Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / What Attorneys Should Know About the State Bar Court
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome, everybody, to What Attorneys Should
- 0:06Know About the State Bar Court. My name is Rachel
- 0:09Cogan. I'm the chair of the BHBA litigation section.
- 0:14I have the honor to introduce today Judge Dennis
- 0:19Saab. Judge Saab has been a judge on the State
- 0:22Bar Court since July 2019. He presides over a
- 0:27variety of cases involving California attorneys.
- 0:30The cases comprise of professional misconduct,
- 0:33criminal convictions, inactive enrollment due
- 0:36to mental illness or infirmity. reinstatement
- 0:40after suspension and disbarment, and others.
- 0:43Judge Saab also hears cases involving the State
- 0:46Bar Court's alternative discipline program for
- 0:49attorneys with substance abuse and or a mental
- 0:52health illness who have committed misconduct.
- 0:55He is currently the supervising judge of the
- 0:57court's trial department. Welcome, Judge Saab.
- 1:01We're so happy that you're here today. I'm going
- 1:05to give you an overview of the State Bar Court,
- 1:08talk about some current topics, and then at the
- 1:11end, hopefully have some time for some questions
- 1:13and answers. All right. First, I have to tell
- 1:16you that the statements made during this presentation,
- 1:19next slide. Next slide, possible? Thank you.
- 1:25Statements made during the presentation are my
- 1:28personal opinions. They are not They're not statements
- 1:34made by the State Bar Court, by the State Bar,
- 1:39or they're not legal advice. You should conduct
- 1:43your own legal research and determine any issues
- 1:50you may have. All right, I'm going to talk about
- 1:53first the composition of the court. And in terms
- 1:56of the composition, there are two departments
- 1:59in the State Bar Court. One of them is the trial
- 2:02department. That's where I'm at. There are three
- 2:05judges in Los Angeles. Besides myself, there
- 2:09is Judge Roland and there's Judge Worthington.
- 2:12In San Francisco, there are two judges, Judge
- 2:15Wang and Judge Shala. And we, at this trial department,
- 2:20we hear trials and we decide cases and we make
- 2:25recommendations. And we have in the court Also,
- 2:29we have an appellate department, and this consists
- 2:32of a presiding judge, two appellate judges, and
- 2:37one judge pro tem. And at times, a trial judge
- 2:41may be asked to sit on assignment at the review
- 2:45department for a particular case. So that's a
- 2:48possibility. All right. The next slide deals
- 2:54with the life cycle of a complaint. If it complains
- 3:01that come into the state bar, go to the prosecuting
- 3:06office. This is the office of chief trial counsel
- 3:08who conducts an investigation. If they determine
- 3:12that the case is worthy of filing, they file
- 3:16it with the trial department or the hearing department
- 3:19and the case is moved through that department.
- 3:23If either side is unhappy with the decision,
- 3:27the hearing department, whether it's an order
- 3:29that you are unsatisfied or dissatisfied and
- 3:34seek a review on or interlocutory review, you
- 3:37can. If you are unhappy with the decision, either
- 3:40side could file an appeal. And this appeal goes
- 3:42to the review department or appellate department.
- 3:46If you're unhappy with the decision there, either
- 3:48side, either the prosecutor or the attorney,
- 3:50you have a right to appeal to the California
- 3:52Supreme Court. And if you're unhappy with the
- 3:55decision of the Supreme Court, you can then move
- 3:58forward to the US Supreme Court. So that is the
- 4:01life cycle of a complaint that would come in
- 4:07from the public. The next slide will talk about
- 4:09the, what does a complaint look like? It's a
- 4:11notice of disciplinary charges. That's the next
- 4:13slide. And this one creates a public proceeding.
- 4:17In criminal matters, you have notice of hearing
- 4:19on conviction. and the case becomes public when
- 4:23the prosecuting office transmits the record of
- 4:27conviction. And in that particular case, when
- 4:31a notice of disability charge is filed or a notice
- 4:35of hearing on conviction is filed, you then will
- 4:39be served as an attorney and you need to file
- 4:42a response, 20 days to file a response. If you
- 4:46do not file a response, The prosecutors typically
- 4:50ask for a request to enter default, and if the
- 4:55attorney does not follow the response or follow
- 4:58an opposition to the motion for entry of default,
- 5:02and the default satisfies our rules, then the
- 5:05court will enter default. And default against
- 5:08an attorney will then place the attorney on inactive
- 5:13enrollment in three days. So that means the attorney
- 5:16will be unable to practice law after those three
- 5:19days. And that could be a significant problem.
- 5:24If you fail to show up at trial, default will
- 5:27be entered, must be entered against you. And
- 5:30this will also lead to your inactive enrollment
- 5:33and eventually lead to your disbarment. Where
- 5:37are these obligations that attorneys should be
- 5:40concerned about, these ethical obligations? That's
- 5:42the next slide. and that is the California Rules
- 5:46of Professional Conduct, not the ABA rules, but
- 5:49the California Rules of Professional Conduct,
- 5:51the State Bar Act, and of course the California
- 5:56Rules of Court. Those are the sources of the
- 6:03ethical obligations attorneys have. The next
- 6:08slide would be When I talk about common complaints
- 6:11and violations, these are what the court typically
- 6:14sees. Performance issues, competency, abandoning
- 6:17clients, duties to clients, conflict and business
- 6:22deals, personal behavior, crimes, multirpitude,
- 6:26substance abuse. When the court sees crimes,
- 6:30these are convictions that you've had in the
- 6:33Superior Court that are now referred to the State
- 6:36Bar Court. to decide if there should be any discipline
- 6:41imposed on the lawyer. It's important to note
- 6:44that the court looks at the facts and circumstances
- 6:46surrounding the conviction. So if you had a clever
- 6:51defense lawyer that was able to negotiate and
- 6:56reach a fair, decent disposition at the criminal
- 7:00court, this court will be able to look at all
- 7:04the facts and circumstances regarding the conviction.
- 7:06to decide. Oftentimes, the court has to decide
- 7:09whether the misconduct is moral turpitude or
- 7:14not. But if you are faced with a crime and faced
- 7:20with criminal charges, it's very important for
- 7:22you to consult with defense lawyers who are familiar
- 7:26with the State Bar Court as a plea could result
- 7:30in a summary disfondment. Fees. Well, common
- 7:35complaint that the court has deals with fees,
- 7:38illegal or unconscionable fees, fees regarding
- 7:41advanced retainers. I invite everyone to look
- 7:45at their retainers, their fee agreements with
- 7:50their clients when they have time. If you see
- 7:54the word non -refundable, such as a payment to
- 7:58the attorney is non -refundable, you should remove
- 8:01that word. Rule 1 .5D of the Rules of Professional
- 8:07Conduct of California provides that a lawyer
- 8:09may make an agreement for, charge, or collect
- 8:13a fee that is earned on receipt or non -refundable
- 8:17only if it's a true retainer and the client agrees
- 8:21in writing. The issue is I have never seen a
- 8:26true retainer come before the court. because
- 8:29a retainer, a true retainer, is a sum of money
- 8:31paid by a client to secure an attorney's availability
- 8:35over a given period of time. That is earned by
- 8:40the attorney when paid, regardless of whether
- 8:42the attorney performs any services for the client.
- 8:46But if the client hires you, for example, to
- 8:48defend a civil action, particular case, that
- 8:53is not a true retainer. the attorney's giving
- 8:56you an advance fee to represent him or her in
- 9:01this lawsuit. So it's very important to note
- 9:05that when clients hire attorneys, that if you
- 9:10have the word non -refundable, it has to be a
- 9:15true retainer and the client has to agree in
- 9:18writing. Rarely the case, rarely the case. A
- 9:22client hires you to represent them in a criminal
- 9:25shoplifting, petty theft, for example, they're
- 9:28hiring you for a specific case. They're not hiring
- 9:31you for you to be available. So in that particular
- 9:34case, the word non -refundable should not be
- 9:37in your fee agreement. Sorry, this violation
- 9:42is often seen with a violation of rule 1 .15A.
- 9:50And that provides that all funds received or
- 9:52held by a lawyer for the benefit of the client,
- 9:55including advances for fees, costs, and expenses,
- 9:58must be deposited in a trust account. And Section
- 10:03B of that rule allows you to deposit flat fees
- 10:07in a non -trust account, provided you have written
- 10:11consent of a client. So, If the client is hiring
- 10:16you, for example, for a naturalization application,
- 10:23and they're giving you these fees, and it's a
- 10:26flat fee, if you want to deposit it in a non
- 10:31-trust account, you must have the client's written
- 10:34consent. Ideally, you would have a paragraph
- 10:36in your retainer that would say that. Another
- 10:39common violation that the court sees in this
- 10:42area is the issue of providing an accounting
- 10:46to the client. Rule 1 .15d4 requires lawyers
- 10:52to promptly account in writing to the client
- 10:55or other person for whom the lawyer holds funds
- 10:59or property. You ask yourself, must I always
- 11:02provide an accounting? I think that depends.
- 11:06For example, if you're hired to represent somebody
- 11:09in naturalization application and you file that
- 11:13application and you're say your fee agreement
- 11:16included representing the client at the USCIS
- 11:20naturalization interview, you appear at the interview.
- 11:23In the case of successful, you receive a letter
- 11:25indicating that the person has been approved
- 11:29and will be scheduled for an oath ceremony. You
- 11:34send your client a disengagement letter. In that
- 11:37particular case, I'm not so sure whether you
- 11:40need to provide an accounting, because here you've
- 11:43completed the services for which you were hired.
- 11:47The client hired you for an actualization application,
- 11:50including interview. You performed your work.
- 11:53You send a disengagement letter. The case is
- 11:56done. You wouldn't have to account for your hours
- 11:59in that particular case, I believe. However,
- 12:02In that hypothetical, if you do not file any
- 12:08application and the next notice you receive is
- 12:13from a new attorney indicating that they've been
- 12:16hired to represent this individual in a naturalization
- 12:20application, then in that case you would have
- 12:23to provide an accounting because here you do
- 12:26not complete the services for which you were
- 12:28hired. There is a case on point, a matter of
- 12:31Brockway. It's often cited. It's a review department
- 12:34case from 2006, and it says an attorney's duty
- 12:37to render appropriate accounts does not require
- 12:40it as a predicate that the client demands such
- 12:43an accounting. But in that situation, in the
- 12:46second hypo where you don't perform, you don't
- 12:49complete the services from which you were hired,
- 12:52the client doesn't need to ask for an accounting.
- 12:54You should be providing the client with an accounting.
- 12:59additional common violations and complaints or
- 13:03handling of funds, commingling, moving disputed
- 13:07funds out of your trust account. The next slide
- 13:11has interference with justice, disobedience of
- 13:16a court order, advising clients to commit a crime,
- 13:18for example, duties to the state bar regarding,
- 13:22say, your MCLA certification, your client. trust
- 13:27account protection program, CTAP reporting, cooperations
- 13:33and investigation, professional employment, improper
- 13:36solicitation or advertising. These are common
- 13:39violations. In terms of CTAP, that is a reporting
- 13:43requirement, fairly new. It's due March 30th.
- 13:47maybe the next business day, that lawyers need
- 13:51to register and are responsible for client funds,
- 13:56registering accounts, doing a self -assessment,
- 13:59certification, and a declaration, and to do that
- 14:02you would go to your My State Bar profile and
- 14:06complete it there. In terms of interfering with
- 14:09justice, I provided a case, it's the next slide,
- 14:14and that's the the matter of Olin. In this particular
- 14:20case, it's a 2024 case from our review department.
- 14:24Attorney Olin was involved in a family law dispute
- 14:27involving his ex -spouse and son. After losing
- 14:32the motion, the attorney emails a judge, bribed,
- 14:37why are you so corrupt? Then he starts bombarding
- 14:41the supervising judge and others with insults.
- 14:46And then he violates a no ex -party emails to
- 14:50judges directive and he keeps emailing away.
- 14:53There's a workplace restraining order issued
- 14:55and later charges are filed. Well, the case went
- 14:58to trial and the judge found that some speech
- 15:01was protected, but found that three counts of
- 15:06filing business and professions code 6106 were.
- 15:11approved by the Office of Chief Child Counsel.
- 15:14The Review Department agrees on culpability,
- 15:17weighs the aggravation, and actually increases
- 15:20the discipline from 90 days to nine months of
- 15:24actual suspension and other matters including
- 15:27cost and rule 9 .20 compliance. The case is important
- 15:33for I think of many reasons. One of the reasons
- 15:38is that The First Amendment protects the freedom
- 15:41of expression of all citizens, and that includes
- 15:44attorneys. But this free speech is not absolute.
- 15:50And with that in mind, statements made, statements
- 15:54that could reasonably be understood as imputing
- 15:58specific criminal or wrongful acts are not entitled
- 16:02to constitutional protection merely because they're
- 16:06a phrase in the form of an opinion. False statements
- 16:10are also not protected speech. And so when you're
- 16:17looking at an attorney's speech and their ethical
- 16:20responsibilities, the few rules and sections
- 16:27come into play. Business and Professions Code
- 16:30Section 6068B, which is setting forth the duty
- 16:35to maintain a respect due to the courts of justice
- 16:40and judicial officers, rule 8 .2a prohibiting
- 16:43false statements as to the qualifications or
- 16:46integrity of a judicial officer, rule 8 .4d prohibiting
- 16:51conduct prejudicial to the administration of
- 16:54justice, and section 6106 prohibiting acts involving
- 16:59moral turpitude, dishonesty, or corruption, and
- 17:02often by making false statements about judges.
- 17:06And so it's very important to know that you don't
- 17:09give up your freedom of speech, but it is limited.
- 17:13And the case of Olin is a good case to read as
- 17:17to the dangers of maybe going too far with emails
- 17:22and so forth. The next slide is a obligation
- 17:29to self -report. And this one is, what's an attorney's
- 17:35duty to self -report? Well, reversal of judgment
- 17:38based on misconduct, grossly incompetent representation,
- 17:43or willful misrepresentation. Entry of judgment
- 17:46for fraud, misrepresentation, breach of judiciary
- 17:49duty, gross negligence, committed in a professional
- 17:53capacity. Malpractice the filing of three or
- 17:56more lawsuits in a 12 -month period. judicial
- 18:00sanctions, again, except for discovery sanctions
- 18:03or sanctions of less than $1 ,000. And I'll talk
- 18:06about this one particular obligation of self
- 18:10-report in just a few minutes or a minute. Bringing
- 18:14of an indictment, information charging a felony
- 18:17against an attorney. So if you're charged with
- 18:19a felony, you must self -report. If you're convicted
- 18:23of a felony, or a misdemeanor in the course of
- 18:26practice of law, or in a manner in which a client
- 18:31was a victim, or a misdemeanor involved in moral
- 18:34tributary, which could be petty theft, for example,
- 18:36you have a duty to self -report, and discipline
- 18:39imposed by another disciplinary board. And that
- 18:42could be just any other bar from any other state.
- 18:47It could be U .S. Patent and Trademark Office.
- 18:50It could be the bankruptcy courts. It could be
- 18:52a federal court. It could be anywhere. You have
- 18:55a duty to report. All right. When I mentioned
- 19:00that I was going to talk about this duty to regarding
- 19:10judicial sanctions, except for discovery sanctions
- 19:12or sanctions of less than a thousand dollars.
- 19:15One of the litigator, Omad Shabani, who's a member
- 19:20of this Bar Association, asked about a particular
- 19:23case and particularly a footnote in the case.
- 19:26And that is the case in the matter of Rubin.
- 19:29It's a review department case from 2021. And
- 19:32in this particular case, Rubin was charged with
- 19:34various counts, including the failing to timely
- 19:37report a $2 ,335 sanction against him in violation
- 19:44of 66803. 66803 requires an attorney to report
- 19:49within 30 days imposition of judicial sanctions
- 19:51against the attorney, except sanctions for failure
- 19:55to make discovery. or monetary sanctions of less
- 19:58than $1 ,000. The trial judge concluded that
- 20:03the sanctions imposed against Rubin were imposed
- 20:07not for a failure to make discovery, but because
- 20:11Rubin was unsuccessful in opposing a motion for
- 20:15a protective order. The review department agreed.
- 20:19So the issue that I think Mr. Shabani wanted
- 20:23me to discuss was, well, is a Code of Civil Procedure
- 20:28Section 2025 .4208 Sanction Order a failure to
- 20:33make discovery that requires self -reporting?
- 20:36According to these cases, yes, I would require
- 20:40an attorney to self -report. It is an interesting
- 20:44question. The court I say it's interesting. The
- 20:49judge who decided this case is no longer with
- 20:52the state park court. She's now a federal district
- 20:54court judge. The review department that authored
- 20:58the decision, I think she's no longer with the
- 21:01court. So the best, safest approach is to report
- 21:07it. But if you're faced with an attorney, if
- 21:12you're representing an attorney that has not
- 21:13reported it, I think you have a chance to argue
- 21:16some argue that a motion for a protective order
- 21:23is the other side of a coin of a motion to compel,
- 21:27right? The motion to compel somebody to do something,
- 21:30and the protective order is to prevent that from
- 21:33happening. So one could argue that it is discovery,
- 21:36but that's just an argument to make. Should you
- 21:40report it? Again, this case provides that you
- 21:43should report it. I looked around to see what
- 21:47happens with these cases that are reported, and
- 21:49that's the next slide, and this should convince
- 21:51you why, the next slide please, why you should
- 21:55report it, not only because you have an ethical
- 21:57duty, but if you look at the statistics regarding
- 22:00reported by self, self -reports, if you look
- 22:03at the right -hand column there, 2025, it looks
- 22:08like the state bar received 175 self -reports.
- 22:13And if you look down, cases filed in the State
- 22:16Bar Court, only 17 were filed. That means 10%.
- 22:2010 % of the self -reports were filed with the
- 22:23court. So to be on the safe side, of course,
- 22:27according to Rubin, you would report that particular
- 22:30sanction for... for not being successful in a
- 22:35motion for protective order. But this statistics
- 22:40also shows you that reporting is the right thing
- 22:43to do because the chances of coming into court
- 22:45to having a case filed against you with 10 %
- 22:48is very little. And so I... I hope I've answered
- 22:54Mr. Shabani's questions regarding that case.
- 22:57The next slide talks about rule 8 .3. I can't
- 23:00say I've seen this yet at the court, but this
- 23:03is effective August 1st, 2023, and it provides
- 23:07a lawyer must without undue delay report to the
- 23:10state bar or a tribunal when the lawyer knows
- 23:13of credible evidence that another has committed
- 23:15a criminal act or is engaged in conduct involving
- 23:18dishonesty, fraud, deceit. or reckless or intentional
- 23:22misrepresentation or misappropriation of funds
- 23:24or property that raises a substantial question
- 23:28as to that lawyer's honesty, trust, or fitness
- 23:32as a lawyer in other respects. So just remember
- 23:35this rule because it's relatively new and it
- 23:40might be something that slips your mind, but
- 23:43just remember that you do have an affirmative
- 23:45duty in this particular case. What the court
- 23:48is also seeing these days, next slide please,
- 23:51is the issue of technology. When you have, lawyers
- 23:58have a, under duty of competence, you do have
- 24:02rule 1 .1, you do have a duty to understand the
- 24:04technology used. So you must be familiar with
- 24:07technology. Along with that, it's important to
- 24:10note, since technology now has a lot of, AI seems
- 24:15to be, ubiquitous, and we just see it everywhere.
- 24:19I think if you turn to Google and you do a search,
- 24:21it might be AI searching. But confidentiality
- 24:24rules under rule 1 .6, there are risks when putting
- 24:28client data into AI tools. Is it a closed universe?
- 24:32Is it not? Is it a chat GPT where other people
- 24:34can see that? It's very mindful of rule 1 .6
- 24:38confidentiality. Integrity. 8 .4. There are dangers
- 24:44with asking ChatDBT or another AI program to
- 24:49prepare an opposition because we have heard,
- 24:57and you've probably heard, that there is fabricated
- 25:00content fake evidence, often called hallucination,
- 25:04and lawyers are being called out for that at
- 25:08this time, both at the trial levels, at the appellate
- 25:12courts, and then now at our court. And for supervision
- 25:15under rules 5 .1 and 5 .3, lawyers are responsible
- 25:19for staff and vendors using AI tools. Last week,
- 25:24the state bar sent out an email highlighting
- 25:27the work that the Committee on Professional Responsibility
- 25:30and Conduct are doing in this regard. They're
- 25:33actively working on revisions and updates to
- 25:35its practical guidance regarding AI. There will
- 25:41be a presentation before the Board of Directors
- 25:44on May 14th and 15th for approval. There's proposed
- 25:48amendments to the rules of professional conduct
- 25:51currently out for public comment. And you're
- 25:54encouraged to write a comment on these proposed
- 25:57amendments. This comment period will end May
- 26:004th. And what does this look like? Well, the
- 26:05proposed amendments address an attorney's ethical
- 26:08obligations under rules of professional conduct,
- 26:111 .1, 1 .4, dealing with communication with clients,
- 26:15confidential information of a client under 1
- 26:17.6, candor towards the tribunal under rule 3
- 26:22.3, responsibility of managerial and supervisory
- 26:27lawyers, That's rule 5 .1 and responsibility
- 26:32regarding non -lawyers assistance 5 .3. So be
- 26:38very mindful of AI. If you do use it, make sure
- 26:42you read the citations and proofread it very,
- 26:45very carefully. If a case is filed before the
- 26:49state bar court or even before it's filed, the
- 26:53next slide tells you uh that there is a diversion
- 26:58being offered by the prosecutors uh at this time
- 27:02for eligible attorneys um and what that looks
- 27:05like is you would probably request it or they
- 27:07would offer it so program that allows these attorneys
- 27:10to receive a non -disciplinary resolution at
- 27:13intake at investigation at the charging stage
- 27:17or even after a case is filed and uh according
- 27:20to the prosecuting office these are for individuals
- 27:23who do not pose a significant risk of future
- 27:25harm and where the conduct is relatively minor
- 27:29and correctable through rehabilitative measures.
- 27:32This doesn't involve court involvement at all,
- 27:35so I often don't see these types of cases as
- 27:39they resolve outside of the court. However, if
- 27:42the case is filed, then of course, the court
- 27:44does see a motion to dismiss these types of cases.
- 27:49Besides the diversion, The court has another
- 27:52track for late cases that are filed. And that's
- 27:55the next slide. And that would be the Alternative
- 27:59Discipline Program. And the Alternative Discipline
- 28:02Program is a separate track and involves a lawyer
- 28:05participating in the Lawyer Assistance Program.
- 28:09And that's a program offered by the State Bar.
- 28:12And where lawyers that have substance abuse or
- 28:15mental health issues or both, and they get established
- 28:19a nexus between that substance abuse or mental
- 28:21health issues and their misconduct may be eligible
- 28:25for this program. The attorneys do have to stipulate
- 28:29to corpability. That stipulation eventually becomes
- 28:33public. But the benefit of the program is that
- 28:39the judge will tell you what the discipline will
- 28:42be. Two levels of discipline, one of them is
- 28:45if you complete the program, one of them is if
- 28:47you don't complete the program. Obviously, if
- 28:50you complete the program, then you will then
- 28:53receive a low level of discipline. Well, say
- 28:56you don't accept diversion or it's not offered
- 29:00and say you don't go into the the alternative
- 29:04discipline program and you decide to go to trial.
- 29:06The next slide will tell us what the trials look
- 29:10like. Well, civil discovery rules and the evidence
- 29:13code generally applies, corroborated evidence,
- 29:18hearsay, excuse me, may be allowed. You should
- 29:21check with your judge. Some judges are a little
- 29:24bit stricter on hearsay than others. And you
- 29:28have a right to a court trial. That's with one
- 29:30of the judges that you that I mentioned at the
- 29:33beginning, one of us five judges, there's no
- 29:35jury, so you don't have to convince the jury
- 29:38here, you have to convince a judge. And the review
- 29:42department, if you decide to appeal the case,
- 29:45they decide the appeal de novo. They don't get
- 29:49to hear the evidence over their decisions based
- 29:52on the record already that was produced at the
- 29:56trial level, and then they decide the case at
- 29:59that point. The levels of discipline, which is
- 30:02the next slide, is an admonition you could receive
- 30:06from the court. Sometimes the prosecutors will
- 30:11offer an agreement in lieu of discipline. There
- 30:14are reprievals. There are private reprievals
- 30:18and a public reprieval. The private reprieval
- 30:20will only come from the court. The prosecutors
- 30:22don't offer private reprievals anymore. And besides
- 30:26that, there is a state suspension. there's actual
- 30:30suspension, and ultimately there's disbarment.
- 30:36Resources, the next slide, this is the last slide,
- 30:40is where do I find some of this information at?
- 30:43Well, the State Bar advisory opinions, from time
- 30:46to time, the Committee on Professional Responsibility
- 30:48and Conduct publishes opinions regarding some
- 30:51hypothetical attorney issue. And while these
- 30:55opinions are not binding, such opinions are often
- 30:57cited. and they cite relevant decisions of the
- 31:02Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals, and of the
- 31:05State Bar Court, and sometimes are used as persuasive
- 31:08authority at the State Bar Court for us at the
- 31:11trial level. There's an ethics hotline, 1 -800
- 31:15-2 -ETHICS. confidential calls to the state bar
- 31:19staff to help them identify, maybe analyze their
- 31:23professional responsibilities. And although the
- 31:26staff attorneys cannot provide legal advice,
- 31:29hopefully they can discuss issues and refer attorneys
- 31:32to statutes and rules and cases and bar opinions.
- 31:37The Rudder Group, professional responsibility,
- 31:40California practice guide, that's very useful.
- 31:44In terms of the client trust account, the Client
- 31:48Trust Accounting Handbook. You can download it
- 31:52for free from the State Bar website. That's helpful.
- 31:57Could be a little overwhelming because I've looked
- 31:59at it, but it's helpful. And of course, another
- 32:03resource is the Lawyer Assistance Program, where
- 32:06this program is designed for lawyers and law
- 32:09students. It provides confidential support for
- 32:12mental health, substance abuse, helps lawyers
- 32:15with work -life balance, And that's available.
- 32:18You can find it at the State Bar website. I also
- 32:23want to point out that the State Bar Court is
- 32:26coming out with a practice guide for self -represented
- 32:29litigants. It should be out very shortly. It
- 32:32will be available at the State Bar Court website.
- 32:34At the State Bar Court website, you can find
- 32:36published cases. You can find our rules of procedure
- 32:39there, as well as our rules of practice. You
- 32:42can also find the calendar for the week. For
- 32:45example, if you look at the State Bar Court website
- 32:47now by just Googling State Bar Court, you could
- 32:51find my calendar for the week and you could see
- 32:53what cases I have, what cases I had this morning.
- 32:56The cases that are public will be noted there.
- 33:00I'll have a Zoom link and they're open to the
- 33:03public. You could watch them just like you're
- 33:04watching this presentation now. Some cases are
- 33:08confidential and those will not, you will not
- 33:11be able to access those. And these typically
- 33:14are cases regarding mental health. cases involving
- 33:19ADP and settlement conferences, whether they're
- 33:24pre -filing settlement conferences or settlement
- 33:27conference after cases file. A lawyer does have
- 33:31the opportunity to request a pre -filing settlement
- 33:35conference by completing a form and sending it
- 33:38to the court. So if you're being investigated
- 33:42and you've been advised that the case is proceeding
- 33:45for refiling, I think, I believe it will give
- 33:48you an option. The letter should advise you of
- 33:50your opportunity to do a pre -filing settlement
- 33:52conference, which I think is a great idea because
- 33:56Both sides could hear the perspective of a settling
- 33:59judge and determine whether a case is strong
- 34:06or weak or where the weakness is in the case.
- 34:09Anyways, my last slide provides for questions.
- 34:13And if anybody has any questions, I'm happy to
- 34:16try to answer them. I think you have to put it
- 34:20in the chat or somewhere. I'm not sure, but you
- 34:23have to put it somewhere. Because again, there's
- 34:25an audience that I cannot see. Okay, someone's
- 34:27speaking. Thank you. So it does look like we
- 34:29have a question in the Q &A. Joshua Johnson asks,
- 34:33do the trial proceedings allow for quote unquote,
- 34:36anarchist briefs when we are aware of the attorney's
- 34:39bad or unlawful behavior? Well, I have received
- 34:43amicus briefs in the past. So and I've considered
- 34:48them. But it's not common, I could say Since
- 34:522019 that I've been on the court. I've only seen
- 34:55one case that had an amicus. Oh, maybe two cases
- 34:58I apologize two case I'm thinking of another
- 35:00case right now. So there were I've had two cases
- 35:03but if an attorney if Without the amicus briefs.
- 35:08Hey, you wanna you have additional information
- 35:11about the attorney. That's negative I suppose
- 35:13you could contact the prosecutor in the case
- 35:16if it's positive then oftentimes we are a court
- 35:21of mitigation and aggravation. And one of the
- 35:25mitigating factors is an attorney to have extraordinary
- 35:28good character. And oftentimes attorneys have
- 35:32other attorneys or members of the general community,
- 35:35both attorneys and non -attorneys, appear and
- 35:37testify on their behalf or write letters, declarations,
- 35:43excuse me, in support of the attorney. So hopefully
- 35:46I've answered your questions about amicus briefs.
- 35:49All right, then I have another one from a Mr.
- 35:52Michael Rubenstein. Has there been an increase
- 35:54in state bar prosecutions for trust fund misconduct
- 35:57since the, I guess, Tom Gerardi matter came into
- 36:01light? That's a thing. Yes, I don't have the
- 36:04numbers, but certainly there are always cases
- 36:10regarding trust fund violations. Some of them
- 36:14are minor, for example, attorneys. that have
- 36:18monies that go into the trust fund account and
- 36:21that money is earned you must remove it from
- 36:23there and then you could go and pay there. So
- 36:33you have a T -Mobile bill, you have a Chase credit
- 36:35card bill. You can't issue a check from your
- 36:38client trust fund account. You have to issue
- 36:41it from your personal account. My internet says
- 36:44it's unstable. I hope everyone can hear that,
- 36:46Kimmy. Okay, we can hear you. Again, thank you.
- 36:50So I'm not sure about the statistics in terms
- 36:53of that, but we always see trust fund violations.
- 36:56And that's very common in the court. Thank you
- 36:58for your question. All right, then I have another
- 37:01one. Alexander asks, how long do investigations
- 37:05typically take? Wow, that I don't know, Alexandra.
- 37:09Thank you for your question. It's a very good
- 37:11question. I, sometimes attorneys come to a settlement
- 37:15conference and complain that they've responded
- 37:19to inquiries three, four years ago. So that,
- 37:25oh, thank you for removing that. So that, that's
- 37:28an issue. I don't know how long they take, but
- 37:31uh you know we do have we don't have a statute
- 37:35of limitations but we have a rule on limitations
- 37:39and if you want to look at this rule of limitations
- 37:42is located it's rule 5 .21 in the rules of procedure
- 37:47of the state bar again that's available at the
- 37:49state park court website so feel free to look
- 37:52at that i don't know how long the investigations
- 37:54last because this court receives complaints filed
- 37:56by the prosecuting office but i've received Sometimes
- 38:01I hear that complaints take years to move forward
- 38:05to the filing stage. And hopefully that helps
- 38:09you out, Alexandra, with your question. Great.
- 38:13I have another question here. In your experience,
- 38:15at what stage in the life cycle of a complaint
- 38:17do respondents most often lose the opportunity
- 38:20to meaningfully shape the outcome? Well, Well,
- 38:28by not showing up, you're really shaping the
- 38:30outcome of your case, right? By not finding a
- 38:32response within the time frame, you're also shaping
- 38:37poorly the outcome of your case. Because as I
- 38:40mentioned, in case you came late, as I mentioned,
- 38:43if you don't file a response, your default may
- 38:46be entered. If you participate in the proceedings
- 38:49and then don't show up for trial, your default
- 38:51must be entered. Default means disbarming. So,
- 38:55but I think at all stages, attorneys have to
- 39:00be mindful. You have an obligation to cooperate
- 39:03in a state bar investigation. And so if you're
- 39:08sent a letter asking about a particular case,
- 39:11don't ignore it. You certainly want to respond
- 39:13to it. And sometimes the case may go away, right?
- 39:15It could be nothing. It could be somebody gave
- 39:18you a payment to represent them in a case and
- 39:22you did. and the client's unhappy because they
- 39:25don't like the results, for example. Well, but
- 39:28participating in every stage of the proceeding
- 39:30is very important. At the pre -filing, it's important.
- 39:35And of course, after the case is filed, attorneys
- 39:37should participate. Where do they lose the case?
- 39:40Sometimes attorneys... believe that they're strong
- 39:44litigators, they could do well at the State Bar
- 39:46Court, but the State Bar Court has rules of procedure
- 39:49and rules of practice that should be followed.
- 39:52Attorneys sometimes don't read those rules, don't
- 39:54read trial sending orders, and they're very specific.
- 39:58And so that's where attorneys can make mistakes.
- 40:00They don't submit a pretrial statement as required.
- 40:03They don't lodge exhibits that are required before
- 40:07trial. They don't exchange exhibits. So all stages
- 40:10of the case, the other case you could set up
- 40:13for a disaster if you don't participate fully
- 40:16and really become accustomed with the rules of
- 40:19practice and the rules of procedure and our case
- 40:22law. So hopefully I've answered that question.
- 40:26Thank you for your question. Great. And so we
- 40:30have another one. What if the client and attorney
- 40:32are sanctioned following the motion filed by
- 40:34the OC? Do we have to report it? The question
- 40:39is Wait, let me see if I understand the question.
- 40:43If the client and the attorney are sanctioned
- 40:47by the court, do we have to report it? Well,
- 40:51it doesn't matter if the client's sanctioned,
- 40:53right? We're just looking at the conduct of the
- 40:55attorney. In that particular case, you should
- 40:57go to Business and Professions Code 6068 -0.
- 41:01And that will tell you, will lay out what obligations
- 41:07you have to self -report. And the only one I
- 41:11mentioned was the one brought by Mr. Shabani,
- 41:13and that deals with being sanctioned on losing
- 41:18a motion for a protective order. But a lot of
- 41:21judges in the Superior Court often sanction attorneys
- 41:25under $1 ,000, and they do so because they're
- 41:28mindful that attorneys don't need to report those
- 41:32types of cases, for the most part, or generally.
- 41:36when the sanction is under $1 ,000. So in your
- 41:40particular question, if the client and the attorney
- 41:43are sanctioned, I must direct you to 6068 -0
- 41:46to determine whether you must self -report. But
- 41:48again, the slide I showed, if you saw it, the
- 41:51slide I showed after that showed that the percentage
- 41:54of state -barred court cases filed with the court
- 41:57is at 10 % of those self -reported cases. Just
- 42:01because you report it doesn't mean it's going
- 42:03to lead to a state bar court case. But if you
- 42:05don't report it, that could be a problem. Hopefully
- 42:08I've answered that question. Thank you for your
- 42:10question. Thank you. And I have another question
- 42:13here. What is the most common issue or mistake
- 42:16made by attorneys that you see? Most common?
- 42:19Yes. I think the failure to communicate with
- 42:24a client. If you gave your client your cell phone
- 42:28number, and are exchanging texts, you better
- 42:33continue with responding to your client because
- 42:36the client often prints out those pages and submits
- 42:40them and the prosecutor will submit them as an
- 42:42exhibit. So if you communicate with your client
- 42:45by cell phone, by text, I think that's dangerous
- 42:49for attorneys because then you've set up certain
- 42:51expectations where the client expects you to
- 42:54answer at all times. all times of the days, every
- 42:57day, even on Sundays. And so I think the most
- 43:00common problem I see is this failure to communicate
- 43:04that is often brought really by the attorney
- 43:08because the attorney may have been too accommodating
- 43:13to the client. There's nothing wrong with a client
- 43:17calling the attorney's office during business
- 43:19hours and asking status of the case. or sending
- 43:23an email to the attorney, and then the attorney
- 43:25responding to that email. If you do that, I think
- 43:29you're on the safe side. But when you give yourself
- 43:31a number and the client gets accustomed to responding
- 43:36to you, that might be the most common problem.
- 43:39That problem doesn't come alone. In other words,
- 43:41I've never seen a case of failure to communicate
- 43:44with a client discharged alone. It often comes
- 43:47with other issues involved, a failure to perform
- 43:50with competence, a failure to having a fee agreement
- 43:56that uses the word nonrefundable. So it often
- 43:58comes with other violations, not just that violation.
- 44:03Thank you for your question. Thank you. So it
- 44:06looks like we have another one. In competency
- 44:09or abandonment cases, what distinguishes sanctionable
- 44:12misconduct from mere negligence that does not
- 44:15arise in discipline? Well, yes. So the charting
- 44:18document will often, when you're charged with
- 44:20failure to perform with competence or diligence,
- 44:23you will often see a series of acts that the
- 44:27prosecutor says that you were not competent with.
- 44:32Sometimes it's a little, what you see sometimes
- 44:36are a combination of failure to respond to discovery,
- 44:41failing to appear at a hearing, failure to oppose
- 44:45emotion. If you have a client, say you have a
- 44:48client that has very limited funds, and the strategy
- 44:51is going to be that you're no longer going to
- 44:54oppose motions because it's cost prohibited,
- 44:58make sure you document that with your client
- 45:00in writing. You tell your client, I will no longer,
- 45:04so based on our conversation, we will no longer
- 45:07oppose or respond to discovery. We'll no longer
- 45:13file any oppositions. I will not appear at a
- 45:15hearing. All this is important for the client
- 45:18to be on board and agreed upon. And if that's
- 45:21not the case, then you really should sub out
- 45:23of the case, right? Because you are going to
- 45:25be responsible, if you serve a discovery, and
- 45:27you're the attorney of record, to respond to
- 45:29that discovery, to appear, to respond to a motion
- 45:32to compel potentially. So a common problem with
- 45:36competency and sanctions is attorneys that they,
- 45:41I don't know if you could say drop the ball,
- 45:44or they no longer actively participate in the
- 45:47litigation. often leading to abandonment and
- 45:50constructive termination of the attorney -client
- 45:53relationship. Very important that if you do decide
- 45:57that you will take a certain strategy at trial
- 46:00or pretrial, that it is clearly documented, that
- 46:04your client's on board. And of course, if you
- 46:06decide that that's the route you're going to
- 46:09take, you could be subject to sanctions when
- 46:11a motion to compel is granted. and the judge
- 46:15decides to award attorney fees and so forth.
- 46:19So, competency, there's usually a series of potential
- 46:23missteps from the attorney. And the court often
- 46:26looks for some kind of gross negligence. Simple
- 46:30negligence like, for example, you didn't file
- 46:33in time to protect the statute in and of itself
- 46:36would be simple negligence. It would be gross
- 46:37negligence. But that often is not seen by itself.
- 46:41It's seen with a combination of other forms of
- 46:43misconduct. Great. Thank you, Judge Saab. And
- 46:47I do have a question here regarding its... Or
- 46:51in the Olin case, are there practical red flags
- 46:54attorneys should recognize in their own communications
- 46:56before they cross into Section 6106 Moral Turpitude
- 47:00Territory? Well, definitely. You know, if you
- 47:05decide to call, ask the judge if you've been
- 47:08bribed or corrupt or make false accusations against
- 47:12the judge, you may be crossing the line according
- 47:15to Olin and other cases that we've had before
- 47:18the court. I had a little case, the matter of
- 47:22Nancy Sussman and Ms. Sussman went on a campaign
- 47:27to attack some judges in the San Diego Superior
- 47:30Court. And if you read that the Sussman decision
- 47:34and read the Olin decision, you'll be able to
- 47:37determine that there is, remember there is, you
- 47:40do have your first amendment. freedom of expression.
- 47:44And that is all attorneys, including attorneys,
- 47:47all citizens including attorneys. Disciplinary
- 47:50rules governing the legal profession cannot punish
- 47:52activity protected by the First Amendment. But
- 47:56remember that free speech is not absolute. And
- 48:00you could have speech that's otherwise entitled
- 48:04to full constitutional protection. That speech
- 48:06may nonetheless be sanctioned if it obstructs
- 48:09or prejudices the administration of justice.
- 48:12So you have to be careful in how far you take
- 48:16your speech. Another case that the court heard,
- 48:21what was that case? Let me think. Can't think
- 48:25of a case right now. But there are other cases
- 48:28that the court has heard regarding speech and
- 48:30attorneys. And so just be careful when you keep
- 48:36in mind that computing specific criminal or other
- 48:41wrongful acts are not entitled to constitutional
- 48:44protection, even if you phrase it as an opinion.
- 48:49But in these particular cases, the prosecutor
- 48:53must prove that the false statements are false,
- 48:58right? So in other words, you make a statement,
- 49:00they have to prove initially that it's a false
- 49:02statement. But if you make a knowingly false
- 49:06statement, and the statement or the statements
- 49:09made with reckless disregard for the truth, you
- 49:12do not enjoy constitutional protection. So just
- 49:16be mindful that you do have your constitutional
- 49:18freedom of expression, but it's limited as attorneys.
- 49:23Great, thank you. And I have a question here
- 49:25as well about Rule 8 .3. How should attorneys
- 49:29navigate the tensions between Rule 8 .3 and duties
- 49:33of confidentiality, especially in firm or client
- 49:35contexts? So again, the court has not seen this
- 49:39rule in a case. The rule of client confidentiality
- 49:47is the greatest rule you probably have as attorneys.
- 49:51And so you definitely cannot violate that rule.
- 49:55But there may be information that you discover,
- 49:59you have credible evidence that is outside that
- 50:02confidentiality. And in that particular case,
- 50:07the duty requires you without undue delay to
- 50:11report that, this conduct of dishonesty, fraud,
- 50:15deceit, intentional misrepresentation or reckless
- 50:19misrepresentation or misappropriation of funds.
- 50:22So if you discover that prior counsel misappropriated
- 50:26funds and you have credible evidence of that,
- 50:30then, and I don't see how that may violate attorney
- 50:36-client privilege, then you would have a duty
- 50:38to report that. But keep in mind that your duty
- 50:42of client confidentiality is paramount, and it
- 50:47supersedes probably every other rule you have.
- 50:55For a alternative discipline program, how rigorously
- 51:00is the nexus between misconduct and mental health
- 51:04or substance abuse use evaluated? So, I don't
- 51:09think it's that difficult to show. If, for example,
- 51:14it's a lawyer who has a multiple driving influence
- 51:18of alcohol or drugs, that often doesn't even
- 51:23require anything. because the convictions themselves
- 51:25and the Supreme Court ordering programs related
- 51:29to that substance abuse is often enough for certain
- 51:32judges. But if not, if it's outside that, say
- 51:36it's a discharge of a firearm somewhere and you
- 51:39want to show the connection, you often show it
- 51:42by a declaration from the attorney and a professional.
- 51:46And that professional could be a therapist, could
- 51:48be a marriage and family counselor, it could
- 51:51be a psychiatrist. And so oftentimes that nexus
- 51:55is established by a declaration from the attorney
- 51:58and a professional. And the goal of the program
- 52:05is to help the attorneys rehabilitate. There's
- 52:10been a recent amendment to the program and that
- 52:13is that the disqualifying or the ineligibility
- 52:18grounds for misconduct involving moral turpitude
- 52:22have been eliminated. Before, if you're charged
- 52:25with moral turpitude, you often are not able
- 52:31to become admitted into ADP. But this has all
- 52:38been resolved in favor of ammunent lawyers, even
- 52:42if they're charged with moral turpitude. Why?
- 52:45Because the court wants to see an increase of
- 52:47these individuals. If you want to learn more
- 52:50about ADP, our rules of procedure, specifically
- 52:54rule 5 .380, lay out the information regarding
- 53:02ADP. And those are confidential proceedings,
- 53:04so you're not going to be able to log on to the
- 53:07state bar court and look at the calendar and
- 53:09be able to watch these proceedings. But look
- 53:12at those rules there in 5 .380. And it's rare
- 53:19for me to see a lawyer that cannot establish
- 53:24a nexus. In fact, I don't know if I've ever seen
- 53:27a lawyer not establish a nexus. So it's not that
- 53:29difficult. And hopefully I answered your question
- 53:32about establishing nexus between misconduct and
- 53:35substance abuse or mental health. Great. So it
- 53:38looks like we just have one question left. What
- 53:41would you say distinguishes attorneys who successfully
- 53:44navigate the process from those who end up with
- 53:47the more severe discipline? You know, it's helpful
- 53:50to have an attorney represent an attorney. there's
- 53:55specific attorneys that deal with State Bar Court
- 53:58defense. They often know what a case is worth
- 54:01sometimes more. So navigating with an attorney
- 54:04that's experienced at the State Bar Court is
- 54:08very helpful. I just often see the same attorneys
- 54:13appear before us because it's a small community.
- 54:17So to navigate the court, it's often best to
- 54:22be represented by counsel. But it's expensive
- 54:25and I understand not all attorneys can afford
- 54:28defense counsel, but at least you should consult
- 54:31with defense counsel to determine, give you ideas
- 54:35of the case and how to navigate the defense of
- 54:37the case. If you decide to represent yourself,
- 54:41then, of course, become familiar with the rules
- 54:44of practice, rules of procedure. I'm not saying
- 54:47you have to read every case law out there on
- 54:48the issue, but be familiar with our rules of
- 54:53procedure, rules of practice. Be familiar with
- 54:54aggravation and mitigation that are additional
- 54:57factors that the court considers. Be familiar
- 55:00with the standards that we try to follow, but
- 55:03we don't have to follow them exactly. And that
- 55:06is those standards. of attorney discipline are
- 55:10located again at the rules of procedure. So navigating
- 55:14helps worse if you have competent counsel. And
- 55:19sometimes I guess it might be better than representing
- 55:23yourself is to have maybe a friend that's a lawyer
- 55:25represent you. If he or she is willing to represent
- 55:28you, that could bring a fresh set of eyes to
- 55:31the case. You have a different perspective because
- 55:34now you're not so and broiled in the matter,
- 55:39right? And so it helps. It creates a buffer zone
- 55:41between you and the prosecutor so that you're
- 55:43not so worried about statements you make that
- 55:46are going to be used against you. So at minimum,
- 55:50know the rules, learn the rules of procedure,
- 55:52rules of practice, seek a friend to assist you,
- 55:56best case scenario, hire competent counsel to
- 56:00represent you. Great. That's all for questions
- 56:06today. Do you have any other closing statements
- 56:09or anything you'd like to discuss about your
- 56:12presentation, Joshua? Well, the only thing I
- 56:14say is I invite everyone to, if you're bored,
- 56:17feel free to watch a trial. Trials, most trials
- 56:20are available. You can see them at the State
- 56:23Barcode website. It'll give you a Zoom link.
- 56:25watch a trial. If you have a case before the
- 56:28court, you have a judge, watch how the judge
- 56:30does trials. That should give you an indication
- 56:33of what you could expect if you do decide to
- 56:36go to trial. And the court does, I would say
- 56:39that there's any given week, there's at least
- 56:42a trial, maybe not this week, but there's trial
- 56:45going on. And so I invite members of the public
- 56:48and attorneys to watch trials, watch proceedings,
- 56:53become familiar with the court. Maybe you may
- 56:55be watching this presentation, but you had no
- 56:57idea that there is a state park court and what
- 56:59the court does. And the court does hear and decide
- 57:05cases that are brought by the prosecuting office.
- 57:10And the goal of the court, of course, is to decide
- 57:13cases fairly, correctly, and efficiently for
- 57:17the protection of the public, the courts, and
- 57:20the legal profession. So, thank you very much
- 57:22for spending your lunch hour with me. And I apologize
- 57:26if you heard the introduction twice. Due to our
- 57:30technical difficulties, I had to do that. Thank
- 57:32you. All right. Thank you. This concludes today's
- 57:35presentation. Thank you so much, Judge Saab,
- 57:37for an excellent presentation. And thank you
- 57:39so much to our audience for joining us today.
- 57:41Have a great day, everybody. Thank you. Have
- 57:43a great day.