Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Coming Soon on With Flying Colors
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Hey everyone, this is Mark Treychel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38I hope your summer is going well.
- 0:41It's finally cooled off a little bit across the country
- 0:44and that's a good thing.
- 0:46This is going to be a catch up call, if you will.
- 0:49I'm going to update you on some things coming down the road.
- 0:51I'm also going to talk about just listen to Callahan's.
- 0:55Quarterly, whatever they call it, Callahan's quarterly state of
- 0:58the industry, and I had a couple of takeaways from that data.
- 1:02That's always an interesting thing to take a look at from a first blush of what's
- 1:06going on quarterly and credit unions.
- 1:08All right, so what's coming up with with flying colors?
- 1:13Later this month, I have an episode coming out on field of
- 1:17memberships and new charters.
- 1:19And my guest on that will be Keith Stone of the finest federal credit union,
- 1:23and also an organizer and CEO of the New Jersey PBA federal credit union.
- 1:30I'll be joined on that with Rick Mumm, a former colleague of mine at NCUA who
- 1:34also does consulting on field membership and also with me with my clients.
- 1:41But anyway, that's coming up.
- 1:42We'll talk about the new charter process and how they were able to achieve the
- 1:46fastest new charter being approved in what we believe is the history of NCOA.
- 1:51At least going back to when they gave them out a dime a dozen back in the 60s.
- 1:55So in the last 40 years, let's say the quickest, but that's
- 2:00coming up at the end of August.
- 2:02Then in September, I have an episode on your called something
- 2:07like you're a code three.
- 2:09Now what followed by another episode called you're a code for now what we're
- 2:13seeing more code four is by the way, I'm very curious to see what the next
- 2:19quarterly round of data will show.
- 2:22I believe it'll show code threes are up.
- 2:24And for the first time, perhaps a material increase in code for assets.
- 2:29We also have an episode coming up.
- 2:32With the concept of NCOA is asking to meet with the credit unions
- 2:38board without staff present.
- 2:40Yes, indeed.
- 2:41That's happening far more frequently than I can ever recall at my times during NCOA.
- 2:46And I'll be discussing that.
- 2:48Those three podcasts I just mentioned, I'll be joined by members of my
- 2:51team, Steve Farr and Todd Miller.
- 2:54And you can expect to hear those episodes in September on Mondays.
- 2:59Other than Labor Day I'll probably put that one out on a Tuesday, but
- 3:03so that's coming down the pike.
- 3:04I've also, I'm going to be on a webinar coming up with the trade
- 3:08association and I'm going to be a guest on a couple other podcasts.
- 3:12And when that happens, I will alert you here.
- 3:14And of course on LinkedIn and perhaps on email, if you subscribe to my podcast.
- 3:20Email list.
- 3:21If you don't, I suggest that you ask that you get added by going
- 3:26to my website, marktreichel.
- 3:28com or reaching out to me on LinkedIn.
- 3:33It's hard to believe that with all the years in place now of doing the
- 3:38podcast this is the third calendar year.
- 3:40So by the end of the year, we'll have completed three years.
- 3:42We have 192 episodes live.
- 3:46With flying colors.
- 3:47And some of you are aware, I have a related podcast called Credit
- 3:52Union Regulatory Exams where it's an audio book style podcast.
- 3:58It's AI driven in that it'll be, for example, NCUA's priority letter.
- 4:04The AI part of it is it's an AI voice that I have coined Samantha shares as in
- 4:10a hat tip to the shares of credit union.
- 4:14And 99 percent of the time, you can't really even tell that she's AI.
- 4:19Occasionally you can, and I'm sure if you do listen, you'll pick that up.
- 4:22But if you like audio books and you want to study some of the NCUA.
- 4:27FDIC, OCC, other guidance out there.
- 4:31That's a good way to do it, whether you like to do it when you're
- 4:34working out walking or what have you.
- 4:36So if you haven't checked that out, I encourage you to check that out.
- 4:40But 46 episodes of that.
- 4:42So what's 46, 192 238 episodes combined of the two shows.
- 4:49So far and moving forward, we will if you subscribe you likely know that the
- 4:57With Flying Colors comes out on Monday FYI, Credit Union Regulatory Exam
- 5:02podcast typically comes out on Tuesday.
- 5:05And with the volume of podcasts that we have done now, there are several
- 5:11that are structured in a way that it's what I would call an evergreen topic.
- 5:16Evergreen meaning it always has relevance.
- 5:19Moving forward starting in September, actually this week, this past Monday,
- 5:25we issued an evergreen topic on 10 reasons why you, why NCUA should not
- 5:31regulate why NCUA should not regulate.
- 5:3410 reasons why NCOA should not regulate succession planning.
- 5:38And we are going to have coming in September without calling it a throwback
- 5:42Thursday on Thursdays, we will be issuing our evergreen podcasts topics.
- 5:49Some of them will be on fair landing.
- 5:51Some of them will be a commercial landing.
- 5:53But there's quite a big arsenal of those that we've built up over these
- 5:57three years, and we will have one of those coming out in September.
- 6:01More often than not every Thursday morning.
- 6:04So you'll have With Flying Colors on Monday, you'll have the Credit Union
- 6:07Regulatory Guidance Podcast on Tuesday, followed by With Flying Colors again
- 6:12on Thursday and again, those will be the evergreen topics on Thursday.
- 6:17All right.
- 6:17So I listened to Callahan talking about the data for this most recent quarter.
- 6:23And I'm going to flip to that.
- 6:25Real quick here.
- 6:27The numbers are generally I would say the numbers that they reported for the
- 6:30industry are better in the second quarter.
- 6:34Some things that caught my ear were that profitability was marginally better.
- 6:40Charge offs were flat.
- 6:41Net interest margin had improved a little bit.
- 6:45I'm curious about this.
- 6:47They indicated that more credit unions are hedging.
- 6:49I would say historically, not enough credit unions
- 6:52have taken advantage of that.
- 6:53Maybe because rates have gone up so much.
- 6:55It's been an aha moment for the industry.
- 6:58But this was ALM first that was doing this portion of their
- 7:01discussion and they indicated they have a lot more credit unions.
- 7:04Pursuing that product.
- 7:06I think that's a fabulous thing.
- 7:08And as a reminder, if you want to be in hedging, you need to, it's easier to
- 7:13do it when you're a code one or a code two, then if you're not a code one or
- 7:17a code two, cause then you need to get NCWA's approval and by then it can be
- 7:21painstakingly long to get that approval.
- 7:23You're better off again, doing it if you're a code one or code two.
- 7:26That, that would be my thought on that.
- 7:28Down to about 4, 600 credit unions, total assets, the 2.
- 7:323 billion.
- 7:34Interestingly, they showed and mentioned that loan growth had slowed to less
- 7:37than 4% over the last 12 months.
- 7:40And that had been over 12%.
- 7:43The last 12 months.
- 7:44So from June to June of 24 to June of 23, compared to June of 23 to June of 22.
- 7:51All right.
- 7:52The other takeaway was that share growth.
- 7:54Had improved.
- 7:55The previous 12 months, the chair growth was 1.
- 7:572 percent over the last 12 month period.
- 8:00It was 12 2.
- 8:017%.
- 8:02They're also very cautious to differentiate between
- 8:05the mean and the median.
- 8:06Of course, the mean is the average.
- 8:08The median is the middle most number.
- 8:11So if you're looking at 4600 credit unions, The median would be 2, 301 and
- 8:18the interesting part on that and probably the biggest takeaway from this was that
- 8:25while share growth on the average was 2.
- 8:287%.
- 8:29The median.
- 8:30So the middle most credit union.
- 8:33Shrunk 1.
- 8:3522%.
- 8:35And the middlemost credit union, they said the asset size of that was 59 million.
- 8:41By the way, the average credit union in assets is 500 million.
- 8:45Again they mentioned that 25 percent of the assets Of the industry we're in
- 8:50credit unions over 10 billion and that's only 21 credit unions So that's where
- 8:54the mean and the median can play havoc with these numbers But the big takeaway
- 8:58for me was that the median credit union meaning half of credit unions
- 9:03had at least a decline in shares of 1.
- 9:0622%.
- 9:06And of course, one thing that gets lost in having growth at 2.
- 9:097 percent as the mean if you're not growing as much as
- 9:15you're paying your members.
- 9:16So let's say.
- 9:17And I don't have this number here in front of me.
- 9:19They didn't mention what the cost of funds was or the cost of shares.
- 9:22But let's say the industry grew at 2.
- 9:257 percent over the last year.
- 9:27If the cost of funds was 2.
- 9:296%, that means share basically grew 10 basis points.
- 9:32If the cost of funds was 3.
- 9:345%, that means you actually shrunk dollar for dollar because you're
- 9:40basically not even retaining the dividends you're paying to your members.
- 9:43That's something I'm going to dig into.
- 9:45I haven't had a time to go look at the numbers and see
- 9:47what the actual share cost was.
- 9:49They didn't have it on one of their slides, but it's something
- 9:51I'm going to take a look at.
- 9:52Certificate growth is at 31%.
- 9:55Unrealized losses have come down from in the industry in totality from an 41
- 10:00billion unrealized loss to 30 billion.
- 10:03So what's that a decrease the 25 percent with rates likely according to all the
- 10:09to rates being down here shortly, that number should continue to get better.
- 10:14Another takeaway was borrowings had decreased a year over
- 10:18year from 6 percent to 5.
- 10:193 percent and cash reserves were being built up to about a 2%.
- 10:26They talked about real estate loans.
- 10:29Only being down slightly.
- 10:30Consumer loans were down 15%.
- 10:32Credit card loans were up 7%.
- 10:35HELOCs were up 20 percent and commercial loans were up 10%.
- 10:38A lot of discussion about most of these numbers look potentially alarming.
- 10:42However, when you compare to pre pandemic, they're really not that bad.
- 10:47But, the proof will be in the pudding to see what happens.
- 10:49Do we have a soft landing?
- 10:50Do we have a hard landing?
- 10:51Where does the election take us?
- 10:53Et cetera, et cetera.
- 10:54I'm looking forward to see what happens in code threes and code four.
- 10:58As I mentioned, we've got podcasts coming on out on the ramifications of those
- 11:03slipping to a three slipping to a four.
- 11:06Lastly, Callahan mentioned that charge offs are down and delinquency is up.
- 11:10So that's a quick take, a quick summary of kind of what's coming
- 11:14forward here for me from from this podcast, from my other podcast.
- 11:19Looking forward to getting some feedback on those other podcasts
- 11:22we've got already lined up.
- 11:23I think they're pretty exciting and I have some other some other ores in the
- 11:27water of some things I'll be adding to the podcast coming here in the fourth quarter.
- 11:31And perhaps In 2025.
- 11:34All right.
- 11:35That's it.
- 11:35That's a wrap as always.
- 11:37I really appreciate you listening.
- 11:38If you enjoy it, if you could alert your friends and peers, that would be great.
- 11:42And, or if you could rate us on iTunes, Apple podcasts five stars,
- 11:47hopefully if you'd have the opportunity to do that would help me out.
- 11:50I'd appreciate it.
- 11:51And that's it.
- 11:52That's Mark appreciate you listening, signing off with flying colors.
- 12:02Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 12:06your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 12:10of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 12:14If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 12:17out our services at marktreichel.
- 12:20com.