Latest / Sometimes There's Side Eye / STSE# 77: What Does "Don't Punish the Growl Mean"?
Transcript
- 0:12Welcome to Sometimes Their Side Eye, a podcast about two friends
- 0:16having real and unfiltered conversations about dogs and
- 0:20people. Listen as we talk about our
- 0:22lives with dogs, training, behavior, share some laughs and
- 0:26a whole lot of banter. I'm Heather.
- 0:30And I'm Christy. What are we talking about this
- 0:32week, Christy? So this week I thought we would
- 0:36talk about the phrase don't punish the growl.
- 0:40In our last episode, Heather talked about not punishing the
- 0:44growl. And I realized that when I
- 0:46started my journey of learning about dogs and dog behavior,
- 0:50people would constantly tell me that.
- 0:53And I was like, I don't know what that means.
- 0:56And I don't know, does that mean just ignore all the growls?
- 1:00Like just do nothing and let things escalate?
- 1:03It didn't know how to implement that.
- 1:06And so I thought, it's such a common phrase, maybe we should
- 1:09address it. Yeah, I definitely say it and
- 1:14assume that everyone understands it.
- 1:16So I'm glad that you mentioned this as a potential topic.
- 1:20And I feel like it's definitely a shift.
- 1:24It's one of those other things that as we understand more about
- 1:29dogs and dog behavior and dog training, that for the majority
- 1:35of people, they have come to understand that if we are either
- 1:43suppressing or ignoring when a dog growls, we are missing out
- 1:48on key information that the dog is trying to tell us.
- 1:51And it is their number, like they're a way for them to speak
- 1:55to us. You're right, yeah.
- 1:58I also think that if we kind of change the mindset of how we
- 2:02think about a growl and think of it as a form of communication,
- 2:06it's an easier form of communication sometimes to
- 2:10understand then well, is your dog's body stiff?
- 2:13Are they whale eyed? Are they shifting weight?
- 2:16Are they tense? Like, are they?
- 2:19Yeah. It is a much clearer way for of
- 2:23them communicating and for us to understand.
- 2:25But it is no different than any of those other characteristics
- 2:30that we are told to look for in understanding.
- 2:33If our dog is fearful, tense, I don't want to say upset, but,
- 2:39you know, all of those different things have some feelings.
- 2:44Yeah. So I think it's it's kind of
- 2:46like shifting the mindset to that it's just another way for
- 2:49us to understand our dogs. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:52So when you say don't punish the growl, what?
- 2:55What would you do instead? I guess it depends on why
- 2:59they're. Growling even.
- 3:02Like what does that look like? Not punishing the girl.
- 3:05Yeah. So something that popped in my
- 3:08head as a really, really classic example of of that I can think
- 3:14of and happened with my dog Link, was if I would go, he's on
- 3:20the couch and I go to grab his collar to remove him from the
- 3:25couch, that would have been a time where I could see him
- 3:29growling. OK.
- 3:30And I think that trying to physically move your dog from a
- 3:35space could be a time that would be a common, common scenario for
- 3:39people that a dog might growl. And for me today, I have a lot
- 3:46of different things that I would do instead.
- 3:49So I am not necessarily a person to go and like grab a collar in
- 3:55the same way that I would have 20 years ago.
- 3:57My first go to is if I want a dog to move, I will throw food.
- 4:03That's like my first thing. If they don't have a queue where
- 4:06I can say off or move or out or whatever your commands are.
- 4:11If I want a dog to move, then I'm going to use food, a toy,
- 4:15something to like motivate them to move out of the space.
- 4:18And so then we are not inciting the growl.
- 4:22So I guess I would say, say you go in, you go to grab your dog's
- 4:27collar because you want them to move and they growl.
- 4:29The first thing I'm going to do is step back because I'm going
- 4:32to respect their space. And the fact that they're
- 4:34telling me, hey, I'm not comfortable with what you're
- 4:36doing and I'm asking you for space.
- 4:41And then I'm going to go to, OK, I need the dog to move.
- 4:45So what other tools do I have to make that happen?
- 4:49I can throw food, throw a toy, use a cue that they know all of
- 4:52the different things. If it's a dog you're having
- 4:55other issues with, I also was thinking or you're working
- 4:59through this problem, then that would also be a dog that in this
- 5:03scenario, I might also have trailing a line.
- 5:06And so then I don't have to like impede on the dog's space.
- 5:09I have a line. I can then use the line to help
- 5:12me guide them off, but that's obviously for this specific
- 5:16example. Does that help?
- 5:19Yeah, I think so because I, I think it's important too, if, if
- 5:24you're having issues with your dog moving or spatial issues,
- 5:29teach that move cue. I just often walk up to Jackson
- 5:33and say, hey, can you move over and like he does?
- 5:36Because he's like, I'm like, you're in my spot.
- 5:38And then I, I often use body pressure, like spatial pressure.
- 5:43I mean, I'm not, I'm not sitting on him.
- 5:48Spatial but but you're right. Spatial pressure is a huge.
- 5:52Yeah. But it was some dogs that could
- 5:54create a growl like, you know, And so I think, you know, when,
- 6:00when I was new to not punishing the growl, I, I thought, oh, if
- 6:05we're not punishing the growl, we're not doing anything else
- 6:08either. And so we're just allowing dogs
- 6:11to growl and possibly escalate. Because I was really thinking at
- 6:15that time, the only time I was really having issues with
- 6:18growling was dog to dog. And, and so then, OK, they're
- 6:23growling at each other. So now I just step back and let
- 6:26whatever happens, happen. Like that's not, and I want to
- 6:30be clear, like that's not what not punishing the growl is.
- 6:34It's stepping in in a different way where we're not saying like,
- 6:38no, don't growl or, or hitting the dog or jerking on them.
- 6:42I do see that a lot still in non training aspects like
- 6:48day-to-day. My neighborhood is very dog
- 6:51social. I mean there's always dogs in
- 6:54the park playing together. There's always and it's not a
- 6:57dog park, they're just playing together.
- 6:59I run into people on my walk every day, deck some place with
- 7:03dogs every day on our walk. Christy never thought this would
- 7:07be her life. No, this was not the life, but
- 7:11Jackson loves it so. And I have a lot of trusted dogs
- 7:14now. And So what I do see is
- 7:18sometimes a new dog will come into the mix and growl and then
- 7:22immediately they're jerked off their feet all together.
- 7:26They're jerked back, they're jerked off their feet, they're
- 7:29hit, they're yelled at there. There's a variety of things that
- 7:32happened because they growled. Interesting.
- 7:36And and I think man, this is such a solid group of dogs that
- 7:42is here that none of the other dogs even reacted to the growl.
- 7:45They were like, oh, OK, you're not friendly.
- 7:47Like we're not interacting with you then if you're going to
- 7:50behave that way, we're turning our attention somewhere else.
- 7:53So they took care of it themselves.
- 7:56And yet the owner is man, like just going after their dog for
- 8:00barking or not barking for growling.
- 8:03And I'm like, oh, OK, they growled and the dogs corrected
- 8:08it. But man, you're really on the
- 8:11dog in a negative way. So I do think there, there's
- 8:14still this concept out there that we have that growling is
- 8:19bad. Yeah.
- 8:20And I do think it's a pre, it's a precursor, yeah, to
- 8:25escalation, Yeah, it can be. It can be, can be.
- 8:28Yeah, cuz it could also a mean play.
- 8:31It could happen. It could happen during dog play.
- 8:34It could happen when you're playing like #1 playing tug with
- 8:38a dog. I want my dog to growl at me
- 8:40when I'm playing tug with them. I'm like, give them a tap on
- 8:43their side to like get them really into it, you know?
- 8:46And I'm like, I'm growling with them actually.
- 8:49And I want that whole back and forth.
- 8:52I think we have to be very careful because there are times
- 8:55where growling really is something entirely different.
- 8:59And you don't want to assume that even when a dog walks up to
- 9:05another dog and that they growl that it's even the precursor to
- 9:10something escalating outside of maybe it's escalating to play,
- 9:14but like escalating to something negative.
- 9:16But then that makes me say that is when you do need to be
- 9:22educated on not just your personal dog, but how, but dog
- 9:29body language for your personal dog.
- 9:31Because just like we've said before, or I wouldn't tell
- 9:36someone to assume that their dog's hackles being up makes
- 9:42means that they're going to attack a dog, You got to look at
- 9:46everything because the whole body is the picture, right?
- 9:50So when you're talking about growls in relation to
- 9:53communication with another dog, you do have to put the other
- 9:58pieces together and look at the whole picture of your dog, their
- 10:03dog, the environment, you know, your dog's history.
- 10:07And, and I know that's a lot to ask in in a moment, but the
- 10:12growl really, truly is information.
- 10:16Yeah. It is.
- 10:17And Jackson's like the noisiest player, the worst growler when
- 10:21he's playing and I have to warn people, OK, he's a very noisy
- 10:26player. He sounds not great, but I also
- 10:30have to listen to his tones, which is interesting because he
- 10:35he's very vocal when he plays, but then there's like a shift in
- 10:38tone and then I'm like, oh, he's not playing anymore.
- 10:42Now he's upset about like he has some feelings about something
- 10:45that happened. Either he's overstimulated or he
- 10:48needs, he actually needs space now.
- 10:51And what's been interesting is a lot of people, if their dog is
- 10:55over playing with Jackson, they can't differentiate those growls
- 10:59at all. And they're like, I don't know
- 11:02why you decided that was too much when you didn't think it
- 11:07was too much before. And I explained like, there's
- 11:10different tones to it. And they're like, I didn't hear
- 11:12anything different. And if that's that's OK, if
- 11:15that's you, you can learn, but you can also play it safe if you
- 11:21feel like that's not something that you're comfortable with.
- 11:25But I would say playing it safe means not hanging your dog by
- 11:32the leash, which Chris, you would never do.
- 11:33But like playing it safe means intervening in a way that is not
- 11:40going to then escalate what was nothing into something.
- 11:45So maybe you and your you know, you when your dog out for a walk
- 11:50in this scenario, come up to another dog in a park, your dog
- 11:53growls that makes you feel uncomfortable.
- 11:56Doesn't matter why it was, but the reaction I would prefer in
- 12:01that situation is me saying to my dog, let's go and turning in
- 12:05the opposite direction, right? Because we are, if if the growl
- 12:12was quote UN quote negative, then we're changing our tone to
- 12:18put it in a different direction. And if the growl was quote UN
- 12:22quote positive, then we are not punishing it.
- 12:25We are just saying let's go and we're making no big deal about
- 12:29it. Yeah.
- 12:30Yeah. And if your dog comes to you
- 12:33easily, like, give him a treat for that too.
- 12:35Like, yes, you know. It's just a very light hearted
- 12:38like, hey, let's go this way instead, let's keep going.
- 12:42So I think what I would say is we don't want to punish the
- 12:48growl, but it's OK to redirect it in a positive way.
- 12:53Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 12:55And I mean, I would say Even so, when I had Julius, I think we
- 13:01talked about this a lot, he was very dog reactive.
- 13:04He ended up in a home with lots of other dogs.
- 13:06I knew he could do it it just on leash.
- 13:09He was extremely dog reactive behind a barrier, extremely dog
- 13:13reactive. And so we, we went to a trainer
- 13:18and she had said, Hey, I don't want you to react at all when my
- 13:23dog comes out, regardless of what he does.
- 13:25And we had really been working on reactivity.
- 13:28So when her dog came out and he only growled instead of
- 13:33exploding, he did a little growl and I go, oh, good boy.
- 13:37And she goes, OK, I don't think I've ever had that happen.
- 13:41Yeah, well. Normally he explodes.
- 13:44And so now for him to request space with a simple growl, yes,
- 13:50that's such a huge step for him. And she's like, OK, I don't
- 13:53usually see people recognize that.
- 13:56Yes. And she was like, no, you did
- 13:57the right thing by like. Telling him.
- 14:00Because he didn't. Explode.
- 14:01Yeah, yeah. He's just telling me information
- 14:04without going to teeth, which is exactly what we want.
- 14:08Right, exactly. I totally agree.
- 14:11Yeah, I think well, and we mentioned in the past in the
- 14:15last episode or I forget, but I was saying also a growl from
- 14:21Tiago and a growl from Tater are two very different things that I
- 14:29treat very differently. If I'm on the couch and I'm
- 14:33snuggling with Thiago and I'll move my arm or whatever and like
- 14:39reposition and he would ever growl at me, I'm going to say
- 14:42whatever because it hasn't happened.
- 14:43I would instantly be like, there's something wrong with my
- 14:45dog because that is not part of his normal repertoire.
- 14:50That is not a way he communicates with me.
- 14:52And whereas if I'm laying with Tater and I go and I want to
- 14:57shift his wait and he like at me, and that wasn't a good
- 15:03impersonation. It actually sounds like a growl,
- 15:05but it's different from a bulldog.
- 15:06And he'll even give a little. Yeah.
- 15:09And he gives a lift curl, right? I don't, I essentially dismiss
- 15:15it. I ignore it.
- 15:17It's not that I don't take it as information because I know it's
- 15:19information, but he is more quick to use his voice as am I.
- 15:25And so that is just part of his personality.
- 15:29So I, I am definitely, while it's information, I am quick to
- 15:33dismiss because I'm just like, dude, whatever, you're my legs
- 15:36asleep and I need you to move. So it is a simple statement to
- 15:41say don't punish the growl, but there is a lot of nuance behind
- 15:46it, and that nuance is different for individual dogs and
- 15:52individual relationships. Yeah, I also think it's
- 15:56important to recognize a growl towards another dog or another
- 16:00animal feels a lot different than a growl towards a human.
- 16:07And I feel like a lot of times there's some feelings associated
- 16:12with that, that growl, that just be aware if your dog growls at
- 16:18you or at a human that is, it's still OK to take that step back.
- 16:22You don't, yeah, react. In fact, we're saying please
- 16:25don't react. Please don't.
- 16:26Cause yeah, 'cause that emotional, like I'm gonna be
- 16:30honest. If I if my dog who loves me,
- 16:33growls at me, I'm offended. Like, I mean, maybe not if like
- 16:40if bulldog growls at me, I'm not offended.
- 16:42And I know he loves me. Yeah.
- 16:44But my own Jackson, who doesn't growl, if he were to growl at
- 16:49me, I would be startled and defended.
- 16:52Interesting. And that that would be a lot of
- 16:54emotion in that that I would automatically want to react to.
- 17:00But that's that's not where you want to start.
- 17:03You want to start in a thought process.
- 17:06Well, what is this? Yeah, start with curiosity.
- 17:10What is? This and and I would say if you
- 17:13need to have a reaction, have the reaction to move away, not
- 17:19move towards. So because a lot of the times
- 17:24I'm going to hazard a guess that if your dog is growling, they're
- 17:27growling because they're asking for space in some way.
- 17:30And so you eat even though like with bulldog, I'm like, oh,
- 17:35whatever, I dismiss the growl, but I'm not going to, it's still
- 17:38information. And so if you are feeling some
- 17:42type of way when your dog growls at you, which is totally
- 17:46warranted, just take a step back, take a breath and, and
- 17:52recognize, OK, this is the time to take space and think about
- 17:55this for a moment. Because there's nothing you're
- 17:58not going to gain anything by pushing forward, right?
- 18:03You could be detrimental. You could push them further, but
- 18:07you're not going to gain anything.
- 18:09So whereas if you're pulling back, just like the park
- 18:13example, when you're like, let's go, you only have something to
- 18:16gain by taking a step back, taking a moment, taking a breath
- 18:20and assessing the situation and then deciding, OK, was that a
- 18:24one off? Is this normal?
- 18:25Is this not normal? Do I think he's painful?
- 18:28Do I think something else is going on?
- 18:30You know, do you have a dog that sometimes resource guards and
- 18:33there was a bone there. I mean, just you can think
- 18:36through the whole process and take that step.
- 18:39It's you're not saying to your dog, great job, way to growl at
- 18:43me. I hope you do it forever, every
- 18:44single day for the rest. Of your life.
- 18:47And I think that is something people think they're like,
- 18:50rewarding the growl. We're not asking you to reward
- 18:53the growl, and it's not rewarding the growl, it's just
- 18:57taking a step back to reassess. And I think I used the example
- 19:02with Thiago in the last episode where there are times where I
- 19:06will reward the growl. I will praise him for growling.
- 19:09If I think that my dog is assessing a situation and
- 19:12protecting me, I will absolutely tell them good job for growling.
- 19:16But that growl is not placed towards me.
- 19:20That's what we're talking about. We're talking about growls that
- 19:23are that are coming at you from your dog and how you sort of
- 19:27handle that. And it's OK for you to have
- 19:29feelings about that. And then kind of decide you're
- 19:32not, you're not putting like a little rosette on that growl and
- 19:37saying way to go. You got to be.
- 19:39You're just taking a moment to step back, assess and then
- 19:42decide what's the right move to go forward.
- 19:45Exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:46And there are times, like you said, that you, you praise a
- 19:49growl. Like I just this week I had a
- 19:51puppy over and Jackson was laying next to me.
- 19:54And the puppy, being a puppy, decided to run across his
- 19:57stomach and rib cage. And Jackson let her know right
- 20:02away that that was not appropriate to do with the
- 20:04growl. I also trust Jackson.
- 20:07I know he's not going to escalate into biting the puppy.
- 20:11He's not going to be overly aggressive with a puppy or any
- 20:14dog. Honestly.
- 20:16And so I was like, yeah, good job, buddy.
- 20:19Like I can't teach that puppy that your growl is setting
- 20:23boundaries for her. And she's getting it at her home
- 20:27with a grown dog and she's now in a new environment getting the
- 20:30same information. So then hopefully that sticks.
- 20:33Yep. And she becomes an appropriate
- 20:35adult dog than with other dogs. Right, so.
- 20:38Sometimes, yeah, sometimes we we reward the growl and sometimes
- 20:42we just don't punish it. Yeah, I agree.
- 20:46I would also say sometimes if you know your dog, I was
- 20:50thinking of. So my brother's dog and Jackson,
- 20:55we've worked really hard on their relationship.
- 20:57It's not 100% it. It very much has to be
- 21:00monitored. They can't be alone together.
- 21:03It's and little things can tip it, but mostly they coexist
- 21:07together. But over Thanksgiving, I had
- 21:10given my dog a bone when my brother's dog was out of the
- 21:14cabin. And then when they came back,
- 21:17there were clearly some remnants in the carpet that I did not get
- 21:20up. And so they were both sniffing
- 21:23there, which turned into a little some puff and stuff.
- 21:28Puff and stuff. Yeah.
- 21:29So not like a full fight, but like growl snarly could turn
- 21:34into a full fight. But as soon as we heard the
- 21:38growl that was indicating it's a different growl from both of
- 21:43them, indicating we're both unhappy and we're not going to
- 21:46back down and then escalating. I think I stood up and said hey,
- 21:51and then my brother did the same thing.
- 21:53No, some people would say that's punishing the growl because it's
- 21:57it's yelling at the dog. But I also know my dog and my
- 22:02brother's dog, to know a simple hey is going to dissipate that
- 22:08energy that they're going to go in different directions and my
- 22:11dog's then going to come to me because he's not scared.
- 22:13If I say hey, it's not oh, my mom's going to beat me.
- 22:17It's hey. My mom is like, hey, seriously,
- 22:20get over here with me. It's an interruption.
- 22:24It's an interruption actually. No, it's a disruption.
- 22:28There you go. It's a disruption of the
- 22:29conversation that they're having, and that's OK.
- 22:33Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's kind of stepping between
- 22:36and saying hey, hey, hey. And we didn't do it in a hey,
- 22:40hey, hey, hey light manner. Yeah, it was serious, but it was
- 22:44also not. Nobody got in trouble for them.
- 22:46It was just like, hey, come, come to your respective corners,
- 22:49your respective owners. Everybody's gonna get their
- 22:52love. Everyone's gonna be OK.
- 22:54No big deal. Yeah, and there again, it's an
- 22:56example of you asking everyone to step back and take a breath.
- 23:00Yeah. Yeah, exactly.
- 23:02Yeah, I think, and that's a, that's a good example of dog,
- 23:05dog growling where it's like like this could turn into
- 23:10something. But I would have, honestly, if I
- 23:14was in the same situation, I would have done exactly what you
- 23:17did. I, I, I would have just sort of
- 23:20did the conversation and yeah, because you know that your
- 23:24connection to your dogs, they're going to come back to you.
- 23:27And then everything, all the energy in the room just goes
- 23:30down 10 notches, which is the whole point, yeah.
- 23:34Yeah. Yeah, so I think, I think I
- 23:36really like the thought of don't punish the growl, but also be
- 23:42inquisitive and curious about what is happening.
- 23:45Take some space. Don't be afraid to take that
- 23:47space and really look at the whole picture and say where is
- 23:51it coming from and assess and then move forward and know that
- 23:56just because you take that moment, you're not rewarding it,
- 24:00but you're also not punishing it.
- 24:02You're just taking information from it because that's truly
- 24:06what it is. It is the dog communicating to
- 24:09you that something that is happening is not OK, or
- 24:12commuting actually communicating to another being that something
- 24:16is not OK because they're either communicating to you, another
- 24:19dog, another species, whatever. And how you handle that can be
- 24:25can set up a really good communication between you and
- 24:28your dog. Yeah, I do also want to say
- 24:31every growl is not appropriate and and even if it's an
- 24:36inappropriate growl, it doesn't mean it needs to be punished.
- 24:40Yes, because. Yeah, because.
- 24:44Because if you punish the growl and they not do not feel that
- 24:48that is an option for them anymore because it's been
- 24:52punished, the next place they may go is to biting or air
- 24:57snapping and having a dog feel like the growl is no longer
- 25:02available as a means of communication to go to using
- 25:07their teeth in whatever way that is, is not what we want to
- 25:11happen. Yeah, yeah.
- 25:13We had a little poodle run up to Jackson in a in a group of dogs.
- 25:19And then she just decided she came up to us.
- 25:21We didn't go to her, she came to us.
- 25:23And then she jumps on Jackson's shoulder with her little paws on
- 25:26his shoulder and like gets right in his face and then growls at
- 25:29him. And I was like, what is
- 25:32happening? And luckily Jackson was like
- 25:35very unintimidated by it. And he was like, whatever.
- 25:38And in that moment, I was like, OK, let's just move on.
- 25:41Why? Don't you scooch?
- 25:42Over Scooch. Scooch, where's your owner?
- 25:45And then calling for her owner to come get her.
- 25:47Hey, she's unhappy, like. Let's move her along.
- 25:50No big deal. And now she we do see her, she
- 25:55she will get growl at Jackson if she's too close to him.
- 25:59But until that point, she's pretty comfortable, which I do
- 26:03think is part of like she's established a boundary of I'm
- 26:06not comfortable with you. And Jackson is like, that's
- 26:08cool. We don't have to be friends.
- 26:10Like I'm going to give you some space.
- 26:12Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I would just be cognizant
- 26:17just like everything else we say browser complex but don't.
- 26:23You know. Don't get caught up in the
- 26:25weeds. Just look at your own dog, learn
- 26:27your own dog, learn your own dog's behavior and and take it
- 26:32for what it is, which is information in a form of
- 26:35communication. Yes, and support them in
- 26:38whatever way you can. I agree.
- 26:40If you've enjoyed this episode, subscribe, rate and share us
- 26:45wherever you get your podcast. Also come on over to Instagram
- 26:49and engage with us at Sometimes Their Side Eye.
- 26:52Thanks for listening everybody. Talk to you next time.
- 26:56Bye bye.