Latest / The Vegan Report / Jurassic Park Is Not Just a Movie. With Alex Ventimilla | Ep. 85
Transcript
- 0:01You are listening to The Vegan Report. My name
- 0:05is Ryan and 32 years have passed since the release
- 0:09of the first Jurassic Park movie, now a cinema
- 0:13classic. For today's episode, we are revisiting
- 0:17their original franchise through an animal rights
- 0:20perspective. As the multi -billion dollar biotech
- 0:24firm Colossal is seriously considering opening
- 0:28its own Jurassic Park, let's examine closely
- 0:32the impact and legacy of those 90s era movies.
- 0:37To discuss this topic, I have with me Alex Ventimiglia
- 0:41Sanchez, a professor of the English and Film
- 0:44Studies Department of the University of Alberta.
- 0:48He is also part of the team behind the amazing
- 0:51egg -truth .com initiative. Among other things,
- 0:56I asked Alex Why does our sense of wonderment
- 1:01towards animals makes us want to abuse them?
- 1:05Do vegans deceptively make animals appear like
- 1:09children? Do we exploit animals because of our
- 1:13conditioning or human nature? Visit the episode's
- 1:18notes and connect with Alex and the egg -truth
- 1:22.com project. Also, a friendly reminder to share
- 1:26this episode with your people. Subscribe or follow
- 1:30the show if you haven't. Leave a good review.
- 1:33Your support of this independent podcast means
- 1:36the world to me. Thank you. It's really fun to
- 1:46have a pretext to talk about dinosaurs and Jurassic
- 1:51Park. I'm feeling nostalgic. This was a big theme
- 1:57of my childhood. Dinosaurs, I loved them. I collected
- 2:01figurines of dinosaurs and I watched Jurassic
- 2:06Park maybe a hundred times. I loved that movie
- 2:09so much and I'm talking about the original version
- 2:13with the puppet dinosaurs, not the CGI versions.
- 2:22Do we share the same passion for dinosaurs? Yeah,
- 2:26yeah, absolutely. I think so first off, I agree
- 2:29any any opportunity to talk about dinosaurs in
- 2:31general, but but Jurassic Park in particular,
- 2:34I think is something that I treasure. I have
- 2:37lots of memories that revolve around dinosaurs.
- 2:43It was like, as you said, it was an obsession
- 2:45of mine when I was a kid. And actually, I didn't
- 2:47quite outgrow it until until recently, I think.
- 2:51And that's only because life has thrown so many
- 2:55things at me that I don't really have much time
- 2:57to indulge in that. But when I was a kid, one
- 3:02of my first memories is actually watching, not
- 3:06Jurassic Park, not originally, The Land Before
- 3:08Time, over and over and over again. It was a
- 3:12bit of an obsession of mine. There was a time
- 3:14when I got an eye injury and I was supposed to
- 3:19be mostly in bed for a couple of months. And
- 3:23then my parents got me that movie and I just
- 3:24ended up watching it over and over again. I think
- 3:26that's where my obsession came from. And then
- 3:29when Jurassic Park came out, I was a little kid,
- 3:32but I begged my parents to let me go watch it
- 3:35in the theater. And so they took me and now it's
- 3:40a bit of a tradition of mine now to watch it
- 3:42at least once a year. It's a movie that I keep
- 3:45coming back to and in many ways it informs what
- 3:48I do now. Maybe not in a very direct way, but
- 3:52I think it became sort of my inspiration for
- 3:57a lot of ideas that I think about and with even
- 4:02today in my research. I believe that we have
- 4:07not yet assimilated the fact that dinosaurs exist,
- 4:13have existed into our culture and cognition as
- 4:20a culture. And I think there should have been
- 4:24something like a philosophical reckoning with
- 4:28the first skeletons of dinosaurs, but nothing
- 4:33did not make people question core beliefs that
- 4:37we have created as a species. Let me just add,
- 4:43I feel the same way about Darwin. I feel like
- 4:46when he came up with theory of evolution and
- 4:51talked about how the difference between humanity
- 4:55and the rest of the animal kingdom is a difference
- 4:58of degrees and not of nature, this should have
- 5:03caused an earthquake philosophically for the
- 5:06entire species, but nothing, not even a ripple.
- 5:10Yeah, you know, I would qualify that claim because
- 5:14I think that in many ways it did, but perhaps
- 5:18not to the degree that you would expect. Because
- 5:23I think part of what you're referencing right
- 5:25now is this popular understanding of the human
- 5:29species as unique still. This human exceptionalism
- 5:34that most people still subscribe to, even if
- 5:37on the surface they might say, well, actually
- 5:38people are just animals at the end of the day.
- 5:42They might say that on the surface, but I think
- 5:45subconsciously or perhaps ideologically, they
- 5:48still subscribe to this idea of humanity as being
- 5:52exceptional in some ways. So I think that's sort
- 5:55of what you're referencing. But I think once
- 5:57you start digging a little deeper, you see that
- 6:00actually both the theory and evolution and dinosaurs
- 6:05in particular, prehistory have actually shaped
- 6:09pockets of society to an incredible extent. So
- 6:16just to give you an example, right? One of the
- 6:19courses that I'm teaching, well, there's a course
- 6:21that I'm teaching right now. One of the texts
- 6:23that I asked my students to read is Heart of
- 6:25Darkness by Joseph Conrad, right? And there are...
- 6:29many references in that book to the theory of
- 6:33evolution. And the references are always made
- 6:39with an eye to how it informed scientific racism,
- 6:43right? So not all of the impact was good, obviously,
- 6:47right? I think people took Darwin's ideas and
- 6:50drew some conclusions that are misinformed. But
- 6:54it did shape a number of things or a number of
- 6:57historical developments to some extent, for example,
- 6:59colonialism, right? But it also shaped other
- 7:03things. So for instance, the way in which concepts
- 7:07from prehistory, paleontology, and particularly
- 7:11the concept of mass extinction. right? Which
- 7:16comes from deep time, which comes from paleontology,
- 7:19from our understanding of the earth now, as opposed
- 7:21to like 300 years ago when we still thought that
- 7:24maybe it was just a few thousand years old, right?
- 7:26So our understanding of deep time and the many
- 7:29prehistoric developments that led up to the origin
- 7:35of humankind and all that, I think that is something
- 7:39that again, perhaps only subconsciously and perhaps
- 7:43only a few people are actively talking about
- 7:45this, but it informs our understanding of today,
- 7:48right? So now today we talk a lot about things
- 7:51like global warming, for example, climate change,
- 7:53right? And part of that conversation is the concept
- 7:57of the sixth mass extinction, which is kind of
- 8:00the focus of my research in some ways. And, you
- 8:03know, mass extinctions are not, like that concept
- 8:07is not very old. It was first proposed in the
- 8:1070s. And for a couple of decades, it was essentially
- 8:14thought of as ridiculous. Because one of the
- 8:19things that Charles Darwin's theory of evolution
- 8:21proposed was that changes were gradual. They
- 8:24were slow. There were no catastrophes. And then
- 8:29suddenly come the Alvarez's. So Walter Alvarez
- 8:33and Luis Alvarez, based in California, they were
- 8:36the ones who first identified or the first proposed
- 8:40the theory of mass extinction, or rather the
- 8:45first explained the extinction of the dinosaurs
- 8:47as possibly being the result of this asteroid
- 8:50colliding. And they went around the world looking
- 8:53for evidence and they found it. And so I think
- 8:56with that comes this realization of just how
- 9:00even the most powerful species or the most powerful
- 9:03creatures on earth are vulnerable to extinction,
- 9:06right? And I think that sort of fear haunts society
- 9:10today because we're seeing catastrophic changes
- 9:13around the world. And I think subconsciously
- 9:16perhaps, right? We're thinking, well, if it happened
- 9:18to the dinosaurs, it could happen to us. And
- 9:21that fear, that specific way of thinking about
- 9:24humanity and our destiny is part of Jurassic
- 9:27Park, right? You might recall this scene. They're
- 9:30in the car, right? They're in the car and they're
- 9:32waiting for the T -Rex to show up. And they kind
- 9:35of jokingly talk about how God creates dinosaur,
- 9:39God kills dinosaurs, God creates people, people
- 9:43kill God. What is it? People create dinosaurs
- 9:46and then dinosaurs eat people, right? So they're
- 9:51making explicit what is sort of implicit in the
- 9:53movie and also in... in evolutionary biology,
- 9:56which is if it happened to the dinosaurs, it
- 9:58can happen to us, right? So I think in that sense,
- 10:02it did make a fairly big splash, but it's not
- 10:05perhaps the place or the credit that should be
- 10:10given to biological sciences, evolutionary sciences,
- 10:14and paleontology is not given, right? And that's
- 10:17why perhaps you have this impression of it not
- 10:19being all that prominent. But I think it's there.
- 10:23It's just It's kind of sneaky, right? But it's
- 10:28there, I think. Before getting into the movie
- 10:31itself and the topic of dinosaurs, I just want
- 10:34to address the question of their appearance.
- 10:37So as a kid, I always imagined them as being
- 10:41reptilian. And of course, I came across the articles
- 10:45talking about how, no, actually, T -rex might
- 10:49have had feathers and might have been those big
- 10:52chicken birds, you know. So what is your opinion
- 10:57on that? Or where is the science on that? I haven't,
- 11:01you know, checked. Did dinosaurs have feathers
- 11:05or not? Oh, yeah, I think the evidence has definitely
- 11:11piled up on the side of dinosaurs being essentially
- 11:17birds. One of them, one of the One of the moments
- 11:22that I remember most, I've been on earth since
- 11:28I was a kid, right? And so I collected National
- 11:33Geographic magazines from the time I was like
- 11:3610. I had a huge collection. I don't have it
- 11:39anymore, but at some point I had like volume
- 11:41for volume of National Geographic. And one of
- 11:43my favorite volumes was the one that announced
- 11:47the first discovery of a fossilized dinosaur
- 11:51that was so well preserved that you could see
- 11:54the traces of feathers on its body, right? And
- 11:57how people were, scientists were debating, are
- 12:00these actually feathers or is it maybe like some
- 12:03other structure on their skin or perhaps underneath
- 12:06their skin that kind of looks like feathers,
- 12:08right? But then after that original discovery,
- 12:13but now paleontology works in a rather funny
- 12:17way, right? You have to know where to look, but
- 12:19you can't know that in advance. So it was only
- 12:22once they realized where they could look for
- 12:24fossils that preserved what you call integument,
- 12:27right? The external structures of the animal.
- 12:29Once they knew where to look, they started looking
- 12:31there, right? And they started digging all over
- 12:34the place. And by now, I think the last time
- 12:37I checked was a couple of years ago, so I'm sure
- 12:39this is outdated, right? But at least 25 different
- 12:44species, many of them are known from many skeletons,
- 12:51not just one, right? Show distinct marks of feathers.
- 12:54And what's interesting is that these species
- 12:56are not all that closely related, right? Some
- 12:59of them are essentially just like little... chicken
- 13:04-looking thingies, right? And then there are
- 13:05some really big ones that are actually very closely
- 13:08related to T. rex, for example, right? And some
- 13:11that are even related to Triceratops. So now
- 13:13the question is not whether they had feathers,
- 13:16but rather how feathered were they depending
- 13:20on the species, right? So for example, the one
- 13:22that looks more like Triceratops, it only really
- 13:24has a few quails on its tail. So it might be
- 13:27that it only had feathers in certain parts of
- 13:29its body, right? But there were others that were
- 13:32essentially fully covered in feathers with like
- 13:34these incredible looking wings that are indistinguishable
- 13:38from the ones that birds have today, except that
- 13:40you can still see their fingers poking out, right?
- 13:44So, yeah, I mean, our perspective of them has
- 13:48changed. And with that, again, our understanding
- 13:50of what killed them, right? Or if something indeed
- 13:55could be said to have eliminated all dinosaurs,
- 13:58because if we understand that birds are dinosaurs,
- 14:01then perhaps the story shouldn't be about how
- 14:04they went extinct, but rather how they had to
- 14:08adapt, right? And I think in that, there is a
- 14:10lesson for us, right? Because we've been doing
- 14:13things a certain way for the better part of 500
- 14:16years, and I don't think it's working, right?
- 14:19So perhaps we shouldn't be striving to get ever
- 14:23bigger and greater and we shouldn't have this
- 14:26idea of like progress meaning bigger and grander
- 14:29things, but rather finding a way to persevere
- 14:35despite a changing landscape, right? I don't
- 14:39like the idea that dinosaurs had feathers. I
- 14:43really don't like that. It's the same. Can I
- 14:46ask you a question though? Because I think sometimes
- 14:49that is more the result of of people not liking
- 14:53birds in general. Something that I've learned
- 14:55is that a lot of people are afraid of birds.
- 14:59Would you say that that applies to you? Do they
- 15:01make you uncomfortable? No, I have a couple of
- 15:04birds, budgies that I take care of at home. I
- 15:10see their personality and how smart they are,
- 15:14and I have no difficulty imagining them being
- 15:18dinosaurs. They could have been part of that
- 15:23Jurassic Park franchise. They're just villains.
- 15:27They really are. But yeah, it's weird how it
- 15:33becomes distasteful for us to imagine those dinosaurs
- 15:38as having feathers. It's like the Greek statues
- 15:42having colors. Yeah, that's a good analogy. I
- 15:48think you get used to a certain mode of representation.
- 15:52And then when it changes, you don't like it.
- 15:54It's kind of like when people, as people get
- 15:56older, they find contemporary music less and
- 16:01less likable, right? Because it no longer resembles
- 16:03what you experienced as a child. And I think
- 16:06that's perhaps a part of it. I was resistant
- 16:08too. Like the first time that these discoveries
- 16:11kind of like became... the subject of popular
- 16:16culture, like through National Geographic, for
- 16:18example, or the first documentaries to show these
- 16:21CGI documentaries that show dinosaurs, right?
- 16:25I don't know if we're allowed to say brands,
- 16:27but there's a new one that came out, and they're
- 16:31covered in feathers. And I also thought, that
- 16:33doesn't feel right. So I know where you're coming
- 16:38from, but I do think that I prefer the other
- 16:43perspective that you offered, right? Looking
- 16:44at your birds, for example, your budgies and
- 16:47thinking, huh, that's something dinosaurs might
- 16:51have done, right? Here in Edmonton, recently
- 16:55there was a vote to choose the city's official
- 17:02bird, right? And everybody just kind of agreed
- 17:06that it had to be the magpie. There are magpies
- 17:08everywhere. This is magpie country. And they
- 17:11are vicious. They are some of the most vicious
- 17:14birds I've ever seen. And I've seen all kinds
- 17:17of birds in the wild. I once had the fortune
- 17:21of seeing an osprey diving into, I think it was
- 17:24a river, and actually catching a fish and flying
- 17:28off with it. And that was incredible. But there
- 17:30is something about a gang of magpies piling up
- 17:34on a rabbit that really feels prehistoric, right?
- 17:38I immediately picture Velociraptors on a Triceratops
- 17:41or something, right? And it's crazy, because
- 17:43MacPies are not that big, right? And the Jackrabbits
- 17:46here, they're pretty big. They don't care. They
- 17:49gang up on them. Alright, they pick them. I'm
- 17:52not sure they actually hunt them. I don't know
- 17:54why they harass them So but they do and they're
- 17:57fearless, right? They actually gang up on my
- 17:58cat You would think a cat would you know would
- 18:01drive him away, but no they they they get together
- 18:04They form these little packs And I swear it's
- 18:07just like that scene in Jurassic Park at the
- 18:10end, right? When the kids and the two paleontologists
- 18:15are together and the raptors are approaching,
- 18:17right? That's my cat's experience on an everyday
- 18:20basis. He's surrounded by magpies and he has
- 18:23nowhere to run. And he doesn't have a T -rex
- 18:25to save him. Yes, they're completely fearless.
- 18:30And there's also the fact that birds with their
- 18:34feathers I associate that with like grace and
- 18:38there's something very artistic very you know
- 18:42it's something that civilized that's something
- 18:46very you know it's the um it's what you see on
- 18:52the um you know hats of nobles from you know
- 18:57the middle ages that kind of thing so the idea
- 19:02of a bloodthirsty creature with feathers, you
- 19:06know, it's, it doesn't have that primitive trait
- 19:11that reptiles to, you know, you look at reptiles
- 19:15and you think, yeah, this is from another era.
- 19:19Yeah, yeah, that is true. And I think, again,
- 19:22right, I think that's where a lot of that resistance
- 19:24comes from, because because I think there is
- 19:28something primeval about leathery scaly skin.
- 19:33At least we perceive it that way. And you're
- 19:35right, feathers were traditionally associated
- 19:38with the aristocracy, for example. But again,
- 19:42I think it sort of depends on what your perception
- 19:46of birds is and how well -informed it is. And
- 19:49again, I remember this scene in Jurassic Park
- 19:51when Alan Grant, the paleontologist, is trying
- 19:54to explain to this kid how vicious raptors were,
- 19:57when he scares the crap out of that kid. And
- 20:00it all starts because the kid says, well, it
- 20:02doesn't look very scary. It's just like a turkey,
- 20:04right? And now when I go back and watch that
- 20:09scene, I think, well, that kid has never met
- 20:11a turkey because turkeys are vicious animals,
- 20:14right? We think of them. Unfortunately, we associate
- 20:18them with things like Thanksgiving dinner, right?
- 20:21Because we've commodified them and we've exploited
- 20:23them. And in that process, we've made them very
- 20:28tame. The more, the wilder turkeys, right? Not
- 20:34even necessarily just like wild turkeys, but
- 20:37varieties of turkeys that have not been so thoroughly
- 20:39domesticated. They're vicious animals and they're
- 20:42big, right? They're very big birds that because
- 20:46they're ground dwelling, they have to come up
- 20:48with other kinds of defenses, right? They can't
- 20:51just stay cuff and fly. They do fly, but that's
- 20:53a last resort, right? Their first resort is to
- 20:56be intimidating. And so they puff up, they puff
- 21:00their feathers, they start making all these really
- 21:02weird noises, and they'll charge at you. So again,
- 21:06it sort of depends on how you look at birds and
- 21:08how you look at animals in general. There are
- 21:11things that we associate with animals that are
- 21:14not necessarily true. And I think one of them
- 21:16is unfortunately because of them. long -standing
- 21:20commodification of certain body parts, certain
- 21:22animal parts. We think of feathers as aristocratic
- 21:25and fanciful, but in reality, you know, they
- 21:28have a distinct evolutionary purpose, actually
- 21:32multiple purposes, and one of them can be intimidation,
- 21:35right? And I think there's something very scary
- 21:37about a bird that puffs up and starts making
- 21:40all these weird noises, right? Sometimes they
- 21:43hiss, right? Here we have like Canadian goose.
- 21:46or Canada goose, I think is the right term, right?
- 21:48Canada goose are scary birds, right? And you
- 21:51look at it and it's like, it looks kind of cute.
- 21:53It's just like a big duck, but they're vicious,
- 21:56right? They're vicious animals. And I think,
- 21:58you know, getting over some of those misconceptions
- 21:59might help you accept feathered dinosaurs, although
- 22:03maybe not, right? Yes. And that brings me to
- 22:07an iconic scene in Jurassic Park, which is the
- 22:11raptors hunting those children. brother and sister
- 22:17in the kitchen. And what is the most frightening
- 22:23in that scene is not so much their appearance,
- 22:26which is frightening, but their intelligence.
- 22:31That's what the scene tells us. Those killing
- 22:36machines, those really scary looking beasts are
- 22:43intelligent. They understand that you're trying
- 22:45to run away and they can visualize and project
- 22:49and make plans to catch you. And that is the
- 22:53most, the scariest part. What do you make of
- 22:55that? First of all, is it even accurate that
- 22:58they had that degree of intelligence? And then
- 23:02what do you make of how they highlight the intelligence
- 23:07as being the scary part? Yeah, you know, that's
- 23:11a really good question. It's something that I
- 23:12hoped that we could discuss today because I think,
- 23:18I cannot speak to the accuracy of it because
- 23:21I'm also, first off, I'm not a paleontologist,
- 23:24right? I study these things from a cultural perspective.
- 23:28I know that in terms of how paleontologists gauge
- 23:33the intelligence of an animal, usually they go,
- 23:36or the traditional method was not all that different
- 23:38from what zoologists have traditionally done,
- 23:41which is they look at a skull, they look at the
- 23:44brain cavity in that skull, and they say, well,
- 23:46you know, this one's bigger than the other, presumably
- 23:48this animal is smarter than the other, right?
- 23:51Has more cognitive abilities in some ways. And
- 23:54so when that scene was made and I've actually
- 24:00spoken to Jack Horner, who was the paleontological
- 24:03advisor for Jurassic Park. So when they made
- 24:07that scene, what they wanted to emphasize is
- 24:10that, because these animals are big, some of
- 24:16these Drameosaurus, the raptors, some of the
- 24:19raptors were as big as the ones portrayed in
- 24:21Jurassic Park, they had big brains. Like Drameosaurus
- 24:25as a whole family was, they generally had big
- 24:29brain cavities in their skulls, and so people
- 24:32or paleontologists assumed that they were smarter
- 24:34than most dinosaurs, and this particular species
- 24:38that was as big as a human did have a fairly
- 24:41big brain, right? So the assumption was, well,
- 24:45okay, so if it has a brain as big as that of
- 24:47a chimp, then perhaps it's as smart as a chimp,
- 24:49right? Now, there was a lot of pushback against
- 24:52that from the paleontological community saying
- 24:54that, well, you know, these are not... Chimps
- 24:57these are not apes these are not mammals these
- 24:59are at the time right they were still seen as
- 25:01primarily reptilian even though already there
- 25:04are some hints of the fact that they are birds
- 25:06in Jurassic Park right. So they thought well
- 25:09it might have had a big brain but so do turtles
- 25:12like some leatherback turtles have fairly big
- 25:14brains and they're not particularly smart right.
- 25:17Alright so now that our understanding of them
- 25:19has changed and now we see them more as birds
- 25:22I think. the trajectory has sort of shifted,
- 25:26right? In the sense that, well, recognizing that
- 25:30there are birds and perhaps puts them, you know,
- 25:32you can look at a raptor skull and then perhaps
- 25:36a bird that's of similar size, like say, I don't
- 25:39know, an ostrich maybe, right? Although I think
- 25:41ostriches have fairly small heads. And you can
- 25:43think, well, perhaps it was as smart as an ostrich,
- 25:45right? Or perhaps a little smarter than that.
- 25:48But even that is changing now because now we
- 25:51know that when it comes to avian birds or the
- 25:54birds of brains, size doesn't matter as much
- 25:58as we used to think, right? You have budgies,
- 26:01so you have essentially parrots, right? Parrots
- 26:06as a whole don't have particularly big brains,
- 26:09but they're insanely smart. Some species more
- 26:14than others, traditionally experiments on avian
- 26:16intelligence have been done with African gray
- 26:18parrots, which are like these fairly big sized
- 26:21gray parrots from Central Africa, right? And
- 26:24I mean, they're incredibly smart, right? They
- 26:28can figure out puzzles, they can... some studies
- 26:32suggest that they do actually understand human
- 26:34speech. Like they understand the correlation
- 26:36between sound and meaning, right? And so you
- 26:38can teach them basic grammatical constructs to
- 26:41communicate and they seem to do a very good job
- 26:43at it, right? So if a bird that's the size of
- 26:47a crow, right, is potentially that smart with
- 26:50a brain that's not that big, how smart could
- 26:54dinosaurs have been? Who knows, right? Because
- 26:57again, other other birds that perhaps behave
- 27:00more like a raptor would, like magpies, crows,
- 27:03ravens, right? Corvids are now understood as
- 27:06perhaps even smarter than parrots. And again,
- 27:10brains that are not that big, and still they
- 27:14have cognitive abilities that we now think are
- 27:18at least as powerful as those of great apes,
- 27:23right? And there is a big difference between
- 27:25a chimp, which is the size of a person, essentially,
- 27:29and a raven, which is no bigger than a cat with
- 27:31a brain that's no bigger than a cat's, but that
- 27:33seems to be as intelligent as great apes. So
- 27:37brain size, that is to say, doesn't really seem
- 27:40to matter when it comes to birds. It's more about
- 27:42the wiring of the brain and how densely packed
- 27:46their neurons are. So it is entirely possible.
- 27:51Not to say that that is accurate, but I think
- 27:54it is entirely possible that large predatory
- 27:58dinosaurs in that family, the Dromaeosaurs, the
- 28:00Trudonids, the Raptors, may have been as intelligent
- 28:04as they are depicted. Of course, this is all
- 28:06conjecture and it's impossible to figure out,
- 28:09but I don't think it's beyond the realm of possibility.
- 28:11Because if we now understand that birds like
- 28:14parrots and crows and ravens are as smart as
- 28:17a five -year -old, but... but with predatory
- 28:20instincts, who knows what they could have accomplished,
- 28:23right? I mean, I don't know if you've been around
- 28:26a lot of kids in your life, like if you have
- 28:28nephews or kids or whatever, right? But five
- 28:30-year -olds are smart and they don't have a moral
- 28:32compass, so they're quite predatory. So imagine
- 28:36a pack of creatures that are as big as a human,
- 28:41but with predatory instincts. no not necessarily
- 28:44a moral compass and you know and and as intelligent
- 28:47as that and I think you know what what you see
- 28:49in that scene right uh coordinated behavior um
- 28:53you know a theory of mind right because I think
- 28:57that's perhaps one of the main things that I
- 28:59identify in those depictions of the raptors that
- 29:01they have a theory of mind that they understand
- 29:03what others are thinking right we know that birds
- 29:05can do that to some extent now so Is it possible
- 29:08i think it's entirely possible do we know no
- 29:10and we can't find out right but but i think it's
- 29:14fun to think about. But why is it scary because
- 29:19we're used to being top dog right i think and
- 29:23again i return to that scene with the kid and
- 29:27actually later scenes. That sort of suggest how
- 29:31uncomfortable we are with we are with them. with
- 29:34predation once the tables are turned. I think,
- 29:38unfortunately, we have become accustomed to this
- 29:44idea of us being the undisputed top of the food
- 29:48chain or however you want to understand it. And
- 29:51that's, again, that's also where the assumption
- 29:55that we can treat animals the way that we do
- 29:57in Western societies comes from, right? If we're
- 30:00a tough dog, we can do whatever we want because
- 30:01we want the evolutionary race or whatever, right?
- 30:04But in scenes like those in Jurassic Park, there
- 30:07are two things going on. So one is that these
- 30:10were actual animals that at some point existed,
- 30:12right? And that we're at some point as dominant
- 30:15as we are today. And the other is that when you
- 30:20put us face to face without all of our technological
- 30:23barriers, we would lose. We would be the prey.
- 30:27And that makes us deeply uncomfortable because
- 30:29that is not something we've experienced for 10
- 30:31,000 years now. So I think that's part of it.
- 30:35That's a big part of it, if you ask me. And later
- 30:38in the movie there, there are some references
- 30:40to how that turning of the tables makes you reconsider
- 30:45some choices. I go back to the scene that happens
- 30:48right after right after they witness how they
- 30:54feed the raptors. I don't know if you remember,
- 30:55they have this big cow, right? And they lower
- 30:58it into the pen and then they don't even show
- 31:00it, you just hear it, right? And you see their
- 31:02facial expressions and the scene then cuts to
- 31:06them having lunch and they get served fish, I
- 31:10believe, or some sort of meat. right? And they
- 31:12can't stomach it anymore, right? Because they
- 31:15realize what, well, I think my understanding
- 31:18of that scene is not only that they realize that
- 31:20they're essentially doing the same thing as they're
- 31:22after us, but also I think if there is perhaps
- 31:25a bit of empathy on their faces for the cow,
- 31:28right? How is what they're doing any different,
- 31:30right? And then how is what the dinosaurs do
- 31:32to them later on any different? So I think there
- 31:35are some There are instances in the film where
- 31:38it does kind of challenge some philosophical
- 31:41assumptions that we make on an everyday basis
- 31:43about our position within the natural world and
- 31:46also our treatment of other species. In the movie
- 31:50where they rescue the boy from that dinosaur
- 31:54island, there's this scene where they're stuck
- 32:02in that cage for flying dinosaurs. And in that
- 32:07scene, it is highlighted how flying dinosaurs
- 32:11are just those scary creatures, truly. But then
- 32:18at the end of the movie, they are in a plane
- 32:22or a helicopter, I don't remember, leaving for
- 32:27good the island. And then they see a pack of
- 32:30those flying dinosaurs in the horizon. And the
- 32:36whole scene is made to symbolize hope around
- 32:41those flying dinosaurs, flying in the horizon.
- 32:46And it feels like a moment of hope or dreamy
- 32:50moment. And I kept thinking, they should have
- 32:56been panicking from looking at that pack of flying
- 33:01dinosaurs escaping the island. What do you make
- 33:06of that scene? Why did they coded the scene as,
- 33:09you know, something hopeful? Yeah. So the first
- 33:14thing that I would say is the third movie is
- 33:16full of questionable decisions, right? So perhaps
- 33:20perhaps part of it is just the fact that that
- 33:23movie was not that well thought out. But, you
- 33:27know, let's give them the benefit of the doubt
- 33:29and assume that they were trying to suggest something,
- 33:32right? Which is often the case in films, right?
- 33:34There's some sort of message. There's a point
- 33:37to everything that happens. And I think one way
- 33:40of understanding that may have to do with the
- 33:45question of captivity, right? Which is also implicit
- 33:49in the first movie. So, and actually much more
- 33:53implicit in the book, but let us not speak of
- 33:56the book. So one of my favorite books, and I
- 34:05read it only recently, so it's titled Fear of
- 34:08the Animal Planet by Jason Prible. I don't know
- 34:12if you've ever heard of it. So Fear of the Animal
- 34:14Planet is this attempt to bring out this hidden
- 34:19history of animal resistance, right? And what
- 34:23he means by that is that There are many instances
- 34:26throughout history where either individual animals
- 34:30or packs of animals or groups of animals seem
- 34:32to have come to this sort of breaking point,
- 34:35right? Where they push back against what could
- 34:42be characterized as some form of oppression,
- 34:44right? To give you an example, you might recall
- 34:48the film Blackfish. about Tillicum, about the
- 34:52orca that was in captivity for so many years
- 34:54in horrible conditions. And it became murderous.
- 34:58I think that's the way it is described in the
- 35:01documentary. And the implication there is that
- 35:05that sort of behavior was a consequence of the
- 35:09way that it was treated. Now, if you look at
- 35:12Jurassic Park and its portrayal of some of the
- 35:15animals, admittedly not all of them, and I think,
- 35:17again, this has something to do with the fact
- 35:18that at the end of the day, it is a Hollywood
- 35:20movie, so it has to just be entertaining. But
- 35:24let's focus on the scene that you brought up.
- 35:28I mean, the animals in that scene, the flying
- 35:33pterosaurs, they... They are amongst the last
- 35:38creatures in captivity on that island, right?
- 35:40They're still in that cage. And animals that
- 35:44are incarcerated like that are usually fiercely
- 35:47territorial, right? Because, well, their territory
- 35:51is tiny. They don't have a lot. And so they're
- 35:54not going to tolerate any other creature that
- 35:57might compete with them for the very limited
- 35:59space and resources that they already have. At
- 36:04the end of the movie, they escaped partly because
- 36:07the people that went through there left the gate
- 36:08open, I think is what happens, right? And so
- 36:11they escape and they fly off. I think it would
- 36:14be fairly safe to assume, right? That just like
- 36:17a rehabilitated tiger, right? Maybe highly aggressive
- 36:22in the cage, but won't necessarily go out and
- 36:25try to kill people when it's released back into
- 36:27the wild, right? An animal like this, a pterosaur.
- 36:32regardless of how big it is, right? If it has
- 36:35a certain innate behavior, like pterosaurs who
- 36:40are most likely fish eaters, at least that the
- 36:42species depicted there are most likely fed on
- 36:44fish or carcasses, right? And it's no longer
- 36:47in this situation in which it has to be highly
- 36:51aggressive. Then I think perhaps you can assume
- 36:54that it's not going to be that aggressive once
- 36:56it's released back into the wild, right? That
- 36:58it will hopefully I think that's perhaps where
- 37:01the hope comes from, that it will revert back
- 37:04to its more quote unquote natural behavior, which
- 37:06is not as aggressive as it is in a cage, right?
- 37:10That's something that I've, I think a lot of
- 37:12people have experienced this to some degree in
- 37:15zoos, right? When they go to the aviaries, like
- 37:18the one depicted in Jurassic Park 3 and in the
- 37:21book, you go to an aviary and the birds there,
- 37:24are all over you, right? They flutter all around
- 37:27you, and that is just a consequence of their
- 37:29very limited space, right? Birds in the wild
- 37:32generally don't fly at you, generally. There
- 37:35are exceptions, but generally speaking, birds
- 37:37are not going to fly at you in the wild, but
- 37:39when they're in a confined space competing for
- 37:42resources on an everyday basis, and they don't
- 37:45get to engage in the sort of behavior they would
- 37:48when they're free, then I think that's kind of
- 37:52what happens, right? So yeah, that's perhaps
- 37:55the way that I would read it. And this is something
- 37:56I used to teach Jurassic Park as part of my introductory
- 38:00courses to critical analysis. And one thing that
- 38:03I always brought up is the fact that at the end
- 38:06of the day, right, Jurassic Park is a zoo. And
- 38:09so I think a lot of what happens in that film
- 38:12can be thought of as commentary to the way that
- 38:15The kind of behavior that that that people that
- 38:18the industrialists and the capitalists and that
- 38:20film engage in which is the commodification of
- 38:22life forms and such it's a direct critique of
- 38:26Zoos, right? Um, so that's perhaps one way to
- 38:30think about it that perhaps the hope is not,
- 38:32you know People hope but hope for the animals
- 38:36to find a better life, right? That's an interesting
- 38:41point you're bringing up and I want to get back
- 38:45to it. But first, since starting this conversation,
- 38:50we have been pretty, I guess the word is direct
- 38:55and honest about animal behaviors. Something
- 38:59I don't see very often with, you know, communication
- 39:05around animals and veganism and the type of stuff
- 39:11activists say to the public so for instance they
- 39:15will highlight how chickens are incredibly smart
- 39:19they're so smart they can do this and that and
- 39:22they're also very cute and but of course if you
- 39:26ever had chickens you know that it's not the
- 39:29whole story and there's this tendency for activists
- 39:35to just exaggerate reality to make animals into
- 39:39a cuter, smarter version than what they really
- 39:45are. What do you make of that manipulation of
- 39:51how we see animals? Yeah, that's a really good
- 39:56question. I think with most of the conversations
- 40:02that go around or that have really on any topic,
- 40:06but in regards to animals, animal liberation,
- 40:09animal rights, and just our understanding of
- 40:13our relationship with animals, I think there
- 40:15are multiple sides to the story. The ones that
- 40:20come to mind are... Well, there's... What I would
- 40:28understand is two sides of a spectrum, right?
- 40:30So on the one hand, it's the... the utilitarian
- 40:33activist perspective of this, which is we understand
- 40:39what people find appealing. We've known this
- 40:42for a while. If for now the reason that we see
- 40:47it in the domestication of certain animals, we
- 40:49seem to find certain features and certain characteristics
- 40:52quite endearing. Amongst them, of course, is
- 40:55intelligence. We do value intelligence above
- 40:58all else because of, you may call it narcissism.
- 41:02But it's because that's what we have. We as a
- 41:05species became this hegemonic, this prominent,
- 41:09because of our intelligence, not because we're
- 41:11faster or stronger or whatever. We use that different
- 41:14kind of scale. And so we value when we recognize
- 41:18that skill in other creatures. And so from an
- 41:21activist perspective, it's just a matter of efficiency.
- 41:24If we know that people respond to certain characteristics,
- 41:28like intelligence and cuteness, then anthropomorphizing
- 41:33animals in a way that makes them resemble us
- 41:37more is a viable, a very viable strategy, right?
- 41:42And I think it works really well in that regard
- 41:44because, yeah, I mean, again, it's just what
- 41:48people seem to respond to. Now, the other side
- 41:51of that perspective or, you know, the counterpoint
- 41:54is that philosophically speaking and in terms
- 41:58of you know, if you're playing the long game
- 42:02kind of thing, the ongoing prioritization of
- 42:08certain characteristics that we associate with
- 42:11ourselves, right, is not a long -term solution
- 42:15because what it does is it continues, it perpetuates
- 42:19the hierarchy that exists. It just kind of extends
- 42:22it, right? So... Whereas before we used to think
- 42:27that perhaps only people should have rights,
- 42:30then we kind of expand that circle like Peter
- 42:34Singer puts it, right? We expand that circle
- 42:36and now chimps and whales and animals that think
- 42:40like us can fit in there, right? But then we're
- 42:43like, well, actually, you know, we see that some
- 42:45of those characteristics are also in chickens
- 42:47and cows and such. So we expand that circle a
- 42:50little bit more. But I think the problem with
- 42:52that sort of approach is that there are always
- 42:54going to be life forms that are excluded from
- 43:02that circle, right? And I think you don't even
- 43:05necessarily need to look at other species. One
- 43:07of my favorite philosophers is Kerry Wolf, who's
- 43:11written on philosophical understandings of animality
- 43:15and such, right? And one sort of like thought
- 43:20experiment that he proposes is that, okay, so
- 43:22like, if you decide that to grant rights to a
- 43:27life form, it must fulfill certain cognitive
- 43:31capacities, right? It must demonstrate that it
- 43:34has certain cognitive capacities, that its intelligence
- 43:37levels are at a certain threshold, right? You
- 43:40can easily look and find people who, because
- 43:44of disabilities, or genetic conditions or whatever
- 43:49are not going to meet that threshold, right?
- 43:52So it kind of shows you the limits of that approach,
- 43:54right? And likewise with animals, I think, anthropomorphizing
- 43:58chickens or pigs like in the movie, babe, right?
- 44:02It can be a very effective method of getting
- 44:04people to think about how we're actually not
- 44:07that different, right? And that perhaps we should
- 44:09give them... more consideration, that we should
- 44:12think more about the way that we relate to other
- 44:14creatures and other species. But I do think there
- 44:17are limits to that approach. So, you know, it's...
- 44:24I can't tell you whether I think it's... Or rather,
- 44:30I can tell you that I don't think it's the most
- 44:31effective way to go about this in the long run,
- 44:34right? That I think true animal liberation calls
- 44:40for a complete reconceptualization of what we
- 44:42value, right? And so focusing on cuteness or
- 44:47intelligence is not the long -term solution,
- 44:49but I think I do see the benefit of making gains
- 44:54wherever we can, right? Because I also understand
- 44:56the situation is dire. So, yeah, I guess I kind
- 45:00of oscillate between those two positions. I mean,
- 45:05not only that, but there are other people speaking
- 45:10to the general public, people who are pro, let's
- 45:15say people who are anti -vegan, pro -hunting,
- 45:18pro -this, pro -that, and they say, hey, those
- 45:21vegans don't know what you're talking about.
- 45:23Those vegans are city people who have never had
- 45:27a chicken, who have never met a goose or something.
- 45:31Um, and what they're talking about is, it's just
- 45:35bullshit. You know, let me show you a few videos
- 45:38of, uh, chickens hunting a mouse. Um, and look
- 45:43at how cute they really are. So no, you know,
- 45:47don't trust them. And so we've put ourselves
- 45:50in that position, my, I guess, in a way, lying
- 45:53to people. Yeah. Yeah. I think you're right.
- 45:55By the way, one of, um, You just reminded me
- 45:58that there is this really short, I think it's
- 46:00one of those TikTok videos, right, that I really
- 46:03appreciated, which was, it was a chicken, I believe
- 46:07hunting a mouse or some small rodent, right?
- 46:12But it was over, like the video played over the
- 46:17Jurassic Park soundtrack, which I thought was
- 46:19brilliant, right? Because yeah, I mean, that's
- 46:21essentially what you're watching. Yeah, you're
- 46:27right. I think that's something that I overlooked
- 46:28just now, but it's a perfectly valid point, which
- 46:30is that it also kind of makes some of these arguments
- 46:34less convincing to the people who perhaps do
- 46:38spend time with these animals, perhaps not under
- 46:42the most ethical conditions, but who understand
- 46:44their behavior perhaps a little bit better, or
- 46:46at least they understand it well enough to see
- 46:48that some of the anthropomorphizing that goes
- 46:51on in these campaigns is just flawed, right?
- 46:53It has no basis on reality. You're absolutely
- 46:56right. And I think that's a perfectly valid point
- 46:58to make. Although I would also counter that perhaps
- 47:02there is very little you can say to a hunter
- 47:06in my experience that will sway them, right?
- 47:09Because perhaps they're also the ones that are
- 47:11going to be hardest to convince because their
- 47:14relationship with animals It's long standing,
- 47:19usually people having hunting for years or since
- 47:21they were little, right? So they become desensitized
- 47:24to it. And so perhaps they're the last people
- 47:26you should be worried about because they're the
- 47:28last ones you're going to convince of anything
- 47:30at all, right? Recently, I was following this
- 47:33conversation around the Calgary Stampede, which
- 47:36is one of the biggest rodeos in North America,
- 47:39right? And there were people protesting in Calgary.
- 47:43And they were protesting the exploitation of
- 47:46animals in the rodeo, and rodeos in general,
- 47:48but specifically at the Calgary Stampede. And
- 47:51some of the cowboys, I guess you would call them,
- 47:56the actual people participating in the rodeo,
- 48:00released a number of statements or went on YouTube
- 48:03and TikTok and such to try to clarify some things.
- 48:06But there was this one particular video that
- 48:09stuck with me, which was, again, one of these
- 48:11cowboys. talking about how they were justified
- 48:17in their treatment of animals. First off, because
- 48:21otherwise most of these horses would be slaughtered
- 48:23since they have no use. And second, because this
- 48:28is just their culture, right? This is the culture
- 48:30of the place and that people who come to this
- 48:32place should, and I believe the phrasing was
- 48:35verbatim. They should learn to enjoy it like
- 48:38everyone else. And I thought it was very telling
- 48:40because that's exactly what happened to that
- 48:42person and everyone else, right? They learned
- 48:45to enjoy it because since they were little, they
- 48:48were indoctrinated into thinking that this is
- 48:51actually something that they're justified in
- 48:53doing, right? And so they learned that this is
- 48:56a valid form of entertainment, right? On learning
- 48:58that, it's complicated, right? So so I don't
- 49:05think that people who are deeply entrenched in
- 49:08a certain subculture That has a particular relationship
- 49:11to animals like hunter and prey or cowboy and
- 49:15cow, right? I do not think they're the first
- 49:18people we should go after because frankly, right
- 49:21they are the people that are the least open to
- 49:24these arguments and second They are in some ways
- 49:27a minority, right? Most people today don't hunt
- 49:30most people today don't ride horses for fun or,
- 49:34you know, engage in all these rodeo practices
- 49:35for fun. I think that's safe to say that most
- 49:38people don't do that, right? What most people
- 49:40do is they go to the supermarket and buy meat,
- 49:43right? They go to the supermarket and buy chicken
- 49:45wings and steaks and eggs and such. And I think
- 49:49those are the people that we should be thinking
- 49:50about because they're the ones who have not been
- 49:54indoctrinated like that, right, to that particular
- 49:56relationship with animality, but rather they
- 50:00are blind to the fact that these are animals.
- 50:03There is no direct relationship between the animal
- 50:07and their everyday life because that has been,
- 50:10well, cut off through the processes of modernization
- 50:14and consumerism and what have you. They don't
- 50:17have a direct relationship with the animal. So
- 50:20in that case, I think establishing that direct
- 50:22relationship is important. And then perhaps,
- 50:24again, that's when you can think of anthropomorphizing
- 50:27as a somewhat valid way or a fairly valid device
- 50:33through which you can kind of start developing
- 50:35a more direct relationship with an animal that
- 50:38is not based on consumerism. Yes, you're you're
- 50:42very right about that. You remind me this morning,
- 50:45I was reading an article from Big Ang. It was
- 50:51titled debunking anti meat lies or something
- 50:55like that. And it started with Do you remember
- 51:00every Sunday the barbecue in summer, you know,
- 51:03the family and it was just, you know, building
- 51:07the foundations of the pados, the, you know,
- 51:11the nostalgia, because that's all they have,
- 51:15you know, they don't have concrete arguments
- 51:19to present. So they have to rely on the conditioning
- 51:23of people. Yeah. Yeah. Okay, so let's get back
- 51:28to Jurassic Park. And you mentioned a few moments
- 51:34ago how it was a critique of Zoo. And I agree
- 51:39with that. At the same time, I think this movie
- 51:45franchise has prepared the ground for a new market,
- 51:51which is the market of resuscitating animals
- 51:56that have been extinct for some time centuries.
- 52:01And I'm talking here about Colossal, the biotech
- 52:05company that has, you know, created those, what
- 52:10would they call them? Mice, mammoth mice, something
- 52:14like that. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, that was
- 52:17Yeah, I remember that. I thought you were talking
- 52:19about the dire wolves. But yeah, before that
- 52:21came the mammoth mouse. Yes, the mammoth mouse.
- 52:24I don't know what they called it. But the dire
- 52:27wolves, they also resuscitated the dire wolves
- 52:30and they want to do the same with mammoths and
- 52:33woolly mammoths. And at some point, they hope
- 52:38to do it with dinosaurs. So recreate basically
- 52:42Jurassic Park. Yeah. What do you make of that?
- 52:46Yeah. Well, first off, I would go back to this
- 52:49other podcast that I used to listen to. And I
- 52:54remember that it was structured around problems
- 52:57and solutions, right? Like social problems and
- 52:59solutions to those problems. And this one time,
- 53:05one of the podcasters brought up genetic engineering
- 53:08as a solution, right? And those two were always
- 53:12bickering and that was the format of the podcast.
- 53:14So the other person went out and found a counter
- 53:18argument to genetic engineering. And this stuck
- 53:22with me because I thought it was, well, I found
- 53:27it hilarious first off, but also it's so on point,
- 53:30right? So he starts reading this FAQ. section
- 53:40from a company that genetically engineered a
- 53:46certain kind of salmon to grow faster and produce
- 53:51more meat and supposedly lower its environmental
- 53:54impact. And he's reading the answer to one of
- 53:58the FAQs. And the question was, how do you make
- 54:04sure that these salmon do not contaminate the
- 54:09genetic diversity of wild salmon? And the answer
- 54:13was all of our salmon have been genetically engineered
- 54:17to precisely with this in mind. So they're all
- 54:20female and kind of reproduced in the wild. And
- 54:22the guy on the podcast, he says, man, this is
- 54:26the plot to Jurassic Park, right? Like, how did
- 54:29they, someone on ironically wrote this and did
- 54:32not realize that they're essentially making the
- 54:34same mistakes they make in Jurassic Park, right?
- 54:37And I think that that is so telling because you
- 54:43can have films, right? And one of the reasons
- 54:45why I love narratives, right? Why I love stories
- 54:48is because of the fact that, and everybody knows
- 54:52this, right? They have a message, they have a
- 54:53moral, right? And I think in regards to Jurassic
- 54:56Park, there are a number of messages, there are
- 54:58a number of critiques and questions of morality,
- 55:02right? And one of them is precisely like what
- 55:04happens when you, temper with the very fabric
- 55:07of life, right? And I think that's not a new
- 55:09question. It's in many ways a re -imagination
- 55:11of Frankenstein, for example, right? Prometheus
- 55:14in some ways is also kind of related to those
- 55:16questions, right? But what's interesting to me
- 55:19is that we have these cultural texts that tell
- 55:25us perhaps we shouldn't play God, right? We shouldn't
- 55:28be messing around with things that we do not
- 55:30really understand. We shouldn't just like...
- 55:33as Malcolm puts it, right? We should ask whether
- 55:36we should before we ask whether we can. And I
- 55:41think unfortunately now we see it, like the technology
- 55:44has gotten to the point where some of the sciences
- 55:49in Jurassic Park are now potentially a reality,
- 55:52right? And we have companies like Colossal that
- 55:56do it not with the explicit purpose of of making
- 56:00a product, at least not yet. They're not unlike
- 56:03this salmon corporation. They did not have mammoth
- 56:09fillets or whatever mammoth steaks in mind. They
- 56:11were not making a product they would sell for
- 56:13people's consumption just yet. But I think we
- 56:16can assume that is the goal. At some point, people
- 56:20who are working on the Pleistocene Park, for
- 56:22example, in Siberia. They have explicitly talked
- 56:25about the possibility of opening up hunting within
- 56:28this reserve as a way of generating revenue,
- 56:31because otherwise they cannot perpetually rely
- 56:34on grants, for example. So I do think that at
- 56:39the end of the day, because all these corporations
- 56:42are corporations that operate within a capitalist
- 56:44system, whether the explicit purpose of it is
- 56:49to generate revenue or not, they have to, right?
- 56:52They're in a position where they have no choice
- 56:54and so ultimately what this will result in is
- 56:57the further commodification of life forms that,
- 57:01you know, have essentially no rights because
- 57:05as they say in Jurassic Park, a genetically engineered
- 57:09form of life that was created has no rights.
- 57:11It's property, right? It's intellectual property
- 57:13according to the law and so it'll be understood
- 57:15that way and it's only going to perpetuate the
- 57:18system in which we do not give any ethical consideration
- 57:22to creatures that are not us because of whatever
- 57:25excuse we can think of, one of them being, well,
- 57:27we created it, so, you know, we own it. Now,
- 57:31having said that, I think colossal is particularly
- 57:34insidious, right? Because not only does it do
- 57:37this, but in addition to that, they lie about
- 57:39it, right? As you might know, the dire wolf is
- 57:43not a different kind of wolf. It's just a regular
- 57:46old gray wolf. which is an endangered species
- 57:49in some jurisdictions that was genetically modified.
- 57:56I don't understand to what extent, but I know
- 57:59that the purpose of that modification was to
- 58:02make it resemble a dire wolf. You have to question
- 58:08whether there's any scientific merit to that.
- 58:10Again, the only real reason I see to do this
- 58:14is to to show that you can, there is no real
- 58:19merit in it because you're not bringing back
- 58:21an extinct species. Not really. This isn't the
- 58:23extinction. It's genetic modification of a species
- 58:27that is in many places protected by law. And
- 58:30we can talk about the merits of conservation
- 58:33and all that stuff, but at the end of the day,
- 58:35it's just experimentation. It's experimentation
- 58:38on a creature that is intelligent, that is sentient,
- 58:43that I think we should value for purposes that
- 58:46are not just entertainment or almost whimsical,
- 58:51right? How can you do this? Oh, yes, we can.
- 58:53Look at this. Here it is. But so what, right?
- 58:56It doesn't accomplish anything. Now they're thinking
- 58:58about all their, they've talked about all their
- 59:00species, right? There's a Tasmanian tiger, which
- 59:03I think if they manage to clone something like
- 59:07a Tasmanian tiger, I think... then the conversation
- 59:10becomes a little more serious, right? Because
- 59:12that is a highly distinct species that you can't
- 59:15just take another marsupial and modify it into
- 59:18resembling a Tasmanian tiger, right? You can't
- 59:20do that to a Tasmanian devil or whatever. You
- 59:22have to actually recreate the entire organism.
- 59:26And, you know, the ecology of places like Tasmania
- 59:29and southern Australia where these animals used
- 59:32to live has been severely degraded as a result
- 59:35of their extinction, right? So perhaps you can
- 59:38think of the merits of introducing a species
- 59:41or recreating a species that is sorely missing
- 59:47in its native environment. That's a different
- 59:49conversation. But what Colossal is doing is not
- 59:51that yet. And again, I think that because it's
- 59:54ultimately a corporation, it'll trend towards
- 1:00:00making a product that they can sell. At the end
- 1:00:03of the day, that's what it's going to be. That's
- 1:00:06what I fear and and they're making Sorry for
- 1:00:10my language put a shit ton of revenue. I think
- 1:00:13that the the CEO and founder has just been Added
- 1:00:19to Forbes list of billionaires, so he's a billionaire
- 1:00:25now and That reminds me of my first contact with
- 1:00:34this new science of resuscitating or creating
- 1:00:37those kinds of mutants that resemble extinct
- 1:00:42species. And that was back in high school, believe
- 1:00:46it or not, from reading Science Magazine. And
- 1:00:50they had an article that started, you wake up
- 1:00:53in the morning and you feel there's something
- 1:00:57weird. um you can quite you know point you know
- 1:01:02what's weird and then you continue reading and
- 1:01:07um the the you realize the protagonist realizes
- 1:01:11that uh he's in a zoo and that an alien species
- 1:01:16um has you know cloned him and um brought him
- 1:01:22back from uh who knows what uh era So humanity
- 1:01:28has been extinct, and we've been brought back,
- 1:01:32which is the plot of a horror movie of the, you
- 1:01:37know, alien kind. So, you know, are they going
- 1:01:43to go as far as resuscitate hominids? Do you
- 1:01:51think that they will cross that line at some
- 1:01:53point? Yeah, I think that's the kind of stuff
- 1:01:56that I mean if I were I'm not a business person,
- 1:02:01right? But I can imagine that Well, you know
- 1:02:06they say that Bad publicity is still publicity,
- 1:02:09right? There's no such thing as bad publicity
- 1:02:11so perhaps this is an ill -informed take but
- 1:02:14but I wonder you know if Attempting something
- 1:02:18like that wouldn't be hugely detrimental to their
- 1:02:26perception in the public sphere, right? Because
- 1:02:29I'm thinking that wolves, as much as people do
- 1:02:33like wolves, I think most people have some sort
- 1:02:36of admiration for this particular species, right?
- 1:02:40It's still considered wholly other, right? It's
- 1:02:43still not people. And so it's okay to put them
- 1:02:47in zoos in most people's eyes. It's okay to,
- 1:02:50you know. occasionally seek them out in the wild,
- 1:02:53maybe domesticate them, some people hunt them,
- 1:02:56right? So I think that's one thing. Another thing
- 1:02:59altogether is to attempt to bring back a species
- 1:03:03that's essentially us with an asterisk, right?
- 1:03:08I don't know. I can imagine there would be lots
- 1:03:10of resistance to that. And I think perhaps that's
- 1:03:14the point to just kind of stir the conversation
- 1:03:16a little bit, right? To see how far they can
- 1:03:18push people and still um you know have a a favorable
- 1:03:25kind of public perception um what i could one
- 1:03:31one thing that perhaps is worth thinking about
- 1:03:34in relation to this is um i don't know if you
- 1:03:41remember it's not that long ago maybe two three
- 1:03:44years ago there were claims that a human being
- 1:03:49had been cloned in China, right? And before that,
- 1:03:54way before that in the early 2000s, when cloning
- 1:03:57first became the talk of the scientific community,
- 1:04:01the question of whether human cloning should
- 1:04:04be allowed was a more public conversation that
- 1:04:07was being had at that time, right? And as I remember,
- 1:04:11people were largely opposed to this idea. Right?
- 1:04:15So I think that they would also, I would hope
- 1:04:17that people would be opposed to the idea of bringing
- 1:04:21back a creature that would be so like us and
- 1:04:26yet not really. and thus open to exploitation,
- 1:04:29right? I don't see that happening, but that's
- 1:04:32the thing with, and again, right? That's what
- 1:04:34Jurassic Park tells us. That's the thing with
- 1:04:36scientific technologies like that, with genetic
- 1:04:39engineering and the fact that all of this is
- 1:04:42being done by private corporations now, is that
- 1:04:44you never know, right? industries are so deregulated
- 1:04:51right now and there are so many ways in which
- 1:04:53they can conduct research that's highly questionable,
- 1:04:56right? And not be in any way confronted by the
- 1:05:01public because the public just straight up doesn't
- 1:05:03know what's going on behind closed doors, right?
- 1:05:04They don't know what's going on in those labs.
- 1:05:07It's entirely possible they would attempt something
- 1:05:09like this, right? So who knows? I would like
- 1:05:13to believe that people wouldn't stand for it,
- 1:05:16but people stand for all kinds of things. There's
- 1:05:19something funny about the idea that there might
- 1:05:23be a clone of Albert Einstein in a Chinese lab
- 1:05:26right now. Yeah. Yeah. And it's funny you mentioned
- 1:05:32that because I think as an alternative to this,
- 1:05:36right, could be I'm not an advocate of AI technologies,
- 1:05:42but I recently saw this thing where this kid
- 1:05:48made an AI version of his grandpa so that his
- 1:05:53grandma, who was now widowed, could talk to him
- 1:05:56again. If this technology exists, and I think
- 1:06:03its ethical quandaries are not as dire as human
- 1:06:07cloning or the cloning of species that are human
- 1:06:09-like, then perhaps we should favor that over
- 1:06:14cloning over Einstein. Isn't it just possible
- 1:06:16to create an AI version of it? Although, of course,
- 1:06:20there are philosophers of AI who would perhaps
- 1:06:23debate whether that artificial intelligence would
- 1:06:27then be entitled to certain rights and considerations,
- 1:06:29but that's beyond my understanding. I can't say
- 1:06:33that I know much about that. Last question about
- 1:06:39Jurassic Park. A theme throughout the movie,
- 1:06:47at least in the beginning, in the first movie
- 1:06:51is the wonderment of the paleontologist looking
- 1:06:59at those dinosaurs and being able to touch them.
- 1:07:03and to look at them, you know, closely. And I
- 1:07:10guess this kind of wonderment, we all share it
- 1:07:14for nature. And it's that very reason why they
- 1:07:19created that park, because they knew people would
- 1:07:23travel to go and look at those creatures. So
- 1:07:29how do you explain how this movie resonates so
- 1:07:34differently with different people. For me, it
- 1:07:38is a reason to be kinder to animals. And it is
- 1:07:44a critique of zoos. And for others, it is a motivation
- 1:07:50to create the very thing that the movie is denouncing.
- 1:07:57So what do you make of that diverse response
- 1:08:02to Jurassic Park? Yeah, that's an excellent question.
- 1:08:08And I think it's one that's difficult to answer.
- 1:08:13But I'm going to try by referencing something
- 1:08:16that we talked about earlier today, which was
- 1:08:20the place of paleontology, dinosaurs and evolutionary
- 1:08:24theory and society's understanding of the self.
- 1:08:31I think you're absolutely right in pointing out
- 1:08:33that there is an almost instinctive sense of
- 1:08:43wonder that we feel in the presence of nature,
- 1:08:46right? Whatever you want to call nature. But
- 1:08:48I think that that instinct or perhaps some, you
- 1:08:55know, feeling that we all have deep inside, I
- 1:08:59think it can be shaped. Right so. When when people
- 1:09:05stand in the face of these. Wonderful creatures
- 1:09:12that we share the world with that affect that
- 1:09:16feeling right will then be sort of channel depending
- 1:09:19or through your worldview through the ideologies
- 1:09:22excuse me for the ideas and ideologies have a
- 1:09:25ship that have shaped you excuse me so. Once
- 1:09:30that affect kind of surfaces within the body,
- 1:09:35right? The mind, my understanding of it is that
- 1:09:39our understanding of the world, like our cognitive
- 1:09:43understanding of the world, which is always going
- 1:09:45to be shaped by the society that we live in,
- 1:09:47it's going to warp that sense of wonder and it's
- 1:09:52going to transform it, right? It's going to channel
- 1:09:54it in a particular direction. And so even though
- 1:09:57we all share that sense of wonder, the way in
- 1:10:00which we project it back out into the world is
- 1:10:04going to be different from person to person,
- 1:10:05right? Although there are some trends, I think
- 1:10:08a lot of people feel the urge to be close to
- 1:10:15this natural world, right? And I think that's
- 1:10:19where the drive to own pets, for example, comes
- 1:10:22from. I've met a couple of vegans who used to
- 1:10:29own exotic pets, right? And I think even though
- 1:10:33most hardcore vegans would describe that as a
- 1:10:36contradiction, I think while it might be a contradiction,
- 1:10:41I think it's also a manifestation of this deep
- 1:10:44-seated love and admiration that we feel for
- 1:10:46the natural world, right? And then later as you
- 1:10:48learn more about for example, the exotic pet
- 1:10:51industry, you realize that that's not the right
- 1:10:54way to channel that affect, right? But that's
- 1:10:58not often the case. Most often, the way in which
- 1:11:02that emotion, that feeling will be channeled
- 1:11:05is, again, right shaped by your society. And
- 1:11:07if your society is one that understands animals
- 1:11:10as objects to be owned, for example, you go and
- 1:11:14get a pet. especially after watching Jurassic
- 1:11:16Park, you go and get a pet that resembles a dinosaur,
- 1:11:19right? Or conversely, you watch Jurassic Park
- 1:11:24and see them, quite frankly, the majesty of predators,
- 1:11:30right? And perhaps that affect is then channeled
- 1:11:34into an urge to go hunting because that's what
- 1:11:36you know, right? So I think that's partly why
- 1:11:41we can all agree on the fact that most people,
- 1:11:44I think, even people who otherwise care very
- 1:11:46little for the environment, we can all agree
- 1:11:48that there is something about nature that attracts
- 1:11:52us, right? That something about it that allures
- 1:11:56us into wanting some sort of relationship with
- 1:11:59it. So I think that's partly where it comes from,
- 1:12:05right? And I think it's also why why biodiversity,
- 1:12:08animal conservation, wildlife conservation, has
- 1:12:12been such a pivotal piece of the environmental
- 1:12:14movement. Because I think it's one aspect of
- 1:12:18nature that most people respond to in some ways.
- 1:12:21And so it becomes an easy way to generate donations,
- 1:12:24for example, or sign people up to volunteer or
- 1:12:27whatnot. Which is why I study. representations
- 1:12:31of conservation and extinction and things that
- 1:12:34have to do with biodiversity because I think
- 1:12:37that it's one of the few things that really seem
- 1:12:40to generate some sort of consensus about the
- 1:12:42need to protect the environment or nature or
- 1:12:45whatever. Now, having said all this, I think
- 1:12:49that thinking of this feeling as a sense of wonder,
- 1:12:58right, I think that is the right way, or sorry,
- 1:13:03I shouldn't say the right way, but I think that
- 1:13:05is the way in which I would encourage all of
- 1:13:07us to channel that affect, right? There's this
- 1:13:11line, it's the last few lines of Charles Darwin's
- 1:13:16On the Origin of Species. And I can recite it
- 1:13:21almost verbatim because it came to... It urged
- 1:13:25me to reshape the way in which I understand my
- 1:13:28relationship with nature because I used to be
- 1:13:29one of these people, right? I used to be one
- 1:13:31of those kids who would watch an animal documentary
- 1:13:35and want to get one of those animals as a pet,
- 1:13:37right? And I had countless... I'm sorry to say
- 1:13:40countless exotic pets when I was a kid. Pets
- 1:13:42that I did not know how to take care of. And
- 1:13:44that unfortunately most of them died because
- 1:13:47I was just a kid. I didn't know. But there were
- 1:13:49no limits to it, right? So I would ask my parents
- 1:13:51for a turtle and they would give me a turtle.
- 1:13:52I would ask them for like a lizard and they got
- 1:13:54me a lizard or a snake or what have you, right?
- 1:13:56But then reading this passage really made me
- 1:14:00kind of like rethink how to understand that feeling,
- 1:14:04right? And it goes something along the lines
- 1:14:06of how there is grandeur in this view of life
- 1:14:12that from so simple at beginnings, endless forms,
- 1:14:17most beautiful and most wonderful have been and
- 1:14:19are being evolved. And what I like about that
- 1:14:24passage or one of the things that I hang onto
- 1:14:26is the concept of the view of it, right? Because
- 1:14:30I think that That sense of wonder you're talking
- 1:14:34about that we experience when i want to ask park
- 1:14:36or wildlife documentary on the other just now
- 1:14:38you send me to your national park or whatever
- 1:14:40right. It doesn't need to be anything other than
- 1:14:44an affect it doesn't need to be anything other
- 1:14:47than a view of the world right it doesn't have
- 1:14:51to be more than just this sublime experience.
- 1:14:55Perhaps learning to just think of it as a way
- 1:14:57of seeing the world as opposed to. as a way of
- 1:15:01owning it or claiming it or even like visiting
- 1:15:08it, right? Because our impact to the places that
- 1:15:09we visit is huge, right? And we shouldn't be
- 1:15:12in some of these places, right? So I think that
- 1:15:15learning that, learning to just feel that and
- 1:15:21not... do something about it. I think that's
- 1:15:26the way that I think we should strive to be.
- 1:15:28Obviously, it's difficult. And again, I don't
- 1:15:31blame people for doing things a certain way.
- 1:15:37I think we're all the product of ideologies.
- 1:15:44There's very little point in blaming people for
- 1:15:46doing certain things. I think it's more about
- 1:15:48perhaps encouraging them to rethink some of those.
- 1:15:52Yeah, some of their impulses. Is it ideology?
- 1:15:57Or are we just a predatory species? Yeah, good
- 1:16:02follow up. I think a lot of it is ideology. Look,
- 1:16:06one of the conversations that I have a lot when
- 1:16:09people when people ask about my veganism, or,
- 1:16:12or, or veganism in general, right? It's like,
- 1:16:14okay, but like, what about and then, you know,
- 1:16:16fill in the blank with some sort of society that
- 1:16:19is not yet fully Western, right? Like, well,
- 1:16:22what about like, I don't know, like the nomads
- 1:16:25of the Kalahari or the Inuit in Northern Canada
- 1:16:28and such and such and such, right? I think that
- 1:16:31evidently we're a predatory species in the sense
- 1:16:34that our evolution was shaped by... this transition
- 1:16:41that you see in the fossil record towards the
- 1:16:43consumption of meat, right? How that meat was
- 1:16:46procured, by the way, is not entirely understood.
- 1:16:48It's possible that hunting was not what drove
- 1:16:53that transition, but rather scavenging, right?
- 1:16:55I mean, you do have to remember that the few
- 1:16:59apes that inhabit the African savanna today,
- 1:17:02or primates, no apes, primates, right? Like the
- 1:17:05olive baboons, they're carnivorous, but they
- 1:17:08hardly ever hunt. they mostly scavenge and that's
- 1:17:11because other animals have taken those apex predatory
- 1:17:15positions, right? But anyway, the point being
- 1:17:16that I think that, yeah, like it's in our instinct
- 1:17:19in some way, right? But I think it's also true
- 1:17:23that in that sense of wonder and in that recognition
- 1:17:27of the grandeur of nature and furthermore, you
- 1:17:31know, the fact that we just, most of us right
- 1:17:33here in Western societies do not need to do it,
- 1:17:38right? I think that challenges the extent of
- 1:17:42that predatory behavior, right? I think most
- 1:17:44people would hesitate to kill the animals that
- 1:17:51they consume on an everyday basis, right? Like
- 1:17:53even somebody who really loves chicken wings
- 1:17:55would be hesitant to kill enough chickens to
- 1:17:59then have a platter of chicken wings, right?
- 1:18:01I think there are limits to that predatory instinct.
- 1:18:04And I think that again, our understanding of
- 1:18:10that consumer -based relationship to animals
- 1:18:13today is mostly, maybe ideological is not the
- 1:18:16right term, but I think it's the product of external
- 1:18:21forces, right? I think in no part of our genetic
- 1:18:25code is there a line that says, go to the supermarket
- 1:18:29and get a steak, right? I think there's a difference
- 1:18:32there. And yeah, I don't know. These are the
- 1:18:37tougher questions to answer, I think. Entire
- 1:18:39volumes have been written about that. But personally,
- 1:18:41I think that perhaps that's one way in which
- 1:18:44we can think of ourselves as different from most
- 1:18:47animals, right? And even then, I would question
- 1:18:49it. But we're not entirely driven by instinct,
- 1:18:52right? We acknowledge that on an everyday basis.
- 1:18:55Otherwise, society, as we know it, would not
- 1:18:57be possible. Why stop at not killing somebody
- 1:19:02who makes us angry, right? Why stop at not harassing
- 1:19:06people that disagree with us? Why not extend
- 1:19:09that control over our instincts to our fellow
- 1:19:14animals? Yes, it's an interesting question. I
- 1:19:17think you're right. If people are interested
- 1:19:21in learning more about this and exploring this
- 1:19:24topic, I actually interviewed Dr. Ahidu who led
- 1:19:29one of the first research showing that our ancestors
- 1:19:33were mostly plant based in their diet. So yeah,
- 1:19:40go look that up. I think it's episode 68 of the
- 1:19:44show. So yeah, yeah, absolutely. I will I will
- 1:19:48look it up because, um, you know, again, right,
- 1:19:52I teach critical analysis. And so I am always
- 1:19:55I'm all about like, Paying attention to the details
- 1:19:59of any utterance of any statement, right? Is
- 1:20:02that when I hear arguments like our ancestors
- 1:20:05were carnivorous or hunters or plant -based,
- 1:20:08right? I always ask which ancestors, right? Because
- 1:20:12human evolution is long, right? If you date back
- 1:20:14to, if you're talking about our ancestors as
- 1:20:17in like primates in general, right? And even
- 1:20:22primates in our family tree that were basal,
- 1:20:25they were overwhelmingly plant -based, right?
- 1:20:29Very few primates in the wild are otherwise,
- 1:20:33right? You do have some tribes of chimpanzees
- 1:20:37that hunt, but for the most part, they're plant
- 1:20:40-based, right? So when I say that like some of
- 1:20:43our ancestors do seem to exhibit some trans towards
- 1:20:47carnivory, right? That occurs at a very particular
- 1:20:51time in human evolution, right? And it's also...
- 1:20:55within the great scope of human evolution, it's
- 1:20:58a fraction of it, a tiny fraction of it, right?
- 1:21:01Not enough, for example, to give us a gut that
- 1:21:04can actually process meat, right? Which is why
- 1:21:06we have to cook it, right? Very few people struggle
- 1:21:09eating a raw banana, but most people will struggle
- 1:21:12to digest a raw piece of meat, right? So that
- 1:21:14transition that I was mentioning before, I should
- 1:21:16qualify that, right? It's not like the defining
- 1:21:19moment of human history. It's one of several
- 1:21:22moments, right? And I think it's the blink of
- 1:21:24an eye in evolutionary terms, right? And it's
- 1:21:27not long enough to have shaped us entirely. So
- 1:21:29we may have predatory instincts, but they're
- 1:21:32not the same kind of predatory instincts that
- 1:21:34drive my cat, for example, right? Who cannot
- 1:21:38survive without meat. So, yeah. Yes. Don't feed
- 1:21:43your cat a plant -based diet. I know I might
- 1:21:47get, you know... A bit of strong reactions from
- 1:21:51from that comment, but I stand by it And yeah,
- 1:21:55I wish I was more, you know pushing back on some
- 1:21:59of the claims, you know Observed and reported
- 1:22:03on in that in his study, but there was a language
- 1:22:06barrier Anyway, I got the scoop on interviewing
- 1:22:10him on that study. I knew it was you know a viral
- 1:22:14online when he published it at the beginning
- 1:22:19of the year. But yeah, I was happy to sit down
- 1:22:22with him. So Alex, do you want to add something
- 1:22:28before we stop the recording? No, just, you know,
- 1:22:34again, my name is Alex Ventimella. I'm a PhD
- 1:22:37candidate at the University of Alberta in the
- 1:22:40English and Film Department. I mostly research
- 1:22:44environmental documentaries that have to do with
- 1:22:47conservation, extinction, and environmental justice
- 1:22:52as well. And I guess I would encourage people
- 1:22:59to learn more about the many ways in which environmental
- 1:23:04issues interconnect. I think the conversation
- 1:23:07has been hung up on climate change. for quite
- 1:23:11a while without truly understanding what drives
- 1:23:14it, for example, without truly understanding
- 1:23:17the ways in which it connects to other issues
- 1:23:20that are longstanding, right? I would encourage
- 1:23:25people to go watch the new David Attenborough
- 1:23:28documentaries, which I hope to discuss with you
- 1:23:30at some point, because those are something that
- 1:23:31I'm very interested in. David Attenborough, for
- 1:23:33example, yeah, I think most people know him,
- 1:23:35right? He was for... the bulk of his career,
- 1:23:40he was apolitical, right? Because that was the
- 1:23:43tradition of the BBC, specifically the BBC's
- 1:23:46natural history unit to produce apolitical documentaries,
- 1:23:49right? And that the situation is now so dire
- 1:23:53that there has been a marked transition, a very
- 1:23:57marked transition in the way Adam Borough communicates
- 1:24:01his environmental message to the public. He is
- 1:24:03now embracing the you know, the concept of a
- 1:24:07plant -based diet. I think he doesn't use the
- 1:24:09term veganism because unfortunately has a lot
- 1:24:11of negative connotations, but he's spoken about,
- 1:24:14you know, how crucial it is to change our relationship
- 1:24:18to the natural world beginning with what we put
- 1:24:20in our bodies, right? And a big part of that
- 1:24:22is, yeah, letting go of that carnivory that has
- 1:24:32added very little to us as a society, but has
- 1:24:37been so hugely detrimental to the world, to nature,
- 1:24:41and to the lives of billions of creatures that
- 1:24:43are sentient and vulnerable and that can't speak
- 1:24:47and thus are easy to ignore. by most people.
- 1:24:52So yeah, definitely check that out, you know,
- 1:24:53inform yourselves, learn about the ways in which
- 1:24:55all these issues sort of interconnect, how they
- 1:24:58all intersect. And you know, if you care about
- 1:25:00pandas, if you care about tigers, if you care
- 1:25:02about all of these beautiful animals out there,
- 1:25:04right, a good place to start is always with your
- 1:25:08own bodies, right? And letting go of those things
- 1:25:10that we consume that put those other creatures
- 1:25:15that we do admire and that we do love in jeopardy
- 1:25:17as well. nicely said. Alex, I love your takes
- 1:25:22on all of those topics and questions. This was
- 1:25:28such a pleasant conversation. Yeah, it was. Thank
- 1:25:31you. Thank you so much. And please come back.
- 1:25:35Absolutely. If you ever need like a last minute
- 1:25:38guest or whatever, I'm always happy to join you.
- 1:25:41Oh, not even, you know, I want to have your take
- 1:25:45on the movie, babe. And I also want to comment
- 1:25:48that documentary and documentaries in general,
- 1:25:50I think, you know, there's a lot to be said about
- 1:25:53them. Yeah, for sure. For sure. Yeah, yeah. So
- 1:25:58for instance, like the last one that came out
- 1:26:00out of that that new school of documentaries
- 1:26:02by by Adam or Ocean, right? Ocean now with that
- 1:26:06markedly political message, anti trolling. anti
- 1:26:10-fisheries, right? It was so, so sorely lacking
- 1:26:14for all of last century, but it's gotten to the
- 1:26:18point where people who care about the environment
- 1:26:20like David Attenborough can no longer pretend
- 1:26:22that these are not issues, right? So which is
- 1:26:24why he stepped away from the BBC, or at least
- 1:26:27he's now in partnership with Netflix as well.
- 1:26:29Disney, corporations that are more open to political
- 1:26:32messaging. Surprisingly enough, Disney being
- 1:26:34one of them, right? But yeah, no, absolutely.
- 1:26:36Let's talk about that. Let's talk about whatever
- 1:26:37you want. But but I'm always happy to discuss
- 1:26:39films because I do think that that there's a
- 1:26:42certain power to the moving image and that encourages
- 1:26:46us to to to to to reconceive our understanding
- 1:26:48of the world. Right. So yeah, let's talk about
- 1:26:50all that. Definitely. See you soon. Thank you,
- 1:26:54everyone, for listening. I kindly invite you
- 1:26:57to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:27:00Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 1:27:04thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 1:27:07next Tuesday for a new episode.