Latest / The Morning Rundown / Hope Florida's Money Trail, a Mail-In Ballot Smackdown, and the Pentagon Loses to an AI Company
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I've got exactly three sips of coffee in me and already
- 0:17[Maya] three headlines that are gonna wreck your morning before we even get
- 0:20[Maya] started.
- 0:22[David] That eager, huh?
- 0:23[Maya] I'm telling you.
- 0:24[Maya] Welcome to "The Morning Rundown."
- 0:26[Maya] I'm Maya, and that's David next to me judging my coffee order
- 0:29[Maya] as usual.
- 0:30[David] It's your fourth cup, and it's not even nine.
- 0:33[Maya] Hey, it's fuel.
- 0:35[Maya] I need it for days like this.
- 0:36[David] Sure, sure, sure.
- 0:37[Maya] So first up, there's a money trail tied to Florida's Hope Florida
- 0:42[Maya] charity, and people wanna know exactly where those donations landed.
- 0:46[David] That's the one with the DeSantis connection, right?
- 0:48[Maya] That's the one.
- 0:49[David] Okay.
- 0:50[David] Keep going.
- 0:51[Maya] Then a judge just blocked a mail-in voting order again, which feels
- 0:56[Maya] like round four of this same fight.
- 0:58[David] Honestly, it might be round five at this point.
- 1:01[Maya] I've genuinely lost count.
- 1:03[Maya] And then somehow the Pentagon lost a legal fight to an AI
- 1:07[Maya] company.
- 1:07[David] Wait, seriously?
- 1:08[David] The actual Pentagon?
- 1:10[Maya] The actual Pentagon.
- 1:12[Maya] Saving that one for last because it's the one where the government
- 1:14[Maya] finally gets told no for a change.
- 1:17[David] That's a plot twist.
- 1:18[Maya] Right, right.
- 1:20[David] Now I'm interested.
- 1:21[David] Where do we even start?
- 1:22[Maya] Florida.
- 1:23[Maya] Always Florida.
- 1:24[David] All right, let's start in Florida.
- 1:27[Maya] Okay.
- 1:28[David] So this Hope Florida thing, a grand jury actually put a number
- 1:32[David] on it, $10 million.
- 1:34[Maya] Wait, 10 million?
- 1:35[Maya] From where?
- 1:36[David] Medicaid settlement money.
- 1:38[David] The state settled with the drug companies over the opioid crisis, and
- 1:41[David] that cash was supposed to go towards addiction and welfare programs.
- 1:44[Maya] Okay, so far normal.
- 1:47[David] Except the grand jury says it got routed through Hope Florida.
- 1:50[David] That's the charity Casey DeSantis set up.
- 1:52[David] And from there it landed in PACs and the state GOP.
- 1:55[Maya] For what, though?
- 1:56[Maya] Just general spending?
- 1:58[David] To help kill a marijuana legalization ballot measure.
- 2:01[David] That's the specific target the grand jury flagged.
- 2:04[Maya] Okay, that's...
- 2:05[Maya] That is a very specific use of opioid settlement money.
- 2:08[David] Yeah.
- 2:09[David] It's not exactly what you picture when you hear Medicaid funds.
- 2:12[Maya] Right.
- 2:13[Maya] So headline-wise, this reads like a slam dunk.
- 2:16[Maya] Governor's people caught funneling taxpayer money into a political campaign.
- 2:20[David] Here's where it gets messier, though.
- 2:22[Maya] Oh, is that the one we get per episode?
- 2:25[David] Guess so.
- 2:25[David] But seriously, the same grand jury that used the word misappropriated also
- 2:30[David] said there's not enough evidence to charge anybody criminally.
- 2:33[Maya] Wait, so they found the money moved wrong, but nobody broke the
- 2:36[Maya] law doing it?
- 2:37[David] That's basically the finding.
- 2:39[David] Misuse, not indictable.
- 2:41[Maya] That's a weird gap.
- 2:42[David] It is, and it's exactly the gap DeSantis is standing in right
- 2:46[David] now.
- 2:46[Maya] What's he saying?
- 2:47[David] He's calling the whole arrangement legally sound and appropriate, full stop, no
- 2:51[David] hedge.
- 2:52[Maya] Even with the grand jury's own language sitting right there?
- 2:55[David] Even then.
- 2:56[David] And Uthmeier, he's the attorney general, and the report actually names him
- 3:00[David] as a financial nexus in how the money moved.
- 3:03[David] He's calling the whole probe politically motivated.
- 3:06[Maya] I mean, when you're named as a nexus in a grand jury
- 3:09[Maya] report, politically motivated is one way to respond to that.
- 3:13[David] Sure, but he's not wrong that the timing's convenient for whoever wants
- 3:16[David] this story out there before an election cycle.
- 3:19[Maya] Okay, but that cuts both ways.
- 3:20[Maya] If there's no criminal charge, calling it a scandal outright is a
- 3:24[Maya] stretch, too.
- 3:25[David] Totally fair.
- 3:26[David] This is the thing.
- 3:27[David] Everybody's picking the half of the report that helps them.
- 3:30[David] Critics take misappropriated and run.
- 3:33[David] DeSantis' team takes no charges and runs the other way.
- 3:36[Maya] And the actual document just sits there saying both things at once.
- 3:40[David] Right.
- 3:41[David] 10 million moved somewhere it wasn't supposed to go.
- 3:43[David] Nobody's facing charges for it.
- 3:45[David] That's the whole finding, messy as it is.
- 3:48[Maya] Practically speaking, though, does any of this actually move the needle for
- 3:51[Maya] voters watching this in November?
- 3:53[David] Probably not directly.
- 3:54[David] No charges means no trial, no resignations forced by the finding itself.
- 3:59[David] But it hands ammunition to whoever's running against Republicans in Florida this
- 4:02[David] cycle, and at the same time, it hands DeSantis' team their own
- 4:06[David] clean talking point, no crime, case closed.
- 4:09[Maya] So it turns into a rhetorical weapon on both sides instead of
- 4:13[Maya] a legal one.
- 4:14[David] Pretty much.
- 4:14[David] That's usually how these stop short of charges findings end up, living
- 4:18[David] in campaign ads and cable news chyrons, not courtrooms.
- 4:22[Maya] And Uthmeier's still the sitting attorney general through all this, right?
- 4:25[Maya] Nothing about the finding changes his job.
- 4:28[David] Nothing changes his job.
- 4:29[David] He's still in office, still running the state's legal apparatus, and still
- 4:32[David] the guy the report names as a financial nexus.
- 4:35[David] That combination alone is gonna follow him.
- 4:37[Maya] It's very on brand for how these Florida stories always land.
- 4:41[Maya] Big number, big claim, and then a very unsatisfying legal ending.
- 4:45[David] Yeah, no neat bow on this one.
- 4:47[Maya] So where does this go next?
- 4:49[Maya] Does anyone actually get held to account, or is this just a
- 4:51[Maya] talking point now?
- 4:53[David] Probably a talking point, honestly, unless something new surfaces.
- 4:56[David] But speaking of courts having a busy week, there's a much bigger
- 4:59[David] fight brewing, and this one is actually still moving through a judge's
- 5:02[David] desk right now.
- 5:03[Maya] Ooh, which one?
- 5:05[David] The mail-in voting order.
- 5:06[David] It just got blocked again.
- 5:07[Maya] All right, let's get into it.
- 5:10[Maya] Uh...
- 5:11[David] So here's the headline.
- 5:12[David] A federal judge just halted Trump's executive order limiting mail-in voting again.
- 5:17[Maya] Wait, again?
- 5:18[Maya] Like, this exact order?
- 5:20[David] Same order, second time it's been stopped cold.
- 5:23[Maya] Okay, that's...
- 5:24[Maya] Wow.
- 5:25[Maya] What happened the first time?
- 5:27[David] We didn't cover the first round, but the short version is a
- 5:29[David] court already knocked it down once before this.
- 5:32[Maya] And now round two, same result.
- 5:35[David] Same result, and the timing is brutal.
- 5:37[David] This Thursday ruling landed about a week before the first mail ballots
- 5:41[David] were supposed to go out.
- 5:42[Maya] Oh, come on.
- 5:43[Maya] A week?
- 5:44[David] A week.
- 5:45[David] States were basically about to print ballots under the old rules, and
- 5:48[David] then the whole thing got pulled out from under them.
- 5:50[Maya] So what's the judge's actual reasoning here?
- 5:53[Maya] Like, is it about the policy itself or something more technical?
- 5:56[David] It's more technical, actually.
- 5:58[David] The judge in this one, Talwani, said states didn't have enough time
- 6:01[David] to redesign their ballots before the midterms.
- 6:03[David] That's the stated reason.
- 6:05[Maya] Not that the policy's wrong, just that the clock ran out.
- 6:08[David] Right.
- 6:08[David] It's a scheduling objection, not really a ruling on the merits.
- 6:11[David] There's a hearing set for September third, and everybody expects an appeal
- 6:15[David] right after.
- 6:16[Maya] Can you give me a concrete example of what states don't have
- 6:19[Maya] enough time to redesign ballots actually means on the ground?
- 6:23[David] Sure.
- 6:23[David] County election offices already printed ballot layout specs, ordered paper stock, and
- 6:28[David] trained poll workers on one set of mail-in rules.
- 6:31[David] Flip that switch a week out, and you're asking them to reprint,
- 6:34[David] recertify, and retrain under a deadline that doesn't exist in a normal
- 6:38[David] election cycle.
- 6:39[Maya] So it's less about the policy being wrong and more that the
- 6:42[Maya] clock just wasn't realistic.
- 6:44[David] That's the judge's whole point, yeah.
- 6:46[David] It's a scheduling issue dressed up as a legal fight.
- 6:48[Maya] Which almost makes it worse in a way.
- 6:51[Maya] Nobody's actually arguing about whether the policy is good.
- 6:54[Maya] They're arguing about whether there was enough runway to do it.
- 6:58[David] Right.
- 6:58[David] And that's a pattern we've seen with a lot of these executive
- 7:00[David] orders lately.
- 7:01[David] The substance survives longer in the news cycle than it does in
- 7:04[David] court because courts keep parking on the timing issue instead of ruling
- 7:07[David] on the merits.
- 7:08[Maya] So this isn't over.
- 7:10[Maya] It's just paused again.
- 7:11[David] Paused again.
- 7:12[David] And look, I get why people roll their eyes at that, but
- 7:15[David] I actually think there's something real underneath this one.
- 7:17[Maya] Meaning what?
- 7:18[David] Meaning you've got an elected president trying to set a ballot integrity rule, and twice now, a single judge has stopped it nationwide before
- 7:22[David] it even gets a real hearing on the substance.
- 7:26[David] I mean, that's kind of what courts are for though, right?
- 7:28[Maya] Checking the executive branch.
- 7:31[Maya] Sure, in theory.
- 7:33[David] But when the same policy gets blocked twice on process grounds without
- 7:34[David] ever really getting weighed on the actual question, is this good election policy or not?
- 7:38[David] That's a legitimate tension.
- 7:42[David] You've got one district judge effectively setting national election timing.
- 7:43[David] Okay.
- 7:45[David] I hear that.
- 7:49[Maya] It does feel like the same problem shows up over and over.
- 7:49[Maya] I hear that.
- 7:50[Maya] It does feel like the same problem shows up over and over.
- 7:53[Maya] Whoever files first in whatever district gets to freeze policy nationwide for
- 7:58[Maya] months, and that part bugs me no matter which side's doing it.
- 8:01[David] Right.
- 8:02[David] And that's kind of the pattern with this administration's executive orders generally.
- 8:05[David] File it, get sued, get an injunction, appeal, repeat.
- 8:09[Maya] So September third, we get a hearing, but nobody thinks that's the
- 8:12[Maya] end of it.
- 8:13[David] Nobody thinks that's the end of it.
- 8:15[David] Whoever loses appeals, and this could easily be dragging into the fall
- 8:18[David] with ballots already mailed under whatever rules end up standing.
- 8:22[Maya] And if this drags past the point where ballots actually go out,
- 8:25[Maya] what happens then?
- 8:26[Maya] Do we end up with two different sets of rules depending on
- 8:28[Maya] when your state printed?
- 8:30[David] That's the messy scenario everyone's trying to avoid, a patchwork where some
- 8:34[David] states mailed under the old rules and others are stuck waiting on
- 8:37[David] the appeal.
- 8:38[David] Nobody wants a midterm where the rules aren't the same nationwide.
- 8:42[Maya] Which is its own problem because election officials need certainty way before
- 8:45[Maya] the actual voting starts.
- 8:47[David] Exactly.
- 8:48[David] And that's the practical cost nobody talks about.
- 8:50[David] Every week this bounces around in court is a week state election
- 8:54[David] offices can't finalize anything.
- 8:56[Maya] It's the kind of thing that sounds procedural until you realize it
- 8:59[Maya] decides who actually gets their ballot in the mail on time.
- 9:03[David] Exactly.
- 9:03[David] Procedural fights still have very real deadlines attached to them.
- 9:07[Maya] Right.
- 9:07[Maya] Okay, so that's one court fight where the judge is checking the
- 9:10[Maya] president.
- 9:11[Maya] I wanna bring up a second one, but honestly, this one cuts
- 9:14[Maya] the other way.
- 9:15[David] How so?
- 9:16[David] Go for it.
- 9:17[David] I think I already know which one you mean.
- 9:19[Maya] Okay, so this one's the Pentagon getting told it overstepped.
- 9:22[David] Wait, the Pentagon actually lost a court case to a company?
- 9:26[Maya] To Anthropic, the AI company behind Claude.
- 9:30[Maya] CNBC reported a judge blocked the Pentagon's blacklist of Claude as a,
- 9:34[Maya] quote, "supply chain risk".
- 9:36[David] Blacklist how?
- 9:37[Maya] Back in March, the Defense Department barred the military from using Claude
- 9:41[Maya] at all.
- 9:42[Maya] Just cut it off.
- 9:43[David] Over what, though?
- 9:43[David] Like, what did Claude do wrong?
- 9:45[Maya] That's the thing.
- 9:46[Maya] It wasn't really about security.
- 9:48[Maya] It was about Claude's safety guardrails, the model refusing certain military use
- 9:52[Maya] requests.
- 9:53[David] So the Pentagon blacklists it for being too careful?
- 9:56[Maya] Basically.
- 9:57[Maya] And a judge just said, "No, you can't do that."
- 10:00[David] Which judge?
- 10:01[Maya] Rita Lin, Biden appointee.
- 10:03[Maya] The Hill reported she wrote a fifty-nine-page order calling the Pentagon's move
- 10:08[Maya] illegal and baseless.
- 10:09[David] Fifty-nine pages is a lot of pages to say you messed up.
- 10:13[Maya] Right?
- 10:14[Maya] But it's not just baseless.
- 10:16[Maya] She found it violated the First Amendment and the Fifth Amendment.
- 10:20[David] Both?
- 10:21[Maya] Both.
- 10:22[Maya] First Amendment because it's retaliation over Claude's speech adjacent guardrails, and Fifth
- 10:27[Maya] Amendment on due process grounds.
- 10:29[David] Okay, so walk me through why the Pentagon even goes there.
- 10:32[David] Like, what's the actual gripe with the guardrails?
- 10:35[Maya] My read is the military wants a model that'll do whatever it's
- 10:38[Maya] told, and Claude's built to refuse certain military use requests.
- 10:43[Maya] So the Pentagon's answer wasn't, "Let's negotiate," it was, "You're banned."
- 10:47[David] And the judge is basically saying you can't punish a company for
- 10:50[David] a design choice you don't like.
- 10:52[Maya] Does this ruling protect other AI companies too, or is it specific
- 10:55[Maya] to Anthropic?
- 10:57[David] The order itself is about Anthropic and Claude specifically.
- 11:00[David] It doesn't rewrite policy for the whole industry.
- 11:03[David] But other companies making similar safety guardrail choices are gonna point at
- 11:06[David] this ruling the next time an agency tries the same move.
- 11:09[Maya] That's the ruling, and I think it's worth sitting with because we
- 11:12[Maya] just spent the last segment on a judge blocking a presidential order.
- 11:16[David] Right, and now it's a judge blocking a Pentagon order.
- 11:18[David] Different target, same referee.
- 11:20[Maya] Exactly.
- 11:21[Maya] Same referee, different team getting the flag thrown on them.
- 11:24[David] I mean, I actually like this one more than the voting fight,
- 11:27[David] honestly.
- 11:27[Maya] Why?
- 11:28[David] Because this is a court checking a federal agency's retaliation against a
- 11:32[David] private company.
- 11:33[David] That's a much cleaner First Amendment case than which mail ballots count.
- 11:37[Maya] Sure, but isn't it the same principle?
- 11:39[Maya] Executive branch does something, court says, "You went too far," court reins
- 11:43[Maya] it in.
- 11:43[David] It's the same mechanism, yeah.
- 11:46[David] I just think the stakes read different when it's the Pentagon punishing
- 11:49[David] a tech company for guardrails versus a president resetting how ballots get
- 11:53[David] counted nationwide.
- 11:54[Maya] Fair.
- 11:54[Maya] One's a policy dispute, and one's a constitutional violation, on paper anyway.
- 11:59[David] Right.
- 11:59[David] But zoom out, three stories today.
- 12:01[David] Three different institutions getting slapped down or accused of overreach.
- 12:05[David] Hope Florida, the mail-in order, now the Pentagon.
- 12:08[Maya] It's not a coincidence.
- 12:09[Maya] It's just this is what a lot of oversight looks like right
- 12:12[Maya] now.
- 12:12[Maya] Courts and grand juries doing the checking.
- 12:14[David] And this Anthropic ruling in particular, it's the one where a company
- 12:17[David] actually won.
- 12:19[David] Hope Florida didn't get charges.
- 12:20[David] The mail-in fight isn't over, but Anthropic just got its access back.
- 12:24[Maya] Yeah.
- 12:24[Maya] This is the case where the little guy, well, multi-billion dollar AI
- 12:28[Maya] company, actually beat the federal government outright.
- 12:31[David] The little guy's doing fine.
- 12:33[Maya] But you get the point.
- 12:34[Maya] Not every one of these fights ends in a stalemate.
- 12:37[Maya] Some of them actually resolve.
- 12:38[David] And this one resolved with the Pentagon getting told its own ban
- 12:41[David] was illegal.
- 12:42[David] Not just paused, not just under review, illegal.
- 12:46[Maya] Which is a stronger word than anything a judge said about the
- 12:48[Maya] voting order.
- 12:49[David] It is.
- 12:50[David] All right.
- 12:51[David] That's a wrap on the courtroom drama for today.
- 12:53[Maya] Three institutions, three different courts, three different outcomes.
- 12:57[David] One for three if you're the government today.
- 12:59[Maya] Ugh.
- 13:00[David] So today's real theme, courts flexing muscle in both directions, reining in
- 13:05[David] the executive on voting and reining in the Pentagon on Anthropic.
- 13:09[Maya] Busy week for judges.
- 13:11[David] Genuinely busy.
- 13:12[David] Three different fights, three different referees, and none of them went the
- 13:16[David] way the government hoped.
- 13:18[Maya] Which, if you're keeping score at home, is kind of the point
- 13:21[Maya] of having judges.
- 13:22[David] Yeah, checks and balances, they still work sometimes.
- 13:26[Maya] Wild concept.
- 13:27[David] Anyway, that's the wrap on all three.
- 13:29[Maya] I kind of love that none of these stories are actually done
- 13:32[Maya] yet.
- 13:33[David] Nope.
- 13:34[David] Appeals, hearings, more filings coming.
- 13:37[Maya] Which is honestly half the fun of doing this show.
- 13:40[David] Job security, really.
- 13:41[Maya] Which means we'll be right back here talking about it.
- 13:45[David] Probably next week, honestly.
- 13:47[Maya] Alright.
- 13:47[Maya] That's the show, guys.
- 13:48[Maya] Stay curious.
- 13:49[Maya] Stay caffeinated.
- 13:50[Maya] We'll see you tomorrow on The Morning Rundown.