Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Tuesday, January 23, 2024
Transcript
- 0:00H Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network.
- 0:34You are an emergency radio turned off from the studio so w v r C
- 0:44Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice of West Virginia comes the
- 0:49most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This this is Metro News Talk Lives
- 0:55with Hobby Kerchible Switch network control from Charleston. The morning standby you, Hoppy.
- 1:03You're on Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by
- 1:08in Covia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 1:14Visit in covid dot com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome to
- 1:17talk Line on Metro News all across the great state of West Virginia. Hopey
- 1:21Kerchival with you Ethan Collins, our producer Austin Wright, with a video stream
- 1:25you can watch at wv metronews dot com. Fun number one one hundred and
- 1:29seven six five eight two five five Text me three oh four talk three oh
- 1:34four. We have a lot to talk about today and starting to see some
- 1:40issues emerge from this session of the West Virginia Legislature. I'll be down there
- 1:45in person tomorrow, but our Brad maclin is there every day and he joins
- 1:49us from the Capitol this morning as report brought to you by AAARP, your
- 1:53ally for Real Possibilities in the Mountain State. Brad, good morning. Let's
- 1:57touch on a couple of things here. First of all, there's a bit
- 2:00bill that is coming up today as we speak in the Senate Education Committee.
- 2:05As you have described it to me, it sounds like a pro life bill
- 2:07even though it's an education bill. What is it exactly or what do you
- 2:12think it is? It is labeled to be It is labeled to be requiring
- 2:19course in public schools on human developments. If you are out there in listener
- 2:24lane and you want to go so far as to look at up Senate Bill
- 2:28for sixty eight, and it is. Yeah, it has particular requirements about
- 2:37the development of a baby. And here's the main thing. It's beginning next
- 2:43year, would require in public schools to incorporate human growth and development discussion into
- 2:50the curriculum in grades little kid's three, five, and eight. It would
- 2:54require a high definition ultrasound video at least three minutes in duration and showing the
- 3:00development of the brain, part sex, organs, and other vital organs in
- 3:05early fetal development. Uh, you know, maybe you should get that anyway
- 3:08in in your science classes. But here's here is where I think there may
- 3:14be some questions. It requires the viewing of a meat Baby Olivia video developed
- 3:21by a nonprofit group called Live Action. And so that that group, Live
- 3:30Action has been active, it's active in politics on abortion issues, and it
- 3:38is national. And the video Meet Baby Olivia is described as showing the process
- 3:43of fertilization and every stage of human development inside the uterus, noting significant markers
- 3:50and cell growth and organ development for every significant marker of pregnancy until birth.
- 3:55The final, the final interesting thing that we're this is my eye on this
- 4:00potential policy is it says the Attorney General of the State of West Virginia shall
- 4:04have a cause of action to suit for damages and then junk to relief on
- 4:10behalf of any and all residents of the State of West Virginia against any person
- 4:14or entity that violates this section. So I haven't heard it. I haven't
- 4:17heard an explanation of that yet. But if you don't show in your classroom
- 4:21Meet Daby Olivia, are you gonna wind up in court with the Attorney General
- 4:26on the other side. Yeah, I mean, I hear you, and
- 4:30we're just sort of learning about this. We'll see what comes out of committee
- 4:33today. I know you're covering that, and I got to let you go
- 4:34soon so you can catch upon that. And people have different opinions obviously on
- 4:41abortion. I get that, but West Virginia's pretty much ruled out abortions except
- 4:45in very very limited cases, and as you said, it would be appropriate.
- 4:49I don't know what exactly is taught in our public schools about human development.
- 4:54I guess you're taught somewhere along the line. But if you're required to
- 4:57show a video that is introduced and put forward by an anti abortion organization,
- 5:03and if you don't, you could be in trouble criminally, that is raising
- 5:08the stakes substantially. If that is in fact what it does, is it
- 5:12your impression that's what it does. I guess we should hear what committee questions
- 5:15are today. I mean, it very clearly states in the text of this
- 5:18video part of the committee process is to potentially amend things, so that maybe
- 5:26could be amended out. But you know from my reading, it's it's at
- 5:29the heart of this bill that you've got to show specifically the meat Baby Olivia
- 5:34video developed by the particular entity live action, you know, And it's a
- 5:42we can too often engage in what about it is, But sometimes it is
- 5:45a healthy intellectual exercise to say, well, what if the opposite were true?
- 5:50And what if West Virginia Schools mandated the presentation of planned parenthood videos?
- 5:57I think people would be well question that. And so if we are now
- 6:02questioning whether it's wise to make third, fifth, and eighth grade teachers show
- 6:10Meet Baby Olivia videos by this group, and then potentially, if they don't
- 6:15be up against in the court of law the Attorney General for the state,
- 6:18that is worthy of public debate. Yeah, it is worthy of public debate.
- 6:24Most certainly we will keep a close eye on that meantime. Up for
- 6:28passage today in the Senate is Senate Bill two eighty. We've talked about that.
- 6:32It says that no public school board, school superintendent, or school principal
- 6:38shall prohibit a public classroom a public school classroom teacher from discussing or answering questions
- 6:45from students about scientific theories of how the universe and or life came into existence.
- 6:51Originally, the bill was allowing for intelligent design, which is the version
- 6:55of creationism to be taught as scientific theory? Then I got watered down.
- 7:00So this is up for passage today, most certainly will pass and there's been
- 7:02debate about, well, it really doesn't do anything because teachers can answer questions
- 7:08anyway. But then there's others who say, well, it doesn't do anything,
- 7:11why are you passing it? And does it open the door for teachers
- 7:15to potentially proselytize about religious explanations of creation? So what do we have on
- 7:25that today? Yeah, so, unlike though we just talked about, it
- 7:29doesn't mandate the teaching of intelligent design and the fact, as you said,
- 7:34it doesn't say the words intelligence design at all. Right, it seems to
- 7:40be what it means that is up for passage today in the Senate. I
- 7:45think there is going to be some floor debate about it. The Senate Minority
- 7:49Leader, Mike Walfole, a Democrat from Cabal County, who is just to
- 7:54plug that segment. I guess later on in the program, I think you
- 7:58might hear from him on the Senate about the symbolism of what this bill does.
- 8:05You know, again, it's not mandatory, a question I heard a
- 8:09couple of times on the House side yesterday, and I thought it was a
- 8:11good question put to other bills, was what is the need to pass a
- 8:18law? What problem is this trying to solve? And that's one I can't
- 8:22figure out in my own head about this Intelligent Design bill. It means that
- 8:26you would not get in trouble with your school boards or superintendent or your principle
- 8:31if you've had a classroom discussion about the scientific theories surrounding the origins of the
- 8:37universe. But what problem is that solving? Are people getting in trouble for
- 8:41that? I haven't heard of it? I have not either. Also,
- 8:46there is House Bill forty six point fifty four introduced by Delicate Steel, and
- 8:52this is going to be the subject of a public hearing tomorrow morning. And
- 8:56this requires a little bit of explanation. But right now, schools, public
- 9:03libraries, and museums are protected from prosecution for the distribution or the access of
- 9:16material that is viewed as obscene. And this would remove that exemption, which
- 9:24means they could be then subject to, in fact, criminal prosecution. They
- 9:28would have criminal liability. If a museum or a public library, or a
- 9:33bonafide school or in the curriculum had material that was defined as obscene and then
- 9:43that miners had access to it. So that has pretty broad implications as well.
- 9:48And on one hand, to go, of course, you don't want
- 9:50miners to see material that's obscene. Okay, now gets into the definition of
- 9:54obscenity and would this have a chilling effect on library, school curriculum, etc.
- 10:03I'm going to have a representative of the West Virginia Library Association later in
- 10:05this program. What do you have on that? So what the listeners need
- 10:11to know is there is a public hearing tomorrow morning eight point thirty in the
- 10:15House Chamber on this issue. And it is an issue that has come up
- 10:20in other Red states Arkansas, for example. One of the books that you're
- 10:24going to hear about is Gender Queer. That can be part of the Metro
- 10:28News Book Club if you want to get up to speed on what kind of
- 10:31book may be questioned in public libraries or school libraries. Gender Queer is the
- 10:39textbook example of that, et cetera. Law has defined obscenity and it's Supreme
- 10:45Court president. It's a three step process, one of which is whether a
- 10:50reasonable person finds it. The matter taken as a whole lacks serious literary,
- 10:56artistic, political, or scientific value. You would certainly hope that the material
- 11:01in a library would meet that standard. But then it relies on what is
- 11:07a reasonable person, what is an average person, and the penalties are significant.
- 11:16It potentially could open up librarians to a twenty five thousand dollars fine or
- 11:20up to five years in jail. So if you were putting things on the
- 11:26shelf of the library and you had any question about it, and you did
- 11:31not want to get into a situation where you were the subject of emotional and
- 11:39public scrutiny, or if you didn't think that you could afford a lawyer,
- 11:43you might have second thoughts about putting a book like Gender Queer on the shelves,
- 11:48or many other books for that matter. Now, the Democrats in the
- 11:52State House have objected to this potential policy and have questioned whether the Bible may
- 11:58be subject because there are certain elements of Bible chapters that are fairly graphics.
- 12:05So that's that's going to be part of this discussion as well. Yeah,
- 12:07that's that's going to be hot, all right. Brad maclady Metro News d
- 12:11Why correspondence at the Capitolis Report brought to you by AARP. Your outlive for
- 12:15real possibilities in the Mountain State. Google them, check them out. AARP
- 12:20is your ally, all right? Thank you, Brad. A lot happening.
- 12:22There a lot of things on the on the culture front emerging during this
- 12:28session of the legislature. Of course, New Hampshire's vote is today. We'll
- 12:31go live to New Hampshire right after this. Thanks to all who have sent
- 12:35in some fantastic pictures of your hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy
- 12:39photo contest. Check out the gallery at the Outdoors page of w b Metronews
- 12:43dot com. Also, submit your pictures now and get in on the final
- 12:46monthly drawing plus the grand prize drawing a Hoodoo Sports Fishing kayak, for which
- 12:50we'll draw during the month of February. Learn how to submit your pick by
- 12:54clicking the Hoodoo Sports icon at the Outdoors page of wv metro News dot com.
- 12:58And remember, if it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to
- 13:01us. Welcome to West Virginia Foot and Ankle Clinic, where Doctor carry Frame
- 13:07and her dedicated team of skilled professionals are ready to provide you with the latest
- 13:11medical and surgical treatment of the lower extremity. Get excellent care for foot and
- 13:16ankle fractures, chronic deformities, tendon infammation and ruptures, and heel pain.
- 13:20Their practice specializes in surgical care of the foot and ankle and advanced wound care.
- 13:26Learn more at West Virginia Foot and Ankle dot com. West Virginia Foot
- 13:30and Ankle Clinic with Healthy Feet, Your world is just a step away.
- 13:33As our beloved state gears out for another election, it's important to know who
- 13:37you were voting for. Justice Haley Pun is a multi generational West Virginia coming
- 13:41from a family of coal miners, Justice Bun understands our West Virginian values.
- 13:46Her legal career includes several years in private practice and seven years as a federal
- 13:50prosecutor fighting violent crime and the opioid epidemic. For being appointed to the Supreme
- 13:54Court in twenty twenty two, she has been her career fighting for the rule
- 13:58of law, faith and integrity. Justice Hailey Bund for West Virginia Supreme Court.
- 14:01Paid for by Hailey Bun for West Virginia. Every house tells a story,
- 14:05and that's where I come in. My name is Aaron Weston and my
- 14:07husband and I in calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise
- 14:11Scholarship recipients. After I graduated from WU, I knew I wanted to carve
- 14:16a career in West Virginia, building a small business and helping people see the
- 14:20potential in their home. Now, that's a great story. Proceeds from the
- 14:22West Virginia Lottery have helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to
- 14:28Promise scholarships since two thousand and two for students like Aaron. West Virginia Lottery.
- 14:33What If You Play? This is talk Line on Metro News, the
- 14:35Voice of West Virginia this Saturday and every Saturday throughout the high school basketball season.
- 14:43Don't miss the High School Basketball Round Up, a weekly update of high
- 14:48school teams across the Mountain State featuring scores, rankings, and in depth features.
- 14:54Join Kyle Wiggs, Joe Riccado, and your host Bred Persinger for the
- 14:58latest high school basket news. On the high School Basketball Round Though from LA
- 15:03Voice some high school sports in West Virginia the Metro News Radio Network. Hi,
- 15:09This is Hopy Kurchible inviting you to join me weekdays from ten o six
- 15:13till noon for Metro News talk lin. Each day, I trying to provide
- 15:16the very latest news and information about our state and our nation. I interview
- 15:18newsmakers and thought leaders who help us better understand these stories. Yes, I'm
- 15:24mixing my observations, but mostly I just want us to be better informed.
- 15:28So I'm inviting you to be my radio and streaming companion as we sort out
- 15:31and work through the news and information of each day. That's a talk line
- 15:35weekdays ten o six till noon on this Metro News radio station. Hey everybody,
- 15:39it's Tony Curridi and I'm Brad Howe. And that makes two of the
- 15:43three guys that bring you the podcast entitled creatively Enough, Three Guys Before the
- 15:46Game. It's our opportunity to really drill down on WVU football and basketball.
- 15:52We break down the opponent and then review every single game. We'll give you
- 15:56some numbers, we'll bicker back and forth, we'll take your call, text
- 16:00your tweet, and get into some of your questions. And we invite you
- 16:03to join us each and every episode at three Guys Before the Game. From
- 16:07Metro News the Metro News Capital Report, bringing you the latest news from the
- 16:12West Virginia State Capitol Complex and the twenty twenty four legislative session. Hoppy Kerchival,
- 16:18Jeff Jenkins, Brad McElhinney, and the rest of the Metro News staff
- 16:22bring you daily updates on what's happening inside the House of Delegates and State Senate,
- 16:26including committee meetings and introduction of bills. Each weekday, morning and afternoon.
- 16:32Get the Capital Report on your favorite Metro News radio station. Metro News
- 16:52Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you
- 16:56with coverage to protect what you care about most in Coca dot com to learn
- 17:00more. Jared Halpern is in nashaua New Hampshire for obvious reasons. Jared,
- 17:07good morning, What are you watching today? Bro? I think there's a
- 17:08couple of storylines. One, obviously is Nikki Haley has wanted this two candidate
- 17:12Ray, She's got it, and now we get to see kind of where
- 17:17everything falls into place. Certainly for her, she is going to need a
- 17:21large turnout of not just maybe anti Trump or Trump's skeptical Republicans, but remember
- 17:27about forty five percent of the electorate here in New Hampshire is unaffiliated. They're
- 17:34not registered with either party, they have the ability to vote in either primary,
- 17:40and she is hoping to get a lot of that independent vote to see
- 17:45if she can keep it close or even pull off what would be a pretty
- 17:48remarkable feed here of upsetting the prohibitive favorite for the Republican domination. And if
- 17:52she doesn't, I'm sorr. I'm sorry, go ahead, good, I'm
- 17:55sorry. I'm The second thing I'm watching is you know, obviously the Democrats
- 17:59are not compete here right the DNZ strip New Hampshire of its delegates because they
- 18:03are violating the DNC rules of going before South Carolina. That being said,
- 18:08Dean Phillips has spent a lot of money here, the Minnesota congressman. He
- 18:12is in a primary contest against Joe Biden. There are something like twenty twenty
- 18:18one Democrats on the ballot. Joe Biden is not one of them. There
- 18:22is a very organized, very professional, very aggressive right end campaign for Biden,
- 18:27even though he's technically not running here. It would do a lot,
- 18:32i think, to kind of silence some of the critics that he was able
- 18:34to have that be successful. So while you know, obviously all of the
- 18:38attention, at least most of the attention is on the Republican side of the
- 18:41aisle, a couple of storylines to watch there on the Democratic side as well
- 18:45that I'm interested in. Yeah, and if look there's all those writing candidates,
- 18:49and are all those candidates and then if Biden does not do well,
- 18:55that will demonstrate some level of weakness that would be problematic for him. Correct,
- 19:00I mean, I say, I don't know how much weakness it shows.
- 19:02But because again he's not on the ballot, right and so he's not
- 19:06He hasn't campaigned here. There's not been like a formal vote for Biden kind
- 19:10of of push from his campaign. That being said, there has certainly been
- 19:15a lot of talk about, you know, were people tired of Biden?
- 19:18Is he tool for the job? Is he in touch with kind of where
- 19:22the base of the Democratic Party is. That will all be quelled in two
- 19:26weeks when the Democrats kick off their primary process on Saturday, February third in
- 19:30South Carolina, where I imagine Biden will get you know, a huge swath
- 19:36of the vote. And listen, there's nothing that that is going to change
- 19:40the trajectory here, barring some like unforeseen event that would prevent Biden from being
- 19:45the Democratic nominee. But yeah, I mean, listen, if if one
- 19:47of these other Democrats is able to like beat Biden, or Biden's ride in
- 19:51campaign falls flat, you know, it kind of just amps up that that
- 19:55retoric and that narrative that's out there. Yeap, And meantime, a lot
- 19:59of the former Republican candidates for the nomination for president are kind of falling in
- 20:04line behind Trump. True, my goodness, Yeah, Ron the sanctimonious has
- 20:11been retired. Jim Scott, Tim Scott, I mean, Tim Scott is
- 20:19a little bit surprising, just given his relationship obviously with Nicky Haley. But
- 20:22I do think that there is a growing sense that, you know, it's
- 20:29going to be Trump, and let's start moving forward in a general election campaign.
- 20:32If Trump is successful here tonight, if he wins, if he wins
- 20:36above fifty percent, if he wins in a pretty demonst fashion in the way
- 20:40that he did Iowa last week, it's going to be really hard for Nicky
- 20:44Haley to kind of, I think, make the case that you know,
- 20:48she has a viable path forward. Obviously, the next big state for Republicans
- 20:52is her home state of South Carolina. But Donald Trump is still a very
- 20:56popular Republican in South Carolina, and Trump is started with more of a conciliatory
- 21:03at least including a conciliatory mess out and endorse them. I mean, he's
- 21:07still calling Nikkia Haley bird brain. So we'll see how conciliatory he is well
- 21:15after while she's still in a race. He's pretty conciliatory when the opponents drop
- 21:18out. Yeah, yeah, right, right right, Hey, tell me
- 21:22this while I have you here. So what I mean, every state has
- 21:25something you need to do. Uh, and I don't think that. So
- 21:29what is it in New Hampshire that candidates they have to do? Is it?
- 21:32Like? What what do they have to do? Candidate's go to a
- 21:34lot of diners here? There are a lot of diners in New Hampshire.
- 21:37Uh, there is one chain of diners. It used to not be a
- 21:40change. It just said the one in Manchester. They've got another couple now,
- 21:42like I think in London Berry and here in Nashville the Red Arrow Diner
- 21:45Red Arrow. If you are in Manchester, ever, even if it's not
- 21:51an election season, go to the Red Arrow Diner in Manchester. They have
- 21:56kind of like bar seating kind of that, you know, that diner seat
- 21:59on the counter, and they will and they have little like nameplates for like
- 22:02famous politicians who have sat there, including non politicians like Adam Sandler and others.
- 22:07So it's a neat it's a neat kind of place if you're a politics
- 22:11nerd to kind of look at the old photographs and remember the old day,
- 22:15remember Gary hart and stuff like that. I'm sure you made it. Remember
- 22:22Gary Hart. I do remember Gary Harty. I've been around a long time,
- 22:25all right. I mentioned matter in fact, real quick, I mentioned
- 22:27something yesterday and then it realized how long it had been. This is showing
- 22:30my ages. I remember the whole Edmund Muskie failing in New Hampshire. You
- 22:33know, this tearful uh press conference with the snow on his head, and
- 22:37I think, and then I read it was fifty two years ago. I
- 22:41thought, oh gosh, that's well. I thought I was old. And
- 22:42I was like reminding people that this is where Clinton got the name. Comeback
- 22:48kid, that's right, that's right. Some because he did not do well
- 22:52in Iowa, and then you know, does well here in New Hampshire and
- 22:56the comeback Kid of Bill Clinton in nineteen ninety two. Yeah, well you'll
- 23:00have stories. I love it. Oh yeah, you'll have stories for the
- 23:03grandkids. What are you talking about, granddad? Go back to sleep.
- 23:06You know, my son's already born. By Jared Halpert and Nashville, New
- 23:11Hampshire. Look forward to your continued reporting from New Hampshire on the primary day.
- 23:15Thank you, sir. Good thing all right, man text topy.
- 23:17So, would you have a problem with a thirty something teacher reading Gender Queer
- 23:21to your grandchild? Yeah? I would because I don't think that's age appropriate.
- 23:26But I think it's not just about the book Gender Queer. I think
- 23:30it's about do you want librarians to face up to five years in prison or
- 23:37in a fine of up to twenty five thousand dollars for having a book in
- 23:41the library that somebody believes or determines or alleges is obscene. That's that's the
- 23:48concern, not just about the book Gender Queer, but about the broader implications
- 23:53of that, the chilling effect. But we'll talk about it. Let's just
- 23:56talk line on Metro News, The Voice of West Virginia's ten thirty let's get
- 24:00a news update checking with a metro news radio network. Follow What's happening state
- 24:04wide this hour, all across the great state of West Virginia, West Virginia
- 24:11my tro news design Kerry Huda Sack, a former STATEDHHR officer, faces up
- 24:15to five years in federal prison for lying to federal investigators looking into COVID spending.
- 24:21Forty nine year old Timothy Pretty If Milton, was in Charleston federal court
- 24:23Monday to plead guilty to a charge of making a false statement. US Attorney
- 24:27Will Thompson says Pretty could have avoided getting in trouble. Tell the tree.
- 24:32You know, you learn that in preschool. Tell the tree is when I
- 24:34asked, especially if federal infistgators are asking you. And if he would have
- 24:37simply have told us he was too busy, he didn't have time to do
- 24:41it, that would have been a totally different result for him and probably would
- 24:45have been understandable under the circumstances of COVID. But there he doubled down and
- 24:48lied about it. Pretty will be sentenced in May. An eighty nine year
- 24:52old woman is dead after being struck by a pickup truck near the Clarksburg,
- 24:56kroger A police say it happened Sunday afternoon. West Virginia second District Congressman Alex
- 25:00Mooney says Congress it should have never passed a temporary spending bill to keep the
- 25:03federal government open. Mooney says on Monday's Metro News talk line, the House
- 25:07and Senate should have passed a long term funding package instead of a continuing resolution
- 25:11that only funds the government through early March. The answer is to pass the
- 25:15twelve month spending bill, and that you know we've done it. Now we've
- 25:19passed it. The Senate has not passed it. I'm sure something more capital
- 25:22supports that bill, so she should call upon her colleagues, Democrats in particular,
- 25:27past that bill to solve the problem. The bill was signed by President
- 25:30Biden Friday to avoid the shutdown deadline on Saturday. You're listening to Metro News,
- 25:36the voice of West Virginia. In school sports, it's easy to see
- 25:41the wins, the moments that make headlines, but there's so much work that
- 25:45goes unseen for any of it to happen. My name is Phil Risen,
- 25:51and I'm the executive director of the National Interscholastic Athletic Administrators Association. Throughout the
- 25:56country, athletic administrators dedicate countless hours to making life changing opportunities possible for student
- 26:04athletes through sports. Their sacrifice is fueled by the belief that every student can
- 26:11grow and deserves their time to shine it on behalf of the Anti Triple A.
- 26:17We want to thank every athletic administrator for your tireless dedication to providing seven
- 26:22point eight million students across the country a path to a better future. This
- 26:29message presented by the NI TRIPLEA the National Interscholastic Athletic Administrators Association. A Cople
- 26:37County man who allegedly killed two women during a drunk driving rack in October twenty
- 26:41twenty two will have his trial moved to March. Twenty Five year old Andrew
- 26:45Wyrick of Kolodin previously pleaded not guilty to two counts of duy causing death and
- 26:49two counts of duy causing serious bodily injury. He appeared before Knawk County Circuit
- 26:55Judge Mary Clareakers, where she postponed his trial Monday because the state medical examiner
- 26:59was not available this week to testify. Read more at wv metronews dot com
- 27:03From the Metro News anchor desk, I'm Kerriehuda Suck talk line from the and
- 27:22Coventurance Studios jackpots in the Migians here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to
- 27:26be a millionaire? Get in the Paraball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and
- 27:30the Megamigon drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big Winter
- 27:33Play? Today? The Paraball jackpot is one hundred and forty five million dollars.
- 27:38The megamig Is jackpot two hundred and sixty two million dollars. So,
- 27:41as we said earlier when we were talking with Brad that Centevil two eighty will
- 27:48be up for third and final reading in the Senate today. It says,
- 27:52quote, no public school board, school superintendent, or school principles shall prohibit
- 27:57a public school classroom teach sure from discussing or answering questions from students about scientific
- 28:03theories of how the universe and or life came to existence. Sounds rather innocuous,
- 28:08but some are concerned about that, including Senator Mike Walfol, who's the
- 28:11minority leader of the Senate Democrat from Cabal County, Mike, good morning,
- 28:15good to talk to you. How are you. I'm doing well, Thanks
- 28:18Afy, Thanks for coming on. You're going to speak in opposition to this
- 28:22bill today, Why well, I'm going to ask a lot of questions of
- 28:26the of the chair of the Education Committee, because I'm not on that committee.
- 28:33The bill, the bill is well intended, the sponsors are well intended.
- 28:41You know, my particular faith, if I say a rosary, I
- 28:48was taught the first sentence of that rosary is creator of having a nurse.
- 28:53That phrase is in there. So also in my faith, been taught to
- 29:00honor an oath. And I took a note when I walked into the Senate
- 29:04chamber to up hold the Constitution. So the first Amendment of the Constitution has
- 29:10what's called the establishment Clause, and you know, I've got to uphold that.
- 29:15And the establishment Clause has been interpreted many many times to prohibit teaching.
- 29:22We'll start with the Book of Genesis. You know, in other words,
- 29:26school teachers, public employees cannot teach the Book of Genesis. That's well established
- 29:33law. And I think intelligent design, which is sort of an offshoot of
- 29:38that, is likewise been clearly determined to be outside of the parameters of the
- 29:48establishment clause or in contact with the establishment clause. So I'm just going to
- 29:52have a lot of questions about those those issues. And the term scientific theory
- 29:57is not defined in the bill, so it just it's puzzling to me on
- 30:03why we need to put this in a bill. But I'm ready to learn
- 30:06about that. And it again, I wrote about this, and this is
- 30:11this is a watered down version of an original bill that was said, passed
- 30:17this in it last year and failed the House and started out in the Senate
- 30:19this year, then got watered down, which allowed for the teaching of intelligent
- 30:23design as a quote unquote theory of how life began. And to me,
- 30:32the best case scenario is it doesn't do anything that science teachers can answer questions
- 30:36anyway and do every day if but it could also do you think it could
- 30:41also open the door for if somebody, if a science teacher chooses and they
- 30:47get a question, they could say, well, yeah, there are competing
- 30:49theories and here's a theory, and now we're gonna, you know, go
- 30:52back and look at the genesis story of how life began and teach that as
- 30:59a theory. I mean, is that is that what do you think could
- 31:02happen? Or is that just a Am I worrying too much about that?
- 31:07No? I mean, uh, let me tell you why this bill is
- 31:11unconstitutional. And I don't think anybody's talked about this. There's such a thing
- 31:15in the law. It's called the vagueness the vague noess doctrine. Okay,
- 31:18that is, if the law is vague, it can it's it's unconstitutional.
- 31:26It's got to be specific. And the most recent case is Fox Television versus
- 31:30the FCC, where the Roberts Court said unanimously that the FCC rules were vague.
- 31:37We can't really tell what they mean. They're too general, so that
- 31:42those rules were declared to be unconstitutional under the vagueness doctrine. I think that's
- 31:48what's going to happen here. This this deal is vague. We don't define
- 31:51scientific theory. We just don't. We don't know what it really means.
- 31:56So somebody's going to challenge this right away, and it's going to be declared
- 32:01unconstitutional, and somebody's going to spend a bunch of money on attorney fees,
- 32:06and you know, if we want to try to do something specific but to
- 32:13do that. But I just think this bill has been I guess you use
- 32:16the term water down. I agree with that. I just don't know what
- 32:20it means. I mean, it's I'm not rejecting anybody's faith. I'm not
- 32:23criticizing the people that wrote the bill. Sure, it's just a matter of
- 32:28I don't think it. I don't think it meets the constitutional standards. There
- 32:31is there are definitions of a scientific theory. I mean, the National Academy
- 32:37of Sciences says that a theory is quote, a well established explanation of some
- 32:43aspect of the natural world that can incorporate facts, laws, inferences, and
- 32:46tested hypotheses there. But that's not in the bill, right, Yeah,
- 32:52And there are I've found at least First of all, I went back and
- 32:54read the Book of Genesis some last night. Second, I looked at the
- 32:59seventh and you know, at least seven theories of evolution or the creation of
- 33:07you know, the evolution of man or man's existence or origins. And there's
- 33:12at least seven that are scientifically accepted. And they have to do with the
- 33:15Big Bang theory, and they have to do with you know, water in
- 33:20the ocean and this and that. But I mean when when somebody challenges this,
- 33:27and it will be challenged and you go to court, you know,
- 33:30it's like, what are we talking about here, or which of these seven
- 33:35are you you know, theories, or which of these one hundred theories that
- 33:39are generally accepted in the scientific world are we permitting teaching? There are?
- 33:45You know, Mike, there are. And it's hard to argue with you,
- 33:49because I agree with you. But there are guidelines in in rules,
- 33:58in education rules and west Weina as to how these subjects are to be taught.
- 34:04And if science teachers are doing their job, that that's what they're doing.
- 34:07And look, if a kid raises her hand and said, well I
- 34:09learn in Sunday school or I learned in church that the story of Genesis is
- 34:14a story of creation. I think any science teacher with his or assault can
- 34:17handle that and say, there are deeply held religious beliefs about creation and and
- 34:22that's fine, that's you know, that's a matter of faith. And I
- 34:27understand that it is not it doesn't happen to fit the definition of science.
- 34:30And here's the scientific explanation. I mean, they can handle that today,
- 34:37they I agree, and that probably happens in the classrooms every week, and
- 34:39this sure it does. The other thing is, you know, if you
- 34:44want to just go down the road here is there. Do you want some
- 34:47gym teacher to come into third grade and be talking about religion anyway? I
- 34:52don't know if I want my third grader or fourth grader to I just to
- 34:58me. I mean, I don't know that I want that. I'm afraid
- 35:01what they might try to say regardless. Well, look, religion, religion
- 35:07is so diff it is so diverse that, yeah, you don't want I
- 35:12mean, that's that's a really good point because for those who have deeply held
- 35:15religious beliefs, which I very much respect, be careful what you ask for,
- 35:19because if you open that door, uh, lord knows what you're going
- 35:23to get. I cited in a commentary this week. What if and you
- 35:25probably don't have this in West Virginia, but what if the teacher is happens
- 35:30to be Hindu and wants to talk about creation? Say, well, you
- 35:35know, how do you know we say that the law in house says that
- 35:37you can discuss scientific theory. Is what your scientific theory? Well, that
- 35:40is that the lotus flower grew from Lord Vishnu's navel and from that all life
- 35:45began, all life sprung. I mean, do you want that? I
- 35:50don't think so now that I'm making I'm making a very extreme point there.
- 35:57But the point is about when you start injecting different religious ideas about how life
- 36:01began, be careful, be careful in the classroom. In the classroom,
- 36:06be careful. The parents would stampede to the Board of Education if that happened,
- 36:12and they should and they should the amen to that. Yeah, do
- 36:16you say amen to that? What about that bill in the house. What
- 36:20about that bill in the House that's going to ban nude paintings in museums and
- 36:24potentially banned the Bible. Whose idea was that that? We just talked about
- 36:30that and uh, that is Deligate Steele, Deligate Steel, And I think
- 36:40it's going to be on the program tomorrow. So we're gonna talk about that.
- 36:44And look again, that opens up this discussion, is that do you
- 36:49want a third grader to have access to the book gender Queer? And I
- 36:54do get concerns about that, But by the same token, Uh, we're
- 36:59walking through the museum with your kid and there's a there is a or a
- 37:05fifteen year old who's a minor and there is a portrait from the Renaissance which
- 37:14shows women's nipples. Is somebody going to get in trouble? Yeah? I
- 37:20literally got a call from the from one of the director of the Huntington Museum
- 37:23of Art. They're concerned about passy to this bill. And would they risk
- 37:30arrest if they don't cover up maybe a statue that has nude women's breaths and
- 37:37would they would they need to hire counsel on that? So well, there
- 37:39you go. It's like, I mean, personification of Ai again over there
- 37:45in the house. Well, let's uh, let's let's bring let's bring uh.
- 37:52Well, I'm gonna stop there. I'm about to say something I shouldn't
- 37:53say. All right, Mike Walfele, who is a Democratic Center from Cabul
- 37:58County Senator goodet, talk to you, Thank you very much, thank you
- 38:01so much. All Right, when we come back on Metro News talk Line,
- 38:05we've told you about the resolution that the Republican Executive Community is going to
- 38:09take up that would limit voting in the Republican primary to Republicans only. The
- 38:15author of that resolution joins us next, so stay with us for that.
- 38:19You know, the weekend's almost here. And I think it would be great
- 38:22to relax on a pontoon vote from lou Wendel Marine this weekend. Check out
- 38:27through inventory at Louwindelmarine Sales dot com. West Virginia is home. It's where
- 38:32we work, live and raise our families. At the heart of our communities
- 38:37are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers. From life saving treatments and emergency
- 38:44care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of life
- 38:50through extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat
- 38:57of our communities. Despite the ill fated efforts of President Biden and his wealthy
- 39:05New York friends, West Virginia coal is thriving and being shipped to forty five
- 39:08countries worldwide. Given its high quality in clean burning properties, countries across the
- 39:14globe are demanding and consuming it, and in state production continues to grow.
- 39:19With billions of dollars of recent investment in West Virginia mining operations, combined with
- 39:23the reliability of our coal fired electric manufacturing facilities, West Virginia coal is here
- 39:30to stay. No other fuel in the world matches West Virginia Coal for baseload
- 39:34generation and steel making. Like a good friend, It's always been and always
- 39:39will be there, keeping the lights on and contributing greatly to our growing economy.
- 39:45In fact, coal continues to sustain fifty thousand plus West Virginia jobs,
- 39:50putting food on the table for Mountain state families. Visit Friends of Coal dot
- 39:53org to learn more. A message from the Friends of Coal. You're listening
- 39:59to talk Line on Metro News. The Voice of West Virginia. West Virginia
- 40:05Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more
- 40:09than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence
- 40:15has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 40:19No matter where we stalk the fish, they're ultimately going to look for the
- 40:22best suitable habitat. And as an angler, that's a secret learning how to
- 40:28read the water and learning where the fish are most likely to be staged for
- 40:31feeding, whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment
- 40:36of the great outdoors. And then right after the cold spale, he started
- 40:39a pattern and I came in and it was the first time out hunted him
- 40:44in the morning. About eight point thirty he strolled in and I finally connected
- 40:47with two days less than the season. Really, West Virginia Outdoors covers it
- 40:52all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors
- 40:57Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the w
- 41:00and Water every weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.
- 41:05Hey, everybody, it's Tony Gritty. I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howe,
- 41:07and we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the
- 41:12Metro News radio network. It's the city net statewide sports line. We talk
- 41:16West Virginia University football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's
- 41:21got anything to do with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't
- 41:23forget the text line available every night. So we invite you to join us.
- 41:27The Senator coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti. It's the city net state
- 41:30wide sports line on Metro News. News in the Mountain State. Happens quick
- 41:36and for decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast.
- 41:42Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you
- 41:45see news happening, become a Metro News hawk by texting news to three five
- 41:50sixty five to one. If you take a picture or video of what you
- 41:52see, submit that as well. Text the word news to three five sixty
- 41:57five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please
- 42:01don't text and drive. Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchible is brought to
- 42:19you by Encovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about
- 42:23most. Visit in Covia dot com to learn more. Talk Line from me
- 42:27Covi Insurance Studios. Jim Butler is a Republican delegate from Mason County. He's
- 42:30a member of the Republican part Executive Committee. He's also on the Resolutions Committee,
- 42:36and he proposed the resolution that starting with the upcoming primary, it should
- 42:40be limited to just readsured Republicans and not open to independence as it has been
- 42:46for a number of years. And he joins us on Metro News talk Line.
- 42:49Jim, good to talk to you again, How are you well?
- 42:52Glad to be on hot Good to talk with you. Thank you, sir.
- 42:53So what is behind your what's your thought here on why this should be
- 42:58done well? The purpose for the Republican Party and the Republican Executive Committee which
- 43:04I'm on is to grow the Republican Party, and I think now is the
- 43:07opportune time to grow our parties by doing what well. By closing the primaries,
- 43:14what we do is we invite any voter who wants to join the Republican
- 43:17Party to come out and vote for Donald Trump, who's overwhelmingly popular across the
- 43:22country, and also to vote for the winning team, to kind of invite
- 43:27people to come home to the principles that most West Virginians fair share, which
- 43:34is the principles of the Republican Party. Do you think that there's two hundred
- 43:37almost two hundred and ninety thousand non affiliated voters in West Virginia. Do you
- 43:44think they would be willing or anxious to say, well, the Republican Party
- 43:47has told me I'm either in or out. Therefore I'll get busy and change
- 43:52my registration in time for this upcoming primary. Do you think realistically and logistically
- 43:57that would happen. I think absolutely it would, and in fact, I
- 44:01think that again, I think now's the opportune time to do it, because
- 44:06if we did it where you had two or three years in order to change
- 44:08your registration to participate in the Republican primary, then people are going to say,
- 44:13oh, I've got two years to do that. I may get around
- 44:15to it eventually and probably never will. But in this case, we have
- 44:20three months to get it done. So it's a short enough time frame to
- 44:24make people take action, but it's also plenty of time to actually get it
- 44:30done. Delegate Jim Butler's with his Republican Mason County and he is on the
- 44:32Republican Party Resolutions Committee, and proposed the change that would restrict the upcoming primary
- 44:43and then future primaries to only registered Republicans in notawow independence that we are not
- 44:46affiliated to vote. Hey Jim, what about the timing of this? You
- 44:51say there's three months is a long time. But I did talk to a
- 44:52clerk from Putnam County I'm sorry, from Preston County, and she said,
- 44:59hey, we've already we've done a lot of work for this primary. Now
- 45:00we've got to change everything up in time for the May primary. Is this
- 45:07a little bit late? I don't think so at all. In fact,
- 45:10the filing deadline is not even up for candidates to file. So again,
- 45:15I think there's plenty of time to do this, and I've checked with the
- 45:19Secretary of State's office officials down there and they said, absolutely, we can
- 45:22do this. There's no reason we can't. And you know legally as well.
- 45:28I checked with the Attorney General's office and they said there's no problem with
- 45:30this whatsoever either. So yes, there is plenty of time, and I
- 45:36think there's a unique excitement this election cycle to make this happen. I mean,
- 45:40as I say, we've got Donald Trump on the on the presidential ticket,
- 45:45and we have very important races up and down the ballot in West Virginia
- 45:49from a US Senator right on down. So this is a time to create
- 45:53the excitement and to actually create voters who actually are looking at the issues maybe
- 46:00more closely and considering more closely who they're voting for. Jim, do you
- 46:07think that if this move is successful, if the Executive Committee approves this change,
- 46:12do you think this would benefit any specific candidates, And I'm thinking Alex
- 46:16Mooney, who's more conservative than Jim Justice. I'm thinking maybe Patrick Morrissey,
- 46:22he might be more conservative than a couple of the other candidates. I'm thinking
- 46:27maybe Chris Warner running for Secretary of State, and you have a former Democrat
- 46:32there who is in that race and might attract some independent voters. Doug scaff
- 46:37So, do you think there's certain candidates who would benefit if in fact this
- 46:42change is approved? Well, I think there are just some of the ones
- 46:46you just named off there. I think it may, but I think overall
- 46:52it's going to benefit every conservative Republican who every year when we run into Republican
- 46:59primaries, we claim to be conservative, we claim to be for West Virginia
- 47:04values, family values, physical responsibility, and those types of things. So
- 47:08I think this type of legislation helps us to elect more conservative Republicans and it
- 47:14helps us to pass better policies for our constituents. What have you heard from
- 47:19your fellow Republicans? This has generated a lot of discussion. Have you heard
- 47:23the pros and the cons? I've heard lots of pros and cons on both
- 47:28sides, and certainly there are My wife actually was an independent for about twenty
- 47:34years, the first twenty years we were together, and her opinion differed from
- 47:38mine for all of that time. But just recently she's come around to agree
- 47:45with my side of this that now is the right time to close the primaries.
- 47:49My daughter's a young woman, twenty years old. She said, this
- 47:52is how you get young people engaged. Again, my daughter's opinion, and
- 47:57I tend to agree with it. If you let if you let indo voters
- 48:00and affiliate voters kind of float around in the middle, they can, they'll
- 48:05tend to be they'll vote for maybe the chinest mail piece or the sharpest TV
- 48:12ad or something like that. They don't really look at the candidates are and
- 48:15what their policies are. But in my daughter's opinion, and I share this,
- 48:20I think that once people have to determine what party they want to belong
- 48:23to, if they're going to switch their registration to Republican, they're going to
- 48:27look closely at the candidates and at the policies that the candidate's estils, and
- 48:31this will be decided. I think Saturday, there was the executive Committee was
- 48:36supposed to meet last Saturday. Whether it's the prompt of this Saturday, this
- 48:38will be discussed. Correct, That is correct? Ye? All right?
- 48:43Delicate. Jim Butler, Republican, Mason County and on the Republican Party Executive
- 48:46Committee and the on the Resolutions Committee that proposed this change. Jim, good
- 48:51to talk to you again. Thanks, We'll watch this vote closely. Thanks
- 48:52for your time. All Right, thanks for the opportunity. All Right man.
- 48:55Talk line continues right back for a new episode of Healthy West Virginia is
- 49:00now posted on the podcast center of metronews dot com. You've heard of knee
- 49:05and hip replacement surgery, did you know ankle replacement surgery is possible too.
- 49:09If you're a patient with ND stage ankle arthritis bone on bone ankle arthritis with
- 49:14or without deformity, Ankle replacement is an option. Listen to Live Healthy West
- 49:20Virginia for candid conversations with insights about improving your health and well being. Live
- 49:23Healthy West Virginia is presented by WVU Medicine. Need help with your prescriptions?
- 49:30Tired of long wait times? Did your current pharmacy close or is moving?
- 49:34Give Fruth Pharmacy a try. We make it easy to transfer your prescriptions and
- 49:37we always welcome new patients. Fruth makes it easy to transfer. Call a
- 49:43local Fruth Pharmacy and they will handle the transferring process for you. We offer
- 49:47prescription rewards too. Give Fruth Pharmacy a call today for more details. Fruth
- 49:52makes it easy. Fruth your hometown Family Pharmacy. It's good to have options
- 50:00when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees, and your company.
- 50:07You want to plan with people you know, like the Health Plan, known
- 50:12for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We
- 50:19are families, we are businesses, and we are all moving forward together.
- 50:25We are here for you. The Health Plan. West Virginia is home.
- 50:30It's where we work, live and raise our families. At the heart of
- 50:35our communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving treatments
- 50:42and emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality
- 50:46of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals, Your health is
- 50:53the heartbeat of our communities. This is talk Line on Metro News, the
- 50:58voice of West Virginia WV. Metronews dot com the only website you need to
- 51:06stay informed in the Mountain State. Get the latest news in sports, story
- 51:09information on the great outdoors, and never miss an episode of your favorite metro
- 51:15news programs and podcast including Talkline, Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys
- 51:20Before the Game. Make a bookmark now and visit wv metronews dot com first
- 51:24thing every morning to find out what's happening all across the state. Wv metronews
- 51:30dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain State's only hook and bullet radio
- 51:35show dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state.
- 51:38Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more
- 51:44than twenty five years. We used to always joke when we came up here,
- 51:46that's a smallmouth here born two pounds. It's it's rare. I mean
- 51:52it's it's more common to catch a four plus than it is one under twelve
- 51:55inches here. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the
- 52:00enjoyment of the great outdoors, it's got back up and must stay in.
- 52:04Around nine o'clock, he came cruising through kind of an open area that I
- 52:07could see on the staying as fortunate enough to bagging probably the biggest bred buck
- 52:12I've ever seen it. The money normally West Virginia. Dear, don't get
- 52:14that wide. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six
- 52:19am and for your daily fix. Outdoors Today brings you two and a half
- 52:22minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro
- 52:27News, the Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to
- 52:31wrap up your weekend. It's the City that Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey,
- 52:36this is Travis Jows joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six
- 52:38oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the sports weekend. We talked
- 52:43Mountaineers, High School, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national
- 52:46scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text
- 52:51the show at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend
- 52:54sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News affiliate four Watch the show at wv
- 52:59Metronews dot com. Talkline from me and Cove Insurance Studios. The pediatric Eurology
- 53:16program at WVU Medicine Children's has been nationally recognized nationally ranked by US News and
- 53:22World Report for the sixth consecutive year Their team now includes the only board certified
- 53:27pediatric eurologists in West Virginia that can help in managing kidney, bladder and reproductive
- 53:30conditions, and they're the only pediatric eurology practice in the state offering robotic surgery.
- 53:37Trust the nation leading experts at WU Medicine Children's called eight five to five
- 53:40WVU Care or visit WU kids dot com. Back in six minutes. This
- 53:45is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. All righty
- 54:15hour, number two talk Line on the Metro News Radio network all across the
- 54:20great State of West Virginia, Broadcasting from the INCUOVA Insurance Studios in the Dale
- 54:23Miller Building. We will be at the AARP broadcast location at the State Capitol
- 54:30at the Upper Rotunda tomorrow. So the filing deadline quickly approaching in West Virginia's
- 54:34the candidates are making their final decisions whether or not to run or not to
- 54:37run. The Attorney General's seat is open because Patrick Marcy is running for the
- 54:44Republican nomination for governor. So a couple of Republicans already in the race,
- 54:47and now we have a Democrat entering the race and she joins us on Metro
- 54:52News talk line. Teresa Torreseeva, who's a Wheeling attorney. Teresa, good
- 54:55morning, how are you? Good morning, good morning. It's great to
- 54:58be joining you from Wheeling. It's good to have you from Wheeling, the
- 55:01state's first capital. So listen, tell the folks of West Virginia. I
- 55:06know who you are, But tell the folks of West Virginia who you are
- 55:07and why you're running for the Democratic nomination for attorney general. Well, the
- 55:12why is the most important question, Hoppy, And for me, the why
- 55:16is that I want to give the people of West Virginia a voice and a
- 55:22choice. And those are really my reasons. A voice and a choice.
- 55:27I want to bring my courtroom experience to the role. I at thirty years
- 55:30of it representing regular folks in courtrooms all over the state and all over the
- 55:36country and balancing things out. And I'm looking to do that in the role
- 55:40of attorney general. Now, what do you view as you talked about the
- 55:45role, but what do you think the job of the attorney general is?
- 55:46Because people have had different approaches to the attorney general's position, what should the
- 55:51Attorney general of West Virginia do? I know the first thing is they represent
- 55:53the state of West Virginia. I mean, that's the first thing. But
- 55:57what beyond that, if anything, well, they do. So it's so
- 56:00much though, to represent the state of West Virginia because it also means that
- 56:05you prosecute claims on behalf of the state of West Virginia. But I think
- 56:08it's also a role that people expect it to be a role it's their voice,
- 56:15right. A lawyer really is a voice for the people, and that's
- 56:19true for our lawyers that work across the state and courtrooms across the state.
- 56:23The attorney general is the voice for the people of West Virginia, and so
- 56:29I do think the role is essentially that you are everything to the people of
- 56:35the state of West Virginia in terms of where it begins and ends as an
- 56:38attorney. Teresa Toursee is with this wheeling attorneys. She's running for the Democratic
- 56:43nomination for attorney general. The current Attorney General, Patrick Marcy, has been
- 56:46very aggressive in joining with other Republican attorneys general across the country and filing lawsuits
- 56:52challenging various administration policies, all kinds of things. Would you be that kind
- 56:59of attorney general? Would would you be aggressive in joining in national litigation or
- 57:04filing suits, as the current Attorney general does, So my focus would be
- 57:07statewide and representing the people of West Virginia and what they wanted, and those
- 57:14choices, honestly would be made on an individual basis. I don't think my
- 57:17focus would be the same. I think it would be more internal to the
- 57:22needs of the people of West Virginia. And that's what I mean happy when
- 57:27I say I want to be a voice. I think it's important. There
- 57:30are an awful lot of people out there whose voice is not being heard,
- 57:34and I think it's important that it be heard. And one of the things
- 57:38you have to do when you're an elected official is you have to forget the
- 57:42partisan politics and you have to remember that you work for everybody. And you
- 57:46know, twenty four percent of West Virginia voters are independent voters and you work
- 57:52for them too, And so for me, I think there's decisions about getting
- 57:57involved in, you know, the political fights, which is what they are
- 58:00and what you're referring to, would have to be made very carefully remembering who
- 58:05you represent, which is everybody, right, not Republican West Virginians or Democrat
- 58:09West Virginians. Or independent, you represent everyone once elected. So I think
- 58:15those decisions need to be made more carefully and the focus needs to be on
- 58:17the legal work that needs done for the people of West Virginia. The legal
- 58:22work is substantial, and that will always be true for any state, of
- 58:27course, and the attorney general's role is so important as an independent constitutional officer
- 58:32in doing that both in policy as well, you know, and protecting the
- 58:37state from entering into problems that could be avoided. And Teresa, as you
- 58:44said, you need to be the attorney general for all the people's that's understood.
- 58:46I think that's that's a given. But you have to get elected,
- 58:50and you have to and you're running as a Democrat. You know what the
- 58:53party situation is in West Virginia. How do you do you run as a
- 58:58Democrat? Do you run as how do you get over the Democratic hump?
- 59:02Frankly in the state. I think it's a great question, and I think
- 59:06it's something that people listening want you to ask, Frankly, and I appreciate
- 59:09the question. So I'm vice chair of the West Virginia Democratic Party. I'm
- 59:14proud to be a Democrat, and I can tell you that there's a lot
- 59:17of excitement among Democrats, but there has been right a lot of loss and
- 59:22a lot of downturn. What I can tell you is that West Virginia,
- 59:25in my opinion, is neither Democrat nor Republican, but leaning very much towards
- 59:32independent. And the way you get over that is the same way Governor Andy
- 59:37Basher did in Kentucky. You remember who you're talking to, and that's everybody,
- 59:43and we stop with the nasty partisan politics and we deal with the problems
- 59:50of everybody. And so I do see that it is the Democratic Party,
- 59:58and all of us as Democrats, have worked do to teach people what we
- 1:00:01stand for. I would encourage people to look at my record of thirty years
- 1:00:07of representing people on my cases, which many of which have been highly publicized
- 1:00:12and real results, and that is what we stand for, public safety and
- 1:00:16representing workers and families and students. And so it will be a fight happy
- 1:00:25but I've never been one to shy away from a fight. And you can't
- 1:00:30win if you don't fight. So I'm in for it all right. Teresa
- 1:00:32tour Seva Wheeling attorney, announcing that she is running for the Democratic nomination for
- 1:00:37Attorney General in West Virginia. Teresa, good luck with your campaign. Thank
- 1:00:40you for coming on today, Hoppy, you broke the news. I appreciate
- 1:00:44you, thank you, thank you. All right, have a good day.
- 1:00:47Well, thank you very much. I appreciate that Teresa to so a
- 1:00:51Democrat who has some name recognition because of some of the cases she's handled in
- 1:00:55West Virginia and getting in that attorney general's race, making that an interesting rate,
- 1:01:00certainly techtopy. And this is as a note of sarcasm, thanks to
- 1:01:05Jim Butler, I will be changing my registration from Republican to independent. And
- 1:01:12this is a weigh in on this I have and I this is well a
- 1:01:16couple of things. One is, this is a party decision, so I
- 1:01:20have an opinion. But this is a party decision. It's not a legislative
- 1:01:22decision. It's not a general public decision. It's a party decision. And
- 1:01:28there are legitimate arguments for closing, for any party to close the primary because
- 1:01:35it is a nominating process and should only one can reasonably argue that members of
- 1:01:42the party should be the ones who decide who the party nominee would be.
- 1:01:45I get that, and I think that's a pretty compelling purist argument. However,
- 1:01:49the Republican Party in West Virginia, which is now dominant, grew to
- 1:01:52dominance with the help of independence of all these people who weren't comfortable with the
- 1:01:59Democrat Party, a lot of them and became independent. And then also there's
- 1:02:05just less party loyalty than there once was, so everywhere people tend more people
- 1:02:13tend to register as independent. And what is the nature of being an independent?
- 1:02:19You're independent, so you don't want to be and I just don't.
- 1:02:24I don't think it's necessarily and I don't know this. I'm just riffing here
- 1:02:29that let's say, how many people are motivated and I'm an independent, how
- 1:02:36many people are motivated by I'll register as independent? Therefore I can vote in
- 1:02:40either primary. I'm sure there are many who do do that, but how
- 1:02:45many also are saying, you know what, I really don't want to be
- 1:02:49affiliated with either party, so I'm just going to be an independent and as
- 1:02:54an added bonus, I can choose what primary I vote in, or maybe
- 1:03:00individuals always vote in the Republican primary, but they prefer to be an independent.
- 1:03:04So the nature of being an independent is that you do not want to
- 1:03:08be affiliated with the particular party. So I would be fascinated to see if
- 1:03:15this goes through. If this happens, and I don't know what's going to
- 1:03:17happen, Starady, but if it does, I think it'll be fascinating to
- 1:03:21see what happens. How many people, how many independents go, oh,
- 1:03:25yeah, well, I got to go change my registration because I want to
- 1:03:30vote for Trump and I wanted to do this. I want to be part
- 1:03:32of the Republican Party. I better go change my registration. How many people
- 1:03:36do that? How many people don't even hear about it because the only time
- 1:03:40they pay attention to elections are when they go vote, and they go,
- 1:03:43wait, mane, I'm an independent and I can't vote in Republican primary.
- 1:03:46And how many people are saying, the heck with you. You can't force
- 1:03:51me. I became an independent. You cannot force me to be a member
- 1:03:53of your party, So the heck with you. So I think it'd be
- 1:03:59fascinating to see if the Executive Committee does approve that, it'd be fascinating to
- 1:04:03see what happens. Let's see text three oh four talk three oh four.
- 1:04:14Wow, I got a lot of texts here, a lot of texts Hoppy,
- 1:04:19we the residents of West Virginia have the same values as Donald Trump.
- 1:04:25Sleep around on your wife, pay the mistress off, marry a younger woman
- 1:04:28when the wife gets too old. It's a pretty broad generalization about West Virginians,
- 1:04:33Hoppy. The delegate cites the principles of the Republican Party. The party
- 1:04:36has no principles beyond Trump. For me and my family, we stand by
- 1:04:41the Constitution, says a Texter Hoppy. I ask my family member who's an
- 1:04:47independent, if they're going to switch to the Republican Party. The answer was
- 1:04:50an emphatic no. Just one other note about that, and we've drawn a
- 1:04:55lot of attention to this, is that this is a proposal. This is
- 1:05:00a proposal, and it did not come from the party. Cherry El Jim
- 1:05:03mccartal, I want to make that clear. I think she's been getting a
- 1:05:06lot of inquiries. This came from a resolutions committee in Jim Butler Wan.
- 1:05:13Jim Butler, a Republican came up with the resolution and to pass the resolution
- 1:05:17committee for three and then it goes to the full Republican Executive Committee. They
- 1:05:23were going to meet last Saturday, but the weather was a problem. So
- 1:05:26they are meeting this Saturday. All right, we'll be back, Stay with
- 1:05:30us. Talk line continues Just a moment. Jackpot too in the milliontore in
- 1:05:32West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire. Get into Piaball drawings
- 1:05:36Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and the megamin Is drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays.
- 1:05:41Will you be the next big winner? Play today? The Paraball jackpot is
- 1:05:44one hundred and forty five million dollars. The megami Is jackpot is two hundred
- 1:05:47and sixty two million dollars. It's good to have options when Tuesday. Health
- 1:05:51coverage for your family, your employees, and your company. You want to
- 1:05:59plan with people you know like the Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer
- 1:06:05service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are families, we
- 1:06:12are businesses, and we are all moving forward together. We are here for
- 1:06:17you the health Plan. Golf Week called Pete Die Golf Club one of America's
- 1:06:23best modern courses. Golf Digest recently called Pete Die one of America's one hundred
- 1:06:28greatest courses, and Pete Dye calls it eighteen of the most exciting and memorable
- 1:06:31holes I've ever built on one course. Pete Die Golf Club invites you to
- 1:06:35join the only course named after the legendary designer himself. National, corporate and
- 1:06:41local memberships available now for a limited time. Visit Petdie dot com to learn
- 1:06:45more. Come play where the Mountaineers play at Pete Die Golf Club. West
- 1:06:50Virginia, high speed fiber internet is coming and city Net is helping lead the
- 1:06:55way to connection. City Net is West Virginia's local technology company. Their home
- 1:07:00office's phone number starts with three zero four, and long after the West Virginia
- 1:07:04Fiber project is completed, citty net will still be your local internet connection no
- 1:07:10more one eight hundred. I can't talk to a human, reach out to
- 1:07:14your neighbors at city Net. When it comes to technology, citty Net connects,
- 1:07:17protects, and perfects. West Virginia is home. It's where we work,
- 1:07:25live and raise our families. At the heart of our communities are West
- 1:07:29Virginia Hospitals, and they're compassionate caregivers. From life saving treatments and emergency care
- 1:07:34to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of life through
- 1:07:41extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the heartbeat of
- 1:07:47our communities. Met Coal Make Steel. Did you know that metallurgical coal impacts
- 1:07:53our daily lives in many ways? It's the coal used in the steel making
- 1:07:56process. Driving over a bridge or loading your family into an you experienced the
- 1:08:00value of metallurgical coal. Most met cole produced in the United States is found
- 1:08:04right here in our Appalachian basins. Infrastructure, comfort, and convenience all made
- 1:08:10possible my metallurgical coal. Learn more about met cole and the impact of the
- 1:08:13Metallurgical Coal Producers Association at Metcoalproducers dot com and remember met Cole Make Steel.
- 1:08:19You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.
- 1:08:26Wow. Metro News this morning the biggest stories from around the state of West
- 1:08:30Virginia when you want them, brought to you by Burdett Camping Center, home
- 1:08:33of the RV warranty Forever. Chris Lawrence at the anchor desk. We are
- 1:08:38ready to get the day started in West Virginia with all of the information you
- 1:08:41need. Harry Houdas sec brings you the day's headlines at Charleston man Is behind
- 1:08:44Bars in charge with murdering his girlfriend. Twenty one year old Isaac Surface was
- 1:08:47arrested Sunday night in connection with the beating death of thirty six year old Laura
- 1:08:51Farley. Surface was named as a person of interest Friday and was later picked
- 1:08:55up on a previous battery warrant before he was charged with first degree murderer.
- 1:08:59Surface is being held without bail. Kyle Wiggs at the Sports Desk, it
- 1:09:02was a huge victory for West Virginia over Kansas ninety one eighty five on Saturday,
- 1:09:09and now the Mountaineers hit the road to the next two at Central Florida
- 1:09:13Tuesday, out at Oklahoma State on Saturday. And Hobby Kirchible's daily commentary.
- 1:09:17Metro News This Morning brought to you by Burdette Camping Center. Listen where you
- 1:09:21get your favorite podcasts and online at wv metro news dot com. Metro News
- 1:09:27is your source for high school sports coverage and the exclusive home of the high
- 1:09:31school sports line. Presented by Parmlah, Kyle Wiggs and Joe Urcado, bring
- 1:09:35you the latest scores and news, along with player and coach interviews and in
- 1:09:41depth stories. Get your high school sports fixed all winter long the high School
- 1:09:45Sports Line presented by Parmah Wednesday nights at seven oh six here on the Metro
- 1:09:50News Radio network and online at wv metronews dot com. Hey there, Dave.
- 1:09:56Weekly here at your host from Metro News Hotline. Get ready for ant
- 1:10:00big journey. Every weekday from three to six pm, We've got all the
- 1:10:02excitement you need from sports to tech, music, pop culture, and everything
- 1:10:06in between. Join Coop and I as we bring you engaging discussions, captivating
- 1:10:11interviews, fun games, and the latest sports and entertainment headlines that will keep
- 1:10:14you a look. Petronews Hotline is your go to source for sports, news,
- 1:10:17entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays from three to six
- 1:10:21on Metronews and wb metronews dot com. Metro News Talkline with Hobby Kerchible is
- 1:10:40brought to you by Incovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you
- 1:10:44care about most. Visit in covid dot com to learn more. Talk Line
- 1:10:47from the Encode Insurance studios. During COVID, the state of West Virginia was
- 1:10:51buying a lot of testing kits. I mean tens of thousands of testing kits
- 1:10:57and one of the vendors of those testing kids. I think they're a out
- 1:11:01of Florida. Naturally, they supply the kits or they're supposed to, and
- 1:11:05then they submit invoices, and it was up to the DHHR, in particular
- 1:11:11individual named Timothy Pretty pr I d d Y to sign off on those invoices
- 1:11:16that in fact, either the tests were received or the services were provided,
- 1:11:21whatever those particular services were. And so this was going on thousands and thousands
- 1:11:27of times, and a federal investigator started looking into this, saying, well,
- 1:11:31wait a minute, did West Virginia get everything they were paying for?
- 1:11:34And when they were investigating this, they questioned Pretty, and Pretty was not
- 1:11:41candid with the investigators, and now he is admitted to making false statements.
- 1:11:47Will Thompson's the US attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia. Will So
- 1:11:51look, I keep having some empathy for tim Pretty because he was kind of
- 1:11:59elevated up DHR. He was supposed to sign off and make sure that tests
- 1:12:03were received or test results were received, and he just what he got overwhelmed.
- 1:12:10Let's start there before we get to the perjury. Possibly he could have
- 1:12:14got overwhelmed, but no one ever should be so overwhelmed that they simply don't
- 1:12:18tell the truth. He lied to federal investigators. He hurt our investigation into
- 1:12:26this, whether or not they were actually stay Western. He actually received the
- 1:12:28benefit of its bargain, and he was given a couple opportunities to tell the
- 1:12:31truth, and he simply chose not to. What did he say he was
- 1:12:36We were asking him to verify that the test kits the lab test team was
- 1:12:43actually done, that people received the services and the test kits that were ordered
- 1:12:46and paid for, and he stated that yes, I did verify that,
- 1:12:51and yes we did receive him, when in fact he did nothing of the
- 1:12:55sort. You all gave him, as you said, several opportunities to tell
- 1:12:59the truth. Yes, he both was interviewed by federal agents and also gave
- 1:13:04him an opportunity to tell the truth and a federal grand jury. So he
- 1:13:09pled guilty to making a false statement. He played guilty yesterday and making any
- 1:13:13false statement to a federal law enforcement office. What's the penalty for that?
- 1:13:16Maximum penalties five years. Now, he has a pretty clean history. I
- 1:13:23don't think he'll get anywhere close to that. M But he's going to think
- 1:13:27he's going to go to jail. That's up for the judges to decide,
- 1:13:30not for es attorney's office. Uh, we haven't seen all the pre sentence
- 1:13:33of investigation report yet. That was ordered yesterday. I don't know if he'll
- 1:13:39go to jail or not. And you weren't You weren't after I mean,
- 1:13:43look, you weren't really after pretty, were you? I mean? Were
- 1:13:45You're just trying to find out if the state got built? Yes, I
- 1:13:49mean we were not looking at him. We were simply asking him to tell
- 1:13:54us. Okay, it shows that this amount of tests were ordered. Uh,
- 1:13:59did people actually received these tests? Where these tests actually shipped? I
- 1:14:02don't know why. We've went back and forth several times trying to figure out
- 1:14:08a reason why he didn't tell the truth. Couldn't really determine one. And
- 1:14:12we don't think it was a financial reason or anything of that nature. We
- 1:14:14don't think he benefited personally. But he did lie and mess up a significant
- 1:14:19investigation. So the investigations botch. Now you can't get because the state got
- 1:14:25and one thing that we focused on pretty But I mean the state got built
- 1:14:29here, didn't it built? The strong word? Yes, it is all
- 1:14:32right. Let me let me let me phrase that, mister attorney, did
- 1:14:38the state end up paying thousands and thousands of dollars for something that they did
- 1:14:42not receive because of his statements, it's hard for us to determine that there
- 1:14:48could be some civil actions. We're not completely done with the criminal case,
- 1:14:53you know. We can always hope that we can find some other ways to
- 1:14:55investigate or prosecute it. But he put a severe damper on it by him
- 1:15:00I'm not telling us the truth. If he had told the truth, would
- 1:15:02that have been a lead toward holding the people really responsible for potentially bilking the
- 1:15:10state? It could have certainly have help. We spent a lot of time
- 1:15:14in resources of seeing whether or not these test kits were actually delivered. If
- 1:15:18he would have told us, hey, I didn't bother to check I was
- 1:15:21And this was in the midstic COVID and there was a lot of pressure put
- 1:15:25on a lot of people working in state and federal and local governments during COVID,
- 1:15:30he could have simply say, you know, I was overwhelmed. I
- 1:15:32didn't have time to do my job completely. I did not check that.
- 1:15:35No, he didn't say that. He went ahead and lied and said he
- 1:15:39did do his job when in fact he didn't. Did you have an attorney?
- 1:15:42An attorney would have advised you, I think, to either say nothing
- 1:15:45or sell the truth. It's just then he did have an attorney. I
- 1:15:54don't know at what point he engaged him. You know. I think that's
- 1:15:59law school one o one. You know, when the federal investigators ask you
- 1:16:01a question, you either don't answer it or you don't lie. Yeah,
- 1:16:05you guys, I mean that that is that is strong because how many you
- 1:16:10can get people on per I mean, I say perjury, but making false
- 1:16:14statements. I mean, that's so many people get caught up in that,
- 1:16:17you know, and just tell the truth is something you learned at an early
- 1:16:20age. Tell us the truth, hey, you know, and we respect
- 1:16:23people's Fifth Amendment, right, you know that's something you don't want to say,
- 1:16:27exercise the right to remain silent. Yeah, but don't don't make up,
- 1:16:31don't lie. Yeah, that almost never works with you, guys.
- 1:16:34Okay. Will Thompson, US Attorney, Southern District of West Virginia, Thanks
- 1:16:39Will, Thanks for having me. All right, man, it's easy for
- 1:16:42me to say, but this has been a an interesting case. And again
- 1:16:47I feel bad for pretty I don't know him. I don't know him at
- 1:16:51all, but he probably either either he just wasn't doing his job or was
- 1:16:57overwhelmed or and you could have he could have said that I was overwhelmed.
- 1:17:00It was COVID. I was just signing off on this stuff. Stuff was
- 1:17:03coming into the office. But anyway, making false statements, and the FEDS
- 1:17:09take that really, really, really seriously. I would take a break and
- 1:17:14come back anti smoking effort to go by students at the capitol today, we'll
- 1:17:18talk about that, and also coming up, we'll talk with the president of
- 1:17:23the West Virginia Library Association about that bill which would apply criminal penalties if there
- 1:17:30is obscene material on the shelves accessible to minors. That's going to be controversial,
- 1:17:40and that's coming up next. This is talk Line on Metro News,
- 1:17:43the Voice of West Virginia. It's eleven thirty. Let's get a news update,
- 1:17:46check in with the Metro News radio network. Finally, what's happening statewide
- 1:17:49this hour, all across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro
- 1:17:57News. I'm Chris Laurence. As lawmakers open up today's four this hour,
- 1:18:00several proposals are starting to take shape. House Bill forty two oh five is
- 1:18:03one that gives the legislature authorization to sue state officials attempting to make aunauthorized changes
- 1:18:09to election laws and Metronoo statewide Correspondent Brad McIlhaney adds, there's another wrinkle that
- 1:18:14empowers voters in much the same way. Another element of House Bill four to
- 1:18:18two zero five would allow citizens to seek court order against any state or local
- 1:18:24official who fails to abide by or to enforce a state election law or regulatory
- 1:18:30requirement. House Judiciary Committee advanced the bill Monday afternoon. It was one of
- 1:18:34several that moved on were election related. Charleston police investigating after receiving a fake
- 1:18:40call about a man claiming he had shot his parents and brother at a home
- 1:18:43in Charleston South Hills neighborhood on Monday. Police Chief of Detectives Lieutenant Tony Hasley
- 1:18:47says it was all a hoax when they arrived on the scene. WCCHS Television
- 1:18:53obtained the nine to one to one call, where the man told dispatchers he
- 1:18:56would not put down the gun because he wanted to shoot more. People don't
- 1:19:00want to put it down because if I see anyone come, I'm going to
- 1:19:02shoot them. If I see cops, I'm going to shoot the cops.
- 1:19:05Still unclear who made the call or why. A Cabal County man facing charges
- 1:19:11for a fatal accident from twenty twenty two will now stand trial in March for
- 1:19:15prosecutors asked for him or granted a trial delay Monday. In the case of
- 1:19:18twenty five year old Andrew Wyrick of Cloden. You're listening to Matronews the Boys
- 1:19:23of West Virginia. You guys just didn't want it bad enough. That should
- 1:19:29have been an easy win. What were you doing out there? You got
- 1:19:31a hustle. You could have made that play if you've been open on the
- 1:19:36car at home after the game, when you think you're helping by telling me
- 1:19:41what I did wrong and what I need to work on. Only here is
- 1:19:47that I'm not good enough, that I'm supposed to be perfect, That it's
- 1:19:51not okay to lose on the car at home. All I need to hear
- 1:19:58is how much you love me and enjoy watching me play. That my worth
- 1:20:02isn't determined by my performance, that even on my worst day, I am
- 1:20:08worthy, that you see me learning, growing and doing my best and that
- 1:20:15is enough. This message presented by the WVSSAC and the West Virginia Athletic Directors
- 1:20:23Association. It is Tobacco Free Day at the Legislature. Among the activities to
- 1:20:27spotlight the event, five hundred middle and high school students are at the Capitol
- 1:20:30today showing their packing of the youth led tobacco Prevention movement. It's a one
- 1:20:34day event that aims to educate the state's youth about the dangers of tobacco products
- 1:20:39and to empower them with tools and resources to take back schools and communities.
- 1:20:43Teams will learn more about how tobacco use affects their lung capacity and how to
- 1:20:46say no to not only tobacco, but to vaping as well. From the
- 1:20:49Macro News anchored ass Guy, I'm Chris Lawrence talk line from the in Cove
- 1:21:10Insurance Studios Hoppy Kerchival with you. West Virginia high speed fiber internet is coming
- 1:21:15and city Neet is helping lead the way to connection. City Net is West
- 1:21:17Virginia's local technology company. Their home office is phone number starts with three oh
- 1:21:21four. Long after the West Virginia Fiber project is completed, city Net will
- 1:21:26still be your local Internet connection. When it comes to technology, city,
- 1:21:29NEET connects, protects and perfects. As you just heard Chris on the news,
- 1:21:33about five hundred middle and high school students representing West Virginia's youth led tobacco
- 1:21:39prevention movement, the RAYS program, are at the state capital today. It's
- 1:21:43the twentieth annual Tobacco Free Day. Joining us on Metro News talk line two
- 1:21:46students participating, Brie Cutwright, a tenth grader from Liberty High School in Harrison
- 1:21:51County, and JR. Ash, who is a senior from Cable Midland in
- 1:21:57Huntington. They're both on the phone with me. JR. Let me start
- 1:21:59with you. Thanks for coming on. So what motivated you to be there
- 1:22:02today? Yeah, So I've worked with RAISE for a couple of years now,
- 1:22:09and I got started when I was first going in the middle school.
- 1:22:13There was RAISED had a group of my middle school and I wanted to get
- 1:22:16more involved because my dad smoked for many years and developed lung cancer. So
- 1:22:20I wanted to figure out the ins and outs of tobacco usage and kind up
- 1:22:27how that process works when someone is smoking and understanding more about how it's not
- 1:22:32a choice and the overall facts about it. So, JR. You saw
- 1:22:35firsthand the impact of long term smoking with your dad. So what do you
- 1:22:41think then when your classmates if they take up smoking or smoke with tobacco or
- 1:22:45vaping, and do you all talk about that? I mean, do you
- 1:22:48feel confident enough to talk to them about the potential health hazards associated with it
- 1:22:54or do you do I keep your mouth shut? Yeah, So that's one
- 1:22:58of raises key. We want to make sure that people have open conversations about
- 1:23:03nicotine and its addictive properties, and so we train our students in the organizations
- 1:23:11to make sure that they are ready for those conversations and they have the knowledge
- 1:23:15and the facts to make sure that they're providing accurate and update information because this
- 1:23:18is something that is changing constantly and it will forever change. JR. Isn't
- 1:23:24there a lot of peer pressure? I mean, I'm sure you have friends
- 1:23:27or people you're in school with who they smoke or you smokeless tobacco, and
- 1:23:30there's peer pressure. So and so does it and they're cool, so I
- 1:23:33should try it. How do you handle the peer pressure? Yeah? So
- 1:23:38peer pressure is a really, really big factor, and so that's another strategy
- 1:23:43that race focuses on is using tactics to avoid peer pressure and to find other
- 1:23:47ways to have fun and to show that you are phillical person that can still
- 1:23:54fit in. And so just finding that whether it's music, if it's art,
- 1:23:58sports, whatever it might be, that you find your place that is
- 1:24:01living with alt, tobacco and nicotine in your life. That's really well said
- 1:24:05Brie Cutwright is also with us. Brie is a tenth grader from Liberty High
- 1:24:09School. So, Bri, why are you involved in the Raised movement?
- 1:24:14I got involved when I was in sixth grade, and I started because my
- 1:24:17grandfather was a smoker, and I grew up around it and saw what it.
- 1:24:21I had seen what it was doing to him, and I noticed those
- 1:24:27things, and when I joined, I'll be honest, it was my favorite
- 1:24:30teacher at the time was leading our group, and I saw, Okay,
- 1:24:32there's more time to spend with my favorite teacher. And then I grew and
- 1:24:36grew, and I fell in love with advocacy, and I fell in love
- 1:24:40with education and spreading the word of tobacco prevention. Did you ever have a
- 1:24:46chance or feel that you wanted to talk with your grandfather about his habit I
- 1:24:55did, and I actually did talk with him and I actually got him to
- 1:24:58quit using to and stop smoking. And it was a huge win for me,
- 1:25:02but even more of a win for him, because who knows if he
- 1:25:05would have kept on with that habit, he might not be here with me
- 1:25:09today. And I feel like it's super important and impactful that I got that
- 1:25:13opportunity, and I want to give all the other parents and grandparents that opportunity
- 1:25:16as well. That's amazing, well done. Congratulations. So let me ask
- 1:25:20you the same thing I as JR. What about peer pressure, which is
- 1:25:24very significant in high school and middle school, And that is other friends or
- 1:25:29associates who smoke and they may be cool, they may not be cool too,
- 1:25:31I don't know, and the impact of that and how you deal with
- 1:25:34that. So at my school, it's very prevalent that it's a certain group
- 1:25:43of kids that do it, and there's like a certain group and everyone knows
- 1:25:47that, Like if those kids all were in the bathroom at once, we
- 1:25:50all know what's happening. So when they start to, like in class,
- 1:25:55when they whenevery wady starts to see it, it's and it's starting to create
- 1:26:00to the other children as well, Like, so all the other students are
- 1:26:02seeing that, and it's like they're getting away with it. Maybe it's cool,
- 1:26:05Maybe I should try it, But in reality, we all know it's
- 1:26:10not cool, and we know that it's something that is not good for us.
- 1:26:14But the prerofessor like, if we just take a second and think about
- 1:26:17it, we can think of a much better solution for this problem. Yeah,
- 1:26:23Brie, have you ever tried smoking? And what was if you did,
- 1:26:25what was your reaction to it? I am not okay, and I'm
- 1:26:31going to stay that way, all right. Bree cut Right, tenth grader
- 1:26:35at Liberty High School in Harrison County, got a grandfather to quit smoking.
- 1:26:39She's involved in Rais Jr. Ash a senior at Capbell Midland, Huntington.
- 1:26:43He saw firsthand impact of smoking on his dad. He's involved in the Ray's
- 1:26:47Movement, the anti Tobacco campaign Jr. Brie, thank you for coming on.
- 1:26:51Good work, good to talk to you both. Thank you, Thank
- 1:26:56you. We'll take a break of me back, well, come back,
- 1:26:58we'll talk to the president. Virginia Library Association Association. They are concerned about
- 1:27:03a bill that there's going to be a public hearing on tomorrow. That would
- 1:27:08criminalize be certain, that would criminalize librarians, school officials, if there were
- 1:27:16materials in libraries that were deemed obscene and accessible to miners. That's next when
- 1:27:27talk line continues. Hello, my name is Haley Bunn, and I'm running
- 1:27:30as an incumbent for the West Virginia Supreme Court. I'm a coal miner's daughter
- 1:27:33and a lifelong West Virginian who has the honor of being the youngest woman ever
- 1:27:38to serve on the Supreme Court. I was appointed by Governor Jim Justice after
- 1:27:43many years in private practice in seven years as a federal prosecutor biting violent crime
- 1:27:47and the opioid epidemic. I'm a Christian, a mother, and a wife,
- 1:27:50and I'd be honored to have your vote. Vote Justice Hailey Bunn for
- 1:27:55West Virginia Supreme Court, paid for by Hailey Bunn for West Virginia. W
- 1:28:00U Medicine Children's has been named the number one children's hospital in West Virginia by
- 1:28:04US News and World Report for the third year in a row. We're the
- 1:28:09largest group of pediatric, primary specialty and high risk maternal care providers in the
- 1:28:14state, and we're home to the state's only pediatric cardiac surgery program and pediatric
- 1:28:19epilepsy Monitoring Unit. Trust the top children's hospital in the state, WVU Medicine
- 1:28:25Children's Visit WVU kids dot com. Every house tells a story, and that's
- 1:28:30where I come in. My name is Aaron Weston, and my husband and
- 1:28:32I in calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipients.
- 1:28:38After I graduated from WVU, I knew I wanted to carve a career
- 1:28:41in West Virginia, building a small business and helping people see the potential in
- 1:28:45their home. Now that's a great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia Lottery
- 1:28:48have helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to Promise scholarships since
- 1:28:54two thousand and two for students like Aaron. West Virginia Lottery What if you
- 1:28:59play? It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family,
- 1:29:03your employees, and your company. You want to plan with people you know,
- 1:29:11like the Health Plan known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right
- 1:29:17here in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses, and we
- 1:29:24are all moving forward together. We are here for you the health Plan.
- 1:29:30This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia, this
- 1:29:35Saturday and every Saturday throughout the high school basketball season. Don't miss the high
- 1:29:41School Basketball Round Up, a weekly update of high school teams across the Mountain
- 1:29:45State featuring scores, rankings, and in depth features. Join Kyle Wiggs,
- 1:29:49Joe Ricado, and your host Bred Persinger for the latest high school basketball news
- 1:29:56on the high School Basketball Round Up from the Voice of high school sports in
- 1:30:00West Virginia, the Metro News Radio Network. Hi, this is Hoppy Kourchible
- 1:30:05inviting you to join me weekdays from teno six till noon for Metro News talk
- 1:30:09Line. Each day, I'm trying to provide the very latest news and information
- 1:30:13about our state and our nation. I interview newsmakers and thought leaders who help
- 1:30:16us better understand these stories. Yes, I'm mixing my observations, but mostly
- 1:30:20I just want us to be better informed. So I'm inviting you to be
- 1:30:25my radio and streaming companion as we sort out and work through the news and
- 1:30:29information of each day. That's talk Line weekdays ten o six till noon on
- 1:30:31this Metro News Radio station. Hey everybody, it's Tony Curridi and I'm Brad
- 1:30:36Howe and that makes two of the three guys that bring you the podcast entitled
- 1:30:41Creatively Enough, Three Guys Before the Game. It's our opportunity to really drill
- 1:30:45down on WVU football and basketball. We break down the opponent and then review
- 1:30:49every single game. We'll give you some numbers, we'll bicker back and forth,
- 1:30:54we'll take your calls, your text your tweets and get into some of
- 1:30:57your questions, and we invite you to join us each in every episode at
- 1:31:00three Guys Before the Game. From Metro News Well, Metro News Capital Report
- 1:31:06bringing you the latest news from the West Virginia State Capitol Complex and the twenty
- 1:31:11twenty four legislative session. Hoppy Kerchival, Jeff Jenkins, Brad McElhinney and the
- 1:31:15rest of the Metro News staff bring you daily updates on what's happening inside the
- 1:31:20House of Delegates and State Senate, including committee meetings and introduction of bills.
- 1:31:25Each weekday, morning and afternoon. Get the Capitol Report on your favorite Metro
- 1:31:30News radio station. Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you
- 1:31:49by Incoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 1:31:55Visiting covia dot com to learn more talk line from the in cob Insurance
- 1:31:59studios. There's going to be public hearing tomorrow morning at the West Virginia Legislature
- 1:32:02on House Built forty six fifty four. Now this is it's just been introduced,
- 1:32:06hasn't been taken up by committee. I think this is going to be
- 1:32:10hot. It's been introduced by Delegate Steel, and I have a request out
- 1:32:14for Delegate Steel to be on this program tomorrow. But what this would do
- 1:32:17would it would remove the exemption that now public libraries and museums have from criminal
- 1:32:26liability relating to distribution and display of obscene material to miners. That's how it
- 1:32:35is, how it's phrase. Now, what that would mean is that a
- 1:32:40librarian or a museum curator, Apparently what that means is could be held criminally
- 1:32:45liable if there is a determination that there is material in that library or in
- 1:32:51that museum that is deemed as obscene. And I think the penalty would be,
- 1:32:58if convicted, would be five years in prison and then a twenty five
- 1:33:00thousand dollars fine, let me bring in on this because this has been making
- 1:33:04the rounds with the libraries in West Virginia. Meghan Tarbet. Megan Tarbet is
- 1:33:10director of the Putnam County Library and she's president of the West Virginia Library Association.
- 1:33:14Megan, good morning, Thank you for joining us. How are you
- 1:33:16hi? Good morning? What does your organization think of this bill? We
- 1:33:20would like it not to leave the committee. It is it would be a
- 1:33:25huge burden to our staff and our community. In many ways, each library
- 1:33:31is in charge of their own selection, so it is it is very local.
- 1:33:35You know, there is no one, one central place telling us what
- 1:33:39to put on our shelves. So you know, it is our libraries who
- 1:33:43are also community members, and a library should have something on it for everyone.
- 1:33:49And we you know, encourage families to come in together. You know,
- 1:33:54we have you can get a library card, but usually you know,
- 1:33:58anyone under twelve has to have a parent signature. So we have systems in
- 1:34:04place already, you know, for families to enjoy our materials together. And
- 1:34:11this bill would just make our jobs infinitely harder, infinitely harder by hell,
- 1:34:18well, the threat of prosecution. So what I'm afraid is that it would,
- 1:34:28you know, cause some self censorship, so you know, libraries wouldn't
- 1:34:31select books that they might otherwise have purchased in the past. And also it
- 1:34:36would be a burden for our budgets having to increase insurance liabilities and you know
- 1:34:45the cost of that on flat and already you know, declining budgets, so
- 1:34:50that means less books on the shelves, less service if we have to put
- 1:34:55money towards those things. Megan Target as with us, she is present Virginia
- 1:35:00Library Association. The argument, which I think we're going to hear on the
- 1:35:02other side, and we'll talk with probably delicate Steal tomorrow, I hope,
- 1:35:06is that, look, they don't want obscene, but they don't want miners
- 1:35:11to have access to material that is by definition and state, well obscene.
- 1:35:17Isn't that a legitimate concern? We do we do under we do understand those
- 1:35:25concerns. Of course, in in libraries, you know, we do our
- 1:35:30best to put books where they best belong, you know, by the body
- 1:35:33age ranges that are suggested, and some libraries are able to have separate sections
- 1:35:41for our children, for our teams and for our adults. But you know,
- 1:35:45our smallest libraries don't have that space to separate out those collections like that.
- 1:35:50So I think part of the concern there is, you know, when
- 1:35:58a library is one room, it is very hard to portion out kind of
- 1:36:02where books go. But also, you know, as I mentioned earlier,
- 1:36:10we are tasked with representing our communities and having materials for a wide range of
- 1:36:18ideas and thoughts, and all of that is encompassed within a single library,
- 1:36:25and as I mentioned, if it's just one room, is it is harder
- 1:36:28to make those space distinctions. Megan, I wonder too that And this is
- 1:36:34a softball question, frankly, but so let's say there's a sixteen year old
- 1:36:41who's in the library and they're doing a research project and they're reading, they're
- 1:36:45looking through an art book on the Renaissance, and there's you know, a
- 1:36:50lot of nude women and men in Renaissance paintings. Would that be do you
- 1:36:55think under this and as this bill is proposed, you think that would be
- 1:36:58a problem. You think that'd be an issue? This is this is going
- 1:37:03to be subjective because right now that wouldn't be defined as as obscene, and
- 1:37:15I believe our our current obscenity code I believe it's sixty one D eight a
- 1:37:20dash two uh. And it talks about, you know, the display of
- 1:37:28obscene materials and what that is defined as. But art you know, would
- 1:37:38not be anything with artistic merit usually is not classified as obscene. But look,
- 1:37:46if if if this became law, I think there could be an interpretation
- 1:37:53by some would say, well, I can use this for anything that I
- 1:37:57think is obscene and then let the you know, let the let the joke
- 1:38:00sort it all out. But what does I wonder too, whether and I
- 1:38:02think you allude to this, Megan, whether the librarian is getting in new
- 1:38:06books all the time and you get in a book that it's a popular book,
- 1:38:10but it's somewhat controversial because it deals with you know, sex or rape
- 1:38:15or gender issues, and that librarian's looking at that and thinking, do I
- 1:38:19want to put this on the shelf? Do you think that would happen?
- 1:38:23Do you think that would give librarians second thought because of the threat of prosecution?
- 1:38:29Absolutely? And what is and why is that a bad thing? Again?
- 1:38:36Our our job isn't to tell people what to read or to hinder their
- 1:38:44quest of knowledge. Our job is to provide a wide array on different topics
- 1:38:53and different reading interests. You know, some will use romance novels for an
- 1:39:00example. You know, some of them are what they call closed door,
- 1:39:04so you know there's romance, but anything physical happens off the page. There
- 1:39:10are what they call spicy books, and they are also people also want to
- 1:39:15read those, and so they both are on the shelves in our libraries.
- 1:39:20Those are of course in our adult fiction sections. But it's not our job
- 1:39:27to guess what people want to read. So that's why we try to purchase
- 1:39:33as widely as possible on a variety of different subjects. Does you said that,
- 1:39:39you know, libraries operate independently, but you do have an association.
- 1:39:42Do you all have any standard that you follow or even anecdotal conversations about controversial
- 1:39:48books that should or should not be placed and be available to children for example?
- 1:39:54I mean, do you all have those discussions? The association is tasked
- 1:40:00with, you know, putting together our our continuing education conferences, and we
- 1:40:03do have different committees. You know, we've we've got an Intellectual Freedom committee,
- 1:40:08so some of those things are talked about in there, but we don't
- 1:40:11we do not have like best practices of what books to put on your shelf
- 1:40:15and what not to every library and library system and their board of directors UH
- 1:40:20works on their collection development policy and also how they deal with challenged materials.
- 1:40:28You know, every library system does have a process if someone and we always
- 1:40:32have. This isn't a recent thing on what to do if if someone does
- 1:40:36have a concern about a book and there you know there are there are forms
- 1:40:42you can fill out. You can you know, say why and what page
- 1:40:45and what passage and then you know that does go for review again like locally
- 1:40:50within like the local UH library and the local board UH you know who best
- 1:40:57know their community. Megan talk and I'm not sure. I guess you will
- 1:41:01be there. Others will be there tomorrow on behalf of the Library Association to
- 1:41:03speak against this bill. Is that correct? Good? That is correct?
- 1:41:06All right, Megan, thank you for coming on good to speak with you.
- 1:41:09I appreciate your time this morning. Thank you, Thank you. That
- 1:41:12public hearing is tomorrow morning on House Bill forty six point fifty four. Will
- 1:41:16be right back. Thanks to all who have sent in some fantastic pictures of
- 1:41:20your hunting and fishing adventures to our Hoodoo Sports Trophy photo Contest check out the
- 1:41:25gallery at the Outdoors page of w v metronews dot com. Also, submit
- 1:41:29your pictures now and get in on the final monthly drawing plus the grand prize
- 1:41:32drawing a Hoodoo Sports Fishing kayak, for which we'll draw during the month of
- 1:41:35February. Learn how to submit your pick by clicking the Hoodoo Sports icon at
- 1:41:40the Outdoors page of w v metro news dot com. And remember, if
- 1:41:44it's a trophy to you, it's a trophy to us. In os West
- 1:41:47Virginians, we are proud of the natural beauty of a mountain state and the
- 1:41:51GLMILM Architects and Engineers. Our goal is to provide design solutions that give people
- 1:41:57the same pride in our built environment. Commitment to quality can be seen and
- 1:42:01recreational facilities throughout the state, from the Charleston Coliseum and Convention Center to the
- 1:42:06Valley Park Community Center, the Shawnee Sport Complex, and through the recent improvements
- 1:42:11to the lodges at Pipestin Resort State Park. CML Architects and Engineers, you
- 1:42:15see us in your community every day. Every house tells a story, and
- 1:42:19that's where I come in. My name is Aaron Weston and my husband and
- 1:42:23I in calendar construction in Charleston. I'm also a West Virginia Promise Scholarship recipient.
- 1:42:28After I graduated from WVU, I knew I wanted to carve a career
- 1:42:30in West Virginia. Building a small business and helping people see the potential in
- 1:42:34their home. Now, that's a great story. Proceeds from the West Virginia
- 1:42:39Lottery have helped generate nearly eight hundred and seventy six million dollars to Promise scholarships
- 1:42:44since two thousand and two for students like Aaron West Virginia Lottery What if you
- 1:42:47play? It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family,
- 1:42:54your employees, and your company. You want to plan with people you know,
- 1:43:00Oh like The Health Plan known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered
- 1:43:08right here in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses, and
- 1:43:14we are all moving forward together. We are here for you the Health Plan.
- 1:43:18You're listening to talk Line on Metro News. The Voice of West Virginia.
- 1:43:26West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated
- 1:43:30to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning
- 1:43:34host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty
- 1:43:39five years. No matter where we stalk the fish, they're ultimately going to
- 1:43:43look for the best suitable habitat. And as an angler, that's the secret
- 1:43:46of learning how to read the water and learning where the fish are most likely
- 1:43:50to be staged for feeding, whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling
- 1:43:56stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. And then right after the colds
- 1:44:00Vale, he started a pattern and I came in and it was the first
- 1:44:03time one hunted him in the morning, about eight point thirty he strolled in
- 1:44:08and I finally connected. With two days left than the season. Really,
- 1:44:11West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for
- 1:44:15your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news
- 1:44:19and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice
- 1:44:24of West Virginia. Hey, everybody, it's Tony Courritty, I'm Greg Hunter
- 1:44:28and I'm Brad Howe, and we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays
- 1:44:31right here on the Metro News Radio network. It's the city Nets Statewide sports
- 1:44:35Line. We talk West Virginia University, football, basketball, baseball, you
- 1:44:41name it. If it's got anything to do with the Golden Blue, We're
- 1:44:44on it. And don't forget the text line available every night. So we
- 1:44:46invite you to join us. The Senator Coach Hunter and me Tony Coritti.
- 1:44:50It's the city Nets state Wide sports Line on Metro News. News in the
- 1:44:55Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have depended on Metro new News for
- 1:45:00accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West
- 1:45:04Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro News Hawk by
- 1:45:09texting news too three five sixty five to one. If you take a picture
- 1:45:13or video of what you see, submit that as well. Text the word
- 1:45:16news to three five sixty five one to submit your tip or story. Standard
- 1:45:20texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive. Talk on for me in
- 1:45:40COVID Insurance Studios, Paul, you want to weigh in on this bill that
- 1:45:43they're gonna have the public hearing on tomorrow. What do you got on it?
- 1:45:45Yeah, happy. I just wanted to give you a quick my thought
- 1:45:48on it and I'll hang out with you. Respond Okay, you know it
- 1:45:51sounds like what I heard. It sounds like the preamble to four point fifty
- 1:45:57one fahrenheit. To me, I think it's pretty scary. Thanks, you're
- 1:46:00welcome. One hundred and seven sixty five eight two five five And Greg,
- 1:46:04Hi, Greg, what do you got for us? Yeah? Hey,
- 1:46:08Hampy, thanks for taking my call. There's a bill up before the House.
- 1:46:12It's House Bill forty three seventy six. It has to do with smoke
- 1:46:15evacuation in our operating rooms. It was passed last year by the House like
- 1:46:21ninety two to three. It was referred to the Senate and it died in
- 1:46:26the Health and the Health Committee in the Senate. I'd just like for your
- 1:46:31listeners to go ahead and contact or congressman and support that bill because it's very
- 1:46:38dangerous. The smoke bloom in the o R contains about cancer cells lookemia.
- 1:46:44There's something like one hundred and fifty chemical compounds within that. Let me ask
- 1:46:50you that going to I've heard about that bill that's been brought to my attention,
- 1:46:54and I didn't know. I mean, but there is sometimes smoke in
- 1:46:57the er when they do certain procedures, so there would be certain toxins in
- 1:47:00the air. But aren't they that now I got twenty seconds. Isn't the
- 1:47:03operating room ventilated pretty thoroughly and people have their masks on it and top No,
- 1:47:09the well the mask only takes seventy seven at leads about thirty percent of
- 1:47:14stuff coming through the operating room masks. They are not really high efficiency.
- 1:47:18Well, i'll tell you what I have. Who brought that to my attention,
- 1:47:21I can't remember, but you did too, and I'll keep an eye
- 1:47:25on that. As you said, it did pass the House last year,
- 1:47:27so I'll watch out for that one. We'll do a little bit more on
- 1:47:30that. Thank you for the heads up. See you tomorrow from Charleston.
- 1:47:32This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.