Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 243: Simple is a Superpower - The 5 Factors to Get Your Message Heard. Ben Guttmann
Transcript
- 0:00How do you craft simple messages that win big?
- 0:03That's the question we will answer in this episode with Ben Gottman.
- 0:06Ben built, ran and sold and award winning marketing agency,
- 0:09teaches marketing at the largest business school in the US
- 0:12and just published an outstanding book called Simply Put
- 0:15why clean messages win and how to design them.
- 0:18The clean and simple message is sticky, convincing and moves others to act.
- 0:21In one word, simple is effective.
- 0:24You probably already know that, but as we fall experienced, simple is not easy.
- 0:29Fortunately for us, Ben identified the five principles to create simple messages.
- 0:35Before we dive in, I have something big to announce.
- 0:38Enrollment for the Speak Like A CEO Academy is now open.
- 0:42If you want to transform your communication skills and work with me for the next 12 weeks,
- 0:46head over to Speak Like A CEO Academy.com.
- 0:50The Academy includes by weekly live group coaching sessions with me and other world class experts,
- 0:54my brand new presentation mastery course, the community for peer to peer exchange,
- 0:59and a huge on-demand knowledge base with step by step templates and frameworks.
- 1:04I hope to see you there and if you sign up for the 12th of June,
- 1:07you will secure the lowest price the Academy will ever be.
- 1:10Speak Like A CEO Academy.com, the link is in the show notes.
- 1:15Now, enjoy this fascinating conversation with one of the world's pre-eminent experts on messaging, Ben Gottman.
- 1:23Ben, thanks so much for being on Speak Like A CEO today.
- 1:25Thanks for having me, Oliver. It's great to be here.
- 1:27So, what's the backstory? How did you get into messaging?
- 1:30So, I ran a marketing agency for 10 years,
- 1:33and I started that agency basically right out of college.
- 1:37When I was a student, I was the big student government dork.
- 1:40I was the president and I did all that stuff.
- 1:42I didn't do a ton of the internships and all the things I probably should have done
- 1:46to get a job at marketing.
- 1:49But thankfully, I had a professor who was an adjunct and he ran his own agency,
- 1:55pulled me aside one day and said, hey, I know you kind of want to maybe start your own thing.
- 1:59We need some help of digital.
- 2:01Maybe we can figure something out.
- 2:03So, one thing led to another.
- 2:05We ended up me and a couple of buddies ended up piling into my 94 Honda Accord,
- 2:10drove out of the city because their office was just north of New York,
- 2:14and slapped their logo on the wall and started working with them.
- 2:18They worked with like four to 500 clients.
- 2:21We were a bunch of knuckleheaded, you know, 21-year-olds.
- 2:24We didn't really know what we were doing.
- 2:26But thankfully, we ended up cutting our teeth on things like the local ice cream shop
- 2:30and the local camera shop and these small businesses that for some reason
- 2:34were trusting us to handle their marketing.
- 2:37And lo and behold, one thing led to another.
- 2:39We ended up moving out of their basement.
- 2:41We got our own office here in Queens.
- 2:44We started to work a slightly bigger clients.
- 2:47We hired employees. We got a bigger office.
- 2:49I have more employees.
- 2:51And 10 years later, we're working with the NFL and I live in New York.
- 2:56And some of these really awesome brands across a whole bunch of different spaces.
- 3:00And that experience was incredible.
- 3:03That's a fun ride.
- 3:05After 10 years, though, you get a little bit of a 10-year-age.
- 3:07And we ended up finding a really good opportunity to sell the business.
- 3:11We sold it to a couple different suitors a couple years ago.
- 3:16And since then, I've been involved in all bunch of different things.
- 3:20I wrote this book, simply put, why clear messages when and how to design them.
- 3:25I've been teaching.
- 3:27I am a adjunct professor at Baruch College here in New York.
- 3:31And I've been doing some independent consulting since then as well.
- 3:35And so I've been able to kind of take what I've learned in the classroom as a teacher.
- 3:39I've been able to take what I've learned in the boardroom as an agency.
- 3:44And see what is the connective tissue between all of this that is the challenge that people have.
- 3:53They hire somebody and marketing to solve, which is they have something they really want to tell people.
- 3:58They have some product they really want to get out there.
- 4:00But they have really hard time doing that.
- 4:02And that's what I aim to work on today with this book and everything else.
- 4:07They do.
- 4:08I think the clarity and being concise and just simply put as you put it in your book,
- 4:14that's a huge challenge for people.
- 4:16I see this every day.
- 4:18And it's understandable.
- 4:19Simplicity is hard as you point out at the book, right?
- 4:22It is really hard and it is way easier to be complicated.
- 4:26Oh, yeah.
- 4:27And so that's what I found.
- 4:28When I looked at what is it that my students asked me and what is their clients were asking me?
- 4:33How do we, you know, all boils down to basically this question, which is what is the difference
- 4:38between a piece of messaging that works and a piece of messaging that doesn't work?
- 4:42And you kind of, you know, kind of spoiled the end there, which is that the answer is simple, right?
- 4:47And that's not particularly revelatory to say that, you know, simple is more effective.
- 4:51But when you look at kind of under the hood of what that means,
- 4:56well, there's a surprising amount of kind of science that goes on about why we prefer simplicity.
- 5:02Yeah.
- 5:03And then there's a really hard process we often have to go through to get to that place of simplicity.
- 5:10Before we go that, I'd love to find out a little bit more about how you discovered what works and what doesn't.
- 5:16I mean, 10 years of marketing, cutting your teeth, you know, from the ice cream shop to the NFL, surely there were some learnings
- 5:22and some stories, maybe you could share about what worked and what didn't work.
- 5:26Well, I'll tell you this, the ice cream shop and the NFL are a lot closer to each other than you would think.
- 5:33Every type of client kind of has the same issues at the end of the day.
- 5:38And we put up a lot of scaffolding in our industry about there being, you know, we have these programmatic ads.
- 5:44We have this new AI tool.
- 5:46And we like to think often that it is this big scientific, very complex business.
- 5:52But what it all boils down to is just two things.
- 5:57There's the vessel and the contents.
- 5:59And so the vessel is that more technical piece.
- 6:01So the vessel is, you know, here is the type of website we're doing.
- 6:04Here's the new TikTok thing. Here's the new type of digital ad that tracks you here and there.
- 6:10That is relatively complex, but it's also very learnable that type of stuff.
- 6:15You can do a few certification, you can watch some YouTube videos, you can get there.
- 6:19The contents, though, that is the hard part.
- 6:23The contents is the creative, right?
- 6:26That is, what is it that you're trying to say?
- 6:28Marketing is just, what are you trying to tell people and how do you get it?
- 6:31How do you tell them, right? The vessel and the contents, or in burst rather, the contents and the vessel.
- 6:36And so it doesn't matter if you are a small business with just a couple hundred dollars in your pocket
- 6:44or if you're a multi-billion dollar organization.
- 6:47If you don't get the contents, right?
- 6:50Well, it doesn't matter really how much, you know, how much you rock a fuel or a gas
- 6:56or whatever other analogy you want to put behind it.
- 6:58That's right. Yeah, I think a lot of companies on TikTok, for instance,
- 7:02are a bit cringe and they're spending clearly a lot of money, but it's not going to have the effect
- 7:06because they're on the right channel, the right vessel potentially.
- 7:09But the content, the message is off.
- 7:12So why is it important that a message is simple, especially today?
- 7:17So this all boils down to this idea of fluency.
- 7:21And so we've heard the word fluent before in our lives, right?
- 7:24You can be fluent in English or Spanish or Mandarin.
- 7:27You can be fluent in your hobby, you can be fluent in your favorite TV show or your favorite or wine.
- 7:33But when you ask a cognitive scientist about the word fluency, it's something a little bit different.
- 7:39It describes how easy is it for you to take something from out in the world,
- 7:45stick it in your head and make sense of it, right?
- 7:48How easy is it for you to perceive something, to understand something and take action on that thing?
- 7:53And when it is easier, when it takes less mental work, less sweat, less processing,
- 8:00well, all the science points to the same thing.
- 8:03We like it more, we trust it more or more likely to buy it or choose it.
- 8:08All the things that we want when we're talking about business, we're talking about marketing, we're talking about advocacy.
- 8:15And the opposite, the inverse of this is also true, right?
- 8:19So if something takes a lot of work, if there's friction, if it makes you really sweat and kind of have to decipher,
- 8:24it's hard to read it, it's hard to hear it, we don't like it, we don't trust it, and we don't buy it.
- 8:28All the things that we don't want when we're in the position of communicating.
- 8:32So it's very important that we get to that state of fluency.
- 8:36That's where we want to be as receivers.
- 8:39But when we're on the other side of things, when we're on the sender side of the equation,
- 8:44we have a really hard time getting there often.
- 8:47We're pulled in this other direction from forces internal and forces external.
- 8:52We have additive biases, we have complexity biases, we're more likely to add them subtract when we're face of a problem.
- 8:58That's one piece.
- 9:00And then on the outside, well, everything pushes us in that direction, right?
- 9:04We're pulled in terms of, you know, the demands of the news cycle, the demands of the resume,
- 9:10the demands of the social media machine looking for more and more and more.
- 9:14And what results is we have this big gap, right?
- 9:18We have as a receiver, we want things to be fluent, and as a sender, we are almost constitutionally built to not get there.
- 9:27That is fascinating. And my understanding is that it is a lot to do with how the brain works, right?
- 9:32It is probably 2% of body mass, but 25% of the energy consumption of our body, you know, those are the figures from the top of my head.
- 9:40So we are evolutionary designed to avoid spending more energy on cognitive tasks.
- 9:47And therefore, if something causes friction in the brain, we avoid it.
- 9:51And today's world that often means we just keep scrolling, or we just don't look at the billboard, or just ignore it, right?
- 9:57Because we get bombarded by thousands of messages every day.
- 10:00Absolutely. And what I like to say is that we think that things change a lot when it comes to marketing, when it comes to tech technology.
- 10:09And we will look back at a book from 30 years ago. Like, oh, the examples are so outdated this and that.
- 10:16But when it comes down to it, we haven't really changed a lot in 250,000 years.
- 10:21We've basically been the same machinery for all of that time.
- 10:25And to your point is what influence our development at that time is still stuff that we're dealing with at this time.
- 10:32We still have to be cognizant of that when we are going about our very modern activities of advertising, of advocacy, of whatever it is.
- 10:41Could you give me an example of messaging or an ad campaign that has worked really well because it's so simple and fluent?
- 10:48Yeah, so I have a few different principles about of simplicity that we use to kind of get to that state of fluency.
- 10:59And so I have all sorts of different examples in the book about different campaigns.
- 11:05So we talk about benefits a lot and I'm sure we'll get into this a little bit more.
- 11:09One of the ones that always comes to mind is it's almost cheating to use Apple.
- 11:15Actually, in my class, I ban my students from using Apple as an example because it's too easy.
- 11:20Good code.
- 11:21I do, it's too, but yeah, it's too.
- 11:23But they have one of the best clear as day examples of talking about benefits in their marketing, which is when they introduced the iPod, sorry, about 20 years ago.
- 11:33Their campaign was, it's a thousand songs in your pocket.
- 11:37A thousand songs, you immediately understand what's in it for you.
- 11:41You don't have to decipher that.
- 11:43You don't have to figure out, you know, if they're eight gigabytes or there's as many pixels on the screen, how long is the battery.
- 11:48I don't care. It's a thousand songs in your pocket.
- 11:51And when you looked at what Microsoft, they've gotten a little bit better recently.
- 11:55But Microsoft at that time was particularly struggling with some messaging.
- 11:59They had a product that competed with the iPod came out just after called the Zoom.
- 12:05They went from campaign to campaign to campaign.
- 12:08And none of them really stuck.
- 12:10One of them was music the way it wants to be.
- 12:13I can't even remember that product.
- 12:16I was like, music the way it wants to be.
- 12:19What does that mean?
- 12:20It's pretty words, but it's not an effective message because it's something that sounds nice to the ear.
- 12:26It looks nice on a flyer, but ultimately doesn't connect at all with what the benefits are.
- 12:31And because it doesn't connect to what my motivations are, it's not fluid.
- 12:35It's not something that I'm interested in kind of internalizing.
- 12:38I take it.
- 12:39I quickly kind of process it and I throw it away.
- 12:41There was another example in your book.
- 12:43I think about every night when I brush my teeth.
- 12:46Oh, yeah.
- 12:47This one is a favorite.
- 12:49So this is not an advertising campaign.
- 12:52But I've had unfortunate dental luck with my genetics, right?
- 12:57So I've ended up with a dentist quite a few times.
- 12:59And one time after a particularly painful appointment, the dentist tells me,
- 13:05well, you only have to floss the teeth you want to keep.
- 13:08That's so good.
- 13:09And after years of having a bad luck as well as having a hard time kind of clicking in terms of getting that habit formed,
- 13:18all of a sudden, this very straightforward and IR goes empathetic
- 13:23because it's talking in the language that I want it to be.
- 13:26A message clicks in a way that if he said something like,
- 13:30you said floss to prevent plaque buildup below the gum line, that would it click?
- 13:34That's a lot of buzzwords.
- 13:36It's their language, not my language.
- 13:38It's not telling me really what's in it for me.
- 13:40But by saying, you only have to floss the teeth you want to keep.
- 13:44That's so good.
- 13:45Immediately ago, damn, you got me.
- 13:47That's the right way to frame it in my book.
- 13:51So he may have tried this on hundreds of patients and see what message stuck.
- 13:57But for a company, obviously, we would like something a bit more methodological.
- 14:00So can you show us and tell us how you would think about crafting a simple message that works?
- 14:07Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:08So I alluded a little bit before to the five principles for this.
- 14:13So when you look at the science about how do we get to fluency?
- 14:19What is a fluent piece of communication?
- 14:23We can identify five design principles that help us get there.
- 14:27This isn't a step-by-step plan.
- 14:29It's not a rubric.
- 14:30But the closer we can adhere to these five principles or follow them,
- 14:34the more we're going to match up with how our receiver wants to get that message.
- 14:40And so the first one, I just hinted at it before, it's beneficial.
- 14:44So what does it matter to the receiver?
- 14:46What's in it for them?
- 14:48And this is, if you've ever worked in sales, it's like sales 101, right?
- 14:52We buy benefits, we don't buy features.
- 14:56Second one is focused.
- 14:58Are you trying to say one thing or multiple things at once?
- 15:02Is this one idea or is this three ideas in a trench coat?
- 15:06What is the one core message you want people to understand?
- 15:10The third is salient.
- 15:12Does your message stand out from the noise?
- 15:14Does it dig when others ag?
- 15:16Is it contrasting of the background?
- 15:18Does it rise to your attention?
- 15:20We're in a very noisy environment in terms of how much media we consume,
- 15:26how many people are trying to blast advertising into our brain.
- 15:29And so how do we stand out in that type of space?
- 15:33Orph is empathetic, and that's talking about the dentist, right?
- 15:37Are you speaking in a language that the audience understands?
- 15:40Are you meeting the where they are?
- 15:42In terms of the little words, but also in terms of their motions, their motivations,
- 15:47and making sure they were able to authentically connect.
- 15:50And then the last one is minimal.
- 15:53Have you cut out everything that isn't important and kept only what is?
- 15:59When we're talking about this, actually, we're not talking about the fewest number of words,
- 16:03or pages, or paragraphs, we're talking about the least amount of friction.
- 16:08And so that's really important.
- 16:10And I lied a little bit when I said it's not in a particular order,
- 16:13but minimal is at the end because if you only really know what it is that you have to keep
- 16:18and what it is that you can toss if you were able to kind of think through the other four ahead of it.
- 16:23Right. That makes sense for that to be at the end.
- 16:26And we all see messages or attempts at messaging that are about completeness
- 16:31and everyone contributes, so everything is in there.
- 16:34And those obviously are not beneficial, and it requires that check at the end.
- 16:39Now, how do you get there? So in practical terms,
- 16:43I understand it's not a five-step process.
- 16:45It is five principles you should adhere to as much as you can.
- 16:48Is it a group of people who understand the product in a room,
- 16:52who work shopping the message, or how would your experience do you best get to messages that work?
- 16:57Yeah, so there's a number of different kind of tools and processes within these principles that I have in the book.
- 17:05Let's zoom in a little bit on the benefits again, actually,
- 17:08because I think that one is also a little bit of my life from before.
- 17:13That one is first because it is the most important of these.
- 17:17It's important that we meet people where they are in terms of what they want,
- 17:22how something fits into their lives.
- 17:26Again, sales 101, marketing 101 piece of benefits.
- 17:31Let's talk a little bit about what this means.
- 17:36So if I have a brand of toothpaste, so bring it back to dental analogy.
- 17:43Brand of toothpaste has mint flavor.
- 17:46The mint flavor is actually a feature.
- 17:49I'm not buying toothpaste because it has mint flavor.
- 17:52I'm buying toothpaste with a mint flavor because it makes my breath fresher.
- 18:00Okay, well, that's the benefit that I get at them.
- 18:03We'll call that the functional benefit, the first level of this.
- 18:06And the way we get from here to there is by a very simple question appropriately.
- 18:11So you say, well, mint toothpaste, mint flavor, so what?
- 18:16Well, that makes my breath fresher.
- 18:18Okay, well, I'm getting a little bit closer to why I'm actually buying that toothpaste.
- 18:23But ultimately, the magic happens when we go through that process a couple more times.
- 18:27So we ask so what and so what again and again.
- 18:30Let's look at that fresh breath.
- 18:32I actually don't even want fresh breath.
- 18:34What do I want?
- 18:35Well, I want to have maybe a more successful date tonight.
- 18:39Okay, well, I'm starting to get a little bit closer to what my actual motivations are.
- 18:43Because I went mint flavor, so what?
- 18:46Fresh breath, so what?
- 18:48More successful date.
- 18:49And you can dig one more layer to go from that second level benefit,
- 18:54which also call the emotional benefit, to what our foundational motivations are,
- 18:59which are another list of five things you've probably seen in a psychology textbook,
- 19:03the Maslow's hierarchy of needs.
- 19:05If you say, well, okay, we have a more successful date.
- 19:09So what?
- 19:10Well, that fulfills my physiological needs, right?
- 19:12Or my love and belonging needs, or one of those things.
- 19:15And so by asking this question a few times,
- 19:17we're able to ladder up from a very kind of tangible thing,
- 19:21which is this flavor, the scent, to something that is a foundational motivation of our behavior.
- 19:28And we're able to then kind of stand in that position, turn around and say,
- 19:31okay, well, we're going to communicate outwards from there.
- 19:34We're able to say, let's invest proportionally in each one of those layers across our communication,
- 19:41right?
- 19:42Maybe our advertising starts with the love and belonging, you know, the date,
- 19:45and then goes through the fresh breath and then talks about the mint flavor instead of going to the way around.
- 19:50So that's a very kind of easy to understand process that everybody can easily pick up
- 20:00and use to make a more effective message.
- 20:03And to that end, by the way, there is a great quote,
- 20:07the chapter that comes from is called the whole, not the drill.
- 20:11And this comes from a quote by Theodore Levitt, who was taught at Harvard in the 20th century.
- 20:16He said, people don't want to buy a quarter inch drill, they want a quarter inch hole.
- 20:21I tell my students, if you remember nothing else from my entire course,
- 20:25the entire degree, if you remember that, you could be out of most people.
- 20:29A hundred percent, I actually quote that as well in my most recent book message machine.
- 20:33We then take it one step further and say, actually, people don't want to hold.
- 20:36They want to picture on the walls.
- 20:38It's exactly what you said. You always go that next level.
- 20:40Yeah, so what, what's the whole for?
- 20:42Yeah, it's for the picture to make your home look more beautiful, right?
- 20:45Or to put up a picture of your family. So a hundred percent.
- 20:49Now, where do people get wrong?
- 20:51So we see love messaging that just doesn't work.
- 20:54And, you know, it is hard. We all know this, right?
- 20:57It is not easy. Complex is easy, simple is often hard.
- 21:01What are the like two, three mistakes you see companies make when they craft the messaging?
- 21:07So I think the biggest one is the benefits people, people miss that.
- 21:10And I'll tell you, I'll tell you why, which is if you are a startup or if you're, you know,
- 21:16just an individual creating their own, their own value out in the world,
- 21:21you see that benefit right with your own eyes.
- 21:25You see it right there.
- 21:27As you get bigger and as you get older and as you get further removed from the customer,
- 21:32that benefit starts to get a little fuzzier and blurrier and you lose it as time goes on.
- 21:38But the features, they stay crisp as ever, right?
- 21:42You're able to see them, touch them, taste them, feel them.
- 21:45And in a way that you don't with the benefits.
- 21:49So we start to just defaulting, well, this drill has this all day battery life and has this comfort grip.
- 21:56But those aren't the reasons we're buying the drill, right?
- 21:59We're buying it because you want to get the whole, you want to get the photo in the wall,
- 22:02you want to get the love and belonging.
- 22:04So that's I think the biggest sin that people do is that it's just very natural for us to fall into that path.
- 22:11The other one that I think ends up being a problem for a lot of communicators is in that focus category.
- 22:21So I use this example to start that chapter.
- 22:25I've seen this happen with professionals.
- 22:28I see it happen with my students, which is what I call the Frankenstein idea.
- 22:33Let's say the student example.
- 22:35I give them an assignment, I say, here's a brand, give me a proposal based off of this brief.
- 22:41And they come back and without fail, at least one of the groups has a project that is we're using NFTs and we're using AI and we're using drones and we're using influencers and we have this hashtag, we have that hashtag, we got this celebrity.
- 22:56And all of a sudden, you have a lot of things thrown at you in a very short period of time.
- 23:01And we're like, well, what actually is this for senior citizens? Is this for teenagers?
- 23:06Is this for people who are frequent flyers or is this people for who are students?
- 23:12They're just trying to be everything for everybody.
- 23:15And because of that, it just all falls apart.
- 23:19Where individually those items might be great, but collectively it ends up being a disaster.
- 23:25And if you look at Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, how she describes the monster, well, it's not that everything was terrible put in it.
- 23:33Is that individually, the items were selected to be beautiful.
- 23:37You know, lustrous black hair, probably white eyes, big muscular soldiers, all these things were just were selected to be individually beautiful components.
- 23:45But when you put them together, it becomes a monster.
- 23:48And that happens all the time when you have a collaborative creative process without leadership.
- 23:55You need to have creative leadership to be able to say, this is good. This is not as good.
- 24:00And be able to kind of cross it out, deal with the politics of that.
- 24:03It puts a big target on your back. Nobody likes to do it.
- 24:06But it's a vitally important piece of the process.
- 24:10Positioning and messaging are not, it's not a democracy, right?
- 24:14It is, yes, consult widely if you like, but decide in a very small circle.
- 24:20What I see as well, if I can add one observation is that companies sometimes go straight from product to performance marketing
- 24:29and skip the process of proper positioning and messaging.
- 24:32And essentially say, okay, we have a product. Let's run some ads and see what people respond to.
- 24:37And while that may be part of your toolbox and can be useful in certain instances,
- 24:42it is not helpful to skip the whole positioning and messaging part and just throw things out of all and see what sticks.
- 24:48Why is that not a good idea? Well, it can be very expensive for one because you don't have a strong hypothesis of what may work.
- 24:54So you have to test a lot.
- 24:55And secondly, you may, you are at risk of becoming a commoditized brand that has no core.
- 25:01That it is, well, it is not clear what you stand for, what your values are, who you are.
- 25:06Because in a way, you outsource this to the crowd on Instagram today.
- 25:11And tomorrow they, that crowd may have a different view on your messaging.
- 25:14So you have to keep changing it and you never develop a strong brand.
- 25:17Is that also your observation?
- 25:19I am so glad you heard that Oliver because I agree on a percent.
- 25:22I think that there are actually two parts of that that are like the sins that a lot of us fall into.
- 25:28Number one is performance marketing has been very successful in the last 20 years because it's basically like a blunt force object.
- 25:36I can slice and dice my target.
- 25:39I can track them all around the internet.
- 25:41I can hit them over the head a thousand times until they buy my stuff.
- 25:45Most of them won't enough will that makes everything worth it.
- 25:48But that era is beginning to kind of fade and change as we look at different policies from the EU, from California, other places.
- 25:58As we look at how technologies are changing in terms of Google and Mozilla and Apple all saying kind of we're doing more privacy less tracking.
- 26:06So I think that's one piece of it, which is that we have to begin to look at a world where that doesn't really work anymore.
- 26:15But the second one is that positioning thing, that positioning piece is so hard for so many people.
- 26:21I have sat in rooms with senior leaders who have worked at a company for years and years and years.
- 26:26And they cannot answer the like basic questions of positioning.
- 26:30And so what I, you can go through a whole exercises, their whole grape books about positioning.
- 26:34But it really boils down to kind of three questions that you have to answer at the beginning there.
- 26:39Number one is who is your stuff for?
- 26:42Who is your audience? Who is your target?
- 26:45Number two is what problem do they have that you solve?
- 26:50How do you make their life better?
- 26:52And then the last one is, well, why are you better than everybody else in solving that problem?
- 26:57Why are you better than every other possible solution to that?
- 27:00What are your benefits?
- 27:02So many people can't get those three right.
- 27:04And it's worth, to your point, it's worth a pause.
- 27:07Whenever you're doing any sort of marketing, any sort of brand building, to get those things right,
- 27:12or at least get a sketch of them, because it ultimately makes everything else easier.
- 27:16That's also the secret. It makes it more effective.
- 27:18But if you understand those things, every time you have to write, copy for your website,
- 27:22every time you have to do an ad campaign, new product description, packaging, you know where you're coming from.
- 27:28You know, okay, this is who I'm talking to, and this is what this is what I do with my product,
- 27:33and this is why people choose me.
- 27:35If you get that right, it's worth the pause in the beginning, because it makes everything else easier.
- 27:42I'm so glad you said that, and only once the positioning is clear,
- 27:45should we move to the messaging.
- 27:47Is that book you can recommend on positioning?
- 27:50There's a lot of great books.
- 27:52April Dunford has a book I'm positioning.
- 27:55I also, I would say if you look at something like the Blue Ocean strategy,
- 28:04there's some elements from that book, which can help you get there and understand, okay, well,
- 28:08what is it that I'm solving, how to create value differently than people?
- 28:12And then also, to be frank, one of the books I recommend a lot when it comes to,
- 28:17when it comes to any sort of marketing, and the positioning is part of it,
- 28:20is Ogil Vian advertising.
- 28:22If you go back 40 years, you can go grab a copy of this book.
- 28:26You know, I'm a believer if something's, if something has been effective
- 28:32and has stood the test of time for that many years or decades or centuries or whatever,
- 28:37it will likely still be applicable in the next decade.
- 28:41And it's, there are certainly great books that have come out more recently.
- 28:45Yours and mine included.
- 28:47But the real kind of gold standard is not what is the latest book on social media.
- 28:51It is, okay, well, how do we talk about psychology?
- 28:53How do we talk about communications in a way that is, is human and applies beyond
- 28:59just whatever the current fat is?
- 29:02It makes a lot of sense.
- 29:03And I would also recommend April Dunford's book.
- 29:05It's called Obviously Awesome.
- 29:06And it's, if you read one book I'm positioning, I would start there.
- 29:10It's just very helpful and very applicable.
- 29:12And she makes the point, which I also make in my book, that positioning statements.
- 29:16So there's this traditional formula.
- 29:18We are a company that does this and we did it.
- 29:20They're not particularly helpful because they're very boring.
- 29:23It's hard to remember.
- 29:25No one thinks in these terms.
- 29:26So it's better to use a canvas like she proposes with some questions you answer.
- 29:31You highlighted the most important three and take it from there.
- 29:35Now, if you take this to a high level like messaging architecture for a business,
- 29:41I think so far we looked at individual products, individual services, ideas.
- 29:45But let's say you're a big company, lots of different products and you need a whole messaging architecture.
- 29:50Do you apply the same principles?
- 29:52Is there anything else you would highlight?
- 29:54I think that, you know, you hit it on a good point there, which I think positioning has to happen
- 29:58at the beginning of that type of process.
- 30:00Because the individual messages are going to be all sorts of different audiences at different times
- 30:07and being able to have that seed that you can grow out of makes it a lot easier.
- 30:11One thing that, you know, actually, if I have any sort of little regret about this book,
- 30:15is that in the beginning of it, especially I talk a lot about tag lines and advertising slogans,
- 30:21partially because, I mean, intentionally that they are a high leverage,
- 30:26part piece of communication and they are going to have a lot of money behind them.
- 30:30They're going to be in a lot of different places.
- 30:32But that's not what we communicate.
- 30:34That's not how we communicate most of the time.
- 30:36Most of the time we're sending emails, we're writing reports, we're just giving presentations,
- 30:40we're talking to our colleagues in the hall.
- 30:42And being able to apply this type of thinking, this type of framework to those interactions,
- 30:49I think is actually really important.
- 30:51I think that, you know, keeping our eyes in the benefits,
- 30:54making sure that we're focused and organized and structured and how we're communicating in different ways,
- 31:00making sure, finally, at the end there, really that minimal,
- 31:03that we're not introducing friction to the process.
- 31:06This happens a lot when you look at organizations also,
- 31:11is that we begin to develop our own little universes of jargon.
- 31:16You know, I remember even in my agency, a small agency, a couple dozen people,
- 31:20we had our own language, right?
- 31:21You had this series of letters meant this thing, right?
- 31:25This shortened version of somebody's name meant this other thing.
- 31:29And when somebody comes in, you have to onboard them to them.
- 31:32But it's very easy for us to think that everybody knows these type of thing.
- 31:36They might not know our jargon, but they might know what we mean by a certain phrase or a certain name for something
- 31:44that other people don't always get.
- 31:46So being able to habitually develop ways where we can kind of break through that bubble,
- 31:54we're talking to our customers, we're talking to our audience,
- 31:56that's going to be something that will pay dividends in the long run, too.
- 32:02That's a great point.
- 32:04You've probably seen this Harris Grammily poll, which suggested that 88% of our time at work
- 32:10is spent communicating.
- 32:11A lot of that obviously includes probably hundreds of messages every day.
- 32:14And that can mean email, as you said, the message to your colleague,
- 32:19Slack channel, et cetera.
- 32:21And I'm really thankful that you've given me this vocabulary of fluency,
- 32:25versus friction, because I noticed this is what I'm doing.
- 32:28So when I look at a text, whether that's an email or a newsletter that's going out,
- 32:31I'm looking at for friction.
- 32:33So I try to detect friction and then try to eliminate it.
- 32:36But I didn't have the words to describe it.
- 32:38So that's actually super useful.
- 32:40Thank you, Ben.
- 32:41Now, how do I know if my message works?
- 32:44Yeah.
- 32:45That's because, you know, okay, I follow you.
- 32:47I hear you five principles.
- 32:49I apply them.
- 32:50I think it's awesome what we've created, but how do I know?
- 32:53So the biggest kind of node in this book is also going to be within the most people
- 33:01will ignore and that they won't do, which is to test your message.
- 33:05You have to go and you have to go find people that are representative of your audience.
- 33:10You have to go try to say the thing you want to say, write the thing you want to write,
- 33:14and see if they get it.
- 33:15And that's the only real test that matters, right?
- 33:18There's not going to be some piece of software you can go and be like,
- 33:20well, this scores this much and grammarly or whatever.
- 33:23You have to be able to talk to who matters and see, okay, did that hit?
- 33:28Did that land?
- 33:29And it's important that they represent your audience too.
- 33:33If I'm advertising to plumbers, it doesn't matter if I talk to 500 accountants.
- 33:41That doesn't help me.
- 33:43If I speak to five plumbers, I'm going to get more insight into my messaging
- 33:48and my efficacy of that, then I will if I talk to 500 accounts.
- 33:52So it's important that we do that.
- 33:54We don't do it a lot.
- 33:55People really don't like to do it because it's awkward, right?
- 33:59I've stood on the concourse, a grand central terminal and flagged down people.
- 34:03Yeah, and flagged down people to ask them, hey, does this work?
- 34:07Getting their opinion on things.
- 34:09And it's awkward.
- 34:11It's really weird the first.
- 34:12People don't like it because it's awkward in the moment,
- 34:15but it's also awkward in terms of getting feedback that's negative.
- 34:19Because you might get feedback that's negative.
- 34:21And people don't like to have people tell them, hey, I don't like what you're doing.
- 34:25I don't understand what you're saying.
- 34:26I don't want to buy your thing.
- 34:27People really don't like that.
- 34:28So people will shy away from it and it will be kind of left in the dustbin
- 34:34and therefore you're going to go in pursuit of not being awkward.
- 34:38You're going to go spend millions of dollars running in the wrong direction.
- 34:41That's a great observation.
- 34:42I've never seen in that clarity.
- 34:43It's actually a combination of two fundamental fears, right?
- 34:46The fear of rejection and the fear of talking to strangers.
- 34:51And you combine these and you have market researches, actually.
- 34:55That's why people like to put out a poll on LinkedIn,
- 34:57but find it hard to go out and actually talk to potential customers.
- 35:00The 500 plumbers for your plumbing software business say,
- 35:04how formal does this process have to be?
- 35:06So can you be at a train station just talk to strangers
- 35:09or should it be in the formal setting of a focus group that I film
- 35:12and keywords, looking for keywords and put in an excel sheet?
- 35:17How formal?
- 35:18I've done both.
- 35:19And if you have the money to spend on it,
- 35:21I mean, I know people that run wonderful marketing research organizations
- 35:25that can provide incredible insights that you would be blown away by.
- 35:31But not everybody has that budget, not everybody has that time.
- 35:35You can get learn a lot with a small sample.
- 35:38I mentioned like the five plumbers, right?
- 35:40You can, if you call up a couple people, if you pull a couple people aside
- 35:44and say, hey, quick reality check here.
- 35:46This is work.
- 35:47And there's even a shortcut.
- 35:49I mean, obviously the idea is you want to go test your audience.
- 35:52But if you say, hey, does this work?
- 35:55Just try talking to the mirror.
- 35:57Try talking to your dog.
- 35:58Try talking to a rubber duck sitting on your desk there.
- 36:01Because that alone will still get you something.
- 36:04As opposed to getting nothing, which is if I kind of do something,
- 36:08and I put it out there about really thinking about it.
- 36:11Go to walk down the hall and talk to somebody that is representative of your demographic.
- 36:18All of these things can be more useful than the zero that you're going to get
- 36:22if you're not going to do something else.
- 36:24Exactly.
- 36:25Even if you're high on expensive marketing research agency,
- 36:27it would still do the other things before,
- 36:29because you work with them with a much better hypothesis that they can test.
- 36:33Rather than just finding out the obvious things for a lot of money
- 36:36that you get found out yourself by talking to five people.
- 36:39Yeah, that is fascinating.
- 36:42So do you see any trends?
- 36:44Does messaging change?
- 36:46I know we're talking about pretty fundamental principles of human psychology
- 36:50and urology that influence what messages resonate.
- 36:53But nevertheless, do you see trends?
- 36:55Maybe potentially due to technology, due to social media?
- 37:00Yeah, I think that the...
- 37:02You're right, you know, the biology doesn't change.
- 37:05But the environment, which the biology is interacting with, certainly does,
- 37:10we, as a species, have complained about things
- 37:14giving noisier and busier and more distracting for a long time.
- 37:17You can look at people complaining about too many books, too many radio stations,
- 37:20too many television shows, too many movies, and ultimately, of course,
- 37:23too much content and social media.
- 37:25But there is evidence to suggest that this is different than that.
- 37:29The amount of time we spend on screens in terms of messaging,
- 37:32number of messages that we've received,
- 37:34these have chains in a way that is more significant than,
- 37:39oh my, they had too many newspapers.
- 37:41So that is certainly the kind of big force that I think makes more of this necessary.
- 37:49And I think that's only going to become worse, to be honest.
- 37:54I think that despite there being a consumer pushback in terms of people downloading
- 37:59meditation apps, people using screen time, things,
- 38:02there is a producer of content desire to put a lot of stuff out there, right?
- 38:09AI makes this a lot easier for people to basically kind of just follow the zone
- 38:14with a million tweets and LinkedIn posts, with a million blog posts,
- 38:19with Google's become a messy morass of spam,
- 38:23Amazon's a messy morass of spam.
- 38:26And all of these things, I think,
- 38:30present more and more of a necessity to be clear and fluent in the things that actually matter.
- 38:38Would you say that messages get more cross because of just the cockpit of overload,
- 38:43just to stand out that books have profanities in the title or that sort of thing?
- 38:47Yeah, so it's funny you mentioned the book, the profanity piece.
- 38:51If you look at the self-help or the business section of really any bookstore
- 38:58over the last few years, last decade, you see everything.
- 39:02You see all of the George Carlin, eight words you can't see on TV.
- 39:05You see all of them in the titles of all these books.
- 39:08And it started about 10 years ago, 12 years ago, with the first couple of books,
- 39:12that they stood out.
- 39:15And because everything else is the seven habits,
- 39:18highly effective people, something like that.
- 39:20But when you get to something like Mark Manson's book,
- 39:23the subtle art of not giving a fact, these things,
- 39:27when you put them side by side, it's like, wow, one of those is so different.
- 39:31And I argue about this in the salient, when we talk about salience,
- 39:35which is, this was different.
- 39:37This was different. This is a different other, this was contrast
- 39:40with the rest of the environment.
- 39:43But when you look today, a decade later,
- 39:46every book has one of these words in it.
- 39:49Every book has the BS or F that or whatever it is.
- 39:53And so all of a sudden, it doesn't work anymore.
- 39:57Because it's not salient, it's not different than everything else.
- 40:00That's saliency is a moving target.
- 40:03It's about seeing what others are doing and doing something different
- 40:07so that you're able to kind of stand out from that busy crowd.
- 40:11Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
- 40:12And it's a moving target.
- 40:14I think that's good to keep in mind.
- 40:16And obviously, to keep your finger on the pulse.
- 40:19Now, if I'm a pseudo-prenual CEO and it's okay,
- 40:22that makes a lot of sense.
- 40:24I want to ensure that our messages are simple and people,
- 40:27they resonate with people.
- 40:29So what are a couple of practical things they should do,
- 40:32maybe more organizational or psychological level internally,
- 40:35that will help them to move the organization from an organization
- 40:39that is addicted to complexity,
- 40:42to one that embraces simplicity.
- 40:45There's one tool that I'll give you that's really,
- 40:52I hate saying easy because easy things will be hard.
- 40:55That's a relatively easy shift, mindset shift,
- 41:00that we can do that will immediately pay dividends.
- 41:03And that is this idea of, speak to one person, not a crowd.
- 41:09So, crowds don't really exist when you think about it.
- 41:12Every time you've ever heard something in a crowd,
- 41:15if you've been at a political rally of 5,000 people,
- 41:17if you've been the receiving end of a super bowl ad of 100 million people,
- 41:21you're still one person.
- 41:23It's still one to one, right?
- 41:24They're still the one speaker, the one advertiser,
- 41:26and is coming into your head.
- 41:28And you make the decision, if I'm going to like this,
- 41:31vote for this person, donate by whatever it is.
- 41:35And so, there are crowd dynamics that is true.
- 41:38But for the most part, we're communicating,
- 41:40we want to speak in a one-to-one relationship.
- 41:43If you get up there and you're at your email,
- 41:45then you're sending out the people,
- 41:46says, hey, everybody, go download my new thing.
- 41:49I hope you all like this.
- 41:51That feels a lot less intimate and a lot less personal than going,
- 41:57Hi, Oliver.
- 41:59Please, it's been great to have you on my email list.
- 42:01Would you like to buy my PDF or whatever it is that's on here?
- 42:05And even if you don't have the person's name,
- 42:07even if by imagining that you're speaking to one person,
- 42:11it will pay dividends in a way that a million other marketing strategy
- 42:17things will only get you halfway to that piece.
- 42:21By the way, who the best in the world is at doing this right now?
- 42:26It's Taylor Swift.
- 42:29I don't know if you saw her movie that she did.
- 42:36But I went with my wife, she's a big swifty.
- 42:39One of my wife to the concert movie,
- 42:42and there's this magic trick that is happening on screen,
- 42:46which is she's standing there in front of 70,000 people
- 42:49and making every single person in that audience feel like
- 42:53she's talking to them, just one on one.
- 42:55As well as being able to do that over the court,
- 42:58over this expansive space and time for all the movie theaters
- 43:01and through all the months later across the world
- 43:04to be able to make every single person there feel like
- 43:07she's just talking to them.
- 43:09And you can achieve this by having a little like
- 43:12avatar of your customer or whatever,
- 43:14or take a post-it note,
- 43:16draw a little stick figure on it,
- 43:18slap it on the side of your computer monitor,
- 43:21and every time you're writing an email,
- 43:22every time you're giving a presentation,
- 43:24you're giving it to that little guy,
- 43:26not to look out.
- 43:28I love that.
- 43:29And I think that's what she has in common with,
- 43:31you know, the Obama's and all the great speakers
- 43:33in history that they really understood they're speaking
- 43:35to one person, not to deal or that's fantastic.
- 43:39If I would add another one,
- 43:41slightly different one,
- 43:43a lot of organizations' complexities just baked into it
- 43:46because people don't want to miss something,
- 43:49because they know they will get probably a negative feedback.
- 43:52Let's say you're writing a briefing for the CEO
- 43:54and the CEO is on stage at some debate or event,
- 43:57and they put all the issues in there that could come up,
- 44:00and of course it's way too long and the CEO won't read it.
- 44:03So what is helpful in my view is if the CEO,
- 44:07whoever's in that leadership position,
- 44:09pushes back and says,
- 44:10hey, can you give me one page briefing with clear messages?
- 44:14Ideally, the CEO knows the messages, of course,
- 44:16but just to educate also the team
- 44:18and not wasting time on things that he would,
- 44:20or she would never read and never use,
- 44:23but to have something that's fit for purpose
- 44:25that follows the five principles you mentioned.
- 44:28And that I think would save so much time
- 44:31and the same, of course, for presentations,
- 44:3330 million PowerPoint presentations
- 44:35that developed every day in businesses around the world.
- 44:39That's probably cool half billion slides every day.
- 44:42How many of those are really clear and simple and actionable?
- 44:47Probably not many.
- 44:49So businesses waste a lot of time,
- 44:51apparently one and a half to two days a week
- 44:54of either creating or listening to presentations,
- 44:57many of which are just not simple enough to resonate.
- 45:00Oh, certainly.
- 45:01I think actually, you really have the nail
- 45:03that had there by these constraints, right?
- 45:05Being able to say, hey, I need this in the one page, right?
- 45:07I need this in the one slide.
- 45:10That can be very beneficial.
- 45:12The other thing, though, that's a little bit contradictory,
- 45:15which I like to argue, is that minimal,
- 45:18again, to talk about minimal,
- 45:19it's not about the least number of slides.
- 45:21It's not about the least number of pages in your website.
- 45:23It's about it being the easiest, right?
- 45:25It's about the least amount of friction in there.
- 45:27And you'll often see that sometimes,
- 45:32more slides make something easier to understand,
- 45:35because instead of cramming everything
- 45:37into this one really dense, confusing slide,
- 45:40if you break something up into its component ideas
- 45:42and you go through your four slides of that,
- 45:44that can often make something a little bit easier to digest.
- 45:49It's, you know, there's a thing I find myself saying a lot,
- 45:52which is, you know, pixels are free, right?
- 45:54So on your website, instead of putting every single thing
- 45:58into this one little section, let it breathe, right?
- 46:00Put more white space between it,
- 46:02put more sections between it,
- 46:03let things have the quiet and the loud
- 46:06so that you're able to properly digest them as we go.
- 46:11You see, this is a kind of user experience.
- 46:14My background is in design,
- 46:16the user experience principles here,
- 46:18which is if you've ever done like a survey,
- 46:20like a marketing research survey
- 46:22or customer satisfaction survey,
- 46:24they don't put all the questions at once, right?
- 46:27Because if you got to that screen
- 46:28and there's all the questions there,
- 46:30you go, oh, I'm not doing this.
- 46:32And you get back at work, right?
- 46:35But it's hard work, it's hard work.
- 46:38But if you go and you just have a couple questions
- 46:41and it says, hey, how was your experience today?
- 46:43Hey, I was the cleanliness.
- 46:44How was the customer service?
- 46:46People will do that bit by bit
- 46:48over the course of five or six screens
- 46:50in a way which they won't do over one screen.
- 46:52But so it's counterintuitive, right?
- 46:54You say it's only one screen, it should be simpler.
- 46:56But you're interested in more friction
- 46:58by throwing 40 questions at somebody
- 47:00instead of dividing it over more digestible,
- 47:03easier to see, easier to comprehend sections.
- 47:05Yeah, 100%.
- 47:07I'm totally with you on that.
- 47:08And the same goes for use letters and everything else.
- 47:10And to your previous point,
- 47:12I love it that you make fluency
- 47:14your guiding principle, not brevity.
- 47:16And I think this works at the macro and the micro, right?
- 47:19If a writer sent in and I take words away
- 47:21because I have this writing principle
- 47:23and I had that delete superfluous words.
- 47:25And at some point you stop
- 47:26and you put something back in
- 47:28because you realize it just needs that
- 47:30maybe not grammatically,
- 47:31but just in terms of getting the message across
- 47:33the nuance of the message.
- 47:35Absolutely.
- 47:36Brevity is correlated
- 47:38with simplicity, with fluency,
- 47:41but it's not the same thing.
- 47:42Yes, that makes a lot of sense.
- 47:44That's awesome.
- 47:45Ben, thank you so much.
- 47:47Everyone, just please get the book.
- 47:49Simply put, why clean messages win
- 47:51and how to design them.
- 47:52And before I let you go,
- 47:53I have to ask you this,
- 47:54always my last question.
- 47:55What's your best piece of communications advice?
- 47:58My best piece of communications.
- 47:59I think I spoiled a few of them
- 48:02of course, this conversation.
- 48:03So I'll give you a little bit of my best piece of advice
- 48:05in general, which is appropriately
- 48:07it's some meta-advice.
- 48:09All advice is auto-biographical.
- 48:12So when people are giving you advice,
- 48:14it's not advice to you,
- 48:16necessarily it's advice to them in the past.
- 48:18By putting that lens on any piece of advice
- 48:21that you've received,
- 48:22you can make more use out of it.
- 48:24You can say what applies to me,
- 48:26what should I take,
- 48:27and then also what should I leave,
- 48:28what should I just let somebody else
- 48:30come in and take a bit of it?
- 48:32That's a brilliant,
- 48:33all advice is auto-biographical.
- 48:35I love that.
- 48:36And I think I've underlined it three times in the book.
- 48:38So that's just brilliant.
- 48:40Then it's been such a pleasure.
- 48:41I could talk to you for hours.
- 48:42I hope we get together in person one day in Berlin,
- 48:45New York, wherever you are.
- 48:46And yeah, all the best for what's coming in your life
- 48:51and your family, your growing families.
- 48:53So all the best to you,
- 48:54all the best for the book.
- 48:55And yeah, thank you.
- 48:57Thanks so much, Oliver.
- 48:58It's been an absolute pleasure.
- 48:59And you know, I'd love to catch up again soon.
- 49:02If anybody's interested to go, you know,
- 49:04check out BendGutman.com.
- 49:06It's got a free chapter you can download.
- 49:08It's two T's and two N's.
- 49:10It's not a great name for radio.
- 49:12I get it.
- 49:13But if you go there,
- 49:14there's a newsletter, a send out.
- 49:15Find my link then.
- 49:16We'd love to hear how this book is made in different ways.
- 49:19Absolutely.
- 49:20And we've also put the link in the show notes.
- 49:22So you can click on it and you know,
- 49:24check out the website.
- 49:25I highly recommend it.
- 49:26I appreciate it, Ben.
- 49:27Thank you so much.
- 49:28And thank you for listening.