Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Broken Money with Lyn Alden: The Technological Arc of Money and Power
Transcript
- 0:00So I think a big theme over the past several decades, there have
- 0:02been more and more financialization and there's
- 0:04like a global arbitrage, right? So when you have 160 different
- 0:08currencies and some of them float against each other and
- 0:10pegs break and there's all these different equity markets, all
- 0:13these different real estate markets.
- 0:14If you're a finance here, you have you have like this whole
- 0:16playground of options to like short one thing and go into
- 0:19another thing. And when you look at the the
- 0:21crypto scene, it's kind of the end stage of that.
- 0:24Like it's kind of the the pinnacle of financialize
- 0:27everything and speculate on everything.
- 0:29Bitcoin is in some ways the reversal of that.
- 0:31It's basically saying that if with the reintroduction of a
- 0:34sound boring good money, it actually can de financialize
- 0:38certain things. Not to an extreme sense, but it
- 0:40can reverse that trend towards evermore financialization and
- 0:44arbitrage. Welcome back to the On Ramp
- 0:46Media archives where we revisit some of the most timeless
- 0:49conversations on Bitcoin, money and markets.
- 0:52Today we're re releasing the classic episode from February
- 0:552024 featuring Lynn Alden, engineer, investor and author of
- 0:59Broken Money, one of the most influential thinkers in macro
- 1:03and monetary history. In this conversation, Lynn
- 1:06unpacks the technological arc of money, from shells and tobacco
- 1:09to gold, Fiat and Bitcoin, showing how every leap in
- 1:13communication and settlement has reshaped who controls money and
- 1:16why. She explains why Bitcoin isn't
- 1:18just another speculative layer of financialization, but the
- 1:22technological completion of money itself, the first true
- 1:25form of digital settlement in human history.
- 1:28We also dive into the macro landscape, fiscal dominance,
- 1:31liquidity cycles, and why hard, scarce assets like Bitcoin and
- 1:35gold are poised to outperform in an era defined by debt,
- 1:38deficits, and geopolitical stress.
- 1:40It's a dense, fascinating discussion that's aged even
- 1:43better with time, especially as many of Lynn's 2024 predictions
- 1:46are now playing out in real time.
- 1:48Let's get into it. Broken Money with Lynn Alden.
- 1:51The technological arc of money and power.
- 1:54A consistent theme that I touch on in Broken Money is idea that
- 1:57money is like a Ledger that people either agree to use or
- 2:00some cases forced to use or using a Ledger either in the
- 2:03literal form or the abstract form.
- 2:05And so the big questions to ask are who can censor transactions
- 2:08and who can create more of those units or in some rare cases who
- 2:12can destroy those units in a centralized way.
- 2:14And so, you know, you can kind of think of that as 2 main
- 2:16things. There's commodity money itself,
- 2:18right? So we have a lot of known
- 2:19examples of those. We have grains, we have
- 2:22obviously gold and silver in later years, we have shells.
- 2:25You know, there's all matter of different types of money that
- 2:27people can use. One of the examples that I like
- 2:30is the tobacco example in early United States before they were
- 2:33actually a country, just the early colonies.
- 2:35And the reason is it was kind of like the gold standard, but
- 2:38accelerated. So like all the flaws of money
- 2:41all kind of happened within a pretty short time period because
- 2:43it was it was less sound. And so we kind of ran through
- 2:46the full gambit of all the problems and, and frictions that
- 2:49people find with money. And so when they get to the
- 2:51colonies, there's not a lot of species, there's not a lot of
- 2:54coinage. And so they're kind of
- 2:55gravitating towards other types of money, especially for kind of
- 2:58everyday transactions of, you know, the indigenous people.
- 3:01And they kind of use that money without the ceremony that was
- 3:04normally attached to that type of money by the natives
- 3:06themselves. But they, they just kind of used
- 3:08it for its scarcity purpose. And then they also turned to
- 3:11using tobacco as money, which was a major cash crop.
- 3:14And what's notable about tobacco, it's obviously it's,
- 3:16you know, you get a lot of value per kind of mass and weight
- 3:19relative to other crops. It's a cash crop in that sense.
- 3:22And it was, it has globally desirable crop.
- 3:24And so they start kind of making that into money.
- 3:26They say, OK, well, here's it's legal tender.
- 3:29We're going to use this along with things like wampum, you
- 3:31know, the the shell money. And but then all the natural
- 3:34things start happening, right? So if tobacco is money, it means
- 3:38more people are holding it for reasons in addition to its
- 3:41utility value. And so it's kind of overvalued.
- 3:43It's like more valuable than you'd expected to be based on
- 3:46its utility alone. And so there's a really strong
- 3:49desire to plant more of it because it's, it's overvalued.
- 3:52And so people start planning more of it and you start to get
- 3:54tobacco price inflation. And then so then the authority
- 3:57is like, no, no, wait, we have to put restrictions on who can
- 4:00plan it, right. And so then they have, you know,
- 4:02if you're, it's kind of like the classic, if you're close to the
- 4:05source of power, you're one of the privileged groups that can
- 4:07plan it. Otherwise you can't.
- 4:09Then there's like bootleg tobacco planting because it's,
- 4:12it's still profitable to try to plan it.
- 4:14Obviously there's more risks then there's problems of
- 4:16fungibility. So not all tobacco is the same.
- 4:18It's different ages, different types, different quality.
- 4:21So then they said, OK, well instead of using tobacco
- 4:23directly, we're going to abstract it.
- 4:24Everybody's going to put their tobacco in a warehouse and
- 4:26professionals will grade it and it will have tobacco receipts.
- 4:30And now you have both tobacco that's not really scarce, but
- 4:33you're still using this money. It's got lack of fungibility,
- 4:35but you're now you're abstracting it.
- 4:37So you have like Lily counterparty risk on top of an
- 4:40unsound money. And eventually the system became
- 4:42so untenable and that the economy's developed enough that
- 4:45they they had more species to work with so that they abandoned
- 4:48that system. And in parallel, similar thing
- 4:50happened with the shell money. S the shell money was very
- 4:52valuable to the natives. It was very hard to make.
- 4:55It's got inherent scarcities to it and it has the good
- 4:57properties of money. It's portable, it's long lasting
- 5:00and it has all those attributes. But as soon as you add metal
- 5:03tooling and other kind of sophisticated techniques of
- 5:06gathering shells and then polishing and drilling them and
- 5:08making them into their final form, they could basically
- 5:11devalue the money. They could inflate the supply
- 5:13more readily than was normally the case.
- 5:15And so similar along with the lines of tobacco, they inflated
- 5:19it until was not really useful money anymore and they had to
- 5:21gravitate towards stronger types of monies.
- 5:23So there's all sorts of examples like that, but I find those
- 5:26interesting because they're well documented compared to many
- 5:29other types of monies. And they was all kind of all the
- 5:31problems kind of unfolded over an accelerated pace because you
- 5:34had like a clash of cultures and you had a kind of unique example
- 5:38of a fairly developed civilization, but in a new
- 5:40environment. So they were kind of cut off
- 5:42from their more developed core. And so you had kind of the clash
- 5:45of folder money systems, new money systems, all kind of
- 5:48coming together. One thing I described in the
- 5:49book is that in the development of money, there's basically 2
- 5:52technological paths that are happening simultaneously. 1 is
- 5:55what we're actually using as money itself, which we just
- 5:58touched on. For example, if our technology
- 6:00is too good for shells, we can't use shells anymore.
- 6:02We have to use something that even our new technology can't
- 6:04make more of quickly, like gold, for example.
- 6:07So you kind of move up the hardness scale in terms of
- 6:09different types of commodity monies that that's one technical
- 6:12path, but the other technical path could basically be
- 6:14described as analog encryption or various technologies that
- 6:18overlay on top of those monies and allow the ownership of it to
- 6:21move around more quickly. Because when you're moving and
- 6:24transporting commodity money, especially gold bars and things
- 6:27like that, both the transport of it securely and then the
- 6:30auditing of it down to its core, these are time consuming,
- 6:34inefficient, expensive processes.
- 6:35And so going back literally hundreds and in many cases
- 6:39thousands of years, there's various types of proto bankers,
- 6:42kind of before the modern banking establishments and early
- 6:45bank, they were trying to find ways to make this more
- 6:47efficient. And so going back to ancient
- 6:50Egypt, for example, there'd be papyrus bills of exchange.
- 6:52And there's also early examples along the Silk Road in like
- 6:56Central Asia and a lot of things that we don't really consider
- 6:59technology today. We're all ways to make the
- 7:01transfer of monies quicker and more efficient.
- 7:04So coinage, for example, is one of the classic monetary
- 7:07technologies. You put them into standard units
- 7:08with various anti forgery techniques or anti shaving
- 7:11techniques on the metal itself to make that exchange more
- 7:14rapid. There's also the invention of
- 7:16paper and then the invention of book binding and then the
- 7:18invention of, you know, different types of inks and then
- 7:21you have analog encryption. So for example, if I give gold
- 7:24to a merchant and that merchant signs a piece of paper that I
- 7:28can then transfer to another city and exchange at a different
- 7:31merchant for gold. Again, obviously those merchants
- 7:33in their network have to have some sort of anti forgery
- 7:36technology on top of it to make sure that people can't just copy
- 7:39those paper receipts and just redeem gold that they never put
- 7:42in. And so you have the development
- 7:43of this various kind of anti forgery encryption techniques in
- 7:47the analog sense. Then things like the printing
- 7:49press, which again is today, it's not new technology, but
- 7:52back then that was a big deal. I mean, complex paper
- 7:55instruments that are standardized and and complex
- 7:58became cheaper to do. And so that that expanded the
- 8:01number of things you can do with paper, like widespread usage of
- 8:04banknotes and things like that. So there was that, that
- 8:06technological path over top of the commodity money angle.
- 8:10And these were kind of developing along the
- 8:12simultaneous lines. And then when you get into the
- 8:14modern era, you get even further developments.
- 8:17And I contend, for example, that the Telegraph was an enormous
- 8:20stepwise change in the speed of money globally.
- 8:24So prior to that, there's virtually no way to send
- 8:27information faster than matter, right?
- 8:29So even with complex banking and Ledger systems, those ledgers
- 8:33still only moved at the speed of people.
- 8:35So foot horses, ships, you know, rare low bandwidth exceptions of
- 8:39like fire signals in the night, you can't send information long
- 8:42distances quickly, faster than ship.
- 8:44But what made the Telegraph so interesting is that now you
- 8:47could send higher bandwidth information around the world
- 8:50very quickly. And the first time in thousands
- 8:53and thousands of years in human history, we had this big gap
- 8:56between how quickly we could transfer information versus how
- 8:59quickly we were still confined to transferring matter.
- 9:02And I think most historians, when they focus on that, they
- 9:04focus on the geopolitical implications.
- 9:06But there's a pretty straightforward monetary
- 9:08implication, which I don't see discussed that often and why I
- 9:11chose to emphasize it so much, which is that information,
- 9:14transferring information allows you to make transactions, but
- 9:16especially in a low bandwidth setting like then, it does not
- 9:19allow you to make settlements. And so the gulf between
- 9:22settlement transactions and settlements became larger than
- 9:24ever. So prior to then there were
- 9:26still somewhat of a gap. So there's various paper
- 9:28instruments I mentioned. They basically increased the gap
- 9:31between transaction speed and settlement speed, but it was
- 9:33still like a manageable size. But this just completely blew
- 9:36open the the scale and the speed of those two things.
- 9:40And what I would argue is that basically we had a century and a
- 9:42half of just extreme levels of financial centralization.
- 9:45And most of that was to bridge that gap between those
- 9:49transaction speeds and those settlement speeds, basically
- 9:51because you had to rely on some sort of trusted entity in in the
- 9:54middle until we basically just dropped the idea of settlement
- 9:57altogether. We just dropped the idea of
- 9:59using any sort of underlying gold and the Ledger itself
- 10:02became settlement. And going to the modern era,
- 10:05what makes Bitcoin so interesting is that finally
- 10:08technology and bandwidth globally came together enough
- 10:11that we could do digital settlement, not just digital
- 10:14transactions. And that really could not have
- 10:16occurred much earlier than it happened.
- 10:18Obviously the development of the Internet, you had to have not
- 10:20just low bandwidth Internet, but fairly high bandwidth Internet
- 10:23pretty globally accessible. Then you had to have pretty
- 10:25advanced that's encryption techniques.
- 10:27Some of them were only invented less than a decade before
- 10:30Bitcoin came out. And so as these things came
- 10:32together, we got the emergence of Bitcoin, which is digital
- 10:35settlement. And so that's what I describe as
- 10:37closing that gap between transactions and settlements.
- 10:41And the kind of the take away point is how much technology
- 10:45influences who controls money. So if you go back centuries, the
- 10:49idea of surveilling every transaction is like science
- 10:52fiction, whereas now it's it's almost like people say, why?
- 10:55Why wouldn't government surveil every transaction, right?
- 10:58It seems normal. And if you kind of question it,
- 11:00it's almost like you're the weird one.
- 11:02You're like, well, what are you up to then if you don't want
- 11:03every transaction being surveilled?
- 11:05And so basically the, the technology, the speed, all these
- 11:08things are heavily influenced by technology.
- 11:10Even though a lot of monetary history books focus on human
- 11:13decisions, which I, you know, they're, they're relevant for
- 11:16certain times in certain areas. But that link between technology
- 11:19and money and how fast it allows money to move and who controls
- 11:22it, I think is something that was generally underexplored and
- 11:25why I emphasize it so much. One of the themes that kind of
- 11:28indirectly comes up in the book is the idea of kind of
- 11:30technological determinism, which is that when certain orders of
- 11:34events happen, one kind of leads to the other.
- 11:36And so if we use another example, there's, if we were to
- 11:38rerun this human history 100 times, you know, either 99 to
- 11:42100 times the bicycle would be invented before the automobile
- 11:46and before the airplane, right? Because one kind of leads ones
- 11:49like a necessary but insufficient part of the next
- 11:52one, right? So something really weird would
- 11:54have to happen to like invent the airplane before you have
- 11:56something like a bicycle or something like a car.
- 11:58And the same thing is kind of true with money, which is that,
- 12:01you know, we kind of saw the emergence of pretty common
- 12:04paths, right? So first there was proto
- 12:06banking. That's kind of it's like channel
- 12:08like banking in the modern context.
- 12:10It's almost like lightning came before Bitcoin in the sense that
- 12:13you'd have these bankers that are basically they have direct
- 12:15connections with other merchants in other cities and they can
- 12:18allow for the transporting of money pretty quickly.
- 12:20It's more about actually transferring money than credit,
- 12:23even though it relies on credit to make that transfer.
- 12:26And then you had the development of, you know, more free banking
- 12:28type of arrangements. But the problem is that when all
- 12:31the gold kind of gets put into a couple different hubs, like a
- 12:34couple different major banks, the governments know where all
- 12:37the gold is now, right? Instead of being diffused
- 12:39throughout the population, it's in certain hubs.
- 12:42And there's ledgers built on top of those hubs that allow people
- 12:44to transfer the ownership of it more readily.
- 12:47That was basically, for example, the whole point of banking in
- 12:50those Italian city states is that they'd have the gold in one
- 12:53spot. And you'd have a Venetian
- 12:54merchant and an Arab merchant. And they could just go to the
- 12:58banker and say, well, OK, we transferred these spices and now
- 13:01we're going to just transfer these Ledger entry for who owns
- 13:04this amount of gold. And the gold would still just
- 13:06kind of be sitting in the same vault.
- 13:08And the problem is that that all coalesces and governments know
- 13:12where it is. And so they can say, well, OK,
- 13:13now every bank, every bank has to put all or some of their gold
- 13:16into this big central vault. And then also you have the
- 13:19constant tendency towards duration mismatching.
- 13:22But there's all these debates around fraction reserve or full
- 13:24reserve banking. I prefer to kind of describe it
- 13:26as either full, either duration matched or duration mismatched
- 13:30banking, which is basically your, your, your liabilities are
- 13:33you're making promises that you only probabilistically can keep.
- 13:36So you have this kind of ultimately unsound arrangement
- 13:40that leads to kind of cascading crises.
- 13:42And then one of the solutions for those is central banking.
- 13:44But then it come, it's almost like a deal with the devil in
- 13:47the sense that it fixed. So you're immediately problem,
- 13:50but then it further over decades further centralizes the system.
- 13:53So one of the things I argue is the fact that gold failed almost
- 13:56everywhere at the same time. Other than Switzerland and a few
- 13:59others, it pretty much all failed at the same time.
- 14:02And the fact that when you look around today, there's no
- 14:04countries on a gold standard, like not one.
- 14:06There's no country that does full reserve banking, even
- 14:09though it's inherently more stable of a system.
- 14:11It's just the incentives have not worked that way.
- 14:13I generally argue that the, the, the, the path of technology that
- 14:16was available so strongly tilt incentives towards some
- 14:19directions that 99 or times out of 100 it leads towards those
- 14:23directions, at least until another technology comes along
- 14:26that swings those incentives back in another direction.
- 14:29So for a century you'd have sound money advocates or
- 14:32Austrian economics proponents saying how things should be and
- 14:36just kind of getting ignored. They're kind of making arguments
- 14:38about and it's just kind of nation states for like that's
- 14:40cool. And they just ignored them.
- 14:42Whereas I kind of view Bitcoin as the first tool that actually
- 14:45gives them the burden of power, right?
- 14:47That they that things now a little bit kind of tilt the
- 14:50scales back in their favor to some extent.
- 14:52So yeah, I kind of view a lot of it as even though there were
- 14:56human decisions that can be described as some case ethical,
- 14:59some cases unethical, and they can affect the timing of certain
- 15:02things. When you generally see the whole
- 15:03world move in a direction for a period of time, it's usually the
- 15:06case that technology has kind of strongly tilted the scales in
- 15:09that favor, at least for that era.
- 15:11All right, just a quick break. If you're not subscribed to the
- 15:14On Ramp Research newsletter, I certainly encourage you to do
- 15:17so. If you're a fan of the last
- 15:19trade and other shows here at On Ramp Media, I know that you'll
- 15:22find a lot of value in the newsletter that Brian on our
- 15:25team produces each week. We just sent out the weekly
- 15:28roundup this morning and Brian really dug into the sovereign
- 15:31accumulation watch, as he called it.
- 15:33So dug into what is happening around the world as nation
- 15:36states approach Bitcoin as a strategic reserve asset.
- 15:39So again, if you're interested in what we do here on the
- 15:42research side and want to follow our research updates as well as
- 15:45team updates, product updates, head to our website on
- 15:48rampbitcoin.com and you can put your e-mail in right on the
- 15:51homepage you see here. I've been giving like a two year
- 15:54view more than a one year view. It's like higher conviction in
- 15:57that period because almost anything happened in one year.
- 15:59Whereas 2 years I think the directions matter more.
- 16:02The structural directions are harder to not go a certain way.
- 16:06And so I do expect that within the next two years we'll
- 16:08probably have another pro liquidity cycle.
- 16:11We we've been in this kind of period of stagnant liquidities,
- 16:13quantitative tightening, partially offset by all these
- 16:15treasury actions we've been talking about, you know,
- 16:17draining the reversal of both facility things like that.
- 16:19But I do think that within the next two years we'll probably
- 16:21have another significant up leg in liquidity.
- 16:24And one of one of the strongest correlations with Bitcoin is
- 16:27liquidity, especially global broad liquidity measures.
- 16:30So I do think that that will be a tailwind for Bitcoin.
- 16:32I think the halving will be a tailwind for Bitcoin.
- 16:35You know, one thing I argue is that the halving, the timing is
- 16:38not always perfect for Bitcoin bull runs.
- 16:40If anything, liquidity correlates with that stronger
- 16:43than the halving. But the halving is certainly
- 16:44still a factor, especially for magnitude, especially for
- 16:47helping reach higher highs and higher lows as it goes through
- 16:50these cycles. So the fact that the halving is
- 16:52coming up, I think is bullish. I think the washout of a lot of
- 16:55the excesses of the past cycle is mostly done, which kind of
- 16:58just sets the floor for Bitcoin. And I also look at the huddle
- 17:02wave, for lack of a better word. There's, there's more
- 17:04sophisticated ways to measure too, like looking at addresses
- 17:07that mostly accumulate Bitcoin and rarely sell Bitcoin and kind
- 17:10of looking at their percentage relative to the whole, but
- 17:12different ways of looking at it is roughly the question of has
- 17:15there been a distribution cycle yet?
- 17:17So generally stronger hands in Bitcoin tend to sell somewhat
- 17:21into strength. So if Bitcoin goes up 5X or 10X,
- 17:24some of those addresses tend to be trimming their holdings.
- 17:27You know, maybe it's because they're rebalancing, maybe it's
- 17:29because they now can consume something that they couldn't
- 17:32consume before, but they want to buy the house that they couldn't
- 17:35buy before and so they're selling some Bitcoin to do it.
- 17:37Generally when you see a significant amount of that
- 17:39distribution and a lot of new investors coming in, that's when
- 17:42you're maybe getting closer to a top in the cycle and that's not
- 17:46really started yet in this cycle, even though we're off the
- 17:49lows by about double or more, there's not really been that
- 17:52distribution cycle yet. And so far that's very clean
- 17:55compared to prior this stage in the bull market like an early
- 17:58bull market environment where prices off the lows, sentiments
- 18:02improving is not really dead anymore.
- 18:04But there's also been virtually no reason for those strongly
- 18:07held coins to go back onto the market.
- 18:09And so I think that most of the catalysts still point toward
- 18:12pretty good two year returns in my expectation.
- 18:15And you know, the longer I go out, you know, the higher
- 18:18conviction I can be. So I might be very uncertain for
- 18:21the next 6 months, pretty high conviction for the next 24
- 18:24months and obviously higher conviction would say A5 year
- 18:26view. Well, so one thing that's
- 18:27interesting is that the entire reverse repo facility basically
- 18:30represents excess demand for T-bills beyond the amount that
- 18:34is available. And so, and that that's a market
- 18:37that I've been following pretty closely throughout my just kind
- 18:40of macro career. So for example, back in 2019, we
- 18:43had the opposite. We had a repo spike and we had
- 18:45that engage in repo activities and that was partially just
- 18:48because there were too many T-bills, relatively available
- 18:51liquidity to absorb those T-bills after all the QE that
- 18:54happened during the during the pandemic stimulation and
- 18:56lockdowns and all that. You had this build up of excess
- 18:59cash that wanted to be in T-bills.
- 19:02And so they set up all the reverse repo facilities, things
- 19:04like that to ensure that T bill yields don't get driven below
- 19:08their the lower bound of their interest rate targets.
- 19:10And so as long as that pool of capital exists, policymakers,
- 19:15specifically the Treasury, have the option to tilt duration
- 19:18towards the shorter end to try to meet that excessive demand
- 19:21for T-bills and relieve the potentially insufficient demand
- 19:24for longer dated securities. And so we've seen kind of a
- 19:28gamification of that in the past year or more.
- 19:31And one of the kind of the dilemmas you face as the
- 19:33Treasury is you're trying to issue debt.
- 19:35I mean, you're not the Treasury's not the one that the
- 19:37term what the deficits are. That's mostly Congress and the
- 19:41president and all that kind of comes together.
- 19:42But as the Treasury, it's your job to figure out what types of
- 19:45bonds to issue to meet those demands.
- 19:48And if you go back long enough, that wasn't always the case.
- 19:51It used to be that Congress would basically authorize every
- 19:53type of bond to pay for every type of debt.
- 19:56And eventually they said, OK, that's the micromanagement is
- 19:59getting too silly there because the whole apparatus is getting
- 20:02too big. And so they said, OK, well,
- 20:03we'll just set a limit. Here's a debt ceiling, and the
- 20:06Treasury can go out and figure the.
- 20:08Details of what bonds to issue and what durations and any sort
- 20:11of parameters they want to do. And so the Treasury has this job
- 20:14of meeting this very large deficit and they have different
- 20:17parameters that they're trying to meet.
- 20:19So one is obviously they want to have the lowest cost available
- 20:22to the government. That's a big variable, right?
- 20:24So if there's different part to the Treasury curve, you can
- 20:26potentially save some money by issuing debt on the on the
- 20:29cheaper part of the curve, but it has other consequences.
- 20:31Another big one is obviously liquidity.
- 20:33If you don't want to cause a liquidity problem, you can issue
- 20:37bonds on the more expensive part of the curve, but that is more
- 20:40conducive to liquidity and asset prices and things like that.
- 20:43So I'm, I'm, I'm like monitoring the reverse repo facility and
- 20:47the rate of QT to be a little bit more important than the
- 20:50rates themselves, partially because the rates themselves
- 20:53weirdly have a dual aspect. So they are tightening to some
- 20:56parts of the economy. But as a point I've been making
- 20:59is they're actually stimulating other parts of the economy.
- 21:01And that's really only the case when you have public debt to GDP
- 21:04this high, right. So back in the Volcker era when
- 21:06you had 30% debt, the, the higher the rates go, it's mostly
- 21:10just depressing the economy. It's mostly an anti
- 21:12inflationary, anti credit creation effect, which is why
- 21:16Volcker did it. But the problem is when you try
- 21:17to repeat that when you now have a percent debt, the GDP just for
- 21:21round numbers, on one hand you are having the same effect of
- 21:25pushing down on interest rate sensitive sectors of the
- 21:27economy, right? So commercial real estates,
- 21:30small business bank lending, residential real estate turnover
- 21:33and things like that, that all that all effects is similar.
- 21:36But another hand, you're completely blowing out the
- 21:38fiscal deficit, which is stimulating parts of the
- 21:41economy. They're not as interest rate
- 21:42sensitive or not interest sensitive at all.
- 21:45And so if you're on the receiving side of those
- 21:46deficits, one or another, if anything, you're propensity to
- 21:49spend is now higher and so that effect is more muted.
- 21:52Whereas liquidity is still pretty much liquidity.
- 21:54So QT is generally still not good for asset prices unless
- 21:57it's being countered by something else like for example,
- 22:00the draining of the reverse repo facility.
- 22:02So I've been paying a little bit more attention to the balance
- 22:05sheet more so than the rates. Another factor with pointing out
- 22:08is that as inflation has cooled down to varying degrees, flat
- 22:12interest rate profile results in widening real rates.
- 22:15So if, if they just hold interest rates flat and interest
- 22:18rates are declining, that means they're increasing real rates.
- 22:22And so they actually have a capacity to mildly reduce rates
- 22:25while still remaining at say the positive real rate level that
- 22:28they had some months ago. So that might be a, that might
- 22:31be a path that they approach. They might, they might trim
- 22:34rates, for example, but say that they're just kind of maintaining
- 22:37the level of hawkishness that they're already at.
- 22:40They're actually that not really viewing it as less hawkish.
- 22:43I think it's one way of looking at it.
- 22:44Of course, you could get the inverse effect.
- 22:46If you get some sort of energy shortage or some sort of
- 22:49inflationary re acceleration, then simply holding rates flat
- 22:53might become more dovish over time because the interest rates
- 22:55are inflation is increasing and real rates are reducing.
- 23:00And so I do think that they're going to air less hawkish this
- 23:03year. I you know, I think they've been
- 23:05signaling that pretty clearly. I do think while the Fed tries
- 23:07not to be immediately political. So when we think about
- 23:10separation of central banking and the executive branch, it's
- 23:13mostly in the acute sense so that, for example, that a
- 23:16president can't just call up the head of the central bank six
- 23:18weeks before an election and say, I'm going to fire you
- 23:21unless you raise rates, right. There's there's certain
- 23:23separations of powers that make that sort of acute or obvious,
- 23:26you know, interaction not really possible.
- 23:29But when things get bad enough or when things get structural
- 23:32enough, there is integration between them.
- 23:34So the obviously examples during World War 2, that was the most
- 23:37direct example of basically the central bank being entirely
- 23:39captured by the Treasury because they viewed it as viewed as a
- 23:42national emergency, not to. And in the more recent sense,
- 23:46you know, Fed officials generally are almost by
- 23:48definition pro establishment. They generally favor
- 23:51establishment candidates. It might not be as acutely, but
- 23:54to the extent that they can put their thumb on one side or the
- 23:57other, that's kind of the direction they're going to point
- 23:59at. So I do think that they have a
- 24:01fairly significant incentive not to have an acute recession this
- 24:04year. Doesn't mean you can't have a
- 24:06slow down, doesn't mean you can't have sector specific
- 24:09weakness. But I think that they're going
- 24:11to probably do their best not to have some sort of full blown
- 24:13whole labor cycle acute recession if they can help it.
- 24:17Over the past 40 years, especially in the United States,
- 24:20there's been this kind of structural tilt towards
- 24:22disinflation. SO4 decades of declining
- 24:24structural inflation, 40 years of declining interest rates.
- 24:27And therefore both stocks and bonds were very good performers.
- 24:31They had partially thanks to those reductions in interest
- 24:34rates, you had higher equity multiples that made sense
- 24:37relative to interest rates over time.
- 24:39And that's kind of a virtuous cycle for as long as it lasts
- 24:42until you hit zero and stay at 0 for a while at least.
- 24:45And so we had this kind of 40 year period where owning stocks
- 24:48and bonds together made a lot of sense.
- 24:50When you look at longer data sets or more multi country data
- 24:53sets, we are not just picking the best equity market in the
- 24:57world of the reserve currency country, right?
- 24:59If you're, if you have a more global view or a view that does
- 25:02not just include that kind of 40 year distillationary regime,
- 25:05generally more diversified portfolios hold up better than
- 25:08the stock bond portfolio. So it could be as simple as
- 25:11adding say a gold slice historically.
- 25:13So instead of saying 60% stock, 40% bonds, if you said 60%
- 25:16stocks, 30% bonds, 10% gold, there are decades where neither
- 25:20stocks nor bonds do particularly well, but gold does amazing.
- 25:23So the 19 and the two would be examples of that.
- 25:25Those tend to be the more inflationary decades.
- 25:27All else being equal, they tend to be weaker dollar decades.
- 25:31So where the dollar index rolls over, you get international
- 25:33equity outperformance, you get commodity outperformance, you
- 25:36get gold outperformance relative to U.S. stocks and bonds.
- 25:39So I think especially in this era of fiscal dominance where
- 25:42we're no longer in that kind of 40 year structural disinflation
- 25:46monetary dominance cycle, I generally think that having that
- 25:49inflationary segment in a portfolio is useful.
- 25:52So that can include probably describe it either as real
- 25:55estate in some contexts, but more specifically, it's kind of
- 25:58commodities, commodity producers and hard monies.
- 26:00And so for example, that can include energy, right?
- 26:03If you, if you map energy prices to inflation, energy prices are
- 26:06kind of like a high beta version of inflation.
- 26:09If you're trying to hedge inflation, one of the best ways
- 26:11to do it historically is having long exposure to various energy
- 26:14assets. And then hard monies have a more
- 26:16complicated relationship to inflation because they're more
- 26:19specifically about currency debasement.
- 26:21But overall they, they, they kind of protect you from similar
- 26:24types of decades, decades where neither stocks nor bonds do
- 26:27particularly well. We could call them
- 26:28stagflationary decades, we could call them weaker dollar, higher
- 26:32inflation, higher international decades.
- 26:34There's different flavors of these types of decades.
- 26:36But in general, those things that have been under invested in
- 26:40during the disinflationary cycle and the potential are the causes
- 26:43of the next inflationary cycle. They're the things that have
- 26:45become scarce. They tend to go up when other
- 26:48things don't. And we've seen in recent years
- 26:50that, you know, during kind of years where both stocks and
- 26:54bonds do poorly, it's those energy and commodities and more
- 26:56inflationary assets that do well.
- 26:58So I do think that's really important.
- 27:00And then having that scarce asset slice, that hard money
- 27:02slice in older eras, that would be gold.
- 27:05Now it could be Bitcoin or it could be a hybrid of gold and
- 27:07Bitcoin, depending on that investors view, their age, their
- 27:10volatility tolerance, how much they've researched those two
- 27:13types of assets, for example. But I do think that if we do
- 27:16enter a more sustained period of a more stagflationary type of
- 27:20environment, which doesn't have to be extreme, it doesn't have
- 27:22like the 70s. It could be like the two, for
- 27:24example. It could be like the 19, which
- 27:25is a decade that I use a lot as an analog that not many other
- 27:29analysts do. I think it now it's becoming
- 27:31more common, but that's if you go back to if you want a third
- 27:33example, the 2019 and the 40s, that'd be another one.
- 27:36I do think that most research shows, you know, there's the
- 27:39Dragon portfolio for example, by I think Chris Cole, he put that
- 27:43for some years ago, he kind of modeled out 100 years and said
- 27:46what kind of portfolio would do well over that longer cycle, not
- 27:49just this 40 year cycle. There's also portfolios, call it
- 27:52the permanent portfolio or other things like that.
- 27:54They kind of model these longer time frames and they generally
- 27:56show that, yeah, having something other than just stocks
- 27:58and bonds tends to be very helpful.
- 28:00Could be gold, could be real estate, could be energy
- 28:03producers, could be Bitcoin. You know, we take for granted
- 28:05that the US stocks always go up. First of all, it's not always
- 28:08the case that there are long stretches where, especially in
- 28:11inflation adjusted terms, stocks don't go up for 15 years or
- 28:14more. And then 2, when you look
- 28:15globally, that happens a lot more frequently.
- 28:18I mean, Japan goes 30 years without new highs or Europe goes
- 28:2120 years without new highs. These things happen on a regular
- 28:24basis, especially when you start with very high equity
- 28:27valuations, a lot of foreign capital pushed into your area.
- 28:30So in the late 80s it was Japan. Everybody was like, OK, Japan's
- 28:33taking the world. We all want to own Japan.
- 28:35Their market cap to GDP became very kind of imbalanced in the
- 28:39late 90s. Early sheet, the creation of the
- 28:41euro, it was very optimistic time for Europe.
- 28:44There was quite a bit of capital pushed into Europe, you know,
- 28:46not to the extremes of Japan, but fairly high starting
- 28:49valuations and high expectations, which then we're
- 28:51not met. And it's so you had 4020 years
- 28:53of not very good on average European equity performance.
- 28:56And right now it argued that the US equity valuations are quite
- 28:59expensive. They it's not new.
- 29:01I mean, they've been expensive in the past five years and
- 29:03they've only gotten more expensive pretty much the the
- 29:05percentage of global capital that's that could be in the USA.
- 29:09Lot of it is in the US, right? So there's not necessarily a ton
- 29:12of capital just sitting there that could decide to come into
- 29:14the USA. Lot of it's already in the US.
- 29:16And so should some of these virtuous cycles start going the
- 29:19other way as they have done in the past in certain decades, so
- 29:22the 70s or the 2 or maybe more structurally, at some point in
- 29:25the future, you could have a shift where the US equity
- 29:28market, you know, maybe doesn't crash, but maybe it just
- 29:30underwhelms for 10-15 years or more.
- 29:33And being in other assets are where it's at.
- 29:36And it could be that those assets go up in price.
- 29:38For example, maybe Bitcoin captures market share, adds A0
- 29:41to its price for example. Hey everyone, hope you're
- 29:44enjoying the show. Just want to give a quick word
- 29:46from on ramp. If you're not familiar, we have
- 29:48an incredible new institutional line of products that have come
- 29:51out, including fundamentals research series that Glenn
- 29:54Cameron, our head of Institutional has been working
- 29:56on. But highly suggest taking a look
- 29:58at it, sharing with, you know, whether it's peers in the space,
- 30:02friends and family, as well as if you're an institutional
- 30:04allocator. Taking a look, it's really
- 30:06foundational stuff about what gives Bitcoin value total
- 30:09addressable market. Well, how it works really great,
- 30:12you know, content that meets the the middle between institutional
- 30:17allocators and the type of research and Polish they
- 30:19require, as well as the understandings from a Bitcoin,
- 30:24you know, centric lens. This also applies to just net
- 30:29new holders that you've been trying to educate in the space
- 30:32on ramp trade offers the lowest fees in the industry.
- 30:36If we ever don't, please let us know.
- 30:38The main reason we can do that is because we offer other
- 30:40financial services outside of just you know, buying and
- 30:44selling Bitcoin. Specifically, our multi
- 30:46institution custody offering would encourage clients to.
- 30:49Check out or prospective. Clients, it's a great offering.
- 30:52You can find it on our website at on rentbitcoin.com.
- 30:55On to the rest of the show. So people can check out broken
- 30:57money wherever books are sold. They can also check out
- 30:59lyndalden.com. Overall, I think that you know
- 31:03this, it's just a very dynamic environment.
- 31:05I describe some decades as being macro heavy and other decades as
- 31:08not being particularly macro heavy.
- 31:10And I think this is a very macro heavy decade where things like
- 31:14liquidity, things like geopolitics, these can impact
- 31:17asset prices more than in a decade that's not macro heavy
- 31:21and they tend to feed on each other.
- 31:23One thing I point out, for example, is that the sovereign
- 31:25debt crises are likely to lead to war and wars likely to lead
- 31:28to sovereign debt crises. So you can't get that vicious
- 31:30cycle. And the same is true like, you
- 31:34know, peace can lead to disinflation and disinflation
- 31:37can lead to peace because things are kind of when orders present,
- 31:40it tends to lead to more order until for something changes it.
- 31:43And so because we're in this macro heavy decade with high
- 31:47public debts and usual liquidity situations and now kind of a
- 31:50breakout of geopolitical conflict that things tend to add
- 31:53together. So surprises are usually towards
- 31:56more macro, not less macro. And so that just, that's just my
- 31:59overall kind of framework for this decade is to kind of expect
- 32:02the unexpected, stay humble and, and like I said, kind of have a,
- 32:05have a sketch of where I think things are going, but then be
- 32:08very quick to adjust that as time goes by.
- 32:11So for example, I've been using 1950 as well as other analogs to
- 32:15help me construct a mental framework of what this can look
- 32:18like. But of course, no one can see
- 32:19the future. I don't know what countries will
- 32:21be in war a year from now. They're not in a war now what
- 32:24wars might end or, you know, what might have happened with
- 32:27country XY. Is it surprise assassinations or
- 32:29this happened or you know who and all that stuff has to be
- 32:32kind of adjusted to overtime. And so I think that just stay
- 32:35humble, have an outlook and then it just keep adjusting to new
- 32:38information.