Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / What Role Do Relationships Play In Healing Attachment Wounds?
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:20It's Thursday, April 24th, 2025 at 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:26Time. Then I thought that I would talk
- 0:28about It's a funny idea and really pertinent to our times
- 0:39because we probably couldn't have had this topic until quite
- 0:43recently. But the topic is how important
- 0:47are relationships and repairing attachment?
- 0:57I get so many requests from people saying can't we use AI to
- 1:02automate the adult attachment interview?
- 1:05Can we get AI to automate the ideal parent figure protocol?
- 1:10Can't we get AI to replace human beings all together and so we
- 1:14can have our attachment box take care of our attachment repair?
- 1:20Which is hilarious in a way. Christian.
- 1:28George, I have a whole harem of AI girlfriends and like, I don't
- 1:32even need this attachment stuff anymore.
- 1:39You know, my position has always been that the telephone company,
- 1:43had they added attachments, could have kept their monopoly.
- 1:49You pushed on one end, it pulls on the other.
- 1:59It's not an interesting thing, the dilemma of that the, you
- 2:06know, the human condition being what it is.
- 2:09We don't, we're really bored at self perception.
- 2:13That's it's not really the thing.
- 2:14One of the things that's built into it, but we really are good
- 2:18at it, is monitoring people's reaction to us and understanding
- 2:22how we are in relationship to that.
- 2:26And if we go with these bots, which are simply reflective of
- 2:29our inner life with, with no contrast to actually be able to
- 2:35see ourselves off, we go into, I'm going to guess, epic
- 2:40delusion beyond what we're ordinarily humanly capable of,
- 2:46rather than some deep, deep insight into the nature of
- 2:51ourselves and our conditioning. You could talk about attachment
- 2:57simply as attachment conditioning.
- 3:00What I like about it is in the Buddhist endeavour to see
- 3:05clearly the nature of the human condition and understand the,
- 3:09the spiritual nature of this life.
- 3:12The the, the pathway to do that is to examine our conditioning.
- 3:25We have that conundrum of the human conditioning to be so much
- 3:29like everybody else, all of the humans, we're just so much
- 3:32alike. Yes, we could make a division, a
- 3:37strong division between the male sex and female sex, but still so
- 3:44similar. And then culture and then class
- 3:49and all of these things that divide up this perception of us.
- 3:54But still we're journeying. All of us are journeying
- 3:59together in this human body, which has a limited range of
- 4:03sensing capacities, which is a limited range of intellectual
- 4:07processing, physical prowess, and we're all confined by these
- 4:15similar constraints. And then our conditioning is
- 4:19completely unique. And so the meaning that we're
- 4:22free to assign what happens to us is unique to us based on
- 4:30that, the accumulation of conditioned responses to things.
- 4:39And it's compounding. We make a meaning of something
- 4:42and then we use it later as a reference to make a meaning to
- 4:45something else. And some of these memory
- 4:50threads, these meaning threads, go all the way back to the very
- 4:54beginning of life, even before there's a sense of self, even
- 4:58before there's a a language or a definition of anything that
- 5:05somatic experience of life. I, Antonio Damasio talked quite
- 5:23a bit about the self. I I I, I quite like the the way
- 5:26that he talked about it. I think it's, is it Bray
- 5:30Kurtzweil who was the these great proponent of singularity
- 5:35where we simply merge with the machine.
- 5:40I keep thinking merge with the machine.
- 5:44There's so much pleasure in this body, so much pain too.
- 5:48But did you ever want to grab on to a machine the way that you
- 5:53want to grab on to a body? Did you ever want a machine to
- 5:59smile at you the way you like some people to smile at you?
- 6:05It's it's, it's silly. Most of the time when I think
- 6:10about that Christian. Or do you know in Terminator 2?
- 6:17At the very long. When they lower him down into
- 6:19the lava Like I've always fantasized about someone giving
- 6:21me a thumbs up like like that. I don't actually remember.
- 6:28That great? It's a great movie.
- 6:30It's always worth rewatch. Jane, you know the, the, the big
- 6:39mission in life is to actually tell somebody who you are
- 6:42authentically and completely and, and have them sit there
- 6:46and, and be totally happy to be in your company, totally
- 6:49delighted to be in your company. Of course, the insecure response
- 6:54is always that they would leave. Lucy seems to be wanting to go
- 6:58on an adventure. There you go.
- 7:13So I would say yes, you, you, you.
- 7:15You need to to be in relationship to other people in
- 7:20order to begin to effect the change and attachment because
- 7:23you need to have the confidence that when you express yourself
- 7:27authentically that people's response will be interest and
- 7:32delight and not searching frantically for the exits, which
- 7:38is what some of us envisioned Mudit do.
- 7:49Do do people define the delight aspect differently?
- 7:54I would think that it's it's based on what the expression of
- 7:57delight was in your family system.
- 7:59But at the same time, because we're so similar, the the
- 8:03mechanism is built into the to the human space suit that we all
- 8:08wander around in, you know? I've noticed some people say
- 8:17that oh I'm paying the light in you, but the receiver doesn't
- 8:20receive it because it's not the same way that.
- 8:22Right. You don't recognize it, but then
- 8:26really, you know, the mission of people is to learn them and to
- 8:29learn their expressions so that you can transliterate what you
- 8:34need to into the terms that they understand.
- 8:41I remember when I was a kid, if, if you did something wrong and
- 8:48my dad was about to lay into you, he would always go and,
- 8:56and, and then you knew that it was coming.
- 9:01And then I had a friend who would go, oh, when he was about
- 9:06to offer comfort, but I would just brace and be ready when,
- 9:10when he did that, even though he was saying something completely
- 9:14different. And so there is the
- 9:16transliteration, that automatic response of how the terms were
- 9:21defined in my family versus the automatic response and his
- 9:27family, you know, and some of the some of the condition is
- 9:32pretty deep. If you say, oh, to me, I'm
- 9:34bracive, then how did how did your caregivers do it?
- 9:44How did they do it? How did they communicate to you?
- 9:48And when you get to know somebody, can you understand how
- 9:52the conditioning is around that they're ready to go based on
- 9:56that? And so when you speak to them
- 9:58and when you try to respond, when you try to express
- 10:05something that you want them to know and it's different, can
- 10:08you, do you have the mentalizing capacity to translate it fast
- 10:13enough so that you're actually actually effective and
- 10:16communicating? You're following me on that one.
- 10:23So, you know, if you're talking to me that you don't say, oh,
- 10:26let me comfort you. You say let me comfort you.
- 10:38Did you have delight when you were a kid?
- 10:41And if you didn't, how do you learn?
- 10:43Learn it. That's the the operation of all
- 10:46of this. How do we learn to be in
- 10:51relationship to other people? How do we learn people well
- 10:54enough? How do we learn the vocabulary
- 10:56of someone else so that we feel safe in relationship to them?
- 11:06Hold on one second. Need to address Lucy.
- 11:13Lucy, come on. He appears to have the zoomies.
- 11:26I don't know if you have a dog, but that's running around.
- 11:37The way that you're you're supposed to address it is by
- 11:39confining the spaces so that they're away from the stimulus.
- 11:44I guess we're a lot like that too.
- 11:57In the, you know, the stages of secure attachment, the first one
- 12:00is feeling safe. How do you feel safe?
- 12:04And children have low intensity limits so that the intensity in
- 12:11the environment needs to be controlled and needs to be
- 12:15predictable for them so they can anticipate what's going to
- 12:18happen. And those are the things that
- 12:24tend to undermine secure attachment and things that are
- 12:30too intense, the range of expressions that are too wide so
- 12:35the child can't manage them. Something predictable, but not
- 12:43predictable for an adult, of course, predictable for a child
- 12:48so that the child can express themselves authentically.
- 12:55And so I, I often call it the arrogance of the secure, which
- 12:58is this expectation that you can express yourself authentically
- 13:02and people will be responsive to you.
- 13:06Because if you didn't grow up with that, you can't really do
- 13:09it very well because you're always anticipating some
- 13:13different kind of outcome. And so the effort, the
- 13:17effortlessness, the freedom isn't, isn't there.
- 13:19Everything has to be mapped and predicted and calculated Mudit.
- 13:28So even expectation not for everybody, but for extremely few
- 13:33number of people, because otherwise you'll come off as
- 13:36arrogant. You know, if, well, it's not I,
- 13:47I would guess it's not exactly arrogance, but if your
- 13:51expectation is that people will pay attention to you and be
- 13:53responsive to you, that can cause confusion.
- 13:59But they don't and it could cause a demand when they don't.
- 14:04You can be demanding of that kind of attention.
- 14:06I think that that's a good thing and necessarily, but it can also
- 14:16produce a confusion in secure people why insecure people can't
- 14:24do it. The Dunning Kruger thing of if I
- 14:31can do it, you should be able to do it.
- 14:32How hard is it? I've always been able to do it.
- 14:35Why can't you do it? And the reason you can't do it
- 14:40is because of arduous, terrible, terrifying conditioning that
- 14:45makes it virtually impossible to be able to do it without
- 14:49significant intervention and training.
- 14:51But they don't have any of those experiences, so they can't
- 14:55relate to them. They never had to lie.
- 14:58They never had to hide. They never had to defend in in
- 15:03that way. And, and actually, they're not
- 15:10that good at it, so they can't even appreciate the level of
- 15:19deceit that one could get into if it were so simple.
- 15:29All you'd have to do is hear it once.
- 15:31Oh, don't do that. No need.
- 15:34Just be authentic. But the, the whole emotional
- 15:39response to it, it's so intense. It's not possible really.
- 15:44The authentic thing, if you, if you have access to it, appears
- 15:48in the mind, of course, but then you're immediately in that
- 15:52process of making reality into what action to take and what
- 15:56outcome is going to be the result of that.
- 16:02And most of the time our expectations are based on things
- 16:05that have happened. And so if you have the
- 16:09expectation that things are going to go well and your, your,
- 16:12your needs and wants are going to be considered, it's a very
- 16:14different way of presenting yourself.
- 16:16And if you you're afraid that you'll be attacked or you're,
- 16:22you're afraid that your needs and wants won't be considered,
- 16:28it's very different. So for those of us who have the
- 16:35conditioning of insecure, disorganized attachment, it was
- 16:38an arduous journey to get there. And while it's not so bad coming
- 16:46back from it, it still is a journey back.
- 16:49And it comes from rebuilding, in a way, the perceptual database,
- 16:55the, the capacity of the assigning of meaning to things.
- 17:02The authentic thing arises in the mind.
- 17:04If it frightens you that you'll be abandoned, then there's a
- 17:09spike of abandonment terror. And then immediately in the mind
- 17:13arises the inauthentic thing that you could do instead.
- 17:17And if you push into that, it immediately relieves the
- 17:19abandonment here, which is where the delusion is.
- 17:22In that Buddhist sense. You think that you're entering
- 17:27into security by being inauthentic because it relieves
- 17:32the abandonment terror, but it puts you in a state of
- 17:37deprivation, which tends to produce anger.
- 17:40You don't ask for the things that you want, so you don't get
- 17:43them, and you're in a state of deprivation.
- 17:45In fact, if you don't test it at all, you think that if you ask
- 17:49for the things that you want, you'll be abandoned because
- 17:52that's what happened. And then you're mad.
- 17:57You're mad that you can't ask authentically for what you need.
- 18:01You're mad that the other person is going to abandon you even
- 18:04though there's no indication from them.
- 18:08This is all in your meaning threads.
- 18:15And then you express, of course, if you do push into
- 18:23authenticity, it didn't, it exacerbates the abandonment
- 18:29here. Then if you can hold that space,
- 18:31you're just sideswiped by the terrible sadness, which is the
- 18:35recognition that actually you're the one who's been depriving
- 18:41yourself of authentic connection, not anyone else, by
- 18:47simply refusing to be authentic. Now, there's a hierarchy.
- 18:52Obviously some people you tell everything too and some people
- 18:55who don't. But there are many of us that
- 18:59just don't tell anybody everything.
- 19:02They're just not. It's just not it.
- 19:06I worked for a a dozen years in rehab and it was said over and
- 19:11over again, well, I don't tell anyone everything, but I do tell
- 19:19everything to five different people.
- 19:21Does that count? And actually the answer to that
- 19:27is no, it doesn't. George, there's one thing that I
- 19:38just kept forgetting to ask is the the abandonment Ted or we
- 19:43use this word. It would be like using a
- 19:50synonym, synonym as saying the fear of being alone.
- 19:54Why don't we use that instead? Because it's more because I
- 20:00don't think it's the same thing. That I'll be alone and hence I
- 20:09will not survive. Alone, you know, when we when
- 20:15you get into exploring and to really pursuing meaning the
- 20:21aloneness is actually an advantage often where you get to
- 20:25be totally engaged without having to address the the
- 20:32attention of other people and in abandonment terror.
- 20:38The idea is that when you need help, it won't be available to
- 20:43you. When you need comfort, it won't
- 20:44be available to you. When you need protection, it
- 20:50won't be available to you. Now, some of us can say there,
- 20:56I'm afraid I'll be alone forever, which is one thing, but
- 21:03then also in abandonment. Here the idea is that you
- 21:07express yourself to somebody and in seeing who you are, they
- 21:12withdraw from you because they're repelled in some way by
- 21:16who you are. That would be abandoned that in
- 21:20that most vulnerable moment when you turn to somebody and you
- 21:23express to them the thing that's essential for you to express and
- 21:28they react to that in horror and withdraw nature of that.
- 21:38How do you know whether you're safe with somebody's if you
- 21:43don't tell them everything? You don't.
- 21:46And so the anxiety that they could abandoned you is always
- 21:50there. Whereas if you're free to tell
- 21:54them everything with the expectation that not only will
- 21:57they stay, but they'll be delighted by your point of view.
- 22:00It's a very different expression.
- 22:05I I use the metaphor of coming out of the theater.
- 22:08You're you can't wait to tell the person you saw the movie
- 22:12with that it's the worst piece of dog dude that you've ever
- 22:16seen. And just as the words are about
- 22:19to come out of your mouth, they look at you with this goofy
- 22:22smile and say, that's the most moving picture I've ever seen.
- 22:31What do you do? Are you free to say, Oh my God,
- 22:35that was the worst piece of crap I ever saw?
- 22:37But if you see it and it just roll into a discussion where
- 22:41neither one of you are afraid that that you have a different
- 22:48opinion, right? Or do you clamp up and go along
- 22:54with the idea that it's an award winner in the future?
- 23:04Can you tell somebody what's going on with you with with No
- 23:12Fear that that it will push them away?
- 23:19As John Balby famously said, you're only as needy as your
- 23:22unmet needs. If you're in a relationship
- 23:28where you never express your authentic needs, you're in a
- 23:30constant state of neediness. It's not it doesn't happen very
- 23:37well often that they coincide. But if you're free to ask for
- 23:45your needs and you're you're the people in your lives not meet
- 23:48those needs, then you're not needy.
- 23:51We always we, we don't. You make a request of your
- 24:01caregiver and your caregiver is overwhelmed by the request and
- 24:05can't meet the needs. They blame you for them.
- 24:09And so we begin to understand ourselves as needy.
- 24:13We begin to understand our needs as being unreasonable.
- 24:17But what 6 month old is capable of manufacturing unreasonable
- 24:23needs? And a year old?
- 24:28What 1 year old is capable of manufacturing unreasonable needs
- 24:33and being so demanding? There isn't intent in that.
- 24:40The range is. It might exceed the caregivers
- 24:44range, but it isn't a child's calculation to be demanding to
- 24:53be too demanding. What's the the percentage across
- 25:01the population of secure versus insecure and disorganized?
- 25:06Depends on the research group. I would say that the numbers
- 25:18that are most commonly quoted are 65% secure. 15% dismissing,
- 25:3015% preoccupied and less than 5% disorganized.
- 25:36But if you examine those numbers, what you would see is
- 25:38that they're they're studies that were done at elite colleges
- 25:45and universities and they excluded for poverty.
- 25:51So, and that really is part of the whole political class of
- 25:56the, you know, professional manager and the the focus on the
- 26:01ideal being that 10% of the upper middle class.
- 26:06So I would say that in the upper middle class those numbers
- 26:09probably hold pretty well. If you look at the same group,
- 26:15but don't exclude for poverty, it drops to 55%.
- 26:18But if you were to do a meta study of the of the population,
- 26:24I think the numbers would be more like 28% secure, 20%
- 26:29dismissing, 20% preoccupied in 32% disorganized Christian.
- 26:41I don't you're probably somewhat plugged into the like attachment
- 26:46kind of researcher university world.
- 26:48Do you know of like ongoing research that's measuring this?
- 26:51I'd, I'd, I'd be particularly curious to see the effect that
- 26:56COVID had on like rates of. Yeah.
- 27:05I don't know. I don't think there's ever,
- 27:07nobody's ever attempted to do a direct study of, of a sampling
- 27:13of the overall population to see what the actual layout of
- 27:18attachment is. Poverty is highly correlated to
- 27:22disorganized. That's why they're so high.
- 27:25You know, I live in Los Angeles. 50% of the kids in Los Angeles
- 27:33are, are impoverished. You look, I read something the
- 27:39other day, 75% of African American children at some point
- 27:44in their life experience poverty.
- 27:46It's hard to know, but we live in a time of unprecedented
- 27:54inequality. And remember, food, shelter,
- 27:59clothing and medicine are the basics of care.
- 28:03If you're impoverished, there's no predictability for any of
- 28:07those. How do you manage that?
- 28:16And you know, I was talking to Mary Main about this and she
- 28:21said, well, the work that Medigroup does is Admiral, it's
- 28:26a waste, admirable. It's a waste of time.
- 28:30Once your attachment is messed up, it's too hard to fix.
- 28:34I think that that was before we had the technology of ideal
- 28:38parent figure. But what we should be doing is
- 28:43funding investment in teaching attachment parenting skills and
- 28:51that as few as 12 interventions, yeah, in early childhood could
- 28:57change the attachment outcome. And if we would provide reliable
- 29:02services for children, we could change that.
- 29:05But we we absolutely refuse to do that as a society.
- 29:12There is zero chance at this point that that could happen.
- 29:17But we don't mind spending $145,000 a year housing somebody
- 29:22in a medium security prison rather than pay, you know, a
- 29:27fraction of that for somebody then who would be contributing
- 29:31to society. So it it is really this huge
- 29:37moral failing I think of of the West in the way they regard this
- 29:43Christian. George, are you familiar?
- 29:46I think it's called circle of security.
- 29:49These are these kinds of like adult, like a 13 classes that I
- 29:57think kind of do that. That kind?
- 30:00Not directly. I've, I've, I haven't read
- 30:04anything in a while, but I read some good things that that they
- 30:09can have pretty profound effects on rates of kids, kids becoming
- 30:14secure. While the.
- 30:15While the adults themselves don't become secure.
- 30:18No, they don't. But as it turns out, you don't
- 30:22need them to be secure. They can still raise secure kids
- 30:25with the right intervention. So why aren't we doing that?
- 30:30Mainly because it it disadvantages some kids that
- 30:34have advantages better that there's no competition.
- 30:55So the idea then is to begin to identify people that are going
- 31:00to be useful to you in your life.
- 31:03And this is really organized around your exploration and then
- 31:07the pursuit of meaning that you have.
- 31:08What is meaningful to you in your life?
- 31:10What is it that you want to do in your life?
- 31:14Where do you derive that that sense of curiosity and interest?
- 31:20And then who do you need to know that's going to support you in
- 31:25being able to do that and establishing those relationships
- 31:29and developing them so that they're available to you so that
- 31:32you pursue the meaning that you have?
- 31:35Hold on, Lucy, come on. The I, I noticed in the, in the
- 31:52work that I do, a lot of the conversations at the beginning
- 31:55are about over and over again recommending that people try
- 32:00authenticity as a basis for relationships and, and how you
- 32:09watch the mind. Each time somebody says
- 32:13something to you and the authentic thing arises, then you
- 32:16don't want to say it because you're, you're afraid that if
- 32:18you say it, they'll leave you. They don't say it, which is in
- 32:22some sense ensuring that they will leave you.
- 32:24It's a paradox. But then if you say the thing
- 32:29that's authentic and then they did, they tell you whether they
- 32:32would leave you or they wouldn't based on that, right?
- 32:36It's fine most of the time. It's fine most of the time.
- 32:41It lands the same way as the inauthentic thing landed, except
- 32:46that you're not frightened anymore because they've, they've
- 32:49not left. Or if they did left, you've used
- 32:53much less energy to try and develop the relationship than
- 32:56you might have because you kick those cans down the road and
- 33:00they they come back to roost. Just mash up metaphors, tell
- 33:18people, but you know you need permission from people to tell
- 33:22them who you are authentically and they they need your
- 33:28permission to be willing to do it.
- 33:30And little by little, you build this, this experience of trust.
- 33:34You really have no obligation to tell people you don't know
- 33:38everything. You make agreements with people
- 33:42that you'll tell them everything and they make agreements with
- 33:46you. The way that that matches in an
- 33:48intimacy that that expression back and forth creates this
- 33:52sense of safety, but also this, you know, because what we're
- 33:56really looking for is this in support and this encouragement
- 33:58to go for the things that matter to us that we can't really go
- 34:03for without that level of support.
- 34:07Because, you know, resiliency has its limits.
- 34:16Our inability to be self reflective limits us.
- 34:19And we need that sounding board. We need that reflection, we need
- 34:23that support, but we don't need that many people either.
- 34:30I mean, how many intimate relationships can you have in
- 34:34the Dunbar system? Primary relationship and a
- 34:41relationship. Most people have bandwidth for
- 34:44one of those B relationships. People you tell everything to,
- 34:49but you don't. You don't have the same level of
- 34:52commitment to care for. Is it two or three or four?
- 34:59Do you? Do you have an amazing capacity
- 35:01for relationships that you could actually have five of those
- 35:05people? It's not that many.
- 35:10Dunbar's research said that if you you flow, I think it was 60%
- 35:17of your relational energy into those few relationships, you're
- 35:22much happier than people who don't, that most people don't do
- 35:26that in the West. It's really one A relationship,
- 35:29no B relationships and CS that you have one intimate
- 35:33relationship with no others, which is a, a burden in a way
- 35:38toward that one person. They have entire responsibility
- 35:43for your care. And then if they want to go off
- 35:45and do something for their own exploration, How do you tolerate
- 35:49the separation if you don't have anyone else that can regulate
- 35:52you? Whereas if you have that, that
- 35:55group of people that can help and they can regulate you in.
- 36:00And also then you're free to go if they have people that are
- 36:03regulating for them, not in a state of deprivation if you've
- 36:09left so that it doesn't restrict your exploration.
- 36:15Makes sense. So even if they developed bots
- 36:25that have massive AI it won't work.
- 36:34We need a human, need a human to grab onto.
- 36:39We need a human to travel with. I was in Los Angeles.
- 36:46They have Waymo now and Waymo are the the driverless cabs and
- 36:54there's a corridor that runs from Santa Monica out to
- 36:57downtown where you can get away MO but it's not very wide so you
- 37:01have to be going across and they don't travel on the highway.
- 37:06But I've not been in one and I was curious about it, so I
- 37:09ordered one in Santa Monica to drive me home in a near downtown
- 37:14Los Angeles. And it took about an hour and 10
- 37:18minutes because they don't drive on the freeway.
- 37:21And by the end of the hour and 10 minutes I was lonely.
- 37:26The Uber driver, even though the AI was making jokes about what
- 37:36was happening and it had a screen and it played music.
- 37:41By the end of it, I was lonely in the back of my driverless
- 37:45cab. Why don't we do some practice?
- 37:53What do you think? What would you like to do,
- 38:01Vipassana. OK, so go ahead and settle in.
- 38:10All right? But go over the meditation.
- 38:14How's that Good? So let's see in May we have a
- 38:18level 1 coming up. I think that's the next thing.
- 38:28Tomorrow is Kaleidoscope. We're going to talk about
- 38:31advanced mentalizing and then we'll have a level 2 coming up
- 38:50soon. That's what's on the calendar.
- 38:53If you're interested, take a look at the 21st of June.
- 38:57I'm going to do a a couple of exploration Saturdays
- 39:01back-to-back. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 39:07I do hope that if you're able to make a donation, you can and you
- 39:10can please do it. Help support being also the work
- 39:14that a group is doing. Really appreciate your practice
- 39:16and I'll see you soon. Bye.