Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Prax Lindsey woes, Hydrogen updates, and Trump in Aberdeen
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week we discussed Prax and
- 0:19it's refinery woes. Hydrogen.
- 0:21Got an update and stay tuned because we are going to give our
- 0:25two cents on Trump in Aberdeen. But joining me in this
- 0:29conversation is, as always, my fearless leader, our news
- 0:33editor, Erica Askeland. How are you doing today, Erica?
- 0:36Very good, although as I'd suggested, my house is an
- 0:40absolute mess. But I'm struck.
- 0:43I'm getting there. I'm getting there.
- 0:45As someone who's recently just moved, I understand the woes of
- 0:48decorating. It's a it's a rough time, but
- 0:51you know what? It's worth it in the end, they
- 0:53keep telling me. It will be.
- 0:55It will be. Yeah.
- 0:56I'm I'm looking forward to getting it, getting over it.
- 1:00And rounding out our trio this week is E Forward editor Ed
- 1:04Reed. How are you doing today, Ed?
- 1:06Any decorating? I'm also well, no, no
- 1:08decorating. I'm just in the, in the madness
- 1:10that I'm sure that in fact that much that Scotland has already
- 1:13gone into and and now England has joined of, of school
- 1:16holidays. So sort of wrangling additional
- 1:20children under foot, just jamming out the works.
- 1:23You know, Erica's chasing her belongings around the house and
- 1:26I'm trying to move children out of rooms.
- 1:29So, you know, we're, we're, we're all facing crises.
- 1:34I'm imagining this is going to this episode's going to be a bit
- 1:36like, you know, that it's a period of time at the start of
- 1:39COVID where like live news interviews had like children
- 1:43walking into the background. I'm really hoping that that's
- 1:46that's the day. Yeah, we totally need some of,
- 1:49you know, kind of babies walking up and interrupting Ed in his
- 1:53podcast. I mean, it's, it's, it's 5050,
- 1:56it's all I'm going to. Say it's a coin toss.
- 1:59Place your bets now, folks. But you know, we probably should
- 2:03get into the week's news. I mean, as much as I'd love to
- 2:05speak about your kids all week, we should probably discuss Prax,
- 2:09the Lindsay Refinery. A lot happened.
- 2:12Unions are giving their two cents.
- 2:14They're calling for government support.
- 2:16But let's maybe take it back to the the headline from the start
- 2:19of the week. Absolutely.
- 2:20So to take it back, in fact, even further to, to, to, to as
- 2:25long ago as June when the, the announcement that, that, that,
- 2:30that the Lindsay refinery was going was insolvent and various
- 2:34other of the Prax Group companies obviously really
- 2:38throwing into question, you know, this sort of the future of
- 2:41that facility. And three weeks later, you know,
- 2:45it's, it's, it's now become clear that it will not continue,
- 2:48that it has come to the end that it cannot essentially be sold
- 2:52as, as an entire unit. I think there are still some
- 2:55plans about maybe, you know, sort of maybe this important
- 2:58infrastructure, there's some storage, there's some
- 3:00distribution assets, you know, which might find a buyer.
- 3:03Obviously, you know, reduced refining capacity does mean more
- 3:07imports. So there might be a way forwards
- 3:09there. But it feels like, you know, the
- 3:12sort of the Lindsay refinery as a sort of a group is, is is no
- 3:15longer going to move forwards and obviously that means job
- 3:18losses. There was a sense of sort of
- 3:21impending, you know, sort of doom essentially, as you know,
- 3:24as soon as, as, as the insolvents which were announced,
- 3:27but finding a buyer would have, would have staved that off.
- 3:29That's now clear that, that, that you know, that that's not
- 3:32going to happen. So there may be as much as I
- 3:35think, I think the number was something like 600 and 36140
- 3:38jobs which which now look very much in question.
- 3:43So obviously that's, you know, a, a, a really, really difficult
- 3:46point for, for, for the Lindsay refinery workers.
- 3:49And as a result, you know, we're sewing as, as you said, you
- 3:52know, kind of concerns from United Union, I believe held a,
- 3:56a protest in Grimsby on the on the 23rd, you know, kind of
- 4:00calling for kind of government intervention.
- 4:02But it really feels like the government has, has, has gone
- 4:04essentially as far as it's going to go for that facility.
- 4:07I mean, you know, they, they, they, they did come in and say
- 4:10that they would keep it running, that they would, you know,
- 4:12essentially, you know, keep on processing the oil that was
- 4:14there. I believe it was supplied by
- 4:17Glencore, but I think also there was a sense that, you know, this
- 4:20can't go on forever that there that there did need to be
- 4:23somebody else kind of coming in and that's now clear.
- 4:25It's not. So yeah, it's it's it's a really
- 4:28challenging time for Lindsay. And I think obviously, you know,
- 4:31there, there's kind of like a big question there around, you
- 4:34know, sort of the future of, of refining in, in the UKI mean,
- 4:38you know, we had Michael Shanks speaking about kind of getting
- 4:41off the, the, the, the roller coaster of fossil fuel prices,
- 4:45while at the same time sort of speaking about, you know, sort
- 4:47of supporting the workers. So I think there's a bit,
- 4:49there's a bit of a sort of challenge there, isn't there
- 4:51around how do you how do you get off that roller coaster of
- 4:54fossil fuel prices and obviously also supports the workers in the
- 5:00fossil fuel roller coaster. I mean, I guess the trouble here
- 5:03is, is the refinery sector right sizing?
- 5:07Because of course, I mean, we do need, you know, petrol and
- 5:11diesel, which I think the Praxlancy refinery was involved
- 5:17with serving Prax, you know, also, you know, has a big
- 5:21distribution network for petrol and a petrol stations.
- 5:25I mean, it's a, it was an odd company and I always wondered
- 5:28about them. I thought, why are these people
- 5:30kind of buying all these assets, you know, Prax refinery and then
- 5:34of course they tried to buy upstream assets West of Shetland
- 5:38and the Shetland gas plant from Total, which of course never
- 5:42went ahead because they lost the plot and apparently have left
- 5:46the country. So, you know, interesting times.
- 5:50But of course, the interesting thing is, is that in Immingham,
- 5:54where the Lindsay Oil Refinery is based and which is going down
- 5:58the pan, you know, there's still the 50 Phillips 66 refinery.
- 6:02So is it just a matter of this is the refining capacity that
- 6:06the UK needs? Is that why, you know, the
- 6:09government is able to shrug its shoulders and go, hey, ho, who
- 6:13needs it? We'll save steel instead.
- 6:15And you know, the rest of the employees can just go hang and
- 6:18find something else to do. It does feel a bit like, yeah,
- 6:21there's, there's, there's a sort of more of a sort of a forwards
- 6:23trajectory, isn't there for this, for the steel industry, as
- 6:25you say. I mean, I think, you know, there
- 6:26has been discussion around perhaps including refineries in
- 6:29the energy intensive industries schemes that would, you know,
- 6:33give them sort of slightly slightly cheaper power, which
- 6:35they're not in at the moment. But yeah, I mean, I think there
- 6:37there is a there is a question around the UK's refining
- 6:42capacity, how we deliver what we need and how we find the right
- 6:46balance in terms of sort of imports.
- 6:48And obviously, you know, Lindsay shutting down doesn't mean more
- 6:50imports and, and there's also a, a pipeline from, from, from
- 6:54Lindsay to Heathrow. And obviously aviation is, is,
- 6:57is, is going to be a major one that will be really challenging
- 6:59to decarbonize. So I think there there were some
- 7:02big questions there. But yeah, it does feel like, you
- 7:05know, the the government is essentially sort of trying to
- 7:08back away from those refining capacity needs.
- 7:13Well, you know what I mean. It was Jim Ratcliffe, you know,
- 7:15back in the days when India still had refinery at
- 7:19Grangemouth. And you know, I think you've
- 7:21just literally put a finger on the problem, which of course,
- 7:25well, one of the main problems for operating refinery is just
- 7:28cost of energy. I mean, they're energy intensive
- 7:31and, you know, they just cost so much more to operate, you know,
- 7:35in the UK then certainly in the USI mean, you know, I was just
- 7:38looking at Repsol's results and their chairman was also
- 7:42complaining that, you know, the EU cost of energy, you know, is
- 7:46also hampering industrial development and stuff like that.
- 7:49But you know, I think in the UK we've definitely seen, you know,
- 7:53a lot of just industrial kind of decline hastening by, you know,
- 8:00just the cost of energy. I suppose part of that problem
- 8:02around around refinery is, is obviously around, you know, kind
- 8:06of the the future, you know, the the price of carbon, right,
- 8:08which we can all see is, is pretty much, you know, going up
- 8:12UKETS, joining up with the EUETS and just, you know, this sort of
- 8:15the, you know, general, you know, sort of outward pressures
- 8:17on that. So it is going to be more and
- 8:19more of a challenge. And I think, you know, Lindsay,
- 8:22you know, might have had some luck, you know, sort of joining
- 8:24up with Viking, perhaps. I think there was some
- 8:27discussion around that back in the day.
- 8:29But yeah, it's a challenge, right?
- 8:30And, and, and obviously that's that those costs are only going
- 8:33to go up. And then I think, you know,
- 8:35Philips's the, the, the Phillips's Humber refinery is,
- 8:39is a very interesting one. It feels like in some ways
- 8:41they're finding other ways to kind of, you know, square that
- 8:44circle at Philips, doesn't it? Because you know, they've got
- 8:46that sort of, you know, that sort of extra kind of graphite
- 8:49production, that kind of black matter.
- 8:50And it feels like they are slightly better integrated into
- 8:54by products and also carbon capture.
- 8:57And it feels like, you know, Lindsay was just too small, too
- 9:00old. It couldn't get that kind of
- 9:02critical mass. Prax bought it from total and
- 9:05never made a profit. So it does, I mean, obviously
- 9:08the government is, is keen to point to the, the, the, the
- 9:11family behind Prax as saying, you know, that that is
- 9:14essentially their fault, right? They, they've mismanaged the
- 9:16plant. They, they were never on top of
- 9:18it. And, you know, there, there is
- 9:19probably some truth to that, but part of it is, you know, Total
- 9:23sold it for a reason. Total was obviously struggling
- 9:27to to, to make headway with it. And if Total, you know, one of
- 9:30the largest energy companies in the world is is is is going to,
- 9:34you know, struggle. It was always going to be a
- 9:37challenge for Prax. Well, I struggled to get a word
- 9:42in edgeways there, but I think we did get, we did have a really
- 9:45well-rounded conversation without me and we don't need me
- 9:49in every conversation. But I do think that does rhyme
- 9:51now this 10 minute segment. So we're going to jump on to
- 9:55hydrogen. So going from dirty, dirty
- 9:57fossil fuels to maybe something cleaner, who knows?
- 10:38So hydrogen's really been hitting the headlines in the
- 10:41past couple of weeks or so, right?
- 10:43We've seen NISO released a report saying that hydrogen is
- 10:46going to play, you know, of quite a big role in the UK's
- 10:50energy mix. And then Hydrogen UK released
- 10:52that report saying this is all the use cases for it.
- 10:55That's what we think is going ahead.
- 10:57And then this week we've seen subsidies handed out to the HAR
- 11:011 project. And Erica, you've been reporting
- 11:04on the potential of blending hydrogen gas in in our grid.
- 11:10Yes well, right. So, I mean, let's just roll back
- 11:14a little bit and we are kind of entering that, um, you know,
- 11:17interesting, uh, summer season, uh, where maybe there's not
- 11:20going to be coming out, but in recent weeks, the Energy
- 11:24Department has been flinging out policy announcements with the
- 11:28energy of a caged orangutan flinging it's own poo is, you
- 11:33know, just the feeling that I've got there.
- 11:35But so, I mean, from Disney's, you know, we had a financial
- 11:39investment decision on Sizewell C So we've committed now to
- 11:42spending 50 billion on that upwards, you know, depending on
- 11:46how much that ends up costs. And then you also get like
- 11:49things like a, a, a clean flexibility road map for
- 11:52consumers so that they can use electricity and off peak times.
- 11:55And it's just this barrage of stuff.
- 11:58And then we got great British energy.
- 12:00They said, oh, here's another 10 million for rooftop solar, you
- 12:03know, on libraries in Yorkshire, which is like very exciting.
- 12:06Then we got a steer on AR-7 for floating offshore wind.
- 12:11You know, we've got a bit of a timeline.
- 12:13They have said that they're going to increase the lengths of
- 12:15contracts. Like, it's really hard to just
- 12:18kind of keep on top of this. This is quite common though,
- 12:20right? This is, you know, we're coming
- 12:22up summer recess. Yes.
- 12:24Shovel everything out the door so we don't have to deal with it
- 12:27when we get back. Oh, we've been working on this
- 12:29and we've been waiting for a good time to announce something
- 12:31about nuclear, but there was never anything in the headlines
- 12:34that coincided with it. Oh, just throw it out now.
- 12:36That'll do there we go. I feel like that's. 100%.
- 12:39These things. 100% and you know us at energy voice have been in
- 12:44this line, you know of fire you know dealing with all these
- 12:47stories and I hope everyone appreciates you're.
- 12:49Welcome readers. Right, Indeed, we're here so you
- 12:53don't have to be that said, so hydrogen announcement just
- 12:59yesterday actually was interesting because as you know,
- 13:03kind of Ryan suggested there was some funding support, although
- 13:08you know it didn't actually clarify kind of what this
- 13:10allocation was. It kind of pointed to the fact
- 13:13that the spending review had thrown an extra 500 million in
- 13:17the pot, you know, kind of for hydrogen transport and storage.
- 13:21And then of of course, the HAR 10 Har One projects are able to
- 13:26put shovels in the ground because the government has said
- 13:28that they've, you know, put a little welly behind those.
- 13:33But then of course, you know, this little extra addition that
- 13:38they put up was that they were going to look at consultation
- 13:44for injecting hydrogen into the UK gas network.
- 13:48So that is an interesting thing and you know, it kind of is a,
- 13:54it's not exactly the same as what we've got in Fife.
- 13:59Our colleague Jessica Mills Davis has been looking, you
- 14:02know, for the last little while at how householders are, whether
- 14:07or not they're going to be keen on having hydrogen kind of
- 14:09pumped directly into their boilers.
- 14:11But what we might have is EU KS gas network taking a percentage
- 14:15of hydrogen in their networks. Now this is a consultation.
- 14:20It's needs to kind of like look at evidence and it will be doing
- 14:24so, but probably till the end of the year, although timing is
- 14:27always flexible. But national gas, which operates
- 14:30the national transmission system, which is essentially a
- 14:34kind of thousands of miles of gas pipelines across the UK,
- 14:39think that it's pretty cool that they're able to do this or that
- 14:43they will be able to do them. I mean I.
- 14:45Think they have to say that, right?
- 14:46Don't they have to say that? Like otherwise, what are they
- 14:48going to? What are, what is their point in
- 14:50a world where we don't have, you know, we have diminishing
- 14:54volumes of gas, where we, you know, obviously moving away from
- 14:57gas for home heating, for industrial uses, what else are
- 15:02they going to do? They're not going.
- 15:03To do shower without, yeah, without hydrogen, I suppose
- 15:06they're on a hiding to nothing, particularly if we're trying to
- 15:08get a what, 3% gas up to like, you know, 95% of the system is
- 15:14going to be not gas. So, you know, I guess like this
- 15:17is their truth. And of course now, you know, the
- 15:19interesting thing about, uh, National Gas, of course, is they
- 15:23used to be part of National Grid, uh, but then, you know,
- 15:27they were acquired by, uh, Macquarie, umm, the Australian
- 15:31infrastructure owner, uh, and they bought a steak and then
- 15:35they bought like a bigger steak and now it's entirely privately
- 15:39owned. And then of course, you know,
- 15:40the way it works is they then work with, you know, the network
- 15:44operators like Cadenton, whatnot, who are also kind of
- 15:49keen to see this. You know, it's interesting what
- 15:51they're going to be doing is kind of putting together testing
- 15:55facilities that they've developed up in Cumbria.
- 15:58So they're working with DNV up at Spade Adam, in Cumbria, which
- 16:03is, you know, kind of of where, you know, the RAF facility is.
- 16:06But they've also got like, you know, these massive, like,
- 16:09testing facilities where they can explode stuff and, you know,
- 16:12burned stuff down and, you know, kind of develop.
- 16:16So it sounds like a lot of fun, actually.
- 16:18Yeah. But they've been able to develop
- 16:19that. I was there.
- 16:21I was there a couple weeks ago. Oh.
- 16:23My God, tell us about Spade. Adam I.
- 16:25Got bitten a lot by midges. They just really love my.
- 16:28Delicious, delicious. Southern blood, yeah.
- 16:32Well, see, yeah. So it was it was good.
- 16:34It was good. So yeah, had, you know, sort of
- 16:37bought around and and spoke to the people about about blending
- 16:41and, you know, obviously, you know DMV talking us through
- 16:43their their various things. Unfortunately we didn't get to
- 16:45see any explosions, which was. All this way and I know.
- 16:49Yeah, Come on guys, give me, give me a good explosion.
- 16:52But yeah, I mean, I think, I think it was, it was really
- 16:54interesting idea. And I think, you know, obviously
- 16:57you know, it's it's good that they're doing.
- 16:58I mean, I always have a concern around, around, around blending
- 17:01hydrogen to gas, right. Like it feels.
- 17:03What is that concern? Tell us.
- 17:06Thinking about how expensive hydrogen is and how cheap gas is
- 17:11you like. I think I've heard you once
- 17:12described it as pouring champagne down the drain.
- 17:15I think is what you once said. I mean it.
- 17:17It may not have been my, my, my, my, my saying original, but I
- 17:21think it's probably quite a good one.
- 17:22I mean, I think there are thing, there are obviously things that
- 17:25we should be doing with hydrogen.
- 17:27I'm not sure that injecting it into the grid for just sort of
- 17:30general gas uses is, is is possibly the best use.
- 17:34I feel like. Yeah, yeah.
- 17:37I mean, it's, it's, it's it's maybe a leap too far.
- 17:40Yeah. I mean, if you look back at that
- 17:41Hydrogen UK report that I've sort of alluded to at the start
- 17:44of this, like heating and stuff wasn't something that was being
- 17:48discussed. It was, it was long distance
- 17:50transport for like his she BS and buses and various other
- 17:53things. It was shipping.
- 17:55It wasn't necessarily blending in homes.
- 17:58That wasn't really what. Yeah.
- 17:59Hydrogen UK, the trade body for this exact sector, was
- 18:04advocating for and this also comes off the back of that
- 18:07subsidies program that Erica touched on at the top of the top
- 18:11of the segment. You know, the the government's
- 18:13just dished out subsidies to 10 of the 11 HAR 1 winning project,
- 18:18which allows them to sell hydrogen at a price competitive
- 18:21with fossil fuels such as diesel.
- 18:23The interesting thing I found about that press release from
- 18:26the government is it never called a subsidy.
- 18:29It just said that it was a it was a initiative to get shovels
- 18:32in the ground and get these projects built.
- 18:34It was ridiculously vague announcement.
- 18:36It was so annoying. You know, it's another one of
- 18:39those bits of poo that really, you know, should have been
- 18:41discarded. And I get it.
- 18:42Like, you know, there's there's people who kind of say, you
- 18:45know, hydrogen so expensive, you know, a bit too precious.
- 18:50We're not making enough of it. There's not a market.
- 18:52But if we did make our gas network increasingly orientated
- 18:57towards hydrogen, would that not boost the market and then reduce
- 19:02prices? Is this not the game that we're
- 19:05aiming to go for? Yield economies of scale, was
- 19:08that what you're sort of going for?
- 19:10Indeed. Look, I mean, obviously look,
- 19:12I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm very open to being proved wrong.
- 19:14I suspect that the way to get it going is not through sort of
- 19:20tiny incremental additions to the gas group.
- 19:24It would be through something rather more sort of I mean, I
- 19:28think I think project Union, I think is a very interesting idea
- 19:30and around I think I think, you know, there's some interesting
- 19:33ideas around storage and I think, you know, they're
- 19:35obviously, you know, and the the applied, you know, kind of, you
- 19:38know, issues we're saying like, I mean, I think, you know, sort
- 19:40of, you know, stand low and, you know, EET, you know, obviously
- 19:43sort of, you know, taking, you know, essentially moving from,
- 19:46you know, to to to blue hydrogen in order to to to use in their
- 19:50refineries, right. That's kind of like a lovely
- 19:52kind of A use case. They've got the carbon storage
- 19:54right there with with with with high net.
- 19:56It feels like that is kind of, you know, like a way forward.
- 19:59I feel like for hydrogen to make an impact on on the gas grid, it
- 20:02would have to be so cheap and so plentiful that it is, you know,
- 20:06that that we can afford essentially to waste it, right?
- 20:09Obviously that's a sort of a slight exaggeration, but I feel
- 20:11like the cost would need to come down so much to make it happen
- 20:15in that way. And it feels like obviously, you
- 20:17know, that is possible. You were a lot of wind that is
- 20:19coming. You know, we've got, you know,
- 20:21at least it feels we can get there.
- 20:23But it feels like actually, you know, the, the, the amount of
- 20:26electrolyzers you're going to need, it's just extraordinary,
- 20:29right? The biggest green.
- 20:30You know, hydrogen electrolyzer is nowhere near as big as the
- 20:34sort of the plans for for, you know, blue or other ones.
- 20:37So I'm, yeah, I'm, I'm sceptical, but obviously always
- 20:41Erica always, always ready to be, to be, to tell them wrong.
- 20:44Hydrogen scepticism now, you know, I think that's, you know,
- 20:46kind of perfectly reasonable. And, you know, if we didn't ask
- 20:49these questions and, you know, if we just took really, you
- 20:53know, it's just there's too much people kind of saying we think
- 20:58that, you know, this is the answer, this is the answer, this
- 21:01is the answer. And of course, there's going to
- 21:03be several answers. So it already we're kind of
- 21:06looking at what the future mix of the UK energy system is going
- 21:09to be nuclear kind of like, is looking like the big winner,
- 21:14frankly, you know, and then, you know, there's going to be a
- 21:16little bit of hydrogen and then there's going to be a bit of
- 21:19wind, you know, AR 7's being kind of kicked down the road a
- 21:22little bit, you know, hydrogen. Here's a few, you know, kind of
- 21:26bits and bobs. I don't know, like I guess you
- 21:29know, that's the way to do it. I mean, I feel like with AR-7
- 21:32that, that there is like a lot of, you know, positivity.
- 21:34I mean, I think you know, like the extending of the, the CFDS
- 21:37from 15 to 20 years, right? Already I've been having
- 21:39conversations with people talking about how important that
- 21:42is, right? And and, you know, able to
- 21:44amortize the cost over a / a longer time frame.
- 21:46So yeah, I mean, who knows? Who knows?
- 21:49I feel like what we're rounding out this segment on is the same
- 21:52thing that here at the end of every bloody panel session about
- 21:55renewables, which is we're going to be joined up thinking and
- 21:58every, every source is going to play its part.
- 22:01And I feel like that's probably what we're ending on.
- 22:03But stick around because Donald Trump's going to be in the UK
- 22:06and we have to talk about that. So Donald Trump is going to be
- 23:06in the UK, more specifically in Scotland.
- 23:08He's gracing Erica and myself with his presence and by that, I
- 23:13mean he's just going to be in the same city that we are in.
- 23:16Obviously, this came off the back of the announcement, a
- 23:19really strange sort of announcement that with ABBC
- 23:23reporter just had a candid phone call with them.
- 23:26I would love to hear this, our press office at the White
- 23:29House's discussion about that. Like who the fuck let that
- 23:32happen? He's coming to Aberdeen.
- 23:34He's wanting to speak about oil and gas.
- 23:36He's wanting to speak about renewables in in the sort of
- 23:40interview with the BBC that announced all of this, he'd
- 23:42said, you know, that he was wanting to sort of get rid of
- 23:46the windmills because he keeps calling them windmills and not
- 23:48turbines. We spoke about that last week.
- 23:52If you want to hear my opinions on the incorrect use of that
- 23:55word, then feel free to go back. But you know, previously he said
- 24:00that the UK is making a big, a very big mistake on Truth
- 24:04Social. He wrote that just before his
- 24:06inauguration, speaking about energy policy and the
- 24:10announcement of his trip. He said he was going to the oil
- 24:13capital of Europe. And he added that they should
- 24:16bring that back to, you know, so make, you know, make Aberdeen
- 24:20great again. If you want to use his, his MAGA
- 24:23terminology, he's been a very sort of vocal opponent of when
- 24:29specifically in Scotland, but globally for a long time.
- 24:34So I've been looking back through some of his previous
- 24:37statements as previous kind of interjections into the Windsor,
- 24:41if you want to put it that way, to sort of paint a picture a
- 24:45little bit before he lands in Aberdeen this the end of this
- 24:50week, starting next. So in 2014, Trump took a stance
- 24:54against the £230 million European Offshore Wind
- 24:59Deployment Centre, which is off the coast of Aberdeen.
- 25:03He, he essentially sort of complained that it was ruining
- 25:06the view of his Cruden Bay Golf Club.
- 25:09He took the the Scottish Government to court over its
- 25:11decision to approve it. The courts rejected the, the
- 25:14bed. Not happy with this, he lodged
- 25:17an appealing on that ruling, which was dismissed the
- 25:20following year in 2015. Which to me again feels like
- 25:24what he does right, Like, you know, he, he lost, he lost the
- 25:28last election and the last one, the one before that.
- 25:31He then said I didn't lose, let's do it again, you know, and
- 25:35he started, threw the Dolly at the pram, kind of did the same
- 25:38thing with the wind turbines up in Aberdeen.
- 25:42So, you know, he's he's got a long standing opposition to
- 25:45offshore wind. When I go to Aberdeen beach,
- 25:49actually, you know, and you can see the IWA Docker, the Aberdeen
- 25:53Bay wind farm, I now kind of sometimes pointed out, you know,
- 25:56if I've got visitors or something and I say, oh, look,
- 25:59you can see Donald Trump's favorite wind farm, which is
- 26:03great. Absolutely.
- 26:05I, I always, it just kind of like gives me a, a great feeling
- 26:08of satisfaction to look at it and see those turbines turning.
- 26:12It's great. I think they're quite beautiful.
- 26:14I mean, I, I, you know, I know that, that, that, that President
- 26:17Trump is not a fan, but I, I feel like just like, you know,
- 26:20sort of, you know, big sort of industrial, you know, I just
- 26:22think, yeah, I, I find them quite, yeah.
- 26:25I've, I've actually been out a few years ago, you know, we did
- 26:28a bit of a tour. You know, we kind of sailed up
- 26:31around it and, and of course there's always, you know, like a
- 26:36vessel, a safety vessel there kind of parked out kind of near
- 26:39it. But, you know, you kind of sail
- 26:42in and around these soaring turbines and you can hear them
- 26:47and, you know, kind of almost feel them.
- 26:50And it kind of like gives you like a real, you know, kind of
- 26:52sense that there's kind of like a cathedral out in the ocean,
- 26:56you know, that you're kind of sailing around.
- 26:58It's really quite something. It's really special.
- 27:00Cathedral in the Ocean, they should really start using that.
- 27:03I'm going to pitch that to VAT and FOWL before this episode.
- 27:07Yeah, you could. You're free to use that.
- 27:08Go right ahead. We do want royalties to that and
- 27:11fall. That's in your next marketing
- 27:13campaign. 100. Percent.
- 27:15But you know, yeah, it's interesting because that wind
- 27:17farm in particular is super integral to that and fall not,
- 27:21not in terms of power production, not in terms of not
- 27:24in terms of maybe the biggest thing in this portfolio.
- 27:27But it's where it tests a lot of its its products that are then
- 27:31rolled out across Ethanglia and various other places.
- 27:34It was a huge pioneering, umm, you know, centre for umm, you
- 27:37know, fixed bottom wind, umm, you know, it was among, you
- 27:41know, one of the 1st and umm, and in fact it was umm, our
- 27:44esteemed colleague Jeremy Cresswell too, uh, Emeritus
- 27:48editor, uh, for Energy Voice, who umm, was actually quite
- 27:52instrumental in uh, establishing.
- 27:54It, I think he chaired the project in in its early days,
- 27:57which is quite, you know, I guess people might say that
- 28:00we've got a conflict of interest considering our colleagues tied
- 28:02so closely to it. But moving quickly to the other
- 28:06side of the pond, then to, to before we get any any complaints
- 28:10about bias reporting, let's discuss the US wind ambitions as
- 28:14well, because obviously Trump isn't just against turbines sort
- 28:19of quote, UN quote, ruining the view in, in Scotland, but also
- 28:24in in the US. He signed an executive order
- 28:28soon into his his second terms are suspending the the leasing
- 28:33of new offshore wind developments.
- 28:36Now this obviously, you know, headlines struck about Empire
- 28:40Wind Ecuador's Ecuador's project and how that was stalled as a
- 28:45result. And it's are, you know, a lot of
- 28:46uncertainty around there. And at the time, Trump said,
- 28:50we're not going to do the big wind thing, Big ugly windmills,
- 28:54They ruin your neighborhood. But then it's funny that he said
- 28:58this and then he decided that he doesn't think that anymore
- 29:02because Empire Wind is back in development.
- 29:04It's it's progressing ahead again off the coast of New York.
- 29:08Isn't that because Ecuador threatened to sue?
- 29:11Well, they they, which is a language that President Trump, I
- 29:14think, understands perhaps a little bit better.
- 29:16I think there was, there was also some discussion around
- 29:19approval for a new pipeline in New York State, which obviously
- 29:22is a challenge for the governor. And I think that was there's
- 29:26been some suggestion that there's been a bit of horse
- 29:28trading is that maybe she she she backs the pipeline and Trump
- 29:32allows Empire Wind on that Empire Wind note, Equinor took
- 29:37an impairment this year of nearly a billion dollars on
- 29:41Empire Wind and. Takes $955 million impairment on
- 29:45its US offshore wind development which was Empire 1.
- 29:48Empire one and two. Yeah.
- 29:50So this this president is meant to be this really savvy
- 29:53businessman and meant to, you know, be supporting industry
- 29:59that that doesn't say send good signals.
- 30:01The sort of flip flopping on your projects cancelled.
- 30:04It's not cancelled. Go ahead run.
- 30:05Go go for it quick because it upsets my political opponents.
- 30:09Again, not really the stable business strategy that we'd we'd
- 30:14hope for, but I think the thing that I find most interesting
- 30:17about Trump's visit is their social media reaction.
- 30:21We've, we've seen, because a lot of people are like, yeah, come
- 30:25over here and kick Starmer's ass and tell him that you should get
- 30:27rid of the windfall tax. And, you know, that's, and it's
- 30:29like, don't get me wrong, I, you know, I've, I've, I've bitched
- 30:33and moaned about the windfall tax plenty normally with in
- 30:35relation to jobs, But you know, I mean, the, the policy policy
- 30:41isn't perfect at the US side of things either.
- 30:43I don't think this is this is really this or champion of the
- 30:49industry that we that some people seem to be presenting
- 30:52them as. Maybe I'm wrong.
- 30:53Maybe I'm biased with sort of preconceived notions of who
- 30:55Donald Trump is and what I think of him.
- 30:57I think people in, you know, a lot of readers of Energy Voice,
- 31:01you know, you see them kind of weigh in, you know what they
- 31:04like about, you know, kind of Trump messaging is drill, baby
- 31:07drill and continue working in the North Sea for 100 years.
- 31:13You know, what is maybe just kind of like a little bit
- 31:15refreshing about that. It's just maybe some positivity
- 31:18for that sector. It kind of feels like there's
- 31:20not been a lot of that, you know, kind of in terms of policy
- 31:24in the UK for a while. And I think people respond to
- 31:26that for better, for worse. And I mean, you know, kind of
- 31:29whether or not that fits into net zero is quite another thing
- 31:32altogether. Well, it's not, it's, it's not
- 31:35only that it doesn't fit into net 0, but it's also unrealistic
- 31:38to say, you know, drill, baby, drill sort of indefinitely
- 31:41because the UK is a finite base. And even the most ardent
- 31:45champions of the industry, for example, the OEUK, are quick to
- 31:50say it's not going to be around forever.
- 31:52The basins in decline. You know what, what the industry
- 31:57would be doing now, if it's drilling is kind of maintaining
- 31:59production. It's not going to get it higher
- 32:01than it has been historically. That's impossible.
- 32:03So it's a case of yeah. No, that's not going to happen.
- 32:05So it, it's a case of, you know, sort of, you know, balancing.
- 32:08And this is, I think this is something that I, I keep
- 32:10referring back in my copy, you know, we're going to start a
- 32:14drinking game any time I refer to a Poldaloo in my coffee.
- 32:18But you know, I keep referring back to, to his, his studies on
- 32:22sort of jobs and the oil and gas sector, the energy transition.
- 32:27And you know, he, he established a really good point in his in
- 32:31his latest report about if you look at Scotland, if you look at
- 32:35in TOG, if you look at the wind developments in Scotland,
- 32:39they're not being developed. They're not going to start
- 32:41creating jobs by the by the end of this decade.
- 32:44They're slightly further afield. And considering in Aberdeen
- 32:47alone, it's like, you know, one in six jobs are either directly
- 32:52impacted by the oil and gas industry or energy sector or
- 32:56their supply chain jobs. That's a big deal.
- 33:00You know, if these jobs disappear.
- 33:01So that's, that's the, the rhetoric we really need to sort
- 33:04of signal, not just get all these wind turbines to fuck and
- 33:07go straight for oil and gas. And that's all we're doing
- 33:10because it's just, it's a, it's not a sustainable practice,
- 33:13right? You know these jobs won't be
- 33:15here forever if we do just abandoned renewables as well.
- 33:18You know what, I was just at a, an event hosted by OUK kind of
- 33:22talking about, you know, kind of messaging and how you address
- 33:28kind of sentiment and you know, there's a lot of people and it,
- 33:31you know what it is about the jobs, it is about the people.
- 33:34It is about the fact that actually like, you know, our,
- 33:38the energy industry is, you know, kind of facing a
- 33:42significant collapse in terms of employment.
- 33:45And I think actually, you know, it's time that people started
- 33:49paying attention to that because, you know, it is like
- 33:53going to risk putting a massive hole in the UK economy and
- 33:59leaving a lot of people out of work and having a a really
- 34:03dilettier various impact on people.
- 34:05So let's not forget that. Certainly what what a hell of a
- 34:08way to end this episode on Erica.
- 34:11You always know how to strike just the right tone, but that
- 34:14does it for this episode of Energy Voice out loud.
- 34:17Thank you Ed and Erica for joining me.
- 34:19But more importantly, thank you for listening to our waffling
- 34:22this week. If you'd like to keep up to date
- 34:24with everything we're doing. Well, we don't have any events
- 34:27happening right now. That summer drought of, you
- 34:29know, news and various other things just isn't happening.
- 34:33It's just not it's not shifting next week.
- 34:35So why don't you just follow us on LinkedIn?
- 34:38Why don't you follow us on energyvoice.com and we'll keep
- 34:41you up to date throughout this summer period.