever an then they weren't available ever after the report came out to explain
- 53:52why the notes were destroyed, Berto, what do you think? Yeah,
- 53:54okay, so my journey, by the way, I kept thinking that I
- 54:01was so convinced so early on on the on this documentary that that it was
- 54:06so clear that I kept thinking, no, no, this has got to
- 54:09be one of those documentaries where in the fourth episode. They it turns around
- 54:15and it's like everything we thought we knew was wrong. And I kept waiting.
- 54:19I'm like, how is this gonna pull back from this nose dive?
- 54:22And of course it never does. But in that part, I was like,
- 54:27Okay, that's that's it. I mean, this is ridiculous. They
- 54:30they Okay, they come out and they do a press briefing with the accused.
- 54:37Okay, number one, second with the accused, the accused victimizer right
- 54:43second, like the fact that they none of them can testify, none of
- 54:46them can testify the evidence. Oh, it's it's gone all the all the
- 54:51notes are gone, and the language they use, it's just like, oh,
- 54:54in the nine hours or whatever. But watching why would they do that?
- 55:00I mean what it seems like he must have known the he must have
- 55:02known someone that knew someone or knew the head of the department or something.
- 55:07Okay, okay, because like that seems so corrupt on its face. Yeah,
- 55:13I had the same reaction. Of course, the documentary is laying out
- 55:15in a certain way. So yeah, they said that she was lying.
- 55:21And the first thing that I and they quoted the report said she was lying.
- 55:28No one I know of, so I'm trained in psychological assessments and forensics
- 55:32actually minor so to speak, in forensic psychology, and these kinds of not
- 55:39only assessments, but how do you report it? You know, it's a
- 55:43big part of forensic psychology is how do you testify in court? How do
- 55:46you write up the report such that it has integrity and it will follow ethicals
- 55:52and legal standards. You know, you don't just say stuff like well,
- 55:57it's I think that you know that the statement of it that you would make
- 56:01as a forensic psychologist that child is lying about being sexually abused is quite a
- 56:08statement that for me and the people I worked with, you know, I
- 56:13don't know about others, would never say that. We would How would we
- 56:16possibly know if a child was lying about it or not. So at the
- 56:22very best or the very most, we could say it seems possible that the
- 56:28child is lying based on the following evidence, But you could never say I
- 56:32know the child is lying. No one knows that because let's say that the
- 56:38child even says, even admits, which I don't think Dylan ever did,
- 56:43I was lying. Well, if the child said it to begin with,
- 56:46and now they're saying they're lying, are they being coaches say they're lying.
- 56:50Are they trying to retract it? Are they trying to get out of feeling
- 56:53like they're in trouble? Are they trying to get out of testify? Are
- 56:55they trying to get out of coming to these multiple assessments? They don't,
- 56:59you know, they don't like being questioned this way. You just can't know.
- 57:05And you also can't know if a child's telling the truth. So if
- 57:07a child is, you know, laying out all the details, you can't
- 57:10say like, I know this child's you just all you can do is a
- 57:14forensic psychologist just just lay out the data and provide like your opinion based on
- 57:20that data. But you would never say, I know the child is lying.
- 57:24Now I've seen this before though on some level what not with this particular
- 57:30issue. But forensic psychologists, this is why I didn't want to go into
- 57:37the field, is so I would be so I would be I was getting
- 57:43trained by other forensic psychologists, you know, people that work work in the
- 57:46courts, and we'd be going over the you know, and I when I
- 57:52was being trained as a psychologist, I had already been a therapist and a
- 57:54professor for like fifteen years and so I wasn't just this naive student. I
- 58:00had written reports and assessed people, and so I would sometimes ask the forensic
- 58:06people. I'd say like, well, if a test in your interview you
- 58:09have this finding, how do you know that you're actually accurate? And they
- 58:15didn't like those kinds of questions. They didn't, you know, They said,
- 58:19well, the data shows blank. And I was saying, well,
- 58:22but how do you know for sure? I mean, you're they seem deluded
- 58:25by their own instruments, because because they are hired to do a job,
- 58:32you know, the whole the whole reason why they can pay their bills is
- 58:36because there's this notion out there that they know what they're doing. And if
- 58:40they were tentative, which is the reality that you should be, because how
- 58:45would you know, then they're basically saying, there's no point in hiring me,
- 58:49and there's no point in a lawyer hiring you, because no lawyer wants
- 58:54to hire a forensic psychologist that says, well, there's no way to tell
- 58:58what a lawyer wants. The people who get hired is when you say one
- 59:02way or the other, and you'll see that. You'll see in cases in
- 59:07court, you'll see one psychologist saying the husband is an abuser, and you'll
- 59:09see another psychologist saying the husband is absolutely not an abuser. And guess who
- 59:15hired Guess which lawyer hired the you know, the forensic psychologists. Well,
- 59:20and so you'll see this happen and instead of the two lawyers hiring different psychologists
- 59:27and both psychologists agreeing we can't tell, because how could we? But here's
- 59:31the data he said this, here's his psychological profile, which is mildly associated
- 59:37with abusing people. But of course it's not a slam dunk. And some
- 59:39people lie. And you know he was a little shifty, but who knows,
- 59:44Like they don't say that usually because you know that's not going to get
- 59:47you money. Right, No, right, in a different lifetime. So,
- 59:52as you know, I've been doing quality control for eads for my whole
- 1:00:00life almost but well, as long as you've been on the podcast, you've
- 1:00:01done Yeah, that's true, true, true. But the thing is quality
- 1:00:07quality assurance is kind of a science in its own right. Right. You
- 1:00:12have to like consider, how do you verify that something is actually working correctly.
- 1:00:16I used to have this interview question because you know, I would hire
- 1:00:20people to do the quality assurance of the erasers, and I had this question
- 1:00:23where essentially it was like, hey, imagine you have this machine that is
- 1:00:28going to move along an infinite line in both directions and it's gonna and the
- 1:00:34key is this, this machine needs to put marks randomly along the line.
- 1:00:39So it'll put a mark, then move randomly in one or the other direction,
- 1:00:43and then put another mark, and then keep doing this forever. Infinite
- 1:00:45line marks forever. But there's one very important thing. It can never mark
- 1:00:52the same place twice, otherwise the universe ends. And so of course it's
- 1:00:55completely abstracted blah blah blah blah blah. But the reason I would ask this
- 1:00:59question, I'd say, like, how would you know? The question would
- 1:01:01be how would you test that this machine is working properly? And you could
- 1:01:06end exactly and that this is what I was always hoping that the more you
- 1:01:10know, mature quality assurance folk would would tell me that, you know,
- 1:01:16it's that question won't work and why, and then they would give me ways
- 1:01:20in which we could talk about, well, what's the actual expected reliability of
- 1:01:23the machine, how do we know the universe is going to end? And
- 1:01:25it would get very interesting, but there were a ton sadly of candidates that
- 1:01:31would say, well, I would run it for you know, uh,
- 1:01:35maybe run it for a few weeks. And you know, I'm like,
- 1:01:37you're already listening. But it's this kind of certain running it for two measurements
- 1:01:44is you're already putting the universe at risk. Yeah, exactly so. But
- 1:01:49it's this kind of thinking that that we can know things in the universe,
- 1:01:52right, that is arrogant. But when you're talking about an infinite machine,
- 1:01:57I sort of get it. It might trip you up. Then when you're
- 1:02:00talking about a child's mind. Yeah, to think that, you know,
- 1:02:04definitively, yeah, it's like wow. But we're talking about economics here.
- 1:02:07I mean. Money will cause politicians to do all sorts of stuff, right.
- 1:02:15Money will cause us to look the other way when it comes to cigarettes
- 1:02:20or global warming or the fact that I will not be able to uh,
- 1:02:27you know the convenience of being able to drive to work. You know,
- 1:02:29we will look the other way. And when there's a ton of and there
- 1:02:32is a ton of money in forensics, that was that was the often the
- 1:02:37what was touted as like, well, you know, there's a lot of
- 1:02:39money in this because you could charge a thousand dollars an hour for this kind
- 1:02:45of work, right wow, Yeah, because you know it's it's highly expert
- 1:02:51and it takes a lot of time, and you could have you could be
- 1:02:55a psychologist and still not qualified to do it. It probably takes five ten
- 1:03:00years postgrad before you can do it really on your own. Wow. And
- 1:03:07the ability to get up on the stand and you know, be able to
- 1:03:10respond to cross examination or expert witness questioning by the opposing attorney, that's a
- 1:03:17whole others. You know, it's not just the ability, it's a whole
- 1:03:21set of skills that you have to be able to do and and to do
- 1:03:24it well or not to do it well. To do it in a way
- 1:03:29that you'll get hired, you have to be, shall we say, arrogant.
- 1:03:32Now, I will also say that I know a lot of psychologists and
- 1:03:36forensic psychologists listening right now. I know you're one of the good ones.
- 1:03:38So I'm not talking about I'm not talking about you. I'm just saying in
- 1:03:43my experience and and I guess I'll also say that even the good ones would
- 1:03:49kind of rub me wrong in terms of like my own career, my own
- 1:03:52career choices, you know, because even the good ones eventually they would say
- 1:03:57to me like, well, at some point, you got to say something.
- 1:04:00You know you have to do, you got to do what you can,
- 1:04:04and you got to say something because that's what you're being hired to do.
- 1:04:09And yes, there's a lot of ambiguity, and there's a lot of
- 1:04:12variabilities, a lot of chances that you're off base, or you didn't get
- 1:04:15enough time to fully evaluate, or the the individuals you're assessing are very good
- 1:04:20at tricking you. You know, we have a lot of ways of trying
- 1:04:24to eliminate those possibilities. But at the end of the day, yeah,
- 1:04:26I mean, but that doesn't mean you don't say anything. You gotta say
- 1:04:30something. Well, for me, I was like, well, I wouldn't
- 1:04:32want to say anything. I would want to go yeah, I would want
- 1:04:35to go to them and say like, I'm worried about saying anything to you
- 1:04:40because you'll take it as reality when I know that I don't know, and
- 1:04:45you know that doesn't go over well in court, right, lawyers are gonna
- 1:04:49never hire you again anyway. So by the way, I should I should
- 1:04:53have been a forensic psychologist because I would have been the opposite extreme. I
- 1:04:58would take one look at the situation be like, yeah, I've made my
- 1:05:00decision, I'm ready to testify. Yeah yeah. So the uh so,
- 1:05:05how this relates again getting back to what Lola was saying, as you know,
- 1:05:10this seeming corrupt assessment of Dylan or at least problematic. Yeah, they
- 1:05:15said that she was lying. And although that's might seem unusual, it happens
- 1:05:21all the time. If you've been through a custody battle and you've seen both
- 1:05:27lawyers higher psychologists, you will hear some wildly different things in court. You
- 1:05:33know, one expert will say this, you know. And so this notion
- 1:05:38that psychologists are somehow objective all the time or accurate is a bit of a
- 1:05:48deception that the industry. And again I'm just hacking on forensic psychologists, but
- 1:05:54it's a it's a bit, you know, it's sort of like the polygraph
- 1:05:57test. There's there's plenty of people have careers based on the fact that they
- 1:06:02are light detectors. Well, these things don't work. Science has demonstrated polygraphs
- 1:06:08are not accurate, they're not reliable at all. And but for a polygraph
- 1:06:14and polygraph people have at least been exposed to that research. How are they
- 1:06:17supposed what are they supposed to do? They've invested all this time and energy
- 1:06:21and becoming that career. Are they supposed to just give it up? No,
- 1:06:25they have They have to say that research wasn't the methodology wasn't right,
- 1:06:30or I know better anecdotally, you know, like there's there's anyway. My
- 1:06:34point is is that I wasn't that surprised when in the documentary they were like,
- 1:06:41how would they know anyway? Now, the destroyed notes thing is actually
- 1:06:45in the documentary they were clearly saying there was something wrong with that. You
- 1:06:48know, one of another forensic psychologist or another a lawyer or someone was saying,
- 1:06:54you never destroy your notes. I'm not quite so sure about that.
- 1:06:59I don't know that practices in that neck of the woods in that particular activity.
- 1:07:05So let me explain a little bit. You're you're talking with a child.
- 1:07:09So what they were seeing in a documentary is there was I think a
- 1:07:13social worker I believe, who was interviewing Dylan over nine sessions or something,
- 1:07:18which is unusual. By the way, you would that that part of it
- 1:07:23was strange that you would need nine individual sessions where the child from Session one
- 1:07:32is saying he touched me here, I touched him here, and then asking
- 1:07:38Dylan to repeat it over and over again in a seven year old I believe
- 1:07:43she's seven anyway. That was also unusual and seems corrupt at least, it's
- 1:07:48a tick in the corrupt column. But the destroyed notes thing, it's it's
- 1:07:54debatable. So you're sitting down and your a value asking all these questions,
- 1:07:58and you're taking notes as as you're talking. Well, your notes might be
- 1:08:01completely discombobulated and very particular to you. Some people take notes that are kind
- 1:08:08of inllegible, and some people take notes that are very particular to them,
- 1:08:13and then when they are out of the evaluation, they'll they'll formally write up
- 1:08:17their notes or formally write up their findings, and then they'll discard their notes
- 1:08:23because their notes are so illegible that there wouldn't make any sense to keep their
- 1:08:27notes. So in the documentary, they were saying, you would never get
- 1:08:31rid of your notes, Well, you would never get rid of your findings.
- 1:08:34You would never get rid of what you discovered, but you might discard
- 1:08:42your temporary notes in that process. Again, I don't know if if no
- 1:08:47one did that in that realm and that neck of the woods. But I
- 1:08:50wouldn't be surprised if some people destroy their notes. So I'm not quite so
- 1:08:56sure as to, you know, the slam dunk accusation of a problem with
- 1:09:02that detail. But it was interesting that when the judge hearing the case of
- 1:09:09custody, that the judge pointed out that, hey, the thing you've brought
- 1:09:15up from this agency's got all these problems. One of the problems he or
- 1:09:17she listed was there's no notes. And I don't know if no notes means
- 1:09:21there were no recordings left, or there were no or the files there's no
- 1:09:26files, I don't know. It seemed to be like there was something that
- 1:09:29they were expecting, at least at the at the judge. Well, okay,
- 1:09:32so here's the other thing. That's a bit of a myth that judges
- 1:09:36know what they're talking about. I have been I've been in court when judges
- 1:09:42have no idea what they're talking Now, maybe that judge did know what they
- 1:09:45were talking about, but I just didn't have enough information, Like I would
- 1:09:49have to talk to the social worker that did the evaluation say like, you
- 1:09:53know, what's your story? And if they said well, I know it's
- 1:09:58not standard that we do it this way, but I always did it this
- 1:10:01way. I would take notes and then I would formally write my notes later
- 1:10:05and those are still in the file. But my sort of haphazard notes I
- 1:10:10always got rid of because they were nonsensical and sometimes there was stuff on there
- 1:10:16that was a little speculative, and I didn't want that in the final report
- 1:10:20that I or the final notes that are included. I don't know if they
- 1:10:24would say that, or if they or if you know, I just don't
- 1:10:26know. There's there's just too much variability in the practices that I've seen on
- 1:10:31that detail that I was like, I don't know if that's as much of
- 1:10:34a slam dunks as they're portraying. Maybe it is in that negular woods,
- 1:10:39but it wouldn't be for me and the people in the assessments that I did
- 1:10:43anyway. The other Okay, so why if something was wrong there? Here
- 1:10:50are the speculation. So you've already speculated about one that they're essentially fraud that
- 1:10:56they had a back you know, back back deal what press conference with the
- 1:11:01guy? Yeah, but you would do a press conference, you know,
- 1:11:08you're hired by a court to do something, and then you go and you
- 1:11:11do a press conference with one of the parties. It's certainly not kouth.
- 1:11:16It doesn't look good. But you know, if if you're wanting to advertise
- 1:11:20your agency as a viable assessment, you know who knows it's it doesn't It
- 1:11:28doesn't look very professional, but you know, it happens. I wouldn't be
- 1:11:33surprised if it happens, you know, at least in part sometimes anyway,
- 1:11:39So was it fraud? Could be? Was it bribery could be? Was
- 1:11:43it back room deals, friends, handshake deals could be? It also could
- 1:11:47just be incompetence. It don't underestimate the amount of incompetence in any field.
- 1:11:53Could the individuals who were doing the evaluation just have no idea what they're doing?
- 1:11:58Yeah, that happens all the time, This assumption that like, well,
- 1:12:00it's it's the Yale New Haven, Dada, Dad must be No,
- 1:12:03there's plenty of incompetence in the world. Who knows. I don't know.
- 1:12:10Now. Another speculation I had while I was watching it was was the organization
- 1:12:15that was assessing and the psychologists and all the other people terrified of Woody Allen's
- 1:12:20lawyers suing them. You know, Woody Allen's lawyers were wealth funded and very
- 1:12:26good. Mia Pharaoh's lawyers were not. You know, Mia Pharaoh was basically
- 1:12:31just like, look the truth will prevail, and Woody Allen was like all
- 1:12:35guns ablaze with all my lawyers right. Well, and not only that,
- 1:12:40I think in this case, the that assessment wasn't it ordered by the prosecutor?
- 1:12:46I don't remember, it probably was. I mean that would be a
- 1:12:48standard that would be standing. And so why why do you bring that up?
- 1:12:53Well, because it wasn't even Why am I bringing that up? Oh?
- 1:12:58You just to emphasize the point that, yeah, it's not like Mia
- 1:13:00had this crack team of Johnny Cochran's you know, right, It's like she's
- 1:13:05there like what are we gonna do here? And then this this prosecutor is
- 1:13:11like trying to do their best and being like, well we'll order this,
- 1:13:15well order that. And the similar is a state actor, right with a
- 1:13:19large caseload and not the funds obviously that Woody Allen as cron round right.
- 1:13:25It's similar with oj Simpson trial, for example, you are going up against
- 1:13:30people who have scores of assistants that can do all sorts of research, and
- 1:13:34you know, anyway, so would you maybe put pressure, as Woody Allen's
- 1:13:41lawyers on the organization and say, hey, by the way, you know,
- 1:13:45I'm just going to throw it out here. If something you do is
- 1:13:47a little off kilter and we don't like the results, you better believe there's
- 1:13:51going to be a lawsuit and we're gonna get you. So watch what you're
- 1:13:55doing. And while the prosecutor isn't saying anything like that, right, can
- 1:13:59we imagine that happening? Yeah, or at least the implication. You know,
- 1:14:01it's all in the implication, right Berto, And so might that have
- 1:14:08or might the organization just been preemptively terrified of Woody Allen's lawyers. There's a
- 1:14:15huge incentive there of like, if we sweep this under the rug, everything
- 1:14:19will go away and we can just go back to our regular jobs and not
- 1:14:23worrying about all the press conferences and losing jobs and scrutiny. And we know
- 1:14:29whereas if we find Woody Allen to be maybe guilty and Dylan to be maybe
- 1:14:33telling the truth, then this will get this will become a protracted legal problem
- 1:14:39for the next seven years of our lives. Do we really want that.
- 1:14:42You know, I've seen people make decisions in my field influenced by those factors.
- 1:14:48Also bias for Woody Allen because he was famous at that time, and
- 1:14:54he was a beloved figure, a very It's hard people who might be a
- 1:15:00little younger might not remember or might not know. But Woody Allen was just
- 1:15:05a huge figure in the seventies and eighties and nineties, particularly seventies, and
- 1:15:12I mean just a gigantic figure, and it wouldn't be unusual for people to
- 1:15:16be kind of starstruck, and just like he wouldn't do that. He's he's
- 1:15:19a nice guy, you know. Yep. Oh, by the way,
- 1:15:23um, it reminds me there was that moment where he's being interviewed and he
- 1:15:27says, look, the whole thing doesn't make sense. I'm fifty seven.
- 1:15:32Why would I choose this time of my life to all of a sudden become
- 1:15:35a pedophile? Right? So, actually Lola asked about that. Lola said,
- 1:15:42let's see, let's see this isn't let's see the duck wait, I'm
- 1:15:48reading all the different questions that well, anyway, Lola brought that point up,
- 1:15:55um, and yeah, that's a missed that people people can't do that.
- 1:16:02I mean, one, you could hide your pedophilia until you're in your
- 1:16:11fifties. Two you could be either hiding it by not acting on it or
- 1:16:19hiding your victims, hiding your victimization of others. Also, some people do
- 1:16:25develop personality changes later in life. There's actually this isn't you know the same
- 1:16:30thing. But there's a medication that you can take form for EPI for Parkinson's
- 1:16:41that can and some people create compulsions. It's usually gambling, but it sometimes
- 1:16:45can be sex, and it sometimes can be child abuse. So now there's
- 1:16:51debate as to whether or not they always head it in them, you know,
- 1:16:56but when you change the chemistry of the brain, we've known that,
- 1:16:59or you have a stroke for example, or surgery. There was a case
- 1:17:03that was in a podcast I think this American Life a long time ago,
- 1:17:06where this guy had surgery on his brain and after because he had I think
- 1:17:13maybe I can't remember why, but they took out a portion of his brain
- 1:17:15and he was doing pretty well afterwards, but he found himself just in massive
- 1:17:21compulsion to abuse children sexually. Oh I remember seeing a video about this.
- 1:17:27Yeah, and now you could debate, you know, was he just hiding
- 1:17:30it before and now he can't. You know who knows. But anyway,
- 1:17:34the point is is that this notion of why that that all abusers who are
- 1:17:41caught when they're fifty five have a known track record going back to when they
- 1:17:46were twenty years old, is you know, obviously silly spin. To me.
- 1:17:50When he said that, I was like, oh my gosh, that
- 1:17:54makes you look more guilty in my mind, because it's a it's a it's
- 1:17:58a total strong man argument setting up right. No one actually said it's not
- 1:18:01like Mia or anyone else said, what we believe is that all of a
- 1:18:05sudden, Woody Allen developed in his fifties pedophilia tendencies. That's not the that's
- 1:18:12not the argument. I don't care how long, how soon, whatever.
- 1:18:15No one's bringing it up. You're bringing it up as like, oh you
- 1:18:19see, like it doesn't make sense from this angle. It's almost it's one
- 1:18:23thing if I said, let's say you accuse me of like, hey man,
- 1:18:29I think I think you're probably a robber, like you steal things.
- 1:18:33And I say, well, look, I have been alive for forty six
- 1:18:36years. I've certainly never been accused or convicted of stealing things, so what
- 1:18:43is your evidence? Okay, fine, but imagine that all of a sudden
- 1:18:45you're like, hey, I saw you eating vanilla ice cream the other day,
- 1:18:48and I go, wait, why would I choose to wait till I'm
- 1:18:54forty six too? Like vanilla ice cream? Liking things is not something you
- 1:18:59can prove whether I did or didn't. So it's like, who is to
- 1:19:03know what he predilected, what he has done in secret, what he wanted
- 1:19:08to do. It's just ridiculous. So I think him bringing that up,
- 1:19:12if if someone was really innocent, I would have not expected that statement.
- 1:19:17I would have expected the statements like no, absolutely, this didn't happen.
- 1:19:20No, of course, not totally. Of course I expect those statements,
- 1:19:24but I would not expect these weird straw man arguments like why would I do
- 1:19:28that? And when I'm fifty seven It's just it struck me as really odd.
- 1:19:31Yeah. Well, on the other hand, if you're accused of something
- 1:19:35like that and you have no hard evidence that you did it or that you
- 1:19:40didn't do it, then you're going to have to resort to circumstantial questionable evidence.
- 1:19:46You know, if if he had the definitive proof that he didn't do
- 1:19:49it, he would obviously present that if he didn't do it right, So
- 1:19:54so in that sense, I would expect things like, hey, look,
- 1:19:57I've been around all the following sets of children, at all those various ranges
- 1:20:01of their life. Let's go interview all these people and they will give you
- 1:20:05accounts and look in my dating pattern, look at my this, look at
- 1:20:09my this, look at my this, And I think, well, I
- 1:20:11don't think he worded it that way, but I'm pretty sure he does point
- 1:20:14those things out, you know. But I would say like, well,
- 1:20:16no, that's what we're doing. And actually it's looking pretty weird because you've
- 1:20:19now dated started having sex with an underage girl and then a writer who and
- 1:20:24then you were dating another under age scare you write movies about it and so
- 1:20:27what? But not not definitive proof other than Dylan U now what? Lola
- 1:20:34on Discord also ask you what would a psychologists look for in a case suspected
- 1:20:40of false allegations or implanting false memories, as Mia was accused of doing to
- 1:20:44Dylan. Does this case have or have not those markers? And how clearly
- 1:20:48does it not have or have such markers? So, yeah, I don't
- 1:20:54know because I don't have access to the reports or the evaluations, so I
- 1:21:00can't know. In the case of Dylan, they talked briefly about it in
- 1:21:03the documentary, But you know, these kinds of evaluations are pretty complicated.
- 1:21:09But the things that we tend and this I don't do this kind of work.
- 1:21:13I've done it in the past and I've worked alongside a lot of people,
- 1:21:15so I'm just speaking from that place. But the sort of things that
- 1:21:18you're looking for when you're evaluating situation like this as a psychologist, are you're
- 1:21:26you're doing a full or as much of a full evaluation of the child as
- 1:21:30possible, not just the issue of the events that are being discussed, but
- 1:21:34what's you know, what's their personality? Like how mature are they? What
- 1:21:39are their general morals? Do they have any attachment problems? What do they
- 1:21:44have ADHD? Do they have early bipolar? Do they you know, are
- 1:21:49they how are their emotional expressions? Are they generally stable? Do they generally
- 1:21:57tell the truth? In session? Out of the reports by other people,
- 1:22:01You're trying to piece together a psychological profile that is inherently circumstantial but can inform
- 1:22:11the powers that you know, the people that are making the decision as to
- 1:22:16whether or not it's the you know, the person's innocent or guilty to tell
- 1:22:19the truth. Um. You know, for example, with Dylan, they
- 1:22:24were looking into how consistent her story was, and apparently they had to ask
- 1:22:30her nine different times, which is unusual, or nine different sessions, probably
- 1:22:33several times where they probably asked her a hundred times. So you're so,
- 1:22:39not only would a lawyer do this, but a psychologist might as well,
- 1:22:42just just kind of, you know, can you tell this story again?
- 1:22:44And if it if it changes wildly, Because the thing is is that when
- 1:22:48a child is making something up, then it will more full over time sometimes,
- 1:22:55but when you're dealing with children, one they will morph things over time
- 1:23:02just kind of naturally. And two, if you keep asking him the same
- 1:23:06question over and over again, even an adult, they might perceive I must
- 1:23:11not be answering the question quite right. And this can actually go two different
- 1:23:15ways. You can either cause a victim to recant their story when they shouldn't
- 1:23:20be, or you can cause someone that isn't a victim to believe they were
- 1:23:26a victim. You know, these are the implanted memories where you ask a
- 1:23:30child, you know, were you abused? And the child says no,
- 1:23:34and you say, well, are you sure you weren't abused? And the
- 1:23:38child says, what do you mean? Well, did you know where did
- 1:23:41he touch you on this doll? Where did he touch you? And the
- 1:23:44child says, he didn't touch me? And then you say, are you
- 1:23:47sure he didn't touch you? And so this is a case where the child
- 1:23:50wasn't abused. Are you sure that he didn't touch you? And the child's
- 1:23:54like yes, and then you bring him in next week he said, so,
- 1:24:00where did he touch you on the doll? I don't know what do
- 1:24:02you he touched me here? And kids just like, I don't know what,
- 1:24:05I don't know what you're asking, and the kid just points at like
- 1:24:08the head, Oh, so he did, so he did touch you.
- 1:24:11And the child's like, oh, crap, I just I just said that
- 1:24:15he touched me because I was just I just wanted to play. I just
- 1:24:19I didn't want to be asked these questions anymore. So crap, I just
- 1:24:21sort of you know, and you're you're seven, you don't know how to
- 1:24:25answer, and so, yeah, yeah, he touched me on that.
- 1:24:28Okay, So so last week you were lying to me when you said he
- 1:24:31didn't touch you? Is that right? And the kids like, fuck,
- 1:24:34what do I say? You know, kids say all sorts of shit.
- 1:24:36So kids like, uh, yeah, I was lying last week. Yeah.
- 1:24:41And the kids is like, can we just move on so I can
- 1:24:43play legos with you or something? I don't want to answer these questions here.
- 1:24:45And you say, okay, well where else did he touch you?
- 1:24:47And the kids like, so, I'm is that what I'm supposed to do.
- 1:24:50I'm supposed to say that he touched me other places? Okay, fine,
- 1:24:54he touched me on the butt, you know. And you keep doing
- 1:24:56this over and over again, and eventually the kid will believe that they were
- 1:25:02being touched in that way, and you can actually again do this to adults
- 1:25:05as well. We've shown this through lots of research. Our memories are extremely
- 1:25:10malleable. We are not tape recorders. We are not hard disk drives.
- 1:25:15We are not YouTube videos. We are not YouTube videos. We are we
- 1:25:20you know. The thing I always say is, have you ever seen a
- 1:25:24brain? It does not look like a hard drive. It looks like a
- 1:25:28pile of mud, you know. And so the fact that that pile of
- 1:25:32mud isn't precise should not surprise you. So I mean, the fact that
- 1:25:38you forget where your keys are sometimes should alert you to the fact that your
- 1:25:43brain isn't exactly precise in its abilities to remember things and remember that you didn't
- 1:25:48remember things anyway, So it can go both ways, and so you have
- 1:25:55to be extremely careful as an evaluator that you're not in planting memories, you're
- 1:25:59not changing memories. And it's really hard to know, and you can never
- 1:26:01really know because a kid will say lots of things, especially under that circumstance,
- 1:26:06because the kid isn't comfortable. Usually the kid knows that it's there's awkwardness
- 1:26:13in the air, there's like why am I here? And usually try to
- 1:26:15play games at first and make the kid feel comfortable, but there's always discomfort.
- 1:26:19You know, the kid would rather be home playing games or something,
- 1:26:24and so that puts a lot of pressure, and so there's a lot of
- 1:26:28But anyway, the kinds of things you're looking for our consistency, you might
- 1:26:31look for a tendency to be fantastical or to make stuff up. And that
- 1:26:38was their contention, was that Dylan had a pattern of making think making up
- 1:26:45stories that she you know, when they just asked her about other kinds of
- 1:26:47things, she would include details that were clearly not possible, Like she would
- 1:26:51talk about I don't know, spaceships or something, and you would say,
- 1:26:56oh, she generally lives in a fantasy world, and so thus, how
- 1:27:00can we trust what she's saying. Now, you wouldn't say she's lying,
- 1:27:05right, someone with an active or overly active fantasy orientation can still be abuse
- 1:27:13and tell the truth. It's not like every single thing that comes out of
- 1:27:15Dylan's mouth as a fantasy. We all understand that. But anyway, Yeah,
- 1:27:24so that's how I answer that question. I could go on and there's
- 1:27:27a whole system of how to evaluate this in kids, but just know that
- 1:27:30it's it's hard, and you look for certain markers, you mark it down,
- 1:27:35you write it in your report, and you give an opinion of just
- 1:27:38like, well, it's it's in my experience, it's possible that that would
- 1:27:42have been much more of a common response that I have seen is something like,
- 1:27:45given the pattern and these five factors that I observed, here's my data,
- 1:27:50it seems quite likely or possible that she was abuse, or it seems
- 1:27:55quite possible that she is making it up, but I can't know for sure
- 1:27:58that kind of thing. Yeah, all right, So I'm just going to
- 1:28:02rattle off the evidence for and against that I compiled. And I'm not an
- 1:28:09expert on this, but this is what I compile. So the evidence that
- 1:28:12he did it, and this is from not just the documentary, but from
- 1:28:14other sources. Evidence that Woody Allen did it. Dylan Faraoh has consistently told
- 1:28:18the child since childhood. Usually this indicates the truth, and she has almost
- 1:28:25nothing to gain and a lot to lose. So, as with most cases
- 1:28:30like this, not only is it likely that Dylan is telling the truth,
- 1:28:35but we almost have a moral duty to believe her. Why would why would
- 1:28:42we disbelieve her? It's basically comes down between Woody's word and Dylan's word,
- 1:28:46And why would Dylan want to ruin Woody Allen's You know, there's no reason
- 1:28:50why she especially now, you know, the only reason why she would come
- 1:28:55forward is if she's like, there's something there's an injustice here, something's wrong,
- 1:29:00and and I want the world to be right. And so I'm willing
- 1:29:06to incur all the hatred and all the denial and all the retraumatization to make
- 1:29:13the world, right, you know, it's usually what's happening. Yeah.
- 1:29:16The other reason why we would say that he did it is that Dylan in
- 1:29:21the documentary, she had a real classic PTSD reaction when she was a recalling
- 1:29:26the story. Remember that moment berdo. Oh, yes, yeah, it
- 1:29:29was Oh it was brutal. Yeah, that's hard to fake. And it's
- 1:29:32possible she was faking. It's possible that she was reacting to an implanted memory,
- 1:29:36but it's much more likely that that physiological reaction was absolutely a reaction to
- 1:29:43the trauma, not just the sexual trauma, but the emotional coercion trauma that
- 1:29:47she went because you know, it wasn't just that he sexually abused her,
- 1:29:51it was that he dominated her her life and her body and her brain,
- 1:29:58not just sexually but just in general. And they had footage of that,
- 1:30:00you know, all that one and one time, and that was traumatizing for
- 1:30:05her, and you saw her have a very classic PTSD reaction. And I
- 1:30:11feel like all with all the reality TV I've been watching lately, I've gotten,
- 1:30:15or at least I believe that I've I've become a little bit of a
- 1:30:20I have a little bit of a skill that's developed over the past couple of
- 1:30:24years of detecting faking of affect on television, you know, because it obviously
- 1:30:30serves some people to do that, and it didn't ring any of those bells.
- 1:30:35Could she be faking, Yeah, absolutely, but it didn't look like
- 1:30:38it to me. Woody Allen admits to having relationship with one of the other
- 1:30:43children SUNI. So, yeah, it's like, it's not a crazy accusation
- 1:30:50at that point. It's like, well, we have a pattern here of
- 1:30:56you having sex with your step children or children. So and with witnesses talking
- 1:31:04about that that was potentially happening before she was even of age, right,
- 1:31:11Yeah, I mean the chance that it was it started when they say it
- 1:31:15started, especially with how much they were hanging out. Yeah, it seemed
- 1:31:20I mean, let's just even say that it's true that they never had sex
- 1:31:25before she was twenty one, which I think is their account of it.
- 1:31:29Well, they were hanging out a lot when she was a teenager, so
- 1:31:36at the very least it's you know, even retrospectively. Anyway, point is
- 1:31:45is that that's at least quote unquote evidence that he mean, he's circumstantal.
- 1:31:49I haven't said he did it because and by the way, not to mention
- 1:31:53that if we if we rewind the clock. The whole idea is that the
- 1:31:58reason why the accusation is not real is because Mia Pharaoh felt scorned by the
- 1:32:03Sunni thing, right, And so then I guess I would expect to see
- 1:32:09that Mia Farrow has been unable to move on from the Sunni devastation, right,
- 1:32:15and that her life really has revolved around that aspect, and that that
- 1:32:20seems completely opposite to the reality, right, And she very much after the
- 1:32:29relationship ended, you know, before you know, she had clearly a lot
- 1:32:32of romantic relationships, you know, some marry some marriages and some not before
- 1:32:39Woody Allen. After Woody Allen, no relationships, Which is another tick in
- 1:32:43the column of Miya Pharo's telling the truth, because if it was truly a
- 1:32:47lie and a manipulation on Mia Pharaoh's part, why would she trick herself into
- 1:32:53believing that her child was abused such that she didn't ever want to take that
- 1:32:58risk again. You know, it just was extremely consistent with if we believe
- 1:33:02the documentary, that Mia after Woody Allen would be like, well, I
- 1:33:06let this man into my house and he abused my children, and I didn't
- 1:33:12and I don't have the ability to make that detection, and so I guess
- 1:33:15I have to deny myself that need for the rest of my life, and
- 1:33:19I'm never going to date again, you know. And that's what she did.
- 1:33:24And it's not like any of the audio of the calls, which,
- 1:33:26by the way, did I understand it, didn't I understand right? The
- 1:33:28audio we were hearing of the calls was taped by Woody Allen. No,
- 1:33:30I don't know. That seemed to be the thing, because that was what
- 1:33:34came out. And in fact, there's one call where she says, are
- 1:33:38you taping this? He's like, no, I don't even know how to
- 1:33:40use those things, and then the thing cuts out or he's like, oh,
- 1:33:43give me a second, and then it's a different call where he's talking
- 1:33:45maybe to his lawyer, saying like, yeah, I'm recording right now.
- 1:33:49It's bizarre. But in those conversations, and maybe we didn't hear all of
- 1:33:54them, but certainly they didn't seem to revolve around Sun Yi and but I
- 1:33:58want you back or I can't believe what you did to me, you know,
- 1:34:00it's all about her, about the little girl. Well, and Mia
- 1:34:06pleading Mia, pleading with Witty Allen to not go to the media anymore.
- 1:34:12She's like, could you please not drag the kids through this and just let's
- 1:34:15just keep it on the d l You know, if you were truly a
- 1:34:19scorned lover, you would relish in the fact that this was in the media
- 1:34:26right where it was seemingly from the documentary. The opposite also mea just seems
- 1:34:30like a saint. So I thought that too as I was watching, and
- 1:34:34I was like, oh my god, this person is unbelievable. Yeah,
- 1:34:38I mean, I literally, while I was watching it with my wife,
- 1:34:41exclaimed she's a saint. She's she's she's like squit around the world, like
- 1:34:47yeah, she's like helping with polio and yeah, oh my god, and
- 1:34:53and to literally save the lives of children around the world and you know,
- 1:34:58adopt them and bring them into home. Now, okay, so now the
- 1:35:00evidence that he didn't do it. Let's go into this. Now he claims
- 1:35:04he didn't do it. Okay, that's evidence. It's not fantastic evidence,
- 1:35:08but it's it's well, what I was saying is unlike Roman Polanski, who's
- 1:35:13like he's not claiming at all that didn't happen. He's just saying, well,
- 1:35:16yes, but it's not as bad as you think. I don't think
- 1:35:19that's a bad thing. Plus she was into it. Right now, whatever
- 1:35:24we feel about that, he's admitting it. Right. He claims that Dylan
- 1:35:30was coached. That it does happen, particularly when there are custody battles,
- 1:35:34particularly when there are breakups. There is actually a pretty high prevalence of it,
- 1:35:42and it's something that people don't often talk about. When you are,
- 1:35:46you know, going through a real nasty divorce and you just hate your your
- 1:35:50ex spouse and you'll do anything to protect your kids, and whether it's a
- 1:35:58real threat or not, you believe that your ex is a bad parent.
- 1:36:01And you know, well, if I accuse my ex of sexual abuse,
- 1:36:06this whole problem will go away, and it's for the better. So I'm
- 1:36:12going to tell little you know, little Bobby, Hey, you know,
- 1:36:15remember when Daddy was in the pool with you that one time and he touched
- 1:36:21you down there, and you know, in your head, as a parent,
- 1:36:26you're like, I know it was accidental, but I could use this
- 1:36:29against it, you know. And so so all we gotta do is just
- 1:36:30get Bobby to say that he you know he was touched, and I'm I
- 1:36:33don't want to throw my X into prison. I just want this custody battle
- 1:36:36to go away. And then you make the report and then forensic people start
- 1:36:42to show up and they ask you more questions and you start elaborating, and
- 1:36:45then you know, you start actually kind of freaking out and you start pressuring
- 1:36:49Bobby to say a little bit more, and this happens. This happens.
- 1:36:55Is it the majority of cases where these come forward. No, but you
- 1:37:00know, it's a thing in custody battles. And did it seem like Mia
- 1:37:05Faroh was capable of that note? Did it seem like that was even really
- 1:37:09a factor? You know that because by the time Sunni was by the whole
- 1:37:15time this this problem was going on between Woody Allen and Mia Pharaoh, Sunni
- 1:37:18was an adult. So that so there wasn't any power that Mia could have
- 1:37:23if if Sunni wanted to be involved with what he, Mia knew she couldn't
- 1:37:27do anything about that. So there wasn't seemingly anything at stake that Mia would
- 1:37:31be motivated to somehow tear him down in that way. But you know,
- 1:37:35it can't happen, and it seemed like the timing was. First came the
- 1:37:41accusation about Dylan, which, by the way, um she claims. Mia
- 1:37:46Pharaoh claims that she wasn't aware that the that the therapist would have to report,
- 1:37:53right, like she she sent Dylan to a therapist, and then she
- 1:37:56wasn't aware that the therapist would have to report, but the therapist report,
- 1:38:00and that's how the thing started, right, And then then the right then
- 1:38:02the state prosecutor takes over exactly, and then Woody Allen comes out and says,
- 1:38:08Oh, I've got an announcement to make. I'm in love with Sunyi
- 1:38:12and that's why you're here. It wasn't like Woody Allen left me. The
- 1:38:17press gets ahold of it, Oh what's happening? Oh yeah, I'm running
- 1:38:20away with Sunni. And then these accusations start coming out. Right, You
- 1:38:25have to wonder if that hadn't come out, would would he Allen even have
- 1:38:30lasted with Sunni? Or did he? Does he need Sunni as his like
- 1:38:33very weird alibi because it kind of works as an alibi in a sense in
- 1:38:38terms of his scrapped together narrative that that that Mia Pharaoh was upset. You
- 1:38:44know, Yeah, and I just remember in the nineties people saying, you
- 1:38:47know, you know what, hens he's he's dating his daughter, and then
- 1:38:53other people said, no, that's not really his daughter, it's it's the
- 1:38:57it's the adopted daughter of his ex girlfriend. You know. It was always
- 1:39:01sort of said that way, and I remember that. I remember thinking,
- 1:39:05oh, kay, I guess that's all right, right, he's not related
- 1:39:09to the child. It's kind of a distant you know, in your head.
- 1:39:14The way it was portrayed, it was like it'd be like Berto,
- 1:39:17if you had an ex girlfriend from like fifteen years ago and she had an
- 1:39:25adult adopted daughter, and you just happened to fall in love with that,
- 1:39:29you know, you just randomly bumped into this woman at a party and then
- 1:39:32oh, you're you're the adopted daughter of my ex from fifteen years ago.
- 1:39:38But we fell in love. What are we going to do? Oh well,
- 1:39:40this kind of looks weird. That's the way it was portrayed. That's
- 1:39:43not how it was. No, no, no, it was there the
- 1:39:46whole time. He being called out, even in his own words. I
- 1:39:50found something very interesting from from the moment that she came into the family,
- 1:39:55like when she was ten basically right, Yeah, as a child, and
- 1:39:58yeah, no, totally, it's just not he was. I mean,
- 1:40:00he was, you know, at the very least a father figure, you
- 1:40:08know, say, like a like a friend of the family as a father
- 1:40:11figure to Sunni. Right, and quite possibly you could make the argument a
- 1:40:17stepfather, which is a father And whether Sunni saw him that way or not,
- 1:40:25I don't know, but you know, the documentary and all the home
- 1:40:29footage, it just shows it. You know that he was over there,
- 1:40:33he was particularly with Dylan. Right. If he wasn't Dylan's father, what
- 1:40:40was he or if he wasn't Dylan's essential father figure, what was he?
- 1:40:44Right? So if he was just like a friend of the family, why
- 1:40:49yeah then and Suni was a sibling of Dylan's, you know what I mean.
- 1:40:56Anyway, like Ronan Pharaoh, you know, one of the kids that
- 1:40:59you know, he's spoken out about this and he'll be like, yeah,
- 1:41:02Sunni is both my sister and and my stepmother. Man. But anyway,
- 1:41:13so now again evidence against that, people will say is the accusers and the
- 1:41:17documentarians are accusing him for personal gain, you know, fame, money.
- 1:41:21Dylan doesn't seem like she's interested in those things. But you know, those
- 1:41:27are the accusations possible motivation. The Michael Jackson supporters will definitely point to that
- 1:41:33as a reason why the fame and money is the reason why they would accuse.
- 1:41:39One of the adopted children said that he never did it, but that
- 1:41:45claim seemed extremely dubious given that the other child, I think it was Moses,
- 1:41:50was like nine years old himself at the time, and looking back,
- 1:41:55he's like, no, it never happens, Like how would he know?
- 1:41:57But you know, and he actually at first he believed, and he wrote
- 1:42:00a letter saying how he felt betrayed, and then he recanted it. But
- 1:42:03I mean, and I'm not blaming him, Like, poor little kid also
- 1:42:06traumatized, traumatized in his own way. He had this father figure of a
- 1:42:11hero of his and then he feels betrayed and then he loves the guy though,
- 1:42:15So he's like waiting all this campaign. I'm sure they've had all sorts
- 1:42:18of conversations, and Woody Allen like, look, if I hadn't watched this,
- 1:42:23and I'm just having a conversation. The guy sounds really convincing. That's
- 1:42:27his skill, his stick is he can you know do oh this little talking
- 1:42:30and then and then why would this happen? Like and all of a sudden,
- 1:42:33you're going along with his little convoluted train of thought, and you're watching
- 1:42:36his movie and you're thinking, wow, yeah, I kind of see his
- 1:42:39points, and there you are. Yeah, and so the guy can be
- 1:42:42super convincing. Imagine if you're a kid, Imagine if you grew up thinking
- 1:42:45of him as a father. Yeah, even if he wasn't convincing, you
- 1:42:47know, when you are in many of you out there might have been in
- 1:42:50a situation like this, and berto you not precisely, but you had a
- 1:42:55similar kind of environment of I have a choice right now, given what I'm
- 1:43:00experiencing. I can either go with what everyone else is saying and essentially lose
- 1:43:06a parent, which I don't want is just terrible. I'm essentially like self
- 1:43:11abandoning my son. Or I can go into denial and yeah, just believe
- 1:43:17that it's not true, so that I can have a parent. You know,
- 1:43:23we will do a lot of things far more sacrificial to retain a parental
- 1:43:30relationship than that. And so is that possible? Yeah? You know,
- 1:43:32but is he telling true? You know? Does he have Sunni also defends
- 1:43:36Woody Allen, But again, how would she know about behind the scenes Dylan
- 1:43:42situation. There's claims that Mia Farah was abusive. That's not evidence that Woody
- 1:43:46Allen was innocent, but it does indicate character issues similar to Woody Allen's character
- 1:43:51being called into question. Those accusations are you know, hotly debated in their
- 1:43:58own family. If that was the case, then why the hell did Woody
- 1:44:03Allen never mention that? Or why didn't he care? Didn't he care so
- 1:44:08much about the boy? What's his name? Didn't he care? Moses?
- 1:44:14Didn't he care it? So didn't he see any of this? How come
- 1:44:17he didn't see any of this abuse happening? Why didn't he step in?
- 1:44:21Why is he anyways? It's yeah. The Woody Allen was investigated by the
- 1:44:28Yale Newhaven Hospital Sexual Abuse Clinic and they quote said, it is our opinion
- 1:44:32that Dylan was not sexually molisted by mister Allen. Again, how would they
- 1:44:36know that? But that was their opinion. We don't have access to the
- 1:44:40data. Woody Allen was investigated by the New York State Department of Social Services
- 1:44:44and quote, no credible evidence was found that the child named and this report
- 1:44:48has been abused or maltreated unquote, Again, how would they know that?
- 1:44:53But we don't know how they came to that conclusion. So a lot of
- 1:44:57experts both saying Dylan was not abused and Woody Allen is not an abuser.
- 1:45:00Again, how would they know that? But they claim that we don't have
- 1:45:04access to those that those data. Doctors examined Dylan and found out evidence abuse.
- 1:45:12That's evidence, you know. For the people that are pro Woody Allen,
- 1:45:15they'll point to that. But that's not unusual because what physical you know,
- 1:45:19a physician examining Dylan, what evidence you know? There are signs which
- 1:45:25I won't go into for you know, the graphical nature of it, of
- 1:45:29abuse happening to someone. But the fact that there isn't evidence doesn't mean it
- 1:45:33didn't happen, right, especially because the description of what was done to her,
- 1:45:39which I again won't mention, wouldn't leave any kind of injuries exactly,
- 1:45:44it should, it should probably wouldn't. And by the way, this is
- 1:45:47another reason why it is so difficult. But as I was listening to it,
- 1:45:54I'm like, well, look, if they were going to fabricate something
- 1:45:58like you imagine, it would be even worse. Right right, Yeah,
- 1:46:02that wasn't Actually that's a good point, Burt. I thought the same thing
- 1:46:06of when people fabricate, not always because sometimes they're trying to you know,
- 1:46:12keep it, especially in a case when when they're trying to deal with a
- 1:46:15custody thing like because the way I purt role play that one person, or
- 1:46:18just like I just want I just want this to go away. I don't
- 1:46:20want to cause a big uproar. I just I just want to use a
- 1:46:24little bit of a influence here to kind of push this person away, so
- 1:46:28I'll kind of intimate. So there's a situations like that. But often when
- 1:46:31there are false reports, it gets pretty fantastical, you know, because it's
- 1:46:35like, well, if I'm gonna lie, I'm gonna really go for it.
- 1:46:39And and even as an adult, you might say like, well,
- 1:46:44I'm going to really go for it because I don't want there to be any
- 1:46:46any ambiguity as to whether or not something happened. But the story remained,
- 1:46:51although definitively abusive, fairly nonsensational. Right, look a look at Okay,
- 1:46:59so let's use the logic right like we were saying, hey, why would
- 1:47:01I have fifty seven? Okay, Well, let's take it this all the
- 1:47:03way. So imagine Mia Farrow sitting there talking to I guess the babysitter,
- 1:47:08going hey, can I get you to say that? Um, let's see
- 1:47:11what could we make up? Oh? I get it right. He had
- 1:47:13his head in her lap. Wait what like doing what? No? No,
- 1:47:16just they're like just kind of I guess breathing in and wait what who
- 1:47:20does? What are you doing about? That one wasn't as definitive or that
- 1:47:26wasn't as sort of as much evidence as I think one of the friends of
- 1:47:30the family saw the two of them in bed naked or something. Absolutely no,
- 1:47:35But I'm using the other one as evidence of like why why would you
- 1:47:38make that up? Right? The thing is that if you don't actually have
- 1:47:43some sort of weird well, okay, I don't want to use these kind
- 1:47:45of terms, but if you don't have some patterns that are maybe unusual,
- 1:47:51then you probably wouldn't put your head in the lap of a seven year old
- 1:47:56and breathe in and out like what the naked like Like okay, but would
- 1:48:00Mia Pharaoh make that? Like now, I'm now I'm really questioning the logic,
- 1:48:04So I would expect things like, you know, the made up story
- 1:48:08would check out, the logic would check out, like, oh, yeah,
- 1:48:12you know he put his finger in her, Okay, fair enough,
- 1:48:14blah blah. But these other things, I'm like, wait what and that
- 1:48:18that's the kind of thing that I actually that points to. Okay, there
- 1:48:23are some very very very difficult attachment and psychological issues that are going on with
- 1:48:29him where he actually feels connected to her by doing something that almost is in
- 1:48:34sexual nature, except it kind of is in this bizarre way, right,
- 1:48:40Yeah, And we don't know the full extent of the because they actually didn't
- 1:48:43describe it. I think for reasons that I think have to do with maybe
- 1:48:49Dylan's desire for at least some privacy and also her PTSD. Actually, just
- 1:48:55a side note, when I saw her have the PTSD reaction, I thought,
- 1:48:59is she getting proper treatment? Because if if I was treating someone like
- 1:49:03her, I would tell her, Look, until you are habituated sufficiently to
- 1:49:09these stories, you can't talk about them in a documentary. You shouldn't even
- 1:49:12be thinking about it because you're gonna harm yourself. And you saw that harm
- 1:49:14happened during the documentary. I think she was told that. I think she
- 1:49:16talked about being told that, and she said, because remember there was a
- 1:49:20moment in which she said that she was advised by her therapist not to bring
- 1:49:25this back up and get traumatized. Well, you you watched it much with
- 1:49:29much more like attention than I did, maybe because it no pun intended.
- 1:49:34It touched me deeply, you know, It's like how so you know it's
- 1:49:39like kid traumatization, which I went through. So it's just I was sitting
- 1:49:45there thinking just a lot of the same thoughts we've talked about before. Man,
- 1:49:49these little kids. You know, I was five, she was probably
- 1:49:53I don't know how soon it started. She was at least seven. And
- 1:49:56you you don't know what's up. You don't know what the world is.
- 1:49:59You don't and all of a sudden you're confronted with something. And you know
- 1:50:02how she was talking about how she felt so guilty for a long time,
- 1:50:05thinking like why do I feel abused? Like, clearly nothing that bad happened
- 1:50:13to me, because I hear these other horror stories that are way worse,
- 1:50:15So what right do I have to feel? And I could relate to that
- 1:50:18because I think I've mentioned that for the longest time, I didn't even think
- 1:50:23it was abuse at all, I thought. In fact, I used to
- 1:50:25think it was sort of kind of cool that that had happened to me.
- 1:50:29Up until my probably nineteen or twenty, I felt that way. I felt
- 1:50:35like, oh, well, no, that was a cool thing that happened
- 1:50:39to me. It certainly never would have been like, oh woe is me?
- 1:50:43I was a victim, and you know, because I had no idea
- 1:50:46the trauma and damage that it was going to cause. You know, yeah,
- 1:50:50yeah, yeah. When we are in a vacuum and we have a
- 1:50:55society that denies the notions that would help a chat. When a child is
- 1:51:01being bullied at school, there's messages of there are bullies in the world.
- 1:51:08There are shows on Hannah Montana, for example, episodes about bullying. There's
- 1:51:14maybe even an anti bullying campaign at school where you watch a video or something
- 1:51:18and you're given at least a chance to understand that, as a victim of
- 1:51:23bullying, that it's not your fault when it comes to this sort of thing.
- 1:51:26We you know, we're so busted up about sexuality that we either have
- 1:51:31minimal education or exposure or we flat out give messages to everyone that if there's
- 1:51:38any sexual involvement or activity that there's something extremely shameful about it and there's something
- 1:51:44seriously wrong with you. So all these victims, including yourself, walking around
- 1:51:47because if you had been pushed down the stairs by your babysitter, you knew
- 1:51:53that you could run to your father and say, she pushed me down the
- 1:51:55stairs. But when she does this sort of thing to you, you're like,
- 1:51:59what am I supposed to do? I'm pretty sure I'm not supposed to
- 1:52:02tell anyone, because I'm pretty sure this is naughty stuff that you're not supposed
- 1:52:08to tell your parents, and no one seems to be talking about this sort
- 1:52:12of thing, so I guess I'm just not going to talk about it.
- 1:52:15And then you have to make up a story in your mind to cope,
- 1:52:16which is it was cool, rather than yeah, exactly admitting the what it
- 1:52:23also felt. I mean, it did feel like that, It did feel
- 1:52:26cool to you, but it also felt it didn't not at all like the
- 1:52:30actual situation of it, because I still have the pictures in my mind,
- 1:52:35and it never felt good, It never felt right. It always confused me.
- 1:52:40Yeah, it felt gross and I never understood what was happening, but
- 1:52:46the surrounding halo around it was Oh cool, I'm she likes me. That's
- 1:52:53the line she gave you. That's the vibe she gave you. Yeah,
- 1:52:56and well, and I looked up to her. I thought, you know,
- 1:53:00I thought she was pretty, she was older, she was she she
- 1:53:02was cool. So I'm like, oh, this is cool. She likes
- 1:53:08me, and and that must mean we could be boyfriend girlfriend or something.
- 1:53:11I mean, now I'm adding words, but it's like the sense of when
- 1:53:14I'm in a secret club. But the actual flashes I have, and I
- 1:53:18don't mean just like me interpreting them now as an adult. I mean,
- 1:53:23I remember the feelings and thoughts in some of those moments, and it was
- 1:53:29just confusing, like why am I doing? What? What? What is
- 1:53:35that like? It never made sense. It was never like yeah, that
- 1:53:40was not it. It's just everything surrounding. It was like, oh cool,
- 1:53:45yeah, secret cool, I'm in the club. Yeah, it's heartbreaking
- 1:53:49to think about you going through that little little bird, a little five year
- 1:53:54old bird. Oh yeah, man. And so then I was sitting there
- 1:53:56watching it. It must have been similar for Dylan where she's going, what
- 1:54:00is it going? Oh? But I guess this is daddy time. In
- 1:54:02fact, she said like maybe this is what daddy's doing. Right, Yeah,
- 1:54:06she said she went over to some other friend's house. Yea, and
- 1:54:13she was like, your dad doesn't like just glom onto you. I thought,
- 1:54:17I thought that's what dads did. Your dad just watches TV and doesn't
- 1:54:23bother you. Like I didn't know that daddies were like that. Yeah,
- 1:54:27this is heartbreaking to hear her talk about that. And right, all the
- 1:54:31lines of evidence, right that line of evidence, the observational evidence, the
- 1:54:36video evidence, like at all, you know, builds this pretty solid picture
- 1:54:44of the conceptualization that I was saying, where it was just complete obsession with
- 1:54:49her. And anyway, final question burto should we be able to watch his
- 1:54:56movies? I gotta be honest, man, I I was looking for reasons
- 1:55:03early in the documentary. I'm like, well, by the time I was
- 1:55:08done, because I'll tell you why, it's see with Michael Jackson. Maybe
- 1:55:14you know what, who knows, but I'll tell you what I was thinking.
- 1:55:17Okay, what he did was terrible and how traumatic to that little girl.
- 1:55:23But I could in some ways still feel empathy for the guy if I
- 1:55:26knew well he was abused to or he had these traumatic things. And then
- 1:55:30he ended up, you know, coming out and saying, yeah, this
- 1:55:33happened, and now he's in treatment stuff, and like I would feel for
- 1:55:38him somewhat, you know, but it's the opposite. If if this happened,
- 1:55:44then he's a monster because he has It's not just that he did that
- 1:55:49is that he's turned this whole family into a mess and accused like the mom
- 1:55:56of the worst things and taking his step and her step her daughter and married
- 1:56:01her like the whole thing, right, makes him a monster. Right,
- 1:56:05So if he let's say he did it, there are various different ways he
- 1:56:11could have tried to extract himself or protect himself, but he decided to attack
- 1:56:16Mia. Yeah, psychopathically, dude. Right. He could have just said,
- 1:56:21look, it didn't happen. I don't know why Mia saying it didn't.
- 1:56:25You know, he could have just can and he probably still would have
- 1:56:27gotten out of it. But he didn't do that. He systematically and they
- 1:56:31portrayed this in a documentary. We don't know the accuracy, but it seemed
- 1:56:34that there's evidence that he actually told me, no, I'm not going to
- 1:56:39go to the press, and then he went to the press. You know,
- 1:56:41let's not go to the press, and then he goes to the press.
- 1:56:43Yeah yeah, so yeah. Now, if if I'm wrong, if
- 1:56:46the documentary is biased and this was the thing and it turns out this is
- 1:56:49all one big mind game and everything, well, apologies to mister Allen.
- 1:56:55But if I am to believe the data in front of me, which seems
- 1:56:59compelling, then f him. Man, I'm done. I will not miss
- 1:57:04it because now every time I watch one of his stupid movies, I'm gonna
- 1:57:09sit there seeing that abuse happening. And it's even worse in the sense because,
- 1:57:15like you know, I've told you, I think that there are now
- 1:57:18some Michael Jackson songs that I can't listen to without getting creeped out. But
- 1:57:24there are some where I still kind pretty yeah, but there are some that
- 1:57:28I still look the other way because I guess their songs are so fucking good,
- 1:57:31but I don't have to, like look at someone doing things that are
- 1:57:35basically kind of creepy in the first place. I don't know, maybe it's
- 1:57:40too soon, but I felt towards the end of that documentary, I was
- 1:57:45like, I'm done. I believe this and I'm done. I mean I
- 1:57:48was. I was still trying to evaluate that, but hearing you talk about
- 1:57:53it, yeah, I mean I see that. I'm convinced by your by
- 1:58:01your take on its heartbreaking. If you really just think, I mean,
- 1:58:04you just really have to think. Okay, what if he did it,
- 1:58:09which it seems like he did. He's a monster, And how can you
- 1:58:14watch his face in a movie? Now? He's not in all of his
- 1:58:18movies, so what about what about the movies where he's not in it?
- 1:58:24You know, like Midnight in Paris with Olwen Wilson. Yeah, can you
- 1:58:27watch that movie? Or is it or is that the man behind it?
- 1:58:30I don't know that. Those are always great questions. It's hard. I
- 1:58:33will say this once again, and I don't want this to sound wrong.
- 1:58:39It's just the actual I'm not bothered by the acts because even though the acts
- 1:58:45are horrible and poor little girl and all these things, I'm like, well,
- 1:58:48if if that had come out and he had like fest fest up and
- 1:58:55really embraced the fact that he's damaged and that he needed help and then apologize,
- 1:59:00and it's not like it excuses it. He probably would have still should
- 1:59:02have served time, done whatever, right, But since not only did that
- 1:59:08not happen, but it was the extreme opposite. That's where I have to
- 1:59:12leave that short. But as far as like movies that he wrote or whatever
- 1:59:15that I don't know, I I don't know. I just can't look at
- 1:59:19him right now. Yeah, and I haven't talked about this yet, but
- 1:59:24I feel like it's important for me to say that I am a I was,
- 1:59:28or am a huge Woody Allen movie fan. I in my office at
- 1:59:32Antioch, I had very separate posters, and you could guess some of them.
- 1:59:38There. There's a Star Wars poster, there's a clockwork orange poster.
- 1:59:43There's a Logan's Run poster, and an Annie Hall poster big basketball. Annie
- 1:59:48Hall had a huge effect on me when I was a kid. When I
- 1:59:53saw it, I had There have been so many copycats of Anie Hall,
- 1:59:58but it was the first of its kind. Almost every rom com you've ever
- 2:00:01seen has its roots in that movie. Any movie that's or any TV show
- 2:00:08that's about just youngish, twenty thirty something people that don't have kids living their
- 2:00:14lives. You know, just the scenes that Woody Allen wrote and created and
- 2:00:20Diane Keaton, and the vibe of it is it holds up today. You
- 2:00:27watch Annie Hall today, it's still good and it was made nineteen seventy seven,
- 2:00:30when a lot of crappy moves were being made. You know, now
- 2:00:33the seventies are kind of a golden era of movies, but in terms of
- 2:00:35rom coms and those kinds of movies, you'd be hard pressed to find a
- 2:00:39movie that even comes close to Annie Halp. Maybe you know the graduate,
- 2:00:45but these are very particular movies, you know, and incredible talent. And
- 2:00:49then the next year he makes Interiors, which is a complete departure from Annie
- 2:00:54Hall. Interiors is a very depressing movie about a enmeshed family. And when
- 2:00:59I saw this movie movie in my twenties, it deeply affected. It's one
- 2:01:03of the lesser known movies. But if you're interested in a just a and
- 2:01:09the cinema, it gives me chills. The cinema talks. So in Annie
- 2:01:12Hall, you don't think of cinematography. You think of acting, You think
- 2:01:15of writing, you think of storytelling, you think of humor, you think
- 2:01:16of romcom stuff. Interiors is a completely different style of movie. That was
- 2:01:23you know, the true a tour and someone who could make a you know,
- 2:01:28Christopher Nolan makes a movie of five years what he Allen makes a movie
- 2:01:30every nine months, and half of them are our genius movies, you know
- 2:01:34what I mean, considered you know, to be a third Anyway, could
- 2:01:39we take some solace, some comfort in hoping that he had not yet become
- 2:01:44a monster at those ages? Well, nineteen seventy nine he makes Manhattan with
- 2:01:49Mariel Hemingway, you know, And okay, but say, could we again?
- 2:01:55I'm just you know, he hadn't done anything horrible. Well not only
- 2:01:58that, No, he was dating a seven year old, you know,
- 2:02:00at different times, different moras. People actually kind of look sideways at those
- 2:02:04things. Whatever. Well, I don't know. I mean, if you're
- 2:02:05looking for an excuse to be able to watch his movies, you know that.
- 2:02:09I guess I'm more. I'm more. Actually, what I'm thinking is
- 2:02:13at which point in the history of a human being do we cut them off?
- 2:02:17Because clearly, especially if you're a parent, right, Like, imagine
- 2:02:21you're a parent of someone who became a psychle killer or something, right,
- 2:02:25but you still have those memories of them as a child. Well, you're
- 2:02:28a parent, it's completely different, right, But maybe you're not a parent.
- 2:02:30Maybe you just knew you you were the preschool teacher of that of that
- 2:02:34kid. You're saying, like Woody Ellen, pre you know, let's say
- 2:02:40there was a moment where he crossed the line with Dylan and that was the
- 2:02:44first time he'd ever done anything. We don't know that, but let's say
- 2:02:46that that was. So are you saying that everything he made before that date
- 2:02:51is okay for us to watch and everything after us not. I'm more I'm
- 2:02:57more making a mental point for myself about when do I start loathing this individual
- 2:03:02in their history? Do I go back to their very inception as a baby,
- 2:03:08or do I pick up point in time? And I guess for me,
- 2:03:10the point in time is the moment when he was confronted by Mia Farrow
- 2:03:17and he ran, and he ran, and he grabbed pitchforks and came back
- 2:03:24with pitchforks and fire. That's the moment in which I turn away. And
- 2:03:28I'm not saying that therefore the movies made starting that year. I'm just saying,
- 2:03:31as a person, that's where I departed shorts. And now I don't
- 2:03:34know what happened before then. Maybe before then there was even more horrors.
- 2:03:39Who knows, But all I know is that's where you leave me. Because
- 2:03:43I can have empathy for people that have done terrible things based on what they've
- 2:03:47done afterwards. Yeah. Yeah, Hannah and her sisters, just a classic
- 2:03:54whitty Allen in a movie with Mia Farrow, Michael Kane, Carrie Fisher.
- 2:03:58Crimes and Misdemeanors. This was the first one that I would have seen in
- 2:04:01the theater because I was in college and I remember going down to the theater
- 2:04:06on on the av um. What was that called the varse. No,
- 2:04:12there was the varsity and then there was a Neptune Varsity. Yeah, No,
- 2:04:15it was varsity and then there was Neptune. Yeah. Anyway, match
- 2:04:19Point again, total departure. Have you seen Match Point with Scarlett Johanson and
- 2:04:25Jonathan rees Myers. No, I have not. It is h it's like
- 2:04:29that recent. No, it was fifteen years ago, but it was.
- 2:04:31It's a thriller and it's like a murder thriller and it's it's not funny,
- 2:04:40you know, and it's just a masterpiece of movie. Vicky Christie Barcelona with
- 2:04:46Penelope Cruz, Heavier Bardem and Scarlett Johanson. Just a beautiful movie. Midnight
- 2:04:55in Paris Light Owen Wilson goes back in time to the times of Hemingway and
- 2:05:02I Scott Fitzgerald Just a real, real cute movie. Twenty thirteen, Blue
- 2:05:09Jasmine, Alec Baldwin, Kate Blanchet, Andrew dice Clay. Just a beautiful
- 2:05:15look into a character that Kate Blanchett plays. You know, she was this
- 2:05:19rich lady and then I think she went through a divorce or something and she
- 2:05:24didn't have anything anymore and all she had or their expensive luggage, and it's
- 2:05:30just a it's just a beautifully written story and a classic. And you know,
- 2:05:36he doesn't just have one or two classics. He's got like, you
- 2:05:40know, fifteen or ten just solid, solid movies and and part of the
- 2:05:46film. You can't talk about film history without talking about Woody Allen through several
- 2:05:51decades. And yeah, and I was a huge fan, and I was
- 2:05:57one of those people you know that would annoy people at parties, you know,
- 2:06:00like, uh, going like you gotta see interiors. It's masterpiece,
- 2:06:06would you know, blah blah blah blah blah. Like I'm one of those
- 2:06:09people. And now I don't know what to do because because because I think
- 2:06:15it's just like I don't want to give him money if he's if he is
- 2:06:18a monster. I don't want to validate him. I don't want to see
- 2:06:21his face if he's a monster. But I have a relationship with interiors.
- 2:06:26I have a relationship with with Hannah and her sister. I've I have a
- 2:06:30relationship with any Hall. You know when when Diane Keaton, where's that outfit
- 2:06:35with the with the tie and the hat and the vest, like, and
- 2:06:41she and all her quirkiness and insecurity, like, I have a relationship with
- 2:06:44her and that character. Yeah, and that's a part of me. And
- 2:06:53you know, when I listened to a pretty young thing, even that song,
- 2:06:58I'm transported back to when I was eleven years old and we had Thriller
- 2:07:01and we'd put it on the record player and me and all my family would
- 2:07:04listen front to back, front to back, and every my older siblings,
- 2:07:09my younger brother, my parents. Everyone loved that album. Everyone in the
- 2:07:12whole community. The videos, my cousins might. We would sit around and,
- 2:07:15oh, you know, beat it is on MTV. Everyone sit down
- 2:07:20and watch it. Everyone in the family to sit down and watch Michael Jackie's
- 2:07:24pastes. And if he did it, then what do I do with that?
- 2:07:29Bill Cosby Show? The Cosby Show I actually have something I have to
- 2:07:31admit. I was kind of just channel surfing about a month ago and the
- 2:07:36Cosby Show came up, and me and my wife we watched an episode of
- 2:07:41it. Because it's said, you know, it's not an amazing show,
- 2:07:47but it's it's it's delightful. You know, it's light, it's from that
- 2:07:54time. It's actually something that was way before it's time, and that there's
- 2:08:00almost no white people in the entire show. In fact, the episode that
- 2:08:03I saw there wasn't any white people, now right, Is that a definition
- 2:08:07of a good show? No, but the progressiveness of not only having every
- 2:08:11family member black, but you don't have like the token white neighbor. But
- 2:08:16there was also the oldest daughter was giving birth, and so the doctors are
- 2:08:22black, the nurses are black, the spouse is black. You know,
- 2:08:26everyone's black. Yeah, this is middle of the eighties. This is a
- 2:08:31long time ago. And Bill Cosby was the engineer of that. He was
- 2:08:37the one who said, no, I'm going to strong arm NBC or whoever
- 2:08:41was in charge, and you know that they were like, we got to
- 2:08:43make this more relatable the white people. Most of your audiences white people.
- 2:08:46You can't you gotta have some white characters. And Bill Cosby said, no,
- 2:08:50this is not gonna happen. Yeah, totally imagine though, So imagine.
- 2:08:56Imagine our our mutual friend Chong shows up at your house one day and
- 2:09:01he grabs a bat and he hits you on the arm multiple times, breaks
- 2:09:05your arm, and then you're telling me, dude, I'm like, hey,
- 2:09:09have you seen Chong? And You're like, no, I'll never see
- 2:09:11him again. I'm so upset at him. I might see him. I'm
- 2:09:15like, well, well he broke my arm with a bat. Oh wow.
- 2:09:18Anyways, I'm throwing a party this this weekend. Oh, he's going
- 2:09:20to be here. Like wait, did you just hear what I said?
- 2:09:22Oh? Yeah, no, I mean that sucks. Like yeah, don't
- 2:09:24get me wrong, I'll be upset at him. Yeah, but anyways,
- 2:09:28he'll be here. He's you know, he's fun at parties. Well that's
- 2:09:30different. Okay. I get the analogy, and I appreciate it, but
- 2:09:33it's different because I'm not I'm not calling what he allen and saying I love
- 2:09:37your work, you know what I mean. I know I'm privately sitting and
- 2:09:39watching a movie on Netflix or something. I just I feel like imagine Chong
- 2:09:43is a creator, but it is. But it is something that because Dylan
- 2:09:46Farrow is a human being that deserves a lot of grace and justice. And
- 2:09:54if I'm just and you know, if I'm going to be a part of
- 2:09:58this, it's sort of like global warming is happening. Do I just say,
- 2:10:01well, what am I? You know, I'm just one person?
- 2:10:03Am I just gopsa to say well, I'm just one person? You know?
- 2:10:05Dylan Faroh and many other people who have been victimized or people who want
- 2:10:09to stand by victims, are you know, they're saying, Okay, yeah,
- 2:10:15do I love the movies. Yeah, but it's a small price to
- 2:10:18pay to stand up for what's right and to stand by Dylan farre and to
- 2:10:22stand with other victims that I'm just not going to watch his movies and I'm
- 2:10:26also going to speak out. And you know, now, one could argue
- 2:10:30that on this podcast, we do a lot of ADA advocacy, including this
- 2:10:35episode. Maybe not particularly this episode, but we do a lot of episodes
- 2:10:41on victim advocacy. Maybe I've paid my dues so that I can watch his
- 2:10:46movies. Now, yeah, I mean it's it's hard because, like you
- 2:10:50take the Chong example. Chong becomes famous, he's famous, he's all over
- 2:10:54the place, and he's got a TV show. That's what it is.
- 2:10:56He's got a T show. And again, you come over to my house
- 2:10:58and I'm watching the Chong Show and you're like, dude, and it's actually
- 2:11:01worse. It's not just that he broke your arm. He ruined your a
- 2:11:05lot of parts of your life. Well, I would expect that Dylan Pharaoh's
- 2:11:09friends are not watching Woody Allen movies when she comes over. But I'm not
- 2:11:13Dylan Pharaoh's friend, you know. And so but then you go to the
- 2:11:16media and you tell everyone, and I was like, okay, okay,
- 2:11:18But then every cafe you go to, everywhere you go, people are watching
- 2:11:22the Chong show. Yeah, and everyone's not only that, they're talking about
- 2:11:26it. And then you tell them the story and they're like, yeah,
- 2:11:28but you know, he's just so entertaining. But listen, I hear you
- 2:11:33because I have the same struggles with things. I like that, like Woody
- 2:11:37Allen. What's funny is you've watched so many Woody Allen movies. I was
- 2:11:41looking forward honestly that I had this long backlog of Woody Allen movies that I
- 2:11:45want to watch that I keep hearing so many great things about. And now
- 2:11:48I am like, have you seen any of the Woody Allen movies? I
- 2:11:50talked about a couple, but most of them know Yeah, And so then
- 2:11:54Stacy Stay, I'm just completely the guy makes so many movies. How could
- 2:12:00you not see some of Stacy hasn't seen any Hall? Have you seen any
- 2:12:03Hall? Oh? Yeah, of course, Oh okay. And and but
- 2:12:07so I'm sitting there going what do I do? I wanted to watch those
- 2:12:09movies, their cinema history. I've been looking forward, like the Ane,
- 2:12:15Barcelona, Vicky whatever the hell I love? You got to see that one.
- 2:12:20I've been looking forward to that movie so long, dude. It's really
- 2:12:22good. And I love Owen Wilson, and I love Alec Ball like I
- 2:12:24love all these people. Yeah, I mean they broke my arm. Yeah.
- 2:12:28I don't know if Blue Jasmine is at the top of the list,
- 2:12:31but Vicky Christina Barcelona, Midnight Paris is cute. Match point though, Man
- 2:12:35with Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Reespires match point so good, Hanna, our Sisters,
- 2:12:41Michael Caine just so good, so good, Manhattan beautiful. Yeah,
- 2:12:48it's not. Let me make another point, which is that I don't have
- 2:12:50proof, right, So it's not like I'm saying like, yeah, we
- 2:12:54should boycott and all these Okay, I have no proof. All I'm saying
- 2:12:58is like me personally, gosh, I find it really difficult after watching that
- 2:13:03documentary to watch this man acting on a movie. Now it's a movie,
- 2:13:07he's not on screen. Maybe it's not as big of a problem for me.
- 2:13:11Yeah, when when you talked through your passionate reasoning, I was like,
- 2:13:16oh boy, I yeah, how could you? How can I now
- 2:13:22watch any How can I even look at his face and not have my blood
- 2:13:26boiling? Now that you've sort of put it that way, now, I
- 2:13:31think Dylan is the main person that we should be caring about. And I
- 2:13:35don't know, but I suspect she doesn't care if I watch a movie.
- 2:13:39I think she cares mostly about Do I believe her? And do I advocate
- 2:13:45for victims who come forward and advocate for people to listen to them, and
- 2:13:50you know, tout the statistics that show that people almost never lie about the
- 2:13:56sort of thing and talk about how victims are often over the coals, particularly
- 2:14:01when the perpetrator is famous and powerful. I'm pretty sure Dylan mostly cares about
- 2:14:07that, and that I will say that I will stand by Dylan faroll that
- 2:14:09I will say I do believe her. I will state that, I will
- 2:14:15state that she deserves justice. I will state that no one should be attacking
- 2:14:18her. And if you are, like, what's wrong with how would you
- 2:14:22possibly know that she's lying? There clearly isn't much evidence that she's lying.
- 2:14:28So at the very least, the best you could say is you don't know,
- 2:14:33you know. The best you could say is, well, you know
- 2:14:35who. But to say that she's a liar or to attack her is u
- 2:14:41is criminal. And you know, God bless you if you're one of those
- 2:14:43people and some and someone does something to you and you come forward and no
- 2:14:48one believes you, how crappy would that be. Now, of course there's
- 2:14:50the whole other set of people that are falsely accused of things. But anyway,
- 2:14:54the point is is that I'm not forgetting, not forgetting too, Suni
- 2:15:01and Mia and uh Um Mason, you know, Um the other little boy,
- 2:15:07Moses and all the other little kids in that family. Who I mean,
- 2:15:11think of Mia, like, think of how assuming that she's telling the
- 2:15:16through other ones, think of how much trauma he caused her. Yeah,
- 2:15:18yeah, yeah that. The last thing I'll say is I want to buy
- 2:15:26a house just like theirs. And one of the first thoughts I had is
- 2:15:31because the documentary it, you know, a lot of the interviews take place
- 2:15:35in their house, you know, me and me of the house that they
- 2:15:37grew up in. And I thought, because sometimes they'll rent a house to
- 2:15:43do interviews in. Actually leaving Netherland was that way where they I could tell
- 2:15:48that they rented a fancy house and then interviewed them all in different parts of
- 2:15:52the house. And I when I was seeing the beginning of documentary, I
- 2:15:58was like, that house is too too cute, it's too cool looking.
- 2:16:01That can't be the house that anyone lives in. But it is. I
- 2:16:05mean, the way it was even decorated, I want to decorate my house
- 2:16:09like that like they. It just had all these little pizzas of art and
- 2:16:15you know it's kind of randomly distributed around the house, and those big windows
- 2:16:20and that sloping lawn down to the water, and the little fences and just
- 2:16:30the hominess of it all and the all the toys that are around. It
- 2:16:35just looked like it just looked like a comfortable, artsy, fun, energetic,
- 2:16:43chaotic but good. I just I want that house. Yeah all right,
- 2:16:48well that doesn't for that episode of psychology in Seattle. Everyone out there,
- 2:16:52please take care of yourself, because you deserve it,