Latest / The Morning Rundown / UN Spin, the Measles Death Fight, and a Grand Jury Clears the Air
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Morning.
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I've got my coffee, you've got that look, and we've got
- 0:18[Maya] three stories today that are just chef's kiss messy.
- 0:21[David] That look is called I already read the transcripts.
- 0:25[Maya] Fair.
- 0:26[Maya] So real quick, UN drama, a measles death fight nobody's telling straight,
- 0:31[Maya] and a grand jury verdict that just torched months of Internet speculation.
- 0:36[David] Torched is generous.
- 0:37[Maya] I'm Maya, this is David.
- 0:39[Maya] Welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:40[David] And the thread through all three today is basically the same thing.
- 0:43[Maya] Which is?
- 0:44[David] The loudest version of the story isn't the true one.
- 0:47[Maya] Ooh, that's a good one.
- 0:49[David] It's not just clickbait cynicism either.
- 0:50[David] It's just how fast information moves versus how fast anyone actually checks
- 0:54[David] it.
- 0:55[Maya] Yeah, no, I've noticed that.
- 0:56[Maya] The take goes out at nine AM, the correction shows up at
- 0:59[Maya] five, and by then nobody's watching.
- 1:02[David] Exactly.
- 1:03[David] So we're basically doing the five o'clock version at nine.
- 1:06[Maya] I like that pitch.
- 1:07[Maya] Okay, I'm sold.
- 1:08[Maya] Let's get into it before I finish my coffee.
- 1:10[David] So let's start with the trip everyone's calling a disaster.
- 1:13[Maya] David, walk us through what actually happened at the UN.
- 1:18[David] So NPR ran this piece right before Trump landed at the UN,
- 1:22[David] and the whole frame was basically rough couple of weeks for the
- 1:25[David] guy, legal messes, political setbacks.
- 1:28[David] Here he comes looking for a win.
- 1:30[Maya] Rough week according to who, though?
- 1:32[David] That's kinda my point.
- 1:34[David] NPR is the one setting that up front and center.
- 1:37[Maya] Because I feel like every week is a rough week if you're
- 1:40[Maya] reading the headlines that way.
- 1:42[David] Right.
- 1:42[David] And a bad news cycle in DC doesn't automatically mean the room
- 1:46[David] in New York went badly for him.
- 1:48[Maya] Those are two totally separate things.
- 1:51[David] Totally separate.
- 1:52[David] One's coverage, one's what actually happens when world leaders are sitting across
- 1:56[David] a table.
- 1:57[Maya] So what actually happened?
- 1:59[David] Well, here's the wrinkle.
- 2:00[David] While all this UN stuff is going on, US outlets are reporting
- 2:04[David] Trump called off planned strikes on the Houthis last minute on a
- 2:07[David] Sunday.
- 2:08[Maya] Wait, called them off?
- 2:10[Maya] Like already had the green light and pulled it back?
- 2:13[David] That's what's being reported, yeah.
- 2:14[David] And meanwhile, on the ground in Yemen, the fighting's not slowing down
- 2:17[David] at all.
- 2:18[Maya] So he's pulling back and it's getting worse?
- 2:22[David] Al Jazeera's covering Houthi forces pushing for strategic ground and thousands more
- 2:26[David] people fleeing their homes because of it.
- 2:28[Maya] Thousands more.
- 2:30[Maya] That's not nothing.
- 2:31[David] And it's not like the summit erases that.
- 2:33[David] Trump can have a decent room in New York, and Yemen can
- 2:36[David] still be getting worse at the exact same time.
- 2:39[Maya] Which is such a weird thing to hold in your head at
- 2:42[Maya] once.
- 2:42[Maya] A diplomatic win column and an actual war escalating, running in parallel.
- 2:48[David] Right.
- 2:49[David] And I think that's actually the more useful way to read this
- 2:51[David] whole rough week story.
- 2:53[David] It's not that NPR made it up.
- 2:55[David] It's that rough week is doing a lot of work as a
- 2:58[David] single headline for a bunch of stuff that isn't really connected.
- 3:01[Maya] Legal setbacks back home, a summit performance, and a war zone decision.
- 3:06[Maya] Those are three different scoreboards.
- 3:09[David] Three different scoreboards, exactly.
- 3:11[David] And people flatten them into one mood.
- 3:14[David] Good week, bad week.
- 3:15[Maya] It's easier to say rough week than actually track three separate storylines,
- 3:19[Maya] honestly.
- 3:20[David] No, it's not.
- 3:21[David] And I think that's the real story underneath all of it.
- 3:24[David] A headline can say one thing, and the ground can be doing
- 3:27[David] something completely different at the same time.
- 3:29[Maya] Okay, hang on.
- 3:30[Maya] I got tangled in my own sentence there.
- 3:33[David] Happens to the best of us.
- 3:34[Maya] What I mean is the decision gets made in one room, and
- 3:37[Maya] the consequences play out somewhere the cameras barely reach.
- 3:41[David] Exactly.
- 3:42[David] Nobody's tracking the retreat and the escalation in the same breath.
- 3:46[Maya] So you've got a president who supposedly had a rough couple weeks
- 3:50[Maya] walking into the UN and a war zone that doesn't care what
- 3:53[Maya] the news cycle says about him.
- 3:55[David] Right.
- 3:56[David] The summit's optics and Yemen's reality are just running on two different
- 3:59[David] tracks.
- 4:00[Maya] And I don't think NPR's framing was wrong exactly.
- 4:03[Maya] I just think it's incomplete.
- 4:05[David] Incomplete's a good way to put it.
- 4:06[David] A rough week in headlines isn't the same as a rough week
- 4:09[David] in the actual room with actual leaders.
- 4:12[Maya] So if I'm being fair to Trump for a second, showing up
- 4:16[Maya] to the UN and calling off a strike doesn't sound like someone
- 4:19[Maya] having a total meltdown of a week.
- 4:22[David] No, it doesn't.
- 4:22[David] It sounds like someone making a call, whether or not you agree
- 4:25[David] with it.
- 4:26[Maya] Which is a very different picture than rough week, legal messes, chaos.
- 4:31[David] Fair point, but that's exactly why lumping legal messes and geopolitical decision
- 4:35[David] under one banner headline is kinda lazy.
- 4:38[Maya] Man, okay.
- 4:39[Maya] Speaking of narratives running way ahead of what's actually true.
- 4:43[David] Oh, wait till you hear what's going on with the CDC and
- 4:45[David] their measles numbers.
- 4:47[Maya] Oh, I've seen people going wild about this online.
- 4:50[David] Yeah.
- 4:51[David] Buckle up.
- 4:52[Maya] Okay, what's the claim?
- 4:54[David] So The Guardian dropped a piece on this, and it's got people
- 4:57[David] fired up.
- 4:58[Maya] Okay, what's the claim?
- 4:59[David] Pennsylvania's measles outbreak.
- 5:01[David] Doctors are calling it accelerating.
- 5:03[David] New cases and apparently new forms of the disease showing up.
- 5:07[Maya] New forms.
- 5:08[Maya] What does that even mean?
- 5:10[David] They didn't get super specific, but the doctors quoted are alarmed, and
- 5:14[David] here's the part that's got Harrisburg screaming.
- 5:17[David] The CDC won't count four deaths in that state as measles deaths.
- 5:22[Maya] Four people died, and the CDC just doesn't log them?
- 5:26[David] That's the framing, yeah.
- 5:27[David] September twenty-second, a Guardian reporter named Schreiber breaks it.
- 5:31[David] Outbreak's accelerating, deaths aren't showing up in the federal count.
- 5:35[Maya] Okay, that sounds bad on its face.
- 5:38[David] It does, but go look at the CDC's own dashboard.
- 5:41[Maya] And?
- 5:42[David] Zero 2026 death records list measles as the underlying cause.
- 5:47[David] Not four excluded, not four disputed, zero full stop under their current
- 5:52[David] methodology.
- 5:53[Maya] So it's not that they're hiding four specific deaths.
- 5:57[Maya] It's that their whole system hasn't logged any yet.
- 6:00[David] Right.
- 6:01[David] And the CDC says the reason is they're working with state epidemiologists
- 6:04[David] on a standardized death definition.
- 6:06[David] It updates as the reviews complete.
- 6:08[Maya] So it's a lag, not a cover-up.
- 6:11[David] That's their position, and it got personal fast.
- 6:15[David] Governor Shapiro basically accused the administration of political interference.
- 6:19[Maya] Ooh.
- 6:20[David] RFK Jr.
- 6:20[David] didn't let that sit.
- 6:22[David] He came back and said the CDC is applying one consistent national
- 6:25[David] standard, not letting politicians decide which deaths count state by state.
- 6:30[Maya] I mean, if you're the secretary, you kinda have to say that.
- 6:33[David] Sure, but think of the alternative.
- 6:35[David] You want the CDC picking and choosing based on which governor is
- 6:38[David] loudest that week?
- 6:39[Maya] No, obviously not, but I get why a grieving family in Pennsylvania
- 6:43[Maya] doesn't care about methodology.
- 6:45[David] Totally fair.
- 6:46[David] And here's where it actually gets complicated, not political.
- 6:49[David] Public health experts are raising real questions about the method itself.
- 6:53[Maya] How so?
- 6:54[David] The system CDC switched to pulls from NCHS underlying cause of death
- 6:59[David] records.
- 6:59[David] That's built for long-term mortality trends, like tracking heart disease rates over
- 7:04[David] a decade.
- 7:05[Maya] Not for tracking an outbreak that's happening right now.
- 7:08[David] Exactly the complaint.
- 7:10[David] Experts say it's confusing for real-time tracking because those records take time
- 7:14[David] to finalize.
- 7:15[David] You're using a slow tool for a fast-moving problem.
- 7:18[Maya] So even people who aren't accusing anybody of anything are like, "This
- 7:22[Maya] data lag is a real issue."
- 7:24[David] Right.
- 7:24[David] And an HHS spokesperson actually addressed that directly, defended the change to
- 7:28[David] reporters, said it's about accuracy over speed.
- 7:31[Maya] I don't love that answer, honestly.
- 7:33[Maya] Accuracy is great, but if kids are dying and the count's frozen
- 7:36[Maya] at zero for months, that's a communications problem, even if it's not
- 7:40[Maya] a scandal.
- 7:41[David] Yeah, I don't think you can wave that off either, but I
- 7:43[David] also don't think you can look at this and go, "Aha, the
- 7:45[David] deep state is erasing measles deaths."
- 7:48[Maya] No, that's a stretch.
- 7:49[David] It's a legitimately clunky rollout of a new counting standard colliding with
- 7:52[David] an outbreak nobody wanted to be happening in the first place.
- 7:56[Maya] And Shapiro gets to look like he's fighting for his state.
- 7:59[Maya] RFK Jr. gets to look like he's defending consistency.
- 8:02[Maya] And meanwhile, the actual number just sits there unresolved.
- 8:06[David] Which, by the way, it doesn't mean the outbreak isn't serious.
- 8:08[David] Doctors calling it accelerating is still doctors calling it accelerating.
- 8:12[Maya] Right.
- 8:12[Maya] Nobody's saying ignore that part.
- 8:14[David] No.
- 8:15[David] It's just the death count fight and the outbreak severity are two
- 8:19[David] separate arguments people are mashing into one.
- 8:21[Maya] Right.
- 8:21[Maya] You don't have to pick a side to hold both of those
- 8:24[Maya] thoughts at once.
- 8:25[Maya] The methodology can be genuinely clunky, and the disease can still genuinely
- 8:30[Maya] be spreading faster than anyone wants.
- 8:33[David] Exactly.
- 8:33[David] Nobody needs a villain in this one for it still to be
- 8:36[David] worth fixing.
- 8:37[Maya] It's just less satisfying than a clean scandal, I guess.
- 8:40[David] Way less satisfying, but probably closer to what's actually happening.
- 8:43[Maya] Okay, so speculation running ahead of what's actually confirmed, that's basically the
- 8:48[Maya] whole show today, huh?
- 8:50[David] Funny you say that because there's a grand jury verdict out of
- 8:52[David] Mississippi that takes that exact problem and turns it up to 11.
- 8:55[Maya] Oh, I need to hear this one.
- 8:57[David] You do.
- 8:58[David] Nolan Wells case.
- 8:59[Maya] All right, let's get into it.
- 9:01[Maya] So walk me through this Mississippi thing because I heard the headline
- 9:04[Maya] and thought, "Oh no, here we go again."
- 9:07[David] Right.
- 9:07[David] The Nolan Wells case.
- 9:08[David] Eighteen-year-old disappeared off a boat on the Fourth of July, and for
- 9:12[David] months the story online was basically that something violent happened to him
- 9:16[David] and nobody wanted to say why.
- 9:17[Maya] And that turned into a whole race angle, didn't it?
- 9:20[David] It did.
- 9:21[David] Speculation that race played a role in how he died, that it
- 9:24[David] got covered up.
- 9:25[Maya] And there's a Grand Jury verdict?
- 9:27[David] A Grand Jury out of Jackson County, 23 people on it, sat
- 9:30[David] through 43 witnesses.
- 9:33[Maya] 43?
- 9:34[Maya] That's basically a whole classroom of people testifying about one afternoon on
- 9:38[Maya] a boat.
- 9:39[David] And their conclusion was that his death was consistent with drowning.
- 9:42[David] There was a bruise on his head, but they found it wasn't
- 9:45[David] fatal and no evidence anybody got into a fight with him that
- 9:47[David] day.
- 9:48[Maya] So no crime.
- 9:50[David] No true bill.
- 9:51[David] That's the term.
- 9:52[David] The DA put it out in a video message instead of a
- 9:54[David] courtroom presser, which is its own choice, but the substance was clear.
- 9:58[Maya] And she pushed back on the whole race angle directly.
- 10:00[David] Rejected it outright.
- 10:02[David] Said the months of speculation about race just weren't supported by what
- 10:05[David] the grand jury actually heard.
- 10:07[Maya] Man, imagine being that family, watching the internet build a whole narrative
- 10:11[Maya] around your kid's death before anyone even finished the investigation.
- 10:15[David] That's the part that gets me too.
- 10:16[David] The New York Times covered it the same week, said plainly there
- 10:19[David] was insufficient evidence of a crime.
- 10:22[Maya] Two separate outlets, same conclusion.
- 10:24[David] Yeah.
- 10:24[David] It's not like one network spun it and another didn't.
- 10:27[David] The facts landed the same place both times.
- 10:30[Maya] It's kind of the mirror image of the measles thing we just
- 10:32[Maya] talked about, right?
- 10:33[Maya] Everybody assumed the worst reason first.
- 10:36[David] Except here it's a jury actually sitting with 43 witnesses instead of
- 10:39[David] a dashboard glitch.
- 10:41[David] But yeah, same instinct.
- 10:42[David] Assume the darkest version, then wait for the paperwork.
- 10:45[Maya] Huh.
- 10:45[Maya] Nobody waits for the paperwork anymore, though.
- 10:48[David] No, they do not.
- 10:49[David] And look, I get it.
- 10:50[David] A teenager dies on a boat trip, of course people want answers
- 10:53[David] fast.
- 10:53[Maya] Yeah, and it's not even a cynical instant necessarily.
- 10:57[Maya] People care about this kid.
- 10:58[Maya] They want it to mean something, want someone held accountable.
- 11:01[David] Totally get that too.
- 11:02[David] It's just that wanting accountability and there actually being a crime to
- 11:05[David] prosecute are two different questions.
- 11:07[Maya] Totally.
- 11:08[Maya] That's human.
- 11:09[Maya] But wanting answers fast and getting the right answer aren't the same
- 11:12[Maya] thing.
- 11:13[David] Twenty-three grand jurors took the time.
- 11:16[David] That's the whole point of the process.
- 11:17[David] It's slow on purpose.
- 11:19[Maya] So drowning, no altercation, no charges.
- 11:22[Maya] Case closed, at least legally.
- 11:23[David] Legally, yeah.
- 11:24[David] Doesn't mean the family's not still grieving, but the criminal question is
- 11:27[David] answered.
- 11:28[Maya] I keep thinking about the video statement thing too.
- 11:31[Maya] Announcing a no true bill on camera instead of at a podium
- 11:34[Maya] feels almost like the DA anticipating exactly this kind of pushback.
- 11:39[David] Maybe, or it's just faster to get in front of 43 witnesses'
- 11:42[David] worth of testimony than to schedule a press conference and field questions
- 11:45[David] live.
- 11:45[Maya] Either way, it meant the finding went out in her own words,
- 11:48[Maya] unedited, instead of getting chopped into a ten-second clip.
- 11:52[David] Which given how this case got talked about online for months might
- 11:55[David] have been the smart move.
- 11:57[Maya] You know, three headlines today and every single one had people racing
- 12:01[Maya] ahead of the facts.
- 12:02[Maya] The UN speech, the measles numbers, now this.
- 12:05[David] It's kind of the whole show in miniature, honestly.
- 12:07[Maya] Right.
- 12:07[Maya] So that's a wrap on today's headlines.
- 12:09[Maya] Let's bring it home because I think these three stories are actually
- 12:13[Maya] the same story wearing different outfits.
- 12:15[David] I'm with you on that.
- 12:16[David] Give me a second and I'll tell you what I think ties
- 12:18[David] them together.
- 12:19[Maya] Mm.
- 12:20[David] So three totally different stories today.
- 12:23[David] UN speech, a measles dashboard, a Mississippi drowning.
- 12:26[Maya] And somehow the same lesson.
- 12:28[David] Right.
- 12:28[David] Everybody had a version of events ready to go before the facts
- 12:31[David] showed up.
- 12:32[David] The UN framing, the coverup theory, the online verdict on that grand
- 12:36[David] jury case.
- 12:37[Maya] All confident, all fast.
- 12:39[David] And all wrong once you actually checked.
- 12:42[David] That's what stuck with me today, how much energy gets spent defending
- 12:45[David] a story nobody bothered to confirm first.
- 12:48[Maya] Yeah, it's a theme all right.
- 12:50[David] Confirm before you commit.
- 12:51[David] That's the takeaway.
- 12:52[Maya] It's a good rule for us too, honestly.
- 12:54[Maya] We try not to run with the loudest version just because it's
- 12:57[Maya] loudest.
- 12:58[David] That's the job.
- 12:59[David] Slower and right beats fast and wrong.
- 13:01[Maya] I like that.
- 13:02[Maya] Okay.
- 13:03[Maya] On that note, thanks for hanging out with us this morning.
- 13:05[Maya] We love you guys.
- 13:06[David] We really do.
- 13:07[Maya] Tomorrow we've got a new batch of headlines, so come back for
- 13:10[Maya] that.
- 13:11[Maya] Have a good one, everybody.
- 13:12[David] See you then.