Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Sunk Cost Fallacy Keeps You in a Dead-End Job
Transcript
- Lucas: So a friend of mine just told me she's staying at a job she can't stand, and when I asked why, she said, 'Because I've been here nine years. I can't just throw that away.' Luna: Oh, that's the sunk cost fallacy doing its thing. That nine years is gone whether she leaves or stays. Lucas: Exactly. And it's one of the most powerful forces in office politics, because it keeps people locked into roles, projects, even entire career paths that no longer make sense. Today I want to dig into why our brains do this, and how to actually escape it. Luna: Let's start with the classic example. The Concorde. That plane kept flying for decades because governments had poured so much money into it, they couldn't admit it was a commercial failure. Lucas: Right, that's where the Concorde fallacy comes from. The British and French governments kept funding the supersonic jet long after it was clear they'd never recoup the investment. Every new pound was justified by the billions already spent, not by future returns. Luna: So the exact same logic applies to a career. You've put in nine years, so you feel like leaving wastes that investment. But if the job is making you miserable, staying might be wasting the next nine. Lucas: And the research backs this up. There's a classic study where people were given tickets to a theater performance. Some paid full price, some got a discount. The ones who paid full price were much more likely to actually go, even when they weren't that interested. The money already spent weighed on them. Luna: But here's the thing — that ticket cost is the same whether you go or not. It's gone. The only thing that matters is whether you'll enjoy the show. Lucas: And that's the sunk cost fallacy in a nutshell. We let past costs — time, money, effort — dictate future decisions, even when those costs are irreversible. In the office, it shows up everywhere. Luna: Like when a manager keeps a failing project alive because they've already put two years into it. Or when someone stays in a role because they've built a reputation there. Lucas: Yes, and there's a great example from the corporate world — actually, let's use a fictional but very realistic one. Imagine an engineer who's been at a tech company for a decade. They've climbed the ladder, they have equity, they're respected. But the company has pivoted, their skills are becoming less relevant, and they're bored. Yet they stay, because leaving feels like throwing away their entire history. Luna: And that history is real, but it's not a reason to stay. The real question is: what does the future look like? Lucas: Exactly. And this is where it gets tricky, because there's a difference between a sunk cost and a genuine investment. If you're staying because you're learning, because you're building relationships, because there's a clear path to something better — that's not a sunk cost, that's a forward-looking decision. Luna: So how do you tell the difference? What's the test? Lucas: There's a classic mental trick: imagine you're advising a friend in your exact situation. What would you tell them? If you'd say 'leave,' but you're staying for yourself, that's a red flag. Luna: That's great. Another one is the 'empty calendar' test. If you had no history with this company, no tenure, no reputation — would you still choose to work here today? Lucas: That's a powerful one. If the answer is no, then you're staying primarily because of what you've already put in, not because of what you'll get out. Luna: I've also heard of something called the 'kill criterion' — you set a condition in advance that would make you walk away. Like, if I'm not promoted within two years, I'm out. That way, you're not making the decision in the heat of the moment, when sunk costs are screaming at you. Lucas: That's smart. It's like setting a stop-loss on a stock. You decide ahead of time what would make you exit, and you stick to it, ignoring the emotional pull of what you've already invested. Luna: But what about the social pressure? We've been talking about internal bias, but there's also the external factor. Your colleagues, your boss, maybe even your family — they all reinforce the idea that you should stay because you've invested so much. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's where office politics comes in. If you're the person who stays for fifteen years, you're seen as loyal. If you leave at year nine, people might whisper that you're wasting your potential. That's a social sunk cost — the reputation you've built. Luna: And that reputation is real. It could follow you. But again, it's about whether that reputation will continue to serve you in the future, not about the past. Lucas: Right. And let's talk about how this plays out in everyday office dynamics, not just big career moves. Think about a project that's clearly failing, but the team keeps throwing resources at it because they've already invested so much. That's the sunk cost fallacy on a smaller scale. Luna: There's a famous example from the tech world — well, not a specific company, but a pattern. Development teams often keep adding features to a product that's already obsolete because they've spent years building it. They can't bear to see that work go to waste. Lucas: And that's exactly why so many companies end up with bloated software. They'd be better off starting from scratch, but the sunk cost of the old codebase makes that feel impossible. Luna: So what's the antidote? On a team level, is there a way to counteract this bias? Lucas: One thing that helps is to frame decisions in terms of opportunity cost. Instead of asking 'how much have we invested?' ask 'what else could we do with this time and money?' That shifts the focus to the future. Luna: Another approach is to have an outside person come in — a consultant, a fresh set of eyes — who has no emotional attachment to the project history. They can see clearly whether it's worth continuing. Lucas: And that's a tactic you can also use for yourself. Talk to a mentor outside your company. They won't have the same emotional investment in your past, so they can give you a more objective read on your situation. Luna: I love that. But let's go back to the individual career level for a second. What about the fear of starting over? Even if you recognize the sunk cost, the thought of losing your seniority, your salary, your comfort — that's a huge barrier. Lucas: It is. And that's where you have to be honest about whether those things are actually at risk. A lot of people overestimate what they'd lose and underestimate what they'd gain. You might take a temporary hit, but the long-term upside could be much bigger. Luna: There's also the psychological factor of identity. If you've been 'the finance person' for a decade, leaving that role feels like losing a part of yourself. That's a sunk cost of identity, not just time. Lucas: That's a really good point. And it's one of the reasons why people stay in careers they've outgrown. They've defined themselves by that job, and walking away feels like a personal failure. Luna: It's not a failure. It's a recognition that you've changed, and the job hasn't. That's a sign of growth, not stagnation. Lucas: And one thing that helps is to reframe the past. Instead of thinking 'those nine years were wasted,' think 'those nine years gave me skills, relationships, and clarity about what I don't want.' That's not wasted — that's tuition. Luna: Tuition — I love that. It turns the sunk cost into a learning investment. You're not throwing it away; you're using it to make a better decision now. Lucas: So if you're listening and you feel that weight of your own history, ask yourself: if I were starting from scratch today, would I choose this job? If the answer is no, then the only thing keeping you is the past. And the past doesn't have a vote in your future. Luna: That's a powerful way to put it. And you know, if today's episode gave you a useful lens to think about your own situation, that's exactly what we hope for. These conversations stay ad-free because of listener support, so if you found value in this, you can buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: It genuinely does help us keep doing this. And it's a nice way to say this was worth your time. Luna: Yeah. So back to the practical side — what's one thing someone can do this week to start breaking free of the sunk cost trap? Lucas: I'd say write down your 'kill criteria.' Define, in writing, what would make you leave your current role — whether it's a specific date, a lack of promotion, or a feeling that you've stopped learning. Then commit to honoring it when the time comes. Luna: And if you can't bring yourself to do that, then at least do the empty calendar test. Would you start here today? If not, start exploring what's next. Even just updating your resume is a step toward the future. Lucas: The future is where the value is. The past is just data. Let today be the day you stop letting yesterday's decisions run your tomorrow.