Latest / Her Life, Her Way: Women, Choices, Challenges & Possibilities / The Lie That Saved My First Dates: Why I Faked My Degree | Her Life, Her Way
Transcript
- I didn’t tell them I went to State because I was afraid they’d see the gap in my resume, but really, I was afraid they’d see the gap in me. It started as a small white lie about a university name and ended up being the biggest story I ever told. It was three years ago, on a Tuesday that felt like every other Tuesday, except for the fact that I was sitting across from a man named David. We were at this little coffee shop with the flickering neon sign and the chairs that wobbled if you shifted your weight too quickly. David was nice. He had kind eyes and asked genuine questions about what I did for work. But there was a knot in my stomach so tight it felt like I was holding my breath underwater. We had been on two dates already. On the first one, he mentioned his alma mater, a big state school with a proud football history. On the second, he casually dropped the name of the professor who had changed his life. And then, on this third date, he looked at me over the rim of his mug and asked, "So, Paige, have you always lived around here? Did you go to college nearby?" The question hung in the air, innocent enough, but it triggered something primal in me. A fear so deep it felt physical. I could have told him the truth. I could have said, "No, I actually went to a small liberal arts college out west, far away from here." Or I could have admitted that I had tried college twice and dropped out both times, never finishing a degree. Instead, I heard myself say, "Oh, yes. I went to State. You know, right down the road." It was a lie. Not just any lie. A carefully constructed, meticulously maintained lie about the very foundation of my intellectual identity. I watched David’s face light up with recognition. "Oh, great! I love the colors," he said. And in that moment, I felt a surge of relief so powerful it nearly brought tears to my eyes. I had survived another interaction. I had passed the test. But as I walked home that night, the relief turned into a heavy, cold stone in my chest. I had connected with him, yes. But I hadn’t connected with the real me. I had connected with a version of me that existed only in the space between his expectations and my insecurity. Let’s talk about why we do this. Why do so many of us curate our histories like museum exhibits, picking only the pieces that reflect well in the light? For me, it wasn’t about arrogance. It wasn’t about thinking I was better than anyone else. It was about shame. Pure, unadulterated shame. Growing up, education was treated like a moral virtue. If you finished your degree, you were responsible. You were stable. You were worthy. If you didn’t, well, let’s just say the silence in my house when that topic came up was louder than any shout. So, I learned to hide. I learned that my worth was tied to a piece of paper I didn’t have. When I started dating seriously in my twenties, I realized that the dating market, much like the job market, has a filter. And that filter often includes a background check of sorts. People want to know where you come from, not just geographically, but intellectually. They want to know if you speak their language. And by claiming I went to State, I was speaking their language. I was using their shorthand. I was signaling that I belonged in their world. But here is the thing about belonging through deception: it is incredibly exhausting. You have to keep track of the lies. You have to remember which city you said you grew up in. You have to remember which major you claimed to study. You have to remember which professors you pretended to admire. It becomes a full-time job. And the worst part is, you start to believe the lie yourself. You start to wonder if maybe, just maybe, the lie is truer than the truth. Maybe the person who went to State is more lovable than the person who didn’t. Maybe the version of me that fits neatly into a conversation is the only version worth loving. I carried that weight for months. Every date became a performance. Every introduction became a pitch. And I was terrified that if someone saw the messy, unfinished, uncertain reality of my actual life, they would walk away. I thought my lack of a diploma was a lack of value. I thought my gaps were flaws. I didn’t understand yet that my gaps were where the light got in. The breaking point didn’t come with a bang. It came with a whisper. It was six months into my relationship with David. We were comfortable now. We had inside jokes. We had plans for a trip to the coast. One evening, we were watching a movie, and the plot involved a character revealing a secret from their past. David paused the movie and said, "I’m glad we can be honest with each other. That’s what makes this work." Those words hit me like a slap. Because I wasn’t being honest. I was hiding the biggest part of my story right under his nose. I looked at him, really looked at him, and I saw a man who valued connection above all else. And I realized I was robbing him of that connection. I was letting him fall in love with a fiction. And worse, I was letting myself believe that I wasn’t enough. So, I told him. I sat on the edge of the couch, my hands shaking, and I said, "David, I need to tell you something. And I’m scared you’ll hate me for it." His face didn’t change. He just leaned forward, attentive, waiting. And I told him. I told him I never went to State. I told him I dropped out. I told him I felt like a fraud every time I said I was an alum. I waited for the anger. I waited for the disappointment. I waited for him to look at me differently. But he didn’t. He just nodded slowly and said, "Okay. Thank you for telling me." Then he added, "And for the record, I never cared where you went to school. I cared about how you thought. How you listened. How you made me laugh." In that moment, the stone in my chest cracked. It didn’t disappear entirely, but it softened. I realized that the fear I had been carrying was not about him. It was about me. It was about the story I had been telling myself about my own inadequacy. David didn’t care about the university. He cared about the woman sitting in front of him. And for the first time in years, I felt seen. Not for the lie, but for the truth. After that confession, something shifted in me. It wasn’t that I suddenly loved my lack of a degree. It wasn’t that I stopped feeling the sting of societal judgment. But I started to separate my worth from my credentials. I began to look at my life not as a series of failures to be hidden, but as a journey to be understood. I realized that the skills I had gained outside the classroom—resilience, adaptability, self-teaching—were just as valuable as any textbook knowledge. I started talking to other women who had taken non-traditional paths. And guess what? Almost all of them had lied at some point. About their jobs. About their ages. About their pasts. We were all performing versions of ourselves that we thought would be acceptable. We were all afraid that if we showed our true selves, we would be rejected. But rejection is not always a bad thing. Sometimes, rejection is just redirection. Sometimes, the people who walk away because of a lie are not the ones who were meant to stay. And the people who stay after the truth comes out? They are the ones who matter. I started to practice radical honesty. Not in a way that overshadows or burdens others, but in a way that honors my own experience. When someone asked where I went to school, I started saying, "I didn’t finish college, but I’ve spent those years learning so much on my own." And I watched how people reacted. Some shrugged. Some asked curious questions. Some even shared their own struggles. The world didn’t end. The relationships didn’t crumble. In fact, they deepened. Because authenticity is magnetic. It draws people in. It invites them to drop their own masks. And once I stopped hiding, I found that I had more energy to give. I wasn’t wasting breath on maintaining a facade. I was free. Free to be imperfect. Free to be incomplete. Free to be human. There is a beauty in being incomplete. We live in a culture that worships completion. We want the finished product. The polished resume. The perfect marriage. The flawless body. But life is not a product. It is a process. It is messy and nonlinear and full of detours. And there is power in embracing that messiness. When I stopped lying about my education, I stopped apologizing for my path. I stopped feeling like I needed to catch up. I started realizing that my unique perspective, shaped by my unconventional journey, was a gift. I could relate to people who were struggling. I could offer empathy to those who felt behind. I could show them that it’s okay to not have it all figured out. And in doing so, I gave myself permission to just be. To be a work in progress. To be a student of life, rather than a graduate of a specific institution. This doesn’t mean we shouldn’t strive for growth. Of course we should. But growth doesn’t require a credential. Growth requires courage. It requires the courage to admit when we don’t know. The courage to try again after failing. The courage to be vulnerable. And that is a skill no university can teach. It is a skill we learn by living. By making mistakes. By getting back up. By telling the truth, even when it shakes our knees. So, to the woman listening who is hiding her gaps, her scars, her unfinished business: please know that you are not broken. You are becoming. And your story, in all its tangled, beautiful complexity, is worth telling. Don’t let fear write it for you. Pick up the pen. Write your own truth. Even if it’s messy. Especially if it’s messy. Because that is where the magic lives. That is where you live. Thank you for spending this time with me. I’m Paige Herrera, and I’m rooting for you, exactly as you are. Until next time.