Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Over Sticker Damage, CarPlay Pizza, Unintended Starbucks Consequence
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Yo, it's Tuesday. It's a beautiful, beautiful Tuesday in Nashville- Woo... and Syracuse, so most of the East Coast.
- 0:07Today we're talking about what happens when you sell vehicles over sticker, CarPlay ordering pizza, and Starbucks drink consequences. [laughs] Aw. Starbucks drinks have consequences, Kyle.
- 0:21I feel like we're gonna get in trouble this week. Oh my gosh. I feel like we need- Well- You know, we need the PR team to come out- No... and the whole nine yards. That is the name of the show.
- 0:31[laughs] It is the name of the show, so [laughs] I guess if we weren't- There you go... getting in trouble- Little troublemaker We're not even doing it right.
- 0:36Uh, making, we're gonna be making a little trouble at noon Eastern today. Yeah. We're gonna be, uh, live streaming the, uh, the ASOTU Live Tonight event that we did last week.
- 0:46We're gonna be, yeah, playing it again, uh, lunchtime. Where are we playing it? Is it LinkedIn, YouTube, Facebook, or is it just LinkedIn? Facebook or a- wherever you get- Airware... your streams. Yeah.
- 0:55[laughs] Airwhere you get your streams, Paul. [laughs] So, so noon Eastern, uh, and you can adjust accordingly. We're gonna replay it. We're gonna be in the comments and have a little fun. Um, it's just such a fun show.
- 1:04I- I- If anything, just tune in for, like, the first 10 minutes because the first 10 minutes- Just gi- yeah, just give it 10 minutes and see what you think- Yeah, right... and then you might hang out for a hot minute.
- 1:12[laughs] You know? See if you... [laughs] We see what you think, see what you say. Um, we have a, a network-style TV show that we're editing right now. We shot it last week.
- 1:20We're gonna be premiering it in Tampa in just, like, three weeks from today. Oh. Is it three weeks from today? It's gonna be so good. It is? Something like that. It's a Tuesday night, right? Three weeks from today.
- 1:29Yeah, it's Tuesday. Holy cow. [laughs] I know, I know. We have some work to do. We have some work to do. We got some work to do. Especially since the show isn't even titled yet. We'll be, uh- It's not titled yet.
- 1:37We'll be okay. But we know the premise. We got this. We got... Yeah. You can go to asotux.com, uh, get tickets. It's really affordable tickets. Mm-hmm. We're having a happy hour and kind of the party.
- 1:45If you were in Digital Dealer, we did the family reunion. We're gonna kinda, like, do that but at the Tampa Theater. We're gonna get dressed up. We're gonna ask you to get dressed up and, like, show everybody.
- 1:54When you show up, everybody go, "Hmm, he cleaned up kinda nice." [laughs] Cleaned up kinda nice. Cleaned up nice. There you go. There you go. So we're gonna do that at asotux.com. Um, and it...
- 2:02Okay, it's time to get in trouble. It's time to get in trouble. Let's get in trouble. All right, all right, all right. Here it comes. A- And so here, let's just, just gird, gird yourself, everyone.
- 2:09A recent GFK survey- I'm not even gonna read the comments, Paul Reve- I'm not even reading the comments. [laughs] Reveals... I'll start over.
- 2:15A recent GFK survey reveals that 34% of customers paid more than sticker price, you already know where we're going in the direction now, paid more than sticker price for a new vehicle in December of 2022, a trend that might hurt repeat business for car dealers and automakers.
- 2:30About 27% of the people who paid above sticker said they would never buy that brand again. Oh. That's not from that dealership. Not from that dealer. It's that brand. That brand. Whoa.
- 2:4431% of people who paid over sticker would advise others to avoid that specific dealership, and 29% plan to never use that dealership for service.
- 2:54Uh, Julie Keanour, GFK senior vice president of consulting, told Automotive News, um, on March 15th that paying sticker doesn't, um... [lips smack] Okay, paying sticker doesn't, she, she used the word engender.
- 3:06It doesn't... I don't even know what other word to use there. I don't even know what that means. [laughs] It doesn't, it doesn't solicit the same backlash as paying above sticker.
- 3:15So if you pay sticker price, the second you pay a dollar over sticker price, she says there's a much bigger lift in negative feelings. The second you pay a dollar over sticker, um- Wow...
- 3:25and dealers are really mixed on this. We know this. We have dealers- Oh, yeah. No, I know... that are great operators on both sides of this argument.
- 3:31So, uh, there are a few, few people quoted in this Automotive News article.
- 3:34Rod, Rob Shub, Fix Ops director of Murphy Ford in Chester, Pennsylvania, thinks it's possible that dealers who charge above sticker might be undercutting their service department. Data seems to show that.
- 3:44Uh, Keith Powell, owner of Yes Chevrolet and Yes Ford near Charleston, West Virginia, uh, calls charging over sticker, he says it's a bad look, and says it's not good for CSI, it's not good for customer retention, he says particularly in a small town- Mm-hmm...
- 3:57which makes a whole lot of sense, right? Everybody talks. Everybody knows and everybody remembers. Yeah.
- 4:01Uh, however, one dealer, Doug Wells, GM of Mercedes-Benz of Edison, doesn't charge above sticker but says he doubts it will, it will really detract from their service department.
- 4:11That kinda makes sense coming from a highline dealer, right? Right. You know? Yeah, because you only got one. Everybody services there. Right. That's, that's the thing. And, and so- You know, it-...
- 4:19th- this is kind of the clincher, though. Of all the demographics in the study, millennials and people that have a household income of over 150,000 have paid over sticker most often. So- Which makes a lot of sense.
- 4:32I mean, y- if, if you want the vehicle and you have- 'Cause you can... the resources. Absolutely. Supply, demand, resources. That's the...
- 4:39I mean, so that's, like, it doesn't blow my mind there, and especially all the new money in the millennial, um, kinda generation. But, uh, it, he- here's the thing.
- 4:49People hear basically percentages right around and hovering around the 30% of people that would not do business again. This is what's dangerous for me.
- 4:57Like, that's a fairly small number out of 100%, and you're like, "But I got 70% left of which that I can convince to, to, to buy in."
- 5:04When our numbers as an industry are already so low from a retention perspective, uh, looking at new cars under 30, uh, you know, uh, around, under and around 30% and used cars at under 10% to dealership retention for the next purchase, cutting out 30% on the top of that- Mm...
- 5:22is a dangerous proposition for anyone that's looking to drive customer life cycle, reduce cost of acquisition.
- 5:28Uh, and I, you know, we still have yet to see the fallout of this, I mean, with so many people across the board kind of, like, balancing this.
- 5:36We'll, uh, we're still probably two, three years from really understanding what it's done to the retention numbers both on brand and, uh, and per dealership. Mm-hmm.
- 5:44And not just that, but we have a whole new slew of vehicles that's coming out, so we may see these retention numbers balanced by new opportunities- That's true...
- 5:52to purchase in the e- That's a really good insight right there. Um, so it's still, it's still yet to be determined.
- 5:58I think the, the anecdotal note is that- Consistently, we've heard from customers, and we've seen online, and we've seen the reviews that this has a, a, this has a definite significant impact to the, the quality of customer life cycle.
- 6:14So, um, and we're kind of coming out of this. At this point, there's not many dealers that are charging over sticker. We're actually seeing, like, deep discounts similar back to 2018, 2019.
- 6:23So it's a little bit of a moot point on, on the, on the intention of dealers at this point. It depends on the br- But- It depends on the brand, though. I mean- It does depend on the brand, without a doubt...
- 6:29'cause in February, one data point from the article said, "In February, the average vehicle sold for 102.8% of sticker." Th- So it's still- Which is wild... it's still, it's still there. Yeah.
- 6:40But obviously, it goes brand by brand, right? Yep.
- 6:42And then, then you see, uh, like many brands like Toyota really doing the de- dig into their data, and it was, like, late last year, they were like, "Hey, dealers that charge over sticker doubled their profits, and dealers that charged sticker or below tripled their profits."
- 6:57[laughs] So Toyota just came out swinging with that. And, and just- Either way, like you said- Just, just screaming at me with that, yeah... we'll, we'll see what ha- Time will tell.
- 7:02But, uh, it was interesting insight you had with the, the new vehicle product coming to market and the EV transition. Yeah.
- 7:07Like, there is definitely going to be this, this maybe new reason for people to check out a brand- Yeah... that they just, because they have the car. Again, you have the product. You have a great product, guess what?
- 7:17You don't have to worry about it. That's kind of how it goes. There you go. Speaking of not having to worry about it. [chimes] Oops, wrong button. What's up? Wrong button. Segway. Too early. [upbeat music] All right.
- 7:26There're, there's so many fun parts about this, but Domino's Pizza continues to revolutionize the pizza ordering experience with the debut of its first of a kind CarPlay app. The app allows users to order- That's sick...
- 7:37their favorite pizza with a few taps on their vehicle's infotainment system. So now you don't need the phone. You can do it right from the CarPlay app.
- 7:44Uh, the app is highlighted in a, a new 30-second spot by the agency Work In Progress. We link it up in the show notes so you can check it out. Um, Domino's, this is cool.
- 7:52They've branded their commitment to letting pizz- people order pizza wherever they are. They call it AnyWare, A-N-Y-W-A-R-E. Like, you know, very clever. Um- That's cheeky. [laughs] Very cheeky, right.
- 8:04Um, so basically, you know, people can order on Alexa, Google Home, smart TVs, Apple and Android operating systems. You can order on Slack, Twitter. You can text them a pizza emoji, right? It's, like, so much fun.
- 8:15But now the CarPlay app, um, [smacks lips] and so- That's wild... uh, incent- to incentivize people to use this app,
- 8:22they're offering special pricing for people who download the app and, like, plug in the CarPlay and order from the CarPlay thing, which is pretty cool, and the commercial shows how it is.
- 8:29The irony, Kyle, the straight irony, and you know where this is going. Domino's just bought a bunch of Chevy Bolts- [laughs]... EVs- That's what I was, I was about to go there. It's so good...
- 8:39to, to deliver their pizzas, and then GM just announced last week that they're getting rid of CarPlay. It's like, I tell you- And now it's-... that decision's coming back. We're gonna say it again. When it comes back.
- 8:49[laughs] Oh, it's way coming back. [laughs] They're gonna be like, "Skrrt, Domino's just messed it all up, yo." [laughs] Yeah, yeah. No, they didn't mess it up. This killed me. This killed me.
- 8:58The R&D department, listen, you should just run some ideas through this community. [laughs] We'll give you the, we're giving, save you, save you the... Or maybe you just wanna keep your PR team busy. I don't know.
- 9:06But, but I love- Yeah, I guess so, man... I think this is just indicative, though, of more things being built into the ecosystem of what you do in your vehicle, and whether that's through CarPlay- Yes...
- 9:16or through other apps and integrations. Um, like, the car is going to be, like we talked about, what, like zoom cameras and selfie ve- cameras and, you know- Yeah... all this stuff.
- 9:26The car, the technology is just going to become more immersive. It's the next evolution of what we saw with the phone in the early 2000s, right?
- 9:34It went from phone to everyday device that operates everything that you touch, and the car is gonna go that way, connected services, app-based services, the ability to do things on the road, on the drive.
- 9:46And with remote work becoming, you know, a thing that's more and more acceptable- Mm-hmm... we're gonna see more and more things connecting you to people and products within cars, and this is- And- I mean-... pizzas.
- 9:58[laughs] And people, products- Products, pizzas... and pizza, baby. [laughs] What else are we doing? What else are we doing? Oh, man. Speaking of what are we doing?
- 10:07Maybe it'll connect you to other things like- What's up? Segway. It's time. [upbeat music] [laughs] Who knows? Maybe it'll connect you to things like something that Starbucks has been doing.
- 10:20[laughs] We got a little recap on a story we ran a couple weeks ago. Uh, Starbucks recently launched its fancy new oil-infused co- olive oil-infused coffee, Oleato- Oleato... which is just a whole mouth full. Oleato.
- 10:33Urging cust- Oleato. Urging customers toward a unique experience and health benefits. However, some customers are feeling a slightly different urge- Different... after trying the beverages.
- 10:44Uh, still, Howard Schultz, CEO, uh, former CEO, added in an interview, "It's one of the biggest launches we've had in decades," um, and, uh, it said that it will transform the coffee industry and be a very new profitable addition to the company.
- 10:58Uh, one barista posted on a Starbucks Reddit page, and, and here's the kicker, that, "Half the team tried it," speaking of a local Starbucks, "yesterday, and a few ended up, mm, needing to use the restroom"- Pretty- "...
- 11:11if you know what I mean." [laughs] Pretty quickly. Pretty quickly.
- 11:15So basically, what they're citing is that the combination of caffeine, which is a stimulant, and olive oil, which is a relaxant, might be responsible for this restroom-inducing effect.
- 11:25A high fat content in the drinks could also be contributing to the problem, as it can cause cramping and increased colon mobility. Ooh. Paul, you ever thought you would say cramping and colon mobility on a podcast?
- 11:38[laughs] About Starbucks. About Starbucks. [laughs] No, cramping and mobility. Oh, man. Oh, I don't... Well, you know, Howard Schultz is just really kind of a genius businessperson, and his whole- Right...
- 11:49his whole path that he's taken to bring Starbucks, like the fact that we have lattes and espresso widely available in the US, is because he had this idea, like, "Hey, we should do this thing over here."
- 11:58And so the olive oil thing, you know, he's gotten on this health kick. He, you know, made friends with olive oil producers and this Mediterranean diet, and he was like, "This is gonna be my parting shot." Just...
- 12:09No pun intended, actually. [laughs] It's gonna be his parting shot- Hey, maybe it, maybe it was more of a weight loss routine and less of health benefits. Oh. [laughs] You know what I mean. You know what I mean.
- 12:19Come on, man. All, all the high school wrestlers are, uh, [laughs] are going with the coffee with olive oil. They're like, "Gotta drop three by this afternoon." Gotta weigh in. Starbucks. By weigh in. [laughs] Yeah.
- 12:28So I mean, we'll see. I mean, just like anything. I mean, like, there are plenty of dietary things out there where people just don't eat because they, you know, they encourage behaviors that are unwarranted.
- 12:39And, uh, I guess we'll see what happens here. But I mean, it's always... The, I mean, this isn't always the case when you try new things. I mean, maybe not, like, this result- Hey, early looks wrong, baby.
- 12:47Early s- early sometimes looks wrong. I, feels wrong. Who knows? We'll see. Smells wrong. I don't... [laughs] This one feels wrong. It, uh- Hey, that's a fun little recap. We had, we had to, we had to run it. Oh- So-...
- 12:57absolutely. Absolutely. So look, it's only Tuesday. We have a lot of work to do this week. Hopefully, we got you smiling a little bit. Join us at noon Eastern today on LinkedIn, YouTube, wherever the Asoto channel...
- 13:09Just search Asoto. We'll hang out a little bit, have some fun. [upbeat music]