Latest / The Team House / Has Israel Gone Too Far? | EYES ON | Ep. 17
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:06we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple or
- 0:10Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get recognized,
- 0:16and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really appreciate
- 0:19your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is to
- 0:24become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five dollars
- 0:29a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all of
- 0:32our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is the
- 0:41biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if you'd
- 0:47like to, and we really appreciate that. So go and check us out
- 0:51at patreon dot com Slash the Teamhouse. Hello everyone, Welcome to another episode
- 0:56of Izon. I'm Andy Miilba recentlyons Dimitri Tacos, Hello, Heydeed. So
- 1:04today I think we've got unfortunately lots of action in the in the Middle East
- 1:10to talk about you want to kick off about the strike in Damascus yesterday.
- 1:15Yeah, I mean everyone pretty much saw what happened already. Now, I
- 1:19mean Israel's kind of kind of brazen airstrike on the Iranian consulate that's our right
- 1:26next door of the Iranian embassy, which is also right next door to the
- 1:29Canadian embassy, killing seven you know IRGC. Yeah, yeah, it was
- 1:38Look, this was the you know, I'll jump to the chase. This
- 1:41was the most significant strike that the Israelis have conducted on Coods Force like ever.
- 1:53The top three field commanders within Kodes Force were killed. I'll say that
- 1:57again, the top three field commanders. Hussein Amanulla who was who was he
- 2:05was chief of staff for Syria and Lebanon, and then uh Rahimi hajj Rahimi,
- 2:10who's a you know, to say, a Koutsforce guy is controversial.
- 2:15Well, Rahimi's particularly controversial because his mandate is Palestine, right, and so
- 2:23a lot of discussion about whether he knew about these attacks, whether he was
- 2:27involved in them or not. The Israelis were convinced that that that Harmas did
- 2:31at least inform him inform that attacks were coming. They may not his Boa
- 2:37and Iran may have not realized this scale, but nevertheless soon became aware of
- 2:42them and reinforced them one hundred percent. So this is kind of revenge for
- 2:46that. And the third guy, third guy killed General Zahiti, all right,
- 2:54The Israelis called him Madabi. He's actually he's a former head of or
- 3:00Kuod's force in Syria and Lebanon, and he is he's actually rumored to be
- 3:07Cannee's successor. Cornee is a Cala, the head of Kotz force, so
- 3:13very very significant. I'll pause there, guys to see if you have any
- 3:16questions. Yeah, I was gonna sorry to drag you back to the beginning,
- 3:21but for those who don't know, can you give a little background on
- 3:23what Kud's force is? Yeah? Absolutely, And you know this term gets
- 3:29used a lot, so look just by way of creds. Okay, this
- 3:34doesn't make me an expert, but I'm one of probably one of the few
- 3:38US military guys I would venture perhaps the only one since aside from the hostages,
- 3:46who spent time in an Iranian jail. Okay, and now we've got
- 3:49to qualify that very brief period of time being questioned by the Revolutionary Guard as
- 3:55they were called then back soon after when the eleven years after the revolution,
- 4:01the beginning of the war with Iran, I was in Tehran, taken off
- 4:05a bus and questioned by them. Again, that doesn't make me an expert,
- 4:11but it does it removes any any reservations that may have about watching the
- 4:17organization they are, uh, because many other people at the time were disappearing.
- 4:23Anyway, cut to the chase, the the Revolutionary Guards, uh,
- 4:29the Iranian Revolutory Guards Court to give it its full title. You hear it
- 4:33referred to as the IRGC. I think of them as kind of, you
- 4:38know, the uh, the Islamic Revolutions version of the Republican Guard. UH.
- 4:45You know, the every revolution has a small group of the Jacobins,
- 4:49and the French revolution a small group of activists, and the Revolutionary Guard with
- 4:54that, and they then became the de facto administration regime of Iran, backing
- 5:00up Supreme Leader Ali Komeni, who became the Supreme Leader in nineteen eighty nine.
- 5:05So you see now, you know a lot of these guys are kind
- 5:09of the same age as me and Jason, you know, old enough to
- 5:13be D's grandfather. They but they were students, you know in the seventies,
- 5:17back in late seventies, you know, you name it. Utman imagad
- 5:21Hussein in ceremony starts trying to remember his name, all of these guys,
- 5:28and now they're at the top of the Iranian ranks structure. Now, kots
- 5:31Force is kind of a subdivision of the ILGC, and they are focused,
- 5:36they are you know, they well, they've been classified as a terrorist organization
- 5:43by the US State Department with good reason. But kots Force is responsible for
- 5:47the Iranian regimes operations overseas, which they conduct primarily through the use of proxies
- 5:55such as his Bala, such as quite improbably Hamas and probably because her Masses
- 6:00of course a Sunni organization. But the Ranians who are happy to hold their
- 6:04nose in this case and support her Maas and then subsequently leave them out to
- 6:10drive because he Mars is doing their bidding and as long as it is Sunni
- 6:13Arabs and Israeli's being killed, this all plays very well to the Iranians.
- 6:18But now they've lost three of the top guys, they have to take action,
- 6:24and you know, and this is this is what is caused incantscern obviously
- 6:30within Israel. Now this comes amidst massive demonstrations against Netan Nyahu. It is
- 6:40many fail a A well they I mean, it's hard to deny it's an
- 6:46escalation. Many feel that there are political motives for this escalation that it is
- 6:53you know that that Netanyahu, if you can really really solidify or continue down
- 7:02this polarization path and and continue this campaign, rally the right behind him,
- 7:10get the patriotic and and and and kind of the Jewish vote, he will
- 7:15take this, you know, to the hilt. And that is what's worrying
- 7:18the vast majority of Israelis right now who don't feel that this is the ticket
- 7:24that they bought when they when they subscribe to the war on Hamas over to
- 7:29you back over to you guys anything. Yeah. So, like my understanding
- 7:34is like Koot's force is basically like an hiergy sees how Iran can kind of
- 7:40project every power because like they don't really have a military that's strong enough.
- 7:44That's right, that's right, and and it's masterful because they are you know,
- 7:47think of all the bumbling efforts we make to to build advisor type units,
- 7:53right both in the Army and the US Marine Corps A very ad hoc
- 7:58group of people, and it's not considered a very you know, one of
- 8:01the things we've always struggled with conventional forces is they want to operate as battalions
- 8:05and brigades and divisions, but not training foreign indigenous troops. That is so
- 8:13unsexy, right, But that that is the core of gray zone operations.
- 8:18I'm using that term, I know, but that is the that's conflict.
- 8:22Everyone uses proxy. Everyone's doing it, you know, and we should get
- 8:26on board. The Mozart group was a perfect opportunity, guys, you all
- 8:28missed it. But so COODS Force are very adept at getting at working with
- 8:37prozis. You know, they live they live in the country, or they
- 8:43work with they work closely with them. They I'm not saying for a moment
- 8:46that they identify with them. They use them here there are tools, but
- 8:50they do it very well, very well indeed. And so with just a
- 8:54small, relatively small group of people, you know, Coods Force, just
- 8:58a few thousand guys can conduct operations that are having a catastrophic not a catstrophic,
- 9:03but a global effect. Think about what the hoho this are doing that
- 9:07we've talked about here Mars is the least capable of all of kusforce's proxies.
- 9:16His Bolla is the most capable. And that is what everyone is worried about
- 9:20now, because Iran won't declare or in Israel, Iran's not going to strike
- 9:24back in the same way. But using his bolla, Iran certainly has the
- 9:31ability to inflict serious damage on Israel. And it's a question of math.
- 9:37It's a question of math, precision fires. His bolla has an arsenal now
- 9:43many times the size of the one that it had in two thousand and six,
- 9:46and even then was able to overwhelm Iron Dome. Paul's there to see
- 9:54if you guys have any questions. It's a really, it's a really.
- 9:58This is a very interesting, important and quite scary flectioning point. And so
- 10:05kods is uh and this is my own ignorance. Has always been a hands
- 10:11off force, or have they ever have been indirect? Well? They combat,
- 10:16well, they they are occasionally involved in in I mean they are involved,
- 10:22you know, I mean they absolutely they you know, they don't have
- 10:26this, they don't have this artificial division between advice and assist and a company,
- 10:33right, No, of course, I mean they but but the point
- 10:35is they don't need to. They do what they need to do to set
- 10:39the example, to rally support. I'll give you an example, you know,
- 10:46for for instance, in Gaza. In Gaza, Israeli intelligence, not
- 10:54officially, but Israeli intelligence claims that they're picking up Farci in Gaza, a
- 10:58Kud's Force guy helping direct Hamas operations, all right, and that is the
- 11:05sort of help that they will give, you know, right up to yeah,
- 11:09right up to the X. But but the point is they they there's
- 11:15always and you know this of course, Jason, there's always kind of a
- 11:18it always they always give Iran deplausible deniability, right, and that is their
- 11:24strength, you know. I mean it's a Koo's Force is a masterful organization
- 11:30in that sense. It is a it's very competent, very efficient. They
- 11:33have their fuck up, some quite hilarious fuck ups at times, but for
- 11:39the most part they they mean business and they do business, you know.
- 11:41And this is a very rare successful strike because they are very good at field
- 11:48craft. By the way, just getting used from the Israelis, and I
- 11:52think this was reported on US media. Hassein Yusuf, who's a senior has
- 11:58Boa official, also on the strike. So you've got guys and and an
- 12:03official from p I J and SoJ Palestinian Islamic TEA hot who are involved in
- 12:09the fighting in Gaza in support of Hamas. So that problem that strike.
- 12:18I'm going to go out on a limon say that those names were known before
- 12:22that, uh that was carried out or maybe like uh, you know,
- 12:28I'm sure some of them at least, but I'm going to eventually say given
- 12:33the names and the stature that it was known, all the names on that
- 12:37target were known. Yeah. Absolutely, the I mean these guys, these
- 12:43guys would have been top of the target list. I mean they I'm sure.
- 12:48I'm sure they're on their own target list too, and and so and
- 12:54And that's a really good point, Jason, because you know how it is
- 12:58when something happens and assumes that the approximate cause is something that happened right before
- 13:03that. I'll give you the case in point. All right, So the
- 13:07the destruction there was a drone attack on a lap you know, two days
- 13:11ago, and then right after this the strike on Damascus. Well, you
- 13:16don't throw together strikes that easily, you know, I mean, this had
- 13:20been planned and they were just waiting for for a for a reason, and
- 13:24the reason was probably as you know, the time, location, the trigger,
- 13:30which had nothing to do with retaliation for any other event. How often
- 13:33do you get these seven individuals in a room. It would have been a
- 13:37high level decision obviously, but it just seemed probably like too juicy a target
- 13:43to pass up. Because now you know, as we've all seen these targeted
- 13:48killings, they they rarely have a good effect. It's a long time,
- 13:52like we all we all feel good, Oh great, but you name it,
- 13:56you know, yeah, Like why is it followed by someone worse?
- 13:58What is the blow at look like? Now? Like after these guys have
- 14:03been taken out and stuff like that, Like what's a response from Iran?
- 14:05Look like? Is it just through Azbola? Like, yeah, I would
- 14:11guess the res I mean, first of all, there has to be a
- 14:13response. Two, yes, his bolla because but it won't just be his
- 14:20Bala. They will probably be renewed drone attacks on southern Israel from the hohofies.
- 14:26But certainly, Yeah, this is what would be interesting is to know
- 14:31what the discussion is that is taking place now between ISRAELA and Kromani. You
- 14:37know, Inzraela. By the way, in Israela Hassan Israela is the head
- 14:41of Lebanese Hezbala. And you know this, this warrants a whole show by
- 14:46itself. But he bottom line is Nisralla is he's not a Lebanese patriot,
- 14:54but he's not certainly not an Iranian stooge either. He is about himself and
- 15:00about Lebanese has Boller. And the problem within cycling a war with Israel is
- 15:07that it sets him back in time, right. He's he's got a plan,
- 15:13and his plan is that, you know, the state of Lebanon becomes
- 15:16essentially his Boller state, and he's he's a long way along that path.
- 15:20We've talked about this when you look at members of the you know, the
- 15:22cabinet there, you look at the problems the militaries having with his Boller infiltration,
- 15:28all of these things. So he's almost there. He has built up
- 15:31his arsenal, which was devastated in the two thousand and six award. He's
- 15:35he's built it up to a point where yeah, it you know, when
- 15:41we talk existential threat and very nearly existential threat, I mean not existential,
- 15:46but can can certainly has has the capability to inflict tens of thousands of casualties
- 15:54on the Israeli population. But to do so, yes, he will become
- 15:58Abal hero, but his bolla will take a schwacking. The Israelis were stumbling
- 16:07sometimes, who have been stumbling when it comes to targeting and gaza, but
- 16:11they have everything in Lebanon dialed in. They've had forty years literally to do
- 16:18this all right. They cannot hit all the time, they don't have enough
- 16:22ammunition to hit all the targets, but they all try, and that is
- 16:25what That'zrola knows. And the backlash will probably go against his bolla, and
- 16:32so he's walking a fine line. He wants, you know, he senses
- 16:36that the you know, the Arab streets, but you know, on the
- 16:38Shea side, everyone is really outraged. This this level of anger in the
- 16:45Arab world. I don't we haven't seen it in our lifetimes, and it's
- 16:48easy to overlook it from where we are, but it is, it is.
- 16:55It has gathered a momentum that is quite frightening, and Azraela realizes that.
- 17:00So now he's caught and the Israelis have just pushed the Iranians right into
- 17:03kind of openly having to to demand retribution. So everything seems set for his
- 17:11balla strike into Israel. I'll pause that from him. Given everything you just
- 17:15said, do you think there's a it's plausible that Esrala would say no that
- 17:21you know he's told, hey, we need you know. That's that's the
- 17:25ten million dollar question, Jason. And the answer is no. One knows,
- 17:27not even you know. If you talk to Israeli intelligence guys who have
- 17:32kind of who have lived in israela for the entire careers, and there are
- 17:37guys like that and women, and they will tell you they don't know.
- 17:41You know he is and Osralla is. He's a very very smart guy.
- 17:48But he also plays his cards quite close to his chest. That's why he's
- 17:52still alive. We don't know, we don't know. And everyone since this
- 17:57kicked off, I say everyone, but you know, all the pundits have
- 18:00been asking will he say no to Iran? Does he have enough laster power
- 18:06confidence by himself to do so? And we will see and so you know,
- 18:15things go ahead. A number of other things are taking place too.
- 18:18This morning there was an attack on well, first of all, you know,
- 18:22relations between Israel and the United States are the worst that they have ever
- 18:26been. Again, you know, I stick to facts on this show that
- 18:30for the first time ever, Guy's polls are showing the US population public disagree
- 18:37with with what's something that Israelis are doing foreign policy, how they're headling Gaza
- 18:44all right, and you know there's Netna who's snubs to the president are Netna
- 18:52who is banking on Trump victory. But then Trump the other day said,
- 18:57hey, Israel just needs to finish this. You know, he seemed impatient.
- 19:00Of course he is. The Republicans don't understand. I mean, the
- 19:03Republicans don't want this probably going on either. My point is that everyone realized
- 19:08that this is severely damaging to the US prestige or view in the world.
- 19:15And we don't have a lot of waks to depend on right now, and
- 19:18we're being dragged into the toilet. That's one argument, but it's hard to
- 19:22argue against, to be honest with you. So what I wanted to do,
- 19:26you know, and then the well, but at the same time,
- 19:30at the same time, we're giving them, you know, eighteen billion dollars
- 19:32in military aid. Yeah, what's it, three point six billion dollars a
- 19:36year? You know, and no, but they're given like the new Aid
- 19:37package, right of ag Yeah, absolutely, yeah, And you know the
- 19:41point is, but we have been giving them three point you know, billions
- 19:45of dollars every year. And there was a very funny Saturday Night Live sketch
- 19:51in Israel. They've got that version of Saturday Night Live where you know,
- 19:56they've got this guy playing Net and Yahoo and he's like, no, tell
- 19:59the goings to fuck off, you know, tell them, you know,
- 20:03tell them to take that three you know, three point six billion dollars and
- 20:07shove it up their ass. You know. So this was kind of a
- 20:10realization among the segment of the Israeli population who have close ties with the United
- 20:15States, who we don't want to alienate the United States. We feel more
- 20:19in ni kin with the United States and with Israel. And then you get
- 20:23this world food kitchen striker case seven killed US, Canada, Australia, Poland,
- 20:30and the United Kingdom aside from the usual Palestinians. All right, whichever
- 20:34way you look at it, his, you know, his his. What
- 20:40the news is reporting that the convoy, uh, give me a second,
- 20:47that it was that it was coordinated, that the yep, the coordinates were
- 20:53set in blah blah blah blah, but it was still struck. He is
- 20:57really said that they were investigating. Initial they said that it was operating outside
- 21:02curfew in an area, not coordinated. But now they apparently are calling to
- 21:07the ladiest yeah, admitting that yes, it was coordinated. So so here's
- 21:11another a potential rift between the US and Israel. You know, I mean,
- 21:18none of us like the thought that Israel or any country can kill our
- 21:22citizens without without even asking. You know, I know that sounds ridiculous,
- 21:26but I mean because they'd ask me. They said, no, you fucking
- 21:30cannot kill He's working for the World Food Kitchen. By the way, you
- 21:34know, another inside I have here is having having driven you know, food
- 21:44humanitarian assistance under bombardiment for the World Food Kitchen. Obviously, I'm not completely
- 21:51unbiased in this in this story. Any any questions on that, I mean,
- 21:56like, I think it's okay to not be be a little biased because
- 22:00they killed fucking aid workers. They didn't kill like you know, hamask guys
- 22:07hiding in in a hospital that like, you know, whether it's what they
- 22:10do nor it was aid workers. It was clearly marked, its coordinated.
- 22:12What do we don't. I mean, you know, it's supposed to be
- 22:15the best military in the world. I get it's war and it's a fucking
- 22:17disaster and it's mayhem and it's chaos, but like, do they even give
- 22:21a shit about how like the world honestly the United States perceives them or they're
- 22:27just gonna keep doing like what they're gonna do and that's that. Yeah,
- 22:32I'm gonna ask you your question. D just very quick. Just's some more
- 22:34stuff coming in sure, So the uh, despite despite this is coming from
- 22:41the World Food Kitchen Aaron gole Ceo, despite coordinating movements for the IDEF,
- 22:45the convoy was hit at as it was leaving Daro Bala Warehouse, where the
- 22:49team had unloaded more than one hundred tons of humanitarian food eight Borti Gaza on
- 22:53maritime route. Reports saw that it was hit actually three times from aeron Gol.
- 23:00This is not only attack against World Food Kitchen, attack on manager and
- 23:03organizations. Yeah, blah blah, Hey three times. What happened? They
- 23:07didn't get it right the first two. I don't know who knows where Anyway,
- 23:10they you know, we'll see. I'm not I'm not dismissing I'm saying,
- 23:11this is yeah, this is this is serious. It seems almost as
- 23:15though net Yahoo is not net Yahoo is doing but Bridge burning things right,
- 23:22And if you've seen the movie Wag the Dog, you might be thinking along
- 23:26those lines. It's quite concerning, Well, what's that, what's what's the
- 23:30play, like, what's the strategy in doing that? To not have any
- 23:34allies left? Oh no, no, no to to net Yahoo. This
- 23:38all makes this, this all makes perfect sense. By the way, it's
- 23:44really has is right in if you mentioned they haven't accept their responsibility for the
- 23:48Damascus sign, but it you know, it does, it does make sense.
- 23:52So you think about it. You push Iran into war, you recover
- 23:59Gaza right for the state of Israel, which is what which is what Netnia
- 24:04who's base, is pushing for, to colonize Gaza and make it part of
- 24:08Israel. You know, that's that's the dog whistle piece you know in the
- 24:12background here, but it's it's quite openly discussed among the members of our of
- 24:18the right wing in Israel. So he's going to satisfy the Israeli extremists,
- 24:25the ultra Orthodox, who are also by the way, you know, calling
- 24:30on him to destroy our AXA and rebuild the temple. You know, I
- 24:33mean, I'm wondering whether this is gonna the Al Jorthodox who don't fight either
- 24:37exactly, and that is also causing internal problems in Israel. They call you
- 24:42know, they they are they're good at beating up or shooting, you know.
- 24:47Reportedly, this is the argument, okay, from from many in Israel.
- 24:52Hey, these guys push us to the brink of war. They cause
- 24:56problems with the Palestinians, and yet they don't have to deal with the consequences
- 25:00because they don't have to serve. And Netna, who has fought against removing
- 25:07that exemption, the Supreme Court is you know, has said that the exemption
- 25:12is no longer valid. So Netnar, who is dragging his feet on how
- 25:17to implement this, saying it's going to take a decade to bring these guys
- 25:19into the military. So you can see how this resentment is building. But
- 25:26they are who's base and political survival was very very important to him, and
- 25:33and and so dividing the world in this way in a way that it hasn't
- 25:38been divided since the early eighties over Israel, and as far worse than it
- 25:42was in the early eighties. Is it makes perfect sense to him. He's
- 25:47driving away friendly you know, I mean moderate friendly Arab countries such as Jordan.
- 25:52He's driving, I mean he is. He has antagonized the Arab street
- 25:56beyond all measure. So I think, I think, you know, the
- 26:00real question here is what else could he have done? What else could he?
- 26:06And I you know, I've got some thoughts here, And bear in
- 26:10mind, my thoughts are not from an armchair, you know. I've I've
- 26:15had to deal with these problems for real. And you know, there's a
- 26:19number of reasons why so many civilians are going to be killed. Underlying it
- 26:23all, frankly, is is a I mean, in some cases it's explicit,
- 26:30you know, by you will protect your soldiers' lives at all costs,
- 26:37and implicit to that on then Neva stated in an order, is if that
- 26:41means a choice between killing many Palasilian civilians or having your own soldiers killed,
- 26:48then that's not a choice, you know. And so a lot of the
- 26:52things that that we do in the in the US, to do with proportionality,
- 26:57or to do with identification, of discrimination, identification, all these things
- 27:06that we're familiar with are not the norm now they use these terms, and
- 27:11I'll give you an example. Have how it goes awry. They do collateral
- 27:14damage assessments. But here is how it's done. First of all, their
- 27:18intelligence within Gaza is not that it is not that good, and it's not
- 27:23a fault of Israeli's intelligence. It's just Tomas. It's got really fucking good
- 27:27at operating without giving their presence away. Okay, So a lot of the
- 27:33intel they're getting is based on drone observations and it's fleeting intelligence. So they
- 27:40feel like they have to make a decision very quickly, and so they do,
- 27:45and they always err on the side of caution for themselves or their forces.
- 27:49They will and so one of the problems here is that the Israeli spokesman
- 27:56can say, pro former, Hey, here's what we're doing, and it
- 28:00is true, and we have people, you know, and a guy like
- 28:03a guy I have great respect for. John Spencer, the Irregular Warfare Institute,
- 28:07goes to Israel, gets their brief, comes back, writes an article
- 28:11in Newsweek, saying there's no army in the world takes so many measures to
- 28:17prevent civilian casualties. Well, John is a great guy. The greatest respect
- 28:21for him, But that is simply not true. John didn't of course didn't
- 28:25lie, but he made a lot of statements without really looking behind. And
- 28:29I'll give you examples. Okay, Collateral damage assessments are based on their intel,
- 28:33but their intail is not good and they're under and again, you know,
- 28:38the arbiter is always if you don't make this strike or it Israeli forces
- 28:44risk raised. Okay, that is it's it's It doesn't get into detailed proportionality.
- 28:51This isn't me just shooting. And I'm getting this and from guys I've
- 28:55spoken to, and in fact it's in the papers in Israel too. So
- 29:00here's some quotes, all right from Israeli soldiers. In practice, the terrorist
- 29:07is anyone the IDF has killed in the areas in which its forces operate,
- 29:10says an officer who served in Gaza. The feeling we had was there wasn't
- 29:14there aren't aren't any rules of engagement there. Another soldier says, okay,
- 29:21so one of the battles, what's the fighting looking like in Gaza? I
- 29:22mentioned the other day they're taking lower casualties than we did in a Flujah.
- 29:26Good for them, except that they're causing many, many thousands times, and
- 29:33civilian counterpeace that we cause in Fallujah, because in Fallujah we took a little
- 29:38bit more risk because we're Americans. We may call it what you were try.
- 29:42Even if you disagree with it, I'm proud of the fact that we
- 29:47risked our own lives to save civilians. There is no such fault within the
- 29:51Israeli military, and it's very, very firmly rooted in their belief. You
- 29:57know that the constant belief that Israel under existential threat. Okay, those are
- 30:03those are kind of the facts. And you know, if anyone wants to
- 30:07challenge me, and there's okay, you know, by all means, please
- 30:10do, please do. But remember three Israeli hostages were killed. All right,
- 30:15they were shot. They were shot. They weren't killed in their strike.
- 30:18They were shot by Israelis. Even after here's what happened, and this
- 30:23kind of day. This isn't tearing open the people who did this. It's
- 30:27explaining why. The problem is a policy, it's not individual actions. So
- 30:33when these three terrats, these three hostages were killed, a drone was sent
- 30:37inside the building. But the Israelis having great success using drones inside buildings.
- 30:41The drone flew into the bill. Oh no shit, sorry, there was
- 30:45a dog. They sent in a dog, and the dogs all have GoPros,
- 30:49and the dog picks up these three Israeli hostages and they don't know the
- 30:53dog has go pro but they're yelling in Israeli and the terrorists. There's coupled
- 30:59Terrists in there, a couple of wounded. Once the Israelis blow destroyed their
- 31:04house, they say, and who I don't disbelieve them. You know,
- 31:08the soldiers involved said they didn't check the go pro camera the hostage. Ah,
- 31:15excuse me, is a go pro camera live feed or no? No,
- 31:19no, it's not live feeds? All right? But anyway, so
- 31:22the hostages, they're not killed in the house destruction, They get on the
- 31:26street. Two are subsequently shot by Israelis, and now it gets really bad.
- 31:32The third one runs back into our house. Israeli soldiers follow him in
- 31:37and shoot him there close range. So I'm like, okay, you know,
- 31:41think about all think about all the measures here that you know that we
- 31:47know rules of engagement that would have prevented that happening. So when the Israelis
- 31:52said, hey, these guys weren't following policy it's hard. It's hard to
- 31:56understand how so many guys didn't follow policy. And the soldiers involved us saying
- 32:00that they were told to shoot anything that came into the area, and when
- 32:05you look at what happened, it's hard to believe. It's hard not to
- 32:07believe them, Okay, and then you know other soldiers are saying, yeah,
- 32:12we had free fire zones. Whenever we set up a like a you
- 32:17know, biboac air, I mean not a like we went firm, but
- 32:22even moving during the day, we were told shoot anything that came into our
- 32:25zone. We gave civilians two weeks to move, and if they didn't move,
- 32:30you know, that's they're fair game. So now there's so many things
- 32:37that interfere with civilians being able to move in that environment. The messaging wasn't
- 32:42clear. The Israeli said they use roof knocking, which means firing a small
- 32:45caliber I mean a smaller carab caliber bomb into the roof or rocket into the
- 32:51roof before you bomb the building. But you know, there's a problem,
- 32:54there's a problem with communicaticating with lethal force, all right, It's not always
- 32:59clearly a parent. If you're in a building and the roof gets hit,
- 33:02you may probably just think, Wow, that was a close one. You
- 33:05don't think, hey, this was a very kind warning that I'm about to
- 33:07be incinerated. If I don't get out of this building, you have to,
- 33:10you know. I mean, it's it's almost as though they've got this,
- 33:15Okay, we're going to go through this. The because their intelligence is
- 33:20not good. They can't make good estimates of proportionality because they don't know the
- 33:25value of the units or organizations they're going after. So you know, there's
- 33:30a lot of things wrong with what is being said about about or about that
- 33:38procedures. And then and then as the shooting their own hostages is concerned,
- 33:45you would think that that would cause them to reframe everything, but it hasn't
- 33:50because again, there is this ethos. I mean, there's no doubt there's
- 33:53revenge underlying this, but that speculation I I the it has got to be
- 34:00revenge in the back of the human beings involved in this. And this is
- 34:02why leadership is so important. But if you had leaders I'm not saying this
- 34:06is happening, but it has happened the US military, if you have leaders
- 34:09who are reconciled just saying hey, whatever. Man, you know, if
- 34:15you feel at risk, then by all means. And so when you get
- 34:21a case like the humanitarian convoy that was fired on and a hundred killed,
- 34:27the Israeli say only percentage of the proportion of those were killed by the Israelis,
- 34:30but the hospitals saying that at large. But anyway, bottom line is
- 34:36definitely number of incidents of people lining up for food being shot by Israeli soldiers.
- 34:44In every case their answer has been I felt threatened, all right,
- 34:47and it seems once you uttered those magic words or bets are off and we
- 34:52went through the stage too, So we can't feel too you know, not
- 34:57as extremely as this obviously. I mean, can you imagine if we had
- 35:00caused thirty one thousand civilians death in any operation, we would be facing criminal
- 35:07charges. Frankly, but yeah, I represent you know, look, I
- 35:13understand this is a brutal dilemma. But I also, speaking as someone who
- 35:17has fought house to house and has planned urban operations, I oppose to that.
- 35:22Guys, if you guse you goun any questions, now, man,
- 35:27you're the of the three of us, you're the u, the one with
- 35:30the most expertise on this. So I'm I'm listening. I'm learning it as
- 35:35well too. I'm sure we're going to hear about it in the comments,
- 35:37but I don't worry about the comments. Were talking the truth exactly. So
- 35:42yeah, I'm learning we don't have we don't have a dog in this fight.
- 35:45Like I don't at least like to be completely honest. I mean,
- 35:47I understand that Israel needs to like smoke Commas. People like Commas leadership.
- 35:53I think they should have done it the wrong, the different way instead of
- 35:57sending like divisions. All right, I'll give you another example. Okay,
- 36:01so in there and and look, I I was a fast support coordinator by
- 36:07military occupational speciality. And you know, again that doesn't make me not bragging.
- 36:12No, I'm just saying because I want to preempt. You know,
- 36:16they're our favorite contributors who piland and call me an idiot again or I'm a
- 36:23Roan. But I do know what I'm talking about. And you know the
- 36:27point is that, for instance, when what the Israelis are doing, they're
- 36:34saying it is are legitimate targets because Hamas is operating out of you know,
- 36:39this building, But the building is an apartment block. The Hamas are operating
- 36:43out of one or two apartments. This is a this is a real case.
- 36:45By the way, this was oh crap, doesn't matter, I'll get
- 36:51back to it. It was a building that was destroyed in one so they'll
- 36:55destroy the whole building. And if they're warning the occupants of that building by
- 36:59faring into the roof, you can see the problem here. And if you've
- 37:02got an apartment blanc and people are worried about walking on the streets because they're
- 37:07free you know, free fire zones, it gets very difficult to be a
- 37:10civilian. Right, it can't come out in the streets. But if you
- 37:13say in the building, you're gonna get killed. So yeah, you know
- 37:17you can say, well netna Hu meanwhile saying Israel has the most moral army
- 37:22in the world. That may be no one's you know, not making comments
- 37:27about the morality of the individual soldier. I'm saying that they that that the
- 37:30way things are set up, the policy that procedures are that their customs are
- 37:37such that nothing other than massive civilian casualties could be anticipated. Yeah, so
- 37:47it's fucked, is what. That's the That's what we've realized. I mean,
- 37:52like, when does it end? Because they're going to go into office
- 37:54wreck and shape like there too. So where do all those civilians that move
- 38:00moved away from Gaza City? Where do they go? What's the move?
- 38:04Doesn't matter to them? Doesn't seem like it From an idiot like me,
- 38:07it doesn't seem like it. Yeah, well that's a it's just hard to
- 38:14see a good outcome or a peaceful outcome to this now, DM and the
- 38:21incidents of the last the attacks and Damascus. Look, I know, I
- 38:23mean, we went through this discussion, solmony. This somony was one of
- 38:29my bags, baby. You know when I was I wore uniform. I
- 38:31was delighted as a human being to see him dead. But I was concerned
- 38:36that it was not part of a synchronized campaign, all right, and I
- 38:40suspect that it may not have been. And the same thing here. Okay,
- 38:45If the Israelis have something lined up to mitigate the backlash, that's good.
- 38:52If they don't, then the jury's out whether this was a good move.
- 38:59Right. But there's no way to your point about to your point about
- 39:02Rafa, this is a This is as near a red line as I can
- 39:07see between the United States and Israel. All Right. There was a point
- 39:13where Israel might have got away with saying, hey, look we'll take care
- 39:15of the civilian population, will put them on the beach, blah blah blah.
- 39:20But after that, you know, now it seems as though with US
- 39:22pols swinging against Israel's actions, death of US citizens in the last twenty four
- 39:29hours is not likely to help that. I would say that the administration's really
- 39:35going to this today, draw a hard line on Rafa, on going into
- 39:39Rafa, because that Netnya who has promised promised the Israeli people that that's exactly
- 39:45what they are, that's what we're doing, you know. So you know,
- 39:52I guess to kind of summarize what, you know, what I've been
- 39:54talking about the problem is that frankly, the IDEAF is not taking the trouble
- 40:06to distinguish between civilians and militants in Gaza. You know, the IDF would
- 40:09argue, we just don't have time to take you know, we don't.
- 40:12We can't do any more than we're doing because it's going to put us in
- 40:15danger. You know, the same time Israel's expanding it's you know, during
- 40:22your Daza operation, because at the beginning it had very few real targets.
- 40:25They were all old as you can imagine, they hadn't been tracking commas.
- 40:30Well now they've got hundreds of targets. But you know how it is,
- 40:32and you know, people move all the time, and they're dropping dumb two
- 40:37thousand bombs capable you know, is every a nose or not even know people
- 40:40killing? That's capable of killing wounding people more than a thousand feet away from
- 40:45the impact, right CP is what one thousand feet for two thousand It doesn't
- 40:49matter, you know, I mean it's so how can you possibly say that
- 40:54when you're dropping dumb bombs in an environment like that, after taking precautions like
- 41:00roof knocking or dropping leaflets, and expecting people to move in that environment,
- 41:05how can you really expect civilian casualties to be lower? Also, what I
- 41:10worry about a little bit is like, you know, like we've discussed in
- 41:15other other episodes, you know, the Iranian the Cuds force proxies all over
- 41:20the Middle East, whether they're in Iraq or Syria or wherever are. You
- 41:24know, kind of we're operating relatively independently, and I don't really see them
- 41:29differentiating Israel and America for the most part, generally. So like I see
- 41:36that there is you know, risk to American personnel at bases, whether it's
- 41:40bag that airport or the embassy or whatever, or Tower twenty two or any
- 41:45of the other bases we have across the region. So what happens if we
- 41:47get hit again and we lose a couple of servicemen again, we're brought back
- 41:52into it, we like in a more kinetic way, like we need to
- 41:55step up and show like, hey, you don't do that. Here's a
- 41:59peep whack. Yeah, that's what I worry about. I know Iran doesn't
- 42:02want to drag Israel or the United States a full fledged war because like their
- 42:08military is not great. I mean, that's why they use the cuts for
- 42:12so much. It's because it's projecting. They don't want to go to to
- 42:16you know, state on state war. This strike against Coots Force officers in
- 42:22that sense was very deliberately, very deliberately designed to give them no choice.
- 42:29But you know, Sonahu, whatever you may say is after escalation and and
- 42:36there's something else you know this remember I talked about the Hannibal directive last episode
- 42:43or two episodes ago. You know, there's these these things going on,
- 42:46things going on within the military. That suggests that, you know, brigade
- 42:52and battalion commanders are making their own decisions on rules of engagement. In fact,
- 42:58that is the overwhelming feedback I'm getting. You know, I spoke to
- 43:04one battalion that moved in, you know, moved up north on the seventh
- 43:08October, and they were weapons tight, you know, usual rules of engagement.
- 43:13And another battalion moved in after them, and they they were reconnaissance by
- 43:16fire. They were you know, they were every morning and every evening.
- 43:20They would fire the morning and evening hate as it used to be called in
- 43:23the First World War, into the villages on the Lebanese side, and that
- 43:27was sanctioned by their commanders, you know. And this is within the same
- 43:30organization. There is no there doesn't appear to be any central rules of engagement.
- 43:35So the Hannibal doctrine was directive, was an official thing that authorized it's
- 43:45really soldiers to risk the lives of hostages in order to free them. In
- 43:51other words, you know, knowing what lay in store for them, you
- 43:53could accept a higher level of risk. Okay, common sense, right.
- 43:57It has been interpreted apparently as me, you can kill hostages. Audio own
- 44:02soldiers to prevent them being kept health captives. Okay, and that was the
- 44:07Hannibal doctrine. There are incidents where soldiers are claiming that the Hannibal doctrine has
- 44:13been called by battalion brigade commanders and then just you know, I guess there's
- 44:19a lot of these code red type things. There's another thing called the Dahia
- 44:22Doctrine, which was formulated in the two thousand and six eleven and more apologies
- 44:28that here, so so its main tendid it is that disproportioned attacks, including
- 44:34against civilian structures and infrastructure, are authorized, you know, for it for
- 44:39achieving the end, and that that is may well be what's that play here?
- 44:45Right? Yeah, I don't know, I don't know how like you
- 44:51could be you could justify this more and more as like even the United States
- 44:55government, like it's like, dude, we I mean, there's only so
- 44:59much we could do, right, And it's not even dividing the world.
- 45:02I mean, the world's pretty much on one side of this for the most
- 45:07part. You know, I think you know, in terms of states,
- 45:09you know, like countries, you know that everyone's pretty much saying, hey,
- 45:14guys, let's chill out a little bit and go back to what you're
- 45:16good at, which is assassinating top level people, the odd nuclear scientists,
- 45:22you know what I mean, Like, let's just do that. Yeah.
- 45:24You know Netna, who actually has not been a Hawk in the past.
- 45:30He's he's a little like he's gonna love this analogy in Israela in the sense
- 45:35he knows how to walk the line right, you know, get everyone fired
- 45:39up, but avoid because he knows he's a survivalist. He knows that in
- 45:45trench conflicts like Lebanon lead to the end of careers. And I mean his
- 45:51career is undoubtedly over. The question is when, and he wants his perhaps
- 45:55he wants his career to end the other side of a war a major wall,
- 46:00because that it will extend, you know, that's the argument against him.
- 46:04So it's no longer at that point longevity. It's legacy yeah yeah,
- 46:09or not even legacy prison, just preservation of power. Yeah. He's a
- 46:15political creature, you know, and he he cut his teeth in the talk
- 46:21in the uh reality not reality TV that you know, the talk show circuit
- 46:28here in the United States in the in the in the late seventies and eighties,
- 46:35that's what made him. Wow. Yeah, I mean legacy hunting or
- 46:38political preservation at the expense of tens of thousands civilians and uh even Israeli soldiers,
- 46:46and you know, just human death and destruction kind of makes you fucking
- 46:52evil in my opinion. That's completely my opinion. If you like bb Netanya
- 46:55who congratulations, I don't. I think he's a fucking rat. Yeah.
- 47:00I I I stay facts, you know, and I do express opinions,
- 47:06of course, otherwise I'd be very boring. But yeah, I am concerned.
- 47:10I'm concerned for is wrong, concerned for them, beliast, I'm concerned
- 47:14for the world. I'm very concerned for the United States most of all,
- 47:17obviously right now, and I think it's important for everyone everyone watching remember that
- 47:23never might I'm not even going to go down that village. So anyway,
- 47:30hey, hey, here's another thing on rules of engagement. Okay, that
- 47:36that wasn't you know, John Spencer didn't mention the Newsweek article. Do really
- 47:40go into every building shooting for the most part? All right, And that
- 47:45is you know, that's kind of the s op in Gaza. I'm not
- 47:51making a comment on right or wrong. I'm just saying you know that leads
- 47:54not just a huge enormous ammunition consumption, which they don't have a problem with
- 48:00when it comes to small arms, because you know, they obviously religioustics bylines.
- 48:05But but but two, you know that is something reconnaissance by fire,
- 48:08as it were, as something that we are never authorized to do in the
- 48:13US, or seldom authorized to do, certainly not in those environments. But
- 48:17that is that, you know. I look, frankly, most civilians,
- 48:24vast majority civilians are killed by artillery, you know, to kill fire sentence,
- 48:30relatively relatively few. Still, hundreds thousands probably killed by direct fire.
- 48:37But so so all of this, all of this is the problem. It's
- 48:39not particular prostigures. It's the kind of the underlying culture. I think.
- 48:45The best way to put this, I know I've brought us near and the
- 48:47end. No, that was perfect, No, I was I was great.
- 48:52I think I think it's tough. Man. I don't know, I
- 48:54don't know what we should say to ye. No, no, man,
- 49:01I'm you know me. I like to learn. So I had to sit
- 49:07back on this one and just listen and ask my little questions. And I
- 49:10appreciate it. That's what I do every episode, So, you know,
- 49:15just for those interested in how, you know, how the what the fighting
- 49:19looks like in Gaza, I mentioned the Israeli casualties being remarkably low. You
- 49:23know, it's in the two hundred and I think fifties in those sixties.
- 49:28And you know, six months of six months, I'm sorry, forty five
- 49:32months of fighting. That's extraordinarily low. And you know, one of the
- 49:39side we've talked about fires. But after they have plasted in an area,
- 49:44then they'll send in their special operations guys who will seize a foothold, kind
- 49:49of a bridgehead or you know, they're sending drones dogs first. Then they'll
- 49:55send us their special abrations forces to to hold a block, and only then
- 50:01will they send in their conventional forces. And then it's a very very slow
- 50:07movement. I've been told, you know, a couple hundred yards a day,
- 50:14So you see, it's a very cautious, very deliberate move that's probably
- 50:19how they're saving their own casualties. Ballpark, Andy, how many Hamas fighters
- 50:22are there, like actually fighting every day? Yeah, that's a good question,
- 50:27so as I haven't seen that anywhere. Yeah, so the Israeli say
- 50:30twenty to thirty thousand at the beginning. They say, Now, remember last
- 50:34week I said fourteen to fifteen thousand they're claiming killed. When you add out
- 50:38the battalions that they say they've killed, it's fourteen fifteen thousand guys. Looking
- 50:42at Hamas's order of battle. Now Israel's saying they've killed nine thousand Hermas operatives.
- 50:47Coincidentally, exactly the number of military age males killed reported dead. Right,
- 50:53so hard to tell, really hard to tell. No one can,
- 50:59No one can tell you how many battalions are left in Rafa. Anyone who
- 51:02says they can is full of shit. I mean, even if we had
- 51:06the best intel in the wall. You know, you're talking about small groups
- 51:09of guys and all the engagements. There are small groups, you know,
- 51:15running around through tunnels in a densely, densely populated area. How can you
- 51:22possibly make a coherent estimate of how many people are there? I mean,
- 51:29how many fighters are that all alone form them into battalions. It's it's ridiculously
- 51:35unrealistic. And as I've mentioned, even if you ignore the figures are Western
- 51:40intelligence reports, the UK in particular. I don't want to burn him,
- 51:45but he's he's particularly well positioned to know about this is saying that Israeli reports
- 51:52of Hamas casualties are very much over the mark. So there's very few silver
- 52:00linings. As we talked about, even if hermask was completely obliterated, there
- 52:05are thousands and thousands of kids who have seen their families right. There is
- 52:10no endgame here. Let's know, would you be happy the rest of your
- 52:14life in your family? I mean just fucking go up and smoke. Would
- 52:21you say, yeah, hey, oh I want to be secular and democratic?
- 52:23Oh yeah, that's what I want to do. If revenge is the
- 52:27one thing that life offered you, that's what you would do. And anyone
- 52:30you know out there who thinks they're different, I would love to hear from
- 52:35them. Yeah. It's like a zenous person in the fucking world. All
- 52:40right. That's on that happy note. On that happy note. Soon,
- 52:45probably not next week, because something exciting will show up soon. We're going
- 52:49to talk about Taiwan guys. And this is the opportunity for Dee to say
- 52:54what was the phrase, uh, non consensual unification, which is it's my
- 53:02favorite favorite movies weners. But I know it's gonna be a serious comment.
- 53:07I just wanted to get that out of the way. Yeah, all right,
- 53:10all right, don't forget to like and subscribe if you're listening to us
- 53:15on Audio rate and review at five stars. Check out Andy's book, check
- 53:19out Andy's Twitter. All the links will be in a description below. Patreon
- 53:22dot com slash the Teamhouse is the best way to support these shows. You
- 53:27get ad free audio, you could ask questions if you have any, even
- 53:31to eyes on. We will get to them, I promise you. And
- 53:35it's just the best way to support the show because YouTube is not awesome right
- 53:38now. Thank you, thanks guys. Yeah, totally