Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] PDD Holdings: Q3 2025 Financial and Governance Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00We're kicking off this deep dive with a a real financial puzzle.
- 0:04It's one of those things that sort of challenges everything
- 0:06you think you know about high growth tech companies, right?
- 0:09So picture this. A global e-commerce giant famous
- 0:13for just explosive growth suddenly reports that its sales
- 0:18growth has slammed on the brakes.
- 0:19We're talking single digits. Single digits, but at the exact
- 0:23same time it delivers a huge profit beat and is sitting on an
- 0:26absolutely astronomical pile of cash.
- 0:29How does that happen? Well, that paradox is PDD
- 0:32Holdings, the company behind Pinduoduo and of course Teemo.
- 0:36And that's our mission today. We're going to dig into their
- 0:38Q32025 earnings and look back at their whole 10 year financial
- 0:42story. Yeah.
- 0:43We want to go past the headlines and really figure out how PDD
- 0:47managed to shift from being this, you know, high flying
- 0:49growth stock to what now looks more like a value generating
- 0:52cash mission. Exactly.
- 0:54It's a fascinating transition. And before we jump in, we should
- 0:58do the standard, but very important note for all our
- 1:00financial deep dives. Absolutely.
- 1:02Yeah. So for everyone listening,
- 1:03Please remember all the analysis here is for informational
- 1:08purposes only. It is not investment advising.
- 1:10All the figures come from public data so they can be revised.
- 1:13You have to do your own due diligence before making any kind
- 1:15of investment decision. OK, let's get into it.
- 1:17The Q32025 snapshot because these numbers, they really threw
- 1:22the market for a loop. They did.
- 1:24PDD reported revenue of about 108 billion R&B.
- 1:29So what, 15.2 billion U.S. dollars.
- 1:32The issue that was only up 9% year over year.
- 1:36And for a company like PDD, 9% is basically standing still.
- 1:39It's a huge deceleration. So what was the reason?
- 1:42Well, management point to a couple of things really.
- 1:45Intest price wars at home in China and just a more cautious
- 1:49consumer, you know, overall. OK, that explains the revenue
- 1:51slowdown. But here's the magic trick.
- 1:53Despite that, their adjusted earnings per share came in at 21
- 1:57point O 8 RMV. Or about $2.97 and that number
- 2:01just blew past what everyone was expecting, which was closer to
- 2:041684. So how do you do that?
- 2:07How do you slow down revenue but stomp on the gas for
- 2:10profitability? What lever did they actually
- 2:13pull? It was a very deliberate, very
- 2:16disciplined choice about where to put their money, specifically
- 2:20cost control. If you look at their operating
- 2:23costs, their sales and marketing spend was kept almost perfectly
- 2:27flat, 30.3 billion RMB versus 30.5 billion the year before.
- 2:31So they just decided to stop spending so much on promotions.
- 2:35They made a conscious choice to go for margin stability instead
- 2:38of just chasing, you know, often inefficient domestic growth at
- 2:42any cost. Wait a second though, if they
- 2:44kept marketing flat at home, are they just shifting all that
- 2:47spending over to Timu? I mean, is this profit beat
- 2:49really sustainable or is it just hiding a massive international
- 2:53cash burn? That is a brilliant question and
- 2:56that's the real tension at the heart of their strategy right
- 2:58now. They're definitely shifting
- 3:00investment, but it's selective. How so?
- 3:02The money they saved on domestic marketing didn't just disappear,
- 3:05they plowed it into R&D. Research and development jumped
- 3:0941%. 41% Wow. Yeah, up to 4.3 billion RMB and
- 3:15that's going into fundamental tech, into platform upgrades,
- 3:19basically defending their core business.
- 3:22It's a trade off, give up some top line growth now for a
- 3:26stronger platform long term. And the foundation for this
- 3:28whole strategy is just it's this massive pile of cash you
- 3:32mentioned. Let's just let that number sink
- 3:34in for a moment. It is their war chest.
- 3:37It defines everything they do. Their net operating cash flow
- 3:40more than doubled in Q3 alone. Doubled.
- 3:43Which swelled their total cash and short term investments to a
- 3:46jaw-dropping 423.8 billion RMB. Which in U.S. dollars is.
- 3:52Approximately 59 1/2 billion dollars. $59.5 billion, I mean,
- 3:56that's more than the GDP of some countries.
- 3:57It gives them the freedom to do whatever they want.
- 4:00To pivot of it, to fight a price war to acquire someone they
- 4:04never have to worry about liquidity.
- 4:07So how did they build this machine in the 1st place?
- 4:08This cash didn't just materialize, it comes from their
- 4:10core business model, right? Absolutely.
- 4:13The foundation of pin to a duo is just incredible efficiency.
- 4:16It's that team purchase social shopping model, they call it C2M
- 4:19customer to manufacturer. Right where you share a deal
- 4:22with friends to get a lower price.
- 4:24Exactly. By using social sharing, PDD
- 4:27gathers up huge amounts of demand for a single product.
- 4:31This lets manufacturers sell directly to a massive group of
- 4:34consumers, cutting out all the middle men.
- 4:36And that primarily helps price sensitive shoppers, especially
- 4:40in China's smaller cities. It does, and that focus on, you
- 4:43know, radical low prices and social sharing let them get to
- 4:46an unbelievable scale very, very quickly.
- 4:49The user base is enormous. It's one of the largest in the
- 4:51world, probably over 900 million active buyers now.
- 4:54And once if you hit that kind of scale, you create a powerful
- 4:58network effect. Merchants have to be on PDD to
- 5:00reach that audience. And how they make money from
- 5:03that huge user base is also really clever.
- 5:05It's incredibly stable because it's split almost perfectly
- 5:085050. That balanced income is a huge
- 5:10advantage. About half, 50.2%, comes from
- 5:14online marketing services. So ads.
- 5:16Ads, promotional fees, merchants paying for better visibility.
- 5:21The other 49.8% comes from transaction services, so
- 5:25commissions, payment fees, that sort of thing.
- 5:27And it acts like a hedge, doesn't it?
- 5:29It's a natural hedge. If consumer spending slows down,
- 5:32transaction fees might dip. But merchants get more
- 5:36desperate, so they might actually increase their ad spend
- 5:39to compete for fewer sales, which props up the marketing
- 5:42revenue. And they have these deep
- 5:44operational moats, too. It wasn't just about price.
- 5:47They engineered the platform to be sticky.
- 5:50Yes, their advantage is twofold. You have the cost leadership,
- 5:54but then you have this brilliant social commerce ecosystem that
- 5:58gamify the whole experience. You mean like Duo duo Orchard?
- 6:02Exactly where you you know you grow a virtual tree by logging
- 6:05in and doing tasks, and they send you a box of real fruit
- 6:08when it's harvested. It sounds silly, but it keeps
- 6:10users coming back every single day, not just when they need to
- 6:13buy something. And they leveraged WeChat for
- 6:14distribution. Deeply, which gave them this
- 6:18super low cost channel that rivals just couldn't copy and we
- 6:22can't forget how they first broke into the market.
- 6:24Agriculture. The massive agricultural market.
- 6:27They processed CN¥270 billion in agricultural orders back in 2020
- 6:33and they do it by using a zero Commission policy for farmers.
- 6:37A bet on market share and getting users to form a habit,
- 6:40not on making money upfront. A.
- 6:42Classic long term play, but that aggressive expansion now leads
- 6:47us directly to the headwinds they're facing, especially with
- 6:50Timu's global push. Right, domestically it's a
- 6:52brutal price war. PDD's singles day sales grew
- 6:5611.7%, which you know, still beat Alibaba and JC, but it's
- 7:00costing everyone a fortune to maintain that.
- 7:02But the bigger more structural risk is TIMU.
- 7:05Its entire business model relies on that ultra low cost
- 7:08cross-border shipping. And that model is now under
- 7:10threat. Directly threatened by rising
- 7:12geopolitical tensions and new trade barriers, the US, for
- 7:15instance, is cracking down on the de minimis rule.
- 7:18That's the one that lets packages under $800 come in duty
- 7:21free. Correct, and the EU is doing
- 7:24something similar, introducing new duties on low value parcels.
- 7:28This is aimed squarely at the business model of Timu and
- 7:32Sheen. So if these rules actually
- 7:34stick, what's the real impact on Teamu's prices?
- 7:37I mean, their whole appeal is being the cheapest.
- 7:40The analysis suggests these duties could raise Teamu's final
- 7:43price to the consumer by 20% or even more. 20% that completely
- 7:49wipes out their. Advantage.
- 7:50It erodes their cost leadership which is the main reason people
- 7:53are using the platform. TMU would then have to totally
- 7:56change its strategy, maybe move to local warehouses which is way
- 7:59more expensive and cuts right into their margins.
- 8:01And then there's the other threat, the shift in how people
- 8:03shop. This might be the biggest long
- 8:05term risk of all bike dance. TikTok shop.
- 8:09Duen in China TikTok shop globally.
- 8:12These aren't just e-commerce apps, they're entertainment
- 8:14platforms where you happen to be able to buy things.
- 8:17It's the difference between opening an app because you want
- 8:19to shop, which is PDD, versus accidentally shopping because
- 8:23you were just scrolling through an addictive video feed A.
- 8:25Whole different user behavior. Completely and if consumer
- 8:28habits shift decisively toward that kind of content driven live
- 8:33stream shopping PD DS simple bargain focused feed is going to
- 8:38feel very old very fast so they. Face some really significant
- 8:42risks. And yet, as we said at the top,
- 8:44their core financials look ridiculously strong.
- 8:47Which brings us to the main point, the numbers that show key
- 8:50DD isn't just a growth play anymore, it's a real value
- 8:53story. The pivot to value really
- 8:55started when they hit gap profitability back in 2021, but
- 8:58look at the valuation compression since then.
- 9:01In 2020, PDD was the definition of a hot growth stock.
- 9:05Its price to earnings ratio was what, nearly 145 times?
- 9:08145 and today. Today, the trailing 12 month PE
- 9:12ratio as of September 2025 has come all the way down to about
- 9:1612.212. From 1:40.
- 9:18Five and it's the same story with price to book.
- 9:20It's fallen from around 18 times down to about 2.87.
- 9:23It's near its lowest valuation ever.
- 9:25The earnings growth has just massively outpaced the stock
- 9:27price. That shift from, you know,
- 9:30speculative favorite to a cheap caskow is just astounding.
- 9:34And the source of all that value is its incredible free cash
- 9:38flow. This is where the business model
- 9:39is just beautiful. DDS FCF soared to a peak of
- 9:44nearly $21 billion in 2023. They generate cash faster than
- 9:49almost anyone, and the secret is that negative working capital
- 9:52cycle we talked about. OK.
- 9:54So break that down for us. How can their free cash flow be
- 9:57so much higher than their reported net income?
- 9:59Well think of PDD as a sort of interest free bank.
- 10:02They collect the cash from you, the customer, the second you
- 10:05place an order right? But they don't pay the merchant
- 10:07until weeks later after the item is delivered and everything is
- 10:10confirmed. So for that entire period, PD is
- 10:12just holding and investing its customers money for.
- 10:15Free. For free.
- 10:16And as the business grows, that float of interest free cash gets
- 10:19bigger and bigger every single quarter.
- 10:21So they're literally using customer and merchant money as a
- 10:24continuous loan to fund their own growth.
- 10:27It's no wonder their SCF margin hit an insane 67.5% in 2022.
- 10:33It's virtually unheard of at this scale, and it's also why
- 10:36serious value investors look at a metric called owners earnings.
- 10:40Which tries to measure the true usable cash flow.
- 10:43Exactly so. PD DS reported net income in
- 10:462023 was about $8.5 billion, but its owner's earnings were around
- 10:5121.5 billion. Wait, say that again.
- 10:54Their real cash generation was almost three times their
- 10:58reported profit. Yes, and that huge gap changes
- 11:02everything about how you should value the company.
- 11:04If you value it on the 8.5 billion net income, it looks
- 11:08reasonably priced. If you value it on the 21.5
- 11:11billion in real cash it's generating.
- 11:13It becomes profoundly cheap. Profoundly cheap.
- 11:16The current owner's earnings yield is around 10 1/2 percent.
- 11:19Gap accounting just doesn't capture the true efficiency of
- 11:22this model. And it's all possible because
- 11:23they're so asset light. Absolutely.
- 11:25They don't own the warehouses, they don't own the delivery
- 11:28fleets. Their annual capital expenditure
- 11:30is incredibly low, under a billion dollars a year, which is
- 11:33less than 3% of revenue. So low investment, high cash
- 11:36generation. Which results in extremely high
- 11:38returns on capital, consistently over 20%.
- 11:41For an investor, that's the signal that management is
- 11:44brilliant at reinvesting every dollar they get back into the
- 11:47business. Now this whole engine depends on
- 11:49steady leadership. Which brings us to governance.
- 11:52The founder, Colin Huang, still has a massive influence, even
- 11:56though he stepped down as CEO. He.
- 11:58Does he holds about 59% of the voting power through special
- 12:01Class B shares? And that's crucial because it
- 12:04keeps the company locked into his original vision, total cost
- 12:08consciousness and user first innovation.
- 12:10And the current Co CE OS have kept that going.
- 12:12Chen, Lei and Zhao GSN. They've provided remarkable
- 12:16stability, overseeing both the pivot to profitability and the
- 12:19huge launch of Teemo. And big institutions,
- 12:22particularly value investors, are clearly believers.
- 12:24Oh. Absolutely.
- 12:25Long term funds like Billy Gifford and Norae Asset bought
- 12:29huge stakes between 2022 and 2025.
- 12:32Their average cost is probably somewhere in the 50 to $60.00
- 12:34range, which shows just how much conviction they had that PDD was
- 12:38undervalued even with all the geopolitical risks.
- 12:41And it's interesting, even with that strong founder control,
- 12:44other shareholders have shown they can still make their voices
- 12:47heard on governance. They have.
- 12:49In 2023, about 15% of shareholders voted against a
- 12:53board member over concerns about a lack of diversity.
- 12:56And management listened. They did.
- 12:58They appointed a female director shortly after.
- 13:01It shows that even though control is centralized, they do
- 13:04respond to clear signals from their investors.
- 13:07Speaking of signals, what's their approach to share
- 13:10buybacks? They've been pretty minimal
- 13:12compared to, say, Alibaba's massive $25 billion program.
- 13:18Why are they just hoarding that $59.5 billion?
- 13:21Management's message is pretty clear.
- 13:24They believe that the return they can get by investing that
- 13:26cash back into the business, specifically into Teemu and R&D,
- 13:31is much, much higher than the return they'd get from just
- 13:33buying back their own stock. So they're choosing growth over
- 13:36shareholder returns for now. They're choosing strategic
- 13:39flexibility. It lets them fund this huge,
- 13:41expensive global expansion without ever having to go into
- 13:44debt. OK, so let's summarize the key
- 13:47Nuggets here for you. PDD Holdings is making a very
- 13:50deliberate choice. It's sacrificing short term
- 13:53growth and margin at home, which is why the PE and PB ratios are
- 13:57so much lower now to pour fuel on its global expansion with
- 14:00TIMU and invest heavily in tech. And they can afford to do it
- 14:04because their core Chinese business is this incredibly
- 14:08efficient asset like machine that spits out cash flow fall
- 14:12far greater than its reported profits.
- 14:14Which has led to this radical compression in its valuation,
- 14:17making it a really compelling case study for deep value
- 14:19investors. I mean PD DS journey proves the
- 14:22power of a superior business model.
- 14:24Think about it. They went from burning cash
- 14:26negative FCF in 2019 to generating over $20 billion in
- 14:30free cash flow just four years later.
- 14:32That kind of turn around at that scale is just a truly rare feat.
- 14:35Which leaves us with a final provocative thought for you to
- 14:38chew on. Given PD DS enormous and still
- 14:41rapidly growing cash file, that $59.5 billion war chest and a
- 14:45management team that clearly prefers to reinvest rather than
- 14:48pay it out, what happens when the internal growth
- 14:50opportunities for a company this big finally start to dry up?
- 14:54Where, ultimately, does all that cash go next?
- 14:57Think about that and we'll catch you on the next deep dive.