Latest / American Combat Files / Episode 4: Part 1 - James E. Nunn & The Battle of Champion Hill
Transcript
- 0:16Welcome to American Combat Files, where we bring America's
- 0:19military history directly to your living room, your
- 0:22classroom, or just your daily commute.
- 0:25This podcast is tailor made for homeschool educators, history
- 0:29enthusiasts, and researchers who live and breathe American
- 0:33history. I'm your host, Earl Richburg,
- 0:35and guess what? I love American military
- 0:38history. So strap yourself in.
- 0:40We're about to drop history right at your front door.
- 0:42Hey, quick note for our homeschool parents and
- 0:45educators, American Combat Files appreciates what you do for the
- 0:49kids you teach. Because of your sacrifices, we
- 0:52are linking free homework assignments in the show notes
- 0:55called The Briefing Room. You'll get free access to a
- 0:59complete 3 tiered Lesson plan for your students alongside the
- 1:03site of sources we use to build today's story.
- 1:07To access the Briefing Room homework link, just tap your
- 1:10phone screen, Scroll down just below the play button and click
- 1:13See more in the episode description.
- 1:16The Brief living room is there waiting for you.
- 1:18Now on to Episode 4, Part 1, Private James E 9 and the Battle
- 1:24of Champion Hill. Imagine lying prone in the dirt
- 1:30in the heat, wearing an itchy heavy wool uniform, clutching
- 1:34your musket rifle as Union artillery adjust their elevation
- 1:40to dial in their range to strike your position on the next round.
- 1:45You watch the first round, or what we call the test shot from
- 1:48the Union 12 pounder gun, splash harmlessly just ahead of your
- 1:54position. Then comes the second round,
- 1:56screaming through the air, slamming straight into Company C
- 2:00right next to your position. These men from the 34th Georgia
- 2:04Infantry took the full brunt of the blast, a wall of fire, iron
- 2:09and shrapnel tearing through the ranks, cutting them down like
- 2:13butter. Off in the distance, near the
- 2:15Champion Hill farmhouse, General Ulysses S Grant rides along his
- 2:20lines, directing his Union army as they prepare to charge the
- 2:24hill that you're lying on. On that hill called Champion
- 2:29Hill lies Private James E Nunn, frozen for a heartbeat by the
- 2:34sheer destruction that just erased Company C so close to
- 2:38your position. Holding an apex defensive
- 2:40position with Company E to keep Grant from taking Pittsburgh,
- 2:45James knew the reality of that day.
- 2:48Standing on Champion Hill in a Confederate Gray uniform with a
- 2:52big span, it meant there was a real chance you were not coming
- 2:57home On the opposite side. Back on the Union side of the
- 3:01battlefield near the Champion farmhouse, Private Thomas Nance
- 3:06of the 46th Indiana Infantry was being shouted at to get into
- 3:11position. Explosions rocked the ground all
- 3:14around his unit. Just as Nance reached the line,
- 3:17a Confederate solid shot ripped through the air, hitting a Union
- 3:21ammunition case on dead on. The blast slam Nance face down
- 3:26to the dirt. He was stunned, disoriented, so
- 3:30he scrambled to his feet just as a second shell smashed into a
- 3:33nearby gun team, killing two artillerymen instantly.
- 3:37The explosion sent heavy debris hurling through the air,
- 3:41narrowly missing his commander and 1st Sergeant.
- 3:44He got to know so well as the caisson shattered into
- 3:47splinters. Confederate Private James E Nunn
- 3:51and Union Private Thomas Nats were both Americans, but on this
- 3:56bloody Saturday in Mississippi, they stood locked on opposite
- 4:00sides of a brutal conflict. Enemies, at least for today.
- 4:05That was the reality of May 16, 1863.
- 4:10Two young men fighting for what they believed was right.
- 4:14We can't know every thought in their minds.
- 4:16Some fought for their home state, some for political
- 4:19ideals, some to protect or maybe dismantle the institution of
- 4:24slavery, and other simply because they were given no
- 4:27choice. In 25 years of research, I have
- 4:31found no records that Confederate private James E 9
- 4:35ever owned a single slave. He was a small family farmer
- 4:40struggling to feed his family in Jackson County, Georgia.
- 4:43Sitting here today, looking back across decades, it feels like a
- 4:47war that never should have happened.
- 4:49American against American, caught up in a storm driven by
- 4:53rich southern plantation owners and northern industrial elitist.
- 4:57I studied the story with a sense of disbelief.
- 5:00And I study it because Private James E Nunn, Company E, 34th
- 5:05Georgia Infantry, was my great, great grandfather.
- 5:08Stand by folks. I have a quick personal note to
- 5:11share. James E 9 was the subject of
- 5:15countless stories my grandmother shared with me when I was a
- 5:18young boy sitting on the front porch swing during those hot
- 5:22Georgia nights. My grandma Esther was a master
- 5:25storyteller and every time my family went down to visit, I sat
- 5:28in all listening to her speak. Also, her deep faith in Jesus
- 5:32Christ, prepared with the raw tales of granddaddy nuns
- 5:35hardships, planted the seed in me to explore his history and
- 5:39the journey he walked. My mother Elizabeth also
- 5:42influenced me just as deeply to her own unwavering faith in
- 5:45Jesus Christ. Little did I know back then that
- 5:48their devotion would one day lead me to become a follower in
- 5:52Christ myself, saving me from my own worldly struggles and
- 5:55teaching me to walk with Him. As much as I honor my mother and
- 5:59my grandmother for their influence, it is Jesus Christ
- 6:02who saved me. He gets all the glory because
- 6:05rescuing me, a Sinner like me, was truly a miracle.
- 6:08Now back to the story. May 16th, 1863, A suffocating
- 6:14human morning in central Ms. To the West, the fortress city of
- 6:18Vicksburg sits high on its Bluffs overlooking the
- 6:21Mississippi River, the absolute key to the Confederacy.
- 6:25To the east, Major General Ulysses S Grant has just burned
- 6:29down the state capitol. Jackson, Ms. Grant is executing
- 6:33one of the most audacious, relentless land campaigns in
- 6:37military history, serving his own supply lines, marching to
- 6:40the heart of enemy territory and forcing A showdown.
- 6:44He knows that capturing Vicksburg will choke off the
- 6:47Confederate steamboats that are supplying troops up and down the
- 6:51Mississippi River. The standing directly in Grants
- 6:53Path is a modest cresting Ridge known locally as Champion Hill.
- 6:58At the time, the hill and its surrounding hundreds of acres
- 7:01belong to Sid Champion, and incredibly, that very land
- 7:05remains in the Champion family to this day.
- 7:08Blocking grants advance from Jackson, Ms. Moving West to
- 7:13Pittsburgh is Confederate Lieutenant General John C
- 7:18Pemberton. He's holding the high ground at
- 7:20Champion Hill. He's positioned along a critical
- 7:22line near the Crest, which is his division of Major General CL
- 7:27Stevenson. And tucked inside that division,
- 7:30Brigadier General Alfred Cummins brigade called 34th Georgia
- 7:35Volunteer Infantry. Along those Georgians stand a
- 7:38young man whose story we will track today, Private James E
- 7:43Nunn. He isn't a general.
- 7:44He doesn't wear gold braid or a Saber or make high level
- 7:48strategic decisions. He doesn't even ride a horse.
- 7:50He cures A musket, rifle, a canteen and a cartridge box.
- 7:54But on this bloody Saturday morning, the survival of an army
- 7:58and the fate of an entire Vicksburg campaign will come
- 8:01down to men just like James. Welcome to American Combat
- 8:04Files, folks. I'm your host, Earl Richburg.
- 8:06Today, in part one of our short American Civil War series, we
- 8:12examine the tactical setup, the terrain mechanics and the
- 8:15opening hours of the deadliest, most decisive battle of the
- 8:19Vicksburg campaign, the Battle of Champion Hill.
- 8:22Before we drop into Private Nuns position on the line, let's take
- 8:26a moment to understand who he was.
- 8:28To the history books, he was just another soldier in the 34th
- 8:32Georgia to me. As mentioned, he's my great,
- 8:35great grandfather on my mother's side.
- 8:37After more than 25 years of researching James E Nunn and the
- 8:41men he fought beside or alongside, I can promise you
- 8:45this. Their story is worthy of being
- 8:47taught and remembered. At his core, James is no
- 8:51different than you and me. He was a simple farmer with a
- 8:55family, a wife and kids in Jackson County, Georgia, living
- 8:58a quiet life until war arrived at his doorstep.
- 9:02When he marched away and he left his wife, Esther and three young
- 9:05daughters, Elizabeth, Georgia and holding.
- 9:08The sad news is he would never return and he would never see
- 9:12his family again. Oh, one of those hot Georgia
- 9:14nights sitting on my grandmother's porch swing.
- 9:16She tells the story that the women left behind Esther and the
- 9:20girls faced unimaginable hardships, including starvation
- 9:24and sometimes bitter cold. She had first hand stories from
- 9:28her Aunt Holdy, which she knew well as a little girl, which is
- 9:31amazing, who was one of James's daughters just mentioned.
- 9:34So these are second hand stories from my grandmother.
- 9:37And when I look at the official military records, they there's
- 9:39no conflict there. The official military records
- 9:42tell us that James face equal torment on the front line.
- 9:46He endured severe hunger, mistreatment, and disease.
- 9:50While a single podcast episode can't capture every detail of
- 9:53his journey, his life illustrates the true tragic cost
- 9:57of the American Civil War, how it fractured families and tore a
- 10:01young nation apart. James E Nunn, my great great
- 10:04grandfather, is a vital piece of our shared American history.
- 10:07In military strategy, terrain is everything.
- 10:10It dictates how you move, how you fight, and where you could
- 10:14die. Champion Hill is not what you
- 10:16might imagine. It sits as an isolated Crest,
- 10:19rising up almost out of nowhere in this flat stretch of southern
- 10:23Mississippi. Yet that single hill rising
- 10:26above the the surrounding terrain was high enough to
- 10:29command the entire landscape, making it the ultimate tactical
- 10:32prize for anyone who wanted to dominate their enemy.
- 10:36In May 1863, Champion Hill was a working farm sitting at a
- 10:40critical strategic junction. Three major roadways conversed
- 10:45in the shadow of its Crest, most notably the Jackson Rd. and the
- 10:50Raymond Roads. In the military chess match
- 10:52between Grant and Pemberton controlling.
- 10:54Champion Hill Mint controlling the crossroads and whip it the
- 10:58lifeline leading to Vicksburg. Stand by folks for a quick Intel
- 11:02drop. Here is how General Pemberton
- 11:06for the Confederate Army set his army into place before General
- 11:10Grant shows up at the battlefield.
- 11:12Pemberton formed his battle line across a three mile front facing
- 11:16east, anchoring the vital high ground at the Crest of Champion
- 11:21Hill, which was Major General CL Stevenson's division.
- 11:25Tucked inside Stevenson's line was General Alfred Cummings
- 11:29Brigade, which already told you composed of battle tested
- 11:32Georgia regiment including the 34th Georgia Volunteer Infantry.
- 11:37James E9 served in Company E of the 34th.
- 11:41Based on extensive research, James was positioned own or
- 11:45immediately adjacent to the Crest of Champion Hill along
- 11:48with his company, right at the focal point of the fighting.
- 11:51When James E 9 looked out from his position that morning, he
- 11:54should have seen the terrain was a maze of thick hardwood forest,
- 11:58deep ravines carved out by rainwater, and open cotton
- 12:02fields. He would have been able to watch
- 12:04as the Union Army showed up and place themselves into position.
- 12:08Back to the story, folks. Like so many men of the 34th
- 12:12Georgia, none came from a rural background.
- 12:16The 34th Georgia had been organized in the summer of 1861,
- 12:20drawing men from the hills and farms of northern Georgia.
- 12:23By May 1863, these weren't green recruits anymore.
- 12:27They were veterans. Combat veterans.
- 12:30They have survived long, hard marches, harsh winters, and
- 12:33deadly skirmishes. For Private None in his
- 12:35comrades, the morning began with an agonizing wait.
- 12:39The worst part of any battle. You sit in the dirt, usually in
- 12:42a hasty duck position, feeling the humidity rise.
- 12:45Listen to the scattered crack of skirmishers in the distance.
- 12:48But now they're getting closer. It has become clear that a
- 12:51massive Union army is deploying just down the hill when you're
- 12:55the farmhouse. At around 10:30 AM, the storm
- 12:59broke. Major General Ulysses S Grant
- 13:01launched his main attack against the opposite end of the
- 13:05Confederate line, the Crest of Champion Hill itself.
- 13:08His general, General Alvin P Hobies Union Division supported
- 13:12by General John A Logan. The Union army charged up the
- 13:16steep slope of Champion Hill. The combat on the Crest was
- 13:20savage, hand to hand point blank fighting Hobies men smashing the
- 13:25Confederate line pushing close to the hill.
- 13:27Pembrokes Confederate Army was on the verge of losing the hill
- 13:31and the escape routes back to Vicksburg.
- 13:33So in a desperate move, Pemberton sent urgent orders
- 13:37down the line to Lawrence Division on the other side. 1st
- 13:41order send reinforcements to the left immediately the hill was
- 13:44falling. The 2nd order shift the entire
- 13:46line to the left. The 2nd order was a big mistake
- 13:49folks. Official records advised that
- 13:51Pemberton was obsessed with preventing his army from getting
- 13:54out flanked by Grant's army. So much so that he spread his
- 13:58line too far apart, causing major gaps along that three mile
- 14:03line. Remember that I mentioned
- 14:05earlier? Pemberton already set up his
- 14:07Army owner Three Mile line to cover the Raymond Road to the
- 14:10South and the rail line to the north, so he should have been
- 14:13content with this, at least to the point that he should not
- 14:16have stretched his line so thin. The 1st order made sense.
- 14:20Send reinforcements to the left immediately.
- 14:22This order is basically calling for what we call today, a Quick
- 14:26Reaction Force or QRF. However, in today's United
- 14:30States Army, a QRF is a dedicated team specifically
- 14:33designed to react if team members need help or bailing out
- 14:36team members that are losing ground.
- 14:38However, some of Pemberton's orders were not followed and
- 14:41some of them never made it to where he wanted them to go.
- 14:44Keep in mind, if you're managing a three mile defensive line, you
- 14:48have to rely on runners on horseback to deliver the
- 14:51message. Commanding generals during these
- 14:53times had several runners assigned to them that would
- 14:56deliver the orders verbally or sometimes in writing.
- 15:00But in this battle some of the orders were not followed and
- 15:03they never arrived. This is where the breakdown of
- 15:06communications failed on Champion Hill.
- 15:09General Loring did not know what was happening on Champion Hill
- 15:14because he was self covering the Raymond Road to make sure they
- 15:18didn't get out flanked in the South, so he hesitated.
- 15:22He argued that Union troops were threatening his own front along
- 15:26the Raymond Road, so we sent the runner back to Peminton arguing
- 15:30that he needed to stay in place. This was a big mistake and later
- 15:33the two generals blamed each other for causing the loss of
- 15:36champion Hill. This back and forth caused
- 15:39precious time that slipped away while the officers argued and
- 15:43messages race back and forth along the Dustville roads.
- 15:46Private James E Nunn and the men of Company E 34th Georgia.
- 15:50They were fighting for their lives in close combat.
- 15:52Within a few hours of fighting and each side taking the Crest
- 15:56of Champion Hill and then losing it again just to only take it
- 16:00back again 'cause the death of Sunny on both sides.
- 16:03As midday approach on May 16th, 1863, the hill was slipping away
- 16:08for the Confederates. No doubt about that.
- 16:11The QRF never showed and the order shipped created large gaps
- 16:15in the line. Now the line was cracking and
- 16:18thousands of Union bayonets were pushing over the Crest again.
- 16:22Private James E 9 and the 34th were caught in the confusion of
- 16:25conflicting orders, and Union soldiers intermingled in their
- 16:29positions. Now on the other side, Private
- 16:32Nets, Private Thomas Nets from Indiana, was out of breath.
- 16:37His mouth was so dry from the brisk run up the slope of
- 16:40Champion Hill. That's in the 46th.
- 16:43Indiana finally reached the Crest and discovered that they
- 16:46were exposed to Confederate fire and the bayonet.
- 16:49There was no organized volleys or no organized formations.
- 16:53There was only survival. Kill or be killed.
- 16:56Nance was amazed at how close he arrived on the hill and how
- 17:00close he was to the rebels within 15 feet in some cases.
- 17:04Back to the 34th Georgia. James pulled the hammer back and
- 17:07took aim at one of the men in blue directly in front of him.
- 17:11James pulled the trigger ever so lightly, just as his father
- 17:15Lemule told him back in Georgia when he was a young boy.
- 17:19The hammer slam forward, striking the percussion cap,
- 17:22causing the predicted explosion. The rifle stopped lunging to his
- 17:25shoulder, and James held the sights as stand as he could on
- 17:28his target. James's infield fired almost
- 17:31simultaneously with his company delivering a wall of steel on
- 17:35the Union skirmishes. Smoke filled the air, but James
- 17:38could still see the shocking image of Union soldiers being
- 17:42butchered from the firepower back to the Indiana side.
- 17:45Private Nance hands were shaking as he took aim, waiting for the
- 17:49command of fire. The command never came, but when
- 17:52it did, it was too late. The Georgia soldiers laid down
- 17:55another wall of steel on his regiment with devastating
- 17:58effects. Nance heard the mini balls
- 18:01whistling by him on his right hand side.
- 18:03The bullet shrieked by and then fucked into Private Welch to his
- 18:07right, one of his friends. Nance broke focus for a moment
- 18:11and turned to watch Private Welch falling backwards,
- 18:14lifelessly limp. The round hit him directly in
- 18:17the forehead. Back to the 34th.
- 18:19Company was running low in ammunition and then the men were
- 18:22thirsty and battered. The bayonet became their only
- 18:24remaining weapon. Just in time before they were
- 18:27slaughtered, the order to retreat or withdraw was given,
- 18:30and that retreat was actually an attempt to Sprint to the Creek.
- 18:34Low on ammunition, low on water, and the men were completely
- 18:38exhausted. Stand by folks for a quick
- 18:40update. No folks, that dramatic back and
- 18:44forth between Confederate private James E Nunn and Union
- 18:49private Thomas Nance is historical fiction.
- 18:52I framed it that way to give you a front row seat to what this
- 18:55battle felt like up close, using my great great grandfather to
- 18:59anchor the story. But make no mistake folks, the
- 19:02names, the regiments, the unit positions, and the order of
- 19:06battle are 100% historically correct.
- 19:10Brutal reality of close combat and the final outcome on that
- 19:15hill is grounded entirely in documented history.
- 19:19We know the charging Indiana men strunk Company E line with a
- 19:23fierce collision of bayonet thrust and blows from the butts
- 19:27of their muskets. The Georgia men stood and fought
- 19:30back face to face, hand to hand. The fighting on Champion hill
- 19:34was savage, lasting for hours at this stage of the battle.
- 19:38Confederate counter attacks actually drove the Union lines
- 19:41back off the Crest multiple times, but because of
- 19:45Pimperton's order to shift left, creating gaps, creating the line
- 19:49being too thin and Grant refused to yield, he aggressively
- 19:54regrouped his forces and launched 3 full brigades
- 19:58straight up the middle of the line, straight up the Crest of
- 20:02Champion Hill. This shattered the Federate line
- 20:05and it unleashed total chaos. What followed wasn't a tactical
- 20:09withdrawal at all, it was men running for their absolute
- 20:12lives. Back to the story.
- 20:15The Confederate line collapsed and the order to retreat
- 20:19dissolved into instant panic. Union and Confederate soldiers
- 20:22were intermingled in the dense haze and thick smoke that
- 20:25blinded everyone, including the officers giving orders.
- 20:29Wounded Confederate soldiers who couldn't keep up or left behind
- 20:32and captured others were taken prisoner while trying to drag
- 20:35injured comrades to safety, their pace overrun by Union
- 20:39troops and hot pursuit Men were shot in the back as they ran,
- 20:43driving the panic even deeper. Paper.
- 20:45What had been the organized discipline?
- 20:4734th Georgia Infantry broke into a scattered, terrified mob.
- 20:51In reality, the visual command wasn't a retreat, it was a
- 20:54withdrawal. Order.
- 20:55Fall back to the West side of Baker's Creek and regroup on the
- 21:00opposite side of the bank so we can attack again.
- 21:02But between a written order on paper and the terrifying reality
- 21:06on the ground, discipline vanished into the smoke.
- 21:09With Champion Hill lost, General Grant turned his sights
- 21:12immediately directing onto the ultimate prize.
- 21:15Vicksburg, Ms. For the retreating Confederates, Baker's
- 21:19Creek became a deadly bottleneck.
- 21:21Official military records Telegram Story Nearly every
- 21:25southern soldier caught on the east side the alongside of that
- 21:29Creek was either killed, wounded, or captured.
- 21:32The official record of the 34th Infantry at the Battle of
- 21:35Champion Hill. 142 killed, 314 wounded, 539 captured.
- 21:42Officially, military records confirm that my great great
- 21:46grandfather Private James E Nunn was captured on that day by
- 21:49Union forces along with his uncle Augustus Nunn.
- 21:53What makes this tragedy even deeper is a detail we haven't
- 21:58touched on yet. James's younger brother, Reuben
- 22:01Nunn, had already died of typhoid fever during the
- 22:04Cumberland Gap campaign prior to Champion Hill.
- 22:09All three men, brothers and uncle, has stepped forward and
- 22:12volunteered together. On the exact same day, from the
- 22:15mud of Mississippi, James E Nunn and his uncle Augustus were
- 22:19shipped north as prisoners of war bound for Camp Morton,
- 22:23Indianapolis, Indiana. The conditions inside Camp
- 22:26Morton were brutal, but the journey to get there was a
- 22:30nightmare of its own. Transported by railroad
- 22:33companies like the Harrisburg and Philadelphia Railroad
- 22:36Company, the prisoners received no food, no water, and 0 basic
- 22:40care men were crammed into locked box cars far beyond
- 22:44capacity, gasping for air in the sweltering heat.
- 22:47Kept completely in the dark about their destination, they
- 22:51only knew one thing. Each passing mile carried them
- 22:53further and further from their home.
- 22:56But if James and Augustus thought Camp Morton was the end
- 22:59of the line, they were wrong. Within just a few weeks of their
- 23:03arrival, conditions inside the camp deteriorated so rapidly
- 23:07that Union authorities began emptying the cells or the pins.
- 23:12The men were marched out, forced right back into a suffocating
- 23:15rail car and shipped off once again headed for another unknown
- 23:19destination. And that's what we pick up our
- 23:22next episode with the raw documented history of life on P
- 23:27Patch Island, Fort Delaware Prison, Delaware River in Part
- 23:312, James E Nunn, POW, Fort Delaware.
- 23:35Thank you for tuning into this episode of American Combat
- 23:38Files. I'll be your host, Earl
- 23:39Richburg. Remember, studying our history
- 23:42is vital to ensuring we don't repeat its mistakes.
- 23:44Keep digging into the past as we strive to become the men, the
- 23:48women, parents and leaders God called us to be.
- 23:51If you haven't sweated your life to Jesus Christ, I encourage you
- 23:54to take that step. Learn more about the salvation
- 23:57found only in Him today. We will see you then, folks.
- 24:02God bless.