Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / The Lockup Cliff How Private Company Shares Hit Public Markets
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's talk about something that quietly moves billions of dollars in market cap, yet most investors don't track it closely: the IPO lockup cliff. Luna: The lockup cliff — that's the date when insiders are finally allowed to sell shares they've been holding since the company went public, right? Lucas: Exactly. Most tech IPOs have a lockup period — typically 90 to 180 days — during which founders, employees, and early investors can't sell their shares. Once that lockup lifts, a huge slug of stock suddenly becomes tradable. Luna: And the market has to absorb that supply. Which can get ugly fast. Lucas: Right. A study from the University of Florida looked at over 1,000 IPOs and found that, on average, the stock drops about 2 to 3 percent on the day the lockup expires. But for tech companies, it's worse — the drop is closer to 6 or 7 percent. Luna: And that's just the day-of. The effect can linger. Lucas: Exactly. About 80 percent of tech IPOs see a price decline within a month of lockup expiration. The selling pressure doesn't all hit on day one — some insiders stagger their sales, but the overhang is real. Luna: So who's most likely to sell? Is it the founders, the VCs, the employees? Lucas: All of the above, but the motives differ. Venture capitalists often sell immediately — they're returning capital to their LPs. Employees tend to hold a bit longer, especially if they believe in the company. Founders are the wild card. Some sell a small portion for diversification, others hold almost everything. Luna: Take Palantir. They went public via direct listing in 2020, which meant no lockup at all. But they imposed their own 180-day lockup voluntarily. When it lifted in early 2021, the stock fell about 12 percent in a single day. Lucas: Palantir is a great example. Today, Palantir trades at around 136 dollars and 75 cents, up about one percent over the last five days. But back then, the lockup cliff was brutal. And it's not just Palantir — Airbnb had a similar story. Luna: Airbnb's lockup expired in early 2021, right around the same time. Their stock dropped about 5 percent on the day, and then another 10 percent over the next two weeks. Lucas: And Airbnb today trades at around 132 dollars and 75 cents, up just over one percent in the last five days. The lockup hangover didn't permanently break the stock, but for a while, it was a tough period for retail investors who bought into the hype. Luna: Which raises the question: why don't companies stagger the lockup expiration? Let insiders sell in batches, maybe 25 percent every quarter. Lucas: Some do. It's called a structured lockup. But most companies stick with the single cliff because it's simpler and the investment banks underwriting the IPO prefer it — they want maximum selling pressure at a predictable time so they can manage the offering. But increasingly, companies are using secondary offerings before the lockup expires to let insiders cash out early. Luna: Secondary market sales have really taken off. I saw a stat that secondary volumes on platforms like Forge and EquityZen have tripled since 2023. So employees don't have to wait for the lockup to lift anymore. Lucas: That's a huge shift. It means the lockup cliff might become less of an event because shares have already been distributed to willing buyers in the private market. But it also means the IPO itself becomes less of a liquidity event for insiders — they've already sold. Luna: This is actually useful if you're thinking about buying into a recent IPO. You can check the lockup expiration date — it's in the S-1 filing — and maybe wait until after that date to buy, if you're worried about the cliff. Lucas: Speaking of useful, if today's conversation helped you understand something about the mechanics of public markets, that's exactly why we do these episodes. The way these stay ad-free and independent is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple way to keep the show going without any ads. Appreciate anyone who chips in. Lucas: Alright, so back to lockups. One wrinkle that's becoming more common: SPACs. SPAC mergers often have shorter lockup periods — sometimes 45 days — and the selling pressure can be even more concentrated because SPAC investors, especially the PIPE investors, might have registration rights that let them sell immediately. Luna: That's been a disaster for a lot of SPAC stocks. The lockup expiration often triggers a massive sell-off because the SPAC sponsors and early investors have no long-term commitment to the company. Lucas: Right. Compare that to a traditional IPO where the underwriters often have a greenshoe option to stabilize the stock. That doesn't exist in a SPAC. So when the lockup lifts, there's no safety net. Luna: What about direct listings? No lockup at all — like Palantir and Slack. But they also don't raise new capital. It's a different trade-off. Lucas: Exactly. In a direct listing, the company is saying 'we don't need your money, we just need a public market for our shares.' The absence of a lockup means the price discovery is more chaotic in the first few weeks, but theoretically, the market finds equilibrium faster. Luna: So for an investor, the key takeaway might be: know the lockup date, know the type of IPO, and be aware of secondary market activity ahead of time. Lucas: That's exactly right. And there's data that shows buying a stock three months after lockup expiration — after the selling pressure has passed — yields better returns on average. But it's not a guaranteed strategy. Luna: Nothing is. But being aware of the mechanics gives you an edge over someone who just buys the hype on day one. Lucas: And that's the whole point of this show — understanding how the machine works so you're not caught off guard. The lockup cliff is just one gear in that machine, but it's a big one. Luna: Next time you see a stock drop on a random Tuesday, check if it happens to be exactly 180 days after the IPO. You might have your answer. Lucas: And if you want more episodes like this, you know where to find us. Until next time.