Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Siege of Jerusalem 1187: The Peaceful Conquest
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked about Hattin, we've talked about Acre, Tyre — but the big one, Jerusalem, fell in October 1187, and it happened in a way that really surprised everyone. After the disaster at Hattin, the city was basically defenseless. Most of the noblemen were dead or captured. The garrison was a skeleton crew. Luna: Wait — so who was actually in charge inside Jerusalem? Lucas: That's the thing — the highest-ranking survivor was Balian of Ibelin. He'd been at Hattin, but he managed to escape. He actually got Saladin's permission to enter the city to retrieve his wife and children, on condition he wouldn't take up arms. But when he got there, the people begged him to lead the defense. So he sent word to Saladin — 'I broke my oath, do what you will' — and Saladin, to his credit, respected his honesty and let him stay. Lucas: So Balian had maybe sixty knights total. The rest were commoners, priests, old men. They knew they couldn't win a siege. Their hope was to negotiate a surrender with terms. Luna: And Saladin — after Hattin, he had every reason to demand unconditional surrender. Lucas: Exactly. The crusaders had slaughtered the city's Muslim and Jewish population in 1099. There was a real thirst for revenge among Saladin's troops. But Saladin himself seems to have been wary of a bloody assault. Sieges are unpredictable, and he knew if he stormed the walls, his men would go on a rampage. He wanted the city intact — especially the Dome of the Rock and al-Aqsa. Lucas: So he offered terms: surrender peacefully, and everyone could leave with their lives and some property. If they resisted, it would be massacre. Balian and the city council debated it for days. Luna: Why would they even hesitate? They had no army. Lucas: Pride, faith, desperation. Some believed reinforcements from Europe were coming. Others couldn't bear to give up the Holy City without a fight. And there was this one dramatic moment — Balian reportedly threatened to destroy the Dome of the Rock and the al-Aqsa Mosque, kill all the Muslim slaves, and fight to the death. Saladin's advisors were furious, but Saladin took it seriously. Lucas: Eventually a deal was struck. The city would surrender peacefully. In exchange, every Frank — that's what the Muslims called the crusaders — could buy their freedom: ten dinars for a man, five for a woman, one for a child. Those who couldn't pay would become slaves. Luna: That's still a lot of people enslaved. How many couldn't pay? Lucas: Our main sources — Ibn al-Athir on the Muslim side and the Itinerarium Peregrinorum on the Christian side — disagree. Ibn al-Athir says about seven thousand men were enslaved, plus women and children. The Christian accounts claim far fewer, maybe fifteen thousand total ransomed. The number of slaves was probably in the thousands. But compared to 1099, it was almost merciful. Lucas: Saladin's own brother, al-Adil, actually asked Saladin to give him a thousand slaves as a gift. Saladin agreed, and al-Adil immediately freed them. Other Ayyubid commanders did the same. There's a famous story about Saladin's son al-Afdal freeing a group of old Frankish women because they reminded him of his own nurse. Luna: That's a surprisingly human moment. But also — wait, this must have cost Saladin a fortune in lost ransom. Lucas: It did. And there were complaints from his emirs who wanted the spoils. But Saladin seems to have seen it as a strategic move — mercy now meant fewer reasons for European kings to come seeking revenge. And it worked, to some extent. The image of Saladin as a chivalrous enemy was born right here. Luna: So after the surrender — what happened? Did he just walk into the Dome of the Rock? Lucas: He did, on October 2nd, 1187. He had the cross removed from the dome — the crusaders had turned it into a church — and had it washed with rosewater. He prayed there, then went to al-Aqsa. The Templars had used it as their headquarters, so it took days to clean out the filth. He restored both as mosques. Lucas: For the Christian population, it was devastating. Thousands fled the city in a great exodus, heading for Tyre or Tripoli. Many were robbed on the road. But some, especially the Eastern Christians, were allowed to stay. Lucas: Now, if you've been following these conversations — about Saladin, the Crusades, the Middle East — you might wonder how we can keep producing episodes like this, ad-free and without a paywall. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that literally funds making this many episodes. It's a small group, but it keeps us independent and deep-dive focused. Luna: Yeah, I think a lot of people don't realize how much goes into sourcing the primary texts and checking the different accounts. It's not just summarizing Wikipedia. Lucas: Exactly. And that support lets us keep doing that. Anyway — back to Jerusalem. One of the most interesting details is how Balian and the other leaders managed to raise the ransom money. They melted down gold and silver from the churches, took loans from the Italian merchants who'd stayed in the city, and even borrowed from Saladin's own treasury. Luna: Wait, Saladin lent them money to pay the ransom? That seems counterintuitive. Lucas: It does, but it's true. Baha ad-Din mentions it. Saladin gave a loan of 30,000 dinars to the patriarch and other leaders to help ransom the poor. He didn't want a mass of destitute refugees flooding the countryside, causing chaos. Plus, it reinforced his image as a generous victor. Lucas: So the siege of Jerusalem wasn't really a siege at all — it was a negotiation with a deadline. And that's what makes it so different from Acre or Tyre. It shows Saladin's pragmatism — he could be ruthless when needed, but here he chose diplomacy. Luna: And it set the stage for the Third Crusade. I imagine Richard the Lionheart was probably furious that Jerusalem had been taken without a glorious last stand. Lucas: Absolutely. When news reached Europe, it was the catalyst for the Third Crusade. But interestingly, Saladin's lenient terms made it harder for the crusaders to rally support — he hadn't created the kind of martyrs that would have inflamed public opinion. That was probably deliberate. Lucas: In the end, Saladin held Jerusalem for just over a hundred years, until the Khwarezmian sack in 1244. But his conquest in 1187 was the high point of Ayyubid power, and it defined his legacy in both Muslim and Christian worlds. Even today, you see his image as the merciful conqueror. Luna: It's almost like he wrote the script for how a conqueror should act — if you want to hold a holy city, you don't desecrate it. Lucas: Right. And that's the lesson that still resonates. Jerusalem changed hands many times, but Saladin's occupation is remembered as one of the most orderly. Not that it wasn't a trauma for the people displaced — it absolutely was. But within the brutal norms of medieval warfare, it was a remarkable exception. Lucas: So there you have it — the fall of Jerusalem in 1187. Next time, maybe we'll look at what happened to the True Cross, which was lost at Hattin and never recovered. That's a story with its own strange twists. Luna: I'd love that. Thanks, Lucas.