Latest / new renaissance capital / The Fight For Bitcoin Rights In South Africa w/ Hermann Vivier
Transcript
- 0:00I hope that people look at this as a canary in the coal mine type moment because ultimately
- 0:04Bitcoin takes power away from powerful individuals.
- 0:09Controlling the money supply has always been a favorite control mechanism for emperors
- 0:15and kings and presidents and who have you all across history.
- 0:21So it's no different today.
- 0:23We're trying to stay and do something about it.
- 0:30What's going on, everybody? Frank Corva here.
- 0:36Just wanted to start off by saying we had a slight technical glitch when we recorded the introduction to the podcast.
- 0:43So I'm just re-recording an introduction here, and then we'll just transition over to the actual recording in just a moment.
- 0:49So let me actually just introduce our guest here.
- 0:52The guest for today is Hermann Vivier, who is the founder of Bitcoin Akazi, the Surfer Kids nonprofit,
- 0:58and just generally speaking, a prominent South African Bitcoiner who's been doing incredible work
- 1:04there. And now we'll transition back over to the actual recording where I discuss how some of that
- 1:10work that Herman is doing is in jeopardy. So to dive right in, Herman, first of all,
- 1:15how are you doing with everything going on? And then second of all, maybe bring us up to speed
- 1:19with what exactly is happening in South Africa right now as it pertains to Bitcoin.
- 1:23um yeah thanks man i appreciate it thanks for doing this um i'm i'm doing all right i mean
- 1:30to be honest with you uh the project that that uh that i helped to run keeps me busy on a daily
- 1:36basis so i've not been paying as much attention as i should to this um it's been sitting in the
- 1:43back of my head obviously it's a massive concern i'm i'm quite concerned um i'm not so concerned
- 1:49for the people who, the small minority of people who have practiced perfect privacy from day one.
- 1:57The cypherpunks, I don't think, have anything to worry about. It's the people who are newly
- 2:05onboarded and it's the people who use custodial services that are currently KYC-free that I'm
- 2:13concerned about. I'm of the belief that in the interim period, non-KYC custodial Bitcoin services
- 2:22are an important part of the ecosystem. Obviously, we want to work towards an environment where
- 2:29everybody is doing self-custody, but at the moment, that's not quite possible in a non-technical way.
- 2:35So yeah, that's my main concern. I'm also a little bit concerned for myself for obvious
- 2:42reasons um i've made it quite clear for a number of years now um that i'm very much
- 2:49interested in bitcoin and it's a fair assumption to make um so um yeah i mean yeah i don't know
- 2:59it's uh it's it's it's a bit of a wild situation to be honest uh i don't know what's going to
- 3:04happen. It was not unexpected. But what was surprising is the level to which the proposed
- 3:15regulations are, number one, incredibly vague. So when you were doing the intro there and you said
- 3:24these regulations could potentially ban Bitcoin, I thought to myself, well,
- 3:29a lot of people would say that is hyperbolic, but not really, because you could interpret
- 3:38the regulations in such a way, they are so vague, that if you take the most extreme,
- 3:45not even the most extreme, if you take a relatively extreme interpretation, that is effectively what they do.
- 3:59Nice.
- 4:02Also, Herman, if you don't mind, just one thing that I'm thinking here, some people who are tuning into this are probably familiar already with what's going on.
- 4:10But maybe let's actually rewind just a teeny bit before you continue.
- 4:13And I don't mean to stop your train of thought, but maybe just give an overview of what these regulations are proposing.
- 4:18What exactly they're, well, as you said, they're vague, so we don't know exactly what they're proposing.
- 4:22But a few of the stipulations, like the fact that you would have to sell your Bitcoin to the to the Treasury, to the South African Treasury, the fact that you would have to turn your Bitcoin over your seed phrase over or that these circular economies would essentially be outlawed.
- 4:36Can we touch on exactly what the regulations are proposing and then how you think they could be interpreted?
- 4:41it um yeah i'll do my best um i i've read through them with the help of a um of an ai obviously um
- 4:54as most people have done um but i spent quite a bit of time interrogating the draft uh to try and
- 5:03understand exactly what is and what isn't possible um and my conclusion is that so so this is this is
- 5:10a proposed amendment to the existing Capital Controls Act of 1961, I think. So the South
- 5:20African government passed the Capital Controls Act in 1961, and it's basically been what it is
- 5:26since then. So it hasn't really been updated. So this is a proposed update. And so people who
- 5:31actually support these new draft regulations are saying, well, this is just a modernization effort.
- 5:36We're just bringing that old act into the digital age.
- 5:40That's the sort of the benevolent interpretation of this.
- 5:47So what the regulations propose very, very basically is that essentially what it seems they're trying to do is to bring all Bitcoin and crypto activity.
- 6:02And look, by the way, first of all, these regulations pertain not only to Bitcoin and crypto, but to other forms of assets, too.
- 6:10So gold and all kinds of other financial assets are covered by this.
- 6:16So it's not only relevant to Bitcoin and crypto, but I think it's quite clear that it's largely aimed at Bitcoin and crypto because it is a modernization effort.
- 6:25effort. And essentially, at a high level, what it seems they're trying to do is to bring all of
- 6:34Bitcoin and crypto into a sort of a KYC walled garden, essentially. So first of all, you'd have
- 6:42to, and I think this is my biggest problem with these draft regulations, is that it seems as if
- 6:48the entire thing hinges on this undefined threshold. And so in these regulations, they
- 6:56mention a threshold and say, for example, any holdings above that threshold would have to be
- 7:07declared and would have to be deposited in a regulated financial institution. And then the
- 7:13obvious first question is, well, what is that threshold? Because if that threshold is, you know,
- 7:18$100, or if that threshold is $10 million, those are two very, very different situations. Are you
- 7:25going to require that everybody who holds more than $100 worth of crypto or Bitcoin deposit that
- 7:31into a KYC financial institution? Or are you going to require that everybody who holds above
- 7:37a $100 million or $10 million worth of Bitcoin or crypto deposit that into a KYC financial
- 7:42institution. That's two very different scenarios. And the threshold is undefined. So that's
- 7:48a big concern. I mean, that has, you know, depending on what the threshold is,
- 7:54this thing could look very, very different. And though that bothers me, that you would
- 7:59choose to omit, well, perhaps not choose. I mean, one could also assume that this is pure
- 8:05incompetence or just total ignorance. It could be that. But the fact that that threshold is omitted
- 8:14raises a lot of very obvious concerns. So, yeah. And so there are other stipulations as well. I
- 8:24think the one that bothers me most coming from a circular economy perspective is that essentially
- 8:31sending Bitcoin back and forth between individuals becomes illegal above that threshold
- 8:39because you're only allowed to send Bitcoin between regulated financial institutions.
- 8:44So I'm allowed to pay you in Bitcoin. I'm allowed to send you Bitcoin.
- 8:50But if it's above that threshold, and again, this threshold is undefined, so we have no idea what it is.
- 8:56But let's assume for argument's sake, the threshold is $100.
- 9:01It would mean that any transaction with a value higher than $100 between two individuals would become effectively illegal unless those two individuals are both transacting using exchange accounts.
- 9:16So if you're holding your Bitcoin on an exchange and I'm holding my Bitcoin on an exchange and I pay you from my exchange account to your exchange account, that's totally fine.
- 9:24Because we are transacting between two regulated financial institutions.
- 9:27But a peer-to-peer transaction on a wallet like Blink or Zeus or whatever, anything that's KYC free, once it's above that threshold, it's effectively illegal.
- 9:37And obviously, again, it depends on what that threshold is.
- 9:40I think this is my biggest gripe with this whole thing.
- 9:44If that threshold is low enough, it could completely kill circular economies.
- 9:49Well, I mean, no, sorry.
- 9:51If that threshold is low enough, it could make circular economies effectively illegal unless the entire circular economy runs on a regulated exchange.
- 10:00Right.
- 10:00Which sucks.
- 10:03That's a kind way to put it.
- 10:04It's terrible.
- 10:06It's similar.
- 10:07It seems like on a certain level it's meant, well, it's similar.
- 10:11it's seeing, well, not exactly. I was going to say it's similar to Executive Order 6102 in the
- 10:15United States, which was when FDR president many decades ago confiscated gold. It's not exactly
- 10:23that because as you're saying, you could still translate, you could still transact through
- 10:26exchanges. But this obviously defeats the P2P nature of Bitcoin, the idea that it was meant
- 10:30to be transmitted without an intermediary. This would force those intermediaries into the equation.
- 10:35why do you think this is happening now is there something well let's actually let me rewind a
- 10:41little bit so the party that's in power right now in south africa is the anc and this was the party
- 10:47of mandela and mandela has been on the record twice he's addressed the country or he addressed
- 10:53the country twice while he was alive to say that he didn't believe in controls like this in certain
- 10:58capital controls like this so the party of mandela is doing this thing that mandela himself said
- 11:04shouldn't be done what is why do you think the ANC is doing this right now do they feel are they
- 11:10worried about the value of the South African Rand are they worried about their own political power
- 11:16maybe a combination of both what do you feel the impetus for this was um
- 11:23yeah I mean first of all so so that it is actually quite similar to the
- 11:31to the confiscation um uh um executive order executive order um that that was uh issued in
- 11:401933 because part of these draft regulations actually do say that the state can force you
- 11:46to sell your holdings your assets to the state um and so you know people i've had a few conversations
- 11:58which is very, it's been very revealing,
- 12:01these conversations I've had with so-called normal people about this.
- 12:06Because people are like, kind of like, yeah, that sucks.
- 12:11But I mean, it's not that bad because they're giving you the same value.
- 12:14And I'm like, no, no, wait, you don't understand.
- 12:17You don't understand.
- 12:18If the South African rand goes into a Zimbabwe territory,
- 12:24then me selling you my Bitcoin for X number of rands today,
- 12:28is totally worthless tomorrow
- 12:33because the number of rands you're giving me today
- 12:35means nothing tomorrow.
- 12:37This is what we saw happen in Zimbabwe.
- 12:39You know, one day you could buy, you know,
- 12:42a loaf of bread with X number of Zim dollars
- 12:46and the next day those same number of Zim dollars
- 12:49would be absolutely worthless.
- 12:50So once you're in a high inflation
- 12:51or a hyperinflationary situation,
- 12:54that essentially becomes confiscation.
- 12:58as I understand it. So it is actually pretty bad because we've been fortunate in South Africa that
- 13:06the decline of the rand has been relatively slow. It's lost a lot of its value against the dollar
- 13:13over many years, but it's been relatively slow. Anyway, the other thing you mentioned, why now?
- 13:19Well, look, the ANC does not have outright power anymore. They were forced into a coalition
- 13:23government with the last election. And so, yes, the party of Mandela had outright majority power
- 13:30from 1994 until 2024. So essentially 30 years, they ruled the country without much resistance
- 13:41because they had an outright majority. They always won more than 50 percent, way more than 50 percent.
- 13:48I mean, at one point, they were close to 70% of the vote.
- 13:52I think in the early 2000s, at one point, they had close to 70% of the vote.
- 13:57But they've been declining.
- 13:59And so they dropped below 50% and, in fact, came very close to 40% in the latest election.
- 14:05So it's a pretty bad collapse they've had.
- 14:08And this is interesting because it speaks to your question as to why now.
- 14:13This is not the first very unpopular thing that the ANC majority...
- 14:18because it is still an ANC majority government.
- 14:20It is a coalition government,
- 14:22but the ANC is by far the largest partner in that coalition.
- 14:27Locally, it's referred to as the Government of National Unity, the GNU.
- 14:31The ANC is the largest partner in that.
- 14:34And it's an interesting question.
- 14:35Why now?
- 14:36Because it's not the first thing.
- 14:37The ANC has done several things over the last two years
- 14:40that have demonstrably contributed to their decline.
- 14:44They've signed several laws that it can be demonstrated
- 14:48it actually made them less popular. And I think this is similar. It's going to make them less
- 14:54popular. So why do this now? I don't know the answer to that question, but it's not different
- 15:00from the other things they've done. They've signed other laws, which also, you know, at the moment,
- 15:07there is a law on the books, which is being challenged in court. So it hasn't really been
- 15:12implemented yet but it on the books It been signed into law In fact it was signed into law just before the previous election And it estimated the ANC lost about 5 of the national vote because of this law And this law effectively nationalizes the private healthcare industry if it comes into effect
- 15:30It's been signed into law. The president signed it into law, but it's being challenged in the
- 15:34courts. So it's not been put into practice yet. And nobody wants that. So why is the ANC
- 15:41enacting these communist policies that is very clearly costing them votes.
- 15:46I don't know. I guess my best guess is that they're so they're so they're so intimately
- 15:53intertwined with their communist ideology that they'll try and execute it even if it
- 16:00even if it means that they that they lose votes. They're essentially one can put it this way. The
- 16:08Communist mind virus is so strong that the virus is destroying the host.
- 16:13That's my best guess.
- 16:15No, it's similar to like, I think it's, it sounds similar, not exactly the same, but similar to what happened in Venezuela, where you basically just have blind ideas, just people who are blindly ideological, who just believe that we're going forward with this thing no matter what, because this is the mission and we don't care, blah, blah, blah, not paying attention to reality, almost thinking within a vacuum or something like that.
- 16:37And just pushing forward no matter what. Maybe they think if they push hard enough on the other side of this thing, the communist utopia they have in their mind will become a reality.
- 16:45But we know that it's only likely going to get worse. History tells us it's only likely to get worse.
- 16:50And I don't even necessarily love using these words, communists, but I think that that's what's I think that's what's in that ideology is what's informing them, because it's it seems like you'd have to be blindly ideologically driven to continue pushing forward things that people don't want, especially in a system where you're democratically elected.
- 17:11So it seems, yeah, it seems like you're just sort of dealing with, I don't know whether it's a human psychology thing where this is what they've always said. So now to save face, they're just going to push forward with it no matter what. They're just not going to factor in reality and how people are reacting to what they're doing and just continue to kind of march forward. But it's really, I guess, scary.
- 17:33So broader context is wanting more control over everything in the country.
- 17:38So this side of this kind of money thing fits into a broader push for more control over the entire situation.
- 17:46There's also, sorry, just want to say there's also the consideration that one has to take into account that the ANC government,
- 17:57look they they have been enacting communist like policies redistribute redistributive policies
- 18:06that you it's you can demonstrate within very recent history in the present moment not even
- 18:12in history in the present moment you can demonstrate that these redistributive policies
- 18:16don't work um what what what we locally refer to as bbbee which stands for broad-based black
- 18:24economic empowerment doesn't work.
- 18:28The idea is nice.
- 18:30The idea being that you have this disenfranchised majority, you know, the non-white majority
- 18:38in South Africa that was disenfranchised during apartheid, obviously.
- 18:43And now you want to do something about it.
- 18:45It sounds fantastic.
- 18:46I mean, I've dedicated half my life to try and do something about that, but I don't do
- 18:51it in a way that's redistributive.
- 18:52the the redistributive efforts have created a a a black elite or a non-white elite and have
- 19:04essentially enriched about a hundred people to an insane level our president being one of them
- 19:10but none of that wealth has has gone to the rest of the country um the disenfranchised part of the
- 19:18I'm not even talking about the white part of the country.
- 19:21Let's ignore the white part of the country.
- 19:22Let's look at the disenfranchised part of the country,
- 19:26that part of the non-white country that was disempowered
- 19:29and disenfranchised during apartheid.
- 19:32About 100 to 150 individuals out of 30, 40 million
- 19:37have become incredibly wealthy,
- 19:39and the rest of them are worse off in some ways
- 19:43than they were before.
- 19:44that's what that's what the redistributive policies of the of the anc majority government
- 19:50has done um and yet they continue on this path and so to your question is it psychological i have
- 19:56no idea but one thing that one has to consider is it might it might not be ideological it might
- 20:04also just be very practical because the government is running out of money and that's yeah they've
- 20:11they've reached the point where they, you know, we, we had a, we're, we're, we're, we're at that
- 20:18point on the, on the so-called Luffer curve, where if they, if they increase taxes any further,
- 20:22they're going to, they're going to collect less tax revenue because taxes in South Africa are
- 20:27already so high. I mean, our tax rate is comparable to the UK, except, except that if you're, if you're
- 20:34living in the UK, you get lots of stuff in return. In South Africa, you get almost nothing in return
- 20:40because all of that tax money is going either towards corrupt individuals
- 20:46or it's being used to fund a huge portion of the population that are unemployed.
- 20:53I mean, unemployment is above 30%.
- 20:56Some estimates are higher.
- 21:00But anyway, so it could be very practical.
- 21:03This could be a part of a larger effort to try and raise.
- 21:06I mean, they're effectively saying, listen, we'll give you our shitty currency in exchange for your high value assets.
- 21:14So, you know, it's a pretty good fundraising mechanism if they can pull it off.
- 21:18Yeah, 100%.
- 21:20Also, to rewind quickly to a point you made about the Zimbabwean dollar devaluing the way that it did,
- 21:26I think something that most people don't know about Executive Order 6102 in the United States is that the price of,
- 21:32I mean, the dollar essentially got cut in half in value right after gold was I'm sorry, gold, gold doubled in value right after it was confiscated from people in America.
- 21:42So this isn't just sort of a situation in Zimbabwe or something.
- 21:44We've seen time and time again, governments from here in the United States to governments in Africa take assets from people.
- 21:52And then essentially those assets increase in value exponentially while the dollars or the fiat currency that the citizens are holding, basically their value gets cut in half or worse in most cases.
- 22:01So it's a really, really dire situation that I think most people, as you said, the normies, most people, we know this from being in Bitcoin world and trying to explain how money works to people.
- 22:13Most people don't really get how money works.
- 22:15They think about money nominally.
- 22:17They don't really understand why inflation is what it is.
- 22:19We have politicians like Elizabeth Warren telling them it's the greed of corporations that's causing inflation versus the fact that, I don't know, the United States goes $100,000 more into debt every one second.
- 22:30And so there's a lot of different dimensions to this that I think are very difficult to understand.
- 22:36And there's cognitive dissonance.
- 22:38People struggle to understand these things.
- 22:40They don't want to believe they're real, all of these things.
- 22:42My other question to you, though, in regard to the government reacting to, let's just say, Bitcoin specifically for the sake of the argument I'm about to make or lay out.
- 22:51South Africa, I felt like it was really on the verge of becoming the next kind of quote unquote Bitcoin country.
- 22:58You have the work that Money Badger is doing, making it easy to pay from your Lightning wallet and have that payment settle over fiat rails.
- 23:07You have the work that KG and the Machankora team are doing.
- 23:10You have multiple circular economies, not just Bitcoin Akazi, Bitcoin Loxion, Bitcoin Witsand, a number of other circular economies.
- 23:17There was so much momentum around Bitcoin within the country, and it really felt great, at least from an outsider, but also someone that came to visit the country.
- 23:25I guess it's a little over a year ago now, January 2025.
- 23:29Do you think that they were noticing that momentum and wanted to slow it down?
- 23:33Like, hey, if we don't do something now to sort of stop this, this thing could become much bigger and we don't have control over it, etc.
- 23:40So were they reacting to, I don't know, what it is that I was seeing?
- 23:45Again, maybe that's biased because I'm a Bitcoiner, but were they reacting to that dynamic that was playing out?
- 23:50i mean the you know the i think the i think the best person to answer that question would actually
- 24:00be somebody from from money badger um you know cardle as i understand it have uh not only cardle
- 24:08but but um amongst other people cardle have have had meetings with the reserve bank um and with the
- 24:18the the higher up officials where you know and i don't want to single him out maybe he doesn't
- 24:23want me to say this so but but the point is that in in meetings behind closed doors and also in
- 24:30policy papers that in in in in papers that that guide policy guidance papers whatever you call
- 24:36them um they've laid out that this is this is where they want to go so it's not something that
- 24:44happened overnight um you know i i remember at the africa bitcoin conference i think it was in kenya
- 24:52uh so that would have been the one before the most recent one just december 2024 yeah yeah it
- 24:59was either 24 or what 23 was also in ghana right it might have been right it might have been in 2023
- 25:06there was
- 25:09I commented on
- 25:12because there were several people there
- 25:14who had very positive reactions
- 25:16to some of the regulations coming out of South Africa
- 25:19and I commented and I was like
- 25:20hey look if you dig deeper into these regulations
- 25:23they're actually telling you
- 25:24that we're on a collision course here
- 25:26we just haven't formulated exactly how we're going to do this
- 25:29but it was pretty clear to me
- 25:30that the South African government
- 25:31is not very welcoming of this
- 25:33the people on the ground are very welcoming
- 25:35the reality on the ground is very fertile for the kind of adoption that we've seen.
- 25:41But the government has not been very receptive in how they frame their approach.
- 25:51So it's not entirely unexpected.
- 25:53I think what was unexpected is how vague the draft regulations are.
- 25:59Again, I mean, I've said that before, but that was very surprising
- 26:02because that's a huge red flag.
- 26:05If a government agency with a lot of power and the South African Reserve Bank and the Treasury is probably the most powerful institutions in the country, if an institution with that much power comes out with the regulations that are so vague and can be interpreted in such a wide, then that's a big red flag.
- 26:25Because you have to assume that powerful people are going to abuse their power at some point.
- 26:29and then the other thing that we haven't mentioned
- 26:33is that the deadline for public comment
- 26:35is incredibly short
- 26:38so we've got a couple of days left
- 26:41and it's only been a couple of days
- 26:43since they published the draft regulations
- 26:45normally you'd have six months or so
- 26:48for public comment
- 26:49in this case they gave us less than a month
- 26:51for public comment
- 26:52so that was surprising
- 26:54but the essence of the draft regulations
- 26:57was not surprising
- 26:58The government in South Africa has not been very welcoming.
- 27:01And there's a disconnect between people on the ground and the government.
- 27:06And there has been for more than a decade and a half, I'd say.
- 27:11Following the first democratic elections, the first two presidents, I think, had a very positive trajectory for the country.
- 27:21I mean, basically just looking at economic growth.
- 27:24but then since then
- 27:26since the
- 27:27pre-World Cup
- 27:29high
- 27:31things have been on a
- 27:33and I'm referring to the football
- 27:35World Cup in 2010
- 27:36since then things have been on a
- 27:38slowly accelerating downward
- 27:40trajectory
- 27:41and so it's not entirely
- 27:44surprising
- 27:45I
- 27:47yeah I just
- 27:50kind of wish I knew how this ends though
- 27:52we are getting closer to that as you just sort of alluded to it so there's i have a question about
- 27:59this public comment uh there's i believe there were two dates listed that public that they're
- 28:04going to be accepting public comment till may 18th or june 10th please correct me if i'm wrong
- 28:08on each of those dates but why two dates um you know yeah you you mentioned to me in a dm you know
- 28:17but that you're not exactly sure.
- 28:19So does this, do you think that the window will remain open
- 28:23until early to mid-June,
- 28:25or do you think May 18th is going to be the hard deadline?
- 28:29I honestly don't know.
- 28:31I honestly don't know.
- 28:33I'm assuming that May 18th will be the deadline for public comment.
- 28:38I'm also assuming that the two dates was just pure incompetence.
- 28:42the level of incompetence is just
- 28:46indescribable. I mean, there are
- 28:50very, very simple administrative processes that I've been involved
- 28:54in personally that
- 28:57it's taken, for example,
- 29:02it's taken us more than two years to try and get a
- 29:06verification letter from the Department of Home Affairs that my wife
- 29:10is a permanent resident.
- 29:12We've tried legal firms
- 29:14and it's just a fucking verification letter.
- 29:17I mean, the level of incompetence is just,
- 29:21yeah, it's just, it's, I don't know,
- 29:24especially at a national level.
- 29:26At a local government level,
- 29:28things are very different,
- 29:30especially the part of the country where we live.
- 29:32At a local government level,
- 29:33things are very efficient,
- 29:35but it's run by a totally different,
- 29:37it's run by people
- 29:38with a totally different mindset.
- 29:40um so i don't know i'm guessing that confusion is incompetence i don't think there's any malice
- 29:45behind the two date confusion or the spelling mistake in the email address where we're supposed
- 29:50to submit public comments or i don't know i'm so i'm gonna i want to clarify for the listeners so
- 29:57they actually for the email you were supposed to send your public comments to
- 30:01they posted the wrong address they were off by a character or a letter or something i think you
- 30:06mentioned something like that yeah yeah you don't think that that was done on purpose to maybe have
- 30:11it because obviously less public comments are going to reach them if they're sending it to an
- 30:15email address that either doesn't exist or the wrong email address i i can understand from an
- 30:19outsider from an outside perspective it looks like that was done on purpose but having dealt with this
- 30:26government and i mean so just just one other example i mean i like so i submit i submit legal paperwork for our charity organization that behind Bitcoin and Kase every year And every year it the same story Every year I submit all the documents and every year they get
- 30:44back to me with a letter saying, oh, this is missing, that's missing, that's missing. I know
- 30:49for a fact it's not missing. I submit the same documents again. They send a letter back, an email,
- 30:55this is missing, that missing, that missing. And it's been going on for year after year after year
- 31:02and eventually after four or five attempts,
- 31:04they say, okay, we've got all your documents.
- 31:06I know for a fact all the documents
- 31:08were submitted every single time.
- 31:10And I spoke to a lawyer recently
- 31:12who explained to me that they've encountered this before
- 31:16and what's probably happening in the background
- 31:18is the person who receives these documents
- 31:20is so lazy to work or so incompetent.
- 31:23The easiest thing to do is just to respond
- 31:25and say the documents are missing
- 31:27because that forces you to then resubmit
- 31:29and resubmit and resubmit.
- 31:31that's that's the level of incompetence and so having dealt with that i i don't think there's
- 31:36any malice in those mistakes i literally think it's just pure plain and simple incompetence i
- 31:42think i don't think there needs to be any malice in that because i think i think they're trying to
- 31:47achieve what they want to achieve with the regulations themselves um it's very it's very
- 31:52clear i think i mean lots of people have come out and have said no there's you know you shouldn't be
- 31:56so pessimistic you should give them the benefit of the doubt that i'm like look look at look at
- 32:02the last 30 years there why on earth would you want to give them the benefit the benefit of the
- 32:07doubt um you know look at all the corruption look at all the incompetence just two days ago there
- 32:12was another massive corruption scandal uncovered with government officials selling fake passports
- 32:18and fake visas to make make money um so why on earth would you give them the benefit of the doubt
- 32:24I think they're trying to accomplish what they want to accomplish through the regulations themselves.
- 32:28I think these little mistakes here and there is just peer incompetence.
- 32:31But that's just my feeling.
- 32:33I could be wrong about that, obviously.
- 32:36Absolutely, Wild.
- 32:38I appreciate sharing all this context and your experience with it.
- 32:41It's really helpful.
- 32:42It's very sad and very disheartening, but helpful, I think, for those who are trying to understand better what's going on.
- 32:48Sorry to interrupt you.
- 32:49I just want to interrupt you there.
- 32:51I, yes, it is sad, but at the same time, I am still optimistic because I think if you look at this in the broader context, like, you know, I'm not a huge fan of democracy.
- 33:02It's got its flaws.
- 33:03But I think what's happening in South Africa is democracy actually working because, and this is kind of miraculous if you think about it.
- 33:12There should have been a populist revolt in South Africa by now.
- 33:15If you look at the number of people who live in abject poverty, there should have been.
- 33:21But somehow people have kept, you know, voter turnout is not particularly high, but somehow
- 33:27democracy is kind of working.
- 33:28And I think what's busy happening is the ANC is getting voted out of power.
- 33:31They've lost, you know, they went from almost 60 percent five years ago to just over 40
- 33:39percent in this most recent election.
- 33:41And I think there's a very real chance that the ANC can be voted entirely out of government
- 33:47by the next election.
- 33:48I'm not saying it's going to happen.
- 33:49And I'm saying there's a real chance if you follow the trajectory or that they become a minority partner in the coalition government with the next election.
- 33:59And that is actually democracy working if you think about it.
- 34:02And if you think about it, if I think about it, I'm actually kind of hopeful because and this is what I've said this on other occasions as well.
- 34:10when you look at other things happening, not these draft regulations, but other similar things that
- 34:15this government is trying to push through, is that when South Africa went into its first democratic
- 34:21phase in 1994 with the first democratic election, that was not the transition to democracy. That was
- 34:27the first step towards the transition to democracy. But what happened then was a liberation movement
- 34:32called the ANC was then expected to turn themselves into a governing political party,
- 34:39which is that it's just that's unrealistic you know one day they're fighting a revolution
- 34:45with the military wing and everything the next day you expect them to become bureaucrats and
- 34:50it's like no that's not going to happen and so what happened in the last 30 years is kind of
- 34:55expected cronyism corruption and so on and so forth and if and when the ANC loses power
- 35:03and they let go of power without too much violence,
- 35:07then that would be the next step towards democracy.
- 35:11And these steps take decades, not years.
- 35:15So if the ANC loses its majority in 2029,
- 35:19which is when the next election is,
- 35:21and they become a minority partner in the government,
- 35:24and then finally they become an insignificant political party,
- 35:29and there's precedence for this
- 35:30because the nationalist party that ruled during apartheid,
- 35:34that party doesn't exist anymore.
- 35:36They contested one or two elections after apartheid
- 35:39and then they disbanded because they became irrelevant.
- 35:41I think the ANC is going to become irrelevant too.
- 35:44And I think that's the slow process of democracy in action.
- 35:47And I think that's how, probably realistically,
- 35:50that's how these types of regulations are resisted
- 35:53by the party whose ideology informs this nonsense
- 35:57just actually becoming irrelevant.
- 35:58Appreciate that perspective, too. Yeah, I'm happy to hear you're optimistic. Makes me feel a little bit better looking in, I guess. And I also feel that the number of South African Bitcoiners who have either reacted to what I've posted about this or have DM me or emailed me saying we're pushing back, you're seeing people say no. And that's, again, that's ideally what democracy should look like.
- 36:22So I think it's inspiring. It's part of the reason I wanted to have this conversation, because I think a lot of people will get behind it and share it because they probably share your same feelings. But I think it really is important that people do something. Now, aside from public comment, which is likely due by May 18th, what else can South African Bitcoiners do right now? And then maybe what else can Bitcoiners around the world do to support what's happening with South African Bitcoiners?
- 36:47um i think the most important thing that um that can be done is just to kind of i mean there's
- 36:55there's a there's a movement of local bitcoiners that um have formed um it's a loose it's a loose
- 37:02association it's no there's no formal entity behind it but it's a it's a loose association
- 37:07of people who have just said look we're going to do what we can to resist this um and uh to get
- 37:13involved with that. I'm constantly retweeting stuff from their profile. They've got an ex-profile.
- 37:19I think it's at, I just got to double check the ad. Is this the property rights defense group?
- 37:27Is that who you're speaking about? Yeah, the property rights defense group.
- 37:31Let's make sure, let's mention it now, but I'll also put this in the show notes.
- 37:36I'm just looking at my phone, pardon me for a second, but yeah, I've been in touch with somebody
- 37:40who's been working on that and I've seen them tweeting,
- 37:42but let's just mention that quickly.
- 37:46Yeah, it's at PRDG underscore ZA.
- 37:51At PRDG underscore ZA.
- 37:55That's it?
- 37:55Yeah.
- 37:56I don't say Z as fancy as you say Z,
- 38:00so I appreciate that.
- 38:03So definitely check out what they're doing.
- 38:05I've had some people from this organization reach out to me.
- 38:07It seems like they're starting to gain a little bit of momentum. And that's something that I think all anyone around the world can retweet what they're doing and obviously share what the likes of Herman is sharing from the, you know, or the Bitcoin Akazi handle, Luthandon Abambi, the community lead at Bitcoin Akazi, who's done such incredible work in developing, bringing merchants on board in the community and educating people in the community.
- 38:31You know, I think he had a really good tweet about this, and I hesitate to talk about this, especially as a white guy.
- 38:36But, you know, he said like, you know, the Fondo, I think, is this amazing example who was obviously very much a victim of apartheid, a black South African whose life has been greatly changed as a result of Bitcoin.
- 38:47His physical living conditions have been better.
- 38:50His lot in life, his job, all of these things have improved as a result of Bitcoin.
- 38:53One of my first thoughts, and I try to believe we can sort of speak to people's hearts and get them to realize the good things that Bitcoin can catalyze.
- 39:05If you think someone in the ANC or maybe the ANC more broadly, if we were to speak about them as an entity, were to hear about a story like the Fondo or the many people in Bitcoin Okazi whose lives have been bettered as a result of Bitcoin, do you think that they would potentially change their mind about this?
- 39:19Or is that just literally very, okay, why do you say that?
- 39:22I think a combination of two things.
- 39:28I think the desperation and the ideology.
- 39:34They would listen to Lutando's story and they would actually just become more determined to exercise their democratic revolution.
- 39:42I mean, that's the irony of this, right?
- 39:44The ANC has this thing.
- 39:46Somebody described this very well once.
- 39:48And they've said South Africa was this miraculous story after 1994.
- 39:51And since 1994, the ANC has had two broadcast channels.
- 39:55The way they talk to the rest of the world and the way they talk to local South Africans
- 39:58are two entirely different conversations.
- 40:00And it's difficult to believe that in 2026, the ANC still has something that they call
- 40:06the National Democratic Revolution, which, according to them, has not been fully completed
- 40:10yet, because the National Democratic Revolution is, in fact, a complete communist transformation
- 40:15of the country.
- 40:16It's insane.
- 40:17like the level of uh you know the the level of insanity this and and this is what they literally
- 40:23tell local south africans and so they would listen to lutando's story and they'll say yeah
- 40:27that's very nice but uh you know we have this national democratic revolution and we haven't
- 40:32carried that out yet because we don't own everything that the whites used to own before
- 40:37that's essentially what it comes down to do so i i know this sounds weird to say and everybody
- 40:44please whatever don't aim your bows and arrows at me but for saying this i guess on a certain level
- 40:49if you're raised in a situation like apartheid south africa and and and so this is before maybe
- 40:55something like bitcoin existed if you were more to the left on things so for example there's a
- 41:00person coming to mind as you're speaking i used to live next door in namibia i lived there for a
- 41:04short period of time and i lived with um a woman there um black namibian woman who uh i was not
- 41:13living with her like in a romantic relationship i just she gave me a place to live it was uh i had
- 41:18gone there to work with a friend of a friend of hers and um you know i think she was very much
- 41:23raised with this idea that cuba was an ally to you know while the united states was very much
- 41:30okay with apartheid and the united states representing free markets capitalism all that
- 41:34stuff cuba wasn't right rush you know there were there were these communist nations that were very
- 41:39much like, no, we want to see black South Africans be free and all of this stuff. So there's a sort of
- 41:45thing that's built in there, right? There's this almost emotional thing you wouldn't want to let
- 41:49go of. And also, I think Bitcoin is still a relatively new technology. The other problem
- 41:55with Bitcoin, something else that came to mind as I'm thinking about all this, is when I spoke with
- 41:59people on the ground in Nepal after the recent revolution in the country, what I heard from
- 42:04someone or from one person in particular who sort of spoke on behalf of many people on the ground
- 42:08is that a lot of the activists who were out protesting
- 42:11were more politically to the left.
- 42:13So when I asked if they were using something like Bitcoin
- 42:15and not the traditional structures,
- 42:17he was like, no, they don't touch that stuff
- 42:18because they just look at it as an extension of capitalism.
- 42:21And so obviously we know Bitcoin is much more than something like that.
- 42:24And I think that's a very reductive way to look at it
- 42:29because it does much more for human beings than that.
- 42:32But I think all of this psychology and that emotion
- 42:36is sort of baked into the picture.
- 42:39And so I'm not saying it's right.
- 42:41I'm surely not saying it's right.
- 42:42But similar to like in Venezuela,
- 42:44when Chavez came to power,
- 42:46Chavez was the first darker skinned
- 42:49Venezuelan president,
- 42:50I think in the modern,
- 42:51I think in the history of the country
- 42:52or the modern history.
- 42:53So people were like,
- 42:54I don't, I almost don't care
- 42:56what this guy's about.
- 42:57Like that guy looks more like me.
- 42:59So I'm going to be behind him.
- 43:00And I know what played out in Venezuela
- 43:02and it was very sad
- 43:03and all that kind of stuff.
- 43:04But it's, but there's something there.
- 43:06So do you think there are some of these dynamics at play of like people came up in a world where this thing that they ideologically blindly believe in was the answer, quote unquote.
- 43:16So they're struggling to let go of that being the answer.
- 43:20Yeah, 100 percent.
- 43:21I mean, all the all the ANC revolutionaries were trained in communist countries.
- 43:28um it uh it was a bizarre experience uh in 2000 and i think it was this is in 2011 or 2012 just
- 43:36after my wife and i married uh we went to a a restaurant in um in cape town and we sat down
- 43:45we had a meal i think it was ethiopian restaurant but it was run by by by locals and my wife made
- 43:54a comment. I don't know what she was. She made a comment in Russian. I don't know if she was on
- 43:59the phone. I can't remember. And this pitch black dude turned around and started speaking to an
- 44:05fluent Russian because he'd spent several years training in a military training camp in communist
- 44:13Russia. And so there's a very, very, very deep ideological connection there. And I think a lot
- 44:20of people don't understand that. And the other thing that's worth saying is that, you know,
- 44:27and this is something that a lot of people struggle with. And I think if people could get
- 44:31their head around this, the world would be a much better place. But understanding something does not
- 44:37mean that you say it's right or that you say it should be that way or that you say you condone it,
- 44:46you support it that that none of that none of that is implied by understanding something
- 44:53i can totally understand where this mindset of the anc is coming from i mean put yourself in
- 44:59the shoes of somebody who grows up under apartheid where everything is taken away from them
- 45:05um because of the color of their skin and now and now that person is raising their children
- 45:12what do you think they're going to teach their children right i can totally understand where
- 45:16this mentality is coming from. I completely understand it. I just also understand that the
- 45:21way in which they're trying to address the problem happens to be ineffective and in fact
- 45:27counterproductive. So yeah, I totally get it. And this is why I say it's a miracle that there
- 45:35has not yet been a populist revolution in South Africa. Because if you look at the history,
- 45:38and if especially the last 30 years um where conditions have not improved what should have
- 45:46happened is parties like the EFF that literally want to chase white people into the ocean
- 45:53and I mean that that the party who sings songs about killing people and shooting them and blah blah blah It kind of miraculous in a very positive way that that party has not gotten a larger percentage of the votes
- 46:12It's a small miracle that there are radical policies because the ANC is one thing,
- 46:19but the redistributive policies of the EFF is on a whole other level.
- 46:23um you know so it's it's it's a it's a it's a radicalized version of of uh redistributive
- 46:32communism um as extreme as you can get so it's it's a small miracle that they're not more popular
- 46:38and that there hasn't been a populist uh populist revolt or uprising very very interesting um you
- 46:46know it's a excuse me it's it's such a difficult situation because i think of that dynamic that
- 46:55you just touched on there it's like it's almost that it's it's beyond the blind it is a blind
- 47:01ideology but it's like it's this emotional sort of wall of like well i'm not going to believe in
- 47:06anything but this because of my experience with it growing up and i i i know this people are
- 47:12probably going to get mad at me for saying this but i but i sympathize with that i get it i just
- 47:15wish people could maybe see what's happening in Bitcoin Okazi and other parts of South Africa as
- 47:22another way. But that's a very difficult wall to break through. Also, the other issue is that once
- 47:28a certain level of corruption starts to happen at the government level, then it becomes sort of,
- 47:35I think officials start thinking, well, what if I'm taken out of power? Will that be tried for
- 47:39some of this corruption? Will other things happen? So there's a whole different layer there of like,
- 47:43well, we need to maintain power because what will happen if we're not in power anymore?
- 47:47Obviously, you won't get the sort of deal flow, so to speak, that you're getting as a high-ranking bureaucrat or a politician within the country.
- 47:55So there's a lot of different factors there that I think affect this.
- 47:58And as much as I think, like, maybe we can appeal to people's better angels,
- 48:02I don't think that that's really going to be the thing that changes things here.
- 48:06Ideally, we see something happen with the Property Rights Defense Group, with South Africans commenting before May 18th.
- 48:11And as you said, some sort of resurgence of something that at least is a semblance of democracy, of actually people raising their voices, saying, you know, this is what's going to happen.
- 48:21And on a final note on this topic, I do see a lot of people seemingly having this desire to stay and fight versus posting on X.
- 48:30Hey, I'm leaving. I'm gone. South Africa. See you. Goodbye. Is that just what I'm seeing on social media?
- 48:36or are people having that conversation as well?
- 48:38Like, are people ready to pack their bags
- 48:39and leave the country
- 48:40because of even the threat
- 48:42of what they're seeing right now?
- 48:44I mean, my wife is not even South African.
- 48:47She moved here in 2010
- 48:49and she told me two nights ago,
- 48:53look, I don't want to go anywhere else.
- 48:55Like, where would you go?
- 48:56I mean, where in the world?
- 48:58Dubai?
- 49:00You know, where would you go?
- 49:03I think the people that are going to leave have left.
- 49:06And I don't blame them.
- 49:08Again, it's one of those things where I don't agree with it, but I understand it.
- 49:13I completely understand it.
- 49:16And like you, I sympathize with people's position.
- 49:21I almost sympathize with what the ANC is trying to do because I can understand.
- 49:26If I was in their position, what would I do?
- 49:29I mean, I'm not a, you know, it's a, it's a very, it's very easy to climb on a, on a, on a, on a, on a tower and judge other people and say, yeah, this is, this is wrong.
- 49:39This is that, but there's like, yeah, I, you know, put yourself in their shoes.
- 49:43So, yeah, I think, I think the people that have left, the people that would have, that, that were going to leave have probably left.
- 49:50I think most people, I've not heard people say they want to leave.
- 49:53I don't want to leave.
- 49:54um that depends on how bad things really become but i don't think it's i don't think it's that
- 49:59much worse than what's happening in many other parts of the world um if i look at if i look at
- 50:04the shit that politicians are getting up to in in other parts of the world you know i i don't i
- 50:10don't necessarily feel that you know there's you know maybe you know maybe bhutan or nepal or i
- 50:18don't know but none of none of the big you know attractive countries and and and the countries
- 50:25that seem to be rising powers like uh china like russia are also not places i want to go to
- 50:31you know i don't that those those seem to seem to seem to be the power centers that are on a
- 50:39upward positive trajectory but i don't want to live there you know south africa might be on a
- 50:44downward trajectory, but I still have relative freedom there. So I don't feel much different here,
- 50:52to put it mildly. And I feel like you didn't mention the United States there, but we have
- 50:55plenty of our own issues and corruption that we're dealing with here, obviously. And I think
- 51:00the whole world is taking note of that. And so I think what this is actually in my mind,
- 51:04the situation this is creating in my mind is, you know, I even I'm looking out my window here in New
- 51:09York. And we have our communist leader here in New York now is Oran Mamdani and stuff. And I'm at a
- 51:16point where I'm like, I'm not leaving either. I'm going to stay and fight too. And I think this is
- 51:21actually a really, really special thing about a lot of Bitcoin enthusiasts, Bitcoiners, et cetera,
- 51:26is that there is a certain level of like, okay, well, we have this tool now. We have this thing
- 51:31we believe in. It empowers us on a certain level where we're quote unquote kind of outside the
- 51:37system in a certain regard having this tool. We're not entirely outside the system because we're still
- 51:41human beings that exist within social structures and government structures. But I do think that it
- 51:47is having an empowering effect on people who are just saying, no, I'm not going to run. I'm going
- 51:51to stay here and I'm just going to fight it out. I had this conversation with a few people in Vegas
- 51:55coming from different parts of the world. I said Bitcoin 2026. Now, I know that's a strange thing
- 52:01to say because there was a lot of also just like finance bros there, but there were some real
- 52:04Bitcoiners there who were talking about real stuff. And it does have me inspired that I think
- 52:09a lot of people want to stay, fight, change, do things locally and make changes in their communities.
- 52:14So my heart is with you guys. I think it's inspiring. I think you're inspiring the world,
- 52:22the South African Bitcoiners. If people weren't aware that there's the pushback that is happening
- 52:28there, I hope that this podcast has made you aware of that. And I hope you're looking at this,
- 52:33especially as a Bitcoiner, as a bit of potentially a canary in the coal mine moment,
- 52:39where I don't think this sort of effort ends in South Africa.
- 52:43I think we probably see something like this play out all over the world eventually.
- 52:47So at the very least, learn from what's happening.
- 52:50And then if you can, on whatever way is possible,
- 52:53share whatever's coming out of the Bitcoin Akazi handle,
- 52:56Lutando Nbambi, his handle, a bunch of other people from South Africa.
- 52:59share what they're doing because it's the time to stand with the South African Bitcoiners and all
- 53:05that they've built because the Bitcoin adoption, the movement in South Africa has been amazing.
- 53:11If you haven't seen it for yourself or you're unaware of it, I mean, there's so much positive
- 53:14stuff happening there. And like you, Herman, I mean, maybe a little bit more after speaking with
- 53:19you. I am an optimist now as well. I think people will push back. And I think ideally,
- 53:24this passes.
- 53:27Well, this passes
- 53:28and you guys can continue
- 53:31with the important
- 53:32yet challenging work
- 53:34that you do on a day-in,
- 53:35day-out basis
- 53:36in Bitcoin Okazi
- 53:36and with the communities
- 53:38with whom you work.
- 53:39On that note,
- 53:40sorry about the little rant there.
- 53:41I was just feeling inspired
- 53:42by what you've shared.
- 53:44Anything we didn't touch on
- 53:45or maybe places
- 53:46that you want to direct people to
- 53:48before we wrap up,
- 53:49whether it's handles
- 53:50or other websites
- 53:51or places where people
- 53:52can follow what's happening?
- 53:54um no i mean i just i would i would again i would uh i would repeat the property rights
- 54:00defense group uh twitter handle um to go to um and yeah i totally agree with you i think that was
- 54:07uh that was well put you know uh we're we're trying to we're trying to stay in and and do
- 54:13something about it um and i think um i think the important i think the very important thing that
- 54:18you said at the end there was that i hope that people look at this as a canary in the coal mine
- 54:23type moment because and this is something that I think people have gotten a little speaking about
- 54:29Las Vegas I think people sometimes get a little lost in this um um in this bullishness that uh
- 54:37that comes with uh with number go up um mentality you know where you think oh god what's going to
- 54:45happen to my personal stack if the US government starts buying bitcoin oh I'm gonna be so rich I'm
- 54:50to be so it's like i don't see any large government embracing this technology for what it is
- 54:58um ultimately bitcoin takes power away from powerful individuals um controlling the money
- 55:06supply has always been a favorite control mechanism for emperors and kings and presidents
- 55:14and who have you all across history.
- 55:17So it's no different today.
- 55:20Being able to print money is something
- 55:23that puts people in great positions of power
- 55:26and taking that power away,
- 55:28it's not something that anyone is going to adopt
- 55:30in one of those positions.
- 55:33And so I've been very skeptical
- 55:34about this government adoption narrative.
- 55:39I know there are some people
- 55:40that have a different perspective on that.
- 55:42I just don't think that governments adopt Bitcoin for what it is.
- 55:45I think what governments do is they try and, and this is exactly what's happening in South
- 55:52Africa right now, the governments try and put it in a box and put it into an environment
- 56:00that they're familiar with.
- 56:02And then they're willing to accept it.
- 56:04And if you're willing to play in that sandbox with them, they'll be fine.
- 56:09But if you step outside, which is where Bitcoin really exists, Bitcoin exists outside that sandbox, then they're not fine with it.
- 56:16Then they're going to come.
- 56:17They're going to try and do something about it because ultimately people who have power typically don't let go of it voluntarily.
- 56:25And so I hope people look at what's happening here and elsewhere and develop a slightly more skeptical attitude towards it.
- 56:35And, you know, I've been talking about stable coins, for example, and the big push behind stable coins coming out of the U.S.
- 56:42And I think this is a great example of why people should have more skepticism towards that.
- 56:48Because I don't think if the South African government, which is relatively small, has this kind of reaction, what is a large government going to do?
- 56:56And how on earth do you think they're having a positive attitude?
- 56:59I mean, anything that they can't control, they're not going to be positive towards.
- 57:02And this is what the South African government is trying to do.
- 57:05It's like, well, we can't control this, so we've got to bring it in.
- 57:08And, yeah, so I think what you said there is the most important thing.
- 57:11I think the most important thing to take away from this is look at this as a canary in the coal mine type moment.
- 57:17And don't think that this is happening somewhere where you're not.
- 57:21It's probably going to happen where you are, unless you live in a tiny, insignificant country where the politicians don't have much power to begin with anyway.
- 57:29Then you're probably fine.
- 57:31But you're but or or not, because if you are in a country like that, you're probably kind of you'll be a part of a proxy fight with other major world powers.
- 57:40And whatever happens in those countries will sort of impact you. Yeah. Yeah. I think that that that is the case.
- 57:46And I think another point to, you know, one of the one of the big takeaways, I think, from Vegas was, you know, there we had the head of the DOJ speak, Todd Blanche.
- 57:54and we had the head of the FBI speak there.
- 57:57And a lot of the critique obviously was you guys didn't,
- 58:00you guys could talk all you want about America
- 58:02being the Bitcoin slash crypto capital of the world.
- 58:04But if you have two samurai devs in jail
- 58:06and you have another crypto developer, Roman Storm,
- 58:10going back, getting his case retried
- 58:12after having a hung jury on two of the three counts,
- 58:16you're not the crypto capital of the world.
- 58:18I quote this off to Peter von, yeah,
- 58:20Peter von Valkenberg of Coin Center said,
- 58:22Yeah, sure. The United States is on pace to become the crypto capital of the world as far as the securitized, regulated version of it is concerned. But as far as P2P rights concerned, no, not so much. I hope we do, but we're not on pace to do that. And I think to the point of what you said, that is it. I think the attack on Bitcoin actually looks like major institutions adopting it or governments saying we're going to hold it as a strategic reserve asset.
- 58:44it's the rhetoric around Bitcoin is a store of value and stable coins are the money you should
- 58:49be using. That's at least what the, in my opinion, that's what the attack on it looks like in the
- 58:53United States. Luckily, we have people like Jack Dorsey who are trying to have, you know, block
- 58:58anyone with a square terminal start accepting it. But that's a whole different story. We have people
- 59:02pushing back globally. But I think, yeah, just believing that Bitcoin has already won and that
- 59:09there isn't going to be these sorts of government crackdowns globally is comedy, in my opinion. I
- 59:14I don't mean to be mean or whatever, but I don't think we're in that sort of place because for Bitcoin to win, it has to exist the way that you've talked about it existing as freedom money outside the system.
- 59:26I'll leave with this.
- 59:27I saw NVK from Cold Card post something last night I thought was pretty profound.
- 59:32So, you know, the most interesting thing about or is it something maybe not the most interesting thing.
- 59:35He said, you know, the MSTRs, the micro strategies slash stretch products of the world will will collapse if Bitcoin does not succeed as freedom money, because all the people who care about it, there's a false dichotomy between store value and medium of exchange.
- 59:50It needs to be both for it to continue, for the system to work.
- 59:55And what's funny is that as you're trying to financialize it, you'll end up causing a financial crisis.
- 1:00:01Because if you have so many financial products underpinned by it and you don't allow it to be what it is, then it ultimately fails.
- 1:00:08Jeff Booth gave a good talk on this at the conference as well.
- 1:00:11So not to get too far off track here, but Armand, I appreciate the fact that I appreciate all you're doing.
- 1:00:17You know, having been there to see it myself and having covered Bitcoin Okazi as a writer, you know, it's tremendously inspiring.
- 1:00:25I appreciate the fact that you're staying to fight and that you're willing to speak up about this.
- 1:00:30And, yeah, I think that what you're doing is going to it's going to not set the pace, but set the tone for all Bitcoiners globally.
- 1:00:38Not just you, but South African Bitcoiners and generally who are pushing back.
- 1:00:41And I think we're going to end up looking to what all you guys are doing as a model.
- 1:00:45So on behalf of Bitcoiners globally, thank you.
- 1:00:47And thank you for taking the time to speak today.
- 1:00:50Cool, man.
- 1:00:50Appreciate it.
- 1:00:51Thank you for doing this.
- 1:00:52Pleasure is all mine.
- 1:00:53All right, everybody.
- 1:00:55That is it for this.
- 1:00:56We will talk soon again.
- 1:00:57Thanks to Harman.
- 1:00:58And take it easy, everybody.
- 1:01:00Thank you.
- 1:01:15you