Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Mine(d) your own oxygen
Transcript
- 0:00Now, Chelsea, I know we're used to the doom and gloom kind of fringy minis coming from me.
- 0:05I tend to think of them not as doom and gloom or pessimistic, but just information that needs to
- 0:10be conveyed, which is like the one topic I have. I think this one is less doomy and gloomy,
- 0:16but there may be an implication of doom gloom stuff in it. So let's just go into this.
- 0:21Not quite sure how to take that. Yeah, we'll see. We'll see what you think when we're done.
- 0:25Okay, so this comes from the BBC. It was published on July 22, 2024, written by Victoria Gill.
- 0:33Title, Oxygen Discovery defies knowledge of the deep ocean. What? We'll read it.
- 0:38Scientists have discovered what they call dark oxygen being produced in the deep ocean,
- 0:43apparently by lumps of metal on the sea floor. About half of the oxygen we breathe comes from
- 0:48the ocean. Before this discovery, it was understood that it was made by marine plants
- 0:52photosynthesizing, something that requires sunlight. Here at depths of five kilometers where no sunlight
- 0:58can penetrate, the oxygen appears to be produced by naturally occurring metallic nodules, which
- 1:02split seawater, H2O, into hydrogen and oxygen. Several mining companies have plans to collect
- 1:08these nodules, which marine scientists fear could disrupt the newly discovered process and damage
- 1:12any marine life that depends on the oxygen they make. I was just thinking, and it's just sitting
- 1:18there not being mined. Yeah, exactly. Those fools. Surely he can't be doing that.
- 1:28Quote, I first saw this in 2013, an enormous amount of oxygen being produced at the sea floor
- 1:32in complete darkness. I just ignored it because I'd been taught you only get oxygen through
- 1:36photosynthesis. Explains lead researcher Professor Andrew Sweetman from the Scott's Association for
- 1:42Marine Science. Eventually, I realized that for years, I had been ignoring this potentially
- 1:47huge discovery. He and his colleagues carried out their research in an area of the deep sea between
- 1:52Hawaiian Mexico, part of a vast swath of seafloor that is covered with these metal nodules. The
- 1:58nodules form when dissolved, metals in seawater collect on fragments of shell or other debris.
- 2:03It's a process that takes millions of years. And because these nodules contain metals like
- 2:08lithium, cobalt and copper, all of which are needed to make batteries, many mining companies
- 2:13are developing technology to collect them and bring them to the surface. But Professor Sweetman
- 2:17says the dark oxygen that they make could also support life on the seafloor. And this discovery,
- 2:22published in the journal Nature Geoscience, raises new concerns about the risk of proposed deep
- 2:27sea mining ventures. The scientists worked out that the metal nodules are able to make oxygen
- 2:32precisely because they act like batteries. If you put a battery into seawater, it starts fizzing,
- 2:37explained Professor Sweetman. That's because the electric current is actually splitting seawater
- 2:41into oxygen and nitrogen, which are bubbles. We think that's happening with these nodules in
- 2:46their natural state. Like a battery in a torch, he added, you put one battery in by torch, they
- 2:51mean a flashlight. Just so you know, that's British for flashlight. We're just gonna say what
- 2:56language are we reading? Yes. I think Scottish might be British. But who knows? Who knows? You
- 3:05put one battery in, it doesn't light up, you put two batteries in, you've got enough voltage to
- 3:08light up the torch. So when the nodules are sitting at the seafloor in contact with one another,
- 3:12they're working in unison like multiple batteries. The researchers put this theory to the test in
- 3:17the lab, collecting and studying potato sized metal nodules. Their experiments measured the
- 3:22voltage on the surface of each metallic lump, essentially the strength of their electric current.
- 3:26They found it to be almost equal to the voltage of a typical AA sized battery. This means they
- 3:31say that the nodules sitting on the seabed could generate electric current large enough to split
- 3:35or electrolyze molecules of seawater. The researchers think the same process, battery powered oxygen
- 3:40production that requires no light and no biological process could be happening on other moons and
- 3:46planets creating oxygen rich environments where life could thrive. That took a turn from what I
- 3:52thought the article was about. Yeah, I know. They've really not talked about the mining at all.
- 3:58I know. I thought it was going to be about mining. Yeah. The Clarion Clipperton Zone,
- 4:03where the discovery was made, is a site already being explored by a number of seabed mining
- 4:07companies. Here we go. Which are developing technologies to collect the nodules and bring
- 4:10them to a ship at the surface. The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration at OAA
- 4:14has warned that the seabed mining could, quote, result in destruction of life and the seabed
- 4:19habitat in the mined areas, that quote. More than 800 marine scientists from 44 countries have signed
- 4:25a petition highlighting the environmental risk and calling for a pause on mining activity.
- 4:29New species are being discovered in the deep ocean all the time and it is often said that we know more
- 4:33about the surface of the moon than we do about the deep sea. And this discovery suggests that the
- 4:37nodules themselves could be providing the oxygen to support their life. Professor Marie Roberts,
- 4:42a marine biologist from the University of Edinburgh, is one of the scientists who signed the seabed
- 4:46mining petition and quote, there's already overwhelming evidence that the strip mining
- 4:50deep sea nodule fields will destroy ecosystems we barely understand, he told the BBC News.
- 4:55Because these fields cover such a huge area of our planet, it would be crazy to press ahead with
- 5:00deep sea mining knowing they may be a significant source of oxygen production. I don't see this
- 5:05study as something that will put an end to mining, said Professor Swiman. But we need to explore it in
- 5:11greater detail and we need to use this information and the data we gather in future if we are going
- 5:16to go into the deep ocean and mine it in the most environmentally friendly way possible. That's the
- 5:21article. We still must mine it. Yeah, it's kind of sad that he's just like resigned himself, so it's
- 5:28gonna get mine. So I guess like we'll try to do it responsibly, I guess. No one's gonna stop this. I do
- 5:35have a few thoughts did take a twist in there about the implications about life elsewhere. Yeah, just
- 5:41kind of off handed suggestions of like, yeah, you actually could very easily get oxygen and oceans
- 5:47without photosynthesis, which is crazy because yeah, that does have implications for other
- 5:51planets that have oceans. But my thoughts on this, I would say generally as a rule that like
- 5:59everything in nature has a purpose. I don't think anything really happens in nature without a purpose.
- 6:05Everything kind of balances each other out. Oh, well, you say that we've gone through like what five
- 6:11mass extinctions, six mass extensions, I can't remember which, but kind of because nature isn't
- 6:17doesn't inherently balance itself. So you end up with huge issues. That that's balance. It's
- 6:23balancing. That's fair. It needs to bring the balance back. You give some you lose. Yeah,
- 6:29yeah, exactly. It seems ballsy to just be like, we don't know what this is for. Yeah, we don't
- 6:36know anything about the devotion, but we're definitely mining it as environmentally friendly
- 6:41as we can, which is probably not very because we don't know what that oxygen is doing there.
- 6:47Yeah, and especially when they say right off the bat, hey, by the way, most are oxygen actually
- 6:51comes from the ocean. This might actually be part of the reason why we've always kind of just assumed
- 6:56this vital plankton, but maybe it's not. This could be our source of air. Yeah, but we're just
- 7:01going to mine that. I also it kind of bothers me a little bit. They didn't reach out to any of the
- 7:07companies who are mining to see what their position is on it. It probably doesn't matter
- 7:12because they're the mining companies. Yeah, yeah. Well, yeah, that's probably what they said. And
- 7:17therefore the company pushed this aside as inconvenient or something like that. Oh, yeah.
- 7:22Yeah. But yeah, that's that's a huge discovery. The fact that it's not just photosynthesis that's
- 7:26creating oxygen in our environments. And we're also just going to do some shit with it. So, yeah,
- 7:33that we need batteries, not for making oxygen for, I don't know, moving around go-karts or
- 7:39something like that. I feel like this is on par for your regular type of episode because I'm
- 7:44feeling uncomfortable about this. But it started with a new scientific breakthrough, which was fun.
- 7:50We need to mine. Yes. We can't just discover that and not mine it. No. It's like an itch you need
- 7:57to scratch. You gotta mine. Yeah, you gotta mine. Anyhow, you guys, you go have fun mining whatever
- 8:06it is you mine for the next 48 hours. Do it responsibly, at least a reasonable amount
- 8:11responsiveness. And we'll see you back here. Bye. Bye.