Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Shifting Sands of Immigration Law: Advising Clients In 2026 Through a Constantly Changing Legal Landscape
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Shifting Sands of Immigration
- 0:05Law Advising Clients in 2026 Through a Constantly
- 0:09Changing Legal Landscape. I'm Belinda Macaulay,
- 0:12CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association, and
- 0:14I'm delighted to be here today to introduce our
- 0:16speaker, Sergio A. Perez. Sergio is the managing
- 0:19attorney of Franco Law Group, ATLC's San Diego
- 0:22office, where he focuses on immigration and employment
- 0:25law and handles cases across San Diego and LA
- 0:28counties. A UCLA School of Law graduate, he co
- 0:33-founded the National Latina Latino Law Students
- 0:36Association and served as managing editor of
- 0:38the Chicano Latino Law Review and has since published
- 0:41widely in the Daily Journal on immigration policy
- 0:44and civil procedure. He is active in the community
- 0:46as a board member of Latinos y Latinas. an acción
- 0:50and a frequent volunteer at naturalization workshops
- 0:54and is licensed to practice before all U .S.
- 0:57immigration courts, the Board of Immigration
- 0:59Appeals, and the federal district courts in California.
- 1:02And now let's get started with Sergio sharing
- 1:04his knowledge. Thank you for that introduction.
- 1:07It's an honor to be here. Thank you all for joining
- 1:10us to discuss the rapidly changing area of immigration
- 1:15law, especially in the Trump era. So without
- 1:19further ado, Let's get started with the first
- 1:22slide, please. All right. It's shifting sands
- 1:32indeed. We are, if you are like me, signed up
- 1:39to receive notifications from EYR and USCIS.
- 1:43It kind of feels like getting bombarded and the
- 1:45sands beneath our feet are shifting constantly
- 1:47indeed. So let's Let's go ahead and review some
- 1:51of these changes, particularly those that have
- 1:53occurred this year in 2026. Next slide, please.
- 2:00All right. So just an overview of immigration
- 2:02law hierarchy. I'm sure most of you not all know
- 2:08this already, but let's recap. So obviously at
- 2:12the top of that hierarchy is the Immigration
- 2:14Nationality Act, the INA. codified at Title 8
- 2:17of the U .S. Code. Next are Supreme Court opinions
- 2:22or SCOTUS opinions. After that, number three
- 2:25are Circuit Court opinions, which are binding
- 2:28in their respective circuits, but you can use
- 2:32as persuasive authority in your circuit if we
- 2:35don't have anything on point. After that, U .S.
- 2:39District Court opinions, but in very limited
- 2:42circumstances because They don't have the same
- 2:45binding authority as circuit court opinions.
- 2:48But I have used district court opinions, again,
- 2:51as persuasive authority where I don't have something
- 2:54that is binding on point. Number five are attorney
- 2:58general opinions. Then, of course, Board of Immigration
- 3:02Appeals or BIA opinions. There are seven regulations,
- 3:06Title VIII of the Code of Federal Regulations.
- 3:10And then after that, agency policies, mainly
- 3:14USCIS. But you should make yourself aware also
- 3:19of policies of other agencies like ICE, the Department
- 3:23of State, particularly their Foreign Affairs
- 3:27Manual, which is a great resource I use all the
- 3:30time. I cite to it in briefs. They have very
- 3:34clear and concise explanations of things for
- 3:38their consular officers. Next slide, please.
- 3:46So let's start with the top of the hierarchy,
- 3:49some notable SCOTUS opinions of 2026. Next slide,
- 3:54please. Okay, so let's start with Blanche V.
- 4:00Lau, published June 23rd, 2026, dealing with
- 4:04returning LPRs. And the court's holding. is that
- 4:08the INA does not require a border officer to
- 4:11have clear and convincing evidence that an lawful
- 4:14permanent resident LPR has committed a crime
- 4:18involving moral turpitude, CIMT, before deeming
- 4:22the resident an applicant for admission. Next
- 4:25slide, please. Okay, so the pertinent facts of
- 4:32the case. Mr. Lau came in LPR in 2007. 2012.
- 4:36He was charged with trademark counterfeiting
- 4:39under New Jersey law, which under immigration
- 4:41law is a crime involving moral turpitude of CIMT,
- 4:45which is a serious matter. While the charge was
- 4:49pending, Mr. Lauf exited the U .S. Now, returning
- 4:54LPRs, General, you're not considered to be, quote,
- 4:56seeking admission for that section of the INA
- 5:00or AUSC 1101, A13 Capital C, unless the LPR has
- 5:06committed, not been convicted, committed certain
- 5:11crimes, including a CIMT, per 8 U .S .C. 1101,
- 5:15A13, capital C, small v. Next slide, please.
- 5:23Now, because of the pending CIMT charge, a CBP
- 5:26officer at a port of entry deemed Mr. Liao to
- 5:29be, quote, seeking admission instead of... deeming
- 5:34him a returning LPR who was already admitted
- 5:36and paroled Mr. Lau in, deferring his admission
- 5:39until a later time when the criminal charge was
- 5:42resolved. In 2013, Mr. Lau pled guilty to and
- 5:45was convicted for that CIMT. The following year,
- 5:492014, DHS initiated removal proceedings based
- 5:52on the conviction. Mr. Lau argued that as an
- 5:55LPR, he's subject to the deportability grounds
- 5:58of a USC 1227. DHS said, No, the inadmissibility
- 6:05grounds of 8 U .S .C. 1182 should apply, which
- 6:08I'm sure most of us are aware are less favorable.
- 6:12And the reason being for that argument is because
- 6:14at the last entry, Mr. Lau was seeking admission.
- 6:17Next slide, please. So the BIA agreed with the
- 6:24government and on appeal, the Second Circuit
- 6:26disagreed and held that a CBP officer must have
- 6:30clear and convincing evidence that Mr. Lau committed
- 6:34the crime in order to deem him to be seeking
- 6:38admission and not the LPR who's already admitted.
- 6:43Then finally, went up to the Supreme Court, SCOTUS
- 6:46held, no, there is no clear and convincing requirement
- 6:49under the INA. So what standard are CBP officers
- 6:53to apply? Well, the court doesn't say. So it
- 6:57appears that, at least for now, Simply being
- 7:01charged with a CIMT or another inadmissible offense
- 7:03will suffice for a CBP officer to be able to
- 7:08deem a returning LPR seeking admission as opposed
- 7:12to being already admitted. Next slide, please.
- 7:19So how do we advise clients in light of this
- 7:22decision? Well, there are greater risks overall
- 7:26under the second Trump administration. But for
- 7:30LPRs with pending inadmissible offenses, obviously,
- 7:35who exit the US, there is a risk. It can be deemed
- 7:40seeking admission upon return simply by having
- 7:43a pending charge. And if they are later placed
- 7:46in the removal proceedings, they can and likely
- 7:49will be subject to inadmissibility grounds as
- 7:52opposed to the more favorable deportability grounds.
- 7:57In advising LPRs, we should do an assessment
- 8:01of their pending charges, if they have any. And
- 8:05I would say even resolved charges, charges that
- 8:08already happened. And the risk is overzealous
- 8:14CBP officers who are under pressure to make arrests,
- 8:20as well as ICE officers. They may see a returning
- 8:23LPR with a criminal history. that does not necessarily
- 8:27render the LPR inadmissible or deportable and
- 8:32just detain them. And in fact, a trusted colleague
- 8:37who recently attended the American immigration
- 8:42lawyers CBP liaison meeting at LAX informed me
- 8:50that CBP representatives basically stated that
- 8:56any returning LPR they are detaining and having
- 9:02somebody else figure it out later. So we should
- 9:05do risk assessments for our LPR clients. And
- 9:10what I've began to offer clients is what I call
- 9:15a border letter. Basically a letter prepared
- 9:17for CBP officers that I give to the client to
- 9:22be given to an officer if the client is sent
- 9:25to secondary inspection, not just when he first
- 9:28gets to the inspection booth. And you won't write
- 9:34it for my intended audience. So not to legalese.
- 9:45And again, only given to a CBP officer if it
- 9:49becomes necessary. And basically explaining Nothing
- 9:52in the client's history is a problem, should
- 9:56not be detained. Next slide, please. All right.
- 10:04Another holding this year by the Supreme Court
- 10:06is Mullen v. Alotolalo, dealing with the ability
- 10:12to apply for asylum. So the holding in that case.
- 10:18An alien standing in Mexico does not arrive in
- 10:21the U .S. by attempting and failing to set foot
- 10:25in this country. An alien arrives in the United
- 10:27States only when he crosses the border, and the
- 10:31INA neither entitles an alien standing in Mexico
- 10:34to apply for asylum nor requires an immigration
- 10:37officer to inspect it. Next slide, please. Okay,
- 10:45so. 8 USC 1158A1 states any alien who is physically
- 10:51present in the US may apply for asylum. And this
- 10:57case stems from a CBP metering policy where if
- 11:02you have ever crossed the border in a car or
- 11:05on foot, you will see that the actual inspection
- 11:10kiosks or booths are several feet or several
- 11:16yards away from the actual border line. And on
- 11:18the border line, there are guards stationed there
- 11:22who do a cursory check of documents that a person
- 11:27intends to present to the officer at the inspection.
- 11:31And if a person does not have any document, those
- 11:35guards don't let the person set foot on US soil.
- 11:40So that was the issue in this case. Before this
- 11:44case got to the Supreme Court, the Ninth Circuit
- 11:46held that an alien arrives in the United States,
- 11:49quote unquote, and thus must be inspected and
- 11:53may apply for asylum when the alien, while standing
- 11:57on the Mexico side of the border, encounters
- 11:59the U .S. official at the border. But of course,
- 12:02SCOTUS held that no arrival, rather unless a
- 12:06person physically sets foot on U .S. soil and
- 12:09the government can impede with the asylum seekers.
- 12:15from doing so. Next slide, please. All right,
- 12:24so you may think, well, this doesn't really affect
- 12:30me as an immigration law practitioner because
- 12:33most of my clients or all of them are already
- 12:35here in the US. So I had this situation in this
- 12:39hypo several years ago. So your client, Mark,
- 12:43Call you and says, hey, my 18 -year -old daughter
- 12:46and two minor sons had to flee Guatemala. They
- 12:51are in Tijuana. I need your help to get them
- 12:54across the border, not Iwi. So they can apply
- 12:58for asylum. So before Mullen via el otro lado,
- 13:03you could advise, well, if their intent is to
- 13:06seek asylum, they can go to the border guards
- 13:10that I mentioned. and express that desire, that
- 13:14intent. And in that situation, actually, it worked
- 13:18after the third attempt. The border guards finally
- 13:22let the kids in and they were placed in removal
- 13:26proceedings, but were able to apply for asylum.
- 13:30With this decision now, that advice will very
- 13:35likely not work and we can't advise clients to
- 13:39e -whee, obviously. If this situation had arisen
- 13:44now, it would be obviously a much tougher situation.
- 13:47And I honestly don't have an answer as to what
- 13:50I would advise at the present time. Next slide,
- 13:54please. All right. So next notable 2026 Stotus
- 14:04opinion, Mullen v. Doe dealing with TPS, which
- 14:08has been in the news. frequently because the
- 14:12court held that a TPS statute bars judicial review
- 14:16of non -constitutional claims and that the TPS
- 14:20statute provides that there is no judicial review
- 14:21of any determination of the Secretary of Homeland
- 14:24Security with respect to the designation or termination
- 14:28or extension of a designation of a foreign state.
- 14:31So basically the president has unfettered authority
- 14:35to designate or terminate a TPS designation.
- 14:40Next slide, please. Moulin Bidot dealt specifically
- 14:47with TPS for Syria and Haiti, but unfortunately,
- 14:51it applies broadly to all TPS. And in fact, pretty
- 14:59much every TPS designation is now being terminated.
- 15:05There are about 12 countries that are affected.
- 15:10Incidentally, I did receive a motion to recalendar
- 15:15from DHS removal proceedings for a Venezuelan
- 15:19client whose TPS just expired thanks to this
- 15:23decision. So if you have clients with administratively
- 15:27closed EOIR cases, be prepared to deal with motions
- 15:32to recalendar now that TPS is being canceled.
- 15:36Next slide, please. All right, so how do we advise
- 15:42clients? Well, obviously we wanna assess for
- 15:46any other form of relief for which the client
- 15:48is eligible. And if all they had as far as eligibility
- 15:53was TPS, it may be a tough conversation to have
- 15:57with the client. And a lot of clients are asking
- 16:00about just self removal, which is certainly an
- 16:04option, but... That would be part of the discussion,
- 16:12obviously, that you would have. You may want
- 16:15to advise about consequences of leaving, like
- 16:19triggering the unlawful presence in a miscibility
- 16:22bar. But many clients, unfortunately, are kind
- 16:27of giving up hope and asking me increasingly
- 16:30about the option of self -removal. Next slide,
- 16:34please. All right, so let's go over a couple
- 16:41of notable 2026 Ninth Circuit opinions. Next
- 16:47slide, please. All right, so first, U .S. v.
- 16:53Lopez cited or published July 28, 2026, which
- 16:58is actually a criminal law case, but is often
- 17:04called criminal migration. that intersection
- 17:07of criminal law and immigration law. So the holding
- 17:12in that case with the convictions under California
- 17:14Penal Code 273 .5, which is a domestic violence
- 17:18statute, do not categorically qualify as crimes
- 17:21of violence given that the statute is a general
- 17:24intent crime and requires only the mens rea of
- 17:27intending to do the assaultive act and does not
- 17:30require intent or knowledge that the use of force
- 17:33is directed. at another next slide please next
- 17:43slide okay so how do we advise clients based
- 17:52on this decision well for now anyway the fact
- 17:57that the 273 .5 is not a crime of violence means
- 18:01that it's not a deportable crime of domestic
- 18:03violence It's not a crime of violence. It's not
- 18:06domestic violence. And as you probably know,
- 18:12being convicted of a crime of domestic violence
- 18:15after being admitted makes an LPR deportable.
- 18:20So this decision may be a basis for a motion
- 18:23to reopen a removal order. So if you have clients
- 18:26with a 273 .5 conviction, you definitely want
- 18:30to assess for possible motion to reopen and sooner
- 18:34rather than later. So you don't have an argument
- 18:42against your motion that it's untimely. You kind
- 18:46of want to do it close to the date of the court's
- 18:50decision. Now, a 273 .5 conviction may still
- 18:54be an inadmissible or deportable CIMT. So you
- 18:57want to analyze for that. to see if you in fact
- 19:01want to proceed with something like a motion
- 19:03to reopen. A couple of deadlines to be aware
- 19:09of. So the government has until September 11th,
- 19:122026 to file a petition for rehearing with the
- 19:17Ninth Circuit and a deadline of October 26th,
- 19:202026 to file a writ of certiorari with SCOTUS.
- 19:26Next slide please. Okay, so other Ninth Circuit
- 19:34opinion of note, Rodriguez, Vasquez v. Bostock,
- 19:38three major dealing with mandatory detention.
- 19:42So the holding is that aliens present without
- 19:44admission who are apprehended in the interior
- 19:48of the United States are not subject to mandatory
- 19:51detention under 8 USC 1225, small v to capital
- 19:57A. Next slide, please. This language here and
- 20:06this slide is from the court's opinion. Historically,
- 20:09unadmitted aliens present in the interior have
- 20:11been treated or detained under USC 1226A, which
- 20:15allows for a RISOM bond, meaning that they're
- 20:18not subject to mandatory detention. Section 1225B2A,
- 20:23which requires mandatory detention, was understood
- 20:26to apply only to aliens seeking to enter the
- 20:29United States at the border. That was the established
- 20:31understanding of the law for the last 30 years
- 20:36or so. Next slide, please. Enter Trump 2 .0,
- 20:46which took a different interpretation, stating
- 20:49that unadmitted aliens present in the interior
- 20:52of the country are subject to mandatory detention.
- 20:55under 12 .5B to A because they are applicants
- 20:59for admission. So obviously, this is a completely
- 21:04different interpretation of the established law.
- 21:09And next slide, please. So for now, if your client
- 21:17is not subject to mandatory detention on some
- 21:20other basis, In the Ninth Circuit, anyway, you
- 21:24can request a bond hearing without having to
- 21:27file a writ of habeas corpus in a federal district
- 21:30court. And you should review the mandatory detention
- 21:34categories in 8 USC 1226 C1. And remember that
- 21:40that statute was amended by the Lake and Riley
- 21:42Act in 2025 to include persons charged with,
- 21:48arrested for, commit committing, Not convicted.
- 21:54Burglary, theft, larceny, shoplifting, assault
- 21:57on a law enforcement officer, or any crime that
- 22:00results in death or serious bodily injury. There
- 22:03was a case where a person had a DUI and crashed
- 22:11into somebody and caused serious bodily injury.
- 22:14And that subjected that person to mandatory detention
- 22:17under the Lake and Riley. Next slide, please.
- 22:24All right, so there's a circuit split on this
- 22:27issue of mandatory detention for non -citizens
- 22:31who entered Iwi and are detained in the interior
- 22:34of the country. The fifth and eighth circuits
- 22:37agree with the government. Second, sixth, now
- 22:41ninth, 10th, and 11th circuits disagree with
- 22:44the government. And we have to expect that a
- 22:49SCOTUS appeal or writ of certiorari will follow.
- 22:54you know, generally the court with the conservative
- 22:57majority tends to vote or tends to rule rather
- 23:03in ways that are not that favorable for our clients,
- 23:07but sometimes they do surprise us. So let's keep
- 23:11our fingers crossed. Next slide, please. All
- 23:17right, so let's go discuss notable 2026 DIA Now,
- 23:26as you may be aware, since Trump took office
- 23:29again January 2025, there was essentially a purging
- 23:34of a board of immigration appeals made of numerous
- 23:38judges. And the court has been publishing what
- 23:44I estimate to be at least approximately two binding
- 23:48opinions per week since January 2025. Now you
- 23:52can review, and you should review, the headnotes
- 23:55of those cases, and you can find them at the
- 23:58URL there, www .justice .gov, UIR volumes 29.
- 24:05In fact, I kind of skim them, go through them
- 24:09when I'm writing a brief, because there are so
- 24:12many opinions being published that I don't want
- 24:15to miss something that is recent and binding.
- 24:21Now, a lot of those decisions that the BIA is
- 24:25publishing reassert or narrow already established
- 24:29precedent, but some do overrule a prior case
- 24:33law. And I did want to mention that. So the makeup
- 24:36of the Board of Immigration Appeals right now,
- 24:39you have 15 appellate judges. Four were appointed
- 24:43by Trump in his first term. Eight were appointed.
- 24:50under the second Trump administration. One is
- 24:53an Obama appointee, and one is a George W. Bush
- 24:56appointee. And the court also has four temporary
- 25:00judges who have all been appointed under the
- 25:03second Trump administration. Next slide, please.
- 25:09So I mentioned that some of the DIA opinions
- 25:13overrule established case law, like this, Jen,
- 25:17matter of del Carmen Lara. dealing with advanced
- 25:20parole, which held a departure from the United
- 25:24States pursuant to a grant of advanced parole
- 25:26is a departure within the meaning of section
- 25:30212A9B, small i, double capital i of the INA,
- 25:35and matter of Arabelli and Yarrabelli, which
- 25:39was published in 2012, is overruled. And in the
- 25:43body of the opinion, the court states, we will
- 25:46apply this new holding. prospectively, meaning
- 25:50it's not retroactive, which is a little bit of
- 25:54a silver lining in an otherwise terrible decision.
- 25:58Next slide, please. Okay, so this decision implicates
- 26:07the unlawful presence in admissibility bar at
- 26:10USC 1182A9B, which basically states that a person
- 26:15who has accrued more than six months, but less
- 26:18than a year of unlawful presence who then exits
- 26:20the United States triggers the unlawful presence
- 26:22inadmissibility bar for three years. If a person
- 26:26accrues a year or more of a lawful presence and
- 26:29then exits the United States, they trigger the
- 26:32unlawful presence inadmissibility bar for 10
- 26:34years. So matter of Arabelli -Yarabelli, which
- 26:39was overruled, held that a departure with advanced
- 26:42parole, no permission from the government to
- 26:46exit the country and then return lawfully. That
- 26:49is not a departure such that it triggers the
- 26:54unlawful presence in a miscibility ground if
- 26:57you have accrued the amounts of the lawful presence
- 27:01described in the statute. Next slide, please.
- 27:08But now, so even an exit with an advanced parole
- 27:12can trigger the unlawful presence and admissibility
- 27:15bar. There are two agency policy that I wanted
- 27:19to highlight that relate to the unlawful presence
- 27:25and admissibility bar. So under the Biden administration
- 27:30on June 24, 2022, USCIS published a policy alert
- 27:352022 -15 which basically stated that if somebody
- 27:40triggers the unlawful presence inadmissibility
- 27:43bar for three years or 10 years, the inadmissibility
- 27:47period can be spent outside the country or inside
- 27:52the United States. So the manner of entry, whether
- 27:56lawful or unlawful, was irrelevant toward that
- 28:01passing of the unlawful presence inadmissibility
- 28:06period. Curiously, though, the Department of
- 28:10State's foreign affairs manual was never revised
- 28:15to coincide with that USCIS policy. It always
- 28:20stated and continues to state that an individual
- 28:23who departs the US after being unlawfully present
- 28:26for a year or more is barred from returning to
- 28:30the US for 10 years. So that raises the question
- 28:35now. If I have advanced parole and I have a crude
- 28:41unlawful presence and I exit, okay, my exit will
- 28:45trigger the unlawful presence and invisibility
- 28:48bar. But will I be able to return? Next slide,
- 28:53please. So it leads me to how do we advise clients?
- 28:59Well, we should assess for any unlawful presence
- 29:03of cruel. prior to applying for or exiting with
- 29:08advanced parole. And we should so advise clients.
- 29:13And again, the question of, can the client even
- 29:16return with advanced parole if inadmissibility
- 29:21bar is triggered? Again, we have overzealous
- 29:25CBP agents who may take the position that, no,
- 29:29you're inadmissible. We can't let you in. And
- 29:32that is a a very real possibility, and I think
- 29:36we should take a wait and see posture to see
- 29:40how CBP is going to implement, if at all, this
- 29:45BIA decision. So again, a return, if a client
- 29:50is able to return with advanced parole and is
- 29:52inspected and admitted, to make them AOS eligible,
- 29:57eligible to adjust status through an immediate
- 30:00relative. But they will trigger the unlawful
- 30:04presence inadmissibility bar if they have accrued
- 30:08the described unlawful presence. So if they do
- 30:13adjust status, they may need the unlawful presence
- 30:15waiver, which requires showing of extreme hardship
- 30:19to a US citizen or lawful permanent resident,
- 30:23spouse, or parent. But again, I would advise,
- 30:27let's take a wait and see posture. to see what
- 30:31CBP does in light of this decision. Next slide,
- 30:37please. So again, advising clients. Got a couple
- 30:43of hypos here. First one, your client Jane accrued
- 30:47three years of unlawful presence in the US after
- 30:50the age of 18. Thereafter she applied for and
- 30:53was granted TPS in 2023. Jane exited the US and
- 30:58reentered with TPS advanced parole. She's now
- 31:02married to a US citizen and wants to apply for
- 31:05adjustment of status, but is concerned about
- 31:07Trump administration policies. Should she proceed
- 31:11with AOS? Well, the age of 18 is key because
- 31:16under the unlawful presence statute, a person
- 31:21does not accrue a lawful presence if they're
- 31:24a minor under 18. So in this hypo, Jane accrued
- 31:28three years on the lawful presence after she
- 31:30was 18. So that would make her inadmissible for
- 31:3310 years if that bar is triggered. But she admitted
- 31:37with TPS advanced parole in 2023. So the matter
- 31:41of Del Carmen Lara is not retroactive. So Jane
- 31:45should be fine, assuming there are no other issues
- 31:49to be concerned about. Second hypo, your client
- 31:53Johnny accrued two years of a lawful presence
- 31:56after his 18th birthday. He was later granted
- 32:00DACA, Third Action for Childhood Arrivals. He
- 32:04was recently granted DACA advanced parole and
- 32:08wants to adjust status when he returns from abroad
- 32:11via his U .S. citizen spouse. Should he proceed
- 32:14with advanced parole? Well, Johnny hasn't exited
- 32:19yet with advanced parole, so matter of del Carmen
- 32:22Lara will apply. he will trigger the unlawful
- 32:26presence in admissibility bar for 10 years because
- 32:28he accrued one year or more of a lawful presence
- 32:31after turning 18. So, you know, we, this is the
- 32:37trickier situation. If he's able to return with
- 32:40advanced parole, he'll have a lawful entry, but
- 32:44will he be able to return? Will he be allowed
- 32:47to return having triggered the lawful presence
- 32:50in admissibility bars? So I would advise Johnny
- 32:53Let's wait and see again. Let's see what happens
- 32:57with CBP and this court decision, and then we'll
- 33:00reassess. Next slide, please. Okay, so next I
- 33:08wanted to talk about not case law, but some new
- 33:16things, things of first impression that we are
- 33:20all seeing under Trump 2 .0. the IRS and ICE
- 33:25memorandum of understanding. So generally non
- 33:31-citizens who don't have social security numbers
- 33:34because they don't have an immigration status
- 33:37and not authorized to work can obtain individual
- 33:44taxpayer identification numbers or ITINs to file
- 33:48taxes, right? The IRS. doesn't care traditionally
- 33:53about immigration status. They wanna collect
- 33:56taxes. And this is the way to facilitate that.
- 34:00And 28 USC 6103, or 03 rather, generally provides
- 34:05for the confidentiality of tax filings and limits
- 34:08the sharing of tax information. Great. Next slide,
- 34:12please. So with this IRS and ICE MOU, The IRS
- 34:21has agreed to share information with ICE regarding
- 34:25suspected and documented immigrants. So who's
- 34:28going to be most vulnerable? Obviously, ITIN
- 34:31tax filers. There is litigation challenging this
- 34:35MOU, Center for Taxpayer Rights at all, the IRS
- 34:39at all, in the district court for DC, Washington
- 34:45DC. And you can review the actual MOU in one
- 34:50of the filings, which is filing number 31 -1,
- 34:53page 45. And you should review it just so you
- 34:57know exactly what the language says. But we're
- 35:00hopeful that this litigation will ultimately,
- 35:05obviously, result in a favorable ruling for our
- 35:07clients. But for now, next slide, please. For
- 35:13now, we got to be... wary for those clients of
- 35:18ours who are ITIN fighters. I did also want to
- 35:21mention another related new directive found in
- 35:24the Federal Register, 91430479. So regulators
- 35:30have been directed to look for individuals using
- 35:32ITINs to open bank accounts, obtain loans, or
- 35:36credit cards. They'll then explain what they're
- 35:40going to do with that, but obviously, Government
- 35:43is trying to identify suspected undocumented
- 35:47non -citizens. Next slide, please. So how do
- 35:53we advise clients in light of all of this? Well,
- 35:57we can't advise clients to not file taxes. They're
- 36:01required to file taxes by law. We can't advise
- 36:05of the risks of filing and not filing in terms
- 36:09of the immigration law side. And we should also
- 36:13refer them to a reputable and trustworthy tax
- 36:18expert, tax attorney, accountant, so that they
- 36:22can be assessed from that aspect as well. But
- 36:26it's a difficult situation for our clients who
- 36:30want to do the right thing and want to file taxes.
- 36:32And in fact, filing taxes is seen as a good moral
- 36:37character for for a lot of immigration benefit
- 36:43applications. So now we're faced with this risk
- 36:46and the best we can do is make our clients aware
- 36:49of the risks of filing or not filing. Next slide,
- 36:55please. Civil penalties and asset seizures. Next
- 37:03slide. So this is another, Trump 2 .0, generally
- 37:12an issue of first impression that we are dealing
- 37:15with. So as part of the 1996 illegal immigration
- 37:20reform and immigration responsibility act, IRA,
- 37:25AUSC 1324D, a non -citizen subject to a final
- 37:30order of removal who willfully fails or refuses
- 37:34to depart the U .S. shall pay a civil penalty
- 37:39of not more than $500 per day. Under Trump 2
- 37:43.0 and specifically Federal Register 90 FR 27439,
- 37:50the government has taken the position that, well,
- 37:53adjusted for inflation, the civil penalty is
- 37:56actually $998 per day. So I say this is an issue
- 38:03of first impression because this law was rarely
- 38:06enforced. Honestly, I'm not even aware if it
- 38:11was enforced before the first Trump administration,
- 38:16if it was sporadically so. There were some instances
- 38:22of the law being enforced under the first Trump
- 38:25administration, but now they're going all out
- 38:28and non -citizens with removal orders are being
- 38:32issued notices of fines of up to $1 .8 million
- 38:37per person. And obviously, this is very concerning
- 38:44for everybody, but more so for our clients. Next
- 38:48slide, please. And in Federal Register 90FR20357,
- 38:58the government describes how they're going to
- 39:00go about enforcing these fines. And that includes
- 39:05Treasury Department collection action, wage garnishment,
- 39:10confiscation of savings homes, vehicles, and
- 39:12other property. And there are very limited appeal
- 39:17options. If you've dealt with one of these already,
- 39:22you'll see that the client is given very, very
- 39:28little time to file an appeal within DHS itself.
- 39:33are 15 business days. And the fines are not accompanied
- 39:38by any evidence, no copy of the removal order,
- 39:42nothing. Just the allegation, you ordered removed
- 39:46on next date, you have failed to depart, and
- 39:51you have 15 days. And I've handled some of these
- 39:55appeals prepared of what I thought were great
- 39:59arguments, and very promptly, received a denial
- 40:03by DHS. And it's not like a nice explanation
- 40:08of the legal reasons behind the denial. It is
- 40:12literally a box checked off on a form saying
- 40:15we are denying. And in the last case I had, the
- 40:18reason was you are not a US citizen. That's it,
- 40:21which we did not allege the client was a US citizen,
- 40:24but that's what DHS, the position they took anyway.
- 40:30There is litigation challenging these civil penalties.
- 40:35Maria L. V. Mullen out of the district court
- 40:38of Massachusetts. And one of the, I reviewed
- 40:43the complaint, one of the arguments raised of
- 40:46the constitutional Eighth Amendment grounds that
- 40:50these civil penalties violate the excessive fines
- 40:54clause of the Eighth Amendment. Because this
- 40:58is such a new thing, I don't believe there's
- 41:00much established case law on whether or how much
- 41:03the government can fine without running afoul
- 41:08of the Eighth Amendment. That remains to be seen.
- 41:11I'm hopeful, obviously, that $1 .8 million will
- 41:15be found to be unconstitutionally excessive.
- 41:19Next slide, please. Okay. So how do we advise
- 41:26clients with this, this issue of new impression
- 41:30that I certainly never dealt with before this
- 41:34current Trump administration? Well, it's a, it's
- 41:38a very scary situation for a client to be in.
- 41:41Obviously the government knows of their presence
- 41:45and their address because these fines notices
- 41:48are being sent to their addresses and many clients
- 41:51want, how do they even know where I live? And
- 41:55I don't have an answer to that other than the
- 41:57government has pretty much unlimited resources.
- 41:59If they want to find someone, they can. And again,
- 42:04limited appeal options. There's the agency appeal
- 42:09process, which I described. And in those arguments,
- 42:15you want to assess the situation. Was there actual
- 42:19willfulness and not leaving? Did the client even
- 42:23know they had a removal order? Many times, clients
- 42:26entered the United States and they're placed
- 42:30in removal proceedings and did not understand
- 42:33the process, didn't speak English, didn't know
- 42:36they had a removal hearing scheduled, didn't
- 42:41appear, they received an inept central removal
- 42:44order. Does that mean that they willfully failed
- 42:48to depart? Well, I would argue, well, if they
- 42:51didn't know, How could there be willfulness?
- 42:54Also, was the client a minor during any of that
- 42:58assessment period? Minors are generally considered
- 43:01less culpable legally. Did the client have any
- 43:05immigration status during the assessments period,
- 43:08like DACA or TPS? And even though an agency appeal
- 43:13has a very high likelihood of being denied, you
- 43:17want to preserve your arguments. administrative
- 43:21exhaustion in case you later, a client wants
- 43:26to file a lawsuit in federal district court challenging
- 43:30this civil penalty. And unfortunately though,
- 43:36doing that at any stage of this process, there's
- 43:39a risk that the government will simply decide
- 43:41to enforce the removal order. So it's a very
- 43:46difficult situation for clients to be in, obviously.
- 43:50but we have to advise them as best we can. And
- 43:55I also try to give clients hope and inform them
- 43:59of this pending litigation and monitoring it
- 44:05to see if there are any positive developments
- 44:09like an injunction or anything. But that's the
- 44:13situation we're in as far as these civil penalties
- 44:15and asset seizures. Next slide, please. All right,
- 44:23so now we're toward the bottom of the immigration
- 44:29law hierarchy agency policies. And USCIS has
- 44:35certainly been changing policy since Trump took
- 44:41office again. And I did want to mention one important
- 44:46one, this was actually from 2025, February, policy
- 44:50memorandum 602 -0187, which basically states
- 44:55that a denial of any petition will result in
- 44:58the issuance of a notice to a peer, which initiates
- 45:01removal proceedings. So that's a drastic change
- 45:05from what we had under the Biden administration.
- 45:09And unfortunately we, well, I heard reports from
- 45:13colleagues that even rejections of an application
- 45:19because of some technical reasons can result
- 45:22in the issuance of a notice to appear in NTA.
- 45:27And sometimes just the filing itself, like for
- 45:30a time I heard reports of I -130 filings with
- 45:33USCIS resulting in NTAs even though there was
- 45:38no decision on the I -130. Risk assessment is
- 45:43even more vital now. For example, if a client
- 45:46has any criminal history, they're going to be
- 45:49most at risk, but any denial under this 2025
- 45:55policy will now unfortunately result in an NTA
- 45:59and removal proceedings being initiated. This
- 46:03month, August 5th, 2026, USCIS published Policy
- 46:09Alert 2026. Basically, giving greater discretion
- 46:17to USCIS officers to deny an application without
- 46:21first issuing a request for evidence RFE or a
- 46:26notice of intent to deny a NOID. Now, RFEs and
- 46:30NOIDs, I always saw them as great second bite
- 46:34at the apple, an opportunity to fix what USCIS
- 46:38claims is lacking. Most of the time, it's evidence.
- 46:42Sometimes it's legal arguments. Unfortunately,
- 46:46now with this policy, USCIS officers are going
- 46:50to be authorized and I think encouraged to just
- 46:53issue a denial without an RFE or annoyed, which
- 46:58under policy above that will result in a notice
- 47:02to appear unfortunately. Next slide, please.
- 47:09So how do we advise clients per these USCIS policy
- 47:14changes? Well, the initial filing has to include
- 47:17all the required evidence. And we have to review
- 47:21the instructions for the form. Every form, every
- 47:25USCIS form has instructions. So we have to review
- 47:29the entirety of it. And they usually have a section
- 47:32with the heading required evidence. So we want
- 47:37to include all the required evidence. Sometimes
- 47:42we can't get the required evidence if they want
- 47:46a certified copy of a court disposition for some
- 47:50court case the client had. Well, you at least
- 47:53want to show your efforts to obtain that evidence.
- 47:58We hear the search results from the court clerk
- 48:01stating that they conducted this search from
- 48:03this date to this date and found nothing or the
- 48:07file has been destroyed per court policy because
- 48:11it predates a certain year. Those cases where
- 48:15you can't get the required evidence, I think
- 48:19there can be a greater risk of a denial, but
- 48:24try to get all the required evidence and hopefully
- 48:28you have it and then you file your petitions.
- 48:33with that required evidence to reduce the likelihood
- 48:36of denial without an RFE or annoyed. So the policy
- 48:40doesn't say RFEs will not and cannot be issued,
- 48:44but I think we're going to see less of them for
- 48:48the remainder of the Trump administration. So
- 48:53let's see, again, the risk assessment. What criminal
- 48:56history does the client have, if any? Unlawful
- 49:01entries, visa overstaged, which under Trump 2
- 49:04.0 have been made a big deal of. So all these
- 49:08can weigh negatively under the greater discretion
- 49:11that USCIS officers have. Next slide, please.
- 49:18The dreaded public charge in invisibility ground.
- 49:23So generally, USC 1182A4A states that any alien
- 49:28who in the opinion of a Consular Officer, Department
- 49:31of State, at the time of application for a visa
- 49:35or in the opinion of the Attorney General, USCIS,
- 49:39at the time of application for admission or adjustment
- 49:41of status is likely at any time to become a public
- 49:45charge is inadmissible. So in the opinion of,
- 49:49I mean, that's already a very low standard, I
- 49:52think. Next slide, please. So before going into
- 50:01the new policy, the current policy, AUSCA 1182A4B
- 50:07lists the factors that a USCIS officer or consular
- 50:11officer should consider. And these include age,
- 50:15health, family status, assets, resources, financial
- 50:20status, and education and skills. Next slide,
- 50:23please. Okay. So, August 18th, just a few days
- 50:33ago, 2026, USCIS published policy alert 2026
- 50:39-09, which is guidance on the new factors that
- 50:46USCIS will apply for the public charge inadmissibility
- 50:50grounds. The policy alert is a whopping 99 pages.
- 50:56Most policy alerts are policy memorandum Memoranda
- 50:59are four to nine pages. So 99 pages is just insane.
- 51:05You could see a summary of the new policy at
- 51:10the URL indicated there, USCIS press release.
- 51:15But we're lawyers. We have to review the 99 pages
- 51:20so that we can advise clients on this new public
- 51:25charge guidance. One key thing that I saw in
- 51:30the new policy is that if an applicant is found
- 51:35inadmissible only under the public charge ground,
- 51:41a USCIS officer may invite the applicant to post
- 51:46a public charge bond in an amount determined
- 51:50by how much the government assistance the applicant
- 51:53may be eligible for and potentially receive over
- 51:58the next five years. That is not clear at all.
- 52:04It could be anything potentially. So the new
- 52:08rule takes effect September 18th, 2026. So there's
- 52:15time before that to review these same 99 pages.
- 52:20And so that we compare to adequately advise clients.
- 52:24Next slide, please. So obviously we have to reveal
- 52:31the entire policy. If possible, if you have a
- 52:35pending adjustment of status applications, I
- 52:38would say try to file them before September 18th
- 52:41so that your filing will not be subject to the
- 52:45new public charge guidance. We saw a similar
- 52:51public charge policy under the first Trump administration.
- 52:57They didn't have a 99 page policy, but it was
- 53:02more onerous than previously existed. And that
- 53:09Trump 1 .0 policy was challenged in court. And
- 53:13at some point there was an injunction and then
- 53:16a 2020 election happened. So it became moot because
- 53:19the Biden administration canceled the policy.
- 53:23I expect that there will be litigation challenging
- 53:25the public charge guidance, the new guidance.
- 53:30But it may be the case that while you file after
- 53:36September 18th, the rule will be in effect and
- 53:41USCIS will be fully applying the new guidance.
- 53:46So definitely become well acquainted with it
- 53:51so that you can adequately advise clients. and
- 53:55assess for inadmissibility under the new rule
- 53:59and other inadmissibility areas potentially.
- 54:04Because remember, under the new rule, the client
- 54:08may be invited to post the bond in an unknown
- 54:12amount, but only if the client is inadmissible
- 54:16under the public charge rule and no other ground.
- 54:21OK. Next slide. Thank you. That was my presentation
- 54:32and we have time for any questions that our attendees
- 54:39may have. I see a question here. If a person
- 54:54arrives at the airport, can a person apply for
- 54:58asylum? I would say yes, because again the statute
- 55:04says anyone who is physically in the US can apply
- 55:07for asylum. So an airport is certainly within
- 55:14the United States and I'm not aware of anything
- 55:18stating that an airport is like an embassy that
- 55:21is technically foreign territories. So I would
- 55:25say, yes, they would have to express their desire
- 55:29to apply for asylum. And if CBP does what they're
- 55:33supposed to do, then they'll process the person
- 55:36for credible fear and whatnot. Let's see. How
- 55:42do you advise a client who has applied for asylum
- 55:46and granted work authorization? and was arrested
- 55:49at the airport when he tried to fly to another
- 55:52state. Well, that is an unfortunate scenario.
- 55:57In fact, traveling, flying domestically is very
- 56:03risky. ISIS is very active at domestic terminals
- 56:07and has been detaining people en masse. And again,
- 56:15the numbers, right? They reportedly have quotas.
- 56:18So how do you advise a client? Well, I would
- 56:24assess for mandatory detention. Can this person
- 56:29request the bond? Are they being held in a jurisdiction
- 56:33where they are not subject to mandatory detention
- 56:37and they're not subject to mandatory detention
- 56:40under any other ground, like a criminal ground,
- 56:43Lake and Riley Act? And if they are one of those
- 56:47circuits, like the Fifth Circuit, who says that
- 56:51George doesn't agree with the Ninth Circuit regarding
- 56:56mandatory detention, then a habeas petition might
- 57:00be the only option to try to get the client released
- 57:04on a bond. Let's see. If an alien is out of status
- 57:13in the U .S. for more than a year, can he apply
- 57:16for adjustment of status if he marries a U .S.
- 57:19citizen? So adjustment of status is in the United
- 57:24States will not end until remember the lawful
- 57:27presence in admissibility bar is triggered when
- 57:31somebody exits the United States. So if they
- 57:38The question is, let's see, so if the person's
- 57:42last entry was lawful, meaning that he was inspected
- 57:45and admitted or paroled, or if he's covered under
- 57:51INA 245 I, then he would be eligible to adjust
- 57:56status and his accrual of a lawful presence would
- 58:00really not matter. So you have to analyze for
- 58:04those things. If he has to do consular processing,
- 58:08then he's going to need an author presence waiver
- 58:10with a qualifying relative. And if he's married
- 58:13to a US citizen, that spouse can be the qualifying
- 58:17relative for the waiver. Let's see, here's a
- 58:23long question here. How is the current landscape
- 58:26related to minor violations? For example, the
- 58:30client wants to apply for citizenship, but received
- 58:33a low level tax offense, not a CIMT. or an IRS
- 58:40late filing or 30 % fraud penalty simply missed
- 58:44to inform USCIS about a move in a 10 -day window.
- 58:50Am I correct? This did not affect the procedure
- 58:54much. Well, should the client refrain from applying
- 58:58for citizenship? Well, USCIS right now is taking
- 59:01the issue of taxes or dealing with it differently
- 59:05than they did under Biden, for example. So before
- 59:11Trump 2 .0, a client who was behind on taxes
- 59:16could enter into an agreement with the IRS, a
- 59:20payment plan, to become current. They're in the
- 59:23process of becoming current. Then they apply
- 59:26for citizenship. That payment plan was enough
- 59:30to satisfy USCIS. Now we're hearing reports of
- 59:33USCIS denying, even if you have that payment
- 59:36plan. you have to be fully up to date and current
- 59:41on taxes for USCIS and I believe they're basing
- 59:44that denials for those reasons on the good moral
- 59:49character requirement. Your client has to show
- 59:53good moral character during the five -year period
- 59:55before applying for citizenship. So I would assess
- 1:00:02for that. You know oftentimes when I have a case
- 1:00:04that is tricky. It's got a lot of these problematic
- 1:00:09facts that might not make the client ineligible.
- 1:00:12But especially right now, it could cause their
- 1:00:18application to maybe be denied on discretion
- 1:00:21or just looked at more closely. I prepare a preemptive
- 1:00:29brief explaining the facts, the law. why my client
- 1:00:34is not ineligible and to attack the discretion
- 1:00:39prong, you know, fill it with equities. Been
- 1:00:42here in the country for 30 years as a family
- 1:00:47ties, U .S. citizen spouse, kids have been working
- 1:00:51for all that time, you know, volunteers at the
- 1:00:56pet shelter playing with puppies, go to the church,
- 1:01:00whatever, whatever we have. I've used you know,
- 1:01:04as a member of this community soccer league,
- 1:01:08whatever we have to use of equities, I throw
- 1:01:11at it. And especially now, you want to gather
- 1:01:14as many equities as you have. A lot of people
- 1:01:17don't have equities like that. They just work
- 1:01:21and then go home and spend time with their families.
- 1:01:23Well, you use what you have available. It may
- 1:01:26just be letters from from friends and family
- 1:01:31attesting to their good moral character. So it
- 1:01:34looks like those are all the questions we had.
- 1:01:38Let's see, there's one more. I have a client
- 1:01:41with an administratively closed EOIR case. She
- 1:01:44submitted her new visa adjustment of status and
- 1:01:49just received an I -131 denial should we expect
- 1:01:53an NTA. So your clients in administratively closed
- 1:01:58proceedings, submitted a new visa adjustment
- 1:02:02of status, which I assume is pending, has not
- 1:02:04been adjudicated. So she filed an I -131, meaning
- 1:02:09that she applied for advanced parole, which was
- 1:02:12denied. Well, your client will not be NTA'd because,
- 1:02:17or shouldn't be NTA'd, because having administratively
- 1:02:20closed proceedings means that the proceedings
- 1:02:23are still open. Well, not open. They're closed,
- 1:02:25but they're still pending before the court. So
- 1:02:29if DHS wants to reactivate the case, what they'll
- 1:02:32do is file a motion to recalendar. So you may
- 1:02:36want to be on the lookout for that. If it's an
- 1:02:39ECAS case, an electronic filing case, you'll
- 1:02:42receive notice of any filing in whatever email
- 1:02:46you have registered for ECAS. If it's a paper
- 1:02:49filing, a paper case, which many cases that like
- 1:02:5610 years old or more or paper cases, then you'll
- 1:03:00probably receive it in the mail. You just want
- 1:03:02to make sure that if you've changed your address
- 1:03:06since this case was, since you last had this
- 1:03:09case active before EOIR, that you make arrangements
- 1:03:13to be able to receive that in that file, any
- 1:03:17file. Okay, so it looks like those are all the
- 1:03:22questions. Great questions. Thank you, everyone.
- 1:03:26I think we're good on time, it looks like. Thank
- 1:03:30you all for your time and attention and your
- 1:03:33questions. I hope that this was very informative
- 1:03:38for you. And I look forward to doing these again.
- 1:03:43This is great. I love talking to folks and sharing
- 1:03:48my experiences, my war stories, if you will.
- 1:03:53Hopefully I will be able to see all you folks
- 1:03:57again soon. Thank you.